Proteome analysis of low-abundance proteins using multidimensional chromatography and isotope-coded affinity tags

The effectiveness of proteome-wide protein identification and quantitative expression profiling is dependent on the ability of the analytical methodologies employed to routinely obtain information on low-abundance proteins, as these are frequently of great biological importance. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, the traditional method for proteome analysis, has proven to be biased toward highly expressed proteins. Recently, two-dimensional chromatography of the complex peptide mixtures generated by the digestion of unseparated protein samples has been introduced for the identification of their components, and isotope-coded affinity tags (ICAT) have been introduced to allow for accurate quantification of the components of protein mixtures by mass spectrometry. Here, we demonstrate that the combination of isotope coded affinity protein tags and multidimensional chromatography/mass spectrometry of tryptic peptide mixtures is capable of detecting and quantifying proteins of low abundance in complex samples.     

Affinity ligand selection from a library of small molecules: assay development, screening, and application

A facile and cost-effective process for screening synthetic libraries for an affinity ligand is described. A high throughput 96-well plate filtration method was designed to screen both discrete compounds and mixtures of compounds attached to a solid support. Human serum albumin (HSA) was used as a target protein to demonstrate the proof of concept. Detection and quantitation by fluorescence was accomplished with the use of fluorescamine to conjugate the protein in the filtrate. It is found that mixtures demonstrating low average binding reflect an overall lower hit rate of the components, whereas deconvolution of mixtures with high protein binding consistently provides a high hit rate. This differs from many of the previous experiences screening solid-phase mixtures in which high false positive rates are noted to occur. A total of 100K compounds were tested: 25K as discrete samples and 75K as mixtures. An overall hit rate of 8% was observed. Secondary screening of compounds measured specificity, recovery, and dynamic binding capacity. The effectiveness of the method is illustrated using an affinity column made with a representative lead compound. A similar purity was achieved in a single-step purification of HSA from serum as compared to that obtained by two steps of ion-exchange chromatography. The process for primary screening of a large number of compounds is simple, inexpensive, and applicable to any soluble target protein of known or unknown function from crude mixtures and may have additional utility as a generic chemical affinity tool for the functional characterization of novel proteins emerging from proteomics work.     

Rapid determination of the binding affinity and specificity of the mushroom Polyporus squamosus lectin using frontal affinity chromatography coupled to electrospray mass spectrometry

The binding affinity and specificity of the mushroom Polyporus squamosus lectin has been determined by the recently developed method of frontal affinity chromatography coupled to electrospray mass spectrometry (FAC/MS). A micro-scale affinity column was prepared by immobilizing the lectin ( approximately 25 microg) onto porous glass beads in a tubing column (9.8 microl column volume). The column was then used to screen several oligosaccharide mixtures. The dissociation constants of 22 sialylated or sulfated oligosaccharides were evaluated against the immobilized lectin. The lectin was found to be highly specific for Neu5Acalpha2-6Galbeta1-4Glc/GlcNAc containing oligosaccharides with K(d) values near 10 microM. The FAC/MS assay permits the rapid determination of the dissociation constants of ligands as well as a higher throughput screening of compound mixtures, making it a valuable tool for affinity studies, especially for testing large numbers of compounds.     

Negatively charged phospholipids and their position in the cholesterol affinity sequence

The effects of low concentrations of cholesterol in mixtures of a negatively charged phospholipid (phosphatidylserine or phosphatidylglycerol) and another phospholipid (phosphatidylcholine, sphingomyelin or phosphatidylethanolamine) have been studied by differential scanning calorimetry. Only mixtures which showed a gel phase miscibility gap have been employed. It was demonstrated that in mixtures with phosphatidylethanolamine, cholesterol was preferentially associated with the negatively charged phospholipid, regardless whether this species represented the component with the high or with the low transition temperature in the mixture. In mixtures of a negatively charged phospholipid and phosphatidylcholine, cholesterol associated with the negatively charged phospholipid; when the phosphatidylcholine was the species with the low transition temperature, cholesterol had an affinity for the phosphatidylcholine and for the negatively charged phospholipid as well. Cholesterol, in a mixture of sphingomyelin with a high and phosphatidylserine with a low transition temperature, was preferentially associated with sphingomyelin.From these experiments it is concluded that phospholipids show a decrease in affinity for cholesterol in the following order: sphingomyelin ? phosphatidylserine, phosphatidylglycerol > phosphatidylcholine ? phosphatidylethanolamine.     

