Development of white spruce somatic embryos: II. Continual shoot meristem development during germination

Summary This study compares the development of shoot apical meristems of white spruce somatic and zygotic embryos during germination. In mature somatic embryos, the functional part of the shoot apical meristem was bi-layered. After partial drying, a normal shoot meristem was formed from these two cell layers during germination. Other cells within the meristem were vacuolated and separated by intercellular air spaces. In the absence of the partial drying treatment, somatic embryos enlarged in size primarily due to vacuolation of cells and the formation of large intercellular air spaces. A majority of these somatic embryos failed to form a functional shoot apical meristem. Compared with somatic embryos, the shoot apical meristem of a mature zygotic embryo was well organized with a densely cytoplasmic apical layer. The cells within the meristem were tightly packed. Judging from the cell profiles during germination, all cells within the meristem of the zygotic embryo took part in the formation of the vegetative shoot apical meristem.     

Comparative anatomy and morphology of Vitis vinifera (Vitaceae) somatic embryos from solid- and liquid-culture-derived proembryogenic masses

Ontogeny of somatic embryos of grapevine (Vitis vinifera) produced from solid- and liquid-culture-derived proembryogenic masses (PEM) was compared using light and scanning electron microscopy. Somatic embryos produced from solid-medium-derived PEM (SPEM) had large cotyledons, little or no visible suspensor structure, and a relatively undeveloped concave shoot apical meristem, whereas those from liquid-medium-derived PEM (LPEM) had smaller cotyledons, a distinct suspensor, and a flat-to-convex shoot apical meristem. The convex shoot apical meristem in LPEM-derived somatic embryos formed as early as the heart stage of development; it was 4-6 cell layers deep and rich in protein. Suspensors persisted in fully developed and mature LPEM-derived somatic embryos. The SPEM-derived somatic embryos exhibited dormancy, as do mature zygotic embryos, which also have a rudimentary suspensor, whereas LPEM-derived embryos were not dormant. We hypothesize that the presence of a persistent suspensor in LPEM-derived somatic embryos modulates development, ultimately resulting in rapid germination and a high plant-regeneration rate.     

Direct somatic embryogenesis from shoot apical meristems of pea, and thidiazuron-induced high conversion rate of somatic embryos

Direct somatic embryogenesis from shoot apical meristems of pea is described. Somatic embryos were induced directly (without callus intervention) from meristematic tissues grown on a medium supplemented with 2.5 μM picloram. Within 4 to 5 weeks, fully morphologically developed somatic embryos were obtained. Somatic embryos originated from apical as well as from basal parts of meristem explants. The initiation and development of somatic embryos was asynchronous, basal somatic embryos developed more quickly than apical ones. Abundant secondary embryogenesis was observed after isolation of primary somatic embryos and culturing them on media for germination. Morphologically normal somatic embryos germinated on medium without growth regulators; the conversion rate was increased by application of 10 μM thidiazuron (TDZ). TDZ was also able to induce shoot bud regeneration on embryos without differentiated a shoot apex, allowing to germinate up to 78 % of all harvested somatic embryos with various morphology. The protocol was successfully tested in 47 out of 48 P. sativum and P. arvense cultivars as well as in two wild peas (P. elatius, P. jomardi). This revised version was published online in July 2006 with corrections to the Cover Date.     

Somatic embryogenesis from immature embryos of redbud (Cercis canadensis)

Somatic embryos developed directly from 96 and 110 day post-anthesis Cercis canadensis L. (redbud) zygotic embryos from one of two trees sampled that were explanted onto modified Schenk and Hildebrandt medium amended with either 1, 2, 3 or 5 mg/1 2,4-D in combination with either 7.6 or 12. 6 mM ammonium ion. Although somatic embryogenesis was expressed on most media, the number of explants that produced somatic embryos and the mean number of embryos formed per explant were greatest on media that contained either 2 or 3 mg/1 2,4-D; 12.6 mM ammonium ion inhibited embryogenesis from 96 day post-anthesis explants. Zygotic embryos explanted 117 days after anthesis produced only callus and roots. Somatic embryos that were bottle-shaped or had distinct cotyledons organized roots on germination media, but only one embryo formed a shoot. No additional development occurred. Histological examination of somatic embryos showed that shoot apical meristems were poorly developed.Abbreviations 2,4-D 2, 4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - NAA 1-naphthaleneacetic acid - BAP 6-benzylaminopurine - FPA Formalin-propionic acid-ethanol (50%)     

