Specification of surface mating systems among conjugative drug resistance plasmids in Escherichia coli K-12

Representative plasmids for most incompatibility groups in Escherichia coli K-12 were transferred to a "bald" strain to compare transfer frequencies for liquid and solid media. Standard broth matings were used for a liquid environment, but for solid surface mating, conjugation was allowed to take place on nutrient plates before washing off the cells for transconjugant selection on plates containing appropriate drugs. Plasmids that determine rigid pili transferred at least 2,000x better on plates than in broth. Some plasmids that determine thick flexible pili transferred 45 to 470x better, whereas others transferred equally well in both environments, as did plasmids of the I complex, which determine thin flexible pili. These results clearly distinguished a number of surface mating systems where most plasmids were derepressed for transfer and determined conjugative pili constitutively. The temperature-independent IncH2 plasmid R831b transferred best on plates, but other IncH plasmids transferred equally well in broth. This inconsistency led to the reclassification of R831b as IncM.     

Effect of lipopolysaccharide mutations on recipient ability of Salmonella typhimurium for incompatibility group H plasmids.

Previous investigations of the incompatibility group F, P, and I plasmid systems revealed the important role of the outer membrane components in the conjugal transfer of these plasmids. We have observed variability in transfer frequency of three incompatibility group H plasmids (IncHI1 plasmid R27, IncHI2 plasmid R478, and a Tn7 derivative of R27, pDT2454) upon transfer into various Salmonella typhimurium lipopolysaccharide (LPS) mutants derived from a common parental strain, SL1027. Recipients with truncated outer core via the rfaF LPS mutation increased the transfer frequency of the IncH plasmids by up to a factor of 10(3). Mutations which resulted in the truncation of the residues following 3-deoxy-D-manno-octulosonic acid, such as the rfaE and rfaD mutations, decreased the transfer frequency to undetectable levels. Addition of phosphorylethanolamine, a component of wild-type LPS, to the media decreased the frequency of transfer of R27 into wild-type and rfaF LPS mutant recipients tested. Reversing the direction of transfer, by mating LPS mutant donors with wild-type recipients, did not affect the frequency of transfer compared to the standard matings of wild-type donor with LPS mutant recipient. These findings demonstrate that conjugation interactions affected by LPS mutation are not specific for the recipient cell. Our results suggest that LPS mutation does not affect conjugation via altered pilus binding but affects some later steps in the conjugative process, and alteration of transfer frequency by O-phosphorylethanolamine and LPS truncation is due to charge-related interactions between the donor and recipient cell.     

Genetic analysis of transfer and incompatibility functions within the IncHI plasmid R27

This study was undertaken to establish a transfer complementation system for IncH plasmids and to locate regions of incompatibility within the HI1 plasmid, R27. Two regions of R27 were found to contribute to incompatibility as determined by incompatibility testing with fragments of R27 cloned in cosmid vectors. One of these regions hybridized with the IncHI1 rep probe (Couturier et al., Microbiol. Rev. 52, 375-395, 1988). Complementation analysis was carried out using transfer-deficient mutants of R27 in combination with pHH1508a. Cosmid vectors, which contained cloned restriction fragments of R27, were able to complement selected R27 Tra- mutants, enabling the transfer-deficient plasmid to transfer at near-normal frequencies. Complementation of R27 Tra- plasmids by pHH1508a at both 26 and 37 degrees C was shown to occur, but was host-dependent in its degree. These results suggest that the transfer mechanisms of IncHI and IncHII plasmids are related.     

