Oil production by six microalgae: impact of flocculants and drying on oil recovery from the biomass

Oil production in batch photoautotrophic cultures of the following microalgae is reported: the freshwater microalgae Chlorella vulgaris, Choricystis minor, and Neochloris sp.; the marine microalgae Nannochloropsis salina and Cylindrotheca fusiformis; and C. vulgaris grown in a full-strength seawater medium. In all cases, the solvent extraction of lipids from freeze-dried biomass is compared with extraction from the fresh biomass paste. For all algae, the oils could be extracted equally effectively from freeze-dried samples and the paste samples (67–88 % moisture by weight). Moisture content determinations of the biomass using the freeze-drying method and the high-temperature oven drying were found to be equivalent for all algae. The biomass recovered by flocculation with metal salts (aluminum sulfate, ferric chloride) followed by centrifugation had a certain amount of the flocculant irreversibly bound to it. Washing failed to remove the adsorbed flocculants. For all algae, the adsorbed flocculants did not interfere with oil recovery by solvent extraction. The solvent system of chloroform–methanol–water proved highly effective for quantitative extraction of the lipids from all algae.     

The influence of different flocculants on the physiological activity and fucoxanthin production of Phaeodactylum tricornutum

Phaeodactylum tricornutum is an economically important species of microalgae that is widely used in aquaculture, and it is rich in bioactive substances including eicosapentaenoic acid and fucoxanthin. The major bottleneck for industrialization of this species is harvesting. Flocculation is used to harvest microalgae, thus the selection of flocculants is of great importance. In this study, we compared the flocculation effect of four different chemicals (ferric chloride, aluminum sulphate, polyaluminum chloride, and aluminum potassium sulphate) on P. tricornutum. Microexamination showed that ferric and aluminum salts had similar flocculation effects on the algae. Growth and chlorophyll fluorescence measurements showed that P. tricornutum can be re-cultured after flocculation. Pigment analysis showed that flocculation did not result in degradation of fucoxanthin, which suggests that the four flocculants tested may be useful for industrial applications. The results also showed that ferric chloride was the best flocculant for harvesting P. tricornutum when the target product was fucoxanthin, as it had the least influence on the physiological activity of P. tricornutum and it did not lead to degradation of cell components. In contrast, aluminum is poisonous to the nervous system of animals and humans. In addition, the culture medium can be recycled after flocculation by ferric chloride.     

Comparative evaluation of inorganic and organic amendments for their flocculation efficiency of selected microalgae

Cost-efficient harvesting of microalgae is a major challenge due to their small size and often low concentration in the culture medium. The flocculation efficacy of different inorganic and organic amendments was evaluated on various microalgae genera—one strain each belonging to Chlamydomonas, Chlorococcum, two of Botryococcus, and of Chlorella. An improvised medium comprising of commercial grade urea, single super phosphate, and muriate of potash was used to grow the microalgae for flocculation experiments. High pH induced increased flocculation efficiency (72–76 %) in selected microalgal strains. Ferric chloride was found to be the most efficient for most of the microalgal strains, while maize starch and rice starch proved superior for Chlorella sp. MCC6 and Botryococcus sp. MCC32. Although the highest flocculation efficiency was obtained with inorganic flocculant, i.e., ferric chloride (87.3 %) with Botryococcus MCC31, this was comparable with rice starch (86.8 %) for Botryococcus MCC32. This study showed that widely available cheaper biopolymers such as rice starch, maize, and potato starch can be promising flocculants due to their better harvesting efficiency (>80 %) and low price, thereby contributing to economical production of biodiesel from algae.     