THE SHOOT APICAL ONTOGENY OF THE PICEA ABIES SEEDLING. I. ANATOMY,APICAL DOME DIAMETER,AND PLASTOCHRON DURATION

Developing embryos in immature Picea abies seeds already have well-delineated shoot apical meristems with clearly evident cytohistological zonation. During early seedling development the zonation characteristic of gymnospermous apical meristems is attained. Seedling development is also accompanied by an approximately threefold increase in apical dome diameter. The latter approaches a steady state about 140 days after germination. Seedlings display a spiral phyllotaxis consisting of a contact parastichy system, usually of the primary Fibonacci series. As the seedlings age and apical domes enlarge, higher Fibonacci number-pairs characterize their phyllotaxis. Mathematical analysis of the relation between cumulative leaf number and age revealed that the length of the plastochronic time interval declines from about 18.5 hr to 5.7 hr as seedling age increases from 20 to 140 days.     

Study of aberrant morphologies and lack of conversion of somatic embryos of chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.)

Summary Somatic embryos which originated from mature embryo axes of the chickpea (Cicer arietinum L.) showed varied morphologies. Embryos were classified based on shape of the embryo and number of cotyledons. “Normal” (zygotic-like) embryos were bipolar structures with two cotyledons and a well-developed shoot and root apical meristem, whereas “aberrant” embryos were horn-shaped, had single and multiple cotyledons, and were fasciated. Histological examination revealed the absence of a shoot apical meristem in horn-shaped embryos. Fasciated embryos showed diaxial fusion of two embryos. Secondary embryogenesis was also observed, in which the embryos emerged from the hypocotyl and cotyledonary region of the primary somatic embryo. This report documents the absence of an apical meristem as a vital factor in the lack of conversion of aberrant somatic embryos.     

Cotton somatic embryo morphology affects its conversion to plant

Somatic embryos differentiated from hypocotyl explant in cotton (Gossypium hirsutum L.) exhibited very divergent morphologies. Six different types of somatic embryos based on cotyledon development were observed. The growth hormones (2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid and kinetin) used in induction and maintenance media did not affect embryo rooting and germination. The 95 % conversion of normal embryos (with two cotyledons) was achieved, while an overall conversion was only 38 %. Horn shaped embryos failed to exhibit shoot growth. Poorly developed apical meristems were responsible for lower conversion percentages in some of embryo classes. However, regenerated plants phenotypically resembled to seed grown control plants regardless of somatic embryo morphology.     

Effect of exogenous ABA on somatic embryo maturation and germination in Persian walnut (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Juglans regia</Emphasis> L.)

Low efficiency of embryo maturation, germination and conversion to plantlets is a major problem in many species including Persian walnut. We studied the effects of abscisic acid (ABA) and sucrose, on the maturation and germination of Persian walnut (Juglans regia) somatic embryos. Individual globular somatic embryos were grown on a maturation medium supplemented with different combinations of ABA and sucrose for ca. 1 month, until shoot meristems and radicles had developed. White and opaque embryos in late cotyledonary stage were subjected to desiccation after the culture period on maturation media. The number of germinated somatic embryos was influenced by the concentrations of ABA in the maturation medium. The best treatment for germination, in which both shoot and root were developed contained 2 mg l⁻¹ ABA and resulted in 41% conversion of embryos into plantlets. Regeneration was reduced at higher levels of ABA. While ABA always reduced the rate of secondary embryogenesis, treatments containing 4.0% sucrose significantly increased the number of secondary embryos. On the other hand, sucrose had little influence on maturation. Normal and abnormal embryos were verified anatomically.     

In vitro regeneration of commercial cultivars of subterranean clover

Regeneration of subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum L.) was achieved by both shoot organogenesis and somatic embryogenesis. Shoots derived via organogenesis were initiated from the hypocotyls of mature imbibed seed. The hypocotyl, including the emerging radicle, was sliced longitudinally into two halves and cultured on shoot induction medium. After 30 days, adventitious shoots were formed from the hypocotyl region while the radicle showed no development. Shoots were then subcultured onto shoot multiplication medium and finally onto a root initiation medium. Histological studies revealed that shoots arose de novo and did not originate from pre-existing meristems. In the second regeneration protocol, shoot apical meristems from young seedlings were induced to form callus. Following four to six weeks culture in the dark, somatic embryos appeared spontaneously on the calli. A majority of embryos had a well-defined root pole, two cotyledonary lobes, and were capable of germination, albeit at a low frequency. Regenerated plants obtained from both protocols appeared phenotypically normal.     

