Deletion Mutations Caused by DNA Strand Slippage in Acinetobacter baylyi

Short nucleotide sequence repetitions in DNA can provide selective benefits and also can be a source of genetic instability arising from deletions guided by pairing between misaligned strands. These findings raise the question of how the frequency of deletion mutations is influenced by the length of sequence repetitions and by the distance between them. An experimental approach to this question was presented by the heat-sensitive phenotype conferred by pcaG1102, a 30-bp deletion in one of the structural genes for Acinetobacter baylyi protocatechuate 3,4-dioxygenase, which is required for growth with quinate. The original pcaG1102 deletion appears to have been guided by pairing between slipped DNA strands from nearby repeated sequences in wild-type pcaG. Placement of an in-phase termination codon between the repeated sequences in pcaG prevents growth with quinate and permits selection of sequence-guided deletions that excise the codon and permit quinate to be used as a growth substrate at room temperature. Natural transformation facilitated introduction of 68 different variants of the wild-type repeat structure within pcaG into the A. baylyi chromosome, and the frequency of deletion between the repetitions was determined with a novel method, precision plating. The deletion frequency increases with repeat length, decreases with the distance between repeats, and requires a minimum amount of similarity to occur at measurable rates. Deletions occurred in a recA-deficient background. Their frequency was unaffected by deficiencies in mutS and was increased by inactivation of recG.     

Instability of a Plasmid-Borne Inverted Repeat in Saccharomyces Cerevisiae

Inverted repeated DNA sequences are common in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. We found that a plasmid-borne 94 base-pair inverted repeat (a perfect palindrome of 47 bp) containing a poly GT sequence is unstable in S. cerevisiae, with a minimal deletion frequency of about 10(-4)/mitotic division. Ten independent deletions had identical end points. Sequence analysis indicated that all deletions were the result of a DNA polymerase slippage event (or a recombination event) involving a 5-bp repeat (5' CGACG 3') that flanked the inverted repeat. The deletion rate and the types of deletions were unaffected by the rad52 mutation. Strains with the pms1 mutation had a 10-fold elevated frequency of instability of the inverted repeat. The types of sequence alterations observed in the pms1 background, however, were different than those seen in either the wild-type or rad52 genetic backgrounds.     

The pca-pob supraoperonic cluster of Acinetobacter calcoaceticus contains quiA, the structural gene for quinate-shikimate dehydrogenase.

An 18-kbp Acinetobacter calcoaceticus chromosomal segment contains the pcaIJFBDKCHG operon, which is required for catabolism of protocatechuate, and pobSRA, genes associated with conversion of p-hydroxybenzoate to protocatechuate. The genetic function of the 6.5 kbp of DNA between pcaG and pobS was unknown. Deletions in this DNA were designed by removal of fragments between restriction sites, and the deletion mutations were introduced into A. calcoaceticus by natural transformation. The mutations prevented growth with either quinate or shikimate, growth substrates that depend upon qui gene function for their catabolism to protocatechuate. The location of quiA, a gene encoding quinate-shikimate dehydrogenase, was indicated by its expression in one of the deletion mutants, and the position of the gene was confirmed by determination of its 2,427-bp nucleotide sequence. The deduced amino acid sequence of QuiA confirmed that it is a member of a family of membrane-associated, pyrrolo-quinoline quinone-dependent dehydrogenases, as had been suggested by earlier biochemical investigations. Catabolism of quinate and skikimate is initiated by NAD(+)-dependent dehydrogenases in other microorganisms, so it is evident that different gene pools were called upon to provide the ancestral enzyme for this metabolic step.     

Terminally redundant deletion mutants of bacteriophage BF23.

Deletion mutants of bacteriophage BF23 were isolated and the positions of the deletions were determined. Two different deletable regions were detected: one in the same region as previously reported for bacteriophage T5, which is closely related to BF23; and the other within both terminal repetitions. The former deletable region lay between positions 0.31 and 0.36, which represented the fractional lengths of the BF23 ( + ) DNA as measured from its left end. The latter deletion was evenly divided between the two terminal repetitions. The deletion in the left terminal repetition lay between positions 0.044 and 0.078 and was repeated in the corresponding region of the right terminal repetition between positions 0.966 and 1.0. The size of the DNA transferred to host cells during the first step of DNA transfer by BF23 carrying deletions in the terminal repetitions of its DNA was less than the size of DNA transferred during the first step by wild-type BF23 by an amount equal to the size of the deletion in each terminal repetition. This finding suggests the existence of a specific mechanism for delineating the position at which the first step of DNA transfer is stopped.     

