Time-lapse tracking of barley androgenesis reveals position-determined cell death within pro-embryos

Following abiotic stress to induce barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) androgenesis, the development of 794 enlarged microspores in culture was monitored by time-lapse tracking. In total, 11% of the microspores tracked developed into embryo-like structures (type-I pathway), 36% formed multicellular structures (type-II pathway) and 53% of the microspores followed gametophytic divisions, accumulated starch and died in the first days of tracking (type-III pathway). Despite the microspore fate, enlarged microspores showed similar morphologies directly after stress treatment. Ultrastructural analysis, however, revealed two morphologically distinct cell types. Cells with a thin intine layer and an undifferentiated cytoplasm after stress treatment were associated with type-I and type-II pathways, whereas the presence of differentiated amyloplasts and a thick intine layer were associated with the type-III pathway. Tracking revealed that the first morphological change associated with embryogenic potential was a star-like morphology, which was a transitory stage between uninucleate vacuolated microspores after stress and the initiation of cell division. The difference between type-I and type-II pathways was observed during the time they displayed the star-like morphology. During the transition phase, embryo-like structures in the type-I pathway were always released out of the exine wall at the opposite side of the pollen germ pore, whereas in the type-II pathway multicellular structures were unable to break the exine and to release embryo-like structures. Moreover, by combining viability studies with cell tracking, we show that release of embryo-like structures was preceded by a decrease in viability of the cells positioned at the site of exine wall rupture. These cells were also positively stained by Sytox orange, a cell death indicator. Thereby, we demonstrate, for the first time, that a position-determined cell death process marks the transition from a multicellular structure into an embryo-like structure during barley androgenesis.     

Isolated microspore culture of maize: effects of isolation technique,reduced temperature,and sucrose level

Improvements in ab initio microspore culture of maize are presented using a modified isolation technique, reduced temperature during early stages of culture, and an elevated sucrose level in the culture medium. Blending-isolation, using excised anthers, was less stressful on microspores than pressing anthers against a stainless steel sieve and resulted in a 3-fold increase in the yield of embryo-like structures (ELS). Exposure to reduced temperature (15°C) during the first 4 days of culture improved microspore viability and increased by 2-fold the number of ELS produced. Higher levels of sucrose (8.0–9.5%) also resulted in improved response. Maximum yield in the present study was 92 ELS per 100 anther equivalents, exceeding previously reported values of 15 ELS per 100 anther equivalents for ab initio microspore culture of maize. The increase in the total number ELS produced had no observable effect on their quality as evidenced by the frequency of formation of callus capable of regenerating plants.     

High frequency androgenesis from isolated microspores of maize

Anthers from a highly androgenic genotype of maize (139/39-02), when cultured in a modified, liquid YP medium, dehisced within 2–7 days resulting in a stationary suspension of microspores. After 12–15 days, the microspore suspension was found to contain multicellular masses which went on to produce macroscopic embryo-like structures within 20–25 days of culture initiation. Embryogenic callus could be obtained by transferring microspore-derived embryos onto a modified N6 medium supplemented with 2.5 mg/l dicamba and 0.1 mg/l 2,4-D. Subculture onto hormone-free medium resulted in plant regeneration. Over 400 embryo-like structures per 100 anthers cultured have been obtained from liquid induction medium as compared to 55 embryos per 100 anthers cultured on an agar-solidified medium. Approximately 5–25% of these embryo-like structures went on to produce callus from which plants could be recovered. Mechanical isolation of microspores from anthers precultured for 0, 3, and 7 days also resulted in embryo production and plant regeneration. This represents the first report of plant recovery from isolated maize microspores. The use of a liquid induction medium applied to a highly androgenic genotype allows for the production of large numbers of microspore-derived plants and provides a single, haploid cell regeneration system for maize.     

Anther culture of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Lupinus angustifolius</Emphasis>: callus formation and the development of multicellular and embryo-like structures

