Comparative Sensitivity of Various Cell Culture Systems for Isolation of Viruses from Wastewater and Fecal Samples

In efforts to define the most sensitive cell culture systems for recovery of viruses from wastewaters, 181 samples were inoculated in parallel into tube cultures of various cell types and were plaqued in bottle and petri dish cultures of three types of monkey kidney cells. Polioviruses were recovered most frequently in the RD line of human rhabdomyosarcoma cells, group A coxsackieviruses in RD and human fetal diploid kidney (HFDK) cells, group B coxsackieviruses in the BGM line of African green monkey kidney cells, echoviruses in RD and primary rhesus monkey kidney (RhMK) cells, and reoviruses in RhMK cells. BGM cells were unsatisfactory for recovery of viruses other than polioviruses and group B coxsackieviruses, and a line of fetal rhesus monkey kidney (MFK) was not a satisfactory substitute for primary RhMK. With RhMK cells, comparable numbers of virus isolations were made in tube cultures and in plaque assays conducted in bottle cultures, but with BGM and MFK cells, fewer isolations were made by plaquing than by inoculation of tube cultures. In comparative plaque assays on fecal samples under three different overlays in bottle and plate cultures of RhMK, BGM, and MFK cells, it was found that plaquing in the most sensitive system, RhMK, was less efficient for virus recovery than was inoculation of tube cultures of RhMK or HFDK cells. Overall, plaque assays performed in petri dishes in a CO₂ incubator yielded fewer virus isolates than did parallel plaque assays performed in closed bottle cultures. Other limitations of plaque assays for recovery of human enteric viruses are discussed.     

Fortified Sera and Their Use in Environmental Virology

Four commercially available fortified sera were compared to fetal bovine serum (FBS) with regard to their ability to maintain or increase the sensitivity of the Buffalo green monkey (BGM) kidney cell line to viral infection. Nine virus strains and five wastewater samples were used. Fortified sera were comparable to FBS for the enumeration of some viruses by the plaque method and for the detection of virus in wastewater by the most-probable-number assay.     

Dengue Virus Plaque Development in Simian Cell Systems: I. Factors Influencing Virus Adsorption and Variables in the Agar Overlay Medium

Chemical and physical variables influencing the plaquing of all dengue serotypes in two simian cell systems were studied. Calf serum in the nutrient overlay may be replaced by mouse ascitic fluid or bovine plasma albumin when employing the rhesus monkey kidney LLC-MK(2) cell system for plaquing all dengue serotypes. Doubling the serum concentration in the overlay had little effect in modifying dengue types 1, 2, 3, and 4 plaque titers. Newborn agamma, 4-week-old and 8-week-old calf serum gave comparable titers with all dengue virus serotypes. Dengue virus titers, plaque size, and development time were unaffected by sodium bicarbonate concentrations ranging from 1.1 to 4.4 mg/ml of overlay. A twofold increase (0.00332 g%) in the amount of either autoclaved or filtered-sterilized neutral red reduced the dengue 2 virus titer as much as 2.2 logs. An increased Mg(++) and decreased Ca(++) concentration in the overlay medium increased the efficiency of the plaquing system.     

Evaluation of mixed cell types and 5-iodo-2'-deoxyuridine treatment upon plaque assay titers of human enteric viruses

Four continuous cell lines, BGM, L-132, HEL-299, and RD, were compared both when cultured separately and as mixtures for use in plaque assay titrations of human adenovirus 1 and six human enterovirus serotypes. The effect of incubating these cell cultures in media containing 5-iodo-2'deoxyuridine (IDU) prior to inoculation with virus was also studied. The use of mixed-cell cultures revealed cell line-dependent synergistic effects as well as inhibitory effects. These effects were strongly virus dependent. In particular, enterovirus 69 did not form plaques on any of the four cell lines when cultured independently. However, it did form plaques on nearly all of the cell lines when cultured as mixtures. Contrary to this effect, when BGM cells were used in combination with the other cell lines, plaque counts for adenovirus 1 were greatly reduced. The effect of IDU pretreatment was also virus and cell line specific and enabled some viruses to form plaques on cell lines when they otherwise would not. Overall, IDU pretreatment resulted in an approximate twofold increase in plaque titers over those obtained without treatment.     

Evaluation of mixed cell types and 5-iodo-2'-deoxyuridine treatment upon plaque assay titers of human enteric viruses.

