Low Selection Pressure Aids the Evolution of Cooperative Ribozyme Mutations in Cells

Understanding the evolution of functional RNA molecules is important for our molecular understanding of biology. Here we tested experimentally how two evolutionary parameters, selection pressure and recombination, influenced the evolution of an evolving RNA population. This was done using four parallel evolution experiments that employed low or gradually increasing selection pressure, and recombination events either at the end or dispersed throughout the evolution. As model system, a trans-splicing group I intron ribozyme was evolved in Escherichia coli cells over 12 rounds of selection and amplification, including mutagenesis and recombination. The low selection pressure resulted in higher efficiency of the evolved ribozyme populations, whereas differences in recombination did not have a strong effect. Five mutations were responsible for the highest efficiency. The first mutation swept quickly through all four evolving populations, whereas the remaining four mutations accumulated later and more efficiently under low selection pressure. To determine why low selection pressure aided this evolution, all evolutionary intermediates between the wild type and the 5-mutation variant were constructed, and their activities at three different selection pressures were determined. The resulting fitness profiles showed a high cooperativity among the four late mutations, which can explain why high selection pressure led to inefficient evolution. These results show experimentally how low selection pressure can benefit the evolution of cooperative mutations in functional RNAs.     

A Case Study of the Dynamics of In Vitro DNA Evolution Under Constant Selection Pressure

Although thousands of in vitro selection and evolution experiments have been performed to seek different types of targets, most of them have only inspected the terminal evolutionary pool for patterns. In addition, to rapidly obtain the most favorable target, many experiments have been carried out under increasing selection pressure. However, increasing selection pressure seldom occurs in natural evolution. We studied the dynamic features of DNA in vitro evolution in the presence of the Mnt repressor under sequential constant selection pressure. When evolving under a constant pressure from an initial random pool of DNA, our system showed a clear, sharp, and reproducible crossover from a random population to an advantageous population (higher binding affinities of DNA sequences to the Mnt repressor). This crossover occurs after a long latent period during which there are no obvious changes in the population phenotype. We demonstrated that the existence of the crossover is caused by a significant sequence-nonspecific binding in the repressor–DNA system. After the crossover, the population settled in a stationary distribution of genotypes, which responded immediately to a subsequent sudden increase in selection pressure. We also experimentally tested the linear correlation between the evolution speed and sequence diversity (Fisher’s theorem) in our system. X. Yang and X. Liu contributed equally to this work.     

Stem-loop potential in MHC genes: a new way of evaluating positive Darwinian selection?

The domains of polymorphic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins which interact with peptides and T-cell receptors are considered to have been under positive evolutionary selection pressure. Evidence for this is a high ratio of non-synonymous to synonymous mutations in the corresponding genomic domains. By this criterion snake venom phospholipaseA ₂ genes have also been under positive selection pressure. Recent studies of the latter genes indicate that positive selection has overridden an evolutionary pressure on base order which normally promotes the potential to extrude single-strand stem-loops from supercoiled duplex DNA (fold pressure). This has resulted in base order-dependent stem-loop potential being shifted to introns, which are highly conserved between species. It is now shown that, like snake venom phospholipaseA ₂ genes, the domains of polymorphic MHC genes which appear to have responded to positive selection pressure have decreased base order-dependent stem-loop potential. The evolutionary pressure to generate stem-loop potential (believed to be important for recombination) has been overridden less in exons under positive Darwinian selection. Thus, base order-dependent stem-loop potential shows promise as an independent indicator of positive selection.     

High hunting pressure selects for earlier birth date: wild boar as a case study

Exploitation by humans affects the size and structure of populations. This has evolutionary and demographic consequences that have typically being studied independent of one another. We here applied a framework recently developed applying quantitative tools from population ecology and selection gradient analysis to quantify the selection on a quantitative trait-birth date-through its association with multiple fitness components. From the long-term monitoring (22 years) of a wild boar (Sus scrofa scrofa) population subject to markedly increasing hunting pressure, we found that birth dates have advanced by up to 12 days throughout the study period. During the period of low hunting pressure, there was no detectable selection. However, during the period of high hunting pressure, the selection gradient linking breeding probability in the first year of life to birth date was negative, supporting current life-history theory predicting selection for early births to reproduce within the first year of life with increasing adult mortality.     

