Interannual climatic variation mediates elevated CO2 and O3 effects on forest growth

We analyzed growth data from model aspen (Populus tremuloides Michx.) forest ecosystems grown in elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide ([CO₂]; 518 μL L^?1) and ozone concentrations ([O₃]; 1.5 × background of 30–40 nL L^?1 during daylight hours) for 7 years using free‐air CO₂ enrichment technology to determine how interannual variability in present‐day climate might affect growth responses to either gas. We also tested whether growth effects of those gasses were sustained over time. Elevated [CO₂] increased tree heights, diameters, and main stem volumes by 11%, 16%, and 20%, respectively, whereas elevated ozone [O₃] decreased them by 11%, 8%, and 29%, respectively. Responses similar to these were found for stand volume and basal area. There were no growth responses to the combination of elevated [CO₂+O₃]. The elevated [CO₂] growth stimulation was found to be decreasing, but relative growth rates varied considerably from year to year. Neither the variation in annual relative growth rates nor the apparent decline in CO₂ growth response could be explained in terms of nitrogen or water limitations. Instead, growth responses to elevated [CO₂] and [O₃] interacted strongly with present‐day interannual variability in climatic conditions. The amount of photosynthetically active radiation and temperature during specific times of the year coinciding with growth phenology explained 20–63% of the annual variation in growth response to elevated [CO₂] and [O₃]. Years with higher photosynthetic photon flux (PPF) during the month of July resulted in more positive growth responses to elevated [CO₂] and more negative growth responses to elevated [O₃]. Mean daily temperatures during the month of October affected growth in a similar fashion the following year. These results indicate that a several‐year trend of increasingly cloudy summers and cool autumns were responsible for the decrease in CO₂ growth response.     

The impact of elevated CO2 on yield loss from a C3 and C4 weed in field-grown soybean

Soybean (Glycine max) was grown at ambient and enhanced carbon dioxide (CO₂, + 250 μL L^?1 above ambient) with and without the presence of a C3 weed (lambsquarters, Chenopodium album L.) and a C4 weed (redroot pigweed, Amaranthus retroflexus L.), in order to evaluate the impact of rising atmospheric carbon dioxide concentration [CO₂] on crop production losses due to weeds. Weeds of a given species were sown at a density of two per metre of row. A significant reduction in soybean seed yield was observed with either weed species relative to the weed‐free control at either [CO₂]. However, for lambsquarters the reduction in soybean seed yield relative to the weed‐free condition increased from 28 to 39% as CO₂ increased, with a 65% increase in the average dry weight of lambsquarters at enhanced [CO₂]. Conversely, for pigweed, soybean seed yield losses diminished with increasing [CO₂] from 45 to 30%, with no change in the average dry weight of pigweed. In a weed‐free environment, elevated [CO₂] resulted in a significant increase in vegetative dry weight and seed yield at maturity for soybean (33 and 24%, respectively) compared to the ambient CO₂ condition. Interestingly, the presence of either weed negated the ability of soybean to respond either vegetatively or reproductively to enhanced [CO₂]. Results from this experiment suggest: (i) that rising [CO₂] could alter current yield losses associated with competition from weeds; and (ii) that weed control will be crucial in realizing any potential increase in economic yield of agronomic crops such as soybean as atmospheric [CO₂] increases.     

Salinity and sea level mediate elevated CO2 effects on C3–C4 plant interactions and tissue nitrogen in a Chesapeake Bay tidal wetland

Elevated atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations ([CO₂]) generally increase plant photosynthesis in C₃ species, but not in C₄ species, and reduce stomatal conductance in both C₃ and C₄ plants. In addition, tissue nitrogen concentration ([N]) often fails to keep pace with enhanced carbon gain under elevated CO₂, particularly in C₃ species. While these responses are well documented in many species, implications for plant growth and nutrient cycling in native ecosystems are not clear. Here we present data on 18 years of measurement of above and belowground biomass, tissue [N] and total standing crop of N for a Scirpus olneyi‐dominated (C₃ sedge) community, a Spartina patens‐dominated (C₄ grass) community and a C₃–C₄‐mixed species community exposed to ambient and elevated (ambient +340 ppm) atmospheric [CO₂] in natural salinity and sea level conditions of a Chesapeake Bay wetland. Increased biomass production (shoots plus roots) under elevated [CO₂] in the S. olneyi‐dominated community was sustained throughout the study, averaging approximately 35%, while no significant effect of elevated [CO₂] was found for total biomass in the C₄‐dominated community. We found a significant decline in C₄ biomass (correlated with rising sea level) and a concomitant increase in C₃ biomass in the mixed community. This shift from C₄ to C₃ was accelerated by the elevated [CO₂] treatment. The elevated [CO₂] stimulation of total biomass accumulation was greatest during rainy, low salinity years: the average increase above the ambient treatment during the three wettest years (1994, 1996, 2003) was 2.9 t ha⁻¹ but in the three driest years (1995, 1999, 2002), it was 1.2 t ha⁻¹. Elevated [CO₂] depressed tissue [N] in both species, but especially in the S. olneyi where the relative depression was positively correlated with salinity and negatively related with the relative enhancement of total biomass production. Thus, the greatest amount of carbon was added to the S. olneyi‐dominated community during years when shoot [N] was reduced the most, suggesting that the availability of N was not the most or even the main limitation to elevated [CO₂] stimulation of carbon accumulation in this ecosystem.     