Four continuous cell lines, BGM, L-132, HEL-299, and RD, were compared both when cultured separately and as mixtures for use in plaque assay titrations of human adenovirus 1 and six human enterovirus serotypes. The effect of incubating these cell cultures in media containing 5-iodo-2'deoxyuridine (IDU) prior to inoculation with virus was also studied. The use of mixed-cell cultures revealed cell line-dependent synergistic effects as well as inhibitory effects. These effects were strongly virus dependent. In particular, enterovirus 69 did not form plaques on any of the four cell lines when cultured independently. However, it did form plaques on nearly all of the cell lines when cultured as mixtures. Contrary to this effect, when BGM cells were used in combination with the other cell lines, plaque counts for adenovirus 1 were greatly reduced. The effect of IDU pretreatment was also virus and cell line specific and enabled some viruses to form plaques on cell lines when they otherwise would not. Overall, IDU pretreatment resulted in an approximate twofold increase in plaque titers over those obtained without treatment.     

Trypsin-treated Ma-104: a sensitive cell line for isolating enteric viruses from environmental samples

During a 1-year survey of enteroviruses in wastewater samples from the Lorraine area, three widely used continuous monkey kidney cell lines were tested: BGM, Vero, and trypsin-treated Ma-104. Decontaminated samples from secondary wastewater treatment plants (influent or effluent) were directly inoculated onto cells, and viruses were revealed after two passages with a liquid medium technique. Out of the total percentage of positive isolates with the three systems (32.7) 24.7% were found with Ma-104, 14.1% with BGM, and only 1.7% with Vero cells. Poliovirus was recovered more frequently with Ma-104 (12.3%) than with BGM (1.7%). Reovirus (3.5%) and echovirus (1.7%) were only found with Ma-104 cells; however, BGM cells allowed the isolation of a few group B coxsackieviruses (5.9%). It must be pointed out that 7.0% of samples with an unconfirmed cytopathic effect were found with BGM against 3.4% found with Ma-104, but they did not have significant differences. Because of its large spectrum of sensitivity, easy maintenance, and resistance to toxic effects, trypsin-treated Ma-104 may be recommended in conjunction with other cell lines for the detection of viruses from environmental samples, especially with the use of a liquid method.     

Fortified sera and their use in environmental virology

Four commercially available fortified sera were compared to fetal bovine serum (FBS) with regard to their ability to maintain or increase the sensitivity of the Buffalo green monkey (BGM) kidney cell line to viral infection. Nine virus strains and five wastewater samples were used. Fortified sera were comparable to FBS for the enumeration of some viruses by the plaque method and for the detection of virus in wastewater by the most-probable-number assay.     

Evaluation of cell lines and immunofluorescence and plaque assay procedures for quantifying reoviruses in sewage.

Twelve continuous cell lines were tested to determine their sensitivity to reovirus types 1, 2, and 3 isolated from sewage. Madin-Darby bovine kidney (MDBK), rhesus monkey kidney (LLC-MK2), and human embryonic intestinal (intestinal 407) cells were most sensitive, respectively. In a similar study, MDBK cells were more sensitive than LLC-MK2 and Buffalo green monkey kidney (BGM) cells to sewage-isolated, protamine-precipitated reoviruses which had not been serotyped and had no previous cell contact. Sewage-isolated, protamine-precipitated reoviruses were also used in conjunction with MDBK cells in a comparative evaluation of immunofluorescent cell count and plaque assay procedures. The immunofluorescence assay is more sensitive and more rapid than the plaque assay. Reoviruses in excess of 10(4)/liter of raw sewage were detected by the immunofluorescent cell count assay.     

Trypsin-treated Ma-104: a sensitive cell line for isolating enteric viruses from environmental samples.

During a 1-year survey of enteroviruses in wastewater samples from the Lorraine area, three widely used continuous monkey kidney cell lines were tested: BGM, Vero, and trypsin-treated Ma-104. Decontaminated samples from secondary wastewater treatment plants (influent or effluent) were directly inoculated onto cells, and viruses were revealed after two passages with a liquid medium technique. Out of the total percentage of positive isolates with the three systems (32.7) 24.7% were found with Ma-104, 14.1% with BGM, and only 1.7% with Vero cells. Poliovirus was recovered more frequently with Ma-104 (12.3%) than with BGM (1.7%). Reovirus (3.5%) and echovirus (1.7%) were only found with Ma-104 cells; however, BGM cells allowed the isolation of a few group B coxsackieviruses (5.9%). It must be pointed out that 7.0% of samples with an unconfirmed cytopathic effect were found with BGM against 3.4% found with Ma-104, but they did not have significant differences. Because of its large spectrum of sensitivity, easy maintenance, and resistance to toxic effects, trypsin-treated Ma-104 may be recommended in conjunction with other cell lines for the detection of viruses from environmental samples, especially with the use of a liquid method.     

