Inhibition of copepod feeding by exudates and transparent exopolymer particles (TEP) derived from a Phaeocystis globosa dominated phytoplankton community

We investigated if (1) dissolved compounds excreted by Phaeocystis globosa and (2) transparent exopolymer particles (TEP) formed from carbohydrates excreted into the water affect the feeding of nauplii and females of the calanoid copepod Temora longicornis during a P. globosa bloom. Copepod grazing on the diatom Thalassiosira weissflogii in the presence of these possible grazing deterrents was measured during three successive weeks of a mesocosm study, simulating the development of a P. globosa bloom. Our results demonstrate no indication for the presence of feeding deterrents in the dissolved phase, but a strong inhibitory effect of transparent exopolymer particles (TEP) on the consumption of algae by both nauplii and adult copepods. The inhibitory effect of TEP was connected to the accumulation of DOM during the progress of the bloom. We suggest that a reduction in the grazing pressure of zooplankton may increase the survival of the liberated single cells during disruption of colonies and allow seeding populations to persist. Furthermore, P. globosa reduces the trophic efficiency of the food web not only by withdrawal of its colonies from grazing but also by a relaxation of the grazing pressure on co-occurring phytoplankton and by alteration of the food web structure via TEP production.     

Dynamics of transparent exopolymeric particles (TEP) production by Phaeocystis globosa under N- or P-limitation: a controlling factor of the retention/export balance

The concentration of transparent exopolymeric particles (TEP) was monitored during Phaeocystis globosa blooms that developed in mesocosms under different initial N:P ratios (from N- to P-limited conditions). TEP concentration was measured using the microscopic (TEP_micro, ppm) and the colorimetric (TEP_color, Xanthan equiv. L⁻¹) methods. TEP concentrations varied from 5 to >75 ppm and from 60 to >1500 μg Xanthan equiv. L⁻¹, and were relatively low until the mesocosms reached nutrient (either N or P) depletion and then increased abruptly. From the TEP_micro versus TEP_color concentrations comparison and from their relation to chlorophyll a concentrations, two phases for the dynamics of TEP production were identified: (1) production through active release of precursors during the growth phase of P. globosa — defined as TEP₁ — and their integration into the TEP pool through coagulation processes; (2) release of large TEP from the mucilaginous matrix of P. globosa colonies subsequent to disruption caused by nutrient depletion — defined as TEP₂ — and their direct integration into the TEP pool outside the constraint of coagulation. The formation of a multiorigin TEP pool during P. globosa blooms may have implications for the fate of the blooms, due to difference in TEP bioreactivity according to their source and to difference in timing and intensity of TEP₁ versus TEP₂ production according to N- or P-depletion. For P. globosa blooms developing under N-limiting conditions, the transition from the first source (i.e. TEP₁) to the second one (i.e. TEP₂) was a slow and continuous process. In contrast, the P. globosa bloom developing under P-limiting conditions showed the sudden formation of heavy mucous aggregates when P became depleted, that may have been caused by a massive release of TEP₂. Our study suggests that the nutrient regime may control the export vs. retention balance during P. globosa blooms, via production of a multiorigin TEP pool.     

A mesocosm study of Phaeocystis globosa population dynamics: I. Regulatory role of viruses in bloom control

The regulatory role of viruses on population dynamics of the prymnesiophyte Phaeocystis globosa was studied during a mesocosm experiment in relation to growth and loss by microzooplankton grazing and cell lysis. The mesocosms were conducted under varying light conditions (20 and 150 μmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹) and nutrient regime (inorganic nitrogen to phosphorus ratios of 4, 16 and 44). Overall, viruses infecting P. globosa (PgV) were found to be an important cause of cell lysis (30–100% of total lysis) and a significant loss factor (7–67% of total loss). We demonstrate that the morphology of P. globosa cells (solitary versus colonial) differently regulated viral control of P. globosa bloom formation. Reduced irradiance (20 μmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹) was provided for 11 days to select for the solitary cell morphotype. Viruses were able to restrict P. globosa bloom formation even after irradiance became saturating again (150 μmol photons m⁻² s⁻¹). Saturating light conditions from the start of the experiment allowed colony formation and because the colony-morphotype acted as a mechanism reducing viral infection bloom formation succeeded. Nutrient depletion, however, affected specifically the colonies that disintegrated while releasing single cells. Virus infection of these solitary cells resulted in the termination of the bloom. The nature of phytoplankton growth-limiting nutrient (nitrate and/or orthophosphate) did not seem to noticeably affect the level of viral control.     

