Balancing oxidative protein folding: The influences of reducing pathways on disulfide bond formation

Oxidative protein folding is confined to few compartments, including the endoplasmic reticulum, the mitochondrial intermembrane space and the bacterial periplasm. Conversely, in compartments in which proteins are translated such as the cytosol, the mitochondrial matrix and the chloroplast stroma proteins are kept reduced by the thioredoxin and glutaredoxin systems that functionally overlap. The highly reducing NADPH pool thereby serves as electron donor that enables glutathione reductase and thioredoxin reductase to keep glutathione pools and thioredoxins in their reduced redox state, respectively. Notably, also compartments containing oxidizing machineries are linked to these reducing pathways. Reducing pathways aid in proofreading of disulfide bond formation by isomerization or they provide reducing equivalents for the reduction of disulfides prior to degradation. In addition, they contribute to the thiol-dependent regulation of protein activities, and they help to counteract oxidative stress. The existence of oxidizing and reducing pathways in the same compartment poses a potential problem as the cell has to avoid futile cycles of oxidation and subsequent reduction reactions. Thus, compartments that contain oxidizing machineries have developed sophisticated ways to spatiotemporally balance and regulate oxidation and reduction. In this review, we discuss oxidizing and reducing pathways in the endoplasmic reticulum, the periplasm and the mitochondrial intermembrane space and highlight the role of glutathione especially in the endoplasmic reticulum and the intermembrane space. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Thiol-Based Redox Processes.     

Diverse pathways of oxidative folding of disulfide proteins: underlying causes and folding models

The pathway of oxidative folding of disulfide proteins exhibits a high degree of diversity, which is manifested mainly by distinct structural heterogeneity and diverse rearrangement pathways of folding intermediates. During the past two decades, the scope of this diversity has widened through studies of more than 30 disulfide-rich proteins by various laboratories. A more comprehensive landscape of the mechanism of protein oxidative folding has emerged. This review will cover three themes. (1) Elaboration of the scope of diversity of disulfide folding pathways, including the two opposite extreme models, represented by bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI) and hirudin. (2) Demonstration of experimental evidence accounting for the underlying mechanism of the folding diversity. (3) Discussion of the convergence between the extreme models of oxidative folding and models of conventional conformational folding (framework model, hydrophobic collapse model).     

Stabilities of disulfide bond intermediates in the folding of apamin.

Apamin is an 18-residue bee venom peptide with the sequence CNCKAPETALCARRCQQH-amide and contains 2 disulfide bonds connecting C-1 to C-11 and C-3 to C-15. In the folding of reduced, unfolded apamin to native apamin with two disulfide bonds, the one-disulfide folding intermediate states are not populated to significant levels. To study the properties of the one-disulfide intermediates, we have synthesized two peptide models to mimic the one-disulfide intermediates, Apa-1 and Apa-2, in which two cysteines in the sequence have been replaced by alanines. These peptides can form only one of the native disulfide bonds, C-1 to C-11 in the case of Apa-1 and C-3 to C-15 in the case of Apa-2. The stabilities of these disulfide bonds have been measured as a function of pH, concentration of urea, and temperature, in order to understand which contributions stabilize the disulfide-bonded structures. Using oxidized and reduced glutathione, the equilibrium constants for forming the disulfide bonds at 25 degrees C and pH 7.0 are 0.018 M for Apa-1 and 0.033 M for Apa-2 and show little dependence on pH or temperature. Both disulfide bonds are destabilized slightly (by approximately a factor of 2) between 0 and 8 M urea. Circular dichroism spectra indicate that although both Apa-1 and Apa-2 exhibit some structure, Apa-2 exhibits more than Apa-1. The results suggest that in the folding of apamin, the one-disulfide intermediate containing the C-3 to C-15 disulfide bond, as in Apa-2, is favored slightly. Secondary structure provides modest stabilization to this intermediate.     