A method of plasmid classification by integrative incompatibility

A method of plasmid classification by integrative incompatibility has been developed. The characteristics of this system are as follows: (i) The conventional plasmids usually used as standards for incompatibility grouping were integrated into the host chromosome to increase stability and to minimize recombination with the superinfecting plasmid. Strains were constructed by integrative suppression which was in some cases facilitated by the introduction of Tn5 into the plasmid. (ii) The resulting Hfr strains were made deficient in the rec A function to eliminate homologous recombination between the resident and the superinfecting plasmids. A test plasmid is introduced into these rec A Hfr test strains in the stationary phase of growth. In an incompatible cross, the number of transconjugant colonies was usually less than 10^?2 of that in a compatible cross. Occasionally, an inhibitory mechanism, other than incompatibility was coded by the resident plasmid [e.g., restriction in R124 (inc FIV)]. This complicated the interpretation, but did not invalidate the experiment. The colonies arising in incompatible crosses were shown to carry drug resistance determinants coded by both the resident and superinfecting plasmids. These were presumably the result of rec-independent integration of all or part of the superinfecting plasmid into the host chromosome. Thus the reduced frequency of superinfectant formation in an incompatible cross is usually the consequence of incompatibility between the resident and the superinfecting plasmids. This integrative incompatibility system should be useful for epidemiological studies of R plasmids.     

Molecular homology and incompatibility relationships between F and IncH1 plasmids

IncH1 plasmids and the F plasmid of Escherichia coli display one-way compatibility. An entering IncH1 plasmid is incompatible with a resident F plasmid, but is compatible when it is the resident plasmid. There is little molecular homology between IncH1 plasmids and the F plasmid. A single 5 MDal EcoRI restriction enzyme fragment from digests of several IncH1 plasmids hybridizes with probes constructed from the primary replication region of F. Homology can be demonstrated only with the gene for the essential replication protein of F (gene E), but the expression of incompatibility behaviour appears to be associated with the presence of the secondary replicon of the F plasmid. Thus R27 and F are compatible under growth conditions allowing replication and maintenance of F by the secondary replicon. However, a mutant F plasmid which lacks the secondary replicon of F is incompatible with R27 in both directions, irrespective of the growth conditions used.     

Incidence of plasmid DNA in Salmonella strains isolated from clinical sources in Ontario, Canada, during 1979 and 1980

Gel electrophoresis of DNA from 70 clinical strains of Salmonella revealed a heterogenous plasmid population. Plasmid DNA, ranging in molecular weight from 1.4 X 10(6) to 145 X 10(6), was demonstrated in 26 of 32 antibiotic-resistant strains. Several resistant strains carried up to six plasmids; however, of these, five strains which were multiply resistant contained a single plasmid of molecular weight 54 X 10(6) to 145 X 10(6). Only one incompatibility group H2 (IncH2) plasmid (pDT28) was detected in a strain of S. heidelberg; thus, this represents a reduction in the prevalence of these plasmids in Ontario Salmonella strains since 1974. The pDT28 plasmid resembled other IncH2 plasmids by its high molecular weight (145 X 10(6) ) and by virtue of its temperature-sensitive mode of transfer, resistance to tellurium, and inhibition of coliphage development. Of the 38 antibiotic-susceptible Salmonella strains, approximately half contained plasmids, ranging in molecular weight from 1.4 X 10(6) to 60 X 10(6). The plasmid-containing antibiotic-susceptible strains carried either a group of two to four small plasmids, with molecular weights less than 4.5 X 10(6), or a single large plasmid of molecular weight 23 X 10(6) or 60 X 10(6).     

IncH plasmids in Escherichia coli strains isolated from broiler chicken carcasses.

Plasmids conferring tellurite resistance were transferred at low temperature (27 degrees C) from Escherichia coli strains isolated from chicken carcasses at the time of slaughter and after storage. They belonged to group IncH, as evidenced by their large molecular weight and incompatibility with plasmid pIP233. E. coli strains contaminating chickens meat can thus represent a source of IncH plasmids in the food chain of humans.     

Temperature sensitive R plasmids isolated from Proteus strains.

Out of 32 R plasmids isolated from Proteus strains, 17 were found to be temperature sensitive with respect to inheritance in E. coli cells. They were fi- and classified into incompatibility group T or V. Cells carrying T group Rms273 plasmid were temperature sensitive with respect to growth and conjugal transfer in both E. coli and Proteus. The V group YOR-10 plasmid was stable in Proteus even at 42 C. However, the loss frequency of YOR-10 plasmid in E. coli reached 100% after 4 hr of incubation at 42 C, in spite of stable inheritance at 25 C. Conjugal transfer of the YOR-10 plasmid in E. coli was also strongly inhibited at 42 C. It has been concluded that instability of V group R plasmids in E. coli is due to their thermosensitive inheritance in the progeny cells at high temperatures.     