Wood properties of two silver birch clones exposed to elevated CO2 and O3

Effects of elevated carbon dioxide (CO₂) and ozone (O₃) on wood properties of two initially 7‐year‐old silver birch (Betula pendula Roth) clones were studied after a fumigation during three growing seasons. Forty trees, representing two fast‐growing clones (4 and 80), were exposed in open‐top chambers to the following treatments: outside control, chamber control, 2 × ambient [CO₂], 2 × ambient [O₃] and 2 × ambient [CO₂]+2 × ambient [O₃]. After the 3‐year exposure, the trees were felled and wood properties were analyzed. The treatments affected both stem wood structure and chemistry. Elevated [CO₂] increased annual ring width, and concentrations of extractives and starch, and decreased concentrations of cellulose and gravimetric lignin. Elevated O₃ decreased vessel percentage and increased cell wall percentage in clone 80. In vessel percentage, elevated CO₂ ameliorated the O₃‐induced decrease. In clone 4, elevated O₃ decreased nitrogen concentration of wood. The two clones had different wood properties. In clone 4, the concentrations of extractives, starch, soluble sugars and nitrogen were greater than in clone 80, while in clone 80 the concentrations of cellulose and acid‐soluble lignin were higher. Clone 4 also had slightly longer fibres, greater vessel lumen diameter and vessel percentage than clone 80, while in clone 80 cell wall percentage was greater. Our results show that wood properties of young silver birch trees were altered under elevated CO₂ in both clones, whereas the effects of O₃ depended on clone.     

Acquisition and within-plant allocation of 13C and 15N in CO2-enriched Quercus robur plants

We assessed the effects of doubling atmospheric CO₂ concentration, [CO₂], on C and N allocation within pedunculate oak plants (Quercus robur L.) grown in containers under optimal water supply. A short-term dual ¹³CO₂ and ¹⁵NO₃^? labelling experiment was carried out when the plants had formed their third growing flush. The 22-week exposure to 700 μl l^?1 [CO₂] stimulated plant growth and biomass accumulation (+53% as compared with the 350 μl l^?1 [CO₂] treatment) but decreased the root/shoot biomass ratio (-23%) and specific leaf area (-18%). Moreover, there was an increase in net CO₂ assimilation rate (+37% on a leaf dry weight basis; +71% on a leaf area basis), and a decrease in both above- and below-ground CO₂ respiration rates (-32 and -26%, respectively, on a dry mass basis) under elevated [CO₂]. ¹³C acquisition, expressed on a plant mass basis or on a plant leaf area basis, was also markedly stimulated under elevated [CO₂] both after the 12-h ¹³CO₂ pulse phase and after the 60-h chase phase. Plant N content was increased under elevated CO₂ (+36%), but not enough to compensate for the increase in plant C content (+53%). Thus, the plant C/N ratio was increased (+13%) and plant N concentration was decreased (-11%). There was no effect of elevated [CO₂] on fine root-specific ¹⁵N uptake (amount of recently assimilated ¹⁵N per unit fine root dry mass), suggesting that modifications of plant N pools were merely linked to root size and not to root function. N concentration was decreased in the leaves of the first and second growing flushes and in the coarse roots, whereas it was unaffected by [CO₂] in the stem and in the actively growing organs (fine roots and leaves of the third growth flush). Furthermore, leaf N content per unit area was unaffected by [CO₂]. These results are consistent with the short-term optimization of N distribution within the plants with respect to growth and photosynthesis. Such an optimization might be achieved at the expense of the N pools in storage compartments (coarse roots, leaves of the first and second growth flushes). After the 60-h ¹³C chase phase, leaves of the first and second growth flushes were almost completely depleted in recent ¹³C under ambient [CO₂], whereas these leaves retained important amounts of recently assimilated ¹³C (carbohydrate reserves?) under elevated [CO₂].     