The presence of a reducible disulfide bond in milk xanthine oxidase

The stoichiometry of reducing equivalents per protomer for the complex molybdoflavoprotein xanthine oxidase has been re-examined by reductive titrations with sodium dithionite and anaerobic reoxidation with cytochrome c and phenazine methosulfate of dithionite- or photo-reduced enzyme. It is found that 8.0 +/- 0.1 reducing equivalents are taken up (or given up) by the enzyme, a value of 2 eq greater than expected on the basis of the known oxidation-reduction centers in the enzyme. The reaction of reduced xanthine oxidase with [14C]iodoacetate indicates that, in the reduced form of the enzyme, additional cysteine residues are available for reaction. These results, in conjunction with the observation that reaction of oxidized enzyme with sulfite results in the appearance of an additional equivalent of thiol capable of reacting with 5,5'-dithiobis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid) or iodoacetate, indicate the presence of a disulfide linkage in the enzyme that can be reduced by dithionite or photochemically employing EDTA and 5-deazaflavin. Neither xanthine nor lumazine, however, is capable of reducing this oxidation-reduction center, suggesting that the disulfide does not play a role in the catalytic reactions of the enzyme. These results resolve discrepancies in the literature which indicated that greater than 6 reducing equivalents were consistently needed to bring about the complete reduction of xanthine oxidase.     

Manipulating disulfide bond formation and protein folding in the endoplasmic reticulum.

Addition of the reducing agent dithiothreitol (DTT) to the medium of living cells prevented disulfide bond formation in newly synthesized influenza hemagglutinin (HA0) and induced the reduction of already oxidized HA0 inside the ER. The reduced HA0 did not trimerize or leave the ER. When DTT was washed out, HA0 was rapidly oxidized, correctly folded, trimerized and transported to the Golgi complex. We concluded that protein folding and the redox conditions in the ER can be readily manipulated by addition of DTT without affecting most other cellular functions, that the reduced influenza HA0 remains largely unfolded, and that folding events that normally take place on the nascent HA0 chains can be delayed and induced post-translationally without loss in efficiency.     

Protein disulfide isomerase: the structure of oxidative folding

Cellular functions hinge on the ability of proteins to adopt their correct folds, and misfolded proteins can lead to disease. Here, we focus on the proteins that catalyze disulfide bond formation, a step in the oxidative folding pathway that takes place in specialized cellular compartments. In the endoplasmic reticulum of eukaryotes, disulfide formation is catalyzed by protein disulfide isomerase (PDI); by contrast, prokaryotes produce a family of disulfide bond (Dsb) proteins, which together achieve an equivalent outcome in the bacterial periplasm. The recent crystal structure of yeast PDI has increased our understanding of the function and mechanism of PDI. Comparison of the structure of yeast PDI with those of bacterial DsbC and DsbG reveals some similarities but also striking differences that suggest directions for future research aimed at unraveling the catalytic mechanism of disulfide bond formation in the cell.     

Effect of an engineered disulfide bond on the folding of T4 lysozyme at low temperatures

Equilibrium and kinetic effects on the folding of T4 lysozyme were investigated by fluorescence emission spectroscopy in cryosolvent. To study the role of disulfide cross-links in stability and folding, a comparison was made with a mutant containing an engineered disulfide bond between Cys-3 (Ile-3 in the wild type) and Cys-97, which links the C-terminal domain to the N terminus of the protein [Perry & Wetzel (1984) Science 226, 555]. In our experimental system, stability toward thermal and denaturant unfolding was increased slightly as a result of the cross-link. The corresponding reduced protein was significantly less stable than the wild type. Unfolding and refolding kinetics were carried out in 35% methanol, pH 6.8 at -15 degrees C, with guanidine hydrochloride as the denaturant. Unfolding/refolding of the wild-type and reduced enzyme showed biphasic kinetics both within and outside the denaturant-induced transition region and were consistent with the presence of a populated intermediate in folding. Double-jump refolding experiments eliminated proline isomerization as a possible cause for the biphasicity. The disulfide mutant protein, however, showed monophasic kinetics in all guanidine concentrations studied.     