Equal G and C contents in histone genes indicate selection pressures on mRNA secondary structure

Summary Protein-specific versus taxon-specific patterns of nucleotide frequencies were studied in histone genes. The third positions of codons have a (well-known) taxon-specific G+C level and a histone type-specific G/C ratio. This ratio counterbalances the G/C ratio in the first and second positions so that the overall G and C levels in the coding region become approximately equal. The compensation of the G/C ratio indicates a selection pressure at the mRNA level rather than a selection pressure or mutation bias at the DNA level or a selection pressure on codon usage. The structure of histone mRNAs is compatible with the hypothesis that the G/C compensation is due to selection pressures on mRNA secondary structure. Nevertheless, no specific motifs seem to have been selected, and the free energy of the secondary structures is only slightly lower than that expected on the basis of nucleotide frequencies.Offprint requests to: M. A. Huynen     

Reduced stability of mRNA secondary structure near the translation-initiation site in dsDNA viruses

Background  

Recent studies have demonstrated a selection pressure for reduced mRNA secondary-structure stability near the start codon of coding sequences. This selection pressure can be observed in bacteria, archaea, and eukaryotes, and is likely caused by the requirement of efficient translation initiation in cellular organism.     

Patterns of evolutionary selection pressure in the immune signaling protein TRAF3IP2 in mammals

TRAF3 interacting protein 2 (TRAF3IP2) is important for immune responses to pathogens, inflammatory signals and autoimmunity in mammals. In the present study, we collected 19 mammalian TRAF3IP2 sequences and investigated the various types of selection pressure acting on them. Maximum likelihood estimations of nonsynonymous (dN) to synonymous (dS) substitution (dN/dS) ratios for the aligned coding sequences indicated that, as a whole, TRAF3IP2 has been subject to purifying selection. However, the N-terminus of the protein has been subject to higher selection pressure than the C-terminal domain. While eight amino acid residues within the N-terminus appear to have evolved under positive selection, no evidence for such selection was found in the C-terminus. The positively selected residues, which fall outside the currently known functional sites within TRAF3IP2, may have novel functions. The different selection pressures acting on the N- and C-terminal regions are consistent with their protein structures: the C-terminal structure is an ordered structure, whereas the N-terminus is disordered. Taken together with the results of previous studies, it is plausible that positive selection on the N-terminus of TRAF3IP2 may have occurred by competitive coevolution between mammalian hosts and viruses.     

Bioengineering of crop plants and resistant biotype evolution in insects: Counteracting coevolution

The use, as opposed to the procurement, of transgenic crop plants is discussed in this paper. Transgenic crop plants must not be used until appropriate strategies for their use have been designed and not before crop plants with a variety of insect defenses have been developed. The use of a crop plant with a single defense will pose as strong a selection pressure as the use of a single synthetic insecticide, since insect herbivores are able to evolve effective counter-defenses. The defenses of insects in natural plant-insect associations and with regard to synthetic insecticides are described to demonstrate that there is nothing unique about insecticide resistance. It is the inevitable alternative to local extinction in response to a persistent and predictable selection pressure. Plants counteract insect defensive evolution by keeping the selection pressure as variable as possible. This leads to the conclusion that the best use of biotechnology in crop protection is to reintroduce chemical diversity into crop plants.     

Immune selection in vitro reveals human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Nef sequence motifs important for its immune evasion function in vivo

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Nef downregulates major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I), impairing the clearance of infected cells by CD8(+) cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs). While sequence motifs mediating this function have been determined by in vitro mutagenesis studies of laboratory-adapted HIV-1 molecular clones, it is unclear whether the highly variable Nef sequences of primary isolates in vivo rely on the same sequence motifs. To address this issue, nef quasispecies from nine chronically HIV-1-infected persons were examined for sequence evolution and altered MHC-I downregulatory function under Gag-specific CTL immune pressure in vitro. This selection resulted in decreased nef diversity and strong purifying selection. Site-by-site analysis identified 13 codons undergoing purifying selection and 1 undergoing positive selection. Of the former, only 6 have been reported to have roles in Nef function, including 4 associated with MHC-I downregulation. Functional testing of naturally occurring in vivo polymorphisms at the 7 sites with no previously known functional role revealed 3 mutations (A84D, Y135F, and G140R) that ablated MHC-I downregulation and 3 (N52A, S169I, and V180E) that partially impaired MHC-I downregulation. Globally, the CTL pressure in vitro selected functional Nef from the in vivo quasispecies mixtures that predominately lacked MHC-I downregulatory function at the baseline. Overall, these data demonstrate that CTL pressure exerts a strong purifying selective pressure for MHC-I downregulation and identifies novel functional motifs present in Nef sequences in vivo.     

