Ontogeny of murine B-cell responses to thymus-independent trinitrophenyl antigens.

The ontogeny of B-cell responsiveness to three thymus-independent trinitrophenyl (TNP) antigens has been examined in BALB/c mice in vivo and in vitro. When in vivo splenic plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses to TNP-conjugated lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS), Ficoll (TNP-Ficoll), and Brucella abortus (TNP-Brucella) were measured in neonatal and adult mice, a defined sequence of responsiveness was observed. Newborn mice responded well to TNP-LPS, but not to TNP-Ficoll or TNP-Brucella. Neonates injected at 1 day of age responded to TNP-LPS and TNP-Ficoll and mice 5 to 14 days of age responded to TNP-LPS, TNP-Ficoll, and TNP-Brucella. Furthermore, the antigen-reactive populations increased at different rates for the three antigens in the first 2 weeks of life. In vitro experiments confirmed the results obtained in vivo although slightly earlier responsiveness to TNP-Brucella was observed in vitro. PFC inhibition assays with free TNP hapten were performed so that avidity profiles could be examined in neonatal and adult anti-TNP PFC responses. The results clearly demonstrate that once a response becomes detectable in neonatal mice immunized with any of the three TI TNP antigens, fully heterogeneous or “adult-like” responses are found. In addition, experiments comparing avidity profiles in athymic (nu/nu) BALB/c mice and their normal (nu/+) littermates demonstrate that T cells are not required for the generation of fully heterogeneous anti-TNP PFC responses. These results indicate that B cells responsive to different TI TNP antigens mature at different times and at different rates during ontogeny. Late maturation events of such B cells do not include the acquisition of additional V-region specificities as detected in a PFC inhibition assay.     

The effects of cortisol on the primary response of mouse spleen cell cultures to heterologous erythrocytes

Cell viability and the production of direct PFC were studied in mouse spleen cell cultures after cortisol treatment in vivo or in vitro at various times relative to primary stimulation with SRBC in vitro.Cortisol treatment in vivo reduced spleen cell numbers by 88% after 48 hr, but cultures of the remaining cells produced as many PFC in vitro as did cultures of equal numbers of normal spleen cells.In normal spleen cell cultures incubated with cortisol for 4 hr prior to the addition of antigen, peak responses of PFC/culture and PFC/10⁶ cells occurred 24 hr later than in controls and averaged, respectively, 27% and 141% of control values. Minimum viable cell numbers were observed in cortisol-treated cultures after 3 days; thereafter cell numbers gradually increased. These results were not significantly altered when cultures were treated simultaneously with cortisol and antigen.The response was not suppressed if the addition of antigen preceded that of cortisol by more than 4 hr. Suppression was also considerably reduced if fetal calf serum was used when preparing cells for culture.     

In vitro studies of the rabbit immune system: I. Hemolytic plaque-forming response of dissociated spleen cells from normal and primed rabbits

The conditions for the in vitro generation of primary and secondary immune responses by rabbit spleen cells to sheep red blood cell (SRBC) antigen have been examined. Spleen cells from many normal and all previously immunized rabbits are capable of producing in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses when cultured as dissociated cell suspensions in the presence of antigen. Primed spleen cells generate approximately 100 times the number of PFCs obtained in normal cultures with a shorter lag period. Both types of cultures demonstrate a period of exponential increase in PFCs during which the doubling time is 12–14 hr. This increase occurs after 1 day of culture of spleen cells from primed rabbits and after 4 days of culture of spleen cells from unprimed rabbits. The PFCs which arise in cultures of primed cells appear not to be the progeny of those generated in vivo but to be derived from an increased number of PFC precursors. Repeated immunization of the spleen cell donor is required to produce significant numbers of indirect (IgG) PFC or indirect precursors; most of the PFC found after a single immunization in vivo or in vitro are direct (IgM). There is no evidence for conversion of IgM to IgG PFC in vitro. This system should provide a means for further identification of the cellular interactions involved in the immune response of the rabbit.     