Role of the [65-72] disulfide bond in oxidative folding of bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A

To assess the role of the [65-72] disulfide bond in the oxidative folding of RNase A, use has been made of [C65S, C72S], a three-disulfide-containing mutant of RNase A which regenerates from its two-disulfide precursor in an oxidation and conformational folding-coupled rate-determining step. The distribution of disulfide bonds in the one-disulfide-containing ensemble of this mutant has been characterized. In general, the disulfide-bond distribution in its 1S ensemble agrees relatively well with the corresponding distribution in wt-RNase A and with distributions based on calculations of loop entropy, except for the absence of the [65-72] disulfide bond. There is no bias (over the entropic influence) for the three native disulfide bonds, [26-84], [40-95], and [58-110]. Previous oxidative folding results for wt-RNase A indicated the predominance of the des [40-95] intermediate over des [65-72] after the rate-determining step in the regeneration process. Considering that there is no preferential distribution of disulfides in the 1S ensemble of [C65S, C72S], in contrast to the preferential population of the [65-72] disulfide bond in wt-RNase A, these results indicate a critical role for the [65-72] disulfide bond in the regeneration of wt-RNase A. Furthermore, analysis of the disulfide distribution of the 1S intermediates of [C65S, C72S] compared to that of wt-RNase A lends support for a physicochemical basis for the previously observed slow folding rate of this mutant, compared to its analogue (des [65-72]) of wt-RNase A.     

Time scale,geometrical constraints,and disulfide bond formation in the folding of small globular proteins

We hypothesize a model of protein folding based on the Poincaré recursion argument and a number of experimental results, including CD, nmr, and Raman spectra. Our model considers that protein folding in vivo proceeds through prefolded peptide segments consisting of 3 to 14 amino acid residues. Such segments may fold spontaneously into nativelike microdomains within a biologically feasible time, i.e., in the 10^?6–10^?1 s time scale. If, due to improper recognition and adjustment of their surfaces, these transiently formed secondary structures are not stabilized by long-range interactions, then the protein species occur within a time- and number-averaged spectrum of populations of transient conformational substates until the final, proper adjustment of the segments takes place. However, if, during protein folding, incorrect disulfide (S-S) bonds are formed, then such unique through-space contacts between the different parts of the polypeptide chain are usually restricted to a minimum. It is postulated that unfolding and refolding processes in vitro, and protein folding in vivo, proceed through variably populated quantized substates. The distribution of these substates depends on a number of molecular interactions between the phase and the hydration spheres surrounding the prefolded surfaces of peptide segments and long-range interactions between these prefolded surfaces.     

Oxidative folding of Amaranthus alpha-amylase inhibitor: disulfide bond formation and conformational folding

Oxidative folding is the fusion of native disulfide bond formation with conformational folding. This complex process is guided by two types of interactions: first, covalent interactions between cysteine residues, which transform into native disulfide bridges, and second, non-covalent interactions giving rise to secondary and tertiary protein structure. The aim of this work is to understand both types of interactions in the oxidative folding of Amaranthus alpha-amylase inhibitor (AAI) by providing information both at the level of individual disulfide species and at the level of amino acid residue conformation. The cystine-knot disulfides of AAI protein are stabilized in an interdependent manner, and the oxidative folding is characterized by a high heterogeneity of one-, two-, and three-disulfide intermediates. The formation of the most abundant species, the main folding intermediate, is favored over other species even in the absence of non-covalent sequential preferences. Time-resolved NMR and photochemically induced dynamic nuclear polarization spectroscopies were used to follow the oxidative folding at the level of amino acid residue conformation. Because this is the first time that a complete oxidative folding process has been monitored with these two techniques, their results were compared with those obtained at the level of an individual disulfide species. The techniques proved to be valuable for the study of conformational developments and aromatic accessibility changes along oxidative folding pathways. A detailed picture of the oxidative folding of AAI provides a model study that combines different biochemical and biophysical techniques for a fuller understanding of a complex process.     

Effect of an alternative disulfide bond on the structure, stability, and folding of human lysozyme

