Assembly of complex organelles: pilus biogenesis in gram-negative bacteria as a model system

Pathogenic bacteria assemble a variety of adhesive structures on their surface for attachment to host cells. Some of these structures are quite complex. For example, the hair-like organelles known as pili or fimbriae are generally composed of several components and often exhibit composite morphologies. In gram-negative bacteria assembly of pili requires that the subunits cross the cytoplasmic membrane, fold correctly in the periplasm, target to the outer membrane, assemble into an ordered structure, and cross the outer membrane to the cell surface. Thus, pilus biogenesis provides a model for a number of basic biological problems including protein folding, trafficking, secretion, and the ordered assembly of proteins into complex structures. P pilus biogenesis represents one of the best-understood pilus systems. P pili are produced by 80-90% of all pyelonephritic Escherichia coli and are a major virulence determinant for urinary tract infections. Two specialized assembly factors known as the periplasmic chaperone and outer membrane usher are required for P pilus assembly. A chaperone/usher pathway is now known to be required for the biogenesis of more than 30 different adhesive structures in diverse gram-negative pathogenic bacteria. Elucidation of the chaperone/usher pathway was brought about through a powerful combination of molecular, biochemical, and biophysical techniques. This review discusses these approaches as they relate to pilus assembly, with an emphasis on newer techniques.     

Transport of outer membrane lipids in mycobacteria

The complex organization of the mycobacterial cell wall poses unique challenges for the study of its assembly. Although mycobacteria are classified evolutionarily as Gram-positive bacteria, their cell wall architecture more closely resembles that of Gram-negative organisms. They possess not only an inner cytoplasmic membrane, but also a bilayer outer membrane that encloses an aqueous periplasm and includes diverse lipids that are required for the survival and virulence of pathogenic species. Questions surrounding how mycobacterial outer membrane lipids are transported from where they are made in the cytoplasm to where they function at the cell exterior are thus similar, and similarly compelling, to those that have driven the study of Gram-negative outer membrane transport pathways. However, little is understood about these processes in mycobacteria. Here we contextualize these questions by comparing our current knowledge of mycobacteria with better-defined systems in other organisms. Based on this analysis, we propose possible models and highlight continuing challenges to improving our understanding of outer membrane assembly in these medically and environmentally important bacteria. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Bacterial Lipids edited by Russell E. Bishop.     

Type V secretion: From biogenesis to biotechnology

The two membranes of Gram-negative bacteria contain protein machines that have a general function in their assembly. To interact with the extra-cellular milieu, Gram-negatives target proteins to their cell surface and beyond. Many specialized secretion systems have evolved with dedicated translocation machines that either span the entire cell envelope or localize to the outer membrane. The latter act in concert with inner-membrane transport systems (i.e. Sec or Tat). Secretion via the Type V secretion system follows a two-step mechanism that appears relatively simple. Proteins secreted via this pathway are important for the Gram-negative life-style, either as virulence factors for pathogens or by contributing to the survival of non-invasive environmental species. Furthermore, this system appears well suited for the secretion of biotechnologically relevant proteins. In this review we focus on the biogenesis and application of two Type V subtypes, the autotransporters and two-partner secretion (TPS) systems. For translocation across the outer membrane the autotransporters require the assistance of the Bam complex that also plays a generic role in the assembly of outer membrane proteins. The TPS systems do use a dedicated translocator, but this protein shows resemblance to BamA, the major component of the Bam complex. Interestingly, both the mechanistic and more applied studies on these systems have provided a better understanding of the secretion mechanism and the biogenesis of outer membrane proteins. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein trafficking and secretion in bacteria. Guest Editors: Anastassios Economou and Ross Dalbey.     

