Clonal anergy is induced in vitro by T cell receptor occupancy in the absence of proliferation.

Murine Th1 clones that receive signals through their TCR in the absence of APC-derived co-stimulatory signals do not produce IL-2 and instead become anergic, i.e., they are subsequently unable to produce IL-2 in response to Ag and normal APC. The critical cellular event required to prevent the induction of this anergic state appears to be T cell proliferation. Anergy was induced when T cell clones were stimulated under conditions where both TCR occupancy and costimulatory signals were provided but where proliferation in response to the IL-2 produced was prevented. Once induced, anergy could be reversed if the T cells were allowed to undergo multiple rounds of cell division. These results show that anergy is induced as a consequence of TCR occupancy in the absence of cell division; this can be achieved either by limiting IL-2 production because of deficient provision of co-stimulatory signals or by preventing response to IL-2.     

Allogeneic non-T spleen cells restore the responsiveness of normal T cell clones stimulated with antigen and chemically modified antigen-presenting cells

Stimulation of IL-2-producing T cell clones with chemically modified APC and Ag induces a state of proliferative unresponsiveness, i.e., subsequent stimulation with normal APC and Ag fails to elicit IL-2 production. One possible effect of chemical modification on the APC is the destruction of its ability to provide costimulatory signals. To test this, various potential costimulators were added to T cells at the time of exposure to Ag and chemically modified APC. None of the cytokines tested, including IL-1, had a positive effect; however, addition of allogeneic spleen cells allowed a T cell proliferative response and prevented the induction of subsequent unresponsiveness. Fractionation of the spleen cells showed that low density B cells and macrophages were the best source of costimulatory activity. Allogeneic resting B cells provided some costimulatory activity and resting T cells, none at all. Attempts to mimic costimulatory signals with the phorbol ester PMA were only partially successful. PMA prevented the induction of T cell unresponsiveness but failed to allow T cell proliferation in response to Ag plus chemically modified APC. Our results suggest that IL-2 production by normal T cell clones is dependent not only on T cell receptor occupancy, but also on short range costimulatory signals that are provided to different degrees by various non-T accessory cells.     

Effect of gamma radiation on resting B lymphocytes. II. Functional characterization of the antigen-presentation defect

The effect of radiation on three discrete Ag-presentation functions in resting B cells was examined: 1) Ag uptake and processing, 2) expression of processed Ag in the context of functional class II molecules, and 3) provision of necessary co-stimulatory, or "second," signals. Analysis of radiation's effect on B cell presentation of intact vs fragmented Ag or its effect on presentation by Ag-pulsed B cells indicated that damage to Ag uptake and processing could not account for the bulk of the radiation-induced Ag-presentation defect. Experiments with phosphatidylinositol hydrolysis as an indirect measure of TCR occupancy suggested that irradiation caused a fairly rapid (within 1 to 2 h) decrease in the ability of the B cell APC to display a stimulatory combination of Ag and class II molecule. Ag dose-response analyses demonstrated that when presenting a fragment of the Ag pigeon cytochrome c to a T cell clone, 3000 rad-treated B cell APC were able to stimulate approximately 50% as much phosphatidylinositol turnover as unirradiated B cells. It was also found that, in contrast to their inability to initiate T cell proliferation, and similarly to chemically cross-linked splenocytes, heavily irradiated resting B cells plus Ag induced a state of Ag hyporesponsiveness in T cell clones. This effect on T cells had the same Ag- and MHC-specificity as did receptor occupancy required for proliferation, indicating that heavily irradiated resting B cells bear functional class II molecules. Co-culture of T cells with allogeneic B cells and syngeneic heavily irradiated B cells or chemically cross-linked splenic APC plus Ag resulted in T cell proliferation and interfered with the induction of the hyporesponsive state. This co-stimulatory function was radiosensitive in resting allogeneic B cells. Together, these data support the hypothesis that the major functional consequences of radiation to resting B cell APC are a reduction in the effective display of Ag plus class II molecules and, probably what is more important, a loss in the ability to provide APC-derived co-stimulatory signals.     

CD28 delivers a costimulatory signal involved in antigen-specific IL-2 production by human T cells.