Ascorbic acid improves conversion of white spruce somatic embryos

Summary The effects of exogenous applications of ascorbic acid on white spruce somatic embryogenesis were examined. Increasing concentrations of ascorbate (1 μM to 100 μM) in the germination medium enhanced somatic embryo conversion in a linear fashion. At the optimal ascorbate level (100 μM) the number of embryos able to undergo normal conversion, i.e., emergence of both root and shoot, increased from 34% (control) to 58%. The effect of ascorbate had a more pronounced effect on shoot growth than on root emergence; and at 100 μM ascorbate, the percentage of embryos able to produce new leaf primordia increased from 47% (control) to 79%. Root emergence increased slightly from 64% in the control embryos to 74% in the presence of ascorbic acid. The ascorbate-treated embryos were characterized by an enlarged apical region, presumably due to a larger number of leaf primordia produced, and by dark green leaves. When allowed to grow further, these embryos were able to develop into normal plantlets.     

Expression and maintenance of embryogenic potential is enhanced through constitutive expression of AGAMOUS-Like 15

The MADS domain protein AGL15 (AGAMOUS-Like 15) has been found to preferentially accumulate in angiosperm tissues derived from double fertilization (i.e. the embryo, suspensor, and endosperm) and in apomictic, somatic, and microspore embryos. Localization to the nuclei supports a role in gene regulation during this phase of the life cycle. To test whether AGL15 is involved in the promotion and maintenance of embryo identity, the embryogenic potential of transgenic plants that constitutively express AGL15 was assessed. Expression of AGL15 was found to enhance production of secondary embryos from cultured zygotic embryos, and constitutive expression led to long-term maintenance of development in this mode. Ectopic accumulation of AGL15 also promoted somatic embryo formation after germination from the shoot apical meristem of seedlings in culture. These results indicate that AGL15 is involved in support of development in an embryonic mode.     

Alterations of the glutathione redox state improve apical meristem structure and somatic embryo quality in white spruce (Picea glauca)

In white spruce, an improvement of somatic embryo number and quality can be achieved through experimental manipulations of the endogenous levels of reduced (GSH) and oxidized (GSSG) glutathione. An optimal protocol for embryo production included an initial application of GSH in the maturation medium, followed by replacement with GSSG during the remaining maturation period. Under these conditions, the overall embryo population more than doubled, and the percentage of fully developed embryos increased from 22% to almost 70%. These embryos showed improved post-embryonic growth and conversion frequency. Structural studies revealed remarkable differences between embryo types, especially in storage product deposition pattern and organization of the shoot apical meristem (SAM). Compared with their control counterparts, glutathione-treated embryos accumulated a larger amount of starch during the early stages of development, and more protein and lipid bodies during the second half of development. Differences were also noted in the organization of SAMs. Shoot meristems of control embryos were poorly organized and were characterized by the presence of intercellular spaces, which caused separation of the subapical cells. Glutathione-treated embryos had well-organized meristems composed of tightly packed cells which lack large vacuoles. The improved organization of the shoot apical meristems in treated embryos was ascribed to a lower production of ethylene. Differences in meristem structure between control and treated embryos were also related to the localization pattern of HBK1, a shoot apical meristem 'molecular marker' gene with preferential expression to the meristematic cells of the shoot pole. Expression of this gene, which was localized to the apical cells in control embryos, was extended to the subapical cells of treated embryos. Overall, it appears that meristem integrity and embryo quality are under the direct control of the glutathione redox state.     

Storability and germination of sodium alginate encapsulated somatic embryos derived from the vegetative shoot apices of mature <Emphasis Type="Italic">Pinus patula</Emphasis> trees

Storability and germination of sodium alginate encapsulated somatic embryos derived from vegetative shoot apices of mature Pinus patula trees were tested on half strength DCR basal medium without growth regulators. The germination percentage of encapsulated somatic embryos was affected significantly by the concentration of sodium alginate and the duration of exposure to calcium chloride. Somatic embryos encapsulated with 2.5 sodium alginate dissolved in DCR basal salts gave significantly higher germination (89) than other treatments. Short (5 min) incubation of the alginate encapsulated embryos in calcium chloride solution proved to be the best encapsulation procedure and the embryos subsequently gave the highest germination (89). Synthetic seeds could be stored at 2 °C for 120 days without a reduction in germination as opposed to non-encapsulated somatic embryos which showed only 9 germination after 20 days at 2 °C. Germinated synthetic seeds produced normal plantlets. This study reports for the first time the storability of encapsulated somatic embryos generated from vegetative shoot apices of mature Pinus patula trees. This has potential for application in forestry.     