Acclimation of photosynthesis to elevated CO2 and temperature in five British native species of contrasting functional type

Acclimation of photosynthesis to growth at elevated CO₂ concentration varies markedly between species. Species functionally classified as stress-tolerators (S) and ruderals (R), are thought to be incapable, or the least capable, of responding positively in terms of growth to elevated [CO₂]. Is this pattern of response also apparent in leaf photosynthesis of wild S- and R-strategists? Acclimatory loss of a photosynthetic and growth response to elevated [CO₂] is assumed to reflect limitation on capacity to utilize additional photosynthate. The doubling of pre-industrial global [CO₂] is expected to coincide with a 3 °C increase in mean temperature which could stimulate growth; will photosynthetic capacity at elevated [CO₂] be greater when the concurrent temperature increase is simulated? Five species from natural grassland of NW Europe and of contrasting ecological strategy were grown in hemispherical greenhouses, environmentally controlled to track the external microclimate. Within a replicated design, plants were grown at (i) current ambient [CO₂] and temperature, (ii) elevated [CO₂] (ambient + 340 μmol mol^–1) and ambient temperature, (iii) ambient [CO₂] and elevated temperature (ambient + 3 °C), or (iv) elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature. After 75–104 days, the CO₂ response of light-saturated rates of photosynthesis (A_sat) was analysed in controlled-environment cuvettes in a field laboratory. There was no acclimatory loss of photosynthetic capacity with growth in elevated [CO₂] or elevated temperature over this period in Poa alpina (S), Bellis perennis (R) or Plantago lanceolata (mixed C-S-R strategist), and a significant (P ? ? bl 0.05) increase in capacity in Helianthemum nummularium (S) and Poa annua (R). Photosynthetic rates of leaves grown and measured in elevated [CO₂] were therefore significantly higher than rates for leaves grown and measured in ambient [CO₂], for all species. With the exception of Poa alpina, stomatal conductance and stomatal limitation on A_sat showed no acclimatory response to growth in elevated [CO₂]. Carboxylation efficiency, determined from the initial slope of the response of A_sat to intercellular CO₂ concentration was significantly increased by elevated [CO₂] and elevated temperature in H.nummularium, implying a possible increase in in vivo RubisCO activity. Increased carboxylation efficiency of this species was also reflected by an increase in the CO₂- and light-saturated rates of photosynthesis, indicating an increased capacity for regeneration of the primary CO₂ acceptor in photosynthesis. The results show that R-strategists and slow-growing S-strategists, are inherently capable of large increases in leaf photosynthetic capacity with growth in elevated [CO₂] in contrast to expectations from growth studies. With the exception of P.annua, where there was a significant negative interaction between CO₂ and temperature, concurrent increase in growth temperature had little effect on this pattern of response.     

Soybean nodulation and N2 fixation response to drought under carbon dioxide enrichment

The combined effects of carbon dioxide (CO₂) enrichment and water deficits on nodulation and N₂ fixation were analysed in soybean [Glycine max (L.) Merr.]. Two short-term experiments were conducted in greenhouses with plants subjected to soil drying, while exposed to CO₂ atmospheres of either 360 or 700 μmol CO₂ mol^–1. Under drought-stressed conditions, elevated [CO₂] resulted in a delay in the decrease in N₂ fixation rates associated with drying of the soil used in these experiments. The elevated [CO₂] also allowed the plants under drought to sustain significant increases in nodule number and mass relative to those under ambient [CO₂]. The total non-structural carbohydrate (TNC) concentration was lower in the shoots of the plants exposed to drought; however, plants under elevated CO₂ had much higher TNC levels than those under ambient CO₂. For both [CO₂] treatments, drought stress induced a substantial accumulation of TNC in the nodules that paralleled N₂ fixation decline, which indicates that nodule activity under drought may not be carbon limited. Under drought stress, ureide concentration increased in all plant tissues. However, exposure to elevated [CO₂] resulted in substantially less drought-induced ureide accumulation in leaf and petiole tissues. A strong negative correlation was found between ureide accumulation and TNC levels in the leaves. This relationship, together with the large effect of elevated [CO₂] on the decrease of ureide accumulation in the leaves, indicated the importance of ureide breakdown in the response of N₂ fixation to drought and of feedback inhibition by ureides on nodule activity. It is concluded that an important effect of CO₂ enrichment on soybean under drought conditions is an enhancement of photoassimilation, an increased partitioning of carbon to nodules and a decrease of leaf ureide levels, which is associated with sustained nodule growth and N₂ rates under soil water deficits. We suggest that future [CO₂] increases are likely to benefit soybean production by increasing the drought tolerance of N₂ fixation.     