Rapid parasite adaptation drives selection for high recombination rates

The Red Queen hypothesis proposes that sex is maintained through selection pressure imposed by coevolving parasites: susceptible hosts are able to escape parasite pressure by recombining their genome to create resistant offspring. However, previous theoretical studies have shown that the Red Queen typically selects against sex unless selection is strong, arguing that high rates of recombination cannot evolve when parasites are of low virulence. Here we show that under the biologically plausible assumption of a severe fitness cost for parasites that fail to infect, the Red Queen can cause selection for high recombination rates, and that the strength of virulence is largely irrelevant to the direction of selection for increased recombination rates. Strong selection on parasites and short generation times make parasites usually better adapted to their hosts than vice versa and can thus favor higher recombination rates in hosts. By demonstrating the importance of host-imposed selection on parasites, our findings resolve previously reported conflicting results.     

SAFETY FACTORS OF TROPICAL VERSUS TEMPERATE LIMPET SHELLS: MULTIPLE SELECTION PRESSURES ON A SINGLE STRUCTURE

A comparison of the safety factors of tropical and temperate limpet shells in the eastern Pacific yielded two results of significance. A safety factor was defined as shell strength/maximum tenacity, where maximum tenacity (force required to detach foot) determines the maximum prying force that a crab or bird predator can exert on the shell. 1) On average, shell strength and foot tenacity for the tropical limpets were twice those for the temperate limpets. In contrast, the average safety factors for the two groups were approximately equal. This comparatively narrow range of safety factors was due to a highly significant association of greater shell strengths with greater foot tenacities. The implication of this result is that selection has acted to closely link the mechanical performances of these two rather independent structures, the shell and the foot. 2) The presence of an additional class of predators which feed on the tropical limpets was reflected in the safety factors of their shells. Whereas the shells of both tropical and temperate limpets are exposed to predator-induced prying forces, the shells of the tropical group are also exposed to lateral crushing forces generated by fish predators. This additional selection pressure was associated with several deviations from a regression of safety factor versus variability in shell strength which had been calculated previously for the temperate limpets. As predicted, the magnitudes of these deviations were correlated with the degree of exposure to this additional selection pressure. Hence, the presence of more than one selection pressure appears to have influenced the precision with which the shells of these species have become adapted to a single selection pressure. The use of safety factor analysis provides a very useful methodology for identifying additional selection pressures or adaptive constraints on biological structures.     

Major histocompatibility complex polymorphism: dynamics and consequences of parasite-mediated local adaptation in fishes

Parasitism is a common form of life and represents a strong selective pressure for host organisms. In response to this evolutionary pressure, vertebrates have developed genetically coded defences such as the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Mechanisms of parasite-mediated selection not only maintain outstanding polymorphism in these genes but have also been proposed to further promote host population divergence and ultimately speciation because it can drive evolution of local adaptation in which MHC genes play a crucial role. This review first highlights the dynamics and complexity of parasite-mediated selection in natural systems, which not only depends on dominating parasite strategies and on the taxonomic diversity of the parasite community but also includes the differences in parasite communities between habitats and niches, creating divergent selection on locally adapted populations. Then the different ways in which MHC genes potentially allow vertebrates to respond to these dynamics and to adapt locally are outlined. Finally, it is proposed that varying selection strength in time and space may lead to variation in the strength of precopulatory reproductive isolation which has evolved to maintain local adaptation.     

Genetic Differentiation in Response to Selection for Water-Soluble Carbohydrate Content in Perennial Ryegrass (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Lolium perenne</Emphasis> L.)