Structure and development of somatic embryos formed inArabidopsis thaliana pt mutant callus cultures derived from seedlings

Summary Seeds of theArabidopsis thaliana mutant primordia timing (pt) were germinated in 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acidcontaining liquid medium. The seedlings formed somatic embryos and nonembryogenic and embryogenic callus in vitro in a time period of approximately two to three weeks. Embryogenesis and callus formation were monitored with respect to origin, structure, and development. Ten days after germination globular structures appeared in close vicinity of and on the shoot apical meristem (SAM). Somatic embryos formed either directly on the SAM region of the seedling or indirectly on embryogenic callus that developed at the SAM zone. Globular structures developed along the vascular tissue of the cotyledons as well, but only incidentally they formed embryos. Upon deterioration, the cotyledons formed callus. Regular subculture of the embryogenic callus gave rise to high numbers of somatic embryos. Such primary somatic embryos, grown on callus, originated from meristematic cell clusters located under the surface of the callus. Embryos at the globular and heart-shape stage were mostly hidden within the callus. Embryos at torpedo stage appeared at the surface of the callus because their axis elongated. Secondary somatic embryos frequently formed directly on primary ones. They preferentially emerged from the SAM region of the primary somatic embryos, from the edge of the cotyledons, and from the hypocotyl. We conclude that the strong regeneration capacity of thept mutant is based on both recurrent and indirect embryogenesis.Abbreviations 2,4-D 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid - DIC days in culture - SAM shoot apical meristem     

Morphology and anatomy of mature embryos and seedlings in parasitic angiospermCuscuta japonica

Morphological and anatomical features of mature embryos and seedlings were observed at different growth stages in the parasitic angiospermCuscuta japonica Choisy. The spirally coiled embryos from scarified seeds had no cotyledons but possessed blunt radicles. Seeds germinated at 30°C in the dark. Although most embryo cells incubated for 16 h did not have starch grains, the shoot cells of three-day-old seedlings possessed numerous starch grains. After these seedlings were transferred to a lightened growth chamber, all the shoot apical regions of seedlings grown for 6,8, and 10 days became greenish and hooked. Most of the shoot cells, including the green apical parts, contained abundant starch grains. The hooks opened only when one seedling made contact with another seedling. This suggested that the green and hooked shoot apical regions played an important role in searching for and twining about their host plants. In some two-day-old seedlings, the massive roots were circular or semi-circular. This enabled the shoot axes to stand erect on some substratum. It would assist the shoots in making contact with the host plant. In eight-day-old seedlings, the green apical regions also were hooked and the roots were considerably degraded.     

Role of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D) in somatic embryogenesis on cultured zygotic embryos of Arabidopsis: cell expansion, cell cycling, and morphogenesis during continuous exposure of embryos to 2,4-D

The relationship between cell expansion and cell cycling during somatic embryogenesis was studied in cultured bent-cotyledon-stage zygotic embryos of a transgenic stock of Arabidopsis thaliana harboring a cyclin 1 At:β-glucuronidase (GUS) reporter gene construct. In embryos cultured in a medium containing 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D), following a brief period of growth by cell expansion, divisions were initiated in the procambial cells facing the adaxial side at the base of the cotyledons. Cell division activity later spread to almost the entire length of the cotyledons to form a callus on which globular and heart-shaped embryos appeared in about 10 d after culture. Anatomical and morphogenetic changes observed in cultured embryos were correlated with patterns of cell cycling by histochemical detection of GUS-expressing cells. Although early-stage somatic embryos did not develop further during their continued growth in the auxin-containing medium, maturation of embryos ensued upon their transfer to an auxin-free medium. In a small number of cultured zygotic embryos the shoot apical meristem was found to differentiate a leaf, a green tubular structure, or a somatic embryo. Contrary to the results from previous investigations, which have assigned a major role for the shoot apical meristem and cells in the axils of cotyledons in the development of somatic embryos on cultured zygotic embryos of A. thaliana, the present work shows that somatic embryos originate almost exclusively on the callus formed on the cotyledons. Other observations such as the induction of somatic embryos on cultured cotyledons and the inability of the embryo axis (consisting of the root, hypocotyl, and shoot apical meristem without the cotyledons) to form somatic embryos, reaffirm the important role of the cotyledons in somatic embryogenesis in this plant.     

