Mechanical properties of collagen fascicles from the rabbit patellar tendon

Tensile and viscoelastic properties of collagen fascicles of approximately 300 microns in diameter, which were obtained from rabbit patellar tendons, were studied using a newly designed micro-tensile tester. Their cross-sectional areas were determined with a video dimension analyzer combined with a CCD camera and a low magnification microscope. There were no statistically significant differences in tensile properties among the fascicles obtained from six medial-to-lateral locations of the patellar tendon. Tangent modulus, tensile strength, and strain at failure of the fascicles determined at about 1.5 percent/s strain rate were 216 +/- 68 MPa, 17.2 +/- 4.1 MPa, and 10.9 +/- 1.6 percent (mean +/- S.D.), respectively. These properties were much different from those of bulk patellar tendons; for example, the tensile strength and strain at failure of these fascicles were 42 percent and 179 percent of those of bulk tendons, respectively. Tangent modulus and tensile strength of collagen fascicles determined at 1 percent/s strain rate were 35 percent larger than those at 0.01 percent/s. The strain at failure was independent of strain rate. Relaxation tests showed that the reduction of stress was approximately 25 percent at 300 seconds. These stress relaxation behavior and strain rate effects of collagen fascicles differed greatly from those of bulk tendons. The differences in tensile and viscoelastic properties between fascicles and bulk tendons may be attributable to ground substances, mechanical interaction between fascicles, and the difference of crimp structure of collagen fibrils.     

Bimodal collagen fibril diameter distributions direct age-related variations in tendon resilience and resistance to rupture

Scaling relationships have been formulated to investigate the influence of collagen fibril diameter (D) on age-related variations in the strain energy density of tendon. Transmission electron microscopy was used to quantify D in tail tendon from 1.7- to 35.3-mo-old (C57BL/6) male mice. Frequency histograms of D for all age groups were modeled as two normally distributed subpopulations with smaller (D(D1)) and larger (D(D2)) mean Ds, respectively. Both D(D1) and D(D2) increase from 1.6 to 4.0 mo but decrease thereafter. From tensile tests to rupture, two strain energy densities were calculated: 1) u(E) [from initial loading until the yield stress (σ(Y))], which contributes primarily to tendon resilience, and 2) u(F) [from σ(Y) through the maximum stress (σ(U)) until rupture], which relates primarily to resistance of the tendons to rupture. As measured by the normalized strain energy densities u(E)/σ(Y) and u(F)/σ(U), both the resilience and resistance to rupture increase with increasing age and peak at 23.0 and 4.0 mo, respectively, before decreasing thereafter. Multiple regression analysis reveals that increases in u(E)/σ(Y) (resilience energy) are associated with decreases in D(D1) and increases in D(D2), whereas u(F)/σ(U) (rupture energy) is associated with increases in D(D1) alone. These findings support a model where age-related variations in tendon resilience and resistance to rupture can be directed by subtle changes in the bimodal distribution of Ds.     

Mechanical properties of human patellar tendon at the hierarchical levels of tendon and fibril

Tendons are strong hierarchical structures, but how tensile forces are transmitted between different levels remains incompletely understood. Collagen fibrils are thought to be primary determinants of whole tendon properties, and therefore we hypothesized that the whole human patellar tendon and its distinct collagen fibrils would display similar mechanical properties. Human patellar tendons (n = 5) were mechanically tested in vivo by ultrasonography. Biopsies were obtained from each tendon, and individual collagen fibrils were dissected and tested mechanically by atomic force microscopy. The Young's modulus was 2.0 ± 0.5 GPa, and the toe region reached 3.3 ± 1.9% strain in whole patellar tendons. Based on dry cross-sectional area, the Young's modulus of isolated collagen fibrils was 2.8 ± 0.3 GPa, and the toe region reached 0.86 ± 0.08% strain. The measured fibril modulus was insufficient to account for the modulus of the tendon in vivo when fibril content in the tendon was accounted for. Thus, our original hypothesis was not supported, although the in vitro fibril modulus corresponded well with reported in vitro tendon values. This correspondence together with the fibril modulus not being greater than that of tendon supports that fibrillar rather than interfibrillar properties govern the subfailure tendon response, making the fibrillar level a meaningful target of intervention. The lower modulus found in vitro suggests a possible adverse effect of removing the tissue from its natural environment. In addition to the primary work comparing the two hierarchical levels, we also verified the existence of viscoelastic behavior in isolated human collagen fibrils.     