The impact of elevated carbon dioxide on the growth and gas exchange of three C4 species differing in CO2 leak rates

Recent work has suggested that the photosynthetic rate of certain C₄ species can be stimulated by increasing CO₂ concentration, [CO₂], even under optimal water and nutrients. To determine the basis for the observed photosynthetic stimulation, we tested the hypothesis that the CO₂ leak rate from the bundle sheath would be directly related to any observed stimulation in single leaf photosynthesis at double the current [CO₂]. Three C₄ species that differed in the reported degree of bundle sheath leakiness to CO₂, Flaveria trinervia, Panicum miliaceum, and Panicum maximum, were grown for 31–48 days after sowing at a [CO₂] of 350 μl l^?1 (ambient) or 700 μl l^?1 (elevated). Assimilation as a function of increasing [CO₂] at high photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD, 1 600 μmol m^?2 s^?1) indicated that leaf photosynthesis was not saturated under current ambient [CO₂] for any of the three C₄ species. Assimilation as a function of increasing PPFD also indicated that the response of leaf photosynthesis to elevated [CO₂] was light dependent for all three C₄ species. The stimulation of leaf photosynthesis at elevated [CO₂] was not associated with previously published values of CO₂ leak rates from the bundle sheath, changes in the ratio of activities of PEP-carboxylase to RuBP carboxylase/oxgenase, or any improvement in daytime leaf water potential for the species tested in this experiment. In spite of the simulation of leaf photosynthesis, a significant increase in growth at elevated [CO₂] was only observed for one species, F. trinervia. Results from this study indicate that leaf photosynthetic rates of certain C₄ species can respond directly to increased [CO₂] under optimal growth conditions, but that the stimulation of whole plant growth at elevated carbon dioxide cannot be predicted solely on the response of individual leaves.     

The effects of elevated atmospheric CO2 on the amount and depth distribution of plant water uptake in a California annual grassland

Soil moisture profiles can affect species composition and ecosystem processes, but the effects of increased concentrations of atmospheric carbon dioxide ([CO₂]) on the vertical distribution of plant water uptake have not been studied. Because plant species composition affects soil moisture profiles, and is likely to shift under elevated [CO₂], it is also important to test whether the indirect effects of [CO₂] on soil water content may depend on species composition. We examined the effects of elevated [CO₂] and species composition on soil moisture profiles in an annual grassland of California. We grew monocultures and a mixture of Avena barbata and Hemizonia congesta– the dominant species of two phenological groups – in microcosms exposed to ambient (～370 μmol mol^?1) and elevated (～700 μmol mol^?1) [CO₂]. Both species increased intrinsic and yield‐based water use efficiency under elevated [CO₂], but soil moisture increased only in communities with A. barbata, the dominant early‐season annual grass. In A. barbata monocultures, the [CO₂] treatment did not affect the depth distribution of soil water loss. In contrast to communities with A. barbata, monocultures of H. congesta, a late‐season annual forb, did not conserve water under elevated [CO₂], reflecting the increased growth of these plants. In late spring, elevated [CO₂] also increased the efficiency of deep roots in H. congesta monocultures. Under ambient [CO₂], roots below 60 cm accounted for 22% of total root biomass and were associated with 9% of total water loss, whereas in elevated [CO₂], 16% of total belowground biomass was associated with 34% of total water loss. Both soil moisture and isotope data showed that H. congesta monocultures grown under elevated [CO₂] began extracting water from deep soils 2 weeks earlier than plants in ambient [CO₂].     

Biomass allocation in old-field annual species grown in elevated CO2 environments: no evidence for optimal partitioning

Increased atmospheric carbon dioxide supply is predicted to alter plant growth and biomass allocation patterns. It is not clear whether changes in biomass allocation reflect optimal partitioning or whether they are a direct effect of increased growth rates. Plasticity in growth and biomass allocation patterns was investigated at two concentrations of CO₂ ([CO₂]) and at limiting and nonlimiting nutrient levels for four fast‐ growing old‐field annual species. Abutilon theophrasti, Amaranthus retroflexus, Chenopodium album, and Polygonum pensylvanicum were grown from seed in controlled growth chamber conditions at current (350 μmol mol^?1, ambient) and future‐ predicted (700 μmol mol^?1, elevated) CO₂ levels. Frequent harvests were used to determine growth and biomass allocation responses of these plants throughout vegetative development. Under nonlimiting nutrient conditions, whole plant growth was increased greatly under elevated [CO₂] for three C3 species and moderately increased for a C4 species (Amaranthus). No significant increases in whole plant growth were observed under limiting nutrient conditions. Plants grown in elevated [CO₂] had lower or unchanged root:shoot ratios, contrary to what would be expected by optimal partitioning theory. These differences disappeared when allometric plots of the same data were analysed, indicating that CO₂‐induced differences in root:shoot allocation were a consequence of accelerated growth and development rates. Allocation to leaf area was unaffected by atmospheric [CO₂] for these species. The general lack of biomass allocation responses to [CO₂] availability is in stark contrast with known responses of these species to light and nutrient gradients. We conclude that biomass allocation responses to elevated atmospheric [CO₂] are not consistent with optimal partitioning predictions.     