Human lysozyme has four disulfide bonds, one of which, Cys65-Cys81, is included in a long loop of the beta-domain. A cysteine-scanning mutagenesis in which the position of Cys65 was shifted within a continuous segment from positions 61 to 67, with fixed Cys81, has previously shown that only the mutant W64CC65A, which has a nonnative Cys64-Cys81 disulfide, can be correctly folded and secreted by yeast. Here, using the W64CC65A mutant, we investigated the effects of an alternative disulfide bond on the structure, stability, and folding of human lysozyme using circular dichroism (CD) and fluorescence spectroscopy combined with a stopped-flow technique. Although the mutant is expected to have a different main-chain structure from that of the wild-type protein around the loop region, far- and near-UV CD spectra show that the native state of the mutant has tightly packed side chains and secondary structure similar to that of the wild-type. Guanidine hydrochloride-induced equilibrium unfolding transition of the mutant is reversible, showing high stability and cooperativity of folding. In the kinetic folding reaction, both proteins accumulate a similar burst-phase intermediate having pronounced secondary structure within the dead time of the measurement and fold into the native structure by means of a similar folding mechanism. Both the kinetic refolding and unfolding reactions of the mutant protein are faster than those of the wild-type, but the increase in the unfolding rate is larger than that of the refolding rate. The Gibbs' free-energy diagrams obtained from the kinetic analysis suggest that the structure around the loop region in the beta-domain of human lysozyme is formed after the transition state of folding, and thus, the effect of the alternative disulfide bond on the structure, stability, and folding of human lysozyme appears mainly in the native state.     

The oxidative folding of proteins by disulfide plus thiol does not correlate with redox potential

The rate and yield of oxidative renaturation of reduced RNase A has been studied as a function of [-S-S-]/[-SH]. The principal conclusion of these studies is that rates and yields of oxidative renaturation are strongly dependent on the low mol. wt disulfide/thiol ratio. The relationships are complex and do not parallel the redox potential of the system. The present results are consistent with earlier findings on other proteins, and lead us to believe that the above conclusion is general. Kinetic studies of oxidative renaturation should recognize and account for the dependence of reaction rate and extent on the disulfide/thiol ratio. This ratio can change substantially over the course of a reaction, either due to stoichiometric transfer of disulfide to protein, and/or adventitious air oxidation of thiols. Failure to account for changes in the disulfide/thiol ratio may compromise the interpretation of such experiments.     

Statistics of disulfide bond formation in proteins

A new set of statistical expressions describing the reformation of disulfide bonds from SH groups is proposed. The results of the statistical calculations of disulfide bond reformation are discussed in terms of protein folding.     

Study of a major intermediate in the oxidative folding of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor: contribution of the fourth disulfide bond

The oxidative folding pathway of leech carboxypeptidase inhibitor (LCI; four disulfide bonds) proceeds through the formation of two major intermediates (III-A and III-B) that contain three native disulfide bonds and act as strong kinetic traps in the folding process. The III-B intermediate lacks the Cys19-Cys43 disulfide bond that links the beta-sheet core with the alpha-helix in wild-type LCI. Here, an analog of this intermediate was constructed by replacing Cys19 and Cys43 with alanine residues. Its oxidative folding follows a rapid sequential flow through one, two, and three disulfide species to reach the native form; the low accumulation of two disulfide intermediates and three disulfide (scrambled) isomers accounts for a highly efficient reaction. The three-dimensional structure of this analog, alone and in complex with carboxypeptidase A (CPA), was determined by X-ray crystallography at 2.2A resolution. Its overall structure is very similar to that of wild-type LCI, although the residues in the region adjacent to the mutation sites show an increased flexibility, which is strongly reduced upon binding to CPA. The structure of the complex also demonstrates that the analog and the wild-type LCI bind to the enzyme in the same manner, as expected by their inhibitory capabilities, which were similar for all enzymes tested. Equilibrium unfolding experiments showed that this mutant is destabilized by approximately 1.5 kcal mol(-1) (40%) relative to the wild-type protein. Together, the data indicate that the fourth disulfide bond provides LCI with both high stability and structural specificity.     

Transition state in the folding of alpha-lactalbumin probed by the 6-120 disulfide bond.

The guanidine hydrochloride concentration dependence of the folding and unfolding rate constants of a derivative of alpha-lactalbumin, in which the 6-120 disulfide bond is selectively reduced and S-carboxymethylated, was measured and compared with that of disulfide-intact alpha-lactalbumin. The concentration dependence of the folding and unfolding rate constants was analyzed on the basis of the two alternative models, the intermediate-controlled folding model and the multiple-pathway folding model, that we had proposed previously. All of the data supported the multiple-pathway folding model. Therefore, the molten globule state that accumulates at an early stage of folding of alpha-lactalbumin is not an obligatory intermediate. The cleavage of the 6-120 disulfide bond resulted in acceleration of unfolding without changing the refolding rate, indicating that the loop closed by the 6-120 disulfide bond is unfolded in the transition state. It is theoretically shown that the chain entropy gain on removing the cross-link from a random coil chain with helical stretches can be comparable to that from an entirely random chain. Therefore, the present result is not inconsistent with the known structure in the molten globule intermediate. Based on this result and other knowledge obtained so far, the structure in the transition state of the folding reaction of alpha-lactalbumin is discussed.     

