Differential effect of ECM molecules on re-expression of cartilaginous markers in near quiescent human chondrocytes

The limited source of healthy primary chondrocytes restricts the clinical application of tissue engineering for cartilage repair. Therefore, method to maintain or restore the chondrocyte phenotype during in vitro expansion is essential. The objective of this study is to establish the beneficial effect of ECM molecules on restoring the re‐expression of cartilaginous markers in primary human chondrocytes after extensive monolayer expansion. During the course of chondrocyte serial expansion, COL2A1, SOX9, and AGN mRNA expression levels, and GAG accumulation level were reduced significantly in serially passaged cells. Exogenous type II collagen dose‐dependently elevated GAG level and induced the re‐expression of cartilaginous marker mRNAs in P7 chondrocytes. Chondroitin sulfate did not show significant effect on P7 chondrocytes, while hyaluronic acid inhibited the expression of SOX9 and AGN mRNAs. Upon treatment with type II collagen, FAK, ERK1/2, and JNK were activated via phosphorylation in P7 chondrocytes within 15 min. Furthermore, GFOGER integrin blocking peptide, MEK inhibitor and JNK inhibitor, not p38 inhibitor, significantly reduced the type II collagen‐induced GAG deposition level. Finally, in the presence of TGF‐β1 and IGF‐I, P7 chondrocytes cultured in 3D type II collagen matrix exhibited better cartilaginous features than those cells cultured in the type I collagen matrix. In conclusion, type II collagen alone can effectively restore cartilaginous features of expanded P7 human chondrocytes. It is probably mediated via the activation of FAK‐ERK1/2 and FAK‐JNK signaling pathways. The potential application of type II collagen in expanding a scarcity of healthy chondrocytes in vitro for further tissue engineering is implicated. J. Cell. Physiol. 226: 1981–1988, 2011. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Effects of oxygen and culture system on in vitro propagation and redifferentiation of osteoarthritic human articular chondrocytes

Regenerative medicine-based approaches for the repair of damaged cartilage rely on the ability to propagate cells while promoting their chondrogenic potential. Thus, conditions for cell expansion should be optimized through careful environmental control. Appropriate oxygen tension and cell expansion substrates and controllable bioreactor systems are probably critical for expansion and subsequent tissue formation during chondrogenic differentiation. We therefore evaluated the effects of oxygen and microcarrier culture on the expansion and subsequent differentiation of human osteoarthritic chondrocytes. Freshly isolated chondrocytes were expanded on tissue culture plastic or CultiSpher-G microcarriers under hypoxic or normoxic conditions (5% or 20% oxygen partial pressure, respectively) followed by cell phenotype analysis with flow cytometry. Cells were redifferentiated in micromass pellet cultures over 4 weeks, under either hypoxia or normoxia. Chondrocytes cultured on tissue culture plastic proliferated faster, expressed higher levels of cell surface markers CD44 and CD105 and demonstrated stronger staining for proteoglycans and collagen type II in pellet cultures compared with microcarrier-cultivated cells. Pellet wet weight, glycosaminoglycan content and expression of chondrogenic genes were significantly increased in cells differentiated under hypoxia. Hypoxia-inducible factor-3α mRNA was up-regulated in these cultures in response to low oxygen tension. These data confirm the beneficial influence of reduced oxygen on ex vivo chondrogenesis. However, hypoxia during cell expansion and microcarrier bioreactor culture does not enhance intrinsic chondrogenic potential. Further improvements in cell culture conditions are therefore required before chondrocytes from osteoarthritic and aged patients can become a useful cell source for cartilage regeneration.     

Human polymer-based cartilage grafts for the regeneration of articular cartilage defects

The use of autologous chondrocyte implantation (ACI) and its further development combining autologous chondrocytes with bioresorbable matrices may represent a promising new technology for cartilage regeneration in orthopaedic research. Aim of our study was to evaluate the applicability of a resorbable three-dimensional polymer of pure polyglycolic acid (PGA) for the use in human cartilage tissue engineering under autologous conditions. Adult human chondrocytes were expanded in vitro using human serum and were rearranged three-dimensionally in human fibrin and PGA. The capacity of dedifferentiated chondrocytes to re-differentiate was evaluated after two weeks of tissue culture in vitro and after subcutaneous transplantation into nude mice by propidium iodide/fluorescein diacetate (PI/FDA) staining, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), gene expression analysis of typical chondrocyte marker genes and histological staining of proteoglycans and type II collagen. PI/FDA staining and SEM documented that vital human chondrocytes are evenly distributed within the polymer-based cartilage tissue engineering graft. The induction of the typical chondrocyte marker genes including cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) and cartilage link protein after two weeks of tissue culture indicates the initiation of chondrocyte re-differentiation by three-dimensional assembly in fibrin and PGA. Histological analysis of human cartilage tissue engineering grafts after 6 weeks of subcutaneous transplantation demonstrates the development of the graft towards hyaline cartilage with formation of a cartilaginous matrix comprising type II collagen and proteoglycan. These results suggest that human polymer-based cartilage tissue engineering grafts made of human chondrocytes, human fibrin and PGA are clinically suited for the regeneration of articular cartilage defects.     