P uptake by arbuscular mycorrhizal hyphae: effect of soil temperature and atmospheric CO2 enrichment

Mycorrhizas are ubiquitous symbioses that may have an important role in the movement of C from air to soil. Studies on the effects of climate change factors on mycorrhizas have been concentrated on the effects of atmospheric [CO₂] whereas temperature effects have been neglected. Based on previous results showing no effect of varying atmospheric [CO₂] on the development and P uptake of the arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) colonizing plants growing in controlled conditions, we hypothesized that soil temperature would have a higher impact on AMF development and nutrient uptake than the effects of [CO₂] on the host plant. Pea plants were grown in association with either a single isolate of Glomus caledonium or AMF from field soil in factorial combination with the corresponding current (10 °C) or elevated (15 °C) soil temperatures at current (350 p.p.m) or elevated (700 p.p.m) atmospheric [CO₂]. ³³P uptake by extraradical AMF hyphae was measured independently from root P uptake in a root exclusion compartment. Intraradical colonization developed well at both soil temperatures and almost duplicated from 10 to 15 °C. Extraradical mycelium developed only at 15 °C in the root exclusion compartment and hyphal P uptake could therefore be studied at 15 °C only. Hyphal P uptake differed markedly between inoculum types, but was not altered by growing the host plants at two atmospheric [CO₂] levels. No significant [CO₂] × soil temperature interactions were observed. The results suggested that, in the system tested, AMF development and function is likely more influenced by the temperature component of climate change than by its [CO₂] component. We suggest that much more attention should be paid to temperature effects in future studies.     

Interactions between atmospheric CO2 concentration and phosphorus nutrition on the formation of proteoid roots in white lupin (Lupinus albus L.)

Atmospheric [CO₂] affects photosynthesis and therefore should affect the supply of carbon to roots. To evaluate interactions between carbon supply and nutrient acquisition, the [CO₂] effects on root growth, proteoid root formation and phosphorus (P) uptake capacity were studied in white lupin (Lupinus albus L.) grown hydroponically at 200, 410 and 750 µmol mol^?1 CO₂, under sufficient (0·25 mm P) and deficient (0·69 µm P) phosphorus. Plant size increased with increasing [CO₂] only at high P. Both P deficiency and increasing [CO₂] increased the production of proteoid clusters; the increase in response to increased [CO₂] was proportionally greater from low to ambient [CO₂] than from ambient to high. The activity of phosphoenol pyruvate carboxylase in the proteoid root, the exudation of organic acids from the roots, and the specific uptake of P increased with P deficiency, but were unaffected by [CO₂]. Increasing [CO₂] from Pleistocene levels to those predicted for the next century increased plant size and allocation to proteoid roots, but did not change the specific P uptake capacity per unit root mass. Hence, rising [CO₂] should promote nutrient uptake by allowing lupins to mine greater volumes of soil.     

Productivity and water use of wheat under free-air CO2 enrichment

A free-air CO₂ enrichment (FACE) experiment was conducted at Maricopa, Arizona, on wheat from December 1992 through May 1993. The FACE apparatus maintained the CO₂ concentration, [CO₂], at 550 μmol mol^?1 across four replicate 25-m-diameter circular plots under natural conditions in an open field. Four matching Control plots at ambient [CO₂] (about 370 μmol mol^?1) were also installed in the field. In addition to the two levels of [CO₂], there were ample (Wet) and limiting (Dry) levels of water supplied through a subsurface drip irrigation system in a strip, split-plot design. Measurements were made of net radiation, R_n; soil heat flux, G_o; soil temperature; foliage or surface temperature; air dry and wet bulb temperatures; and wind speed. Sensible heat flux, H, was calculated from the wind and temperature measurements. Latent heat flux, λET, and evapotranspiration, ET, were determined as the residual in the energy balance. The FACE treatment reduced daily total R_n by an average 4%. Daily FACE sensible heat flux, H, was higher in the FACE plots. Daily latent heat flux, λET, and evapotranspiration, ET, were consistently lower in the FACE plots than in the Control plots for most of the growing season, about 8% on the average. Net canopy photosynthesis was stimulated by an average 19 and 44% in the Wet and Dry plots, respectively, by elevated [CO₂] for most of the growing season. No significant acclimation or down regulation was observed. There was little above-ground growth response to elevated [CO₂] early in the season when temperatures were cool. Then, as temperatures warmed into spring, the FACE plants grew about 20% more than the Control plants at ambient [CO₂], as shown by above-ground biomass accumulation. Root biomass accumulation was also stimulated about 20%. In May the FACE plants matured and senesced about a week earlier than the Controls in the Wet plots. The FACE plants averaged 0.6 °C warmer than the Controls from February through April in the well-watered plots, and we speculate that this temperature rise contributed to the earlier maturity. Because of the acceleration of senescence, there was a shortening of the duration of grain filling, and consequently, there was a narrowing of the final biomass and yield differences. The 20% mid-season growth advantage of FACE shrunk to about an 8% yield advantage in the Wet plots, while the yield differences between FACE and Control remained at about 20% in the Dry plots.     