Growth, plaque assay and immunofluorescent studies on Tataguine virus in cell culture.

The growth characteristics of Tataguine virus were studied in Cercopithecus monkey kidney (Vero); rhesus monkey kidney (LLC-MK2), baby hamster kidney (BHK-21); porcine kidney (PK-15), mouse fibroblasts (L-929) and Aedes albopictus cell monolayers. The virus replicated without producing any cytopathology in Vero, BHK-21 and Aedes albopictus: but not in the other three cell culture systems. Two or three subsequent serial blind passages in those cultures supporting the growth of the virus did not produce any appreciable increase in virus titre. Immunofluorescent staining of inoculated Vero cells demonstrated the presence of Tataguine virus antigen in the cytoplasm of infected cells. Plaques 1--1.5 mm in diameter were produced only in Vero cell culture. In neutralization tests performed on Tataguine virus, immune mouse and hamster sera, higher antibody titres were obtained by plaque reduction than mouse protection tests.     

Studies on Parainfluenza Virus Infections among Infants and Children in Sendai

A cell line sensitive enough for the recovery of all parainfluenza viruses and free of simian virus contamination frequently occurring in monkey kidney cells was sought. The VERO cell obtained from African monkey kidney was found suitable for the initial isolation of types 1, 2 and 3 parainfluenza viruses, although the cells did not always allow the successive transfer. Mixed cultures of VERO and HEp-2 cells were also useful in the recovery of various respiratory viruses including parainfluenza viruses. The characteristics of hemagglutinins of parainfluenza viruses were examined, and type 2 parainfluenza and SV5 viruses agglutinated both guinea pig and green monkey erythrocytes at 36 C, whereas types 1 and 3 parainfluenza viruses agglutinated only guinea pig erythrocytes. Thus parainfluenza viruses were divided into two groups by the presence or absence of hemagglutinins for green monkey erythrocytes. Identification of these parainfluenza isolates, employing HI microtechnique was simple and reliable, even with the first passage harvest, when guinea pig erythrocytes were used and the test read at 36 C. Specific standard antisera for these parainfluenza viruses were prepared by immunizing chickens intravenously and bleeding within a short period. These type-specific antisera were useful for the identification of parainfluenza isolates by HI test.     

Studies on the interaction between coxsackievirus A9 and HeLa cells. I. Plaque-forming ability of coxsackievirus A9 in HeLa cell cultures.

Most of the coxsackievirus A9 (CA 9 virus) including the prototype strain formed plaques in HeLa cell monolayers under agar overlay, although they showed little or no cytopathogenicity under fluid medium. These viruses were isolated or passaged in primary cynomolgus monkey kidney (MK) cell cultures, and the infectivity of any strain in terms of plaque-forming units was much higher in MK cells than in HeLa cells, even after plaque purification of the virus in HeLa cell cultures. CA 9 virus contained in the original throat swabs as well as some clones obtained by plaque purification in MK cells failed to form plaques in HeLa cells, but virus preparations obtained after several undiluted passages through MK cells included plaque-formers in HeLa cells, suggesting that such plaque (HeLa)-forming viruses may have developed at a certain rate during multiplication of the original non-plaque (HeLa)-forming virus population in MK cells. Out of four lines of HeLa cells examined, two, including a clonal line S3, failed to support plaque formation by CA 9 virus.     

Altered receptor specificity of coxsackievirus B3 after growth in rhabdomyosarcoma cells.

Serial "blind" passages in human rhabdomyosarcoma (RD) cells of prototype viruses from each of the six immunotypes of the group B coxsackieviruses (CB) resulted in the isolation of intratypic variants of CB1, CB3, CB5, and CB6. Each variant virus strain acquired the capacity to agglutinate human erythrocytes and produce small plaques on HeLa cells, although their serological specificity remained unchanged. An alteration in VP1 mobility in sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis was noted for CB3-RD. The CB3-RD variant was plaque purified on RD cells and studied for receptor interactions on both HeLa and RD cells. An attachment restriction appeared to exist for prototype CB3 on RD cells, whereas CB3-RD attached well to both cells. In attachment interference assays, HeLa cells saturated with CB3-RD blocked the attachment of CB3. In contrast, saturation of cells with CB1 (which shares a common receptor with parental CB3) failed to block the attachment of CB3-RD. This unidirectional receptor blockade suggested that a second site for the attachment of virions to receptors was acquired by the CB3-RD variant. Thus, more than one virus receptor specificity may be operative in the selection of host range virus mutants. The implications of this phenomenon as they may relate to pathogenesis are discussed.     