Inhibition and facilitation of transfer among Pseudomonas aeruginos R plasmids.

Esamining 12 plasmids in Pseudomonas aeruginosa, we found two types of interaction in their transfer (inhibition and facilitation), using donor cells carrying two compatible plasmids. (i) Ten plasmids representing incompatibility groups P-1, P-2, P-5, P-6, and P-7 were all transmissible at a high frequency, 10-2 to 10-1, except for one with a lower frequency of about 10-3. The transfer of P-5 plasmids was inhibited by P-2 plasmids reciprocally or unilaterally, and the unilateral transfer inhibition was observed in other combinations between plasmids belonging to groups P-1, P-2, P-6, and P-7. It was characteristic of Pseudomonas plasmids that most plasmids with high transferability inhibited the transfer of other coexisting plasmids without distinct inhibition of their own transfer. (ii) Two plasmids, Rms149 of P-8 group and Rlb679, which was not classified, were transmissible at an exceptionally low frequency of 10-7 to 10-6, but their transfer was facilitated by plasmids with high transferability.     

IncH plasmids in Escherichia coli strains isolated from broiler chicken carcasses

Plasmids conferring tellurite resistance were transferred at low temperature (27 degrees C) from Escherichia coli strains isolated from chicken carcasses at the time of slaughter and after storage. They belonged to group IncH, as evidenced by their large molecular weight and incompatibility with plasmid pIP233. E. coli strains contaminating chickens meat can thus represent a source of IncH plasmids in the food chain of humans.     

Capacity of aquatic bacteria to act as recipients of plasmid DNA.

A total of 68 gram-negative freshwater bacterial isolates were screened for their ability to receive and express plasmids from Pseudomonas aeruginosa donors. The plate mating technique identified 26 of the isolates as recipient active for the self-transmissible wide-host-range plasmid R68; 10 were recipient active by R68 mobilization for the wide-host-range plasmid cloning vector R1162. Frequencies of transfer were compared by using three conjugal transfer procedures: broth, plate, and filter mating. For every recipient tested, a solid environment was superior to a liquid environment for transfer. The broth mating technique failed to demonstrate R68 transfer in 63% of the recipient-active isolates. Filter mating, in general, yielded the highest transfer frequencies. The more-rapid plate mating procedure, however, was just as sensitive for testing the capacity of natural isolates to participate in conjugal plasmid transfer.     

Capacity of aquatic bacteria to act as recipients of plasmid DNA

A total of 68 gram-negative freshwater bacterial isolates were screened for their ability to receive and express plasmids from Pseudomonas aeruginosa donors. The plate mating technique identified 26 of the isolates as recipient active for the self-transmissible wide-host-range plasmid R68; 10 were recipient active by R68 mobilization for the wide-host-range plasmid cloning vector R1162. Frequencies of transfer were compared by using three conjugal transfer procedures: broth, plate, and filter mating. For every recipient tested, a solid environment was superior to a liquid environment for transfer. The broth mating technique failed to demonstrate R68 transfer in 63% of the recipient-active isolates. Filter mating, in general, yielded the highest transfer frequencies. The more-rapid plate mating procedure, however, was just as sensitive for testing the capacity of natural isolates to participate in conjugal plasmid transfer.     

Relationships between autonomous and integrated forms of tetracycline resistance plasmid in Staphylococcus aureus.

Recombinant plasmids carrying apparently the complete genome of a small staphylococcal plasmid, pT181, or of its temperature-sensitive replication mutant, pSA0301, were isolated and characterized; in these recombinants, pT181 or pSA0301 were considered as “integrated” into the other plasmid, inasmuch as they seem to have a subsidiary role in the replication of the respective recombinant plasmids. Using these recombinants, the incompatibility relationships between integrated and autonomous forms of the same plasmid were studied. The results obtained showed that, although integrated plasmids express their incompatibility toward autonomous ones, they are not susceptible to the incompatibility manifested by an autonomous or another integrated plasmid. No differences were observed between pT181 and pSA0301 in their response to the incompatibility manifested by recombinant plasmids. The expression of the incompatibility of an integrated plasmid did not require the function of the repC gene, involved in plasmid autonomous replication. Moreover, the pT181 repC⁺ gene seems not to be expressed when pT181 is integrated into another plasmid in that the integrated form does not complement autonomous pSA0301 for replication at nonpermissive temperature.     