Targeting of Neisserial PorB to the mitochondrial outer membrane: an insight on the evolution of β-barrel protein assembly machines

Mitochondria originated from Gram-negative bacteria through endosymbiosis. In modern day mitochondria, the Sorting and Assembly Machinery (SAM) is responsible for eukaryotic β-barrel protein assembly in the mitochondrial outer membrane. The SAM is the functional equivalent of the β-barrel assembly machinery found in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria. In this study we examined the import pathway of a pathogenic bacterial protein, PorB, which is targeted from pathogenic Neisseria to the host mitochondria. We have developed a new method for measurement of PorB assembly into mitochondria that relies on the mobility shift exhibited by bacterial β-barrel proteins once folded and separated under semi-native electrophoretic conditions. We show that PorB is targeted to the outer mitochondrial membrane with a dependence on the intermembrane space shuttling chaperones and the core component of the SAM, Sam50, which is a functional homologue of BamA that is required for PorB assembly in bacteria. The peripheral subunits of the SAM, Sam35 and Sam37, which are essential for eukaryotic β-barrel protein assembly but do not have distinguishable functional homologues in bacteria, are not required for PorB assembly in eukaryotes. This shows that PorB uses an evolutionary conserved 'bacterial like' mechanism to infiltrate the host mitochondrial outer membrane.     

Minor pseudopilin self-assembly primes type II secretion pseudopilus elongation

In Gram-negative bacteria, type II secretion systems (T2SS) assemble inner membrane proteins of the major pseudopilin PulG (GspG) family into periplasmic filaments, which could drive protein secretion in a piston-like manner. Three minor pseudopilins PulI, PulJ and PulK are essential for protein secretion in the Klebsiella oxytoca T2SS, but their molecular function is unknown. Here, we demonstrate that together these proteins prime pseudopilus assembly, without actively controlling its length or secretin channel opening. Using molecular dynamics, bacterial two-hybrid assays, cysteine crosslinking and functional analysis, we show that PulI and PulJ nucleate filament assembly by forming a staggered complex in the plasma membrane. Binding of PulK to this complex results in its partial extraction from the membrane and in a 1-nm shift between their transmembrane segments, equivalent to the major pseudopilin register in the assembled PulG filament. This promotes fully efficient pseudopilus assembly and protein secretion. Therefore, we propose that PulI, PulJ and PulK self-assembly is thermodynamically coupled to the initiation of pseudopilus assembly, possibly setting the assembly machinery in motion.     

The bacterial outer membrane β-barrel assembly machinery

β-Barrel proteins found in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria serve a variety of cellular functions. Proper folding and assembly of these proteins are essential for the viability of bacteria and can also play an important role in virulence. The β-barrel assembly machinery (BAM) complex, which is responsible for the proper assembly of β-barrels into the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria, has been the focus of many recent studies. This review summarizes the significant progress that has been made toward understanding the structure and function of the bacterial BAM complex.     

Assembly of the secretion pores GspD,Wza and CsgG into bacterial outer membranes does not require the Omp85 proteins BamA or TamA

In Gram‐negative bacteria, β‐barrel proteins are integrated into the outer membrane by the β‐barrel assembly machinery, with key components of the machinery being the Omp85 family members BamA and TamA. Recent crystal structures and cryo‐electron microscopy show a diverse set of secretion pores in Gram‐negative bacteria, with α‐helix (Wza and GspD) or β‐strand (CsgG) transmembrane segments in the outer membrane. We developed assays to measure the assembly of three distinct secretion pores that mediate protein (GspD), curli fibre (CsgG) and capsular polysaccharide (Wza) secretion by bacteria and show that depletion of BamA and TamA does not diminish the assembly of Wza, GspD or CsgG. Like the well characterised pilotins for GspD and other secretins, small periplasmic proteins enhance the assembly of the CsgG β‐barrel. We discuss a model for integral protein assembly into the bacterial outer membrane, focusing on the commonalities and differences in the assembly of Wza, GspD and CsgG.     

Crystal Structure of the Minor Pilin CofB,the Initiator of CFA/III Pilus Assembly in Enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli

Type IV pili are extracellular polymers of the major pilin subunit. These subunits are held together in the pilus filament by hydrophobic interactions among their N-terminal α-helices, which also anchor the pilin subunits in the inner membrane prior to pilus assembly. Type IV pilus assembly involves a conserved group of proteins that span the envelope of Gram-negative bacteria. Among these is a set of minor pilins, so named because they share their hydrophobic N-terminal polymerization/membrane anchor segment with the major pilins but are much less abundant. Minor pilins influence pilus assembly and retraction, but their precise functions are not well defined. The Type IV pilus systems of enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli and Vibrio cholerae are among the simplest of Type IV pilus systems and possess only a single minor pilin. Here we show that the enterotoxigenic E. coli minor pilins CofB and LngB are required for assembly of their respective Type IV pili, CFA/III and Longus. Low levels of the minor pilins are optimal for pilus assembly, and CofB can be detected in the pilus fraction. We solved the 2.0 Å crystal structure of N-terminally truncated CofB, revealing a pilin-like protein with an extended C-terminal region composed of two discrete domains connected by flexible linkers. The C-terminal region is required for CofB to initiate pilus assembly. We propose a model for CofB-initiated pilus assembly with implications for understanding filament growth in more complex Type IV pilus systems as well as the related Type II secretion system.     