CD4+ T cells require two signals to produce maximal amounts of IL-2, i.e., TCR occupancy and an unidentified APC-derived costimulus. Here we show that this costimulatory signal can be delivered by the T cell molecule CD28. An agonistic anti-CD28 mAb, but not IL-1 and/or IL-6, stimulated T cell proliferation by tetanus toxoid-specific T cells cultured with Ag-pulsed, costimulation-deficient APC. Furthermore, the ability of B cell tumor lines to provide costimulatory signals to purified T cells correlated well with expression of the CD28 ligand B7/BB-1. Finally, like anti-CD28 mAb, autologous human APC appeared to stimulate a cyclosporine A-resistant pathway of T cell activation. Together, these results suggest that the two signals required for IL-2 production by CD4+ T cells can be transduced by the TCR and CD28.     

The processing and presentation of the self-antigen hemoglobin. Self-reactivity can be limited by antigen availability and costimulator expression.

APC do not distinguish between self- and foreign proteins. Previous studies from our laboratory demonstrated that most endogenous host APC constitutively processed and presented the self-Ag, hemoglobin (Hb), as detected by the Hb-specific T cell hybridoma, YO1.6. We have now examined APC in organs known to be involved in RBC degradation (liver Kupffer cells and splenic small resting B cells) for the presence of Hb/Ia complexes and for the expression of the costimulation necessary to trigger proliferation of T cell clones. We detected Hb/Ia complexes not only on splenic small resting B cells, but also on liver Kupffer cells. Interestingly, complexes were not present on lymph node small resting B cells. Splenic small resting B cells expressed costimulatory activity and efficiently stimulated the Th2 clones only. The opposite pattern was observed with liver Kupffer cells, which expressed costimulatory activity for Th1 clones only. However, if costimulatory activity was provided for the Th2 clones (IL-1 beta) and Th1 clones (allogenic spleen cells), the clones did proliferate in response to Kupffer cells and small resting B cells, respectively. In this report we have demonstrated that 1) endogenously formed self Hb/Ia complexes are expressed on splenic small resting B cells and liver Kupffer cells but not on lymph node small resting B cells and 2) these APC are also able to limit the expression of costimulatory activity for Th2 and Th1 T cell clones. Thus, endogenous APC not only constitutively process and present the self-Ag Hb, but also limit expression of the costimulatory activity necessary to trigger T cell proliferation against a self-Ag. The constitutive processing and presentation of self-Ag, as well as the regulation of costimulatory activity on APC, is likely an important feature of the maintenance of self-tolerance.     

Molecular requirements for T cell activation by the staphylococcal toxic shock syndrome toxin-1

The activation of Ag-specific, Ia molecule-restricted, TCR V beta 3+ T cell clones by staphylococcal toxic shock syndrome toxin-1 (TSST-1), was investigated. The results show that although Ag- and TSST-1-induced activation of T cell clones both require TCR expression and similar biologic activation signals, the Ia molecule requirement for TSST-1 recognition was much less stringent than that observed for antigenic peptide recognition. In addition, T cell clones recognized TSST-1 without processing by APC. These results suggest that the ability of TSST-1 to polyclonally activate T cells is dependent on TCR recognition of the intact toxin molecule bound to a nonpolymorphic region(s) of the Ia molecule resulting in the same activation events induced by Ag recognition.     

Heterologous cross-linking of Lyt-2 (CD8) to the alpha beta-T cell receptor is more effective in T cell activation than homologous alpha beta-T cell receptor cross-linking