A Sister-Strand Exchange Mechanism for Reca-Independent Deletion of Repeated DNA Sequences in Escherichia Coli

In the genomes of many organisms, deletions arise between tandemly repeated DNA sequences of lengths ranging from several kilobases to only a few nucleotides. Using a plasmid-based assay for deletion of a 787-bp tandem repeat, we have found that a recA-independent mechanism contributes substantially to the deletion process of even this large region of homology. No Escherichia coli recombination gene tested, including recA, had greater than a fivefold effect on deletion rates. The recA-independence of deletion formation is also observed with constructions present on the chromosome. RecA promotes synapsis and transfer of homologous DNA strands in vitro and is indispensable for intermolecular recombination events in vivo measured after conjugation. Because deletion formation in E. coli shows little or no dependence on recA, it has been assumed that homologous recombination contributes little to the deletion process. However, we have found recA-independent deletion products suggestive of reciprocal crossovers when branch migration in the cell is inhibited by a ruvA mutation. We propose a model for recA-independent crossovers between replicating sister strands, which can also explain deletion or amplification of repeated sequences. We suggest that this process may be initiated as post-replicational DNA repair; subsequent strand misalignment at repeated sequences leads to genetic rearrangements.     

Homologous and nonhomologous recombination resulting in deletion: effects of p53 status, microhomology, and repetitive DNA length and orientation

Repetitive DNA elements frequently are precursors to chromosomal deletions in prokaryotes and lower eukaryotes. However, little is known about the relationship between repeated sequences and deletion formation in mammalian cells. We have created a novel integrated plasmid-based recombination assay to investigate repeated sequence instability in human cells. In a control cell line, the presence of direct or inverted repeats did not appreciably influence the very low deletion frequencies (2 x 10(-7) to 9 x 10(-7)) in the region containing the repeat. Similar to what has been observed in lower eukaryotes, the majority of deletions resulted from the loss of the largest direct repeat present in the system along with the intervening sequence. Interestingly, in closely related cell lines that possess a mutant p53 gene, deletion frequencies in the control and direct-repeat plasmids were 40 to 300 times higher than in their wild-type counterparts. However, mutant p53 cells did not preferentially utilize the largest available homology in the formation of the deletion. Surprisingly, inverted repeats were approximately 10,000 times more unstable in all mutant p53 cells than in wild-type cells. Finally, several deletion junctions were marked by the addition of novel bases that were homologous to one of the preexisting DNA ends. Contrary to our expectations, only 6% of deletions in all cell lines could be classified as arising from nonhomologous recombination.     

Deletion mutagenesis independent of recombination in bacteriophage T7.

Deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7-infected Escherichia coli was examined. The phage ligase gene was interrupted by insertion of synthetic DNA designed so that the inserts were bracketed by 10-bp direct repeats. Deletion between the direct repeats eliminated the insert and restored the ability of the phage to make its own ligase. The deletion frequency of inserts of 85 bp or less was of the order of 10(-6) deletions per replication. The deletion frequency dropped sharply in the range between 85 and 94 bp and then decreased at a much lower rate over the range from 94 to 900 bp. To see whether a deletion was predominantly caused by intermolecular recombination between the leftmost direct repeat on one chromosome and the rightmost direct repeat on a distinct chromosome, genetic markers were introduced to the left and right of the insert in the ligase gene. Short deletions of 29 bp and longer deletions of approximately 350 bp were examined in this way. Phage which underwent deletion between the direct repeats had the same frequency of recombination between the left and right flanking markers as was found in controls in which no deletion events took place. These data argue against intermolecular recombination between direct repeats as a major factor in deletion in T7-infected E. coli.     

Palindromy and the Location of Deletion Endpoints in Escherichia Coli

The contributions of direct and inverted repeats to deletion formation were studied by characterizing Ampr revertants of plasmids with a series of insertion mutations at a specific site in the pBR322 ampicillin resistance (amp) gene. The inserts at this site are palindromic, variable in length, and bracketed by 9- or 10-bp direct repeats of amp sequence. There is an additional direct repeat composed of 4 bp within the insert and 4 bp of adjoining amp sequence. DNA sequencing and colony hybridization of Ampr revertants showed that they contained either the parental amp sequence, implying deletion endpoints in the flanking 9- or 10-bp repeats, or a specific 1-bp substitution, implying endpoints in the 4-bp repeats. Although generally direct repeats seem to be used as deletion endpoints with a frequency proportional to their lengths, we found that with uninterrupted palindromes longer than 32 bp, the majority of deletions ended in the 4 bp, not the 9- or 10-bp repeats. This preferential use of the shorter direct repeats associated with palindromes is interpreted according to a DNA synthesis-error model in which hairpin structures formed by intrastrand pairing foster the slippage of nascent strands during DNA synthesis.     