The filamentous bacteriophage assembly proteins require the bacterial SecA protein for correct localization to the membrane.

The noncapsid assembly proteins pI and pI of the filamentous bacteriophage f1 are inserted into the inner membrane of Escherichia coli via an internal signal sequence. Inhibition of the activity of SecA with low concentrations of sodium azide results in rapid accumulation of pI and pI proteins in the cytoplasm. However, both proteins are inserted into the membrane under the same conditions when synthesized in bacteria containing a secA azide resistance mutation. The other noncapsid assembly protein, pIV, is an outer membrane protein synthesized with a cleavable signal sequence. Wild-type bacteria accumulate the precursor to pIV when protein synthesis is in the presence of low concentrations of sodium azide. These results suggest that the f1 bacteriophage assembly proteins require SecA and consequently the bacterial Sec system to reach their proper membrane location.     

VirB8: a conserved type IV secretion system assembly factor and drug target.

Type IV secretion systems are used by many gram-negative bacteria for the translocation of macromolecules (proteins, DNA, or DNA-protein complexes) across the cell envelope. Among them are many pathogens for which type IV secretion systems are essential virulence factors. Type IV secretion systems comprise 8-12 conserved proteins, which assemble into a complex spanning the inner and the outer membrane, and many assemble extracellular appendages, such as pili, which initiate contact with host and recipient cells followed by substrate translocation. VirB8 is an essential assembly factor for all type IV secretion systems. Biochemical, cell biological, genetic, and yeast two-hybrid analyses showed that VirB8 undergoes multiple interactions with other type IV secretion system components and that it directs polar assembly of the membrane-spanning complex in the model organism Agrobacterium tumefaciens. The availability of the VirB8 X-ray structure has enabled a detailed structure-function analysis, which identified sites for the binding of VirB4 and VirB10 and for self-interaction. Due to its multiple interactions, VirB8 is an excellent model for the analysis of assembly factors of multiprotein complexes. In addition, VirB8 is a possible target for drugs that target its protein-protein interactions, which would disarm bacteria by depriving them of their essential virulence functions.     

Assembly of β-barrel proteins into bacterial outer membranes

Membrane proteins with a β-barrel topology are found in the outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria and in the plastids and mitochondria of eukaryotic cells. The assembly of these membrane proteins depends on a protein folding reaction (to create the barrel) and an insertion reaction (to integrate the barrel within the outer membrane). Experimental approaches using biophysics and biochemistry are detailing the steps in the assembly pathway, while genetics and bioinformatics have revealed a sophisticated production line of cellular components that catalyze the assembly pathway in vivo. This includes the modular BAM complex, several molecular chaperones and the translocation and assembly module (the TAM). Recent screens also suggest that further components of the pathway might remain to be discovered. We review what is known about the process of β-barrel protein assembly into membranes, and the components of the β-barrel assembly machinery. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein trafficking and secretion in bacteria. Guest Editors: Anastassios Economou and Ross Dalbey.     

The Type 1 secretion pathway — The hemolysin system and beyond

Type 1 secretion systems (T1SS) are wide-spread among Gram-negative bacteria. An important example is the secretion of the hemolytic toxin HlyA from uropathogenic strains. Secretion is achieved in a single step directly from the cytosol to the extracellular space. The translocation machinery is composed of three indispensable membrane proteins, two in the inner membrane, and the third in the outer membrane. The inner membrane proteins belong to the ABC transporter and membrane fusion protein families (MFPs), respectively, while the outer membrane component is a porin-like protein. Assembly of the three proteins is triggered by accumulation of the transport substrate (HlyA) in the cytoplasm, to form a continuous channel from the inner membrane, bridging the periplasm and finally to the exterior. Interestingly, the majority of substrates of T1SS contain all the information necessary for targeting the polypeptide to the translocation channel — a specific sequence at the extreme C-terminus. Here, we summarize our current knowledge of regulation, channel assembly, translocation of substrates, and in the case of the HlyA toxin, its interaction with host membranes. We try to provide a complete picture of structure function of the components of the translocation channel and their interaction with the substrate. Although we will place the emphasis on the paradigm of Type 1 secretion systems, the hemolysin A secretion machinery from E. coli, we also cover as completely as possible current knowledge of other examples of these fascinating translocation systems. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Protein trafficking and secretion in bacteria. Guest Editors: Anastassios Economou and Ross Dalbey.     

