Absorbable versus nonabsorbable sutures to prevent postoperative stretching of wound area

In surgery it is not uncommon to demand considerable tensile strength of sutures, at least for the time it takes the scar to gain sufficient strength to resist wound-shearing forces without the help of sutures. There is controversial thinking as to whether absorbable or nonabsorbable sutures should be used in this situation. By tattooing two pairs of marks on each side of the wound after a midline sagittal excision of the scalp for correction of androgenetic alopecia and suturing 13 patients with Dexon (polyglycolic acid) and 8 with Prolene (polypropylene), the authors were able to measure a 48 to 59 percent larger postoperative stretching of the wound area in the Dexon group 2 months postoperatively. In addition, the scar width was 60 to 76 percent larger in the Dexon group 3 months postoperatively. These differences were highly significant. Differences in scar depression also supported the idea of more stretching in the Dexon group. This indicates the importance of careful choice of suture material in situations where problems are to be expected, such as in wide scars or wound failure.     

Effect of surgical thread from the dura mater, modified with succinate, on the energy metabolism of white rat kidney mitochondria]

The activity of energy metabolism has been studied in the experiment with white rats, which had been carried out nephrotomia with following use for suture such absorbable surgical threads as catgut plain, biofil (of dura mater spinalis of the cattle) and biofil modified with succinate. The research proves the use of catgut plain decreases of energy quotient and such polarographic index as the rate of phosphorylating respiration of mitochondria of the kidneys in postoperative period. The greater activity of energy metabolism during this period has been stated with the use of biofil. The use of biofil modified with succinate results in the activation of bioenergy processes.     

Repairing Facial Injury with Refining Plastic Surgery Techniques

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the refining plastic surgery techniques for repairing facial surface injury. For this purpose, 82 patients with facial surface injury were recruited in the study. All wounds were repaired by refining plastic surgery techniques. The wounds were processed by fine wound excision and plastic surgery repair technique. The deep tissue fracture and dislocation were sutured and reduced using 8-0 absorbable suture and the skin wounds were sutured using 8-0 cosmetic suture. The facial injuries showed good rates of healing with fine debridement and fine recovering. The minimum scarring was observed and good cosmetic effect was achieved. We conclude that refining plastic surgery techniques including fine debridement and fine recovering are ideal for the reconstruction of facial injuries.     

Two modified techniques for flexor tendon repair.

The aim of this article is to present two new techniques for digital flexor tendon repair: a modification to the conventional Kessler technique (wrap core suture) and tendon splints (H-shaped splint). These techniques were aimed at enhancing the biomechanical properties of such repairs as related to resistance to both gap formation and repair failure. Comparing (in an ex vivo study) the tensiometric properties (gap formation and failure strengths) of 24 flexor digitorum profundus tendons repaired with the described techniques (12 repairs per each technique) and the conventional Kessler repair (24 repairs), we found that the former provided significantly stronger repairs than the latter in vitro. A statistically significant difference (p < 0.001) was found between each of the two presented techniques and the Kessler repair. The wrap core suture increased the load at which a visible (1 mm) gap formed by 22.6 percent when compared with the conventional Kessler suture. The mean gap strength of the wrap core repair was 6.5 N, whereas that of the conventional Kessler was 5.3 N. The failure loads (ultimate strength) of the wrap core suture were 33.8 percent higher than those of the conventional Kessler. The mean breaking load of the wrap core repair was 19.4 N, whereas that of the conventional Kessler was 14.5 N. The H-splint repair increased the load at which a visible gap formed and the failure loads (ultimate strength) by 158.5 and 333.1 percent, respectively, when compared with the conventional Kessler suture. The mean gap strength of the H-splint repair was 13.7 N, and its mean breaking load was 62.8 N.     

Polypropylene mesh seeded with fibroblasts: A new approach for the repair of abdominal wall defects in rats

Purpose

The purpose of study was to develop bioengineered scaffolds by seeding primary mouse embryo fibroblast cells (p-MEF) on polypropylene mesh and to test its efficacy for the repair of abdominal wall defects in rats.

"Staying power"--absorbable vs. nonabsorbable

An experiment was designed to compare the "holding power" or "staying power" of absorbable (polyglycolic acid and polyglactin 910) and nonabsorbable (nylon) suture. The aim of this experiment was to determine what provides the lasting strength of the bond between soft tissues that are approximated or plicated. When correcting the rectus diastasis during abdominoplasty, we used nylon sutures in 15 patients and absorbable synthetic sutures in 15 other patients. We then marked the closed folds of the rectus sheath with small metal vascular clips. Two days later and approximately 6 months after operation an upright anteroposterior abdominal x-ray was taken and the position of the metal clips was compared in the test groups. Although there was usually slight separation of the clips after 6 months, no significant difference between the two groups was noted, thereby indicating that holding power is not related to type of suture material but more likely to fibroplasia.     