Altered physiological and growth responses to elevated [CO2] in offspring from holm oak (Quercus ilex L.) mother trees with lifetime exposure to naturally elevated [CO2]

An important question with respect to plant performance in future climatic scenarios is whether the offspring of mature trees that have experienced lifelong exposure to elevated [CO₂] show altered physiological responses to elevated [CO₂] compared with those originating from current ambient CO₂ concentrations. To investigate this question, acorns were collected from two seed sources, denoted as ‘control’ and ‘spring’, from Quercus ilex mother trees grown at ambient (36 Pa) and at about twice ambient CO₂ concentrations, respectively, close to a natural CO₂ spring, Laiatico, central Italy. The seedlings were raised for 8 months under controlled conditions at ambient and elevated [CO₂] in a reciprocal experimental design and were used for the determination of biomass, photosynthesis and foliar carbohydrate concentrations, as well as the accumulation of structural biomass and lignin during leaf maturation. Under ambient [CO₂], biomass and foliar carbon acquisition in control progeny were not significantly different from spring progeny. However, under elevated [CO₂], spring seedlings showed less CO₂ acclimation than control seedlings but no significant differences in non‐structural carbohydrate concentrations and structural biomass per unit leaf dry mass. Developmental lignin accumulation in leaves was delayed under elevated [CO₂] compared with ambient [CO₂], but only in control progeny. Under elevated [CO₂], whole‐plant biomass, leaf area and stem diameter were significantly increased in Quercus ilex seedlings from both seed sources but with a higher stimulation of above‐ground biomass in spring than in control seedlings and a higher stimulation of below‐ground biomass in control seedlings. These results indicate that life history and/or progeny may determine the species‐specific CO₂ response and suggest that positive CO₂ acclimation is possible.     

Ozone and density affect the response of biomass and seed yield to elevated CO2 in rice

Tropospheric O₃ reduces growth and yield of many crop species, whereas CO₂ ameliorates the negative effects of O₃. Thus, in a combined elevated CO₂ and O₃ atmosphere, seed yield is at least restored to that of charcoal‐filtered (CF) air at ambient CO₂. The CO₂‐induced yield increase in CF air is highly variable, suggesting other potential resource limitations. To understand such variability in response, we tested that (1) competition for resources precludes some of the CO₂ enhancement on biomass and yield; and (2) O₃ reduces competition in elevated CO₂. We grew rice (Oryza sativa L.) at five densities in CF and O₃‐fumigated (+O3) air at ambient (A) and elevated [CO₂] (+CO2) in 1997 and 1998. O₃ reduced biomass by 25% and seed yield by 13–20% in A, but had little effect in +CO2. A competition model of biomass and yield response to density based on resource availability without competition showed that fewer resources were used for biomass in +O3 than in CF (average 53% vs. 70%) in A, while in +CO2 85% of resources were used for biomass regardless of O₃ suggesting greater depletion of resources. The enhanced biomass response to CO₂ with O₃ is consistent with a 22% greater CO₂ enhancement ratio [mass in +CO2 air/mass in A air; enhancement ratio (ER)] in +O3 than in CF air. For seed yield, few resources were used (average 17% and 25% for CF in 1997 and 1998, respectively), and ER was 13% greater in +O3. With competition the rate of change of individual plant biomass to density was not affected by +CO2 in CF air in 1997 but was increased 19% with more nutrients in 1998, indicating resource limitations with +CO2. The rate of change of individual plant yield to density was reduced with CO₂ in 1997 and unchanged in 1998 showing a different response to resource limitation for reproductive biomass. The resource use in +O3‐A suggested that increased density and soil fertility might compensate for pollutant damage. Although ambient [O₃] can modulate the response to elevated CO₂, resource limitation precludes the CO₂ fertilization impact and both factors need consideration for better management and forecasts of future productivity.     