Advances in understanding bacterial outer-membrane biogenesis

The outer membrane of gram-negative bacteria such as Escherichia coli serves as a protective barrier that controls the influx and efflux of solutes. This allows the bacteria to inhabit several different, and often hostile, environments. The assembly of the E. coli outer membrane has been difficult to study using traditional genetic and biochemical methods, and how all its components reach the outer membrane after being synthesized in the cytoplasm and cytoplasmic membrane, how they are assembled in an environment that is devoid of an obvious energy source, and how assembly proceeds without disrupting the integrity of this essential cellular structure are all fundamental questions that remain unanswered. Here, we review the new approaches that have led to the recent discovery of components of the machinery involved in the biogenesis of this distinctive cellular organelle.     

An essential role of Sam50 in the protein sorting and assembly machinery of the mitochondrial outer membrane

The preprotein translocase of the outer mitochondrial membrane (TOM complex) contains one essential subunit, the channel Tom40. The assembly pathway of the precursor of Tom40 involves the TOM complex and the sorting and assembly machinery (SAM complex) with the non-essential subunit Mas37. We have identified Sam50, the second essential protein of the mitochondrial outer membrane. Sam50 contains a beta-barrel domain conserved from bacteria to man and is a subunit of the SAM complex. Yeast mutants of Sam50 are defective in the assembly pathways of Tom40 and the abundant outer membrane protein porin, while the import of matrix proteins is not affected. Thus the protein sorting and assembly machinery of the mitochondrial outer membrane involves an essential, conserved protein.     

Assembly and function of the archaeal flagellum

Motility is a common behaviour in prokaryotes. Both bacteria and archaea use flagella for swimming motility, but it has been well documented that structures of the flagellum from these two domains of life are completely different, although they contribute to a similar function. Interestingly, information available to date has revealed that structurally archaeal flagella are more similar to bacterial type?IV pili rather than to bacterial flagella. With the increasing genome sequence information and advancement in genetic tools for archaea, identification of the components involved in the assembly of the archaeal flagellum is possible. A subset of these components shows similarities to components from type?IV pilus-assembly systems. Whereas the molecular players involved in assembly of the archaeal flagellum are being identified, the mechanics and dynamics of the assembly of the archaeal flagellum have yet to be established. Recent computational analysis in our laboratory has identified conserved highly charged loop regions within one of the core proteins of the flagellum, the membrane integral protein FlaJ, and predicted that these are involved in the interaction with the assembly ATPase FlaI. Interestingly, considerable variation was found among the loops of FlaJ from the two major subkingdoms of archaea, the Euryarchaeota and the Crenarchaeota. Understanding the assembly pathway and creating an interaction map of the molecular players in the archaeal flagellum will shed light on the details of the assembly and also the evolutionary relationship to the bacterial type?IV pili-assembly systems.     

Co-operation between different targeting pathways during integration of a membrane protein

Membrane protein assembly is a fundamental process in all cells. The membrane-bound Rieske iron-sulfur protein is an essential component of the cytochrome bc₁ and cytochrome b₆f complexes, and it is exported across the energy-coupling membranes of bacteria and plants in a folded conformation by the twin arginine protein transport pathway (Tat) transport pathway. Although the Rieske protein in most organisms is a monotopic membrane protein, in actinobacteria, it is a polytopic protein with three transmembrane domains. In this work, we show that the Rieske protein of Streptomyces coelicolor requires both the Sec and the Tat pathways for its assembly. Genetic and biochemical approaches revealed that the initial two transmembrane domains were integrated into the membrane in a Sec-dependent manner, whereas integration of the third transmembrane domain, and thus the correct orientation of the iron-sulfur domain, required the activity of the Tat translocase. This work reveals an unprecedented co-operation between the mechanistically distinct Sec and Tat systems in the assembly of a single integral membrane protein.     