Ag recognition of Lyt-2 (CD8)-positive T lymphocytes requires the presentation by APC of a suitably processed Ag in association with MHC class I molecules. In previous studies we have obtained evidence that, for optimal activation, both the alpha beta-TCR and Lyt-2 have to participate in this recognition process. In the current study we investigate the functional consequences of limited cross-linking of these cell surface molecules by using soluble, dimeric hetero- and homoconjugates of mAb to Lyt-2 and to the TCR beta-chain (F23.1). Heterologous cross-linking of Lyt-2 to the TCR induced a vigorous, selective Lyt-2+ T cell proliferative response. Functionally active cytotoxic cells were generated, and a high frequency of responding cells was observed in limiting dilution analyses. In contrast, homologous TCR cross-linking initiated a less pronounced proliferation with a relatively low frequency of response, whereas Lyt-2 cross-linking resulted in no cellular proliferation. Significant T cell activation occurred with exposure to anti-Lyt-2: F23.1 mAb dimers at concentrations an order of magnitude lower than those required for stimulation by F23.1:F23.1 mAb dimers. The induction of proliferation by mAb dimers occurred in the absence of Fc components and in rigorously APC depleted, purified T cell preparations. Effective stimulation of resting T cells could be induced also by heterodimers of monovalent Fab fragments. Heterologous cross-linking of Lyt-2 to the TCR was superior to homologous TCR cross-linking primarily with respect to proliferation in IL-2 containing media and to IL-2R expression, whereas proliferation in response to other lymphokines and the production of IL-2 itself were similar under both cross-linking regimens. Thus, when linked to the TCR, Lyt-2 contributed a strong, positive signal toward IL-2-dependent growth of resting T cells. We assume that in the case of Ag-driven T cell activation, the class I MHC molecule acts as the physiologic cross-linking ligand for Lyt-2 and the TCR.     

Immunosuppressive activity of T cell clones generated from human T cells stimulated with autologous TPHA cells

T cell clones were generated from human T cells stimulated with autologous phytohemagglutinin (PHA)-activated T (TPHA) cells. Characterization of three T cell clones originated from donor SF and one from donor JM showed that they proliferated when stimulated with autologous TPHA cells, non-T cells, and peripheral blood mononuclear cells, but did not proliferate when stimulated with allogeneic TPHA cells, non-T cells, and mononuclear cells, with autologous and allogeneic resting T cells, and with PHA. These results in conjunction with the blocking of the proliferation by anti-histocompatibility leukocyte antigen class II monoclonal antibodies indicate that these class II antigens are involved in the proliferation of T cell clones stimulated with autologous lymphoid cells. The four T cell clones are cytotoxic neither to autologous lymphoid cells nor to a panel of cultured human cell lines. The four T cell clones display immunosuppressive activity, since they inhibit the proliferation of autologous and allogeneic cells stimulated with antigens and mitogens and the secretion of immunoglobulin by B cells stimulated with pokeweed mitogen in presence of T cells. Furthermore, the four T cell clones display differential inhibitory activity on the proliferation of cultured human cell lines. The immunosuppressive activity is species-specific, since the T cell clones do not inhibit the proliferation of murine cells. The suppression is mediated by a factor(s) with an apparent m.w. of 13,000 to 16,000. The suppressor activity is labile at alkaline pH and is lost following incubation with pronase (100 U/ml) for 30 min at 37 degrees C.     

Induction of IL-2 receptor expression and proliferation of T cell clones by a novel cytokine(s).

We found a unique T cell IL-2 receptor (IL-2R)3-inducing activity in the supernatant (SN) of the TH1 clone stimulated with antigen on spleen cells as antigen-presenting cells (APC). We have tentatively named this activity the IL-2R-inducing factor (IL-2RIF) and have characterized the activity. The SN induced IL-2R and proliferation of TH1 clones stimulated with B cell APC, which could not induce IL-2R in the absence of the SN. Other known cytokines were examined for a IL-2RIF activity; however, none of cytokines examined exerted a similar activity. Moreover, the neutralizing antibodies against the known cytokines tested did not block the IL-2RIF activity in the SN. When TH1 clones were stimulated with immobilized anti-CD3 or with fixed B cell APC in the presence of partially purified IL-2RIF, these clones expressed IL-2R and showed IL-2-dependent proliferation, whereas they induced neither IL-2R expression nor proliferation in the absence of IL-2RIF activity. These observations suggest that IL-2RIF activity is mediated by a novel cytokine(s) and the cytokine plays an important role as a second signal in the activation of the TH1 clone.     

