Mechanism of adaptive response: Estimation of human lymphocyte adaptive response to radiation using various criteria

Blood lymphocytes of 15 healthy donors have been investigated for their ability to reduce radiosensitivity after low-dose irradiation-radio-induced adaptive response (AR). The frequency of unstable chromosome aberrations was used to evaluate cell radiosensitivity after the irradiation of cells in low adaptive (5 cGy) and high challenge (1 Gy) doses in comparison with the effect of challenge irradiation only. Three indexes have been used, i.e., (A) the frequency of cells with aberrations per total analyzed cell, (B) the number of chromosome aberrations per one cell, (C) and the number of chromosome aberrations per one aberrant cell. It was found that the donors can be divided in the four following groups: 1. AR was not estimated any of the indexes used; 2. AR was estimated with indexes A and B, but not C; 3. AR was shown by indexes B and C; 4. AR was evident with all three indexes. The generally accepted AR repair model only explains the appearance of group-3 and-4 donors, but not group-2. For the purpose of understanding the AR mechanisms and the difference in AR estimations with various criteria, the metaphase distribution by the number of chromosome aberrations has been analyzed for each donor. It was shown that, in group-2 donors, the number of cells without aberrations after adaptive and challenge irradiations was significantly higher than after irradiation with a challenge dose only. Thus, in this group, AR is formed as a result of the changed frequency of cells in the 0 class (population shift). A similar shift is observed in the metaphase distribution in the donors of group 4, but not in group 3. The data obtained show that AR is probably a result of several processes, including the activation of the reparation of premutational genome damages, population shifts evident in the frequency of undamaged cells, and, possibly, the activation of apoptotic cell death. The complex character of AR is reflected to different degrees in each criterion of radiosensitivity.     

An individual variability of the adaptive response to irradiation in human cells. Approach to its determination

On human blood lymphoxytes with micronuclei (MN) assay and cytokinetic cytochalasin block and analysis of chromosome aberrations the change of cell population composition, adaptive response (AR) and phenomenon of enhanced radiosensitivity after low dose (5 cGy) and challenge doses (1.0 Gy) have been studied. Irradiation have been carried out in G1 and G2 phases of cell cycle (24 h and 48 h after PHA stimulation). Fixation of cells have been conducted after 50 h (2 h after demecolcin adding) and 72 h (24 h after cytochalasin adding) chromosome and MN assay. Evaluation criteria were the frequency of binucleated cells with MN on 1000 binucleated cells and the frequency of cells with chromatid aberration on 100 metaphases. It was shown that cell population constitution change, AR occurring depended on the individual peculiarity. The evaluation of AR presence by the indexes of bimucleated cells with MN frequency and cells with chromatid aberrations don't coincide (coincidence is observed in 3 cases from 15). It is supposed that in G2 phase after irradiation in challenge dose the MN assay and metaphase analysis can register different cells (24 h and 2 h after mitotic block). The cell population constitution change can probably influence on the AR evaluation but in isn't the AR mechanism. The main mechanism of AR forming * the protection from the damages by different ways. AR depends on many factors, individual peculiarities observes by the use of definite evaluation criteria, in individuals with definite genetic constitution. Perhaps these considerations permit to discuss the problem of AR universality.     

Adaptive response in different mitotic cycles after irradiation

The frequency of cells with chromosome aberrations and the number of aberrations per cell have been studied by metaphase analysis in the nonirradiated progeny of irradiated human blood lymphocytes. DNA fragmentation (DNA double-stranded breaks) has been investigated by DNA comet assay. To study the adaptive response (AR), PHA-stimulated lymphocytes were irradiated by the adaptive dose (0.05 Gy) in 24 h and by challenge dose (1 Gy) in 48 h after stimulation. The first through fourth mitoses were identified by 5-bromodeoxyuridine. It was found that the frequency of chromosome aberrations and double-strand breaks were increased in all mitotic cycles after the challenge irradiation. In most individuals, the adaptive response is induced by adaptive and challenge irradiations in the first and the second mitotic cycles (48 and 72 h after stimulation, respectively); however, it is absent in the third and the fourth mitoses. In the first mitosis (1Gy in 48 h after stimulation), only chromatid aberrations are observed; chromosome aberrations were registered in subsequent mitoses. DNA comet assay showed that the adaptive response was obvious at 48–72 h, but not 96 h, after stimulation. It can be concluded that the nonirradiated progeny of irradiated lymphocytes have genomic instability. The adaptive response is manifested up to the third mitosis and is explained by the decreasing number of chromatid and chromosome aberrations and DNA fragmentation. We suppose that double-stranded DNA breaks may be damage signals for the induction of adaptive response.     