The affinity of newly synthesized proteoglycan for hyaluronic acid can be enhanced by exposure to mild alkali.

The affinities for hyaluronic acid of newly synthesized proteoglycan from post-confluent rabbit chondrocyte cultures and purified bovine proteoglycan monomer were compared. In mixtures prepared at pH 6.8 the newly synthesized proteoglycan had the lower affinity; however, in mixtures incubated at pH 8.5 for 24 h before addition of hyaluronic acid, the newly synthesized proteoglycan exhibited a markedly higher affinity than the bovine monomer. The results suggest that proteoglycan secreted without associated link protein [Plaas, Sandy & Muir (1983) Biochem. J. 214, 855-864] has a low affinity for hyaluronate and that this may be increased during subsequent extracellular processing.     

Applications of affinity chromatography in proteomics

Affinity chromatography is a powerful protein separation method that is based on the specific interaction between immobilized ligands and target proteins. Peptides can also be separated effectively by affinity chromatography through the use of peptide-specific ligands. Both two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE)- and non-2-DE-based proteomic approaches benefit from the application of affinity chromatography. Before protein separation by 2-DE, affinity separation is used primarily for preconcentration and pretreatment of samples. Those applications entail the removal of one protein or a class of proteins that might interfere with 2-DE resolution, the concentration of low-abundance proteins to enable them to be visualized in the gel, and the classification of total protein into two or more groups for further separation by gel electrophoresis. Non-2-DE-based approaches have extensively employed affinity chromatography to reduce the complexity of protein and peptide mixtures. Prior to mass spectrometry (MS), preconcentration and capture of specific proteins or peptides to enhance sensitivity can be accomplished by using affinity adsorption. Affinity purification of protein complexes followed by identification of proteins by MS serves as a powerful tool for generating a map of protein-protein interactions and cellular locations of complexes. Affinity chromatography of peptide mixtures, coupled with mass spectrometry, provides a tool for the study of protein posttranslational modification (PTM) sites and quantitative proteomics. Quantitation of proteomes is possible via the use of isotope-coded affinity tags and isolation of proteolytic peptides by affinity chromatography. An emerging area of proteomics technology development is miniaturization. Affinity chromatography is becoming more widely used for exploring PTM and protein-protein interactions, especially with a view toward developing new general tag systems and strategies of chemical derivatization on peptides for affinity selection. More applications of affinity-based purification can be expected, including increasing the resolution in 2-DE, improving the sensitivity of MS quantification, and incorporating purification as part of multidimensional liquid chromatography experiments.     

Design and synthesis of visible isotope-coded affinity tags for the absolute quantification of specific proteins in complex mixtures

Identification of proteins in complex mixtures by mass spectrometry is most useful when quantitative data is also obtained. We recently introduced isotope-coded affinity tags (ICAT reagents) for the relative quantification of proteins present in two or more biological samples. In this report, we describe a new generation of ICAT reagents that contain the following additional features: (1) a visible tag that allows the electrophoretic position of tagged peptides during separation to be easily monitored; (2) a photocleavable linker that allows most of the tag to be removed prior to mass spectrometric analysis; (3) an isotope tag that contains carbon-13 and nitrogen-15 atoms instead of deuterium to ensure precise comigration of light and heavy tagged peptides by reverse-phase HPLC. These reagents contain an iodoacetyl group that selectively reacts with peptide cysteine residues. Peptide modification chemistry is also reported that allows tagging of peptides that are devoid of cysteine. The synthesis of these visible isotope-coded affinity tags (VICAT reagents), and their reaction with peptides are described in this report. VICAT reagents containing a carbon-14 visible probe or an NBD fluorophore are described. These reagents are most useful for the determination of the absolute quantity of specific target proteins in complex protein mixtures such as serum or cell lysates.     