Plant carbohydrates are of increasing interest as renewable feedstocks to replace petrochemicals in the generation of fuels and production of high-value chemicals. Greater understanding of the genetic control of diversity in fructan synthesis and accumulation would facilitate more directed channelling of feedstock to process in a ryegrass biorefinery. Divergent populations produced by phenotypic selection for water-soluble carbohydrate content have been used to investigate relationships between traits, and to identify patterns of genetic differentiation which indicate genomic regions under high and low selection pressure. Selection for high water-soluble carbohydrate content was associated with increased synthesis of large fructan polymers and increased accumulation of above-ground plant biomass, particularly during spring. Three rounds of selection and two rounds of recombination resulted in widespread genetic differentiation across the whole genome, causing reduced allelic richness and increasing homozygosity at some loci. A smaller number of loci were shown to be subject to high selection pressure. Breeding material subjected to many years of selection for water-soluble carbohydrate also showed allelic differences which may reflect the consequences of high selection pressure at some of these same loci. However, some of the loci unaffected in the divergent selection experiment showed similar effects. This might arise from differences in linkage disequilibrium in these two sets of plant materials, but more likely from the different genetic background of the germplasm. This illustrates the complex nature of the water-soluble carbohydrate trait in perennial ryegrass.     

The influence of aberrant values on the statistics related to a selection program

Summary Examples are presented to illustrate some of the effects aberrant values, in particular, measurement errors, may have on estimates of the genetic parameters related to selection studies. It is shown that aberrant values may cause observed response to selection pressure to differ considerably from predicted response. Possible dangers of indiscriminate screening are also discussed.     

Statistical analysis of pathogenicity of somatic mutations in cancer

Recent large-scale sequencing studies have revealed that cancer genomes contain variable numbers of somatic point mutations distributed across many genes. These somatic mutations most likely include passenger mutations that are not cancer causing and pathogenic driver mutations in cancer genes. Establishing a significant presence of driver mutations in such data sets is of biological interest. Whereas current techniques from phylogeny are applicable to large data sets composed of singly mutated samples, recently exemplified with a p53 mutation database, methods for smaller data sets containing individual samples with multiple mutations need to be developed. By constructing distinct models of both the mutation process and selection pressure upon the cancer samples, exact statistical tests to examine this problem are devised. Tests to examine the significance of selection toward missense, nonsense, and splice site mutations are derived, along with tests assessing variation in selection between functional domains. Maximum-likelihood methods facilitate parameter estimation, including levels of selection pressure and minimum numbers of pathogenic mutations. These methods are illustrated with 25 breast cancers screened across the coding sequences of 518 kinase genes, revealing 90 base substitutions in 71 genes. Significant selection pressure upon truncating mutations was established. Furthermore, an estimated minimum of 29.8 mutations were pathogenic.     

Environmental variation and moose Alces alces density as determinants of spatio-temporal heterogeneity in browsing

Understanding temporal variation in habitat selection and browsing intensity by large herbivores is fundamental because of their large impact on the ecosystems. I studied the annual variation in winter browsing pressure on young trees and habitat selection by moose Alces alces over a ten year period. Specifically, the relationships between browsing pressure on Scots pine Pinus sylvestris and two birch species ( Betula ssp.) and three explanatory variables – 1) availability of forage, 2) moose density (estimated by pellet group counts) and 3) snow cover was studied. At a larger spatial scale (forest stand level) the relationship between moose habitat selection between three different habitat types (forest <30 yr, forest>30 yr and mire) and two explanatory variables, 1) snow condition and 2) moose density, were studied. Browsing pressure on Scots pine, the dominating food plant, was related to forage availability, moose density and snow condition. No significant relationships between any of the three explanatory variables and browsing pressure on the two birch species were found. Moose selection for certain habitats varied between years and was affected by number of days with >0.10 m of snow.
Habitat selection was not significantly related to moose density and the relationship between overall moose density and habitat specific moose densities was proportional within the studied density range. These findings have implications for understanding varying browsing patterns – and will affect both the ability to predict herbivores' effect on the forest ecosystem. A snow dependent browsing pattern also indicates that one can expect a long term decrease in browsing pressure on the tree and shrub layer as a consequence of the ongoing large-scale climate change.     

