Correlation of enzyme thermostability and its surface hydrophobicity (using a modified alpha-chymotrypsin as an example)

Basing on the hypothesis that contact of hydrophobic surface clusters of proteins with water is thermodynamically disadvantageous, it is suggested to carry out the hydrophilization of protein surface by covalent modification in order to increase its thermostability. Hydrophilic fragments were introduced into the surface of alpha-chymotrypsin using acylation by anhydrides of aromatic carboxylic acids and reductive alkylation by aliphatic aldehydes. As a result of the hydrophilization the stability of the enzyme against irreversible thermoinactivation increased thousand-fold. The correlation is observed between the degree of hydrophilization of the protein surface and the increase in thermostability of modified alpha-chymotrypsin. The level of thermostability achieved by covalent modification of alpha-chymotrypsin is practically equal to thermostability of proteinases from extreme thermophiles, the most stable proteolytic enzymes currently known.     

Regulation of thermal stability of enzymes by changing the composition of media. Native and modified alpha-chymotrypsin

Stabilizing effect of denaturing salts on irreversible thermoinactivation of native and modified alpha-chymotrypsin at elevated temperatures is observed. The effect is caused by a shift of conformational equilibrium, at the primary step of reversible unfolding in the course of thermoinactivation, to a more unfolded form which is not able to refold "incorrectly". The stability of alpha-chymotrypsin is regulated within a wide range by medium alteration: the stabilizing effects are similar to those achieved by multipoint attachment of the enzyme to a support or by hydrophilization of protein by covalent modification.     

Protein stabilization via hydrophilization. Covalent modification of trypsin and alpha-chymotrypsin

This paper experimentally verifies the idea presented earlier that the contact of nonpolar clusters located on the surface of protein molecules with water destabilizes proteins. It is demonstrated that protein stabilization can be achieved by artificial hydrophilization of the surface area of protein globules by chemical modification. Two experimental systems are studied for the verification of the hydrophilization approach. The surface tyrosine residues of trypsin are transformed to aminotyrosines using a two-step modification procedure: nitration by tetranitromethane followed by reduction with sodium dithionite. The modified enzyme is much more stable against irreversible thermoinactivation: the stabilizing effect increases with the number of aminotyrosine residues in trypsin and the modified enzyme can become even 100 times more stable than the native one. Alpha-chymotrypsin is covalently modified by treatment with anhydrides or chloroanhydrides of aromatic carboxylic acids. As a result, different numbers of additional carboxylic groups (up to five depending on the structure of the modifying reagent) are introduced into each Lys residue modified. Acylation of all available amino groups of alpha-chymotrypsin by cyclic anhydrides of pyromellitic and mellitic acids results in a substantial hydrophilization of the protein as estimated by partitioning in an aqueous Ficoll-400/Dextran-70 biphasic system. These modified enzyme preparations are extremely stable against irreversible thermal inactivation at elevated temperatures (65-98 degrees C); their thermostability is practically equal to the stability of proteolytic enzymes from extremely thermophilic bacteria, the most stable proteinases known to date.     

Chemical modification of the epsilon-amino groups of lysine residues in horseradish peroxidase and its effect on the catalytic properties and thermostability of the enzyme.

Chemical modification of horseradish peroxidase (donor:hydrogen-peroxide oxidoreductase, EC 1.11.1.7) (isoenzyme C) by anhydrides of mono- and dicarboxylic acids and picryl sulfonic acid has been performed. The effect of the modification on the catalytic activity, absorption and circular dichroism spectra of peroxidase has been studied. Rate constants of irreversible thermoinactivation (kin) for the native and modified peroxidase at 56--80 degrees C have been measured. The effective values of the thermodynamic activation parameters of thermoinactivation, delta H not equal to and delta S not equal to, have been also determined. A relationship between the number of modified epsilon-amino groups of lysine residues and the nature of the modifier on the one hand, and the conformation and thermostability of the enzyme on the other, is discussed. It has been shown that it is the degree of modification, rather than the nature of the modifier, that produces the major effect on the macromolecular conformation and the thermostability of the enzyme after modification. The conclusion is drawn that the thermostability of the modified enzyme increases due to the decrease of the conformational mobility in the protein moiety around the heme.     