Deletion between direct repeats in T7 DNA stimulated by double-strand breaks.

An in vitro system based on extracts of Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage T7 was used to study genetic deletions between directly repeated sequences. The frequency of deletion was highest under conditions in which the DNA was actively replicating. Deletion frequency increased markedly with the length of the direct repeat both in vitro and in vivo. When a T7 gene was interrupted by 93 bp of nonsense sequence flanked by 20-bp direct repeats, the region between the repeats was deleted in about 1 out of every 1,600 genomes during each round of replication. Very similar values were found for deletion frequency in vivo and in vitro. The deletion frequency was essentially unaffected by a recA mutation in the host. When a double-strand break was placed between the repeats, repair of this strand break was often accompanied by the deletion of the DNA between the direct repeats, suggesting that break rejoining could contribute to deletion during in vitro DNA replication.     

A simple technique for the isolation of deletion mutants of phage lambda.

We describe a simple technique for isolating deletion mutants of phage lambda and use it to dissect a cloned fragment of foreign DNA. The technique is based on our previous finding that the normally essential product of lambda head gene D is dispensible for phage growth if the DNA content of the phage is less than 82% that of lambda wild-type (Sternberg and Weisberg, 1977). A significant fraction of the few phage that form plaques when a D amber mutant is plated on a nonsuppressing host contains deletions that reduce the phage chromosome size to less than 82% that of wild-type. It is possible to isolate deletions ranging in size from less than 1.5 kb to 14 kb (3 to 27% of wild-type lambda), and the size range can be restricted by an appropriate choice of the DNA content of the starting phage. This method, unlike the older EDTA or heat resistance methods, permits the scoring of deletions because of the absence of phenotypic variants. We investigated the effect of several host and phage mutations on deletion frequency and type and have determined that a host polA mutation increases the frequency of deletions about 30-50-fold without changing the type of deletions. A host mutD mutation or thymine deprivation increases deletion frequency about 10-fold. In contrast, a host ligts mutation has no effect on the frequency of deletions. We have also determined that the size of the smallest lambda chromosome packageable in a plaque-forming phage particle is 72-73% that of lambda wild-type.     

Histone H3 and H4 gene deletions in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

The genome of haploid Saccharomyces cerevisiae contains two nonallelic sets of histone H3 and H4 genes. Strains with deletions of each of these loci were constructed by gene replacement techniques. Mutants containing deletions of either gene set were viable, however meiotic segregants lacking both histone H3 and H4 gene loci were inviable. In haploid cells no phenotypic expression of the histone gene deletions was observed; deletion mutants had wild-type growth rates, were not temperature sensitive for growth, and mated normally. However, diploids homozygous for the H3-H4 gene deletions were slightly defective in their growth and cell cycle progression. The generation times of the diploid mutants were longer than wild-type cells, the size distributions of cells from exponentially growing cultures were skewed towards larger cell volumes, and the G1 period of the mutant cells was longer than that of the wild-type diploid. The homozygous deletion of the copy-II set of H3-H4 genes in diploids also increased the frequency of mitotic chromosome loss as measured using a circular plasmid minichromosome assay.     

Slipped Misalignment Mechanisms of Deletion Formation: In Vivo Susceptibility to Nucleases

Misalignment of repeated sequences during DNA replication can lead to deletions or duplications in genomic DNA. In Escherichia coli, such genetic rearrangements can occur at high frequencies, independent of the RecA-homologous recombination protein, and are sometimes associated with sister chromosome exchange (SCE). Two mechanisms for RecA-independent genetic rearrangements have been proposed: simple replication misalignment of the nascent strand and its template and SCE-associated misalignment involving both nascent strands. We examined the influence of the 3′ exonuclease of DNA polymerase III and exonuclease I on deletion via these mechanisms in vivo. Because mutations in these exonucleases stimulate tandem repeat deletion, we conclude that displaced 3′ ends are a common intermediate in both mechanisms of slipped misalignments. Our results also confirm the notion that two distinct mechanisms contribute to slipped misalignments: simple replication misalignment events are sensitive to DNA polymerase III exonuclease, whereas SCE-associated events are sensitive to exonuclease I. If heterologies are present between repeated sequences, the mismatch repair system dependent on MutS and MutH aborts potential deletion events via both mechanisms. Our results suggest that simple slipped misalignment and SCE-associated misalignment intermediates are similarly susceptible to destruction by the mismatch repair system.     