Rigid fixation of the calvaria in craniosynostosis without using "rigid" fixation

Early observations of intracranial translocation of metal wires, plates, and screws used for infant skull surgery have led some surgeons to investigate alternative forms of fixation. The purpose of this study was to review a series of infants and children in whom absorbable suture fixation was used as the sole method of fixation in cranial vault remodeling. Standard osteotomies were successfully modified to permit the use of this less rigid form of fixation. Over a 6-year period, 142 cranial vault procedures were performed, primarily for craniosynostosis, using absorbable sutures (2-0 polydioxanone). Patients who did not have absorbable suture fixation, or who had a combination of absorbable sutures with another form of fixation, were excluded from this review. Records were reviewed for results (assessed by both the treating surgeon and an independent anthropologist) and for complications. The average age of patients was 2 years, 7 months (range, 1 month to 16 years). The clinical results were judged as follows: grade I (excellent), 49 percent; grade II (minor imperfections), 48 percent; grade III (small surgical procedure needed), 2 percent; and grade IV (complete reoperation required), 1 percent. Anthropologic results were similarly distributed: excellent, 36 percent; good, 56 percent; fair, 8 percent; and poor, 0 percent. Those 3 to 8 percent of patients who were found to have the poorest results were all noted to have syndromes, and it appeared that an inherent lack of growth was the primary basis for the low score. There were no deaths or major complications in this series of patients. The smaller complications identified were infections [four cases (2.8 percent)] and transient cerebrospinal fluid leak [two cases (1.4 percent)]. The most important factor in determining whether absorbable suture fixation was sufficient was the size of a preexisting calvarial defect. Although concerns have been raised about a possible link between absorbable suture fixation and subsequent poor reossification, no such association was noted in this review. The primary disadvantage of using absorbable sutures was the lack of rigidity provided. Advantages included lower costs, speed of application, and the absence of observed intracranial translocation. In conclusion, the use of absorbable suture fixation (with modifications in osteotomy design) was associated with both acceptable aesthetic outcomes and low complication rates. Craniofacial surgeons may wish to consider the use of absorbable sutures as another option for bone fixation in treatment of craniosynostosis.     

Reduction of adhesions with composite AlloDerm/polypropylene mesh implants for abdominal wall reconstruction

Ventral hernia repair often includes the use of structural prosthetic materials, such as polypropylene mesh, that can induce dense abdominal adhesions to peritoneal structures. AlloDerm (LifeCell Corp., Branchburg, N.J.), a commercially available decellularized human dermal analogue with its native basement membrane components intact, is gradually revascularized and replaced with autologous tissue after implantation. The authors hypothesized that AlloDerm integrated with polypropylene mesh would reduce adhesions and provide a biodegradable scaffold to generate an autologous vascularized tissue layer separating the abdominal viscera from the mesh. Ventral hernia defects (3 x 1 cm) in 19 guinea pigs were repaired using an inlay technique with polypropylene mesh alone (n = 6) or with composite implants constructed by integrating polypropylene mesh and AlloDerm with its basement membrane surface oriented toward (polypropylene/AlloIn, n = 7) or away from (polypropylene/ AlloOut, n = 6) the peritoneal cavity. At 4 weeks, the authors determined the amount of mesh implant surface area covered by adhesions, the strength of the adhesions [graded from 0 (none) to 3], and the incidence of bowel adhesions. Histologic analyses were performed on full-thickness tissue sections from the repair sites. The mean surface areas affected by adhesions and mean adhesion strength were significantly lower in the polypropylene/AlloIn (area, 12.4 percent; mean grade, 1.0) and polypropylene/AlloOut (area, 9.5 percent; mean grade, 0.5) groups than in the polypropylene group (area, 79.5 percent; mean grade, 2.9); there were no such differences between the polypropylene/AlloIn and polypropylene/AlloOut groups. The bowel was adherent to 67 percent of polypropylene repairs and 0 percent of the composite mesh repairs. The AlloDerm was remodeled to form a vascularized tissue layer beneath the mesh in composite repairs, unlike the significantly thinner, dense scar layer that formed in the polypropylene repairs. Immunohistochemical labeling for factor VIII showed neovascularization throughout the AlloDerm.The AlloDerm thus functioned as a biodegradable tissue scaffold, guiding the formation of a thick, well-vascularized tissue layer separating the polypropylene mesh from intraperitoneal structures. This significantly reduced both the amount of surface area covered by adhesions and adhesion strength. Basement membrane orientation had no effect. Composite mesh implants composed of structural prosthetic materials integrated with AlloDerm may have useful clinical applications for abdominal wall reconstruction by reducing adhesions and providing a vascularized tissue layer to separate and protect the peritoneal structures from polypropylene mesh fibers.     