Critical conditions for ferric chloride-induced flocculation of freshwater algae

The effects of algae concentration, ferric chloride dose, and pH on the flocculation efficiency of the freshwater algae Chlorella zofingiensis can be understood by considering the nature of the electrostatic charges on the algae and precipitate surfaces. Two critical conditions are identified which, when met, result in flocculation efficiencies in excess of 90% for freshwater algae. First, a minimum concentration of ferric chloride is required to overcome the electrostatic stabilization of the algae and promote bridging of algae cells by hydroxide precipitates. At low algae concentrations, the minimum amount of ferric chloride required increases linearly with algae concentration, characteristic of flocculation primarily through electrostatic bridging by hydroxide precipitates. At higher algae concentrations, the minimum required concentration of ferric chloride for flocculation is independent of algae concentration, suggesting a change in the primary flocculation mechanism from bridging to sweep flocculation. Second, the algae must have a negative surface charge. Experiments and surface complexation modeling show that the surface charge of C. zofingiensis is negative above a pH of 4.0 ± 0.3 which agrees well with the minimum pH required for effective flocculation. These critical flocculation criteria can be extended to other freshwater algae to design effective flocculation systems.     

Selection of optimal flocculant for effective harvesting of the fucoxanthin-rich marine microalga <Emphasis Type="Italic">Isochrysis galbana</Emphasis>

Flocculation harvesting of the fucoxanthin-rich marine microalga Isochrysis galbana has received little attention. Therefore, we attempted to screen for an optimal chemical flocculant and optimize flocculation conditions from five chemical flocculants—ferric chloride (FC), aluminum sulfate (AS), polyaluminum chloride (PAC), aluminum potassium sulfate (APS), and zinc sulfate (ZS)—for effective flocculation of I. galbana. The growth rate, photosynthetic performance, and fucoxanthin content were determined in re-suspended flocculated algal cells and in the flocculation supernatant cultured algal cells. The results showed that high growth rate and fucoxanthin accumulation were observed when FC was used as the flocculant in I. galbana cultures, which indicated that FC may cause less harm to I. galbana than the other aluminum-based flocculants. Furthermore, satisfactory flocculation efficiency was also observed when FC was used to flocculate I. galbana, and the FC dosage was less than that required for flocculation of I. galbana using PAC, APS, and AS. Thus, we selected FC as the optimal flocculant for harvesting I. galbana based on its flocculation efficiency together with algal physiological performance, growth rate, and fucoxanthin content.     

Inexpensive non-toxic flocculation of microalgae contradicts theories; overcoming a major hurdle to bulk algal production

There are two major energy and cost constraints to bulk production of single cell microalgae for biofuels or feed: expensive culture systems with high capital costs and high energy requirements for mixing and gas exchange; and the cost of harvesting using high-speed continuous centrifugation for dewatering. This report deals with the latter; harvesting by flocculation where theory states that alkaline flocculants neutralize the repelling surface charge of algal cells, allowing them to coalesce into a floc. It had been assumed that with such electrostatic flocculation, the more cells to be flocculated, the more flocculant needed, in a linear stoichiometric fashion, rendering flocculation overly expensive. Counter to theory of electrostatic flocculation, we find that the amount of alkaline flocculant needed is a function of the logarithm of cell density, with dense cultures requiring an order of magnitude less base than dilute suspensions, with flocculation occurring at a lower pH. Various other theories abound that flocculation can be due to multi-valent cross-linking, or co-precipitation with phosphate or with magnesium and calcium, but are clearly not relevant with the flocculants we used. Monovalent bases that cannot cross-link or precipitate phosphate work with the same log-linear stoichiometry as the divalent bases, obviating those theories, leaving electrostatic flocculation as the only tenable theory of flocculation with the materials used. The cost of flocculation of dense cultures with this procedure should be below $1.00/T algae for mixed calcium:magnesium hydroxides.     