How to Make a Dolphin: Molecular Signature of Positive Selection in Cetacean Genome

Cetaceans are unique in being the only mammals completely adapted to an aquatic environment. This adaptation has required complex changes and sometimes a complete restructuring of physiology, behavior and morphology. Identifying genes that have been subjected to selection pressure during cetacean evolution would greatly enhance our knowledge of the ways in which genetic variation in this mammalian order has been shaped by natural selection. Here, we performed a genome-wide scan for positive selection in the dolphin lineage. We employed models of codon substitution that account for variation of selective pressure over branches on the tree and across sites in a sequence. We analyzed 7,859 nuclear-coding ortholog genes and using a series of likelihood ratio tests (LRTs), we identified 376 genes (4.8%) with molecular signatures of positive selection in the dolphin lineage. We used the cow as the sister group and compared estimates of selection in the cetacean genome to this using the same methods. This allowed us to define which genes have been exclusively under positive selection in the dolphin lineage. The enrichment analysis found that the identified positively selected genes are significantly over-represented for three exclusive functional categories only in the dolphin lineage: segment specification, mesoderm development and system development. Of particular interest for cetacean adaptation to an aquatic life are the following GeneOntology targets under positive selection: genes related to kidney, heart, lung, eye, ear and nervous system development.     

Evidence of functional selection pressure for alternative splicingevents that accelerate evolution of protein subsequences

Recently, it was proposed that alternative splicing may act as a mechanism for opening accelerated paths of evolution, by reducing negative selection pressure, but there has been little evidence so far whether this could produce adaptive benefit. Here we employ metrics of very different types of selection pressures (e.g. against amino acid mutations (Ka/Ks); against mutations at synonymous sites (Ks); and for protein reading-frame preservation) to address this question via genome-wide analyses of human, chimpanzee, mouse, and rat. These data show that alternative splicing relaxes Ka/Ks selection pressure up to seven-fold, but intriguingly that this effect is accompanied by a strong increase in selection pressure against synonymous mutations, which propagates into the adjacent intron, and correlates strongly with the alternative splicing level observed for each exon. These effects are highly local to the alternatively spliced exon. Comparisons of these four genomes consistently show an increase in the density of amino acid mutations (Ka) in alternatively spliced exons, and a decrease in the density of synonymous mutations (Ks). This selection pressure against synonymous mutations in alternatively spliced exons was accompanied in all four genomes by a striking increase in selection pressure for protein reading-frame preservation, and both increased markedly with increasing evolutionary age. Restricting our analysis to a subset of exons with strong evidence for biologically functional alternative splicing produced identical results. Thus alternative splicing apparently can create evolutionary “hotspots” within a protein sequence, and these events have evidently been selected for during mammalian evolution.     

Limited MHC polymorphism in the southern elephant seal: implications for MHC evolution and marine mammal population biology.

Genes of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) are highly polymorphic in most terrestrial mammal populations so far studied. Exceptions to this are typically populations that lack genome-wide diversity. Here I show that two populations of the southern elephant seal (Mirounga leonina) have low DNA restriction fragment length polymorphism at MHC loci when compared with terrestrial mammals. Limited studies on MHC polymorphism in two cetacean species suggest this is a feature of marine mammal populations in general. MHC polymorphism is thought to be maintained by balancing selection, and several types of disease-based and reproductive-based mechanisms have been proposed. For the three marine mammal species examined, the low MHC polymorphism cannot be explained by low genome-wide diversity, or by any reproductive-based selection pressure. It can, however, be explained by diminished exposure to pathogenic selection pressure compared with terrestrial mammals. Reduced exposure to pathogens would also mean that marine mammal populations may be susceptible to occasional pathogen-induced mass mortalities.     

The paucity of plants evolving genetic resistance to herbicides: Possible reasons and implications

Resistances to antibiotics and pesticides except herbicides rapidly developed following their introduction. Despite repeated use of herbicides only a few cases of acquired genetic resistance have been reported. By extrapolation from analogous situations, it is suggested that this is due to a combination of low selection pressure of most herbicides, lower fitness of resistant weed strains in the absence of herbicide, the ability of herbicide thinned strands of susceptible weeds to produce relatively more seeds, as well as to the large soil reservoir of susceptible weed seeds. The few reported cases of resistance are to persistent, high selection pressure herbicides supporting our contentions.