Transformation of shoots into roots in Arabidopsis embryos mutant at the TOPLESS locus

We describe a novel phenotype in Arabidopsis embryos homozygous for the temperature-sensitive topless-1 mutation. This mutation causes the transformation of the shoot pole into a root. Developing topless embryos fail to express markers for the shoot apical meristem (SHOOT MERISTEMLESS and UNUSUAL FLORAL ORGANS) and the hypocotyl (KNAT1). By contrast, the pattern of expression of root markers is either duplicated (LENNY, J1092) or expanded (SCARECROW). Shifts of developing topless embryos between permissive and restrictive temperatures show that apical fates (cotyledons plus shoot apical meristem) can be transformed to basal fates (root) as late as transition stage. As the apical pole of transition stage embryos shows both morphological and molecular characteristics of shoot development, this demonstrates that the topless 1 mutation is capable of causing structures specified as shoot to be respecified as root. Finally, our experiments fail to show a clear link between auxin signal transduction and topless-1 mutant activity: the development of the apical root in topless mutant individuals is not dependent on the activity of the predicted auxin response factor MONOPTEROS nor is the expression of DR5, a proposed 'auxin maximum reporter', expanded in the apical domain of topless embryos.     

Roles of arabinogalactan proteins in cotyledon formation and cell wall deposition during embryo development of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Arabidopsis</Emphasis>

Arabinogalactan proteins (AGPs) are a class of highly glycosylated, widely distributed proteins in higher plants. In the previous study, we found that the green fluorescence from JIM13-labeled AGPs was mainly distributed in embryo proper and the basal part of suspensor but gradually disappeared after the torpedo-stage embryos in Arabidopsis. And (β-d-Glc)₃ Yariv phenylglycoside (βGlcY), a synthetic reagent that specifically binds to AGPs, could inhibit embryo development. In this study, as a continuous work, we investigated the AGP functions in embryo germination, cotyledon formation, and cell wall deposition in Arabidopsis embryos by using immunofluorescent, immunoenzyme, transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) techniques. The results showed that 50 μM βGlcY caused inhibition of embryo germination, formation of abnormal cotyledon embryos, and disorder of cotyledon vasculature. Compared with the normal embryos in vitro and in vivo, the AGPs and pectin signals were quite weaker in the whole abnormal embryos, whereas the cellulose signal was stronger in the shoot apical meristem (SAM) of abnormal embryo by calcofluor white staining. The FTIR assay demonstrated that the cell wall of abnormal embryos was relatively poorer in pectins and richer in cellulose than those of normal embryos. By TEM observation, the SAM cells of the abnormal embryos had less cytoplasm, more plastid and starch grains, and larger vacuole than that of normal embryos. These results indicated that AGPs may play roles in embryo germination, cotyledon formation, cell wall cellulose and pectin deposition, and cell division potentiality during embryo development of Arabidopsis.     

Failure to establish a functional shoot meristem may be a cause of conversion failure in somatic embryos of Daucus carota (Apiaceae)

A carrot cell culture line was shown to be highly embryogenic, but plantlet recovery (conversion) was low (about 14%). The majority of somatic embryos that did not convert showed pronounced vacuolation in the apical notch, leading to their inability to form primary leaves and thereby convert. Comparisons of developing meristems in the shoot apical notch of converting somatic and zygotic embryos revealed similarities in cytoplasmic density and meristem organization between the two populations. Abscisic acid (ABA) was shown to significantly increase conversion in somatic embryos of globular, torpedo, and preplantlet stages (62%, 62.5% and 40%, respectively). Somatic embryos that were treated with 50 μM ABA showed retention of the highly cytoplasmic cells in the apical notch. Histological analysis showed a resemblance between shoot apices of converting somatic embryos and ABA-treated somatic embryos. ABA may be an induction agent for meristematic organization, or perhaps may cause cells of the apical notch to extend competence for determination as meristematic cells.