Algal Flocculation with Synthetic Organic Polyelectrolytes

The feasibility of removing algae from water and wastewater by chemical flocculation techniques was investigated. Mixed cultures of algae were obtained from both continuous- and batch-fed laboratory reactors. Representative cationic, anionic, and nonionic synthetic organic polyelectrolytes were used as flocculants. Under the experimental conditions, chemically induced algal flocculation occurred with the addition of cationic polyelectrolyte, but not with anionic or nonionic polymers, although attachment of all polyelectrolyte species to the algal surface is shown. The mechanism of chemically induced algal flocculation is interpreted in terms of bridging phenomena between the discrete algal cells and the linearly extended polymer chains, forming a three-dimensional matrix that is capable of subsiding under quiescent conditions. The degree of flocculation is shown to be a direct function of the extent of polymer coverage of the active sites on the algal surface, although to induce flocculation by this method requires that the algal surface charge must concurrently be reduced to a level at which the extended polymers can bridge the minimal distance of separation imposed by electrostatic repulsion. The influence of pH, algal concentration, and algal growth phase on the requisite cationic flocculant dose is also reported.     

Effects of pH,Salinity, Biomass Concentration,and Algal Organic Matter on Flocculant Efficiency of Synthetic Versus Natural Polymers for Harvesting Microalgae Biomass

This study investigated the effects of pH, salinity, biomass concentration, and algal organic matter (AOM) on the efficiency of four commercial cationic flocculants. The tannin-based biopolymers Tanfloc SG and SL and the polyacrylamide polymers Flopam FO 4800 SH and FO 4990 SH were tested for flocculation of two microalgae models, the freshwater Chlorella vulgaris and the marine Nannochloropsis oculata. Both biomass concentration and AOM presence affected all polymers evaluated, whereas salinity and pH affected only Flopam and Tanfloc, respectively. A restabilization effect due to overdosing was only observed for Flopam polymers and increasing Tanfloc dose resulted in improved efficiency. Flopam polymers showed a significant decrease in the maximum quantum yield of photosystem II as function of polymer dose for Chlorella, which supported the need for toxicological studies to assess the potential toxicity of Flopam. In overall, Tanfloc was not affected by salinity nor presented potential toxicity therefore being recommended for the flocculation of both freshwater and marine species.     

Coagulation/flocculation-based removal of algal-bacterial biomass from piggery wastewater treatment

Two conventional chemical coagulants (FeCl₃ and Fe₂(SO₄)₃) and five commercial polymeric flocculants (Drewfloc 447, Flocudex CS/5000, Flocusol CM/78, Chemifloc CV/300 and Chitosan) were comparatively evaluated for their ability to remove algal-bacterial biomass from the effluent of a photosynthetically oxygenated piggery wastewater biodegradation process. Chlorella sorokiniana, Scenedesmus obliquus, Chlorococcum sp. and a wild type Chlorella, in symbiosis with a bacterial consortium, were used as model algal-bacterial consortia. While the highest biomass removals (66-98%) for the ferric salts were achieved at concentrations of 150-250 mg L⁻¹, dosages of 25-50 mg L⁻¹ were required for the polymer flocculants to support comparable removal efficiencies. Process efficiency declined when the polymer flocculant was overdosed. Biomass concentration did not show a significant impact on flocculation within the concentration range tested. The high flocculant requirements herein recorded might be due to the competition of colloidal organic for the flocculants and the stationary phase conditions of biomass.     

Flocculation of microalgae using cationic starch

Due to their small size and low concentration in the culture medium, cost-efficient harvesting of microalgae is a major challenge. We evaluated the potential of cationic starch as a flocculant for harvesting microalgae using jar test experiments. Cationic starch was an efficient flocculant for freshwater (Parachlorella, Scenedesmus) but not for marine microalgae (Phaeodactylum, Nannochloropsis). At high cationic starch doses, dispersion restabilization was observed. The required cationic starch dose to induce flocculation increased linearly with the initial algal biomass concentration. Of the two commercial cationic starch flocculants tested, Greenfloc 120 (used in wastewater treatment) was more efficient than Cargill C*Bond HR 35.849 (used in paper manufacturing). For flocculation of Parachlorella using Greenfloc 120, the cationic starch to algal biomass ratio required to flocculate 80% of algal biomass was 0.1. For Scenedesmus, a lower dose was required (ratio 0.03). Flocculation of Parachlorella using Greenfloc 120 was independent of pH in the pH range of 5 to 10. Measurements of the maximum quantum yield of PSII suggest that Greenfloc 120 cationic starch was not toxic to Parachlorella. Cationic starch may be used as an efficient, nontoxic, cost-effective, and widely available flocculant for harvesting microalgal biomass.     

