Stimulation of differentiation of several murine embryonal carcinoma cell lines by retinoic acid

Retinoic acid stimulates several murine embryonal carcinoma (EC) cell lines, even those previously considered to be incapable of differentiating, to give rise to cell types distinguishable from the parental phenotype in morphology, production of plasminogen activator and surface protein properties. Retinoic acid promotes these changes over a range of low concentrations (10⁻⁹–10⁻⁵ M) which are generally non-toxic to the cells. The effects are clearly demonstrated when EC cells are aggregated prior to exposure to retinoic acid. It is concluded that the observed phenotypic alterations induced by retinoic acid reflect differentiation of the EC cells since non-EC cell characteristics are maintained by cloned cells several generations after retinoic acid is removed from the cultures. Our studies suggest that although retinoic acid stimulates the conversion of EC cells to differentiated derivatives, it does not influence the direction of differentiation. Furthermore, the effectiveness of retinoic acid in stimulating differentiation of EC cells from lines such as Nulli-SCC1 raises the question of whether true ‘nullipotent’ EC lines really exist.     

Differentiation-defective mutants of mouse embryonal carcinoma cells: response to hexamethylenebisacetamide and retinoic acid

We have generated by mutagenesis eight differentiation-defective sublines from three murine embryonal carcinoma (EC) cell lines. These mutants grossly resemble parental cells in the absence of inducers of differentiation. Based upon response to retinoic acid (RA) or hexamethylenebisacetamide (HMBA), the mutants can be grouped into three types: (a) RA-selected cells that lack cellular RA binding protein (cRABP) activity and fail to differentiate in response to RA or HMBA; (b) RA- or HMBA-selected cells that possess cRABP but differentiate poorly, if at all, in the presence of RA or HMBA; and (c) cells originally selected for lack of response to HMBA but which retain cRABP and the ability to differentiate in response to RA.     

Collagen synthesis in mouse embryonal carcinoma cells: effect of retinoic acid

In five lines of mouse embryonal carcinoma cells, PCC3/A1, PCC4, PCC4/Aza-R1, and F9, collagen synthesis was examined by immunofluorescence reaction using specific antibodies directed against collagen. All the embryonal carcinoma cell lines showed type IV collagen, and PCC7-S/Aza-R1 revealed the additional presence of type III collagen. When the F9 and PCC3/A1 EC cells were treated with retinoic acid and dibutyryl-cAMP, they differentiated into morphologically different cellular types. These cellular types showed new types of collagen. Thus, in treated F9 cells, type I, type III, and type V collagen were detected and in treated PCC3/A1 cells, type III and type V collagen were detected. In two established cellular strains, PYS-2 corresponding to parietal endoderm and 3TDM-1 corresponding to trophoblastoma, collagen was identified by immunological reaction and electrophoretic mobility. The trophoblastoma cell line was characterized by the production of type I, type III, and type IV collagen, whereas endodermal PYS-2 revealed type IV collagen.     

Response of human rhabdomyosarcoma cell lines to retinoic acid: relationship with induction of differentiation and retinoic acid sensitivity

The ability of retinoids to induce growth inhibition associated with differentiation of diverse cell types makes them potent anti-cancer agents. We examined the effect of retinoic acid (RA) in cell lines derived from rhabdomyosarcoma (RMS), a malignant soft-tissue tumor committed to the myogenic lineage, but arrested prior to terminal differentiation. We showed that several RMS derived cell lines, including RD human rhabdomyosarcoma cells, are resistant to the growth-inhibitory and differentiation effects of RA. We established that this RA-resistance correlates with reduced expression and activity of RA-receptors in RD cells. We stably expressed either RARalpha, RARbeta, RARgamma, or RXRalpha expression vector into RD cells and found that only RARbeta or RARgamma induced a significant RA growth arrest without promoting differentiation indicating that changes in the amounts of RARs and RXRs are not sufficient to determine the RA myogenic response of rhabdomyosarcoma cells. Activation of RD cell differentiation by ectopic MRF4 expression enhanced RA-receptor activity and led to RA induction of differentiation. These studies demonstrate that RA-resistance of RD cells is linked to their lack of differentiation and suggest that the differentiation-promoting activity of RA requires factors other than RAR-RXR heterodimers.     