Integration of photosynthetic acclimation to CO2 at the whole-plant level

Primary events in photosynthetic (PS) acclimation to elevated CO₂ concentration ([CO₂]) occur at the molecular level in leaf mesophyll cells, but final growth response to [CO₂] involves acclimation responses associated with photosynthate partitioning among plant organs in relation to resources limiting growth. Source–sink interactions, particularly with regard to carbon (C) and nitrogen (N), are key determinants of PS acclimation to elevated [CO₂] at the whole-plant level. In the long term, PS and growth response to [CO₂] are dependent on genotypic and environmental factors affecting the plant's ability to develop new sinks for C, and acquire adequate N and other resources to support an enhanced growth potential. Growth at elevated [CO₂] usually increases N use efficiency because PS rates can be maintained at levels comparable to those observed at ambient [CO₂] with less N investment in PS enzymes. A frequent acclimation response, particularly under N-limited conditions, is for the accumulation of leaf carbohydrates at elevated [CO₂] to lead to repression of genes associated with the production of PS enzymes. The hypothesis that this is an adaptive response, leading to a diversion of N to plant organs where it is of greatest benefit in terms of competitive ability and reproductive fitness, needs to be more rigorously tested. The biological control mechanisms which plants have evolved to acclimate to shifts in source–sink balance caused by elevated [CO₂] are complex, and will only be fully elucidated by probing at all scales along the hierarchy from molecular to ecosystem. Use of environmental manipulations and genotypic comparisons will facilitate the testing of specific hypotheses. Improving our ability to predict PS acclimation to [CO₂] will require the integration of results from laboratory studies using simple model systems with results from whole-plant studies that include measurements of processes operating at several scales. Abbreviations: CAM, crassulacean acid metabolism; FACE, Free-Air CO₂ Enrichment; Pi, inorganic phosphate; LAR, leaf area ratio (m² g^-1); LWR, leaf weight ratio (g g^-1); NAR, net assimilation rate (g m^-2 d^{- 1}); PS, photosynthetic; RGR, relative growth rate (g g^-1 d^-1); R:S, root/shoot ratio; rubisco, ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase; RuBP, ribulose bisphosphate; SLA, specific leaf area (m² g^-1); SPS, sucrose phosphate synthase; WUE, water use efficiency (g biomass g H₂O^-1).     

Stomatal acclimation to increased CO2 concentration in a Florida scrub oak species Quercus myrtifolia Willd

Native scrub‐oak communities in Florida were exposed for three seasons in open top chambers to present atmospheric [CO₂] (approx. 350 μmol mol^?1) and to high [CO₂] (increased by 350 μmol mol^?1). Stomatal and photosynthetic acclimation to high [CO₂] of the dominant species Quercus myrtifolia was examined by leaf gas exchange of excised shoots. Stomatal conductance (g_s) was approximately 40% lower in the high‐ compared to low‐[CO₂]‐grown plants when measured at their respective growth concentrations. Reciprocal measurements of g_s in both high‐ and low‐[CO₂]‐grown plants showed that there was negative acclimation in the high‐[CO₂]‐grown plants (9–16% reduction in g_s when measured at 700 μmol mol^?1), but these were small compared to those for net CO₂ assimilation rate (A, 21–36%). Stomatal acclimation was more clearly evident in the curve of stomatal response to intercellular [CO₂] (c_i) which showed a reduction in stomatal sensitivity at low c_i in the high‐[CO₂]‐grown plants. Stomatal density showed no change in response to growth in high growth [CO₂]. Long‐term stomatal and photosynthetic acclimation to growth in high [CO₂] did not markedly change the 2·5‐ to 3‐fold increase in gas‐exchange‐derived water use efficiency caused by high [CO₂].     

[CO2]- and density-dependent competition between grassland species

The predicted ongoing increase of atmospheric carbon dioxide levels is considered to be one of the main threats to biodiversity due to potential changes in biotic interactions. We tested whether effects of intra‐ and interspecific planting density of the calcareous grassland perennials Bromus erectus and Carex flacca change in response to elevated [CO₂] (600 ppm) by using factorial combinations of seven densities (0, 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, 24 tillers per 8 × 8 cm² cell) of both species in plots with and without CO₂ enrichment. Although aboveground biomass of C. flacca was increased by 54% under elevated [CO₂], the combined aboveground biomass of the whole stand was not significantly increased. C. flacca tended to produce more tillers under elevated [CO₂] while B. erectus produced less tillers. The positive effect of [CO₂] on the number of tillers of C. flacca was strongest at high intraspecific densities. On the other hand, the negative effect of [CO₂] on the number of tillers of B. erectus was not present at intermediate intraspecific planting densities. Seed production of C. flacca was more than doubled under elevated [CO₂], while seed production of B. erectus was not affected. Moreover, the mass per seed of C. flacca was increased by elevated [CO₂] at intermediate interspecific planting densities while the mass per seed of B. erectus was decreased by elevated [CO₂] at high interspecific planting densities. Our results show that the responses of C. flacca and B. erectus to elevated [CO₂] depend in a complex way on initial planting densities of both species. In other words, competition between these two model species is both [CO₂]‐ and density dependent. On average, however, the effects of [CO₂] on the individual species indicate that the composition of calcareous grasslands is likely to change under elevated [CO₂] in favor of C. flacca.     