Type III collagen can be present on banded collagen fibrils regardless of fibril diameter

Monoclonal antibodies that recognize an epitope within the triple helix of type III collagen have been used to examine the distribution of that collagen type in human skin, cornea, amnion, aorta, and tendon. Ultrastructural examination of those tissues indicates antibody binding to collagen fibrils in skin, amnion, aorta, and tendon regardless of the diameter of the fibril. The antibody distribution is unchanged with donor age, site of biopsy, or region of tissue examined. In contrast, antibody applied to adult human cornea localizes to isolated fibrils, which appear randomly throughout the matrix. These studies indicate that type III collagen remains associated with collagen fibrils after removal of the amino and carboxyl propeptides, and suggests that fibrils of skin, tendon, and amnion (and presumably many other tissues that contain both types I and III collagens) are copolymers of at least types I and III collagens.     

Effects of cyclic stress on the mechanical properties of cultured collagen fascicles from the rabbit patellar tendon

Effects of cyclic stress on the mechanical properties of collagen fascicles were studied by in vitro tissue culture experiments. Collagen fascicles (approximately 300 microns in diameter) obtained from the rabbit patellar tendon were applied cyclic load at 4 Hz for one hour per day during culture period for one or two weeks, and then their mechanical properties were determined using a micro-tensile tester. There was a statistically significant correlation between tensile strength and applied peak stress in the range of 0 to 5 MPa, and the relation was expressed by a quadratic function. The maximum strength (19.4 MPa) was obtained at the applied peak stress of 1.8 MPa. The tensile strength of fascicles were within a range of control values, if they were cultured under peak stresses between 1.1 and 2.6 MPa. Similar results were also observed in the tangent modulus, which was maintained at control level under applied peak stresses between 0.9 and 2.8 MPa. The stress of 0.9 to 1.1 MPa is equivalent to approximately 40% of the in vivo peak stress which is developed in the intact rabbit patellar tendon by running, whereas that of 2.6 to 2.8 MPa corresponds to approximately 120% of the in vivo peak stress. Therefore, the fascicles cultured under applied peak stresses of lower than 40% and higher than 120% of the in vivo peak stress do not keep the original strength and modulus. These results indicate that the mechanical properties of cultured collagen fascicles strongly depend upon the magnitude of the stress applied during culture, which are similar to our previous results observed in stress-shielded and overstressed patellar tendons in vivo.     

Development of collagen fibril organization and collagen crimp patterns during tendon healing

Normal tendon comprises coaxially aligned bundles of crimped collagen fibres each of which possesses a fibrillar substructure. In acute traumatic injury this level of organization is disrupted and the mechanical function of the tendon impaired. During repair, a degree of recovery of the fibrillar structure takes place. In this tudy we have assessed the re-establishment of tendon organization after injury on the basis of the collagen fibril diameter distribution and the collagen crimp parameters. Crimp became undetectable following injury but one month later was present throughout the tissue. At this time the periodicity was greatly reduced by comparison with that of the normal tendon and normal values were not re-established within 14 months following injury. Collagen fibril diameters remained abnormally small over this same period of time. In particular, fibrils of diameters in excess of 100 nm, commonly found in normal and contralateral tendons, were totally absent from the observed distributions in the healing tendons. Such large diameter fibrils often account for as much as 50% of the total mass of collagen present in the uninjured tissue. Thus the mechanical properties of the healing tendon may remain significantly different from those of normal tendon for a minimum time of 14 months after injury.     