Heterogeneity of alpha-L-fucosidase from human kidney during affinity chromatography

During affinity chromatography on N-(epsilon-aminocaproyl)-beta-L-fucopyranosylaminosepharose of the enzyme preparation of alpha-L-fucosidase from human kidney the elution profile of the enzyme revealed two components, which can be designated as alpha-L-fucosidases A and B. In the absence of sodium aside in the buffer mixtures used one of the components (fucosidase A) was retained by an affinity adsorbent, while the other one (fucosidase B) was adsorbed under the same conditions; the latter component was eluted with a solution containing the enzyme inhibitor--L-fucose. Data from the enzyme rechromatography suggest an equilibrium of the fucosidases A and B, which differ in their affinities for the affinity sorbent.     

Non-SELEX: selection of aptamers without intermediate amplification of candidate oligonucleotides

Aptamers are typically selected from libraries of random DNA (or RNA) sequences through systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX), which involves several rounds of alternating steps of partitioning of candidate oligonucleotides and their PCR amplification. Here we describe a protocol for non-SELEX selection of aptamers--a process that involves repetitive steps of partitioning with no amplification between them. Non-equilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM), which is a highly efficient affinity method, is used for partitioning. NECEEM also facilitates monitoring of bulk affinity of enriched libraries at every step of partitioning and screening of individual clones for their affinity to the target. NECEEM allows all clones to be screened prior to sequencing, so that only clones with suitable binding parameters are sequenced. The entire protocol can be completed in 1 wk, whereas conventional SELEX protocols take several weeks even in a specialized industrial facility.     

Preparation of cellodextrins and isolation of oligomeric side components and their characterization

Cellodextrin (beta-1,4-glucose oligomer) mixtures are prepared by precipitation of oligomers with 1-propanol and ethanol after partial hydrolysis of cellulose with hydrochloric acid or by acetolysis of cellulose. Cellooligomers (DP3-DP8) can be isolated by high-resolution size-exclusion chromatography on Bio-Gel P 4 using water as eluent. Recycle operation of the columns allows the separation of oligomers up to a degree of polymerization of 12. However, ion-exchange chromatography of their borate complexes demonstrates the heterogeneity of cellodextrins, homogeneous according to size-exclusion chromatography. At least four secondary oligomeric components are observed in the different samples. By preparative affinity chromatography on phenyl-boronate-agarose two of these components could be purified and subsequently characterized. In one series of oligosaccharides the glucose unit at the reducing end of the beta-1,4-glucose oligomers is derivatized to fructose. This enolization reaction occurs during size-exclusion chromatography. The precipitation step with alkanols during preparation of oligomer mixtures generates oligomeric glycosides. Additionally, the formation of amines from respective beta-1,4-glucose oligomers is observed with the ammonium carbonate eluent used in affinity chromatography. Analysis methods combined to assess for the homogeneity of cellodextrins include enzyme- and acid-catalyzed (partial) hydrolysis of the different oligomers and subsequent analysis of degradation products by sugar borate chromatography; 13C and 1H NMR spectroscopy; and fast atom bombardment mass spectroscopy.     

Probing protein phosphatase substrate binding: affinity pull-down of ILKAP phosphatase 2C with phosphopeptides

Proteomics and high throughput analysis for systems biology can benefit significantly from solid-phase chemical tools for affinity pull-down of proteins from complex mixtures. Here we report the application of solid-phase synthesis of phosphopeptides for pull-down and analysis of the affinity profile of the integrin-linked kinase associated phosphatase (ILKAP), a member of the protein phosphatase 2C (PP2C) family. Phosphatases can potentially dephosphorylate these phosphopeptide substrates but, interestingly, performing the binding studies at 4 °C allowed efficient binding to phosphopeptides, without the need for phosphopeptide mimics or phosphatase inhibitors. As no proven ILKAP substrates were available, we selected phosphopeptide substrates among known PP2Cδ substrates including the protein kinases: p38, ATM, Chk1, Chk2 and RSK2 and synthesized directly on PEGA solid supports through a BAL type handle. The results show that phosphopeptides tethered to a flexible solid support bind with high affinity and specificity to ILKAP, which is pulled down from lysates of cells transfected with ILKAP cDNA. Phosphorylation on Ser or Thr residues is important for binding of ILKAP, but sequences around the phosphorylated residue are important for the binding affinity of ILKAP. We conclude that solid-phase affinity pull-down of proteins from complex mixtures can be applied in phosphoproteomics and systems biology.     