Protein disulfide bond formation in the cytoplasm during oxidative stress

The majority of disulfide-linked cytosolic proteins are thought to be enzymes that transiently form disulfide bonds while catalyzing oxidation-reduction (redox) processes. Recent evidence indicates that reactive oxygen species can act as signaling molecules by promoting the formation of disulfide bonds within or between select redox-sensitive proteins. However, few studies have attempted to examine global changes in disulfide bond formation following reactive oxygen species exposure. Here we isolate and identify disulfide-bonded proteins (DSBP) in a mammalian neuronal cell line (HT22) exposed to various oxidative insults by sequential nonreducing/reducing two-dimensional SDS-PAGE combined with mass spectrometry. By using this strategy, several known cytosolic DSBP, such as peroxiredoxins, thioredoxin reductase, nucleoside-diphosphate kinase, and ribonucleotide-diphosphate reductase, were identified. Unexpectedly, a large number of previously unknown DSBP were also found, including those involved in molecular chaperoning, translation, glycolysis, cytoskeletal structure, cell growth, and signal transduction. Treatment of cells with a wide range of hydrogen peroxide concentrations either promoted or inhibited disulfide bonding of select DSBP in a concentration-dependent manner. Decreasing the ratio of reduced to oxidized glutathione also promoted select disulfide bond formation within proteins from cytoplasmic extracts. In addition, an epitope-tagged version of the molecular chaperone HSP70 forms mixed disulfides with both beta4-spectrin and adenomatous polyposis coli protein in the cytosol. Our findings indicate that disulfide bond formation within families of cytoplasmic proteins is dependent on the nature of the oxidative insult and may provide a common mechanism used to control multiple physiological processes.     

Contribution of individual disulfide bonds to the oxidative folding of ribonuclease A

The eight cysteine residues of ribonuclease A form four disulfide bonds in the native protein. We have analyzed the folding of three double RNase A mutants (C65A/C72A, C58A/C110A, and C26A/C84A, lacking the C65-C72, C58-C110, and C26-C84 disulfide bonds, respectively) and two single mutants (C110A and C26A), in which a single cysteine is replaced with an alanine and the paired cysteine is present in the reduced form. The folding of these mutants was carried out in the presence of oxidized and reduced glutathione, which constitute the main redox agents present within the ER. The use of mass spectrometry in the analysis of the folding processes allowed us (i) to follow the formation of intermediates and thus the pathway of folding of the RNase A mutants, (ii) to quantitate the intermediates that formed, and (iii) to compare the rates of formation of intermediates. By comparison of the folding kinetics of the mutants with that of wild-type RNase A, the contribution of each disulfide bond to the folding process has been evaluated. In particular, we have found that the folding of the C65A/C72A mutant occurs on the same time scale as that of the wild-type protein, thus suggesting that the removal of the C65-C72 disulfide bond has no effect on the kinetics of RNase A folding. Conversely, the C58A/C110A and C26A/C84A mutants fold much more slowly than the wild-type protein. The removal of the C58-C110 and C26-C84 disulfide bonds has a dramatic effect on the kinetics of RNase A folding. Results described in this paper provide specific information about conformational folding events in the regions involving the mutated cysteine residues, thus contributing to a better understanding of the complex mechanism of oxidative folding.     

Hepatitis C virus glycoprotein folding: disulfide bond formation and association with calnexin.