Regulation of antibody production by helper T cell clones in experimental autoimmune myasthenia gravis

Ten acetylcholine receptor (AChR)-specific T cell clones from Lewis rats were studied. These clones had various AChR subunit and peptide specificities, and proliferated in response to antigen on appropriate APC. All the T cell clones were CD4+CD8- and OX22-, helped anti-AChR antibody production by AChR-primed lymph node B cells, and could secrete IL-2. However, several lines of evidence suggested that IL-2 was not the lymphokine that mediated T cell help. B cells primed with native AChR and then exposed in culture to very low concentrations of native AChR effectively presented the Ag to the T cell lines, presumably due to uptake via Ag receptors, but primed B cells were no more effective than were non-specific APC at presenting a synthetic AChR peptide which is recognized by AChR-specific T cells but not by AChR-specific B cells. Increasing AChR doses produced an antibody production response that was bell shaped and low doses stimulated, whereas higher AChR concentrations suppressed the antibody production response. Evidence suggested that AChR exerted its inhibitory effect through the T cells, but not via IL-2.     

Induction of competence to respond to IL-4 by CD4+ T helper type 1 cells requires costimulation.

Rested murine CD4+ Th1 clones do not produce IL-4, but have previously been shown to be capable of responding to IL-4 if they are first activated with Ag and APC. In this study, we have examined the activation requirements for induction of competence to respond to IL-4 in these clones. TCR occupancy alone (given either as chemically fixed APC and Ag, anti-CD3, Con A, or ionomycin and PMA) was inadequate, but the addition of a source of costimulation to any of these stimuli resulted in complete induction of competence to respond to IL-4. Pretreatment of the Th1 clones with TCR occupancy alone induced an anergic state from which subsequent full stimulation with Ag and APC failed to give IL-4 responsiveness. Pretreatment of the cells with IL-2 alone was an inadequate signal to induce IL-4 responsiveness and only a partial response was obtained when TCR occupancy was combined with IL-2. Addition of anti-IL-2 and anti-IL-2R antibodies during full activation with APC and Ag gave a 50% inhibition of competence induction. These results demonstrate that costimulation, in addition to its role in IL-2 production, is an important second signal for inducing T cells to become competent to respond to IL-4.     

CD8+ suppressor T cell clone capable of inhibiting the antigen- and anti-T cell receptor-induced proliferation of Th clones without cytolytic activity

A CD8+ Ts clone 13G2 was established from lymph node cells of bovine alpha s1-casein-primed C57BL/6 mice by in vitro antigenic stimulation followed by maintenance with IL-2-containing medium. The clone suppressed the Ag-induced proliferative responses of CD4+ Th cell clones without detectable cytotoxicity for both APC and responding T cells. The clone was able to suppress the in vitro proliferative response and antibody formation of Ag-primed lymph node cells. The suppression was Ag-nonspecific and not restricted to the MHC. The clone was able to suppress the proliferation of Th clones induced by an immobilized anti-TCR antibody in which APC was absent. The clone was, however, unable to suppress the proliferation of Th clones induced by anti-CD3 or IL-2. Thus, the mechanism of suppression by 13G2 was found to be due to a direct action on Th by inhibiting a consequence of signal transduction initiated through the TCR.     

Distinct proliferative T cell clonotypes are generated in response to a murine retrovirus-induced syngeneic T cell leukemia: viral gp70 antigen-specific MT4+ clones and Lyt-2+ cytolytic clones which recognize a tumor-specific cell surface antigen

After immunization of B6 mice with the syngeneic retrovirus-induced T cell leukemia/lymphoma FBL-3, two major tumor-specific proliferative T cell clonotypes were derived. T cell clones derived from long-term lines propagated by in vitro culture with irradiated tumor cells and syngeneic spleen cells were exclusively of the Lyt-2+ phenotype. Such clones were cytolytic, retained their proliferative phenotype indefinitely when expanded by repeated cycles of reactivation and rest, and recognized a tumor-specific cell surface antigen in association with class I MHC molecules. This tumor cell antigen was not present on nontransformed virus-infected cells. Class II MHC-restricted MT4+ clones specific for the viral antigen gp70 were derived from lymph node T cells of FBL-3 tumor-immune mice only by in vitro culture with purified Friend virus in the presence of syngeneic splenic APC. Once derived, however, such clones could be stimulated in the presence of FBL-3 tumor cells and syngeneic spleen cells, demonstrating the reprocessing of tumor-derived gp70 antigen by APC in the spleen cell population. In contrast, no reprocessing of the tumor cell surface antigen by splenic APC for presentation to the class I MHC-restricted T cell clones could be demonstrated. Evidence is presented that FBL-3 T leukemia/lymphoma cells function as APC for Lyt-2+ class I MHC-restricted clones, and that no concomitant recognition of Ia molecules is required to activate these clones. Both Lyt-2+ and MT4+ clones were induced to proliferate in the presence of exogenous IL2 alone, but this stimulus failed to result in significant release of immune interferon. In contrast, antigen stimulation of both clones resulted in proliferation as well as significant immune interferon release. Immune interferon production is not required for the generation of MHC-restricted cell-mediated cytolytic function.     