Validation of a high-throughput microtissue fabrication process for 3D assembly of tissue engineered cartilage constructs

Described here is a simple, high-throughput process to fabricate pellets with regular size and shape and the assembly of pre-cultured pellets in a controlled manner into specifically designed 3D plotted porous scaffolds. Culture of cartilage pellets is a well-established process for inducing re-differentiation in expanded chondrocytes. Commonly adopted pellet culture methods using conical tubes are inconvenient, time-consuming and space-intensive. We compared the conventional 15-mL tube pellet culture method with 96-well plate-based methods, examining two different well geometries (round- and v-bottom plates). The high-throughput production method was then used to demonstrate guided placement of pellets within a scaffold of defined pore size and geometry for the 3D assembly of tissue engineered cartilage constructs. While minor differences were observed in tissue quality and size, the chondrogenic re-differentiation capacity of human chondrocytes, as assessed by GAG/DNA, collagen type I and II immunohistochemistry and collagen type I, II and aggrecan mRNA expression, was maintained in the 96-well plate format and pellets of regular size and spheroidal shape were produced. This allowed for simple production of large numbers of reproducible tissue spheroids. Furthermore, the pellet-assembly method successfully allowed fluorescently labelled pellets to be individually visualised in 3D. During subsequent culture of 3D assembled tissue engineered constructs in vitro, pellets fused to form a coherent tissue, promoting chondrogenic differentiation and GAG accumulation.     

The matrix-forming phenotype of cultured human meniscus cells is enhanced after culture with fibroblast growth factor 2 and is further stimulated by hypoxia

Human meniscus cells have a predominantly fibrogenic pattern of gene expression, but like chondrocytes they proliferate in monolayer culture and lose the expression of type II collagen. We have investigated the potential of human meniscus cells, which were expanded with or without fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2), to produce matrix in three-dimensional cell aggregate cultures with a chondrogenic medium at low (5%) and normal (20%) oxygen tension. The presence of FGF2 during the expansion of meniscus cells enhanced the re-expression of type II collagen 200-fold in subsequent three-dimensional cell aggregate cultures. This was increased further (400-fold) by culture in 5% oxygen. Cell aggregates of FGF2-expanded meniscus cells accumulated more proteoglycan (total glycosaminoglycan) over 14 days and deposited a collagen II-rich matrix. The gene expression of matrix-associated proteoglycans (biglycan and fibromodulin) was also increased by FGF2 and hypoxia. Meniscus cells after expansion in monolayer can therefore respond to chondrogenic signals, and this is enhanced by FGF2 during expansion and low oxygen tension during aggregate cultures.     

P38 mitogen‐activated protein kinase promotes dedifferentiation of primary articular chondrocytes in monolayer culture

Articular cartilage is an avascular tissue with poor regenerative capacity following injury, a contributing factor to joint degenerative disease. Cell‐based therapies for cartilage tissue regeneration have rapidly advanced; however, expansion of autologous chondrocytes in vitro using standard methods causes ‘dedifferentiation’ into fibroblastic cells. Mitogen‐activated protein kinase (MAPK) signalling is crucial for chondrocyte metabolism and matrix production, and changes in MAPK signals can affect the phenotype of cultured cells. We investigated the effects of inhibition of MAPK signalling on chondrocyte dedifferentiation during monolayer culture. Blockade of extracellular signal‐regulated kinase (ERK) and c‐Jun N‐terminal kinase (JNK) signalling caused a significant increase in cartilage gene expression, however, also caused up‐regulation of fibrotic gene expression. Inhibition of p38 MAPK (p38) caused a significant up‐regulation of collagen type II while suppressing collagen type I expression. P38 inhibition also resulted in consistently more organized secretion of collagen type II protein deposits on cell culture surfaces. Follow‐on pellet culture of treated cells revealed that MAPK inhibition reduced cell migration from the pellet. ERK and JNK inhibition caused more collagen type I accumulation in pellets versus controls while p38 inhibition strongly promoted collagen type II accumulation with no effect on collagen type I. Blockade of all three MAPKs caused increased GAG content in pellets. These results indicate a role for MAPK signalling in chondrocyte phenotype loss during monolayer culture, with a strong contribution from p38 signalling. Thus, blockade of p38 enhances chondrocyte phenotype in monolayer culture and may promote more efficient cartilage tissue regeneration for cell‐based therapies.     