On the response of a cell population to low-dose irradiation

The cell composition of a population of human blood lymphocytes was studied after irradiation at doses of 5 cGy, 1.0 Gy and 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy and the use of a cytokinesis block. The frequencies of uni-, bi- and multinucleate lymphocytes with and without micronuclei (MN) were taken into account. By the standard criterion the frequency of binucleate lymphocytes with MN among binucleate lymphocytes--the donors were characterized as follows: in with reduction of radiosensitivity after irradiation with 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy as compared to the values of radiosensitivity after irradiation with 1.0 Gy only (an adaptive response, AR); in with no change of radiosensitivity after exposure to these doses (no AR); and with an increased ofradiosensitivity after exposure to these doses (syndrome of increased radiosensitivity, IRS). It was found that upon exposure to 1.0 Gy and 5 cGy + 1.0 Gy in some donors with AR, without AR and with IRS the total numbers of damaged cells in the population and the number of binucleate cells with MN were equal. This result calls in question the involvement of the repair mechanism in the alteration of radiosensitivity of lymphocytes in these donors. It was also observed that in the same donors a simultaneous increase (or a decrease in the case of IRS) of the portion of undamaged binucleate cells in the population took place. Our results demonstrate the existence of a new, populational, mechanism involved in the alteration of radiosensitivity after exposure to the adaptive and challenge doses.     

The dose dependence of cytogenetic damages and the adaptive response of mammalian cells under the action of ionizing radiation at low doses

The dose-effect dependence of cytogenetic damage after single dose irradiation in the dose range of 0.1-2 Gy and the adaptive response after double-dose irradiation were studied on Chinese hamster and human melanoma cells in culture. The non-linear dose dependencies were found for the induction of chromosome aberrations with decrease in cell radiosensitivity in the definite dose range. This decrease started at 10 and 20 cGy for melanoma and Chinese hamster cells respectively. The maximal adaptive response was induced at 1 cGy for melanoma cells and at 20 cGy for Chinese hamster cells. It can be supposed that the same inducible repair processes are responsible for non-linearity of dose-effect curves and induction of the adaptive response. These processes are similar in mechanisms and different in quantitative proportion for different cell types.     

The cytogenetic damage, radiosensitivity and adaptive response in children living in the different districts of Moscow

The spontaneous level of blood lymphocytes with micronuclei (MN), the sensitivity to 1.0 Gy irradiation and adaptive response (AR) after adaptive irradiation with a dose of 0.05 Gy 5 hr later have been studied in children population living in different districts of Moscow. It was shown that spontaneous frequency of cells with MN, the sensitivity to 1.0 Gy acute irradiation and the AR manifestation have significant differences in samples taken from children living in different districts. The individual variability is significant also. In each group of children the individuals with the enhanced radiosensitivity after adaptive irradiation have been observed. In conformance with the data of radioecological inspection the radiation situation in different Moscow districts is quite safe on overage but in some districts the spontaneous level of lymphocytes with MN, and radiosensitivity after 0.05 Gy irradiation were enhanced, the AR was not found.     