Influence of changes in salinity and light intensity on growth of phytoplankton communities from the Schelde river and estuary (Belgium/The Netherlands)

In the Schelde continuum, a succession in the phytoplankton community is observed along the transition from the river to the freshwater tidal reaches of the estuary and from the freshwater to brackish reaches of the estuary. The goal of this study was to experimentally evaluate the contribution of changes in salinity and light climate to this succession. In summer 2000 and in spring 2001, phytoplankton communities from the river, the freshwater tidal reaches and the brackish reaches of the estuary were incubated under high or low light intensities and exposed to a change in salinity. HPLC analysis was used to evaluate the response of different algal groups to changes in light intensity and salinity. When incubated at a light intensity corresponding to the mean underwater light intensity of the freshwater tidal reaches, growth of phytoplankton from the river as well as from freshwater tidal reaches was significantly lower than when incubated at a light intensity corresponding to the mean underwater light intensity of the river. The phytoplankton community from the freshwater tidal reaches did not appear to be better adapted to low light intensities than the phytoplankton community from the river. Although diatoms were expected to be less sensitive to a reduction in light intensity than green algae, the opposite response was observed. Freshwater and brackish water phytoplankton were negatively affected by respectively an increase or decrease in salinity. However, the effect of salinity was not strong enough to explain the disappearance of freshwater and brackish water phytoplankton between a salinity of 0.5 and 10 psu, suggesting that other factors also play a role. In the freshwater phytoplankton communities from the river and the freshwater tidal reaches, green algae and diatoms responded in a similar way to an increase in salinity. In the brackish water phytoplankton community, fucoxanthin displayed a different response to salinity than lutein and chlorophyll a.     

Non-pollen palynomorphs in the Black Sea corridor

There have been few studies of non-pollen palynomorphs (NPP) in Holocene brackish water environments. The Black Sea is one of the world’s largest and deepest bodies of stable brackish water and a natural laboratory for study of marine carbon cycling to anoxic sediments. The main NPP in the modern sediments of this brackish water sea are dinoflagellate cysts (dinocysts), acritarchs (mainly the prasinophytes Cymatiosphaera, Micrhystridium, Sigmopollis and Pseudoschizaea) and diverse fungal remains. Other NPP include colonial algae, tintinnids, copepod and cladoceran egg covers, testate amoebae and microforaminiferal linings. These NPP assemblages are similar to those in the marginal marine environment of the Pliocene St. Erth Beds (England), but have more abundant NPP, and virtually lack scolecodonts. In the Black Sea corridor, modern assemblages from areas with salinity >22‰ have higher percentages of microforaminiferal linings and fewer prasinophytes, colonial algae and fungal spores. Prasinophytes dominate only in mid-Holocene sediments, during a 2000 years interval of sea level transgression and sapropel deposition. Early Holocene sediments have lower dinocyst diversity, increased fresh–brackish water colonial algae (Pediastrum spp. and Botryococcus braunii), zygnemataceous spores and desmids (including Zygnema, Cosmarium), ostracod linings and fewer foraminiferal linings. These assemblages are similar to those in the Baltic Sea where the annual salinity is about 6–8‰.     