Alterations in Glycosphingolipid Patterns in a Line of African Green Monkey Kidney Cells Infected with Herpesvirus

The major glycosphingolipids (GSLs) of a line of African green monkey kidney cells (BGM) were characterized as glucosylceramide, lactosylceramide, galactosyl-galactosyl-glucosylceramide, and N-acetylgalactosaminyl-galactosyl-galactosyl-glucosylceramide. Neutral GSLs accounted for approximately 80% of the total GSLs isolated. The predominant gangliosides were N-acetylneuraminyl-galactosyl-glucosylceramide, N-acetylgalactosaminyl-N-acetylneuraminyl-galactosyl- glucosylceramide, and galactosyl-N-acetylgalactosaminyl-N-acetylneuraminyl -galactosyl-glucosylceramide. The incorporation of labeled galactose into GSLs was compared in mock-infected and herpes simplex virus type 1-infected BGM cells. Herpes simplex virus type 1 infection resulted in a three- to four-fold increase in galactose incorporation into glucosylceramide and a decrease in galactose incorporation into galactosyl-galactosyl-glucosylceramide and N-acetyl-galactosaminyl-galactosyl-galactosyl-glucosylceramide. The virus-induced alteration in the GSL labeling pattern occurred early in infection, before the release of infectious virus, and was not prevented by the presence of cytosine arabinoside. Treatment of uninfected BGM cells with cycloheximide resulted in alterations in the GSL pattern which were similar to those observed in herpes simplex virus type 1-infected cells. These observations suggest that an early virus function such as inhibition of host cell protein synthesis is responsible for the observed alterations of GSL metabolism. Experiments with a syncytium-producing strain of herpes simplex virus type 1, herpes simplex virus type 2, and pseudorabies virus indicated that other herpes viruses altered GSL metabolism in a manner similar to herpes simplex virus type 1.     

Hemagglutinating Activity of Enteroviruses Recovered in Two Primary Cell Lines and a Stable Cell Line

A microhemagglutination technique was used to detect hemagglutinating properties of enteroviruses recovered in two primary cell lines, monkey kidney (MK) and human amnion (HAm), and in a continuous cell line, human embryonic lung (HEL). During a 3-year period, 1,528 isolations of enteroviruses were tested for hemagglutinating activity and hemagglutination inhibition response; 96.3% of the viruses were also identified by virus neutralization tests. Enteroviruses recovered in HEL were far less likely to develop hemagglutinins than viruses isolated in MK or HAm. Of the enteroviruses known to agglutinate human type O cells, 77.8% of the primary viral isolates from MK, 62.1% of the isolates from HAm, and 20.3% of the isolates from HEL exhibited this property. An additional 8.1% of the isolations obtained in HEL hemagglutinated human cells after a single passage in MK. The microhemagglutination technique using microtiter equipment was simple to perform, saved time and valuable typing sera, and helped to obtain identifications rapidly.     

Plaque production by arboviruses in Singh's Aedes albopictus cells.

We report plaquing tests of 124 virus strains, mostly arboviruses of 21 serological groups, in Singh's line of Aedes albopictus cells. Thirty of these plaqued: all were arboviruses of six groups and were known or presumed to be mosquito borne. Failing to plaque were 86 strains of arboviruses, mostly tick borne, two strains of insect pathogens, and six animal viruses not classified as arboviruses. Among mosquito-borne agents, plaquing ability appeared related to serological classification. California group and most A-group viruses failed to plaque, but nearly all members of B and Bunyamwera groups readily plaqued. Within serological group B, 14 of 16 mosquito-borne agents plaqued, but none of 13 tick-borne or vector-unassociated viruses did so. Some implications of these results for recognition and classification of arboviruses are discussed.     