Androgenesis is an important technique to generate double haploid plants. Anther and microspore cultures are the methods to induce haploid embryogenesis. For culture initiation, it is necessary to select anthers with the appropriate developmental stage of microspores. For lupins, limited reports about the establishment of initial cultures for androgenesis are available. In this study, different parameters of anther culture of three genotypes of Lupinus angustifolius were investigated. For all genotypes, a considerable correlation was observed between the buds and the anthers, depending on their location in the inflorescences. Buds from the central segment of inflorescences had yellowish green anthers that contained the maximum number of microspores at uninucleate stage. Cytological investigation shows that the anthers containing these microspores were the most responsive to induction. Two types of developmental pathways were observed for microspores. In case of cold pre-treated and untreated inflorescences, microspores developed into multicellular and embryo-like structures, respectively. Effects of different factors showed significant differences among: genotypes, pre-treatment, growth regulators (GRs) and genotypes × GRs interaction. Among three genotypes, Emir showed the highest number of multicellular and embryo-like structures on MS medium + 2.0 mg/l 2,4 D + 0.5 mg/l Kinetin (Kin). For all genotypes, anthers produced calli on MS medium containing 2.0 mg/l 2,4 D + 0.5 mg/l Kin. These calli continued their growth on regeneration medium (MS + 2.0 mg/l BA + 0.5 mg/l NAA) and produced roots. Taken together, these results provide a good basis for further research towards the development of haploid plants for L. angustifolius.     

In vitro androgenesis of triticale in isolated microspore culture

Culture conditions for triticale (X Triticosecale Wittmack) androgenesis were studied using microspore culture. Sporophytic development of isolated triticale microspores in culture is described in five winter hexaploid triticale genotypes. Microspores were isolated using a microblendor, and embryogenesis was induced in modified 190-2 medium both in the presence and absence of growth regulators. The highest induction of microspore embryogenesis was obtained in a growth regulator-free medium. Adventitious embryogenesis was observed during in vitro development of triticale microspores. Albino and green plantlets were regenerated from embryo-like structures. More than 50% of regenerants were albino. In total, 126 green plantlets were produced, transplanted and established in soil. Cytological evidence revealed that 90% of the transplanted regenerants were haploid. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Tracking individual wheat microspores in vitro: identification of embryogenic microspores and body axis formation in the embryo

 The development of isolated, defined wheat microspores undergoing in vitro embryogenesis has been followed by cell tracking. Isolated wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). microspores were immobilized in Sea Plaque agarose supported by a polypropylene mesh at a low cell density and cultured in a hormone-free, maltose-containing medium in the presence of ovaries serving as a conditioning factor. Embryogenesis was followed in microspores isolated from immature anthers of freshly cut tillers or from heat- and starvation-treated, excised anthers. Three types of microspore were identified on the basis of their cytological features at the start of culture. Type-1 microspores had a big central vacuole and a nucleus close to the microspore wall, usually opposite to the germ pore. This type was identical to the late microspore stage in anthers developing in vivo. Microspores with a fragmented vacuole and a peripheral cytoplasmic pocket containing the nucleus were defined as type 2. In type-3 microspores the nucleus was positioned in a cytoplasmic pocket in the centre of the microspore. Tracking revealed that, irrespective of origin, type-1 microspores first developed into type 2 and then into type-3 microspores. After a few more days, type-3 microspores absorbed their vacuoles and differentiated into cytoplasm-rich and starch-accumulating cells, which then divided to form multicellular structures. Apparently the three types of microspore represent stages in a continuous process and not, as previously assumed, distinct classes of responding and non-responding microspores. The first cell division of the embryogenic microspores was always symmetric. Cell tracking also revealed that the original microspore wall opened opposite to a region in the multicellular microspore which consisted of cells containing starch grains while the remaining cells were starch grain-free. The starch-containing cells were located close to the germ pore of the microspore. In more advanced embryos the broken microspore wall was detected at the root pole of the embryo. Received: 27 December 1999 / Accepted: 11 May 2000     

Cytological analysis of early microspore divisions leading to gametic embryo formation in <Emphasis Type="Italic">Quercus suber</Emphasis> L. anther cultures

The correlation between the phenologic stage of the inflorescence and the microspore development stage was studied. Cytological examinations of the development of microspores during in vitro anther culture of cork oak (Quercus suber L.), were carried out during the first four weeks of culture. To observe the division occurring in the microspores, anthers were taken randomly from the cultures after heat shock treatment and were stained with DAPI. Most of the anthers responding to a heat stress treatment contained 91 % vacuolated microspores, indicating that this developmental stage is responsive to embryogenesis induction in cork-oak microspores. After the heat shock treatment some cork-oak microspores were induced and initiated the embryogenic pathway with the occurrence of numerous symmetric mitosis, producing structures with two to ten or more nuclei. These lead to the formation of high numbers of multicellular cork-oak microspores (pro-embryos). Twenty-forty days after induction, small white globular and cotyledonal embryos were observed, which further developed root and shoot, regenerating plantlets.     