The salinity preference of members of the genus Macroplea (Coleoptera, Chrysomelidae, Donaciinae), fully aquatic leaf beetles that occur in brackish water

Reed beetles (Donaciinae) of the genus Macroplea Samouelle, 1819 live permanently submerged. Literature indicates that Macroplea mutica occurs in brackish water, whereas Macroplea appendiculata is restricted to freshwater. The salinity preference of these two species was tested in a linear and a circular device that offered a continuous salinity gradient. The distribution of animals in the devices was monitored over at least 3 h in each of the 21 experiments. Both species preferred freshwater (salinity 0) over brackish water (salinity 10). In particular, this holds true for specimens collected in brackish water. Likewise, immediate reactions could be observed when during such experiments the direction of the gradient was reversed. While M. mutica can be regarded as a truly marine insect, this marine environment does not strictly reflect its fundamental niche with respect to salinity preference. This is in line with accumulating evidence that M. mutica can be found in freshwater habitats (and M. appendiculata in brackish water). This indicates that the species’ distribution might be influenced by other factors like host plant preference or dispersal mechanisms. It is discussed if—in spite of similar fundamental niches—differences in salinity tolerance (and hence performance in brackish water) may have contributed to speciation in the genus Macroplea.     

Toxicity and bioaccumulation of iron in soil microalgae

Microalgae are extensively used in the remediation of heavy metals like iron. However, factors like toxicity, bioavailability and iron speciation play a major role in its removal by microalgae. Thus, in this study, toxicity of three different iron salts (FeSO₄, FeCl₃ and Fe(NO₃)₃) was evaluated towards three soil microalgal isolates, Chlorella sp. MM3, Chlamydomonas sp. MM7 and Chlorococcum sp. MM11. Interestingly, all the three iron salts gave different EC50 concentrations; however, ferric nitrate was found to be significantly more toxic followed by ferrous sulphate and ferric chloride. The EC₅₀ analysis revealed that Chlorella sp. was significantly resistant to iron compared to other microalgae. However, almost 900 μg g^?1 iron was accumulated by Chlamydomonas sp. grown with 12 mg L^?1 ferric nitrate as an iron source when compared to other algae and iron salts. The time-course bioaccumulation confirmed that all the three microalgae adsorb the ferric salts such as ferric nitrate and ferric chloride more rapidly than ferrous salt, whereas intracellular accumulation was found to be rapid for ferrous salts. However, the amount of iron accumulated or adsorbed by algae, irrespective of species, from ferrous sulphate medium is comparatively lower than ferric chloride and ferric nitrate medium. The Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) analysis shows that the oxygen atom and P?=?O group of polysaccharides present in the cell wall of algae played a major role in the bioaccumulation of iron ions by algae.     

The flocculation of bacteria using cationic synthetic flocculants and chitosan

Summary Bacteria are flocculated with high molecular weight cationic synthetic flocculants and chitosan. High charge density polymers are the most effective of the synthetic flocculants. Only chitosan is effective in flocculating the E. coli and B. subtilis cultures in complex broth. The difference in effectiveness between the synthetic flocculants and chitosan for flocculating E. coli, B. subtilis and Z. mobilis may be attributed to hydrogen bonding between the polysaccharide flocculant and cell surface polymers in addition to electrostatic interactions, and, in complex media, complexation of synthetic polymers with anionic polyelectrolytes.     

Colour removal from landfill leachate by coagulation and flocculation processes

A study was conducted to investigate the efficiency of coagulation and flocculation processes for removing colour from a semi-aerobic landfill leachate from one of the landfill sites in Malaysia. Four types of coagulant namely aluminium (III) sulphate (alum), ferric (III) chloride, ferrous (II) sulphate and ferric (III) sulphate were studied using standard jar test apparatus. Results indicated that ferric chloride was superior to the other coagulants and removed 94% of colour at an optimum dose of 800 mg/l at pH 4. The effect of coagulant dosages on colour removal showed similar trend as for COD, turbidity and suspended solids. This suggested that colour in landfill leachate was mainly contributed by organic matters with some insoluble forms that exhibited turbidity and suspended solids readings. The results from this study suggested that ferric chloride could be a viable coagulant in managing colour problems associated with landfill leachate.     