Commitment in a murine embryonal carcinoma cell line during differentiation induced by retinoic acid

Murine embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells are induced to differentiate when cultured in the presence of retinoic acid (RA). Whereas the EC cells have a high plating efficiency, the differentiated cells have little or no colony-forming ability under the same conditions. We have assumed that the loss of colony-forming ability following exposure of EC cells to RA corresponds to the irreversible commitment of EC cells to differentiate. We found that uncommitted EC cells persist in RA-treated aggregates of EC cells and that the proportion of EC cells stabilizes at a level inversely related to the RA concentration. Both experimental evidence and mathematical modelling results are consistent with the interpretation that there is a dynamic equilibrium achieved by a balance between the processes of EC cell proliferation and differentiation. Since different cell types are induced by different RA concentrations, our results suggest that the commitment to differentiate is not related in any simple way to the developmental program which ensues.     

Commitment to differentiation induced by retinoic acid in P19 embryonal carcinoma cells is cell cycle dependent

The rate at which P19 embryonal carcinoma cells in monolayer culture become anchorage dependent during differentiation induced by retinoic acid (RA) was investigated. In both nonsynchronized cultures and cultures synchronized by mitotic selection, the ability to grow in semisolid medium, characteristic of the malignant stem cell, decreased after a lag period of about 12 hr in the continuous presence of RA, prior to an increase in cell generation time. However, striking differences between synchronized and nonsynchronized cultures were observed in their commitment to differentiation following RA removal. After only 2 hr of exposure to RA, synchronized cells continued a program of differentiation in which they became anchorage dependent, while at least 24 hr of exposure was required for exponentially growing cells to become similarly committed. Induction of anchorage dependence by RA was also strikingly cell cycle dependent; 2 or 4 hr of exposure of synchronized cells to RA in G1 phase, when the intrinsic capacity for soft agar growth is low, was sufficient to commit cells to anchorage dependence, but a similar exposure in S phase was not. Together, these results suggested that interactions between cells in different cell cycle phases in asynchronous cultures influenced commitment since exposure to RA for more than one cycle (13 hr) was required for all cells to become anchorage dependent. Increased plasminogen activator secretion and epidermal growth factor binding, markers of certain differentiated cell types, increased only 3 and 5 days after RA addition, respectively, and were not induced by pulsed exposure to RA of less than 24 hr, even in synchronized cells.     

Retinol conversion to retinoic acid is impaired in breast cancer cell lines relative to normal cells

The bioactivity of retinol (vitamin A) is in part dependent on its metabolism to retinoic acid (RA). We investigated the ability of breast epithelial cells to synthesize RA when challenged with a physiological retinol dose (2 microM). Normal human mammary epithelial cells (HMEC) cultured from reduction mammoplasties were competent in RA synthesis and the ability to synthesize RA was retained by immortal, nontumorigenic breast epithelial cell lines (MTSV1.7, MCF-10F, and 184B5). In contrast, most (five of six) breast cancer cell lines could not synthesize RA or did so at low rates relative to normal cells. A notable exception was the MDA-MB-468 cell line, which was fully competent in RA synthesis. Most (>/=68%) of the RA synthesized by breast cells was recovered from the culture medium. Cellular retinol binding protein and cellular RA binding protein II, both expressed in HMEC, had various expression patterns in the cell lines that did not correlate with the observed differences in RA synthesizing ability. Strong RA induction of the RA hydroxylase P450RAI (CYP26) was confined to ERalpha-positive T47D and MCF-7 breast cancer cells and did not appear to explain the lack of detectable RA levels in these cells since RA remained undetectable when the cells were treated with 5-10 microM liarozole, a P450RAI inhibitor. We hypothesize that retinol bioactivity is impaired in breast cancer cells that cannot synthesize RA. In preliminary support of this hypothesis, we found that retinol (0.5-2 microM) inhibited MCF-10F but not T47D or MCF-7 cell growth.     