Human bites of the eyelid

Five patients with traumatic colobomas of the eyelid secondary to human bites were surgically repaired with retrieved autogenous tissue. All patients were treated with prophylactic intravenous antibiotics. Surgical repair consisted of debridement of the autograft, meticulous layered closure of the autograft to the wound, and placement of a lid margin suture. In two of the patients, mild upper eyelid retraction was noted, and two patients had loss of cilia.     

Effects of tag and suture type on survival and growth of brown trout with surgically implanted telemetry tags in the wild

To test the effects of surgical implants with or without external antennae, 188 wild brown trout Salmo trutta , 150–290 mm, were tagged and released in a small river in May 2005. After 5 months, 103 of the fish were recaptured and examined. Thus, information on the relative survival, growth and general condition of each fish was obtained. The relative survival did not differ between the three groups (control, antennae and no antennae), but the specific growth of the two tagged groups were lower than that of the control fish. The tag:body-mass ratio had a significant negative effect on specific growth. A relative high occurrence of tag expulsion was observed in both treatment groups (23%). The probability to expel a tag was correlated with the tag:body-mass ratio. Finally, the relative survival, growth, expulsion rate and general condition were compared between fish tagged with different types of suture material (absorbable v . non-absorbable). The results show only minor differences, but absorbable suture provided better wound healing and fewer expulsions.     

Clinical experience with polydioxanone monofilament absorbable sutures in plastic surgery

Various sizes of undyed monofilament polydioxanone surgical suture were assessed in 52 surgical patients who underwent plastic surgery. With a single exception, follow-up observations were carried out for at least 40 days. Clinical results were judged satisfactory in 13 patients and excellent in 39 patients. The suture was found significantly better than gut in terms of pliability, ease of passage through tissue, ease of tying, strength, fray resistance, and overall handling properties. The undyed suture material tested in this study was rated as having inferior visibility when compared with surgical gut. This new suture material, the first synthetic absorbable available as a monofilament, would appear to be particularly useful in situations requiring extended wound support, in potentially infected wounds in which a monofilament suture would have lessened tendency to harbor pathogenic bacteria, and in cases where ease of passage through tissue, smooth tie-down, and precise knot placement are important.     

Evaluation of four methods of flexor tendon repair for postoperative active mobilization

Active mobilization of repaired flexor tendons requires sufficient suture strength. This study was designed to investigate the suitability of four newly developed and comparatively strong tendon sutures for flexor tendon repair with active digital mobilization. Fifty fresh flexor digitorum profundus tendons were randomly assigned to five groups and repaired using the Tang, cruciate, Robertson, Silfverskiold, and modified Kessler suture methods. The repaired tendons were subjected to mechanical testing in an Instron tensile machine to determine the 2-mm gap formation force, ultimate strength, elastic modulus, and energy to failure of the sutures. The 2-mm gap formation forces of the sutures were 43.0 N for the Tang, 37.4 N for the cruciate, 25.0 N for the Robertson, 32.3 N for the Silfverskiold, and 21.2 N for the modified Kessler methods. The ultimate strength of the sutures was 53.6 N for the Tang, 46.3 N for the cruciate, 41.6 N for the Robertson, 41.0 N for the Silfverskiold, and 24.7 N for the modified Kessler methods. Statistically, the gap formation force and ultimate strength were the highest in the Tang, higher in the cruciate, and the lowest for the Robertson and the modified Kessler methods. The elastic modulus of the repaired tendons, as represented by the linear slope of the force-displacement curve, was also statistically the largest in the Tang, larger in the cruciate, and lowest for the Robertson and modified Kessler methods. Energy to failure was statistically the largest in the Tang, higher in the cruciate, lower in the Silfverskiold and the Robertson, and the lowest for the modified Kessler methods. It was concluded that significant differences exist in mechanical properties of the newly developed tendon suture methods. Among the methods for tendon repair that were tested, the Tang and the cruciate sutures were the best candidates for flexor tendon repair in the hand with postoperative active mobilization because of their superior tensile strength, elastic properties, energy to failure, and reasonable operation time.     