Cellular requirements for the expression of IgM. Immunological memory in vitro

In vitro culture techniques have been used to compare the direct (IgM) plaqueforming cell (PFC) response to heterologous erythrocytes (RBC) by normal mouse spleen cells and spleen cells from mice injected intravenously with 5 × 10⁴ RBC ten days previously [low dose primed (LDP)]. Although LDP mice fail to undergo a significant primary PFC response, their spleen cells are capable of a secondary or enhanced PFC response in vitro. The secondary PFC response is shown to be a function of: (A) an increase in the frequency of immunocompetent cells or units (IU) due to in vivo priming, and (B) an increased number of PFC generated per IU subsequent to in vitro stimulation. The latter increase is shown to be mediated through a shorter PFC doubling-time during logarithmic expansion of the PFC population. Analysis of nonadherent spleen cell dose response experiments indicate that two nonadherent cell types interact in the secondary response. Subsequent cocultivation experiments suggested that both of these cell types must be “primed” to allow induction of a secondary response. Although adherent cells are required for the secondary response, normal splenic adherent cells serve as equivalent substitutes for LDP adherent cells.     

Induction of an antibody response in vitro against synthetic antigens in guinea pigs. I. Culture and assay conditions

Guinea pig spleen and lymph node cells were found to produce anti-2,4-dinitrophenyl (Dnp) oligolysine PFC in vivo against 2,4-dinitrophenyl-β-alanyl glycyl glycyl (Dagg-SRBC) but not against trinitrophenyl-SRBC target indicator cells. Furthermore, when sensitized spleen cells or their purified B-cell fractions were cocultured with primed peritoneal exudate lymphocytes (PEL) but not splenic T cells they were able to generate a secondary PFC response in vitro to the synthetic antigens, Dnp oligolysines. PFC were not induced in vitro if these same cultures were pulsed with short-chain peptides (five lysines) or the complex antigen, dinitrophenyl-bovine γ-globulin (DnpBGG). Con A was able to substitute for PEL in triggering spleen cells to mount a secondary in vitro PFC response to homologous Dnp oligolysines. More importantly, the Con A-aided spleen cell cultures were not induced above background values when challenged in vitro with heterologous Dnp oligolysines. This study suggests that spleen cells may lack a nonspecific signal for the development of a secondary in vitro PFC response.     

Lactoferrin-mediated modulation of mononuclear cell activities: I. Suppression of the murine in vitro primary antibody response

The effect of the iron-binding glycoprotein lactoferrin (LF) on the in vitro primary antibody response of mouse splenic cells to a T-lymphocyte-dependent antigen, sheep erythrocytes (SE), and a T-lymphocyte-independent antigen, trinitrophenolated Brucella abortus, was examined. Both iron-saturated and native LF (8% saturated) at 10^?10 to 10^?6M concentrations but not transferrin (an iron-binding glycoprotein similar to LF) significantly (P < 0.05) decreased the number of direct (IgM) plaque-forming cells (PFC) to SE and trinitrophenol (TNP) as determined by the hemolytic plaque assay. LF was equally effective in decreasing the PFC response to TNP in T-lymphocyte-depleted splenic cell cultures. Concentrations of LF which decreased the PFC response were noncytotoxic. A 1-hr exposure of splenic cells to LF at the beginning of the 5-day culture period but not 1 hr prior to assaying for PFC, or exposure of isolated macrophage-rich but not lymphocyte-rich populations to LF prior to reconstitution resulted in a significant decrease in the anti-SE response. These data suggest that LF which is synthesized and released by polymorphonuclear leukocytes and present in inflammatory lesions may play a role in modulating the antibody response through an effect on the macrophage.     

Regulation of the immune system by synthetic polynucleotides. VII. Suppression induced by pretreatment with poly A:U.

Pretreatment of mouse spleen cells with polyadenylic-polyuridylic acid complexes (poly A:U) either in vivo or in vitro 24 hr prior to addition of antigen, resulted in a substantial time dependent decrease in anti-SRBC PFC. Enhancement was observed 6 hr after poly A:U, while inhibition did not become evident until 24 hr after pretreatment. Inhibition of the PFC response appeared to result from poly A:U activation of a nylon wool adherent, T suppressor cell, capable of diminishing the response of normal spleen cells exposed to antigen on co-culture.     