On the mechanism of adaptive response in human cells

There was investigated one of the mechanisms of adaptive response, related to chromosome aberrations induced by gamma-rays, in lymphocytes of healthy donors and donors with hereditary diseases (Marfan's syndrome and homocystinurea) whose cells are repair-deficient. 3H-thymidine treatment was used as an adaptive dose in G1-period of cell cycle and 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP), activated with UV-light, was used as a challenge agents. Cells of healthy donors and cells of patients with Marfan's syndrome had normal adaptive response in relation to gamma-irradiation and photomutagenic action of 8-MOP. There was no induction of adaptive response in realation to gamma-irradiation and 8-MOP photomutagenic action in cells of patients with homocystinurea. The cells from donors characterised with normal repair system and lack of adaptive response 8-MOP photomutagenic action wasn't modified by 3H-thymidine. We have found parallelism of adaptive response protective effect against chromosome aberrations, induced by UV activated 8-MOP and gamma-rays in repair proficient cells of healthy donors and repair deficient cells of patients with Marfan's syndrome. These data lead us to conclusion that mechanism of adaption, at least in some cases has no connection with repair process modification.     

Absence of radiation-induced adaptive response in lymphocytes of patients with Down's syndrome]

The adaptive syndrome and response (AR) in lymphocytes from 6 patients with Down syndrome (DS) were investigated. No AR was found to occur in all cases in DS cells pre-exposed to 3 rad of X-rays in S phase of cell cycle and then irradiated with 150 rad of gamma rays in G2 whereas the chromosome aberrations yield in cells from control donors was decreased twice under such conditions of the experiment.     

On the new mechanism of adaptive response

The role of changes in cell composition of population of human blood lymphocytes in the forming of an adaptive response (AR) has been studied. By micronuclei assay and cytokinetic block with cytohalasin B the frequency of mono-, bi- and multinuclear cells with micronuclei (MN) and without MN were determined in the initial population. The same parameters have been studied after exposure of the population to the adaptive (0.05 Gy), challenge (1.0 Gy) doses and to doses 0.05 + 1.0 Gy 5 hours after. 13 from 23 investigated individuals manifested the AR: the decreasing of the ratio of damaged binuclear cells to the all binuclear cells after the adaptive and challenge exposure. It was shown that the ways of an AR forming are different: in 7 of 13 individuals with AR the number of binuclear cells with MN did not decrease but the amount of binuclear undamaged cells increased. The ratio of these parameters enhances but not for the account of cells with MN decreasing. There is the linear correlation between the frequency of cells with MN and the frequency of binuclear cells in population (spontaneous, after irradiation with doses of 0.05, 1.0 and 0.05 + 1.0 Gy) with the coefficient of correlation about -1. These results show the presence of new mechanism of AR forming, which is not connect with the induction of damage repair and rather with the stimulation of cell division. In the another group of individuals the decrease in damaged cells number after irradiation with doses of 0.05 + 1.0 Gy have been observed. Probably the stimulation of repair system occurred to the moment of 1.0 Gy irradiation. Thus, the mechanism of an AR forming depends on the individual properties of organism. The work was suppoted by RFBR grant 03-04-48325a.     

Reciprocal adaptive response of human peripheral lymphocytes induced by bleomycine or gamma rays.

The adaptive response and reciprocal adaptive response induced in vitro by exposure to low doses of gamma rays (0.05 Gy) or bleomycin (0.05 microg/ml) in human peripheral blood lymphocytes were assessed by the frequency of chromosome aberrations. Gamma rays (1.5 Gy) or bleomycin (1.5 microg/ml) were used as the challenge doses. In the experiments, blood samples from 5 healthy donors were investigated. It has been found that low doses of bleomycin and gamma rays induced a reciprocal adaptive response to high doses of gamma rays or bleomycin. Moreover, the results confirmed that the adaptive response did not correlate with the radiosensitivity of the peripheral blood lymphocytes.     