The effect of TGF-beta1 and beta-estradiol on glycosaminoglycan and type II collagen distribution in articular chondrocyte cultures

Articular cartilage extracellular matrix (ECM) plays a crucial role in regulating chondrocyte functions via cell-matrix interaction, cytoskeletal organization and integrin-mediated signaling. Factors such as interleukins, basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), bone morphogenic proteins (BMPs) and insulin-like growth factor (IGF) have been shown to modulate the synthesis of extracellular matrix in vitro. However, the effects of TGF-beta1 and beta-estradiol in ECM regulation require further investigation, although there have been suggestions that these factors do play a positive role. To establish the role of these factors on chondrocytes derived from articular joints, a study was conducted to investigate the effects of TGF-beta1 and beta-estradiol on glycosaminoglycan secretion and type II collagen distribution (two major component of cartilage ECM in vivo). Thus, chondrocyte cultures initiated from rabbit articular cartilage were treated with 10ng/ml of TGF-beta1, 10nM of beta-estradiol or with a combination of both factors. Sulphated glycosaminoglycan (GAG) and type II collagen levels were then measured in both these culture systems. The results revealed that the synthesis of GAG and type II collagen was shown to be enhanced in the TGF-beta1 treated cultures. This increase was also noted when TGF-beta1 and beta-estradiol were both used as culture supplements. However, beta-estradiol alone did not appear to affect GAG or type II collagen deposition. There was also no difference between the amount of collagen type II and GAG being expressed when chondrocyte cultures were treated with TGF-beta1 when compared with cultures treated with combined factors. From this, we conclude that although TGF-beta1 appears to stimulate chondrocyte ECM synthesis, beta-estradiol fails to produce similar effects. The findings of this study confirm that contrary to previous claims, beta-estradiol has little or no effect on chondrocyte ECM synthesis. Furthermore, the use of TGF-beta1 may be useful in future studies looking into biological mechanisms by which ECM synthesis in chondrocyte cultures can be augmented, particularly for clinical application.     

The effect of oxygen tension on human articular chondrocyte matrix synthesis: Integration of experimental and computational approaches

Significant oxygen gradients occur within tissue engineered cartilaginous constructs. Although oxygen tension is an important limiting parameter in the development of new cartilage matrix, its precise role in matrix formation by chondrocytes remains controversial, primarily due to discrepancies in the experimental setup applied in different studies. In this study, the specific effects of oxygen tension on the synthesis of cartilaginous matrix by human articular chondrocytes were studied using a combined experimental‐computational approach in a “scaffold‐free” 3D pellet culture model. Key parameters including cellular oxygen uptake rate were determined experimentally and used in conjunction with a mathematical model to estimate oxygen tension profiles in 21‐day cartilaginous pellets. A threshold oxygen tension (pO₂ ≈ 8% atmospheric pressure) for human articular chondrocytes was estimated from these inferred oxygen profiles and histological analysis of pellet sections. Human articular chondrocytes that experienced oxygen tension below this threshold demonstrated enhanced proteoglycan deposition. Conversely, oxygen tension higher than the threshold favored collagen synthesis. This study has demonstrated a close relationship between oxygen tension and matrix synthesis by human articular chondrocytes in a “scaffold‐free” 3D pellet culture model, providing valuable insight into the understanding and optimization of cartilage bioengineering approaches. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2014;111: 1876–1885. © 2014 The Authors. Biotechnology and Bioengineering Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Enhanced cartilage tissue engineering by sequential exposure of chondrocytes to FGF-2 during 2D expansion and BMP-2 during 3D cultivation