Selective grazing of Temora longicornis in different stages of a Phaeocystis globosa bloom—a mesocosm study

Selective grazing of a calanoid copepod Temora longicornis was measured during different stages of a Phaeocystis globosa bloom, in order to reveal (1) if T. longicornis feeds on single cells and/or colonies of P. globosa in the presence of alternative food sources, (2) if copepod food selection changes during the initiation, maintenance, collapse and decay of a P. globosa bloom and (3) if P. globosa dominated food assemblage provides a good diet for copepod egg production. Our results show low but constant feeding on small colonies of P. globosa, irrespective of the type or concentration of alternative food sources. In contrast, feeding on single cells was never significant, and the total contribution of P. globosa to carbon ingestion of T. longicornis was minor. T. longicornis fed most actively on the decaying colonies, whereas during the peak of the bloom copepods selected against P. globosa. Mostly, T. longicornis fed unselectively on different food particles: before the bloom, the major part of the diet consisted of diatoms, whereas during and after the bloom copepod diet was dominated by dinoflagellates and ciliates. Egg production was highest during the decay of the bloom, coinciding with highest proportional ingestion of heterotrophic organisms, but was not seriously reduced even during the peak of the bloom. We conclude that P. globosa blooms should not threaten survival of copepod populations, but the population recruitment may depend on the type (and concentration) of the dominant heterotrophs present during the blooms. Due to relatively unselective grazing, the impact of T. longicornis to the initiation of a Phaeocystis bloom is considered small, although grazing on decaying colonies may contribute to the faster termination of a bloom.     

Living in a Phaeocystis colony: a way to be a successful algal species

Evidence is provided showing that in two species of Phaeocystis (P. globosa and P. pouchetii) the colonial cells possess a much higher growth rate than the single cells when grown under identical conditions. Based on the DNA-cell-cycle method gross growth rate of colony cells exceeded those of co-occurring single cells by a factor 1.5 up to 3.8. The dominance of colonies in blooms of Phaeocystis can therefore be primarily due to their significantly high growth rate allowing a rapid bloom formation.Both Phaeocystis species showed ultradian growth but differed in timing of the initiation of the second DNA replication phase. In both species the first DNA-replication period started at the end of the (local) light period and was completed in the early dark period. In P. globosa this was immediately followed by the second DNA-replication period (first half of the dark period). In P. pouchetii this process was delayed by ca. 12 h until the middle of the light period (local noon).Flow cytometric analysis of the cell size and chlorophyll fluorescence showed little variation in colony and single cells of P. pouchetii. In contrast, colonies of P. globosa showed often the presence of two cell morphs, co-occurring in the same colony. The size of both morphs was identical but they differed in chlorophyll fluorescence up to a factor 4. In general the high chlorophyll cell morph dominated (>70% of the total colony cells). Both colony cell morphs were observed in cultures, mesocosms differing in N/P ratio but also in the field.     

STUDIES ON TRANSPARENT EXOPOLYMER PARTICLES (TEP) PRODUCED IN THE ROSS SEA (ANTARCTICA) AND BY PHAEOCYSTIS ANTARCTICA (PRYMNESIOPHYCEAE)1

The distribution and production of transparent exopolymer particles (TEPs) were studied quantitatively both in cultures of Phaeocystis antarctica Karsten (Prymnesiophyceae) and in natural phytoplankton assemblages in the Ross Sea, Antarctica. TEP production in culture was a function of growth rate and photosynthetic activity and was strongly influenced by photon flux density. The concentrations of TEP measured during a bloom, dominated by P. antarctica, were higher than those produced by coastal diatom blooms and were correlated with chlorophyll a (Chl a), being low at Chl a levels below 3 μgL^?1 but increasing rapidly at greater Chl a concentrations. Because higher chlorophyll hek are dominated 4 larger P. antarctica colonies, this relationship suggests that TEP was produced primarily by sloughing and disintegration of the colonial matrix. TEP concentrations (both absolute and relative to Chl a) increased as the bloom's biomass increased. Vertical distributions of TEP and Chl a showed TEP: chlorophyll maxima at the bottom of the water column at most stations. Because TEP and floc formation are tightly coupled, we suggest that mucous flocs derived from TEP, rather than intact P. antarctica colonies, are the dominant component of aggregates and subsequent organic carbon vertical flux.     