Elevated CO2 enhances plant growth in droughted N2-fixing alfalfa without improving water status

The long-term interaction between elevated CO₂ and soil water deficit was analysed in N₂-fixing alfalfa plants in order to assess the possible drought tolerance effect of CO₂. Elevated CO₂ could delay the onset of drought stress by decreasing transpiration rates, but this effect was avoided by subjecting plants to the same soil water content. Nodulated alfalfa plants subjected to ambient (400 μmol mol^?1) or elevated (700 μmol mol^?1) CO₂ were either well watered or partially watered by restricting water to obtain 30% of the water content at field capacity (ampproximately 0.55 g water cm^?3). The negative effects of soil water deficit on plant growth were counterbalanced by elevated CO₂. In droughted plants, elevated CO₂ stimulated carbon fixation and, as a result, biomass production was even greater than in well-watered plants grown in ambient CO₂. Below-ground production was preferentially stimulated by elevated CO₂ in droughted plants, increasing nodule biomass production and the availability of photosynthates to the nodules. As a result, total nitrogen content in droughted plants was higher than in well-watered plants grown in ambient CO₂. The beneficial effect of elevated CO₂ was not correlated with a better plant water status. It is concluded that elevated CO₂ enhances growth of droughted plants by stimulating carbon fixation, preferentially increasing the availability of photosynthates to below-ground production (roots and nodules) without improving water status. This means that elevated CO₂ enhances the ability to produce more biomass in N₂-fixing alfalfa under given soil water stress, improving drought tolerance.     

Altered night-time CO2 concentration affects the growth, physiology and biochemistry of soybean

Soybean plants (Glycine max (L.) Merr. c.v. Williams) were grown in CO₂ controlled, natural-light growth chambers under one of four atmospheric CO₂ concentrations ([CO₂]): (1) 250 μmol mol^–1 24 h d^–1[250/250]; (2) 1000 μmol mol^–1 24 h d^–1[1000/1000]; (3) 250 μmol mol^–1 during daylight hours and 1000 μmol mol^–1 during night-time hours [250/1000] or (4) 1000 μmol mol^–1 during daylight hours and 250 μmol mol^–1 during night-time hours [1000/250]. During the vegetative growth phase few physiological differences were observed between plants exposed to a constant 24 h [CO₂] (250/250 and 1000/1000) and those that were switched to a higher or lower [CO₂] at night (250/1000 and 1000/250), suggesting that the primary physiological responses of plants to growth in elevated [CO₂] is apparently a response to daytime [CO₂] only. However, by the end of the reproductive growth phase, major differences were observed. Plants grown in the 1000/250 regime, when compared with those in the 1000/1000 regime, had significantly more leaf area and leaf mass, 27% more total plant dry mass, but only 18% of the fruit mass. After 12 weeks of growth these plants also had 19% higher respiration rates and 32% lower photosynthetic rates than the 1000/1000 plants. As a result the ratio of carbon gain to carbon loss was reduced significantly in the plants exposed to the reduced night-time [CO₂]. Plants grown in the opposite switching environment, 250/1000 versus 250/250, showed no major differences in biomass accumulation or allocation with the exception of a significant increase in the amount of leaf mass per unit area. Physiologically, those plants exposed to elevated night-time [CO₂] had 21% lower respiration rates, 14% lower photosynthetic rates and a significant increase in the ratio of carbon gain to carbon loss, again when compared with the 250/250 plants. Biochemical differences also were found. Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/ oxygenase concentrations decreased in the 250/ 1000 treatment compared with the 250/250 plants, and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase activity decreased in the 1000/250 compared with the 1000/1000 plants. Glucose, fructose and to a lesser extent sucrose concentrations also were reduced in the 1000/250 treatment compared with the 1000/1000 plants. These results indicate that experimental protocols that do not maintain elevated CO₂ levels 24 h d^–1 can have significant effects on plant biomass, carbon allocation and physiology, at least for fast-growing annual crop plants. Furthermore, the results suggest some plant processes other than photosynthesis are sensitive to [CO₂] and under ecologically relevant conditions, such as high night-time [CO₂], whole plant carbon balance can be affected.