Chaperone-mediated refolding of recombinant prochymosin

It has been verified that prochymosin is characterized by a two-stage refolding: dilution of unfolded protein into pH 11 buffer followed by neutralization at pH 8; the high-pH step is indispensable. Here we demonstrate that one-stage refolding around pH 8 can be achieved when GroE or 10-fold molar excess (rather than catalytic concentration) of protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) over prochymosin is present. The helping effect varies with the oxidation states of prochymosin. GroE and PDI increase the reactivation of the unfolded, partially reduced and the unfolded, oxidized prochymosin from 5% to 40% and from 50% to 100%, respectively. For the unfolded and fully reduced prochymosin, GroE does not have a positive effect, whereas PDI promotes renaturation from 2% to 28%. Based on our previous and present observations, we propose that at pH 8 there may be two kinds of incorrect interactions within and between prochymosin polypeptides leading to unproductive pathways: one prevents disulfide rearrangement, which can be avoided by high pH; the other interferes with acquisition of native conformation, which can be relieved by GroE and PDI.     

Study of the kinetics of thermoinactivation of lysyl-tRNA-synthetase from the liver of x-irradiated rats

A study was made of the kinetics of thermoinactivation of lysyl-tRNA-synthetase isolated from rat liver at early times of radiation damage development after the effect of a minimum absolutely lethal X-radiation dose (0.21 C/kg). The thermostability of a dimer form of the enzyme was shown to be higher than that of a monomer. It was established that substrates had a stabilizing effect on the enzyme during thermoinactivation. On the basis of the data obtained from the studies in the kinetic properties of the enzyme and the thermoinactivation a conclusion is made that lysyl-tRNA-synthetase is stabilized during subunit aggregation. The thermostability of the enzyme was decreased by irradiation.     

Intermediate studies on refolding of arginine kinase denatured by guanidine hydrochloride.

The refolding course and intermediate of guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl)-denatured arginine kinase (AK) were studied in terms of enzymatic activity, intrinsic fluorescence, 1-anilino-8-naphthalenesulfonte (ANS) fluorescence, and far-UV circular dichroism (CD). During AK refolding, the fluorescence intensity increased with a significantly blue shift of the emission maximum. The molar ellipticity of CD increased to close to that of native AK, as compared with the fully unfolded AK. In the AK refolding process, 2 refolding intermediates were observed at the concentration ranges of 0.8-1.0 mol/L and 0.3-0.5 mol GuHCl/L. The peak position of the fluorescence emission and the secondary structure of these conformation states remained roughly unchanged. The tryptophan fluorescence intensity increased a little. However, the ANS fluorescence intensity significantly increased, as compared with both the native and the fully unfolded states. The first refolding intermediate at the range of 0.8-1.0 mol GuHCl/L concentration represented a typical "pre-molten globule state structure" with inactivity. The second one, at the range of 0.3-0.5 mol GuHCl/L concentration, shared many structural characteristics of native AK, including its secondary and tertiary structure, and regained its catalytic function, although its activity was lower than that of native AK. The present results suggest that during the refolding of GuHCl-denatured AK there are at least 2 refolding intermediates; as well, the results provide direct evidence for the hierarchical mechanism of protein folding.     

Equilibrium and kinetic studies on folding of canine milk lysozyme

Thermal and chemical unfolding studies of the calcium-binding canine lysozyme (CL) by fluorescence and circular dichroism spectroscopy show that, upon unfolding in the absence of calcium ions, a very stable equilibrium intermediate state is formed. At room temperature and pH 7.5, for example, a stable molten globule state is attained in 3 M GdnHCl. The existence of such a pure and stable intermediate state allowed us to extend classical stopped-flow fluorescence measurements that describe the transition from the native to the unfolded form, with kinetic experiments that monitor separately the transition from the unfolded to the intermediate state and from the intermediate to the native state, respectively. The overall refolding kinetics of apo-canine lysozyme are characterized by a significant drop in the fluorescence intensity during the dead time, followed by a monoexponential increase of the fluorescence with k = 3.6 s(-1). Furthermore, the results show that, unlike its drastic effect on the stability, Ca(2+)-binding only marginally affects the refolding kinetics. During the refolding process of apo-CL non-native interactions, comparable to those observed in hen egg white lysozyme, are revealed by a substantial quenching of tryptophan fluorescence. The dissection of the refolding process in two distinct steps shows that these non-native interactions only occur in the final stage of the refolding process in which the two domains match to form the native conformation.     