Suture materials and other factors associated with tissue reactivity, infection, and wound dehiscence among plastic surgery outpatients

The most common complications in plastic surgery are tissue reactivity, infections, and wound dehiscence. In the literature, there are only a few studies with sample sizes large enough and methods of statistical analysis appropriate for evaluating the role of suture materials in inducing such complications. In the 1000 plastic surgery outpatients in this study, the association of different suture materials, individual patient characteristics, surgeon skill, and wound site and length with postoperative wound complications (i.e., tissue reactivity, infection rate, and wound dehiscence) were investigated. No substantial differences were found between the different suture materials and suturing techniques. A moderate increase in the risk of tissue reactivity for silk and polyglactin 910 and a protective effect of thinner internal sutures were observed. In multivariate analysis, such differences were not statistically significant. Male sex [odds ratio (OR), 1.7; 95 percent confidence interval (CI), 1.06 to 2.72] and older age (OR, 2.34; 95 percent CI, 1.36 to 4.05) were found to be the most important risk factors for tissue reactivity and infection rate (male sex: OR, 5.1; 95 percent CI, 1.7 to 15.9; older age: OR, 5.6; 95 percent CI, 1.9 to 16), whereas younger age was associated with an increased risk of dehiscence (OR, 3.06; 95 percent CI, 1.41 to 6.65). Wounds on the lower limbs showed a lower risk of tissue reactivity and wounds on the back a higher risk of dehiscence. Wound length was associated with the risk of tissue reactivity in one-layer sutures (OR, 2.92; 95 percent CI, 1.51 to 5.65). An increased risk of both tissue reactivity (OR, 1.53; 95 percent CI, 1.03 to 2.27) and dehiscence (OR, 2.44; 95 percent CI, 1.1 to 5.43) was observed for operations performed by less-experienced surgeons. Rather than factors related to suture materials and different surgical techniques, and with the exception of surgeon experience, general characteristics of the patients (i.e., sex and age) and of the wounds (i.e., length and site) seemed to be primarily responsible for local wound complications.     

The role of TGF-beta1 as a determinant of foreign body reaction to alloplastic materials in rat fibroblast cultures: comparison of different commercially available polypropylene meshes for hernia repair

BACKGROUND: Animal experiments on hernia repair demonstrated better biocompatibility of light-weight polypropylene meshes. However, implanted medical devices trigger a variety of adverse tissue responses, such as inflammation, fibrosis, infection and thrombosis, but the mechanisms involved in such responses remain largely unknown. This study aimed to determine the effect of transforming growth factor beta1 (TGF-beta1) on host tolerance by quantification of foreign body reaction in cultured fibroblasts depending on the amount and composition of implanted material used for hernia repair. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An NRK-49F fibroblast culture was incubated in the presence of 4 commercially available meshes approved for hernia repair. A mesh-free cell suspension served as a control group, in which the influence of TGF-beta1 on fibroblasts was evaluated. Levels of TGF-beta1 in the supernatant were dynamically measured in a time interval of 6 to 96 h and cell proliferation rates were assessed colorimetrically using MTT test. RESULTS: A dose-dependent suppression of fibroblasts proliferation by TGF-beta1 was observed. All meshes suppressed the secretion of TGF-beta1 and conversely increased significantly cell proliferation in comparison to the control group (p<0.01) in the first 24 to 48 h of incubation. That effect was more pronounced in meshes partially containing absorbable material when compared to samples of pure polypropylene meshes (p<0.05) and to the control group (p<0.001). CONCLUSION: Our experiment revealed that early biological reaction of connective tissue cells towards polypropylene meshes and their variants depended much more on the composition and type of the material than on its absolute amount. The assumption that material weight reduction alone might affect the foreign body reaction of mesh implants could not be confirmed by our in vitro study.     

End-to-end versus end-to-side microvascular anastomosis patency in experimental venous repairs

In this experimental study, venous end-to-end and end-to-side microvascular anastomoses in similar and diameter-discrepant vessels were compared. In 50 rats, end-to-end microvascular repair of the divided epigastric vein and end-to-side repair of the epigastric vein into the femoral vein showed 5-day patency rates of 75 and 88 percent, respectively. These data are not statistically different. In 20 rats, microvascular repair of end epigastric to end femoral veins (size discrepant) and end epigastric to side femoral veins showed 5-day patency rates of 50 and 85 percent, respectively. These data are statistically different (p less than 0.05). We conclude from these experimental data that end-to-side venous repairs may be useful in lowering the anastomosis thrombosis rate seen when size-discrepant veins are repaired.     