Human T cell clones present antigen

Two human T cells clones are described which react with influenza virus hemagglutinin type H3 and synthetic peptides of H3 when presented by PBMC APC. Both T cell clones also responded to peptide Ag in the absence of additional APC suggesting that T cells can simultaneously present and respond to Ag. T cell clones could only present peptide Ag and not an appropriate strain of inactivated whole influenza virus thus indicating an inability to process Ag conventionally. Peptide presentation by T cells was dose dependent, restricted by MHC class II Ag and was dependent on the number of Ag presenting T cells per culture. Experiments with nested peptides showed that the same epitope was recognized in the presence and absence of PBMC APC. No Ag or IL-2 from the propagation procedure was carried over into assays and two-color fluorescence-activated cell sorter analysis of each clone detected no contaminating cells with the phenotype of monocytes, macrophages or B cells; in each T cell clone, all cells expressing MHC class II Ag co-expressed CD3. These date therefore provide strong evidence that human T cell clones can simultaneously present and respond to appropriate forms of Ag.     

Inability of human alveolar macrophages to stimulate resting T cells correlates with decreased antigen-specific T cell-macrophage binding

Alveolar macrophages (AM) from the majority of human volunteers are defective antigen presenting cells (APC) in T cell proliferation assays despite the display by the cells of HLA-D region antigens. We have confirmed that AM secrete relatively little interleukin 1 (IL 1), but addition of exogenous IL 1 did not improve the capacity of AM to initiate antigen-induced T cell proliferation. Thus, the presence of HLA-D region antigens and IL 1 is not sufficient to enable an accessory cell to act as an APC. We developed a T cell-accessory cell binding assay to investigate early events in T cell activation. AM demonstrated a diminished capacity as compared with monocytes to bind antigen-specific T cell clones. Nevertheless, AM often induced proliferation of T cell clones as effectively as monocytes, indicating that antigen display was intact. The inefficiency of AM in bind T cell clones correlated with their reduced capacity to induce resting T cells to express IL 2 receptors, secrete IL 2, and proliferate in response to antigen. Indirect immunofluorescence established that similar percentages of AM and monocytes expressed LFA molecules, but the density of the molecules was greater on monocytes than AM. A role for LFA antigens in the physical binding of T cells to monocytes was demonstrated by blocking antigen-specific binding with a monoclonal antibody to LFA-1 antigen. LFA-1 antibody also blocked the low levels of specific binding between AM and T cell clones, indicating that LFA-1-ligand interactions were operative between these two cell types. These studies indicate that there are critical cell membrane characteristics that promote binding of T cells to APC in addition to T cell receptor-antigen interactions. This combination of nonspecific and specific interactions leads to avid T cell-APC binding that may be essential for activation of resting T cells. Furthermore, we postulate that the failure to AM to act as effective APC results from an inability to bind T cells efficiently.     

Antigen presentation by human antigen-presenting cells to antigen-specific xenogeneic murine T cells

Successful antigen presentation by xenogeneic human antigen-presenting cells (APC) to stimulate the proliferation of antigen-specific, keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)-specific, ovalbumin (OVA)-specific, and purified protein derivative of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (PPD)-specific murine T cells was observed. Evidence indicating a direct cell interaction between antigen-specific murine T cells and xenogeneic human APC was given by experiments using antigen-specific murine T cell clones. The OVA-specific B10.S(9R) T cell line (9-0-A1) and PPD-specific B10.A(4R) T cell line (4-P-1) were stimulated by both xenogeneic human APC and murine APC from syngeneic or I-A compatible strains, while the PPD-specific human T cell line (Y-P-5) was stimulated by autologous human APC but not by murine APC. Anti-HLA-DR monoclonal antibodies (MoAb) blocked the xenogeneic human APC-antigen-specific murine T cell clone interaction. Thus, human xenogeneic APC can stimulate antigen-specific murine T cells through HLA-DR molecules in the same manner as syngeneic murine APC do through Ia molecules coded for by the I region of the H-2 complex, while murine APC failed to present antigen to stimulate human antigen-specific T cells.     