Interferon inhibition of the primary in vitro antibody response to a thymus-independent antigen

Partially purified and crude mouse L cell interferon preparations inhibited the in vitro plaque-forming cell (PFC) response of mouse C57B1/6 spleen cells to the T-cell independent lipopolysaccharide antigen of Escherichia coli 0127. PFC responses of 5-day cultures were inhibited approximately 70–90% by 100–200 NIH reference units of interferon/culture. A similar inhibitory effect was obtained with spleen cells from athymic (nude) mice homozygous for the nu/nu allele. Spleen cultures depleted of adherent cells were also inhibited in their anti-0127 PFC response by interferon. Interferon, then, appears capable of inhibiting the PFC response to E. coli 0127 via direct action on B cells. Heating experiments along with the use of interferon preparations of different specific activities suggest that the inhibition was due to the interferon in the preparations.     

Immunorestoration of old mice by injection of thymus extract: Enhancement of T cell-T cell cooperation in the in vitro antibody response

The effect of injecting a thymus extract (TP-1 or Thy-5) into immunodeficient old mice on the in vitro antibody response of their spleen cells was investigated by techniques suitable for dissecting out T- and B-cell reactivities. The anti-TNP antibody response of HRBC-primed spleen cells from old mice uninjected or injected with TP-1 or Thy-5 was elicited in vitro by TNP-HRBC or TNP-Ficoll. Treatment with TP-1 or Thy-5 was found to induce only a slight increase in the anti-TNP antibody response to both immunogens. The helper activity of HRBC-primed spleen cells from untreated or treated old mice was titrated by adding graded numbers of these primed cells to cultures containing a constant number of normal spleen cells from young mice and the immunogen TNP-HRBC. Under these conditions it was found that both thymus extracts are very effective in restoring T cell-T cell cooperation in the generation of helper cell activity.     

Polyclonal Antibody Production in Murine Spleen Cells Induced by Staphylococcus

Polyclonal plaque-forming cell (PFC) responses in murine spleen cells induced by Staphylococcus aureus and S. epidermidis were studied. Injection of Balb/c mice with S. aureus strain 248βH resulted in the generation of anti-trinitrophenyl (TNP) and anti-sheep red blood cell PFC in their spleens. Cultures of Balb/c spleen cells in the presence of S. aureus 248βH, Cowan I, or a protein A-deficient mutant yielded many anti-TNP PFC. The larger the number of organisms that were added to the cultures, the better was the PFC response. Both living and killed organisms, were capable of inducing the response, but an excess of living 248βH organisms in the cultures abrogated the response. All of the organisms (12 strains of S. aureus and 11 strains of S. epidermidis) freshly isolated from patients had the ability to induce the polyclonal PFC response in cell cultures. These organisms stimulated cultured C3H/HeJ mouse spleen cells, which were unresponsive to bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS). Cultured cells from the spleens of athymic nu/nu mice also responded to these organisms, and the number of PFC in nu/nu cell cultures was always greater than that in nu/+ cells prepared from a haired litter mate. Moreover, the responses of nu/nu spleen cell cultures to which nylon wool column-filtered splenic nu/+ T cells were added were lower than expected. These findings suggest that the polyclonal PFC response to staphylococci is thymus independent, but that the magnitude of the response is regulated by mature T cells. Cultures of macrophage-depleted spleen cells responded to the organisms to an extent similar to that of the control. The 248βH organisms were less capable of stimulating spleen cells of 2-week-old mice (i.e., early maturing B cells) than LPS. However, spleen cells from adult (7-week-old) and aged (9-month-old) mice responded well to both the organisms and LPS. Previous sensitization with the organisms in vivo did not affect any polyclonal responses of spleen cells in vitro to either the organisms or LPS. The role of staphylococcal protein A in the polyclonal PFC response to staphylococci is discussed.     

An in vitro model for induction of immunological unresponsiveness to turkey gamma-globulin in primed mouse spleen cells. I. The secondary in vitro response and induction of unresponsiveness.