Effects of static stress on the mechanical properties of cultured collagen fascicles from the rabbit patellar tendon

In-vitro tissue culture experiments were performed to study the effects of static stress on the mechanical properties of collagen fascicles obtained from the rabbit patellar tendon. After collagen fascicles having the diameter of approximately 300 microm were cultured for 1 and 2 wk under static stress between 0 and 3 MPa, their mechanical properties and crimp morphology were determined using a micro-tensile tester and a light microscope, respectively. The tensile strength and tangent modulus of the fascicles were significantly decreased by culture under no load compared to control fascicles. A statistically significant correlation, which was described by a quadratic curve, was observed between applied stress and tensile strength. The maximum tensile strength (16.7 MPa) was obtained at the applied stress of 1.2 MPa; the strength was within a range of control values. There was a similar correlation between applied stress and tangent modulus, and the modulus was maintained at control level under 1.3 MPa stress. The stress of 1.2 to 1.3 MPa is equivalent to approximately 50 percent of the peak stress developed in the intact rabbit patellar tendon by running. Strain at failure of cultured collagen fascicles was negatively correlated with applied stress, and that at 1.2 to 1.3 MPa stress was almost the same as the control value. Crimp morphology in the fascicles cultured under about 1.2 MPa stress was similar to that in control fascicles. These results indicate that cultured collagen fascicles change the mechanical properties and structure in response to static tensile stress. In addition, their mechanical properties and structure are maintained at control level if the static stress of 50 percent of in-vivo peak stress is applied.     

Mechanical properties of the rabbit patellar tendon.

The mechanical and structural properties of the patellar tendon fascicle-bone units of rabbit knees were determined by tensile tests, particularly focusing on their local differences. There were no significant differences in the strains measured by a video dimension analyzer among the proximal, middle, and distal regions of the central portion of tendon. The mechanical properties of the medial portion agreed well with those of the central portion. However, significant differences were observed in the tensile strength between the lateral and the other two portions: the tensile strength of the lateral portion was about 16 percent larger than those in the other portions.     

Actin filaments are required for fibripositor-mediated collagen fibril alignment in tendon

Cells in tendon deposit parallel arrays of collagen fibrils to form a functional tissue, but how this is achieved is unknown. The cellular mechanism is thought to involve the formation of intracellular collagen fibrils within Golgi to plasma membrane carriers. This is facilitated by the intracellular processing of procollagen to collagen by members of the tolloid and ADAMTS families of enzymes. The carriers subsequently connect to the extracellular matrix via finger-like projections of the plasma membrane, known as fibripositors. In this study we have shown, using three-dimensional electron microscopy, the alignment of fibripositors with intracellular fibrils as well as an orientated cable of actin filaments lining the cytosolic face of a fibripositor. To demonstrate a specific role for the cytoskeleton in coordinating extracellular matrix assembly, cytochalasin was used to disassemble actin filaments and nocodazole or colchicine were used to disrupt microtubules. Microtubule disruption delayed procollagen transport through the secretory pathway, but fibripositor numbers were unaffected. Actin filament disassembly resulted in rapid loss of fibripositors and a subsequent disappearance of intracellular fibrils. Procollagen secretion or processing was not affected by cytochalasin treatment, but the parallelism of extracellular collagen fibrils was altered. In this case a significant proportion of collagen fibrils were found to no longer be orientated with the long axis of the tendon. The results suggest an important role for the actin cytoskeleton in the alignment and organization of the collagenous extracellular matrix in embryonic tendon.     