Doubled haploid sunflower (Helianthus annuus) plant production by androgenesis: fact or artifact? Part 2. In vitro isolated microspore culture

Previously reported attempts to routinely produce certified doubled haploid sunflower plants were unsuccessful. Isolated microspore culture was assayed in order to overcome the high reactivity of somatic tissues such as anther wall, multicellular hair-type structures, anther connective and parenchymatous vascular bundle. Using filtration or density gradients in liquid medium (N6 supplemented with NAA 1 mg l^-1, BA 0.2 mg l^-1 and maltose 0.44 M), asymmetrical and symmetrical microspore divisions were obtained. However, contaminating cells or groups of cells coming from hairy type structures were very reactive, and able to develop into calluses. A second purification step was therefore necessary after two days in culture, to isolate a population consisting of highly viable swollen microspores. Using this procedure, besides avoiding somatic contaminants, the microspore response in terms of viability and initial division rate was increased, and sustained division and microcallus formation were achieved after addition of aminocyclopropane carboxylic acid, an ethylene precursor.Abbreviations ACC aminocyclopropane carboxylic acid - AOA aminooxyacetic acid - DAPI 4,6 diamidino-2-phenyl indole     

Programmed cell death during the transition from multicellular structures to globular embryos in barley androgenesis

Androgenesis represents one of the most fascinating examples of cell differentiation in plants. In barley, the conversion of stressed uninucleate microspores into embryo-like structures is highly efficient. One of the bottlenecks in this process is the successful release of embryo-like structures out of the exine wall of microspores. In the present work, morphological and biochemical studies were performed during the transition from multicellular structures to globular embryos. Exine wall rupture and subsequent globular embryo formation were observed only in microspores that divided asymmetrically. Independent divisions of the generative and the vegetative nuclei gave rise to heterogeneous multicellular structures, which were composed of two different cellular domains: small cells with condensed chromatin structure and large cells with normal chromatin structure. During exine wall rupture, the small cells died and their death marked the site of exine wall rupture. Cell death in the small cell domain showed typical features of plant programmed cell death. Chromatin condensation and DNA degradation preceded cell detachment and cytoplasm dismantling, a process that was characterized by the formation of vesicles and vacuoles that contained cytoplasmic material. This morphotype of programmed cell death was accompanied by an increase in the activity of caspase-3-like proteases. The orchestration of such a death program culminated in the elimination of the small generative domain, and further embryogenesis was carried out by the large vegetative domain. To date, this is the first report to show evidence that programmed cell death takes part in the development of microspore-derived embryos.     

Pro-embryos induction from <Emphasis Type="Italic">Olea europaea</Emphasis> L. isolated microspore culture

Studies were undertaken with one olive (Olea europaea L.) cultivar to identify buds with microspores competent to embryogenesis in vitro. Isolated microspore cultures were performed for the induction of gametic embryogenesis. Different pollen development stages and stress conditions (heat or cold shock) were evaluated. The correlation of inflorescence, anther morphology and the suitable stage of microspore development were analysed. The morphology of responsive buds was identified which corresponded with microspores from the late uni-nucleate to early bi-nucleate pollen stages. Symmetrical divisions of microspores as well as resulting multinucleate structures and pro-embryos were observed. In this paper, a new method of isolated microspore culture that leads to cell division and pro-embryos in olive, is reported.     

Induction of embryogenesis from isolated apple microspores

 We report, for the first time, the induction of embryogenesis and plant formation from isolated apple (Malus domestica Borkh.) microspores in vitro. Different isolation techniques were tested and an optimized protocol was elaborated. Furthermore, the influence of the induction medium and starvation treatment, using different starvation material, temperatures and time, were studied. In addition to embryo induction, the number of multicellular structures per divided microspores was found to be a suitable parameter of assessment and could be used in earlier stages during microspore culture. Although the number of embryos induced in these first experiments is low, the best frequency of embryo induction was shown to be at least twice as efficient as that obtained by anther culture. Received: 9 September 1998 / Revision received: 22 December 1998 / Accepted: 12 January 1999     

Selection of Brassica napus L. embryogenic microspores by flow sorting

Flow cytometry can be used to select and sort microspore subpopulations of Brassica napus cv. Topas. Data obtained from embryogenic microspore populations were used to identify potentially embryogenic microspores from developmentally heterogeneous microspore populations based on differences in forward light scatter and green autofluorescence. Culture enrichment for embryogenic microspores is possible. Frequencies of 8 and 14% microspore embryogenesis were obtained when selected 16 h and 72 h after culture initiation. This represents 5- and 13-fold increase in microspore embryogenesis compared to non-sorted controls.     