Evaluation of fibrin glue in rat sciatic nerve repairs

Using the rat sciatic nerve model, we evaluated the merits of homologous fibrin glue in the repair of peripheral nerve transections as compared to standard epineural suture repairs. A total of four study groups were used, with 10 animals assigned to each group. In group I, the transected sciatic nerve was repaired with six interrupted 10-0 nylon sutures; in group II, only two interrupted sutures were used; in group III, a two-suture repair was reinforced with fibrin glue; and in group IV, only fibrin glue was used. All animals were sacrificed at 8 weeks, and histologic sections evaluated. When fibrin alone was used, dehiscence occurred in 80 percent of the animals, and as reinforcement of a two-suture repair, it only increased the inflammatory reaction.     

A mysterious pacemaker suture: an uncommon foreign body reaction

Surgical suture material is usually inert and nontoxic and causes minimal inflammation of tissue. However, foreign body reactions to various suture types can lead to granuloma, abscess, or even sinus formation. We report an elderly female who was incidentally detected to have a mass protruding from the incision site which was confirmed histopathologically a chronic granulomatous reaction to non absorbable suture. The foreign body granulomatous reaction to suture material in the setting of pacemaker implantation has not been described in the literature. We also discuss the existing literature on this underrecognised entity.     

Mersilene suture as a vehicle for delivery of growth factors in tendon repair.

Extensive clinical and laboratory studies have demonstrated that growth factors accelerate and modulate the wound-healing process. The purpose of this experiment was to apply the principles of growth factor-enhanced wound healing to an in vitro rat tendon model. A method was developed for covalently binding a biologically active peptide to nonabsorbable braided polyester suture (Mersilene). Sutures were treated with various growth factors, which included epidermal growth factor, platelet-derived growth factor, and keratinocyte growth factor, and bovine serum albumin was the control. Spectrophotometric assessment was used to verify the peptide's activity. The suture was subsequently placed through individual harvested rat flexor tendons, which were arranged in standard tissue culture conditions. Markedly increased cellular proliferation along the suture was appreciated on the tendons treated with epidermal growth factor-bound suture. Platelet-derived growth factor was shown to have a lesser effect, whereas keratinocyte growth factor had no visible effect on cellular proliferation. This preliminary study describes a new technique of binding growth factors to suture. It also demonstrates that the presence of growth factors may help facilitate flexor tendon healing and allow early postoperative rehabilitation to decrease adhesion formation.     

Determinants of poor outcome after laceration and surgical incision repair

The most important outcomes after repair of traumatic lacerations and surgical incisions are their long-term cosmetic appearance and development of infection. However, few studies have attempted to identify patient and wound characteristics associated with increased infection rates and suboptimal scar appearance. The authors determined patient and wound characteristics associated with wound infection or suboptimal appearance after laceration or incision repair. A secondary analysis of data collected from a multicenter randomized clinical trial comparing the outcome of lacerations and incisions closed with tissue adhesive or standard closure methods conducted at 10 clinical inpatient and outpatient sites was performed. The presence of infection and scar appearance were prospectively determined using validated outcomes. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify patient and wound characteristics associated with poor wound outcome (wound infection at 5 to 10 days or suboptimal appearance at 3 months). Eight hundred fourteen patients with 924 wounds (383 lacerations, 541 incisions) were enrolled. Mean age was 32 years and 47 percent were female. Characteristics associated with suboptimal cosmetic appearance on multivariate analysis were presence of associated tissue trauma [odds ratio (OR), 3.9; 95 percent confidence interval (CI), 1.4 to 10.7], use of electrocautery (OR, 3.4; 95 percent CI, 1.8 to 6.5), incomplete wound edge apposition (OR, 2.9; 95 percent CI, 1.7 to 5.0); extremity location (OR, 2.1; 95 percent CI, 1.2 to 3.7), and wound width (OR, 1.08; 95 percent CI, 1.01 to 1.14). Characteristics associated with wound infection on univariate analysis included associated tissue trauma (8.7 percent versus 1.2 percent, p = 0.04) and incomplete wound apposition (6.6 percent versus 0.5 percent). Suboptimal appearance was more common in infected wounds (relative risk, 3.2; 95 percent CI, 1.8 to 5.6). Suboptimal wound appearance is increased with extremity wounds, wide wounds, incompletely apposed wounds, associated tissue trauma, use of electrocautery, and infection. Type of closure device and use of deep sutures had no effect on infection rates or cosmetic appearance.