Deleted mitochondrial DNA in the skeletal muscle of aged individuals.

Human mitochondrial DNA deletions occur mainly in the major region between the origins of replication of the heavy and light strands both in mitochondrial myopathy and in the ageing process. To determine whether deletions in the minor region also contribute to the ageing process, we analyzed a 3,610-basepair deletion (nucleotide position 1,837-5,447, from the 16S rRNA gene to the ND2 gene) in the skeletal muscle from individuals of various ages. The direct repeated sequence at each boundary of the deletion was identified as 5'-CCCC-3'. This minor-region deletion was detected in one of five individuals of the sixth decade, two of five in the seventh decade, and all of five in the eighth decade, but not in individuals below age 60. These results indicate that age-related accumulation of mtDNA deletions occurs not only in the major region but also in the minor region.     

Deletions in Plasmid Pbr322: Replication Slippage Involving Leading and Lagging Strands

We test here whether a class of deletions likely to result from errors during DNA replication arise preferentially during synthesis of either the leading or the lagging DNA strand. Deletions were obtained by reversion of particular insertion mutant alleles of the pBR322 amp gene. The alleles contain insertions of palindromic DNAs bracketed by 9-bp direct repeats of amp sequence; in addition, bp 2 to 5 in one arm of the palindrome form a direct repeat with 4 bp of adjoining amp sequence. Prior work had shown that reversion to Ampr results from deletions with endpoints in the 8- or 4-bp repeat, and that the 4-bp repeats are used preferentially because one of them is in the palindrome. To test the role of leading and lagging strand synthesis in deletion formation, we reversed the direction of replication of the amp gene by inverting the pBR322 replication origin, and also constructed new mutant alleles with a 4-bp repeat starting counterclockwise rather than clockwise of the insertion. In both cases the 4-bp repeats were used preferentially as deletion endpoints. A model is presented in which deletions arise during elongation of the strand that copies the palindrome before the adjoining 4-bp repeat, and in which preferential use of the 4-bp repeats independent of the overall direction of replication implies that deletions arise during syntheses of both leading and lagging strands.     

A role for DNA mismatch repair protein Msh2 in error-prone double-strand-break repair in mammalian chromosomes

We examined error-prone nonhomologous end joining (NHEJ) in Msh2-deficient and wild-type Chinese hamster ovary cell lines. A DNA substrate containing a thymidine kinase (tk) gene fused to a neomycin-resistance (neo) gene was stably integrated into cells. The fusion gene was rendered nonfunctional due to a 22-bp oligonucleotide insertion, which included the 18-bp I-SceI endonuclease recognition site, within the tk portion of the fusion gene. A double-strand break (DSB) was induced by transiently expressing the I-SceI endonuclease, and deletions or insertions that restored the tk-neo fusion gene's reading frame were recovered by selecting for G418-resistant colonies. Overall, neither the frequency of recovery of G418-resistant colonies nor the sizes of NHEJ-associated deletions were substantially different for the mutant vs. wild-type cell lines. However, we did observe greater usage of terminal microhomology among NHEJ events recovered from wild-type cells as compared to Msh2 mutants. Our results suggest that Msh2 influences error-prone NHEJ repair at the step of pairing of terminal DNA tails. We also report the recovery from both wild-type and Msh2-deficient cells of an unusual class of NHEJ events associated with multiple deletion intervals, and we discuss a possible mechanism for the generation of these "discontinuous deletions."     

The roles of the simian virus 40 tumor antigens in transformation of Chinese hamster lung cells.

Simian virus 40 mutants and deletions between 0.54 and 0.59 map units direct the synthesis of defective 20K t antigens (Crawford et al., 1978). These deletion mutants transformed actively growing CHL cells nearly as efficently as did wild-type virus, in either the focus formation assay or the growth in soft agar assay. In contrast, when CHL cells were in a resting state during infection, the transformation frequency of the mutants relative to wild-type dropped approximately 50 fold. The presence of the phorbol ester, TPA, diminished this difference. CHL cell lines transformed by the deletion mutants and selected by the focus assay grew almost as efficiently in soft agar as lines transformed by wild-type SV40. Both produced tumors in nude mice. The function of the 20K t antigen is discussed.