The hepatitis C virus (HCV) glycoproteins (E1 and E2) are released from the polyprotein by signal peptidase-mediated cleavage and interact to form a heterodimer. Since properly folded subunits are usually required for specific recognition and stable oligomer formation, the rate of stable E1E2 complex formation, which is low, may be limited by the rate of HCV E1 and/or E2 folding. In this study, the folding of the HCV E1 and E2 glycoproteins was monitored by observing the kinetics of intramolecular disulfide bond formation. The association/dissociation of E1 and E2 with calnexin was also examined, since this molecular chaperone appears to play a major role in quality control via retention of incompletely folded or misfolded proteins in the endoplasmic reticulum. Our results indicate that the disulfide-dependent folding of E2 occurs rapidly and appears to be complete upon cleavage of the precursor E2-NS2. In contrast, folding of E1 is slow (> 1 h), suggesting that this step may be rate limiting for E1E2 oligomerization. Both HCV glycoproteins associated rapidly with calnexin, but dissociation was slow, consistent with the slow folding and assembly of E1E2 glycoprotein complexes. These results suggest a role for prolonged association with calnexin in the folding and assembly of HCV glycoprotein heterodimer complexes.     

Evidence for intramolecular disulfide bond shuffling in the folding of mutant human lysozyme

Our previous results using the Saccharomyces cerevisiae secretion system suggest that intramolecular exchange of disulfide bonds occurs in the folding pathway of human lysozyme in vivo (Taniyama, Y., Yamamoto, Y., Kuroki, R., and Kikuchi, M. (1990) J. Biol. Chem. 265, 7570-7575). Here we report on the results of introducing an artificial disulfide bond in mutants with 2 cysteine residues substituting for Ala83 and Asp91. The mutant (C83/91) protein was not detected in the culture medium of the yeast, probably because of incorrect folding. Thereupon, 2 cysteine residues Cys77 and Cys95 were replaced with Ala in the mutant C83/91, because a native disulfide bond Cys77-Cys95 was found not necessary for correct folding in vivo (Taniyama, Y., Yamamoto, Y., Nakao, M., Kikuchi, M., and Ikehara, M. (1988) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 152, 962-967). The resultant mutant (AC83/91) was secreted as two proteins (AC83/91-a and AC83/91-b) with different specific activities. Amino acid and peptide mapping analyses showed that two glutathiones appeared to be attached to the thiol groups of the cysteine residues introduced into AC83/91-a and that four disulfide bonds including an artificial disulfide bond existed in the AC83/91-b molecule. The presence of cysteine residues modified with glutathione may indicate that the non-native disulfide bond Cys83-Cys91 is not so easily formed as a native disulfide bond. These results suggest that the introduction of Cys83 and Cys91 may act to suppress the process of native disulfide bond formation through disulfide bond interchange in the folding of human lysozyme.     

DsbA and DsbC-catalyzed oxidative folding of proteins with complex disulfide bridge patterns in vitro and in vivo

Oxidative protein folding in the periplasm of Escherichia coli is catalyzed by the thiol-disulfide oxidoreductases DsbA and DsbC. We investigated the catalytic efficiency of these enzymes during folding of proteins with a very complex disulfide pattern in vivo and in vitro, using the Ragi bifunctional inhibitor (RBI) as model substrate. RBI is a 13.1 kDa protein with five overlapping disulfide bonds. We show that reduced RBI can be refolded quantitatively in glutathione redox buffers in vitro and spontaneously adopts the single correct conformation out of 750 possible species with five disulfide bonds. Under oxidizing redox conditions, however, RBI folding is hampered by accumulation of a large number of intermediates with non-native disulfide bonds, while a surprisingly low number of intermediates accumulates under optimal or reducing redox conditions. DsbC catalyzes folding of RBI under all redox conditions in vitro, but is particularly efficient in rearranging buried, non-native disulfide bonds formed under oxidizing conditions. In contrast, the influence of DsbA on the refolding reaction is essentially restricted to reducing redox conditions where disulfide formation is rate limiting. The effects of DsbA and DsbC on folding of RBI in E.coli are very similar to those observed in vitro. Whereas overexpression of DsbA has no effect on the amount of correctly folded RBI, co-expression of DsbC enhanced the efficiency of RBI folding in the periplasm of E.coli about 14-fold. Addition of reduced glutathione to the growth medium together with DsbC overexpression further increased the folding yield of RBI in vivo to 26-fold. This shows that DsbC is the bacterial enzyme of choice for improving the periplasmic folding yields of proteins with very complex disulfide bond patterns.