The response of embryonal carcinoma cells to retinoic acid depends on colony size

Single cells of the feeder-layer-dependent mouse embryonal carcinoma (EC) cell line, NG2, can spontaneously give rise to colonies containing a wide variety of differentiated cell types in vitro. When cultured with retinoic acid at a concentration of 10(-7) M, single NG2 cells irreversibly differentiated to parietal endoderm, as identified by morphological criteria and immunohistochemical staining. Parietal endoderm was also the first product of spontaneous differentiation. However, when retinoic acid was added to monolayer groups of NG2 cells, not all of the cells were induced to differentiate. The parietal-endoderm cells which did form were generally found at the periphery of cell colonies, as is the case during spontaneous differentiation. Differentiation in the centre of these colonies yielded a variety of cell types over a 21-day period. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that retinoic acid induces the differentiation of EC cells by accelerating cellular response to intrinsic stimuli, rather than by overriding these stimuli.     

The cell cycle,cell death,and cell morphology during retinoic acid-induced differentiation of embryonal carcinoma cells

Time-lapse films were made of PC13 embryonal carcinoma cells, synchronized by mitotic shake off, in the absence and presence of retinoic acid. Using a method based on the transition probability model, cell cycle parameters were determined during the first five generations following synchronization. In undifferentiated cells, cell cycle parameters remained identical for the first four generations, the generation time being 11–12 hr. In differentiating cells, with retinoic acid added at the beginning of the first cycle, the first two generations were the same as controls. The duration of the third generation, however, was increased to 15.7 hr while the fourth and fifth generation were approximately 20 hr, the same as in exponentially growing, fully differentiated cells. The increase in generation time of dividing cells was principally due to an increase in the length of S phase. Cell death induced by retinoic acid also occurred principally in the third and subsequent generations. Cell population growth was then significantly less than that expected from the generation time derived from cycle analysis of dividing cells. Cells lysed frequently as sister pairs suggesting susceptibility to retinoic acid toxicity determined in a generation prior to death. Morphological differentiation, as estimated by the area of substrate occupied by cells, was shown to begin in the second cell cycle after retinoic acid addition. These results demonstrate that as in the early mammalian embryo, differentiation of embryonal carcinoma cells to an endoderm-like cell is also accompanied by a decrease in growth rate but that this is preceded by acquisition of the morphology characteristic of the differentiated progeny.     

Lipid patterns of embryonal carcinoma cell lines and their derivatives: Changes with differentiation

The lipid composition of several teratocarcinoma cell lines has been examined by biochemical and immunological methods in order to identify properties that might be correlated with the state of cell differentiation. The data indicate qualitative and quantitative changes in the phospholipid, cholesterol, and glycolipid composition. In particular, the ratios of cholesterol/phospholipid and of sphingomyelin/phosphatidylcholine are higher in differentiated cells. Gangliosides with short glycosidic chains (GM₃ and GD₃) are characteristic of undifferentiated, multipotent, embryonal carcinoma cell lines. More complex gangliosides (GM₁ and GD_1a) appear early during the course of differentiation. Each differentiated cell line presents a unique ganglioside map. Results are tentatively correlated with a stabilization of the membrane bilayer in differentiated cell lines, whereas a more fluid state of the membrane in embryonal carcinoma cell lines would allow maximal flexibility. Subtle differences in ganglioside composition among embryonal carcinoma cell lines are discussed in relation with their potentialities, and their developmental age.     

Aggregation and cell cycle dependent retinoic acid receptor mRNA expression in P19 embryonal carcinoma cells.

Differentiation of P19 EC cells along different pathways into derivatives resembling cells of the three embryonic germ layers is accompanied by characteristic differences in modulation of expression of each of the three retinoic acid receptor genes, RAR alpha, -beta and -gamma. Differentiation induced by addition of RA to P19 EC cells cultured in monolayer is accompanied by a rapid increase in expression of both RAR alpha and -beta. Induction of RAR beta occurs in a characteristic biphasic manner, suggesting that multiple factors and/or different mechanisms are involved in controlling its expression. RAR beta mRNA is induced to a far higher level during early aggregation in the presence of RA than during early differentiation in monolayer, suggesting that the direction of differentiation depends on the number and/or ratio of alpha and beta type of RA receptors. Aggregation of P19 EC cells in the presence of RA, but not DMSO, is accompanied by repression of RAR gamma, suggesting that the expression of RAR beta and RAR gamma during neuroectodermal differentiation is mutually exclusive. The effects of RA on RAR expression are significantly greater in G1 than in S-phase of the cell cycle. These results extend previous observations that commitment to differentiation is cell cycle dependent and indicates that critical target gene regulation in response to RA has to take place in G1 for differentiation to occur.     