Towards a systems biology approach to study type II/IV secretion systems

Many gram-negative bacteria produce thin protein filaments, named pili, which extend beyond the confines of the outer membrane. The importance of these pili is illustrated by the fact that highly complex, multi-protein pilus-assembly machines have evolved, not once, but several times. Their many functions include motility, adhesion, secretion, and DNA transfer, all of which can contribute to the virulence of bacterial pathogens or to the spread of virulence factors by horizontal gene transfer. The medical importance has stimulated extensive biochemical and genetic studies but the assembly and function of pili remains an enigma. It is clear that progress in this field requires a more holistic approach where the entire molecular apparatus that forms the pilus is studied as a system. In recent years systems biology approaches have started to complement classical studies of pili and their assembly. Moreover, continued progress in structural biology is building a picture of the components that make up the assembly machine. However, the complexity and multiple-membrane spanning nature of these secretion systems pose formidable technical challenges, and it will require a concerted effort before we can create comprehensive and predictive models of these remarkable molecular machines.     

New tools in an old trade: CS1 pilus morphogenesis

CS1 pili serve as the prototype for a large class of serologically distinct pili associated with enterotoxigenic Escherichia coli that cause diarrhoea in humans. The four genes essential for CS1 pilus morphogenesis, cooB, A, C and D, are arranged in an operon and encode structural and assembly proteins unlike those of other pilus systems commonly associated with Gram-negative bacteria. CS1 pili are composed primarily of the major pilin subunit, CooA, which determines the serological type of the pilus. The major pilin subunit is assembled into pili by the proteins CooB, CooC and CooD. CooD is both a minor component found at the pilus tip and an essential assembly protein, whereas CooC is an outer membrane protein thought to be involved in pilin transport. CooB is a novel periplasmic chaperone-like protein that forms intermolecular complexes with and stabilizes the major and minor pilins. Unlike other pilin chaperones, CooB also stabilizes the outer membrane component of the assembly system, CooC. The proteins of CS1 pili have no significant homology to those of the well-characterized Pap (pyelonephritis-associated) pili and related systems, although most of the features of pilus morphogenesis are similar. Therefore, these appear to be among the rare cases of convergent evolution. Thus, for CS1 pili, enterotoxigenic E. coli use new protein 'tools' in the old 'trade' of forming functional pili.     

Towards a systems biology approach to study type II/IV secretion systems

Many gram-negative bacteria produce thin protein filaments, named pili, which extend beyond the confines of the outer membrane. The importance of these pili is illustrated by the fact that highly complex, multi-protein pilus-assembly machines have evolved, not once, but several times. Their many functions include motility, adhesion, secretion, and DNA transfer, all of which can contribute to the virulence of bacterial pathogens or to the spread of virulence factors by horizontal gene transfer. The medical importance has stimulated extensive biochemical and genetic studies but the assembly and function of pili remains an enigma. It is clear that progress in this field requires a more holistic approach where the entire molecular apparatus that forms the pilus is studied as a system. In recent years systems biology approaches have started to complement classical studies of pili and their assembly. Moreover, continued progress in structural biology is building a picture of the components that make up the assembly machine. However, the complexity and multiple-membrane spanning nature of these secretion systems pose formidable technical challenges, and it will require a concerted effort before we can create comprehensive and predictive models of these remarkable molecular machines.     

Decoding the roles of pilotins and accessory proteins in secretin escort services

Secretins are channels that allow translocation of macromolecules across the outer membranes of Gram-negative bacteria. Virulence, natural competence, and motility are among the functions mediated by these large oligomeric protein assemblies. Filamentous phage also uses secretins to exit their bacterial host without causing cell lysis. However, the secretin is only a part of a larger membrane-spanning complex, and additional proteins are often required for its formation. A class of outer membrane lipoproteins called pilotins has been implicated in secretin assembly and/or localization. Additional accessory proteins may also be involved in secretin stability. Significant progress has recently been made toward deciphering the complex interactions required for functional secretin assembly. To allow for easier comparison between different systems, we have classified the secretins into five different classes based on their requirements for proteins involved in their assembly, localization, and stability. An overview of pilotin and accessory protein structures, functions, and characterized modes of interaction with the secretin is presented.