Interactions between octopine and nopaline plasmids in Agrobacterium tumefaciens.

Transfer of octopine Ti plasmids to strains already carrying an octopine Ti plasmid was found to occur at the same (high) frequency as transfer to Ti plasmid lacking recipients, showing that resident Ti plasmids do not exhibit entry exclusion towards incoming Ti plasmids. The resident octopine Ti plasmid was lost by the recipient after the entrance of the incoming Ti plasmid, which is indicative of the incompatibility between the Ti plasmids. Octopine Ti plasmids were found to become established only infrequently in recipients with a nopaline Ti plasmid and, vice versa, nopaline Ti plasmids were only rarely established in recipients with an octopine Ti plasmid. Rare clones in which the incoming octopine (nopaline) Ti plasmid had been established despite the presence of a nopaline (octopine) Ti plasmid appeared to harbor cointegrates consisting of the entire incoming Ti plasmid and the entire resident Ti plasmid. The integration event invariably had occurred in a region of the plasmids that is highly conserved in evolution and that is essential for oncogenicity. These results show that octopine and nopaline Ti plasmids cannot be maintained as separate replicons by one and the same cell. Therefore, be definition, these plasmids belong to the same incompatibility group, which has been names inc Rh-1. Agrobacterial non-Ti octopine and nopaline plasmids were found to belong to another incompatibility group. The tumorigenic properties of strains harboring two different Ti plasmids, in a cointegrate structure, were indicative of the virulence genes of both of them being expressed. The agrobacterial non-Ti octopine and nopaline plasmids did not influence the virulence properties encoded by the Ti plasmid.     

Transfer-defective and tetracycline-sensitive mutants of the incompatibility group HI plasmid R27 generated by insertion of transposon 7

Transposon Tn7 insertion was used to obtain either transfer-defective (Tra-) or tetracycline-sensitive (Tc-) mutants of the HI incompatibility group (IncHI) plasmid R27. The 600 apparent R27::Tn7 derivatives fell into three classes: Tra-, Tc-, and Tra- Tc-. Mutants of R27 defective in the thermosensitive mode of transfer characteristic of IncH plasmids were obtained with transfer frequencies of less than 1 X 10(-8) transconjugants per recipient after 18 hr at 26 degrees C. These mutants, which were generated at a frequency of 1 per 100 insertions, were nonleaky and nonrevertible. Tc- mutants of R27, generated at a frequency of 0.5 per 100 insertions, were also nonrevertible. Loss of tetracycline resistance was associated with an increased frequency of transfer (average 3.6 X 10(-3) transconjugants per donor per hour at 30 degrees C) compared with transfer of the wild-type R27 plasmid (1.6 X 10(-8) per donor per hour). Tn7 insertions which generated Tc- or Tra- mutants of R27 had no effect on entry exclusion of other H group plasmids. The molecular weights of Tra- and Tc- R27::Tn7 derivatives were approximately 120.5 MDa, corresponding to the sum of R27 (112 MDa) and Tn7 (8.5 MDa). A third class of Tn7 insertion derivatives (Tra- Tc-) was obtained; however, strains expressing this phenotype were plasmid free, and appeared to have Tn7 integrated at a chromosomal site. Restriction digestion with XbaI and subsequent hybridization with ColE1::Tn7 were used to compare R27::Tn7 derivatives and to locate Tn7 insertion sites. Loss of tetracycline resistance was associated with Tn7 insertion into a 24-kb XbaI fragment of R27. Although loss of plasmid transfer in several R27::Tn7 derivatives was accompanied by insertion of Tn7 into a 14-kb XbaI fragment of the plasmid, these mutants had also undergone a small increase in the size of the 24-kb XbaI fragment of R27.     