Bovine calf articular chondrocytes, either primary or expanded in monolayers (2D) with or without 5 ng/ml fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF-2), were cultured on three-dimensional (3D) biodegradable polyglycolic acid (PGA) scaffolds with or without 10 ng/ml bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2). Chondrocytes expanded without FGF-2 exhibited high intensity immunostaining for smooth muscle alpha-actin (SMA) and collagen type I and induced shrinkage of the PGA scaffold, thus resembling contractile fibroblasts. Chondrocytes expanded in the presence of FGF-2 and cultured 6 weeks on PGA scaffolds yielded engineered cartilage with 3.7-fold higher cell number, 4.2-fold higher wet weight, and 2.8-fold higher wet weight glycosaminoglycan (GAG) fraction than chondrocytes expanded without FGF-2. Chondrocytes expanded with FGF-2 and cultured on PGA scaffolds in the presence of BMP-2 for 6 weeks yielded engineered cartilage with similar cellularity and size, 1.5-fold higher wet weight GAG fraction, and more homogenous GAG distribution than the corresponding engineered cartilage cultured without BMP-2. The presence of BMP-2 during 3D culture had no apparent effect on primary chondrocytes or those expanded without FGF-2. In summary, the presence of FGF-2 during 2D expansion reduced chondrocyte expression of fibroblastic molecules and induced responsiveness to BMP-2 during 3D cultivation on PGA scaffolds.     

Effect of reduced oxygen tension and long-term mechanical stimulation on chondrocyte-polymer constructs

We have investigated the influence of long-term confined dynamic compression and surface motion under low oxygen tension on tissue-engineered cell-scaffold constructs. Porous polyurethane scaffolds (8 mm × 4 mm) were seeded with bovine articular chondrocytes and cultured under normoxic (21% O₂) or hypoxic (5% O₂) conditions for up to 4 weeks. By means of our joint-simulating bioreactor, cyclic axial compression (10–20%; 0.5 Hz) was applied for 1 h daily with a ceramic ball, which simultaneously oscillated over the construct surface (±25°; 0.5 Hz). Culture under reduced oxygen tension resulted in an increase in mRNA levels of type II collagen and aggrecan, whereas the expression of type I collagen was down-regulated at early time points. A higher glycosaminoglycan content was found in hypoxic than in normoxic constructs. Immunohistochemical analysis showed more intense type II and weaker type I collagen staining in hypoxic than in normoxic cultures. Type II collagen gene expression was slightly elevated after short-term loading, whereas aggrecan mRNA levels were not influenced by the applied mechanical stimuli. Of importance, the combination of loading and low oxygen tension resulted in a further down-regulation of collagen type I mRNA expression, contributing to the stabilization of the chondrocytic phenotype. Histological results confirmed the beneficial effect of mechanical loading on chondrocyte matrix synthesis. Thus, mechanical stimulation combined with low oxygen tension is an effective tool for modulating the chondrocytic phenotype and should be considered when chondrocytes or mesenchymal stem cells are cultured and differentiated with the aim of generating cartilage-like tissue in vitro. This work was supported by the Swiss National Science Foundation (grant no. 3200B0-104083).     

INTEGRIN EXPRESSION AND COLLAGEN TYPE II IMPLICATED IN MAINTENANCE OF CHONDROCYTE SHAPE IN MONOLAYER CULTURE: AN IMMUNOMORPHOLOGICAL STUDY

Chondrocytes grown in monolayer culture at low density, with serum added, either dedifferentiate after several days whereby their cell shape changes or they are overgrown by fibroblast-like cells. The aim of this study was to optimize the cultivation of chondrocytes in monolayer culture and to slow down their transformation or their overgrowth by fibroblast-like cells. For this purpose freshly isolated chondrocytes of cartilage anlagen from 17-day-old mouse embryos were grown on plastic or collagen type II-coated substrates. With this model: (a) chondrocytes grown on plastic substrates had almost completely changed to fibroblast-like cells after 5 days in culture. (b) When grown on collagen type II, the chondrocytes maintained their round phenotype for more than 2 weeks in culture. (c) Immunomorphological investigations showed that chondrocytes produce collagen type II and fibronectin and express specific surface receptors (integrins of the β1-group) on the membrane from day 1 until the end of the culture period when grown on collagen type II. (d) Treatment with β1-integrin antibodies clearly reduces chondrocyte adhesion on collagen type II by about 70%. Hence, these data indicate that the most probable influence of collagen type II on cellular behaviour depends on the integrins participating in a chondrocyte—collagen type II interaction, and this model represents a pure chondrocyte culture which allows cell growth for an extended period.     