Release and degradation of amnesic shellfish poison from decaying Pseudo-nitzschia multiseries in presence of bacteria and organic matter

Domoic acid (DA), the neurotoxin produced by diatoms such as Pseudo-nitzschia multiseries is water-soluble and can bioaccumulate, causing mass death of birds and marine mammals worldwide. Humans eating contaminated shellfish most commonly suffer from memory loss but mortalities have been recorded. The fate of particulate and dissolved DA released from the cells or added as standards was studied when incubated with different bacterial abundances, copepod faecal pellets, mussel pseudo-faeces and bottom sediment. Strains of P. multiseries from Canada and Brazil were grown in non-axenic continuous monocultures with different nutrient conditions, or in a follow-up mesocosm experiment. Incubation lasted up to 75 days in the dark under quiescent conditions after the cells had been killed. Release of DA from decaying cells did not depend on bacterial abundance when the bacterial source was cultures of P. multiseries, and the dissolved toxin was stable with bacteria from P. multiseries cultures (at least 20 days with 1× or 4× bacterial concentration), or with a naturally occurring density of bacteria from surface waters of a known P. multiseries bloom area (35 days). However, four-fold concentration of the natural bacterial consortium from the bloom site reduced the onset of DA degradation to 16 days. Thus, this study suggests that when testing toxin degradation by bacteria, it is important to use bacterial consortia from known bloom areas of Pseudo-nitzschia. Copepod faecal pellets did not affect DA degradation, whereas the presence of mussel pseudo-faeces and bottom sediment rapidly removed most of the toxin. We believe that the rapid removal of DA in the two latter treatments was due to higher bacterial abundance and the presence of enzymes from the mussels and/or associated bacteria that are important for the degradation process. The mechanisms underlying the observed effects on DA degradation with mussel pseudo-faeces and sediment require further research, but suggest interesting possibilities as a potential future mitigation technique.     

Long-term development of the crustacean plankton in the Saidenbach Reservoir (Germany) – changes,causes, consequences

The rates of development and food intake of the copepod Temora longicornis (Müller) were studied using artificial blooms of Phaeocystis globosa Scherffel under different conditions of nutrient limitation. Mesocosms with 800 l of natural seawater were manipulated by inoculation with cultured P. globosa and by addition of nitrogen and/or phosphorus, to obtain N- or P-limited blooms of P. globosa. During development and ageing of these blooms, water from the mesocosms was used as medium for incubation of nauplii of T. longicornis. Only moderate rates of naupliar development as well as high rates of mortality were observed, irrespective of major differences of nutrient conditions and density of P. globosa. Grazing by the nauplii on P. globosa seemed to be low, suggesting a low food quality of this alga at all physiological conditions studied. The results of this study indicate a low capability of T. longicornis nauplii for control of nuisance algal blooms caused by P. globosa.     

Differentiation betweenPhaeocystis pouchetii (Har.) Lagerheim andPhaeocystis globosa Scherffel

An Arctic clone ofPhaeocystis pouchetii LAGERHEIM was compared toPhaeocystis globosa SCHERFFEL isolated from the southern North Sea with regard to temperature tolerance and colony shapes. Already youngP.pouchetii colonies (<100 m) show the typical distribution of the cells in groups, separated from each other by wide zones of cell-free mucilage; the maximum colony size is ca 2 mm in diameter.P.pouchetii colonies form clouds with bubble-like vesicles, spherical colony-shapes are seldom found.P.globosa colonies are spherical up to a size of 2 mm; the cells are distributed homogeneously over the periphery of the colonies. A pouchetii-like distribution of cells never occurs either in the spherical young colonies or in the pear-shaped old colonies (size up to 8 mm). A development from the colony shape of the globosa-type to the pouchetii-type or vice versa was never found. Therefore the colony shape has to be considered a constant distinctive character. Single cells ofP.pouchetii andP.globosa cannot be separated from each other by using the light microscope; this also holds for the flagellates and the non-motile cells.P.pouchetii grows well between 0°C and 14°C,P.globosa between 4°C and 22°C, respectively. Because of the distinctive differences in the morphology of the colonies and the differences in temperature tolerances we propose thatPhaeocystis globosa should no longer be considered conspecific withPhaeocystis pouchetii.     