Differential responses to retinoic acid and endocrine disruptor compounds of subpopulations within human embryonic stem cell lines

The heterogeneous nature of stem cells is an important issue in both research and therapeutic use in terms of directing cell lineage differentiation pathways, as well as self-renewal properties. Using flow cytometry we have identified two distinct subpopulations by size, large and small, within cultures of human embryonic stem (hES) cell lines. These two cell populations respond differentially to retinoic acid (RA) differentiation and several endocrine disruptor compounds (EDC). The large cell population responds to retinoic acid differentiation with greater than a 50% reduction in cell number and loss of Oct-4 expression, whereas the number of the small cell population does not change and Oct-4 protein expression is maintained. In addition, four estrogenic compounds altered SSEA-3 expression differentially between the two cell subpopulations changing their ratios relative to each other. Both populations express stem cell markers Oct-4, Nanog, Tra-1–60, Tra-1–80 and SSEA-4, but express low levels of differentiation markers common to the three germ layers. Cloning studies indicate that both populations can revive the parental population. Furthermore, whole genome microarray identified approximately 400 genes with significantly different expression between the two populations (p<0.01). We propose the differential response to RA in these populations is due to differential gene expression of Notch signaling members, CoupTF1 and CoupTF2, chromatin remodeling and histone modifying genes that render the small population resistant to RA differentiation. The findings that hES cells exist as heterogeneous populations with distinct responses to differentiation signals and environmental stimuli will be relevant for their use for drug discovery and disease therapy.     

Expression of homeobox genes in oral squamous cell carcinoma cell lines treated with all‐trans retinoic acid

Oral squamous cell carcinoma (OSCC) may arise from potentially malignant oral lesions. All‐trans retinoic acid (atRA), which plays a role in cell growth and differentiation, has been studied as a possible chemotherapeutic agent in the prevention of this progression. While the mechanism by which atRA suppresses cell growth has not been completely elucidated, it is known that homeobox genes are atRA targets. To determine if these genes are involved in the atRA‐mediated OSCC growth inhibition, PCR array was performed to evaluate the expression of 84 homeobox genes in atRA‐sensitive SCC‐25 cells compared to atRA‐resistant SCC‐9 cells following 7 days with atRA treatment. Results showed that the expression of 8 homeobox genes was downregulated and expression of 4 was upregulated in SCC‐25 cells but not in SCC‐9 cells. Gene expression levels were confirmed for seven of these genes by RT‐qPCR. Expression of three genes that showed threefold downregulation was evaluated in SCC‐25 cells treated with atRA for 3, 5, and 7 days. Three different patterns of atRA‐dependent gene expression were observed. ALX1 showed downregulation only on day 7. DLX3 showed reduced expression on day 3 and further reduced on day 7. TLX1 showed downregulation only on days 5 and 7. Clearly the expression of homeobox genes is modulated by atRA in OSCC cell lines. However, the time course of this modulation suggests that these genes are not direct targets of atRA mediating OSCC growth suppression. Instead they appear to act as downstream effectors of atRA signaling. J. Cell. Biochem. 111: 1437–1444, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Suppression of PTEN expression during aggregation with retinoic acid in P19 mouse embryonal carcinoma cells

Apoptosis is thought to be involved in the maintenance of cellular homeostasis, as well as various pathological processes. However, little information is available about the regulation of apoptosis during the aggregation stage of P19 embryonal carcinoma (EC) cells. Here we report that aggregation-induced apoptosis is markedly attenuated by treatment with retinoic acid (RA). PTEN (phosphatase and tensin homolog deleted on chromosome 10) expression was down-regulated during the aggregation phase of P19 EC cells in the presence, but not in the absence, of RA. Suppression of PTEN expression during the aggregation was accompanied by increased phosphorylation of serine/threonine kinase Akt and glycogen synthase kinase-3beta (GSK-3beta). Our results suggest that RA attenuates the induction of apoptosis during the aggregation phase of P19 EC cells, probably by suppressing PTEN expression.