Ultrashort echo imaging of cyclically loaded rabbit patellar tendon

Tendinopathy affects individuals who perform repetitive joint motion. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is frequently used to qualitatively assess tendon health, but quantitative evaluation of inherent MRI properties of loaded tendon has been limited. This study evaluated the effect of cyclic loading on _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ values of fresh and frozen rabbit patellar tendons using ultra short echo (UTE) MRI. Eight fresh and 8 frozen rabbit lower extremities had MR scans acquired for tendon _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ evaluation. The tendons were then manually cyclically loaded for 100 cycles to 45 N at approximately 1 Hz. The MR scanning was repeated to reassess the _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ values. Analyses were performed to detect differences of tendon _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ values between fresh and frozen samples prior to and after loading, and to detect changes of tendon _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ values between the unloaded and loaded configurations. No difference of _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ was found between the fresh and frozen samples prior to or after loading, p=0.8 and p  =0.1, respectively. The tendons had significantly shorter _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ values, p  =0.023, and reduced _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ variability, p  =0.04, after cyclic loading. Histologic evaluation confirmed no induced tendon damage from loading. Shorter _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$, from stronger spin–spin interactions, may be attributed to greater tissue organization from uncrimping of collagen fibrils and lateral contraction of the tendon during loading. Cyclic tensile loading of tissue reduces patellar tendon _T2^?${T_2}^{?}$ values and may provide a quantitative metric to assess tissue organization.     

Analysis of collagen fibril diameter distribution in connective tissues using small-angle X-ray scattering

Analysis of the diameters of collagen fibrils provides insight into the structure and physical processes occurring in the tissue. This paper describes a method for analyzing the frequency distribution of the diameters of collagen fibrils from small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) patterns. Frequency values of fibril diameters were input into a mathematical model of the form factor to calculate the equatorial intensity which best fits the experimentally derived data from SAXS patterns. A minimization algorithm utilizing simulated annealing (SA) was used in the fitting procedure. The SA algorithm allowed for random sampling of the frequency values, and was run iteratively to build up an optimized frequency distribution of fibril diameters. Results were obtained for collagen samples from sheep spine ligaments. The mean fibril diameter value obtained from this data-fitting method was 73 nm+/-20 nm (S.D.). From scanning transmission electron microscopy, the mean diameter was found to be 69 nm+/-14 nm (S.D.). The good agreement between the two methods demonstrates the reliability of the SAXS method for the tissue examined. The non-destructive nature of this technique, as well as its statistical robusticity and capacity for large sampling, means that this method is both quick and effective.     

Mechanical properties of the canine patellar tendon: some correlations with age and the content of collagen.

Portions of the patellar tendon (PT) are currently used for autogenous and allogeneic reconstruction of a torn or damaged anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). Age-related changes in the mechanical properties of the PT may influence its use in this reconstruction procedure. Age-dependent changes in the PT were determined in the dog, which is often used to experimentally study this reconstruction. Tensile failure experiments were performed at 100% s-1 on patella-patellar tendon-tibia preparations from dogs aged 0.5-15 yr. The contents of collagen soluble and insoluble in pepsin were also measured at each age. Fifty-nine percent (16/27) of the preparations failed by avulsion at the patella, but neither the failure load nor the mode of failure were a function of age. Failure load and energy were higher for tendon substance failures compared to avulsions of bone from the patella. While a positive, linear correlation was measured between tensile modulus of the PT and age, the slope of regression was not significantly different from zero. The content of total collagen in the PT decreased significantly with age. The content of collagen insoluble in pepsin, however, increased with age and positively correlated with tensile modulus of the tendon. These results are different from those reported for the canine CCL, by others, which degenerates with age. Age-related changes in the mechanical properties of the canine PT are qualitatively similar to earlier, limited data on human patellar tendons.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Assembly of type I collagen: fusion of fibril subunits and the influence of fibril diameter on mechanical properties.