Regulation of T cell proliferation by IL-7

The regulation of murine T cell proliferation by IL-7 was investigated. Highly purified resting splenic T cells were induced to proliferate in a short term assay by IL-7 in the presence of the comitogen, Con A. The proliferation of these resting T cells showed both IL-2-dependent and -independent components as determined by the susceptibility of the response to the blocking effects of anti-IL-2 mAb. Furthermore, IL-7 was found to augment the Con A-induced production of IL-2 and expression of IL-2R by resting splenic T cells. In contrast, Con A blasts and long term, Ag-dependent cloned T cells proliferated in response to IL-7 independently of any involvement of IL-2. Finally, differences were observed between IL-7 and IL-6 with regard to the regulation of T cell growth and activation. As with IL-7, IL-6 stimulated resting splenic T cells to proliferate in the presence of comitogen. However, in contrast to IL-7, IL-6 failed to stimulate the proliferation of Con A blasts or T cell clones and did not augment the Con A-induced expression of IL-2R on resting T cells.     

Relationship between T cell receptors and antigen-binding factors. I. Specificity of functional T cell receptors on mouse T cell hybridomas that produce antigen-binding T cell factors

Upon antigenic stimulation with OVA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages, the mouse T cell hybridoma 231F1 produced glycosylation inhibiting factor (GIF) having affinity for OVA and IgE-suppressive factors, whereas another T cell hybridoma, 12H5, cells produced OVA-binding glycosylation enhancing factor (GEF) and IgE-potentiating factor. The OVA-binding GIF from the 231F1 cells is an Ag-specific Ts cell factor, whereas OVA-binding GEF from the 12H5 cells is an Ag-specific augmenting factor. Both hybridomas express CD3 complex and functional TCR-alpha beta. Cross-linking of TCR-alpha beta or CD3 molecules on the hybridomas by anti-TCR-alpha beta mAb or anti-CD3 mAb and protein A resulted in the formation of the same factors as those obtained by the stimulation of the cells with OVA-pulsed syngeneic macrophages. It was also found that both the 231F1 cells and 12H5 cells formed IgE-binding factors upon incubation with H-2d and H-2b APC, respectively, with a synthetic peptide corresponding to residues 307-317 in the OVA molecules (P307-317). Six other synthetic peptides, including those containing the major immunogenic epitope, i.e., P323-339, failed to stimulate the hybridomas in the presence of APC. Indeed, all of the 10 T cell hybridoma clones, which could produce either OVA-binding GIF or OVA-binding GEF, responded to P307-317 and APC for the formation of IgE-binding factors. In contrast, GIF/GEF derived from six other hybridoma clones, whose TCR recognized P323-339 in the context of a MHC product, failed to bind to OVA-coupled Sepharose. The results indicate the correlation between the fine specificity of TCR and the affinity of GIF/GEF to the nominal Ag. The amino acid sequence of P307-317 suggested that TCR on the cell sources of Ag-binding factors are specific for an external structure of the Ag molecules.     

Role of the actin cytoskeleton in T cell absorption and internalization of ligands from APC

A feature of T-APC interaction is that, via either TCR or CD28, T cells can absorb molecules from APC on to the cell surface and then internalize these molecules. Here, using both normal and TCR-transgenic T cells, we investigated the mechanism of T cell absorption of molecules from APC and the role of the cytoskeleton. The results show that although activated T cells could absorb APC molecules in the form of cell fragments, uptake of molecules by resting T cells required direct T-APC interaction. Based on studies with latrunculin B, surface absorption of molecules by resting T cells was crucially dependent upon the actin cytoskeleton for both CD28- and TCR-mediated absorption. Significantly, however, TCR-mediated absorption became strongly resistant to latrunculin B when the concentration of MHC-bound peptide on APC was raised to a high level, implying that the actin cytoskeleton is only important for absorption when the density of receptor/ligand interaction is low. By contrast, in all situations tested, the actin cytoskeleton played a decisive role in controlling T cell internalization of ligands from the cell surface.