Spleen cells from mice previously immunized with turkey γ-globulin (TGG) were shown to give a vigorous secondary response in vitro when challenged in Mishell-Dutton cultures with TGG covalently coupled to pig erthrocytes (TGG-PRBC). However, 90–100% of the response could be abrogated by the incorporation of soluble TGG (sTGG) into the culture medium at concentrations greater than 1 mg/ml. Unresponsiveness, as measured by the absence of plaque-forming cells (PFC) in cultures receiving sTGG, was found to be antigen specific in that these cultures were still able to give normal PFC responses to sheep or burro erythrocytes. Spleen cells incubated with sTGG for short periods of time were shown to remain unresponsive after removal of sTGG from the culture and addition of TGG-PRBC. A 1-hr exposure period resulted in greater than 70% Unresponsiveness and a complete unresponsive state required only 8 hr of exposure. In contrast to the continued Unresponsiveness of sTGG-treated cells in vitro, spleen cells incubated with sTGG for 24 hr were fully responsive to an immunogenic challenge with alum-precipitated TGG when they were transferred into irradiated syngeneic mice. These data suggest that the readily induced unresponsive state in cultures of TGG primed cells may involve either a reversible antigen blockade of antigen-sensitive lymphocytes or a peripheral inhibition of reactive cells by suppressor lymphocytes.     

Development of responsiveness and incidence of bispecific cells as revealed by in vitro assessment of the maturation of mouse bone marrow cells.

The kinetics of the maturation of B cells were studied in adult thymectomized, lethally irradiated, and bone marrow-reconstituted mice. The spleen cells of the recipients were taken at various intervals after transfer and cultured in vitro with trinitrophenylated sheep erythrocytes (TNP-SRBC). The cultures were supplemented with either allogeneic culture supernatant or educated T-cell helper activity. Appearance of functional B cells in the bone marrow inoculum was assessed by the number of hemolytic plaque-forming cells (PFC) on the fourth day of culture. In a parallel series the frequency of surface Ig-bearing cells was determined by using fluorescent rabbit anti-mouse Ig serum. When helped by allogeneic culture supernatants, differentiating bone marrow cells showed a slower rate of maturation into functional B cells than when helped by specifically educated T cells. But in both cases the recovery of responsiveness reached the same level (number of PFC/10⁶ cells) as that of normal spleen cells 55 to 60 days after transfer. During the initial periods of recovery, bispecific PFC (reacting both to TNP and to native SRBC determinants) were detected regularly in numbers far exceeding their frequency in normal spleen cell cultures; in some experiments, the number of bispecific PFC amounted to as much as 30% of the total PFC, whereas, when the bone marrow cells completely recovered (sixtieth day), the frequency of bispecific PFC was similar to that found in normal spleen cell cultures. The number of surface Ig-bearing cells also reached a normal level after the fiftieth day following transfer. In general, the degree of functional maturation was better correlated with the cells bearing surface Ig in the shape of rings or caps, whereas the predominance of spot-bearing cells indicated immaturity of the population.     

Plaque-forming cells fater in vitro stimulation with theta-AKR antigen

Spleen cells of inbred mice strains carrying θ-C3H allele have been cultured in the presence of AKR thymus cells and their in vitro primary PFC response against thymic alloantigen θ-AKR was studied.The responses of a magnitude which was comparable with that obtained in previous in vivo experiments were obtained 4 days after stimulation. The strain-dependent variability of the magitude of anti-θ-AKR responses was observed in vitro. RR and C58/J spleen cells produced much more PFC than C57BL/6J and DBA/2J spleen cells. This was in agreement with previous in vivo studies on the genetic control of the anti-θ AKR responses.In the absence of AKR thymus cells, spleen cells of high responders, RR, developed in vitro PFC which released antibodies lytic to AKR thymus cells. Their number was ten-times lower than in stimulated cultures. Spleen cells of all strains tested produced also small numbers of PFC secreting antibodies against θ-identical allogenic thymus cells and even to syngenic thymus cells.     