Cation-induced toroidal condensation of DNA studies with Co3+(NH3)6

The unfolding and refolding of Staphylococcus aureus penicillinase have been followed by urea-gradient electrophoresis. Unfolding of the native state proceeds by an all-or-none transition to fully unfolded protein, with no detectable accumulation of partially unfolded states. In contrast, refolding is complex and proceeds by very rapid, reversible formation of a partially folded state, H, which had been detected and characterized previously, as it is the most stable conformation at intermediate denaturant concentrations. At very low urea concentrations, a more compact conformational state was observed as a transient intermediate in refolding. There was little kinetic heterogeneity of the unfolded protein, as is normally observed with proteins containing proline residues.     

Effects of the IbpAB AND ClpA chaperones on DnaKJE-dependent refolding of bacterial luciferases in Escherichia coli cells

The rate and level of DnaKJE-dependent refolding of the thermoinactivated Aliivibrio fischeri luciferase are considerably lower in Escherichia coli ibpA and ibpB mutants than in wild type cells. The rate and level of refolding are lower in E. coli ibpB::kan than in ibpA::kan cells. The decline of refoldings level in E. coli clpA::kan makes progress only with the increase of thermoinactivation time of luciferase. Plasmids with the genes ibpAB don't compensate clpA mutation. It is supposed that small chaperones IbpAB and chaperone ClpA operate independently in a process of DnaKJE-dependent refolding of proteins at the different stages.     

Direct observation of microscopic reversibility in single-molecule protein folding

Both folded and unfolded conformations should be observed for a protein at its melting temperature (T(m)), where DeltaG between these states is zero. In an all-atom molecular dynamics simulation of chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (CI2) at its experimental T(m), the protein rapidly loses its low-temperature native structure; it then unfolds before refolding to a stable, native-like conformation. The initial unfolding follows the unfolding pathway described previously for higher-temperature simulations: the hydrophobic core is disrupted, the beta-sheet pulls apart and the alpha-helix unravels. The unfolded state reached under these conditions maintains a kernel of structure in the form of a non-native hydrophobic cluster. Refolding simply reverses this path, the side-chain interactions shift, the helix refolds, and the native packing and hydrogen bonds are recovered. The end result of this refolding is not the initial crystal structure; it contains the proper topology and the majority of the native contacts, but the structure is expanded and the contacts are long. We believe this to be the native state at elevated temperature, and the change in volume and contact lengths is consistent with experimental studies of other native proteins at elevated temperature and the chemical denaturant equivalent of T(m).     

Amino acid residues stabilizing a Bacillus alpha-amylase against irreversible thermoinactivation

The alpha-amylase of Bacillus licheniformis (BLA) is stable and active at high temperature. More than 80% of its activity is retained after heat treatment at 90 degrees C for 30 min, and the optimum temperature for its activity is 80-85 degrees C. In contrast, the alpha-amylase of Bacillus amyloliquefaciens (BAA), the amino acid sequence of which shows 80% homology with that of BLA, is rapidly inactivated at 90 degrees C. Various chimeric genes were constructed from the structural genes for the two enzymes, and their products were analyzed for stability as to irreversible thermoinactivation. Two regions in the amino acid sequence of BLA comprising Gln178 (region I) and the 255th-270th residues (region II), respectively, were shown to determine the thermostability of BLA. Region I plays a major role in determining the thermostability. By means of site-directed mutagenesis of the BAA gene, deletion of Arg176 and Gly177 in region I and substitutions of alanine for Lys269 and aspartic acid for Asn266 in region II were shown to be responsible for the enhancement of the thermostability. Mutant BAAs containing the above deletion and substitutions showed almost the same thermostability as BLA as to irreversible thermoinactivation. Nevertheless, the mutant BAAs showed a temperature optimum as low as that of BAA (65 degrees C), indicating that they are still susceptible to reversible inactivation at temperatures higher than 65 degrees C.     

On the role of reversible denaturation (unfolding) in the irreversible thermal inactivation of enzymes

The contribution of the reversible thermal unfolding of an enzyme toward the overall irreversible thermoinactivation process has been examined both theoretically and experimentally. Using bovine pancreatic ribonuclease as a model, we have studied the effect of such variables as pH and salts both on the equilibrium constant of reversible denaturation and on the rate constant of the overall irreversible process. It has been demonstrated that at temperatures where a significant fraction of the enzyme molecules are in the native conformation, there is a correlation between the enzyme thermostabilities with respect to the reversible and irreversible inactivations: greater stability against the former is accompanied by greater stability against the latter. On the other hand, at very high temperatures (where essentially all of the enzyme molecules are unfolded), such a correlation does not exist. These findings are considered in terms of a kinetic model for irreversible enzyme thermoinactivation, and the implications of the derived relationship are discussed.     

Rapid folding and unfolding of Apaf-1 CARD

Caspase recruitment domains (CARDs) are members of the death domain superfamily and contain six antiparallel helices in an alpha-helical Greek key topology. We have examined the equilibrium and kinetic folding of the CARD of Apaf-1 (apoptotic protease activating factor 1), which consists of 97 amino acid residues, at pH 6 and pH 8. The results showed that an apparent two state equilibrium mechanism is not adequate to describe the folding of Apaf-1 CARD at either pH, suggesting the presence of intermediates in equilibrium unfolding. Interestingly, the results showed that the secondary structure is less stable than the tertiary structure, based on the transition mid-points for unfolding. Single mixing and sequential mixing stopped-flow studies showed that Apaf-1 CARD folds and unfolds rapidly and suggest a folding mechanism that contains parallel channels with two unfolded conformations folding to the native conformation. Kinetic simulations show that a slow folding phase is described by a third conformation in the unfolded ensemble that interconverts with one or both unfolded species. Overall, the native ensemble is formed rapidly upon refolding. This is in contrast to other CARDs in which folding appears to be dominated by formation of kinetic traps.     

Refolding of partially thermo-unfolded cinnamomin A-chain mediated by B-chain

The pure cinnamomin A-chain is unstable compared to that in the mixture of A- and B-chain or in intact cinnamomin molecule either being stored at 4 degrees C or being heated. When being heated at 45 degrees C for 20min, the A-chain generates partially unfolded intermediate and loses its tertiary structure as monitored by circular dichroism (CD) and tryptophan fluorescence, thus resulting in the inactivity of its RNA N-glycosidase albeit it retains most of its secondary structures. This partially unfolded intermediate is sensitive to protease, exhibiting property of a molten globule. The changes in conformation and activity are irreversible upon cooling. The partially unfolded intermediate can fully restore its RNA N-glycosidase activity in the presence of cinnamomin B-chain. The phenomenon, that the cinnamomin B-chain mediates the refolding of partially unfolded A-chain, probably plays an important role in the intracellular transport of the cytotoxic protein, i.e., keeping the structural stability of A-chain and refolding partially unfolded A-chain that occasionally appeared in the process of intracellular transport, to avoid the destiny of proteolysis that occurs in most denatured proteins in cell.     

Kinetic traps in the folding/unfolding of procaspase-1 CARD domain

We have examined the folding and unfolding of the caspase recruitment domain of procaspase-1 (CP1-CARD), a member of the alpha-helical Greek key protein family. The equilibrium folding/unfolding of CP1-CARD is described by a two-state mechanism, and the results show CP1-CARD is marginally stable with a DeltaG(H2O) of 1.1 +/- 0.2 kcal/mole and an m-value of 0.65 +/- 0.06 kcal/mole/M (10 mM Tris-HCl at pH 8.0, 1 mM DTT, 25 degrees C). Consistent with the equilibrium folding data, CP1-CARD is a monomer in solution when examined by size exclusion chromatography. Single-mixing stopped-flow refolding and unfolding studies show that CP1-CARD folds and unfolds rapidly, with no detectable slow phases, and the reactions appear to reach equilibrium within 10 msec. However, double jump kinetic experiments demonstrate the presence of an unfolded-like intermediate during unfolding. The intermediate converts to the fully unfolded conformation with a half-time of 10 sec. Interrupted refolding studies demonstrate the presence of one or more nativelike intermediates during refolding, which convert to the native conformation with a half-time of about 60 sec. Overall, the data show that both unfolding and refolding processes are slow, and the pathways contain kinetically trapped species.     

Function of disulflde bond Cys45-Cys50 of prochymosin

The conditions (temperature, time, pH) for solubilizing inclusion bodies of prochymosin mutant, Cys45Asp/Cys50Ser, are identical with those for the wild type. Moreover, they have similar oxidative refolding behavior. Under the same renaturation conditions both of them can undergo correct refolding leading to the formation of activable molecules. This is quite different from the mutant with deletion of Cys250-Cys283, indicating that Cys45-Cys50 contributes less to the correct refolding of prochymosin than Cys250- Cys283. However, deletion of Cys45-Cys50 results in a remarkable decrease of the thermostability of pseudochymosin, suggesting that this disulfide bond plays an important role in stabilizing enzyme conformation. The proteolytic (P) and milk-dotting (C) activities of the mutant of pseudochymosin, Cys45Asp/Cys50Ser, are lower than those of its wild counterpart. The C/P ratio of the former is onefold higher than that of the latter.     

The nature of the rate-limiting steps in the refolding of the cofactor-dependent protein aspartate aminotransferase

The refolding of mitochondrial aspartate aminotransferase (mAAT; EC 2.6.1.1) has been studied following unfolding in 6 m guanidine hydrochloride for different periods of time. Whereas reactivation of equilibrium-unfolded mAAT is sigmoidal, reactivation of the short term unfolded protein displays a double exponential behavior consistent with the presence of fast and slow refolding species. The amplitude of the fast phase decreases with increasing unfolding times (k approximately 0.75 min(-1) at 20 degrees C) and becomes undetectable at equilibrium unfolding. According to hydrogen exchange and stopped-flow intrinsic fluorescence data, unfolding of mAAT appears to be complete in less than 10 s, but hydrolysis of the Schiff base linking the coenzyme pyridoxal 5'-phosphate (PLP) to the polypeptide is much slower (k approximately 0.08 min(-1)). This implies the existence in short term unfolded samples of unfolded species with PLP still attached. However, since the disappearance of the fast refolding phase is about 10-fold faster than the release of PLP, the fast refolding phase does not correspond to folding of the coenzyme-containing molecules. The fast refolding phase disappears more rapidly in the pyridoxamine and apoenzyme forms of mAAT, both of which lack covalently attached cofactor. Thus, bound PLP increases the kinetic stability of the fast refolding unfolding intermediates. Conversion between fast and slow folding forms also takes place in an early folding intermediate. The presence of cyclophilin has no effect on the reactivation of either equilibrium or short term unfolded mAAT. These results suggest that proline isomerization may not be the only factor determining the slow refolding of this cofactor-dependent protein.     

Why is one Bacillus alpha-amylase more resistant against irreversible thermoinactivation than another?

Half-lives of Bacillus alpha-amylases at 90 degrees C and pH 6.5 greatly increase in the series from Bacillus amyloliquefaciens to Bacillus stearothermophilus to Bacillus licheniformis, e.g. the difference in thermostability between the first and the third enzymes exceeds 2 orders of magnitude. This stabilization is achieved by lowering the rate constant of monomolecular conformational scrambling, which is the cause of irreversible thermoinactivation of B. amyloliquefaciens and B. stearothermophilus alpha-amylases, so that for B. licheniformis alpha-amylase, another process, deamidation of Asn/Gln residues, emerges as the cause of inactivation. The extra thermostability of the thermophilic enzyme was found to be mainly due to additional salt bridges involving a few specific lysine residues (Lys-385 and Lys-88 and/or Lys-253). These stabilizing electrostatic interactions reduce the extent of unfolding of the enzyme molecule at high temperatures, consequently making it less prone to forming incorrect (scrambled) structures and thus decreasing the overall rate of irreversible thermoinactivation. The implications of these findings for protein engineering are discussed.     

Sweetness of sweet protein thaumatin is more thermoresistant under acid conditions than under neutral or alkaline conditions

Thermostability of thaumatin and mechanisms of thermoinactivation were examined at 80 degrees C in the pH range from 2 to 10. The sweetness of thaumatin disappeared on heating at pH above 7 for 15 min, but the sweetness remained even after heating at 80 degrees C for 4 h at pH 2. This indicated that the sweet protein thaumatin is more thermoresistant under acid conditions than under neutral or alkaline conditions. Prolonged heating of thaumatin under acid conditions slowly reduced sweetness, and produced a heterogeneous population of molecules, all of which was soluble and monomeric. The resultant molecules were clearly distinct from those generated by heating at pH above 7. Hydrolysis of peptide bonds and other irreversible chemical reactions slowly took place in the molecule heated under acid conditions, and it would be, in part, a cause of thermoinactivation of thaumatin under acid conditions. The thermostability of thaumatin and the mechanism of thermoinactivation were largely dependent on pH.