The influence of oxygen and hydrostatic pressure on articular chondrocytes and adherent bone marrow cells in vitro

Tissue engineering of articular cartilage from chondrocytes or stem cells is considered to be a potential aspect in the treatment of cartilage defects. In order to optimize culture conditions the influence of low oxygen tension (5%) - single or in combination with intermittent hydrostatic pressure (HP: 30/2 min on/off loading; 0.2 MPa) - on the biosynthetic activity (sulfate and proline incorporation) of human osteoarthritic chondrocytes cultured on collagen I/III membranes was investigated. Additionally, chondrogenesis from high density or monolayer cultures of bovine adherent bone marrow cells (aBMC) with and without chondrogenic medium supplements (CM) was analyzed by RT-PCR (mRNA expression of aggrecan and collagen type II). We could show that low oxygen tension increases significantly the biosynthesis of collagen I/III membrane-associated chondrocytes and even higher under co-stimulation with HP. While there is no chondrogenesis in monolayer cultures, CM induces expression of cartilage matrix molecules in high density cultures of aBMC which is even increased under the influence of low oxygen tension. Both, low oxygen tension and HP without CM are alone not sufficient stimuli for chondrogenesis. It can be concluded that low oxygen tension and HP might be useful tools in cartilage tissue engineering and that these physico-chemical factors promote but do not induce chondrogenesis under the given conditions.     

Effects of extracellular matrix proteins in chondrocyte‐derived matrices on chondrocyte functions

Loss of cartilaginous phenotype during in vitro expansion culture of chondrocytes is a major barrier to the application of chondrocytes for tissue engineering. In previous study, we showed that dedifferentiation of chondrocytes during the passage culture was delayed by matrices formed by primary chondrocytes (P0‐ECM). In this study, we investigated bovine chondrocyte functions when being cultured on isolated extracellular matrix (ECM) protein‐coated substrata and P0‐ECM. Low chondrocyte attachment was observed on aggrecan‐coated substratum and P0‐ECM. Cell proliferation on aggrecan‐ and type II collagen/aggrecan‐coated substrata and P0‐ECM was lower than that on the other ECM protein (type I collagen and type II collagen)‐coated substrata. When chondrocytes were subcultured on aggrecan‐coated substratum, decline of cartilaginous gene expression was delayed, which was similar to the cells subcultured on P0‐ECM. These results indicate that aggrecan plays an important role in the regulation of chondrocyte functions and P0‐ECM may be a good experimental control for investigating the role of each ECM protein in cartilage ECM. © 2013 American Institute of Chemical Engineers Biotechnol. Prog., 29:1331–1336, 2013     

Comparative chondrogenesis of human cells in a 3D integrated experimental–computational mechanobiology model

We present an integrated experimental–computational mechanobiology model of chondrogenesis. The response of human articular chondrocytes to culture medium perfusion, versus perfusion associated with cyclic pressurisation, versus non-perfused culture, was compared in a pellet culture model, and multiphysic computation was used to quantify oxygen transport and flow dynamics in the various culture conditions. At 2 weeks of culture, the measured cell metabolic activity and the matrix content in collagen type II and aggrecan were greatest in the perfused+pressurised pellets. The main effects of perfusion alone, relative to static controls, were to suppress collagen type I and GAG contents, which were greatest in the non-perfused pellets. All pellets showed a peripheral layer of proliferating cells, which was thickest in the perfused pellets, and most pellets showed internal gradients in cell density and matrix composition. In perfused pellets, the computed lowest oxygen concentration was 0.075 mM (7.5% tension), the maximal oxygen flux was 477.5 nmol/m²/s and the maximal fluid shear stress, acting on the pellet surface, was 1.8 mPa (0.018 dyn/cm²). In the non-perfused pellets, the lowest oxygen concentration was 0.003 mM (0.3% tension) and the maximal oxygen flux was 102.4 nmol/m²/s. A local correlation was observed, between the gradients in pellet properties obtained from histology, and the oxygen fields calculated with multiphysic simulation. Our results show up-regulation of hyaline matrix protein production by human chondrocytes in response to perfusion associated with cyclic pressurisation. These results could be favourably exploited in tissue engineering applications.     