Manipulation of division symmetry and developmental fate in cultures of potato microspores

The effect of media composition on microspore culture was investigated in one tetraploid and two diploid potatoes. The viability of microspores isolated from 4.5 to 5 mm buds was in the range of 33 to 52%. In media for anther culture, microspores showed no further development and lost viability within 2 days. In M1 medium containing mineral components, sucrose, uridine, cytidine, myo-inositol, glutamine and lactalbumin hydrolysate, 18 to 37% of microspores underwent mitosis within 14 days. Up to 95% of the divisions were symmetric and produced equal nuclei. Some symmetrically divided microspores eventually produced structures with 3 to 10 nuclei. The proportion of the total microspore population producing multinuclear structures reached 9% in diploid clones responsive to anther culture and 1 to 2% in recalcitrant cv. Borka. Symmetric mitoses in M1 medium were induced in the presence of glutamine and lactalbumin hydrolysate. Nucleosides and myo-inositol had no effect on microspore division. In the absence of all organic components except sucrose, most mitoses were asymmetric, formation of multinuclear structures was reduced and most pollen accumulated starch indicative of gametophytic fate. In complete M1 medium, starch accumulation was suppressed. Suppression also occurred in asymmetrically divided microspores, indicating a direct inhibition of pollen development independent of the mode of microspore division. This inhibitory effect of M1 medium might present a stress which triggers the induction of symmetric microspore division and subsequent formation of multinuclear structures. This revised version was published online in June 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Cytochemical studies of callus development from microspore in cultured anther of rice

Cytochemical studies of androgenic anthers of Oryza sativa picked from the culture at 2 day intervals from 0 to 40 days have been carried out. Glutaradehyde-OsO₄-fixed and plastic-embedded sections were stained with TBO, SBB and PAS for acidic polymers, lipids and polysaccharides respectively. Among the population only 4% of microspores, which accumulate abundant amorphous lipid in the first few days of culture, are androgenic. Less than 30%, which have many lipid granules and some amorphous lipid, become nutritive microspores. Starch grains also accumulate in these nutritive microspores which degenerate at the stage when the androgenic multicellular microspores are in rapid development. The remaining microspores, which have no or little lipid, degenerate early. At about the 100-cell stage, each multicellular unit consists of two cell types, large and small. The large cells contain abundant amorphous lipid and starch grains which the small ones stain intensely with TBO.Our results indicate that the epidermis and endothecium of the cultured anthers are not quiescent. They can accumulate and transport lipid and polysaccharides at certain stages during the cultural period. Globular embryoid appearing structures and leaf-like protrusions can be observed at the surface of the callus in about 40-day old culture, indicating that both embryogenesis and organogenesis may take place in rice callus.Abbreviations OsO₄ osmium tetroxide - TBO toluidine blue O - SBB sudan black B - PAS periodic acid-Schiff's reagent - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid     

Influence of Fe concentration in the medium on multicellular pollen grains and haploid plants induced by mannitol pretreatment in barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

Summary. This study aims to clarify the short- and long-term effects of the iron concentration in the medium on androgenesis induced in barley by isolated microspore culture. The ultrastructural features and pectin composition of the intine wall were studied in the initial stages of androgenesis. The evolution of electron-dense iron deposits on the intine was analysed in multicellular pollen grains obtained by isolated microspore culture performed for 3, 6, and 9 days using various concentrations of FeNa₂ EDTA. Finally, the number of embryo-like structures and green plants obtained by microspore culture using different Fe concentrations was evaluated in order to estimate the optimum concentration for isolated microspore culture. Correspondence and reprints: Departamento de Bioquimica, Biologia Celular y Molecular de Plantas, Estación Experimental del Zaidin, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientificas, Profesor Albareda 1, 18008 Granada, Spain.     

Regeneration of Fertile Barley Plants from Mechanically Isolated Protoplasts of the Fertilized Egg Cell

A simple procedure is described for the mechanical isolation of protoplasts of unfertilized and fertilized barley egg cells from dissected ovules. Viable protoplasts were isolated from ~75% of the dissected ovules. Unfertilized protoplasts did not divide, whereas almost all fertilized protoplasts developed into microcalli. These degenerated when grown in medium only. When cocultivated with barley microspores undergoing microspore embryogenesis, the protoplasts of the fertilized egg cells developed into embryo-like structures that gave rise to fully fertile plants. On average, 75% of cocultivated protoplasts of fertilized egg cells developed into embryo-like structures. Fully fertile plants were regenerated from ~50% of the embryo-like structures. The isolation-regeneration techniques may be largely genotype independent, because similar frequencies were obtained in two different barley varieties with very different performance in anther and microspore culture. Protoplasts of unfertilized and fertilized eggs of wheat were isolated by the same procedure, and a fully fertile wheat plant was regenerated by cocultivation with barley microspores.     