In vitro generation of K562 killers in human T-lymphocyte subsets

Group A streptococcal pyrogenic exotoxin (SPE) is a potent modulator of the immune system when used experimentally in mice. Typically, a late burst of plaque-forming cells (PFC) follows an early suppression of the antibody response in appropriately immunized and SPE-treated mice or their spleen cells in vitro. This altered response to antigen caused by SPE is termed a deregulated antibody response. The site of action of SPE was studied by use of cellular reconstruction and complementation experiments using the separated subpopulations of immunocytes which are required for full expression of mouse spleen PFC responses to sheep erythrocytes or to trinitrophenylated (TNP) rabbit erythrocytes in vitro. The SPE site was thus localized to the T-cell subpopulation. Recently SPE has been purified to a very high degree, making it possible to ascertain that SPE alone generates the deregulation of the immune system as described before and to limit the role of nondefined components of cruder preparations of SPE. A purified horse anti-scarlet fever antitoxin which recognizes highly purified SPE as being homogeneous also recognized a single component of crude SPE by agar-gel analysis. A rabbit anti-SPE immunoglobulin raised against crude SPE and absorbed with killed, strain NY5, Group A streptococci recognized the pure SPE and a major component of the homologous crude SPE similarly. Both of these antisera neutralized the capacity of SPE to deregulate the in vitro PFC response to TNP almost completely. A third antiserum raised in rabbits against a NY5 Group A streptococcal whole cell vaccine recognized a different component of crude SPE and totally failed to recognize pure SPE. This antiserum also recognized a purified Group A streptococcal peptidoglycan as being related to components contained in the crude SPE preparation. This antiserum, however, totally failed to neutralize the capacity of SPE to deregulate the PFC response to TNP. These results show that SPE-A is the active component of cruder preparations of SPE which deregulates PFC responses.     

Immune responses in vitro. I. Culture conditions for antibody synthesis

The addition of mercaptoethanol to the culture medium and the optimization of other components has substantially improved the response of mouse spleen cells to in vitro immunization with heterologous RBC. As a result of these changes in the medium, the necessity of rocking and feeding cultures has been eliminated. The in vitro response of C₅₇Bl spleen cells was as much as 30 times greater than that achieved in vivo. This suggests the loss of an in vivo control mechanism. Because the magnitude of responses was strain dependent, this culture system may facilitate the study of the genetic control of antibody synthesis.     

Immunoadjuvant activity of pyran copolymer: I. Evidence for direct stimulation of T-lymphocytes and macrophages

A single injection of pyran copolymer has been shown to greatly increase the number of hemolytic plaque forming cells to sheep erythrocytes (sRBC). Pyran given from 1 day before to 2 days after sRBC inoculation increased both specific activity and plaques/spleen, suggesting that macrophage activation was probably not responsible for the enhancement seen. In addition, pyran given 1 day prior to the primary injection of sRBC was found to increase the secondary response to SRBC given alone. As similar experiments using thymectomized irradiated bone marrow reconstituted mice showed no increase in specific activity following pyran administration, it was unlikely that pyran was acting directly on B cells. Furthermore, experiments measuring the antibody response to Escherichia coli lipopolysaccharide, a thymic independent antigen, pyran did not increase the response to this antigen. In contrast to the above, pyran delayed and depressed cell mediated cytotoxicity to the allogeneic DBA/2 P815 mastocytoma. However, no difference in the titers of cytotoxic antibody against mastocytoma cells was seen between pyran-treated and normal animals. Pyran was mitogenic for spleen cells in vitro. However, following the administration of pyran in vivo, mitogen induced blastogenesis in vitro to PHA and LPS was inhibited and this inhibition was determined to be macrophage-dependent. These results are consistent with a model in which the immunoregulatory effects of pyran act through macrophages and T-lymphocytes.     

Nude mice--a model system for studying the cellular basis of the humoral immune response

Mice homozygous for the nu gene fail to develop a thymus. In comparison to spleen cells from +/nu mice spleen cells from nu/nu mice have a deficient 19S PFC response to SRBC when tested in culture or in vivo. This deficiency is due to a lack of “helper” T cells in nu/nu spleen; A cells and B cells appear to be normal. The capacity of nu/nu spleen cells to produce a PFC response in culture can be corrected by the addition of T cells obtained from either the thymuses or the spleens of +/nu mice. In contrast to “helper” T cells obtained from the spleen, “helper” T cells obtained from the thymus appear to require the capacity for proliferation during the response to SRBC.     