Influence of oxygen on the proliferation and metabolism of adipose derived adult stem cells

Articular cartilage is an avascular connective tissue that exhibits little intrinsic capacity for repair. Articular cartilage exists in a reduced oxygen ( approximately 5%) environment in vivo; therefore, oxygen tension may be an important factor that regulates the metabolism of chondrocyte progenitors. A number of recent studies have developed tissue engineering approaches for promoting cartilage repair using undifferentiated progenitor cells seeded on biomaterial scaffolds, but little is known about how oxygen might influence these engineered tissues. Human adipose-derived adult stem (hADAS) cells isolated from the stroma of subcutaneous fat were suspended in alginate beads and cultured in control or chondrogenic media in either low oxygen (5%) or atmospheric oxygen tension (20%) for up to 14 days. Under chondrogenic conditions, low oxygen tension significantly inhibited the proliferation of hADAS cells, but induced a two-fold increase in the rate of protein synthesis and a three-fold increase in total collagen synthesis. Low oxygen tension also increased glycosaminoglycan synthesis at certain timepoints. Immunohistochemical analysis showed significant production of cartilage-associated matrix molecules, including collagen type II and chondroitin-4-sulfate. These findings suggest oxygen tension may play an important role in regulating the proliferation and metabolism of hADAS cells as they undergo chondrogenesis, and the exogenous control of oxygen tension may provide a means of increasing the overall accumulation of matrix macromolecules in tissue-engineered cartilage.     

Combination of reduced oxygen tension and intermittent hydrostatic pressure: a useful tool in articular cartilage tissue engineering.

Cartilage cells are normally studied under atmospheric pressure conditions and without loading. However, since cartilage exists in a condition of reduced oxygen and intermittent hydrostatic pressure we hypothesized lower partial oxygen pressures (PO2) and different intermittent hydrostatic pressures (IHP) would increase articular chondrocyte proliferation and matrix production and to stabilize chondrocyte phenotype in vitro. Monolayers of adult bovine articular chondrocytes were cultured under 5% or 21% PO2 in combination with IHP (0.2 MPa amplitude, frequencies 5/5s = 0.1 Hz, 30/2 or 2/30 min on/off loading). We measured proliferation (3H-thymidine incorporation) and collagen secretion (protein-binding assay, collagen type II-ELISA and immunocytochemical staining of pericellular collagen types I, II and IX). Reduced PO2 stimulated proliferation and collagen type II and IX secretion of chondrocytes in comparison to 21% PO2. Additionally, collagen type I expression was delayed by low PO2, indicating a stabilization of the cell phenotype. IHP 5/5s and 30/2 min inhibited proliferation but increased collagen secretion (pericellular collagen type IX was decreased). IHP 30/2 min delayed first expression of collagen type I. In contrast, IHP 2/30 min increased proliferation, but lowered collagen expression. All stimulating or inhibiting effects of PO2 and IHP were additive and vice versa. Reduced PO2 and different settings of IHP increased proliferation, collagen secretion, and phenotype stability of chondrocytes. The oxygen- and IHP-induced effects were additive, suggesting that a combination of these parameters might be a useful tool in cartilage tissue engineering.     

Extent of cell differentiation and capacity for cartilage synthesis in human adult adipose‐derived stem cells: Comparison with fetal chondrocytes

This study evaluated the extent of differentiation and cartilage biosynthetic capacity of human adult adipose‐derived stem cells relative to human fetal chondrocytes. Both types of cell were seeded into nonwoven‐mesh polyglycolic acid (PGA) scaffolds and cultured under dynamic conditions with and without addition of TGF‐β1 and insulin. Gene expression for aggrecan and collagen type II was upregulated in the stem cells in the presence of growth factors, and key components of articular cartilage such as glycosaminoglycan (GAG) and collagen type II were synthesized in cultured tissue constructs. However, on a per cell basis and in the presence of growth factors, accumulation of GAG and collagen type II were, respectively, 3.4‐ and 6.1‐fold lower in the stem cell cultures than in the chondrocyte cultures. Although the stem cells synthesized significantly higher levels of total collagen than the chondrocytes, only about 2.4% of this collagen was collagen type II. Relative to cultures without added growth factors, treatment of the stem cells with TGF‐β1 and insulin resulted in a 59% increase in GAG synthesis, but there was no significant change in collagen production even though collagen type II gene expression was upregulated 530‐fold. In contrast, in the chondrocyte cultures, synthesis of collagen type II and levels of collagen type II as a percentage of total collagen more than doubled after growth factors were applied. Although considerable progress has been achieved to develop differentiation strategies and scaffold‐based culture techniques for adult mesenchymal stem cells, the extent of differentiation of human adipose‐derived stem cells in this study and their capacity for cartilage synthesis fell considerably short of those of fetal chondrocytes. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2010;107: 393–401. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.