The adaptive response of first generation offsprings irradiated parents

In offspring's of first generation irradiated inhabitants of Techa river (fathers, mothers and both parents) the spontaneous level of damaged blood lymphocytes, sensitivity of lymphocytes to the additional acute irradiation in dose 1.0 Gy and radioinduced adaptive response after adaptive (5 cGy) and challenge (1.0 Gy) irradiation 5 h after was studied. The micronuclei test with cytochalasin B as a criteria of the effect have been used. It was shown, that descendents of irradiated parents differ from the control group. The main difference is the significant decrease of the adaptive response frequency in the progeny. In the offspring's of the irradiated fathers and mothers there is no one individuals with the adaptive response; in the offspring's of both irradiated parents the frequency of individuals with adaptive response decreases in control from 19.5% to 6.8%. The distribution of descendents according to response on adaptive irradiation differ significantly from the control distribution and from the each other. And the tendency to the radiosensitivity increase after adaptive irradiation was observed. In the whole joint group of progeny the mean spontaneous cell frequency with micronuclei decreased, but the sensitivity of lymphocytes to the additional acute irradiation doesn't differ from the control. The results of the paper permit to suppose that transgenerational genome instability in human can be determined. Earlier discovered decrease of the adaptive response frequency in the Techa river livings is observed in the offspring's of irradiated fathers, mothers and both parents.     

The cell composition in the lymphocyte population and the radiation adaptive response

Using lymphocytes of 5 healthy individuals the ability to adaptive response (AR), cell composition of population after PHA stimulation, changes in cell composition population after irradiation in the dose of 1.0 Gy and after irradiation in adaptive (0.05 Gy) and challenge (1.0 Gy) doses have been studied. AR observed in 2 of the 5 individuals only. After PHA stimulation the persons with AR have the total amount of cells after mitosis or during mitosis (the number of binucleated cells + the number of multinucleated cells + the whole cells with micronuclei + the number of mitotic cells) on average is higher than in persons without AR. In individuals with AR the linear correlation between the number of binucleated cells with micronuclei (on the 1000 scored binucleated cells) and the part of binucleated cells in the population is observed with coefficients of correlation -0.89 and -0.91. In the humans without AR this correlation is absent. The correlation observed permits to suppose that AR may occur at the expense of not only the decrease in number of damaged lymphocytes, but also the increase in the share of not damaged binucleated cell with the stable number of damaged cells.     

Structural rearrangements of the chromatin during the adaptive response in two genetically close djungarian hamster fibroblast cell lines with different radiosensitivity

The capacity of cell for the adaptive response (AR) induction after gamma-irradiation using micronuclear test was investigated. Our model consists of the parental djungarian hamster embryonic fibroblast cell line DH-TK- and its radioresistant progeny (PIC-20). We demonstrated that AR for the more radiosensitive parental cell line was shifted to the lower adaptive and to the challenge doses. The maximal AR for DH-TK- cells was induced at 0.3 Gy adaptive dose and 1.5 Gy challenge dose (adaptive response coefficient (ARC) was 0.4+/- 0.1), whereas for PIC-20 cells these means were 0.5 Gy and 3.0 Gy correspondingly (ARC = 0.45+/-0.1). Using the method of anomalous viscosity time dependence (AVTD) we demonstrated the chromatin rearrangements in both cell lines during 3-5 h after adaptive dose application. The rearrangement degree evaluated by the relative maximal reduced viscosity was considerably higher in PIC-20 cell line than that in DH-TK cells (2.4+/-0.3 vs 1.4+/-0. 1). Interestingly, the time of chromatin rearrangement did not depend neither on the dose nor on the cell type and was similar in both cell lines after 5 h of adaptive dose application. It was also shown that during the AR chromatin relaxation was lower after exposure to both the adaptive and challenge doses than after challenge dose only. In contrast, in the degree of AR chromatin relaxation was higher for both cell lines.     

Cellular reactions induced by chronic exposure to 14C beta-rays

In V-79 cells the Effects of chronic exposure on induction of chromosome aberrations and abnormal metaphases as well as on efficiency of subsequent exposure to 2 Gy gamma-rays were investigated. It was found that chronic exposure increased the yield of chromosome aberrations as well as abnormal metaphases (spread-metaphases and apoptotic metaphases). In spite of the level of damages in cells, the chronic beta-exposure protected cells against the additional induction of chromosomal aberrations by subsequent exposure to higher acute dose of gamma-irradiation. Cytogenetic adaptive response was retained in the surviving progeny of irradiated cells which were cultured in free medium during 40, 70 days or one year after chronic exposure. At this time the level of residual chromosome aberrations, colony forming ability and distribution of the cells by the number of chromosomes were almost the same as in unirradiated cells. However, the high level of abnormal metaphases and half as much of cells in colony in the surviving progeny of irradiated cells in comparison with unirradiated cell, allow us to suggest that the chronic exposure induced the selection of adaptive forms in condition of the higher level of radiation.     

The radioenhancement of two human head and neck squamous cell carcinomas by 2'-2' difluorodeoxycytidine (gemcitabine; dFdC) is mediated by an increase in radiation-induced residual chromosome aberrations but not residual DNA DSBs

PURPOSE: The present study aimed at investigating if 2'-2' difluorodeoxycytidine (dFdC) radioenhancement was mediated by an effect on induction and/or repair of radiation-induced DNA DSBs and chromosome aberrations in cells with different intrinsic radiosensitivity. METHODS: Confluent human head and neck squamous cell carcinoma cell lines designated SCC61 and SQD9 were treated with 5 microM dFdC for 3 or 24 h prior to irradiation. DNA DSBs induction and repair were analyzed by PFGE. Radiation-induced chromosome aberrations were examined with a FISH technique. RESULTS: In both cell lines, dFdC did not modify radiation-induced DNA DSBs in a dose range between 0 and 40 Gy. After a single dose of 40 Gy, dFdC affected neither the kinetic of repair nor the residual amount of DNA DSBs up to 4 h after irradiation. Whereas dFdC did not increase the induction of chromosome aberrations, after a single dose of 5 Gy, the percentage of aberrant cells and the number of aberrations per aberrant cells were significantly higher in combination with dFdC. CONCLUSION: Our data suggest that under experimental conditions yielding substantial radioenhancement, dFdC decreases the repair of genomic lesions inducing secondary chromosome breaks but has no effect on DNA DSBs repair as measured by PFGE.     

Effect of antioxidant-ambiol on the radiation adaptive response

For studying of the mechanism of adaptive response of plants the seeds of soft wheat Triticum aestivum cultivar Moscovskaya 39 were irradiated in doses 0.25, 50 and 0.25 + 50 Gy and the frequency of cells with aberrations and the mitotic activity in the meristem of seedlings were scored. The pre- and post-treatments of seeds with antioxidant--ambiol were also used. It was found that the exposure of seeds to 0.25 Gy reduce the effects of challenge dose of 50 Gy: the mitotic index increases and the frequency of cells with aberrations decreases--the adaptive response appear. It was also found that the pretreatment with ambiol reduce the effects of the irradiation in the dose of 50 Gy. Post-treatment was less efficiently. Both treatments raise the adaptive response. The correlation between the frequency of aberrant cells and the mitotic index was found and, regardless of the type of treatment all points of experiment fall on the common regression line with the regression coefficient -0.85 (p < 0.01). These facts serve as evidence (1) that the radioprotective effect by the pre- and post-treatment occurs by a common mechanism and (2) that the in the exhausted concentration antioxidant does not change the extent of genome damage inflicted by irradiation. The evidence is consistent with the hypothesis that a nonspecific inducible process of stimulated repopulation was a mechanism of adaptive response of plants.     

Cytogenetic results of irradiation of Southern Ural residents

The paper summarizes the results of studies of 85 individuals exposed in the Southern Ural region. The spontaneous frequency of the cells with micronuclei (MN) in a population of human blood lymphocytes after PHA stimulation and cytokinetic block with cytochalasin B has been determined. The sensitivity of lymphocytes to the irradiation at the dose of 1.0 Gy and the adaptive response (AR) after the irradiation at the low adaptive dose of 0.05 Gy, and the challenge dose of 1.0 Gy 5 h later have been studied too. It was shown that the peculiarity of the Urals population consists in a higher individual variability of the frequency of cells with MN in all groups have been investigated (spontaneous, after acute irradiation in the dose 1.0 Gy) in comparison with Moscow people. The proportion of persons with a significant AR in the Urals groups was considerably lower than that identified among Moscow residents, and the number of persons with enhanced radiosensitivity increased following low-dose irradiation. We can suppose that prolonged action of low level radiation with another ecological factors, living in the contaminated regions result in the enhancement of the sensitivity to the genotoxic agents in the separate individuals.     

Detection of genomic instability in offspring of male mice chronically exposed to gamma-radiation by the "adaptive response" test

The genomic instability (GI) in somatic cells of the progeny (F1 generation) of male mice chronically exposed to low-dose gamma-radiation was studied by comparative analysis of chromosome damage. BALB/C male mice exposed to 0.1 Gy (0.01 Gy/day) and 0.5 Gy (0.01 and 0.05 Gy/day) were mated with unirradiated females 15 days after irradiation. For comparison of radiosensitivity, two-month-old males, the descendants of irradiated and unirradiated animals, were subjected to irradiation with a dose of 1.5 Gy (0.47 Gy/min) from a 60Co source. GI was revealed by the standard scheme of adaptive response. The experiments indicated that, by using the test "adaptive response", it is possible to detect the transition of gamma-radiation-induced genomic instability in sex cells of male parent into somatic cells of mice (F1 generation) either from changes in radiosensitivity or by the absence of the adaptive response induced by a standard scheme.     

Aspects of the adaptive response to very low doses of radiation and other agents

When human lymphocytes and other cells are pre-exposed to very low doses of ionizing radiation and subsequently exposed to a high dose, less genetic damage, i.e., fewer chromosome aberrations, is found than is observed in cells that had not been pre-exposed. This has been termed the adaptive response and has been attributed to the induction of a repair mechanism by the low dose exposure. Several experiments have now been carried out on this adaptive response to better characterize the phenomenon. (A) Experiments with differential display of mRNAs indicate that human lymphocytes exposed to 2 cGy of X-rays have somewhat different mRNAs expressed than do unexposed cells. This is providing access to DNA that might be involved in adaptation. (B) Other experiments with embryonic cells from transgenic mice that are deficient in superoxide dismutase (SOD) have shown that the adaptive response is unrelated to the amount of SOD in the cells, and thus is independent of superoxide radicals. (C) Experiments in which very low doses of various restriction enzymes were electroporated into human lymphocytes have shown that low levels of double-strand DNA breaks alone are able to induce the adaptive response. (D) Experiments in which human male lymphocytes (XY chromosome constitution) and human female lymphocytes (XX chromosome constitution) were cocultivated have shown that adaptation is not caused by a change in the rate of cell progression to mitosis after a challenge dose, and is a further indication that cell stage sensitivity is not a factor in the adaptive response.     

Melanin decreases clastogenic effects of ionizing radiation in human and mouse somatic cells and modifies the radioadaptive response

Melanin’s influence on the chromosome aberration frequency induced by radiation in human lymphocytes and mouse bone marrow cells has been studied. We revealed earlier that melanin significantly decreases the frequencies of different radiation-induced mutations in animal germ cells. Melanin protection in somatic cells has been found to be less effective. The melanin effect in somatic cells depends on radiation dose: the lower the damage level, the better the melanin protection. In order to determine the influence of melanin at low radiation doses, the adaptive response was investigated in mouse bone marrow cells in vivo. The level of chromosome aberrations in these cells after fractionated irradiation of 0.2 Gy+1.5 Gy with a 4-h interval was about half that after a single dose of 1.7 Gy. If melanin was injected prior to irradiation, the aberration level decreased by a factor of about two in both cases. This observed result may be due to the potential radioprotective effect of melanin and to the absence of any adaptive response, whereas in the case of melanin application between the priming and challenge doses, the combined effect of the adaptive response as well as melanin protection resulted in a 4-fold decrease of chromosome aberrations. These results allow us to draw the following conclusions: adaptive response can be prevented by a radioprotector such as melanin, and melanin is capable of completely removing low-dose radiation effects. Received: 2 December 1998 / Accepted in revised form: 15 September 1999