The influence of Phaeocystis globosa on microscale spatial patterns of chlorophyll a and bulk-phase seawater viscosity

A two-dimensional microscale (5 cm resolution) sampler was used over the course of a phytoplankton spring bloom dominated by Phaeocystis globosa to investigate the structural properties of chlorophyll a and seawater excess viscosity distributions. The microscale distribution patterns of chlorophyll a and excess viscosity were never uniform nor random. Instead they exhibited different types and levels of aggregated spatial patterns that were related to the dynamics of the bloom. The chlorophyll a and seawater viscosity correlation patterns were also controlled by the dynamics of the bloom with positive and negative correlations before and after the formation of foam in the turbulent surf zone. The ecological relevance and implications of the observed patchiness and biologically induced increase in seawater viscosity are discussed and the combination of the enlarged colonial form and mucus secretion is suggested as a competitive advantage of P. globosa in highly turbulent environments where this species flourishes.     

The contribution of single and colonial cells of Phaeocystis pouchetii to spring and summer blooms in the north-eastern North Atlantic

Studies of the phytoplankton ecology in different localities in north-Norwegian fjords, the White Sea and the Barents Sea were carried out in spring and early summer to investigate the contribution of single and colonial stages of Phaeocystis pouchetii to phytoplankton abundance. Three different types of flagellated and four colonial cells were observed in all localities. P. pouchetii was rare under the ice of the Barents and White Seas, but their abundance increased rapidly during ice retreat. Single cell C dominated over colonial cell C, often by 50 times or more. The highest share of colonial cells was encountered in April in northern Norwegian fjords, in May in the Barents Sea and in May–June in the White Sea. At times the single cell dominated the total P. pouchetii biomass in Balsfjord (April 1999, 2001) with hardly any colonies present. In the White Sea colonies of P. pouchetii were less abundant than in the other regions. Cell carbon of P. pouchetii colonies appears never to be as dominating in the north-eastern North Atlantic as P. globosa blooms in coastal regions such as the southern North Sea. However, the lobal matrix of P. pouchetii colonies appears to be less solid than that of P. globosa and partly dissolution of the colony matrix during handling and storage of fixes samples induces uncertainty about the absolute numbers of P. pouchetii colonial cell counts. Despite of that, single cells of P. pouchetii seem to dominate significantly over colonial cell biomass at most sites and during some years and in some regions colonial cells seem rare. We speculate that top-down regulation of Phaeocystis spp. blooms possibly determines the ratio between single and colonial cells.     

Responses of the coastal bacterial community to viral infection of the algae Phaeocystis globosa

The release of organic material upon algal cell lyses has a key role in structuring bacterial communities and affects the cycling of biolimiting elements in the marine environment. Here we show that already before cell lysis the leakage or excretion of organic matter by infected yet intact algal cells shaped North Sea bacterial community composition and enhanced bacterial substrate assimilation. Infected algal cultures of Phaeocystis globosa grown in coastal North Sea water contained gamma- and alphaproteobacterial phylotypes that were distinct from those in the non-infected control cultures 5 h after infection. The gammaproteobacterial population at this time mainly consisted of Alteromonas sp. cells that were attached to the infected but still intact host cells. Nano-scale secondary-ion mass spectrometry (nanoSIMS) showed ∼20% transfer of organic matter derived from the infected ¹³C- and ¹⁵N-labelled P. globosa cells to Alteromonas sp. cells. Subsequent, viral lysis of P. globosa resulted in the formation of aggregates that were densely colonised by bacteria. Aggregate dissolution was observed after 2 days, which we attribute to bacteriophage-induced lysis of the attached bacteria. Isotope mass spectrometry analysis showed that 40% of the particulate ¹³C-organic carbon from the infected P. globosa culture was remineralized to dissolved inorganic carbon after 7 days. These findings reveal a novel role of viruses in the leakage or excretion of algal biomass upon infection, which provides an additional ecological niche for specific bacterial populations and potentially redirects carbon availability.     

CURRENT KNOWLEDGE OF THE LIFE CYCLES OF PHAEOCYSTIS GLOBOSA AND PHAEOCYSTIS ANTARCTICA (PRYMNESIOPHYCEAE)1

Despite continuous efforts since the 1950s and more recent advances in culturing flagellates and nonflagellate cells of the prymnesiophyte Phaeocystis, a number of different life‐cycle models exist today that appear to apply for P. globosa Scherff. and P. antarctica G. Karst., both spherical colony formers. In one such model, this life cycle consists of three different flagellates and one nonmotile cell stage that is embedded in carbohydrate matrix‐forming colonies of different sizes and forms. Recently, noncolonial aggregates of diploid nonmotile cells attached to surfaces of diatoms were put forward as a new stage in the sexual life cycle of P. antarctica. However, it can be discussed that these “attached aggregates” (AAs) are an intermediate between motile diploid flagellates, with their well‐known tendency to adhere to surfaces, and the young spherical colony with its diploid nonmotile cells, which in nature is commonly found attached to diatoms. A life‐cycle model pertaining to both P. globosa and P. antarctica is presented.     

The effect of elevated CO2 on the production and respiration of a Sargassum thunbergii community: A mesocosm study

Approximately one‐third of anthropogenic carbon dioxide is absorbed into the ocean and causes it to become more acidic. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) suggested that the surface ocean pH, by the year 2100, would drop by a further 0.3 and 0.4 pH units under RCP (Representative Concentration Pathway) 6.0 and 8.5 climate scenarios. The macroalgae communities that consisted of Sargassum thunbergii and naturally attached epibionts were exposed to fluctuations of ambient and manipulated pH (0.3–0.4 units below ambient pH). The production and respiration in S. thunbergii communities were calculated from dissolved oxygen time‐series recorded with optical dissolved oxygen sensors. The pH, irradiance, and dissolved oxygen occurred in parallel with diurnal (day/night) patterns. According to net mesocosm production – photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) model, the saturation and compensation PAR, the mean maximum gross mesocosm production (GMP), and daily mesocosm respiration were higher in the CO₂ enrichment, than in the ambient condition, while the mean of photosynthetic coefficient was similar. In conclusion, elevated CO₂ stimulated oxygen production and consumption of S. thunbergii communities in the mesocosm. Furthermore, the sensitivity of the GMP of the S. thunbergii community to irradiance was reduced, and achieved maximum production rate at higher PAR. These positive responses to CO₂ enrichment suggest that S. thunbergii communities may thrive in under high CO₂ conditions.     

摄食信息对球形棕囊藻和布氏双尾藻竞争结果的影响

浮游动物的摄食信息能增大棕囊藻囊体体积,囊体形成被认为是棕囊藻的诱导性防御机制。利用桡足类火腿伪镖水蚤和异养甲藻海洋尖尾藻释放的摄食信息,研究了诱导性防御对球形棕囊藻和布氏双尾藻的竞争的影响。结果表明,球形棕囊藻接收了火腿伪镖水蚤和海洋尖尾藻释放的摄食信息之后形成更大的囊体。防御启动后的球形棕囊藻比未接收摄食信息的球形棕囊藻更快地形成囊体,且囊体维持的时间更长。对照组和火腿伪镖水蚤摄食信息诱导的球形棕囊藻的生物体积比布氏双尾藻更高,且球形棕囊藻在竞争中占优势;而海洋尖尾藻摄食信息诱导的球形棕囊藻生物体积低于布氏双尾藻,且球形棕囊藻相对布氏双尾藻的竞争力下降。微型浮游动物海洋尖尾藻摄食信息导致球形棕囊藻相对硅藻布氏双尾藻的竞争力的下降,有利于解释硅藻先于棕囊藻发生藻华。     

Viral attack exacerbates the susceptibility of a bloom‐forming alga to ocean acidification

Both ocean acidification and viral infection bring about changes in marine phytoplankton physiological activities and community composition. However, little information is available on how the relationship between phytoplankton and viruses may be affected by ocean acidification and what impacts this might have on photosynthesis‐driven marine biological CO₂ pump. Here, we show that when the harmful bloom alga Phaeocystis globosa is infected with viruses under future ocean conditions, its photosynthetic performance further decreased and cells became more susceptible to stressful light levels, showing enhanced photoinhibition and reduced carbon fixation, up‐regulation of mitochondrial respiration and decreased virus burst size. Our results indicate that ocean acidification exacerbates the impacts of viral attack on P. globosa, which implies that, while ocean acidification directly influences marine primary producers, it may also affect them indirectly by altering their relationship with viruses. Therefore, viruses as a biotic stressor need to be invoked when considering the overall impacts of climate change on marine productivity and carbon sequestration.     

Methods used to reveal genetic diversity in the colony-forming prymnesiophytes Phaeocystis antarctica, P. globosa and P. pouchetii—preliminary results

Previous work on the genetic diversity of Phaeocystis used ribosomal DNA and internal transcribed spacer (ITS) sequence analyses to show that there is substantial inter- and intraspecific variation within the genus. First attempts to trace the biogeographical history of strains in Antarctic coastal waters were based on a comparison of ITS sequences. To gain deeper insights into the population structure and bloom dynamics of this microalga it is necessary to quantify the genetic diversity within populations of P. antarctica from different locations (i.e., each of the three major gyres in the Antarctic continental waters) and to calculate the gene flow between them. Here we describe methods to quantify genetic diversity and our preliminary results for P. antarctica in comparison to two other colonial species: P. globosa and P. pouchetii. For this study of genetic diversity, two fingerprinting techniques were used. First, amplified fragment-length polymorphisms (AFLPs) were established as a pre-screening tool to assess clone diversity and to select divergent clones prior to physiological investigations. Second, the more-powerful microsatellite markers were established to assess population structure and biogeography more accurately. Results show differences in the AFLP patterns between isolates of P. antarctica from different regions, and that a wide variety of microsatellite motifs could be obtained from the three Phaeocystis species.     

Effects of light on nitrogen and carbon uptake during a Prorocentrum minimum bloom

During a 4-week period in late spring 1998 an extensive Prorocentrum minimum (Pavillard) Schiller bloom developed in several tributaries of the Chesapeake Bay. Experiments were carried out in one of these tributaries using ¹³C and ¹⁵N isotopic techniques to characterize C and N uptake as a function of irradiance during the course of this bloom. Uptake rates of N substrates (NO₃⁻, NH₄⁺, urea, and an amino acid mixture) and C substrates (bicarbonate and urea) were measured. For each N substrate, short-term uptake rates (0.5 h) were not substantially different over the irradiance range measured, suggesting that N uptake of this dinoflagellate was not strongly light-dependent over this time scale. Dark uptake rates of all N substrates ranged between 35 and 113% of light uptake rates. Over the duration of the P. minimum bloom, however, total ambient N uptake rates increased with increasing natural irradiance. Uptake of bicarbonate showed typical light-dependent photosynthetic characteristics and the measured photosynthetic parameters suggested that at least on the short time scale (0.5 h), P. minimum cells were adapted to high light. Rates of C uptake from the substrate urea were minimal, <1% of total C uptake from photosynthesis, but doubled over the course of the bloom, and like N uptake, were not strongly light-dependent on the short time scale (0.5 h). Significant N dark uptake by P. minimum was likely to have been important by providing N sources over the daily scale to sustain the bloom.     

Differential Photosynthetic Acclimation Pattern to Limiting Growth-Irradiance in Two Types of C4 Plants

Photosynthetic acclimation to reduced growth irradiances (650 and 200 µmol m^–2 s^–1) in Eleusine coracana (L.) Garten, a nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide-malic enzyme (NAD-ME) C₄ species and Gomphrena globosa L., a nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate-malic enzyme (NADP-ME) C₄ species were investigated. E. coracana plants acclimated in 4 and 8 d to 650 and 200 µmol m^–2 s^–1, respectively, whereas G. globosa plants took 8 and 10 d, respectively, to acclimate to the same irradiances. The acclimation to reduced irradiance was achieved in both species by greater partitioning of chlorophyll towards the light-harvesting antennae at the expense of functional components. However, magnitude of increase in the light-harvesting antenna was higher in E. coracana as compared to G. globosa. Superior photosynthetic acclimation to reduced irradiance in G. globosa was due to the smaller change in functions of the cytochrome b ₆/f complex, photosystem (PS) 1 and PS2 leading to the higher carbon fixation rates compared to E. coracana.