Structural stability of the extracellular matrix is primarily a consequence of fibrillar collagen and the extent of cross-linking. The relationship between collagen self-assembly, consequent fibrillar shape and mechanical properties remains unclear. Our laboratory developed a model system for the preparation of self-assembled type I collagen fibers with fibrillar substructure mimicking the hierarchical structures of tendon. The present study evaluates the effects of pH and temperature during self-assembly on fibrillar structure, and relates the structural effects of these treatments on the uniaxial tensile mechanical properties of self-assembled collagen fibers. Results of the analysis of fibril diameter distributions and mechanical properties of the fibers formed under the different incubation conditions indicate that fibril diameters grow via the lateral fusion of discrete approximately 4 nm subunits, and that fibril diameter correlates positively with the low strain modulus. Fibril diameter did not correlate with either the ultimate tensile strength or the high strain elastic modulus, which suggests that lateral aggregation and consequently fibril diameter influences mechanical properties during small strain mechanical deformation. We hypothesize that self-assembly is mediated by the formation of fibrillar subunits that laterally and linearly fuse resulting in fibrillar growth. Lateral fusion appears important in generating resistance to deformation at low strain, while linear fusion leading to longer fibrils appears important in the ultimate mechanical properties at high strain.     

In vivo forces used to develop design parameters for tissue engineered implants for rabbit patellar tendon repair

Previous studies in tissue engineering have shown that suspending undifferentiated mesenchymal stem cells in collagen gels and wrapping them about a suture causes alignment of cells and contraction of constructs in culture in a form that is suitable for implantation for tendon repair. Little is known about the patterns of these in vivo signals that might improve tendon repair biomechanics. Three hypotheses were tested in this study using the rabbit patellar tendon (PT) model: (1) peak in vivo forces and the rates of rise and fall in these forces will increase significantly with increasing levels of activity; (2) the PTs safety factor for all activities will be in the range of values found for tendons (2.5-3); (3) rabbits will not "favor" the operated limb at the time of evaluation but maintain similar vertical ground reaction forces in both limbs during quiet standing (QS). In vivo rabbit PT forces were measured during QS and while the animal hopped on a treadmill whose speed (0.04 and 0.13 m/s) and inclination (0 degrees and 12 degrees) were controlled. Implantable force transducers were surgically placed in one PT and data collected three days post surgery in each of eight New Zealand White rabbits. Peak tensile forces increased significantly with inclination of the treadmill and the rates of rise and fall in tendon force increased significantly with both speed and inclination (p<0.001). Such design criteria should be useful in mechanically stimulating cell-gel constructs for tendon repair.     

Evidence against proteoglycan mediated collagen fibril load transmission and dynamic viscoelasticity in tendon

The glycosaminoglycan (GAG) dermatan sulfate and chondroitin sulfate side-chains of small leucine-rich proteoglycans have been increasingly posited to act as molecular cross links between adjacent collagen fibrils and to directly contribute to tendon elasticity. GAGs have also been implicated in tendon viscoelasticity, supposedly affecting frictional loss during elongation or fluid flow through the extra cellular matrix. The current study sought to systematically test these theories of tendon structure–function by investigating the mechanical repercussions of enzymatic depletion of GAG complexes by chondroitinase ABC in a reproducible tendon structure–function model (rat tail tendon fascicles). The extent of GAG removal (at least 93%) was verified by relevant spectrophotometric assays and transmission electron microscopy. Dynamic viscoelastic tensile tests on GAG depleted rat tail tendon fascicle were not mechanically different from controls in storage modulus (elastic behavior) over a wide range of strain-rates (0.05, 0.5, and 5% change in length per second) in either the linear or nonlinear regions of the material curve. Loss modulus (viscoelastic behavior) was only affected in the nonlinear region at the highest strain-rate, and even this effect was marginal (19% increased loss modulus, p = 0.035). Thus glycosaminoglycan chains of small leucine-rich proteoglycans do not appear to mediate dynamic elastic behavior nor do they appear to regulate the dynamic viscoelastic properties in rat tail tendon fascicles.     