Effects of culture density,conditioned medium and feeder cultures on microspore embryogenesis in Brassica napus L. cv. Topas

Summary In microspore cultures of Brassica napus L. cv. Topas, embryo yield increases with culture density up to about 40,000 microspores per ml. A much higher density (100,000 per ml) appears inhibitory to embryogenesis. A relatively high culture density (30,000 or 40,000 per ml) for the first 2–4 days of culture is crucial for embryogenesis, after which cultures may be diluted to allow better embryo growth.Medium conditioned by culturing microspores at 30,000 or 40,000 per ml for 1 day improved microspore-embryo yield in low density cultures (3,000 or 4,000 per ml) more than 3-fold. In contrast, media conditioned with microspores from 1–4 days or 0–4 days of culture were inhibitory.Use of feeder cultures resulted in up to 10-fold increase of embryo yield in low density microspore cultures, depending on the method used. Filter papers and other membranes placed on top of feeders greatly inhibited embryogenesis in the feeder layer as well as microspores cultured on the feeder, possibly due to poorer gaseous exchange.     

Stress as the major signal controlling the developmental fate of tobacco microspores: towards a unified model of induction of microspore/pollen embryogenesis

Specific stress treatments (sucrose starvation, alone or combined with a heat shock) applied to isolated tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum L.) microspores irreversibly blocked normal gametophytic development and induced the formation of embryogenic cells, which developed subsequently into pollen-derived embryos by culture at 25°C in a sugar-containing medium. A cold shock at 4°C did not inhibit microspore maturation in vitro and did not induce cell division activity, even when combined with a starvation treatment. In the absence of sucrose, microspores isolated in the G1 phase of the cell cycle replicated their DNA and accumulated in G2. Late microspores underwent miotosis during the first day of culture which resulted in a mixed population of bicellular pollen grains and uninucleate microspores, both embryogenic. After the inductive stress treatments the origin of the first multicellular structures, formed in the sugar-containing medium, could be traced to divisions of the microspore cell or divisions of the vegetative cell of bicellular pollen, indicating that the symmetry of microspore mitosis in vitro is not important for embryogenic induction. These results represent a step forward towards a unified model of induction of embryogenesis from microspores/pollen which, within a relatively wide developmental window, are competent to deviate from normal gametophytic development and initiate the alternative sporophytic programme, in response to specific stress signals.Abbreviation DAPI 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole We acknowledge the help of Monica Boscaiu and Zarko Hrzenjak with the artwork, and Michaela Braun-Mayer for growing the tobacco plants. This project was financed by the Austrian Fonds zur Forderung der wissenschaftlichen Forschung, grant S6003-BIO.     

Morphological events in cultures of mechanically isolated maize mcirospores

Summary In tis androgenic response, maize is considered to be a recalcitrant plant. We used mechanically isolated microspores of maize genotype A18 to establish a responsive microspore culture of maize. Morphological events occurring during the first days of maize androgenesis in a microspore culture were observed and described, and some morphological markers for distinguishing between embryogenic microspores and nonembryogenic microspores were identified. It was found that the enlargement of microspores during the first days in culture and the ‘star-like’ organization of the cytoplasm inside the microspore are connected with reprogramming of the developmental pathway in maize microspores. Some differences were also found in the surface wall architecture of embryogenic microspores. Fertile plants were successfully recovered from microspore-originated structures.     

Increased frequency of dividing microspores and improved maintenance of multicellular microspores of Coffea arabica in medium with coconut milk

The number of dividing microspores of Coffea arabica L. cv. Catuai and Catimor could be drastically increased in microspore media containing 16% (w/v) coconut milk, allowing cell divisions to continue in the microspore and multicellular microspores to survive until day 60. After a cold treatment, the microspores were mechanically isolated prior to cultivation in Murashige and Skoog medium supplemented with sucrose and maltose and (mg l^-1) 2,4-d: 2, BAP: 1 or a combination of kinetin: .5, 2,4-d: .5 and NAA: .5 as stationary suspension at a density of 1,200/ml. The crucial stage during microsporogenesis suitable for in vitro androgenesis proved to be mid uninucleate till early binucleate in flowerbuds with the size of 13–15 mm two to three days before anthesis. The initial steps of androgenesis were determined.Abbreviations BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - 2,4-d 2,4-dichlorophenoxy-acetic acid - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid