Structures of biologically active oxysterols determine their differential effects on phospholipid membranes

Oxysterols, derivatives of cholesterol that contain a second oxygen moiety, are intermediates in cholesterol catabolism, regulators of lipid metabolism, and toxic sterols with proatherogenic effects. In model membranes, cholesterol and eight selected oxysterols were compared by fluorescence probe techniques that measure changes in bilayer order and phase behavior and by the formation of detergent-resistant membranes (DRM). The oxysterols were modified on the sterol nucleus or on the isooctyl side chain. The model membranes consisted of dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and mixtures of dioleoyl phosphatidylcholine with DPPC and with sphingomyelin. The different oxysterols induced changes in membrane properties according to the differences in their structures. Whereas the effects of some oxysterols on membrane order, fluorescence probe microenvironment, and DRM formation were similar to those of cholesterol, others had little or no effect. An empirical correlation ranking the oxysterols by their ability to modify membrane biophysical properties when compared to cholesterol led to a significant structure/function relationship between the biophysical measurements and an important cellular phenomenon, apoptosis. 7beta-Hydroxycholesterol, which is the most cytotoxic of the eight selected oxysterols, was one of the least cholesterol-like with respect to modification of membrane properties. The results suggest that an underlying mechanism for oxysterol-induced apoptosis in cells, e.g., monocyte/macrophages, should include their biophysical effects on membranes, such as the regulation of the formation and composition of sterol-rich membrane domains.     

Molecular dynamics simulation of the structure of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine bilayers with cholesterol, ergosterol, and lanosterol

Five molecular dynamics computer simulations were performed on different phospholipid:sterol membrane systems in order to study the influence of sterol structure on membrane properties. Three of these simulated bilayer systems were composed of a 1:8 sterol:phospholipid ratio, each of which employed one of the sterol molecules: cholesterol, ergosterol, and lanosterol. The two other simulations were of a bilayer with a 1:1 sterol:phospholipid ratio. These simulations employed cholesterol and lanosterol, respectively, as their sterol components. The observed differences in simulations with cholesterol and lanosterol may have their implication on the form of the phospholipid/sterol phase diagram.     

Side chain oxygenated cholesterol regulates cellular cholesterol homeostasis through direct sterol-membrane interactions

Side chain oxysterols exert cholesterol homeostatic effects by suppression of sterol regulatory element-binding protein maturation and promoting degradation of hydroxymethylglutaryl-CoA reductase. To examine whether oxysterol-membrane interactions contribute to the regulation of cellular cholesterol homeostasis, we synthesized the enantiomer of 25-hydroxycholesterol. Using this unique oxysterol probe, we provide evidence that oxysterol regulation of cholesterol homeostatic responses is not mediated by enantiospecific oxysterol-protein interactions. We show that side chain oxysterols, but not steroid ring-modified oxysterols, exhibit membrane expansion behavior in phospholipid monolayers and bilayers in vitro. This behavior is non-enantiospecific and is abrogated by increasing the saturation of phospholipid acyl chain constituents. Moreover, we extend these findings into cultured cells by showing that exposure to saturated fatty acids at concentrations that lead to endoplasmic reticulum membrane phospholipid remodeling inhibits oxysterol activity. These studies implicate oxysterol-membrane interactions in acute regulation of sterol homeostatic responses and provide new insights into the mechanism through which oxysterols regulate cellular cholesterol balance.     

The study on the interaction between phytosterols and phospholipids in model membranes

Sterols are one of the major components of cellular membranes. Although in mammalian membranes cholesterol is a predominant sterol, in the human organism plant sterols (phytosterols) can also be found. Phytosterols, especially if present in concentrations higher than normal (phytosterolemia), may strongly affect membrane properties. In this work, we studied phytosterol-phospholipid interactions in mixed Langmuir monolayers serving as model membranes. Investigated were two phytosterols, beta-sitosterol and stigmasterol and a variety of phospholipids, both phosphatidylethanolamines and phosphatidylcholines. The phospholipids had different polar heads, different length and saturation of their hydrocarbon chains. The interactions between molecules in mixed sterol/phospholipid films were characterized with the mean area per molecule (A(12)) and the excess free energy of mixing (DeltaG(Exc)). The effect of the sterols on the molecular organization of the phospholipid monolayers was analyzed based on the compression modulus values. It was found that the incorporation of the phytosterols into the phospholipid monolayers increased their condensation. The plant sterols revealed higher affinity towards phosphatidylcholines as compared to phosphatidylethanolamines. The phytosterols interacted more strongly with phospholipids possessing longer and saturated chains. Moreover, both the length and the saturation of the phosphatidylcholines influenced the stoichiometry of the most stable complexes. Our results, compared with those presented previously for cholesterol/phospholipid monolayers, allowed us to draw a conclusion that the structure of sterol (cholesterol, beta-sitosterol, stigmasterol) does not affect the stoichiometry of the most stable complexes formed with particular phospholipids, but influences their stability. Namely, the strongest interactions were found for cholesterol/phospholipids mixtures, while the weakest for mixed systems containing stigmasterol.     

An X-ray diffraction study of model membrane raft structures

Protein sorting and assembly in membrane biogenesis and function involves the creation of ordered domains of lipids known as membrane rafts. The rafts are comprised of all the major classes of lipids, including glycerophospholipids, sphingolipids and sterol. Cholesterol is known to interact with sphingomyelin to form a liquid-ordered bilayer phase. Domains formed by sphingomyelin and cholesterol, however, represent relatively small proportions of the lipids found in membrane rafts and the properties of other raft lipids are not well characterized. We examined the structure of lipid bilayers comprised of aqueous dispersions of ternary mixtures of phosphatidylcholines and sphingomyelins from tissue extracts and cholesterol using synchrotron X-ray powder diffraction methods. Analysis of the Bragg reflections using peak-fitting methods enables the distinction of three coexisting bilayer structures: (a) a quasicrystalline structure comprised of equimolar proportions of phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin, (b) a liquid-ordered bilayer of phospholipid and cholesterol, and (c) fluid phospholipid bilayers. The structures have been assigned on the basis of lamellar repeat spacings, relative scattering intensities and bilayer thickness of binary and ternary lipid mixtures of varying composition subjected to thermal scans between 20 and 50 °C. The results suggest that the order created by the quasicrystalline phase may provide an appropriate scaffold for the organization and assembly of raft proteins on both sides of the membrane. Co-existing liquid-ordered structures comprised of phospholipid and cholesterol provides an additional membrane environment for assembly of different raft proteins.     

The effect of oxysterols on the interaction of Alzheimer's amyloid beta with model membranes

The interaction of amyloid beta (Aβ) peptide with cell membranes has been shown to be influenced by Aβ conformation, membrane physicochemical properties and lipid composition. However, the effect of cholesterol and its oxidized derivatives, oxysterols, on Aβ-induced neurotoxicity to membranes is not fully understood. We employed here model membranes to investigate the localization of Aβ in membranes and the peptide-induced membrane dynamics in the presence of cholesterol and 7-ketocholesterol (7keto) or 25-hydroxycholesterol (25OH). Our results have indicated that oxysterols rendered membranes more sensitive to Aβ, in contrast to role of cholesterol in inhibiting Aβ/membrane interaction. We have demonstrated that two oxysterols had different impacts owing to distinct positions of the additional oxygen group in their structures. 7keto-containing cell-sized liposomes exhibited a high propensity toward association with Aβ, while 25OH systems were more capable of morphological changes in response to the peptide. Furthermore, we have shown that 42-amino acid Aβ (Aβ-42) pre-fibril species had higher association with membranes, and caused membrane fluctuation faster than 40-residue isoform (Aβ-40). These findings suggest the enhancing effect of oxysterols on interaction of Aβ with membranes and contribute to clarify the harmful impact of cholesterol on Aβ-induced neurotoxicity by means of its oxidation.     

Studies on β-sitosterol and ceramide-induced alterations in the properties of cholesterol/sphingomyelin/ganglioside monolayers

Phytosterol—β-sitosterol promotes apoptosis in various cancer cells and inhibits their growth. Supplementation of cancer cells with this compound causes modifications in membrane composition, namely, substitution of cholesterol (Chol), decrease of sphingomyelin (SM) content and increase of ceramide (Cer) level. The aim of this work was to investigate the influence of partial replacement of cholesterol by plant sterol, substitution of sphingomyelin by ceramide and both these factors simultaneously on the properties of the monolayers composed of major lipids identified in breast cancer membranes, namely Chol/SM/GM3 mixtures. Brewster Angle Microcopy experiments and the analysis of the isotherms recorded during films compression and resulting parameters evidenced that β-sitosterol weakens the interactions between molecules, decreases films stability and condensation. The influence of ceramide on sterol/SM/GM3 films was reflected in strong modifications of their texture, however, the morphology of monolayer was determined by the structure of sterol present in the system. It was also found, that simultaneous replacement of 50 mol% of Chol and SM by phytosterol and Cer, respectively, induces lipids segregation, which is manifested in large diversity of phases observed in BAM images. To facilitate the analysis of the data collected for multicomponent monolayers, the properties of selected sterol/GM3, sterol/Cer, SM/GM3, Cer/GM3 binary films were also investigated. The obtained results evidenced that the studied herein modifications in the composition of Chol/SM/GM3 monolayer, reflecting compositional alterations induced by phytosterol in cancer membranes, strongly affect the organization of model system, therefore they should be considered in the studies on anticancer mechanism of β-sitosterol.     

Membrane and protein interactions of oxysterols

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Oxysterols, oxidation products of cholesterol, mediate numerous and diverse biological processes. The objective of this review is to explain some of the biochemical and cell biological properties of oxysterols based on their membrane biophysical properties and their interaction with integral and peripheral membrane proteins. RECENT FINDINGS: According to their biophysical properties, which can be distinct from those of cholesterol, oxysterols can promote or inhibit the formation of membrane microdomains or lipid rafts. Oxysterols that inhibit raft formation are cytotoxic. The stereo-specific binding of cholesterol to sterol-sensing domains in cholesterol homeostatic pathways is not duplicated by oxysterols, and some oxysterols are poor substrates for the pathways that detoxify cells of excess cholesterol. The cytotoxic roles of oxysterols are, at least partly, due to a direct physical effect on membranes involved in cholesterol-induced cell apoptosis and raft mediated cell signaling. Oxysterols regulate cellular functions by binding to oxysterol binding protein and oxysterol binding protein-related proteins. Oxysterol binding protein is a sterol-dependent scaffolding protein that regulates the extracellular signal-regulated kinase signaling pathway. According to a recently solved structure for a yeast oxysterol binding protein-related protein, Osh4, some members of this large family of proteins are likely sterol transporters. SUMMARY: Given the association of some oxysterols with atherosclerosis, it is important to identify the mechanisms by which their association with cell membranes and intracellular proteins controls membrane structure and properties and intracellular signaling and metabolism. Studies on oxysterol binding protein and oxysterol binding protein-related proteins should lead to new understandings about sterol-regulated signal transduction and membrane trafficking pathways in cells.     

Role of oxysterol structure on the microdomain-induced microsolubilization of phospholipid membranes by apolipoprotein A-I

Oxygenated derivatives of cholesterol, oxysterols, have different physicochemical properties and three-dimensional shapes. The kinetics of microsolubilization of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) multilamellar vesicles by apolipoprotein A-I (apoA-I) to form discoidal high-density lipoproteins (rHDL) was dramatically affected by oxysterol chemical structure. Under the experimental conditions of varying oxysterol chemical structure, sterol concentration, and the lipid phase state of DMPC, the kinetics varied over 3 orders of magnitude. Some oxysterols behaved similarly to cholesterol and increased the rate of microsolubilization; however, they were not as effective as cholesterol. Other oxysterols greatly inhibited this process. In general, there was no correlation of the rates with membrane fluidity as measured by fluorescence polarization. The rate of DMPC microsolubilization by apoA-I is highly dependent upon the presence of lattice defects in the membrane surface that occur due to imperfect packing of coexisting lipid phases. The differential ability of various oxysterols to induce the formation of an ordered lipid phase is the probable basis for their effects on the rates of DMPC microsolubilization. There was no effect of oxysterol chemical structure on the structure of the equilibrium rHDL products; however, there was a dramatic effect of sterol concentration on rHDL particle size. Different oxysterols regulate the kinetics of apoA-I membrane association by altering structural microheterogeneity at the membrane surface. However, once the kinetic barrier is overcome, the particle sizes of rHDL products formed are determined solely by the amount of sterol presence.     

Differential lipid packing abilities and dynamics in giant unilamellar vesicles composed of short-chain saturated glycerol-phospholipids, sphingomyelin and cholesterol

The ability of membrane components to arrange themselves heterogeneously within the bilayer induces the formation of microdomains. Much work has been devoted to mimicking domain-assembly in artificial bilayers and characterizing their physico-chemical properties. Ternary lipid mixtures composed of unsaturated phospholipids, sphingomyelin and cholesterol give rise to large, round domains. Here, we replaced the unsaturated phospholipid in the ternary mixture with sphingomyelin and cholesterol by saturated glycero-phospholipids of different chain length and characterized the critical role of cholesterol in sorting these lipids by confocal imaging and fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS). More cholesterol is needed to obtain phase segregation in ternary mixtures, in which the unsaturated phospholipid is replaced by a saturated one. Finally, lipid dynamics in distinct phases is very low and astonishingly similar, thereby suggesting the poor ability of cholesterol in sorting short-chain saturated glycero-phospholipids and sphingomyelin.     

A comparison of the packing behavior of egg phosphatidylcholine with cholesterol and biogenically related sterols in Langmuir monolayer films

Cholesterol and selected derivatives were studied as mixed Langmuir monolayers with egg phosphatidylcholine (PC). As an extension of our earlier work, which employed binary sterol/PC mixtures, here we examined ternary mixed monolayers containing cholesterol along with an alternate sterol and PC in different molar ratios, using pressure-area isotherms. The ternary systems behaved similarly to the binary sterol/PC systems reported previously, with similar condensation noted for the sterol/PC films. To better understand how variations in sterol structure affect sterol packing in such membrane monolayers, binary mixtures containing cholestenone, cholestanol, and lanosterol with PC were also studied. Cholestanol behaved similarly to cholesterol when incorporated with PC, while cholestenone and lanosterol did not cause as much film condensation. The observed differences in molecular packing, and attributed sterol structural differences, are considered within the context of sterol/phospholipid mixtures in biological membranes.     

Cyclodextrin-catalyzed extraction of fluorescent sterols from monolayer membranes and small unilamellar vesicles

This study examined the kinetics of sterol desorption from monolayer and small unilamellar vesicle membranes to 2-hydroxypropyl-beta-cyclodextrin. The sterols used include cholesterol, dehydroergosterol (ergosta-5,7,9,(11),22-tetraen-3beta-ol) and cholestatrienol (cholesta-5,7,9,(11)-trien-3beta-ol). Desorption rates of dehydroergosterol and cholestatrienol from pure sterol monolayers were faster (3.3-4.6-fold) than the rate measured for cholesterol. In mixed monolayers (sterol: 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine 30:70 mol%), both dehydroergosterol and cholestatrienol desorbed faster than cholesterol. clearly indicating a difference in interfacial behavior of these sterols. In vesicle membranes desorption of dehydroergosterol was slower than desorption of cholestatrienol, and both rates were markedly affected by the phospholipid composition. Desorption of sterols was slower from sphingomyelin as compared to phosphatidylcholine vesicles. Desorption of fluorescent sterols was also faster from vesicles prepared by ethanol-injection as compared to extruded vesicles. The results of this study suggest that dehydroergosterol and cholestatrienol differ from cholesterol in their membrane behavior, therefore care should be exercised when experimental data derived with these probes are interpreted.     

Lipid dynamics and domain formation in model membranes composed of ternary mixtures of unsaturated and saturated phosphatidylcholines and cholesterol

In recent years, the implication of sphingomyelin in lipid raft formation has intensified the long sustained interest in this membrane lipid. Accumulating evidences show that cholesterol preferentially interacts with sphingomyelin, conferring specific physicochemical properties to the bilayer membrane. The molecular packing created by cholesterol and sphingomyelin, which presumably is one of the driving forces for lipid raft formation, is known in general to differ from that of cholesterol and phosphatidylcholine membranes. However, in many studies, saturated phosphatidylcholines are still considered as a model for sphingolipids. Here, we investigate the effect of cholesterol on mixtures of dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC) and dipalmitoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DPPC) or distearoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DSPC) and compare it to that on mixtures of DOPC and sphingomyelin analyzed in previous studies. Giant unilamellar vesicles prepared from ternary mixtures of various lipid compositions were imaged by confocal fluorescence microscopy and, within a certain range of sterol content, domain formation was observed. The assignment of distinct lipid phases and the molecular mobility in the membrane bilayer was investigated by fluorescence correlation spectroscopy. Cholesterol was shown to affect lipid dynamics in a similar way for DPPC and DSPC when the two phospholipids were combined with cholesterol in binary mixtures. However, the corresponding ternary mixtures exhibited different spatial lipid organization and dynamics. Finally, evidences of a weaker interaction of cholesterol with saturated phosphatidylcholines than with sphingomyelin (with matched chain length) are discussed.     

Speculations on the evolution of sterol structure and function.

The essential oxygen requirement for sterol biosynthesis dates this molecule as a relative latecomer in cellular evolution. Structural details of the cholesterol molecule and related sterols can be rationalized in terms of optimal hydrophobic interactions between the planar sterol ring system and phospholipid acyl chains in the membrane bilayer. The prediction that the cholesterol precursor lanosterol (4,4',14 trimethyl cholastadienol) is incompetent for membrane function is verified by in vivo experiments with eucaryotic sterol auxotrophs and microviscosity measurements of sterol-containing artificial membranes. For procaryotic cells the sterol specificity is very much broader. Methylococcus capsulatus produces 4,4-dimethyl- and 4-monomethyl sterols, but not sterols of the cholesterol type. Similarly lanosterol and its partially demethylated derivatives satisfy the sterol requirement of Mycoplasma capricolum. A more primitive but unspecified role of cyclized squalene derivatives is therefore postulated for procaryotic membranes. The finding that cholesterylmethyl ether satisfies the sterol requirement of certain microbial systems is at variance with current views on the role played by the sterol hydroxyl group in membrane organization and function.     

Phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin containing an elaidoyl fatty acid can form cholesterol-rich lateral domains in bilayer membranes

Elaidic acid is a trans-fatty acid found in many food products and implicated for having potentially health hazardous effects in humans. Elaidic acid is readily incorporated into membrane lipids in vivo and therefore affects processes regulating membrane physical properties. In this study the membrane properties of sphingomyelin and phosphatidylcholine containing elaidic acid (N-E-SM and PEPC) were determined in bilayer membranes with special emphasis on their interaction with cholesterol and participation in ordered domain formation. In agreement with previous studies the melting temperatures were found to be about 20 degrees C lower for the elaidoyl than for the corresponding saturated lipids. The trans-unsaturation increased the polarity at the membrane-water interface as reported by Laurdan fluorescence. Fluorescence quenching experiments using cholestatrienol as a probe showed that both N-E-SM and PEPC were incorporated in lateral membrane domains with sterol and saturated lipids. At low temperatures the elaidoyl lipids were even able to form sterol-rich domains without any saturated lipids present in the bilayer. We conclude from this study that the ability of N-E-SM and PEPC to form ordered domains together with cholesterol and saturated phospho- and sphingolipids in model membranes indicates that they might have an influence on raft formation in biological membranes.     

Pathways of cholesterol oxidation via non-enzymatic mechanisms

Cholesterol has many functions, including those that affect biophysical properties of membranes, and is a precursor to hormone synthesis. These actions are governed by enzymatic pathways that modify the sterol nucleus or the isooctyl tail. The addition of oxygen to the cholesterol backbone produces its derivatives known as oxysterols. In addition to having an enzymatic origin, oxysterols can be formed in the absence of enzymatic catalysis in a pathway usually termed “autoxidation,” which has been known for almost a century and observed under various experimental conditions. Autoxidation of cholesterol can occur through reactions initiated by free radical species, such as those arising from the superoxide/hydrogen peroxide/hydroxyl radical system and by non-radical highly reactive oxygen species such as singlet oxygen, HOCl, and ozone. The susceptibility of cholesterol to non-enzymatic oxidation has raised considerable interest in the function of oxysterols as biological effectors and potential biomarkers for the non-invasive study of oxidative stress in vivo.     

Schistosoma mansoni: sterol and phospholipid composition of cercariae, schistosomula, and adults

The sterol and phospholipid composition of cercariae, schistosomula, and adult Schistosoma mansoni was analyzed by gas-liquid chromatography and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Cercariae and schistosomula contained cholesterol, desmosterol, campesterol, stigmasterol, and beta-sitosterol while adults contained only cholesterol. In all stages cholesterol comprised greater than 50% of the total sterols, and in cercariae and schistosomula desmosterol comprised 38 and 21% of the total sterols, respectively. The other three sterols, campesterol, stigmasterol, and beta-sitosterol, made up approximately 10% of the total. The same five sterols found in cercariae and schistosomula were present in the hepatopancreas of uninfected snails but with a much higher desmosterol concentration in the parasite, 38%, than in the snail, 2%. As in cercariae and schistosomula the three minor sterols comprised approximately 10%. Thus, the sterol composition of cercariae and schistosomula was similar but not identical to that of the snail host. Phosphatidylcholine was the major phospholipid of all three stages (50%) as determined by two HPLC procedures. The remaining phospholipids consisted of phosphatidylethanolamine, phosphatidylserine, and phosphatidylinositol. In addition, in adults there were small quantities of sphingomyelin and lysophosphatidylcholine. The percentage of each phospholipid was similar among stages with the exception of a slight increase in phosphatidylserine in adults compared to cercariae and schistosomula. These results show that a characteristic lipid composition is found in cercariae, schistosomula, and adults.     

Changes in the phospholipid composition of the arterial cell can result in severe atherosclerotic lesions

The oxysterol concentration in the plasma and the phospholipid composition of vascular tissue obtained by coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) were compared with plasma and vascular tissue from age and sex matched controls. The plasma from CABG patients had a higher concentration of oxysterols than was present in the controls. Human endothelial cells were cultured for 72 hours in a medium containing plasma obtained from CABG patients, from controls or from the same controls to which 5 oxysterols were added to make the total oxysterol level equivalent to that in the CABG plasma and then pulsed with calcium (45Ca(2+)) for one hr. A significantly higher influx of 45Ca(2+) was noted in the endothelial cells cultured in the plasma obtained from CABG patients and from the controls with 5 added oxysterols, but not in those cultured without added oxysterols indicating that oxysterols increased calcium influx into endothelial cells. A phospholipid analysis indicated that the arterial tissue from CABG patients had 48.2% sphingomyelin in its phospholipid fraction compared to 10% in arterial tissue from umbilical cords. The saphenous vein obtained during CABG surgery from the same patient had only 24% sphingomyelin in its phospholipid fraction and unlike the coronary arteries had no atherosclerotic lesions. The higher level of oxysterol in the plasma of patients suffering from severe atherosclerosis could increase the concentration of sphingomyelin in the arterial cell membrane and thereby increase calcium influx required for producing the calcific type VII lesions in the coronary arteries.     

Use of fluorescence to determine the effects of cholesterol on lipid behavior in sphingomyelin liposomes and erythrocyte membranes

The purpose of this study was to generate the equivalent of a cholesterol/temperature phase map for a biological membrane using fluorescence spectroscopy. The pseudo-phase map was created using human erythrocytes treated with various concentrations of methyl-beta-cyclodextrin to remove defined amounts of cholesterol and a trio of fluorescent probes that assess different membrane properties (laurdan, diphenylhexatriene, and merocyanine 540). Parallel experiments with two-photon microscopy suggested that changes in cellular cholesterol content affected the entire membrane rather than being localized to specific macroscopic domains. The various regions of the composite erythrocyte pseudo-phase map were interpreted using analogous data acquired from multilamellar vesicles that served as simplified models of cholesterol-dependent phases. The vesicles consisted of various concentrations of cholesterol (0 to 50 mol%) with either palmitoyl sphingomyelin, 1:1 dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, or phospholipid mixtures intended to simulate either the inner or outer leaflet of erythrocyte membranes. Four distinguishable regions were observed in sphingomyelin phase maps corresponding to the traditional solid-ordered and liquid-disordered phases and two types of liquid-ordered behavior. Physical properties were less diverse in the mixed phospholipid vesicles, as expected, based on previous studies. Erythrocytes displayed five regions of different combinations of membrane properties along the phase map. Some of the observations identified similarities between the cells and liquid-ordered behavior observed in the various types of liposomes as well as some interesting differences.