A mechanistic study for strain rate sensitivity of rabbit patellar tendon

The ultrastructural mechanism for strain rate sensitivity of collagenous tissue has not been well studied at the collagen fibril level. Our objective is to reveal the mechanistic contribution of tendon’s key structural component to strain rate sensitivity. We have investigated the structure of the collagen fibril undergoing tension at different strain rates. Tendon fascicles were pulled and fixed within the linear region (12% local tissue strain) at multiple strain rates. Although samples were pulled to the same percent elongation, the fibrils were noticed to elongate differently, increasing with strain rate. For the 0.1, 10, and 70%/s strain rates, there were 1.84±3.6%, 5.5±1.9%, and 7.03±2.2% elongations (mean±S.D.), respectively. We concluded that the collagen fibrils underwent significantly greater recruitment (fibril strain relative to global tissue strain) at higher strain rates. A better understanding of tendon mechanisms at lower hierarchical levels would help establish a basis for future development of constitutive models and assist in tissue replacement design.     

Effects of the frequency and duration of cyclic stress on the mechanical properties of cultured collagen fascicles from the rabbit patellar tendon

The effects of frequency or duration of cyclic stress on the mechanical properties of collagen fascicles were studied by means of in vitro tissue culture experiments. Collagen fascicles of approximately 300 microm in diameter were obtained from rabbit patellar tendons. During culture, cyclic stress having the peak stress of approximately 2 MPa was applied to the fascicles at 1 Hz for 1 hour/day (1 Hz-1 h group), at 1 Hz for 4 hours/day (1 Hz-4 h group), or at 4 Hz for 1 hour/day (4 Hz-1 h group). The frequency of 4 Hz and the duration of 1 hour/day are considered to be similar to those of the in vivo stress applied to fascicles in the intact rabbit patellar tendon. After culture for 1 or 2 weeks, the mechanical properties of the fascicles were determined using a microtensile tester, and were compared to the properties of non-cultured, fresh fascicles (control group) and the fascicles cultured under no load condition (non-loaded group). The tangent modulus and tensile strength of fascicles in the 4 Hz-1 h group were similar to those in the control group; however, the fascicles of the 1 Hz-1 h and 1 Hz-4 h groups had significantly lower values than those of the control group. There was no significant difference in the tensile strength between the 1 Hz-1 h and non-loaded groups, although the strength in the 1 Hz-4 h group was significantly higher than that of the non-loaded group. It was concluded that the frequency and duration of cyclic stress significantly affect the mechanical properties of cultured collagen fascicles. If we apply cyclic stress having the frequency and duration which are experienced in vivo, the biomechanical properties are maintained at control, normal level. Lower frequencies or less cycles of applied force induce adverse effects.     

Extracellular compartments in tendon morphogenesis: collagen fibril, bundle, and macroaggregate formation

The formation of collagen fibrils, fibril bundles, and tissue-specific collagen macroaggregates by chick embryo tendon fibroblasts was studied using conventional and high voltage electron microscopy. During chick tendon morphogenesis, there are at least three extracellular compartments responsible for three levels of matrix organization: collagen fibrils, bundles, and collagen macroaggregates. Our observations indicate that the initial extracellular events in collagen fibrillogenesis occur within narrow cytoplasmic recesses, presumably under close cellular regulation. Collagen fibrils are formed within these deep, narrow recesses, which are continuous with the extracellular space. Where these narrow recesses fuse with the cell surface, it becomes highly convoluted with folds and processes that envelope forming fibril bundles. The bundles laterally associate and coalesce, forming aggregates within a third cell-defined extracellular compartment. Our interpretation is that this third compartment forms as cell processes retract and cytoplasm is withdrawn between bundles. These studies define a hierarchical organization within the tendon, extending from fibril assembly to fascicle formation. Correlation of different levels of extracellular compartmentalization with tissue architecture provides insight into the cellular controls involved in collagen fibril and higher order assembly and a better understanding of how collagen fibrils are collected into structural groups, positioned, and woven into functional tissue-specific collagen macroaggregates.