Harvesting of microalgae using flocculation combined with dissolved air flotation

This study explored efficient methods of harvesting the Tetraselmis sp. KCTC12236BP using flocculation and dissolved air flotation. Concentration ranges of flocculation agents were optimized using jar tests (batch flocculation experiments) using inorganic (aluminum sulfate, ferric sulfate) and organic (chitosan) flocculants in a pH range of 4 ～ 10. The optimal dosage and pH level were 1.2 g/L and pH 5 ～ 6 for aluminum sulfate, 0.7 g/L and pH 4 ～ 8 for ferric sulfate, and 5.0 mg/mL and pH 7 ～ 8 for chitosan. The highest harvesting efficiency achieved with each of the four compounds was 85.6, 92.6, 93, and 91.3%, respectively.     

Elongation and mat formation of <Emphasis Type="Italic">Chara aspera</Emphasis> under different light and salinity conditions

Former laboratory results indicate that shoot elongation at low light intensities of Chara aspera is absent already at 10 psu which is within the physiologically optimal salinity range for brackish water populations. To investigate if similar restrictions occur in the field, density and morphology of C. aspera were compared between three freshwater and three brackish water sites along its depth range. The lower depth limit of C. aspera varied considerably among sites (30–600 cm) related to turbidity. Light availability at the lower depth limit corresponded to about 15% of surface irradiance in freshwater and brackish water with lower salinity (3.4 psu). Total length increased and fresh weight:length ratio decreased with depth at these sites indicating shoot elongation related to lower light availability. Due to shoot elongation, light availability was far higher at the upper parts of the shoot than at the bottom in the turbid sites. Light availability at the lower depth limit was higher (about 40%) at two sites with higher salinity (7–8 psu), where no shoot elongation was observed at the lower depth limit. Instead, the plants were stunted and often covered with filamentous algae or shaded by other rooted submerged macrophytes indicating competitive disadvantages of C. aspera at higher salinities. As growth in high densities (mat formation) exposes the plants to severe self-shading, it is suggested that shoot elongation is a prerequisite to mat formation. Dense vegetation of C. aspera was found only in freshwater and brackish water with lower salinity. Single, richly branched plants occurred in clearwater sites with higher salinity. C. aspera was not found in “double stress” environments with both high turbidity and high salinity: We asume that the species is a poor competitor under these conditions. Our results indicate that morphological differences between freshwater and brackish water populations of C. aspera are at least partly explained by salinity rather than genetic differences.     

Comparison of different artificial neural network architectures in modeling of Chlorella sp. flocculation

Biodiesel production from microalgae feedstock should be performed after growth and harvesting of the cells, and the most feasible method for harvesting and dewatering of microalgae is flocculation. Flocculation modeling can be used for evaluation and prediction of its performance under different affective parameters. However, the modeling of flocculation in microalgae is not simple and has not performed yet, under all experimental conditions, mostly due to different behaviors of microalgae cells during the process under different flocculation conditions. In the current study, the modeling of microalgae flocculation is studied with different neural network architectures. Microalgae species, Chlorella sp., was flocculated with ferric chloride under different conditions and then the experimental data modeled using artificial neural network. Neural network architectures of multilayer perceptron (MLP) and radial basis function architectures, failed to predict the targets successfully, though, modeling was effective with ensemble architecture of MLP networks. Comparison between the performances of the ensemble and each individual network explains the ability of the ensemble architecture in microalgae flocculation modeling.     

The released polysaccharide of the cyanobacterium Aphanothece halophytica inhibits flocculation of the alga with ferric chloride

The effect of the released polysaccharide (RPS) of the cyanobacterium Aphanothece halophytica GR02 on the recovery of the alga by flocculation with ferric chloride was studied. With increasing RPS concentration in algal cultures from 0 to 68 mg L⁻¹ the flocculation efficiency at the same dosage of ferric chloride decreased, and higher dosages of ferric chloride were required to attain the same flocculation efficiency. It is demonstrated that RPS could form complexes with ferrum during flocculation. In conclusion, RPS of A. halophytica GR02 had a significant inhibitory effect on flocculation of the alga with ferric chloride. The inhibitory mechanism of A. halophytica GR02 RPS allows the RPS to compete for ferrum by forming complexes with ferrum, thus leading to the consumption of ferrum in ferric chloride.