Identification of regions of the Streptococcus faecalis plasmid pCF-10 that encode antibiotic resistance and pheromone response functions

The conjugative plasmid pCF-10 (58 kb) of Streptococcus faecalis has been mapped with restriction enzymes. By restriction mapping and Southern hybridization analysis, a 16-kb segment of the plasmid was shown to resemble closely the conjugative tetracycline resistance transposon, Tn916. Mutagenesis of the plasmid with the erythromycin resistance transposon Tn917 was used to localize a tetracycline resistance determinant and several regions involved in conjugal transfer. Fifty Tn917 insertions (outside the region of the plasmid homologous to Tn916) affecting mating behavior and the ability of donor cells to respond to the sex pheromone cCF-10 were mapped to nine distinct segments, or tra regions. Insertions into tra regions 1-3 and 7-9 led to an enhanced transfer ability of mutant plasmids relative to the transfer frequency obtained for the wild-type plasmid. Cells carrying these mutant plasmids differed in colony morphology or growth in broth culture from cells carrying pCF-10. Insertions into tra regions 4-6 resulted in reduced plasmid transfer, or completely eliminated the mating potential of donor cells. Insertions generating transfer-defective plasmids could be grouped further according to the ability of strains harboring the mutant plasmids to respond to cCF-10. HindIII fragments of pCF-10 coding for transfer functions have been cloned into Escherichia coli.     

The complete nucleotide sequence of the resistance plasmid R478: defining the backbone components of incompatibility group H conjugative plasmids through comparative genomics

Horizontal transfer of resistance determinants amongst bacteria can be achieved by conjugative plasmid DNA elements. We have determined the complete 274,762 bp sequence of the incompatibility group H (IncH) plasmid R478, originally isolated from the Gram negative opportunistic pathogen Serratia marcescens. This self-transferable extrachromosomal genetic element contains 295 predicted genes, of which 144 are highly similar to coding sequences of IncH plasmids R27 and pHCM1. The regions of similarity among these three IncH plasmids principally encode core plasmid determinants (i.e., replication, partitioning and stability, and conjugative transfer) and we conducted a comparative analysis to define the minimal IncHI plasmid backbone determinants. No resistance determinants are included in the backbone and most of the sequences unique to R478 were contained in a large contiguous region between the two transfer regions. These findings indicate that plasmid evolution occurs through gene acquisition/loss predominantly in regions outside of the core determinants. Furthermore, a modular evolution for R478 was signified by the presence of gene neighbors or operons that were highly related to sequences from a wide range of chromosomal, transposon, and plasmid elements. The conjugative transfer regions are most similar to sequences encoded on SXT, Rts1, pCAR1, R391, and pRS241d. The dual partitioning modules encoded on R478 resemble numerous sequences; including pMT1, pCTX-M3, pCP301, P1, P7, and pB171. R478 also codes for resistance to tetracycline (Tn10), chloramphenicol (cat), kanamycin (aphA), mercury (similar to Tn21), silver (similar to pMG101), copper (similar to pRJ1004), arsenic (similar to pYV), and tellurite (two separate regions similar to IncHI2 ter determinants and IncP kla determinants). Other R478-encoded sequences are related to Tn7, IS26, tus, mucAB, and hok, where the latter is surrounded by insLKJ, and could potentially be involved in post-segregation killing. The similarity to a diverse set of bacterial sequences highlights the ability of horizontally transferable DNA elements to acquire and disseminate genetic traits through the bacterial gene pool.     

Partition-associated incompatibility caused by random assortment of pure plasmid clusters

Summary Bacterial plasmids and chromosomes encode centromere-like partition loci that actively segregate DNA before cell division. The molecular mechanism behind DNA segregation in bacteria is largely unknown. Here we analyse the mechanism of partition-associated incompatibility for plasmid pB171, a phenotype associated with all known plasmid-encoded centromere loci. An R1 plasmid carrying par2 from plasmid pB171 was destabilized by the presence of an F plasmid carrying parC1, parC2 or the entire par2 locus of pB171. Strikingly, cytological double-labelling experiments revealed no evidence of long-lived pairing of plasmids. Instead, pure R1 and F foci were positioned along the length of the cell, and in a random order. Thus, our results raise the possibility that partition-mediated plasmid incompatibility is not caused by pairing of heterologous plasmids but instead by random positioning of pure plasmid clusters along the long axis of the cell. The strength of the incompatibility was correlated with the capability of the plasmids to compete for the mid-cell position.