Immunofluorescence Staining of Group B Coxsackieviruses

Studies were conducted on the sensitivity and specificity of indirect fluorescent-antibody (FA) staining for identification of group B coxsackieviruses. Antisera produced in four different species (monkeys, rabbits, horses, hamsters) and immune ascitic fluids prepared in mice were compared for suitability in FA staining. The horse antisera showed high titers of nonspecific staining, and the rabbit antisera showed relatively low homologous FA titers. Immune reagents from monkeys, hamsters, and mice were used for homologous and heterologous testing against cell cultures infected with the various group B coxsackieviruses. Antisera or immune ascitic fluids produced in these three species showed some heterotypic and nonspecific staining at low dilutions, with the monkey antisera showing the highest heterotypic titers. However, the immune reagents could be diluted to a point where they gave no heterotypic reactivity, but still showed characteristic homotypic staining. Heterotypic staining appeared as diffuse, low-level staining of the cells, whereas homotypic staining revealed characteristic, brightly staining aggregates of viral antigen in the cytoplasm of the infected cells. By using hamster immune sera, appropriately diluted to eliminate heterotypic staining and yet give strong homotypic staining, it was possible to identify correctly 79 (93%) of 85 field strains of group B coxsackieviruses at the first passage level in BS-C-1 cells; the remainder of the strains were identified after two passages in BS-CS-1 cells. No incorrect identifications were made. A limited number of field strains of group B coxsackieviruses were passed into rhesus monkey kidney and human fetal diploid kidney cells, and these were all correctly identified by FA staining, even the strains which failed to produce a cytopathic effect in the human fetal diploid kidney cells. Two human heart and brain tissues from which coxsackievirus type B4 had been isolated failed to show homotypic FA staining in excess of nonspecific or heterotypic staining.     

Comparison of methods for recovering indigenous viruses from raw wastewater sludge.

Five general methods for recovering indigenous viruses from raw wastewater sludge were compared. Each method included elution, concentration, and disinfection steps. The elution method, found to consistently yield the greatest viral recovery, was a two-phase technique that involved blending sludge with Freon. Other methods, including two being tested as American Society for Testing Materials tentative standard methods, were less effective. Viral recoveries were generally greater (sometimes much greater) if samples were concentrated by high-speed centrifugation rather than by organic flocculation with 3% beef extract. Three cell lines were used to measure viral recoveries by the plaque assay. The efficiency of recovery was greatest on BGM cells, followed by RD and MA-104 cells.     

Persistently infected cultures as a source of hepatitis A virus

Primary African green monkey kidney, continuous African green monkey kidney cell line BS-C-1, and buffalo green monkey kidney cultures were infected with a uniform inoculum of hepatitis A virus (HAV). Although both the cell line BS-C-1 and primary African green monkey kidney cultures produced useful amounts of virus, HAV was detected earlier and in greater quantities in primary African green monkey kidney cultures. A persistently infected primary African green monkey kidney culture was developed. The influence of incubation time (4 to 40 days) and concentration (2 to 15%) of fetal calf serum in the maintenance medium on production of HAV by this culture was examined. An incubation period of 24 to 28 days was found to be optimal; reducing this period led to decreased yields of HAV. No significant difference in the amount of HAV produced was observed with differing concentrations of fetal calf serum. Three different methods of extraction and the effect of multiple extractions on the recovery of HAV from cell lysates were examined. Sonication was a critical factor. Two extractions yielded more than 90% recoverable virus. Yields in excess of 10(11) physical particles of HAV per 850-cm2 roller bottle were routine. The total yield could be increased by concentrating the HAV present in spent maintenance medium by using bentonite or organic flocculation.     

Persistently infected cultures as a source of hepatitis A virus.

Primary African green monkey kidney, continuous African green monkey kidney cell line BS-C-1, and buffalo green monkey kidney cultures were infected with a uniform inoculum of hepatitis A virus (HAV). Although both the cell line BS-C-1 and primary African green monkey kidney cultures produced useful amounts of virus, HAV was detected earlier and in greater quantities in primary African green monkey kidney cultures. A persistently infected primary African green monkey kidney culture was developed. The influence of incubation time (4 to 40 days) and concentration (2 to 15%) of fetal calf serum in the maintenance medium on production of HAV by this culture was examined. An incubation period of 24 to 28 days was found to be optimal; reducing this period led to decreased yields of HAV. No significant difference in the amount of HAV produced was observed with differing concentrations of fetal calf serum. Three different methods of extraction and the effect of multiple extractions on the recovery of HAV from cell lysates were examined. Sonication was a critical factor. Two extractions yielded more than 90% recoverable virus. Yields in excess of 10(11) physical particles of HAV per 850-cm2 roller bottle were routine. The total yield could be increased by concentrating the HAV present in spent maintenance medium by using bentonite or organic flocculation.