In vitro development of a primary antibody response with lymph node cells.

Utilizing a variety of lymphoid tissues from three common laboratory species, comparative studies were performed to investigate the competence of the dissociated cells to respond to a heterologous erythrocyte with the development of specific plaque-forming cells. Dissociated spleen cells harvested from BDF1 mice consistently developed specific plaque-forming cells (PFC) to sheep red blood cells (SRBC), while hamster spleen cells inconsistently developed specific antibody-forming cells to SRBC. Under identical conditions, guinea pig spleen cells did not develop significant numbers of PFC to SRBC. However, lymph node cell cultures of all three species tested yielded specific PFC. In the mouse and hamster lymph node cell cultures, the yield of PFC per culture or per 10⁶ recovered viable cells was always greater than the yield from companion spleen cell cultures. Guinea pig mesenteric lymph node cell cultures developed the major PFC response to SRBC, while both mesenteric and peripheral lymph node cell cultures from hamsters were equivalent in their response to SRBC. The data demonstrate that it is possible to develop a primary antibody response to SRBC in vitro utilizing normal endogenous hamster or guinea pig lymphoid cells, if lymph nodes are the source of cells.     

The induction of hapten-specific immunological tolerance and immunity in B lymphocytes. V. Evidence for b-cell deletion in vitro with serum from tolerant mice.

The serum from mice that had been rendered specifically tolerant (TolS) to the trinitrophenyl (TNP) hapten by the injection of trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid (TNBS) is effective in the in vitro induction of immunological unresponsiveness in murine spleen cells. This tolerance system was investigated with particular emphasis upon the mode of induction. The observed inhibition by TolS of responses to the thymic-independent (TI) antigen TNP-lipopolysaccharide (TNP-LPS) was stable following adoptive transfer to lethally irradiated recipients and was due neither to the delay of in vitro responsiveness nor to effector cell blockade at the level of the antibody-forming cell. Neither suppressor cells nor cell-bound tolerogen carry-over were responsible for the tolerance induced by TolS. TNP-LPS doses, including a wide range of polyclonal activating concentrations, were ineffective in reversing the unresponsive state induced by cocultivation with TolS. Additionally, unconjugated LPS in either fetal calf serum (FCS)-containing or FCS-free cultures did not break tolerance. This failure of polyclonal activating substances to reverse the unresponsive state suggests that blockade of TNP-specific receptors is not the mechanism of tolerogenesis, since such compounds trigger cells polyclonally through nonimmunoglobulin receptors. Tolerance induced by incubation of spleen cells with TolS for 24 hr followed by extensive washing was stable whether the immunogenic stimulus was the TI antigen TNP-LPS or the thymic-dependent (TD) form of the hapten, TNP-sheep erythrocytes (TNP-SRC). Washing spleen cells at elevated temperatures after preculturing with TolS to avoid possible reassociation of surface Ig (sIg)-bound TNP conjugates did not lead to escape from tolerance. Antigen-free incubation for 24 hr following cultivation with TolS was equally unsuccessful in reversing the unresponsive state. Thus, extensive washing following tolerance induction and antigen-free cultivation where unblocking or turnover and resynthesis of sIg receptors should have taken place provided no support for receptor blockade as the mode of in vitro induction and maintenance of tolerance by TolS. Treatment with the proteolytic enzyme pronase with the intention of removing potential tolerogen from the cell surface revealed a stable tolerant state. Incubation with anti-Ig or anti-TNP antisera under conditions designed to allow capping and removal of sIg-bound tolerogen or surface-bound TNP conjugates also failed to reverse the tolerance induced by incubation with TolS. The results presented here and previously lend no support to active or passive suppression or blockade of reactive cells as the mechanism of tolerance induction in vitro by TolS. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that TolS-induced unresponsiveness is due to a functional deletion of TNP-specific B lymphocytes. Furthermore, the similarities observed between the induction of tolerance by TNBS injection and TolS-induced unresponsiveness are consistent with the suggestion that TNBS-induced tolerance in vivo is mediated by a component of TolS which is active as a tolerogen in vitro.