Screening of ligand binding on melatonin receptor using non-peptide combinatorial libraries

The screening of combinatorial libraries requires a deconvolution procedure to obtain, in fine, the most active compound of the starting library. The standard screening assays used in regular molecular pharmacology, have been poorly assessed when transposed to combinatorial chemistry-related experiments, particularly those involving large numbers of chemicals in a single assay. One key issue is the effect of the inactive analogs on the identification of the active ligand in mixtures. We chose melatonin receptors to measure the apparent affinity of a single ligand when tested alone or in mixtures of non-peptide low molecular weight compounds. Using ligands with IC50 from the micro- to the picomolar range, mixed with increasingly complex mixtures of 5 to 20 or 25 inactive compounds, we analyzed the displacements from the mt1 and MT2 melatonin receptor subtypes of the radioligand 2-iodomelatonin (KD= 25 pmol/l and 200 pmol/l, respectively) . The behavior of equimolar mixtures in displacement curves led to the conclusion that the observed binding affinity reflects the dilution effect of mixing the active component with inactive compounds but does not reveal noticeable interactions which would interfere with the binding process. From the practical point of view, the concentrations of the active species in the binding assay should be large enough to displace significantly the radioligand, a requirement which may be limited by the solubility of the ligand mixtures. In contrast, previous observations with peptide libraries report that the dilution effect is often compensated by additive or synergic action of structurally related analogs, thus making possible the deconvolution of very large (typically up to 10(7) compounds) peptide libraries.     

Inhibition of serine amidohydrolases by complexes of vanadate with hydroxamic acids

Serine beta-lactamases are inhibited by phosphonate monoester monoanions. These compounds phosphonylate the active site serine hydroxyl group to form inert, covalent complexes. Since spontaneous hydrolysis of these phosphonates is generally quite slow, the beta-lactamase active site must have considerable affinity for the (presumably) pentacoordinated phosphonyl transfer transition state. Structural analogs of such a transition state might well therefore be effective and novel beta-lactamase inhibitors. Complexes of vanadate with hydroxamic acids may be able to achieve such a structure. Indeed, mixtures of these two components, but neither one alone, were found to inhibit a typical class C beta-lactamase. A Job plot of the inhibition by vanadate/benzohydroxamic acid mixtures indicated that the inhibitor was a 1:1 complex for which an inhibition constant of 4.2 microM could be calculated. A bacterial DD-peptidase, structurally similar to the beta-lactamase, was also inhibited (K(i) = 22 microM) by this complex. A similar rationale would suggest that other serine hydrolases might also be inhibited by these mixtures. In fact, chymotrypsin was inhibited by a complex of vanadate with benzohydroxamic acid (K(i) = 10 microM) and elastase by a complex with acetohydroxamic acid (K(i) = 90 microM).     

Capture of peptides with N-terminal serine and threonine: a sequence-specific chemical method for Peptide mixture simplification

The objective of this study was to evaluate a sequence-specific chemistry for the ability to specifically capture peptides that contain N-terminal serine or threonine residues from mixtures. The first step is the oxidation of the 1,2-amino alcohol structure -CH(NH(2))CH(OH)- of peptides containing N-terminal serine or threonine with periodate. The newly formed aldehyde reacts with a labeling reagent containing a hydrazide, RCONHNH(2), to form a hydrazone-peptide conjugate, RCONHN=CH-peptide. Biotin-labeled conjugates can then be isolated by affinity purification with streptavidin. The method described in this report can be useful in simplifying the complex mixtures of peptides that are generated in typical proteomic analysis, where proteins are digested with trypsin and analyzed using liquid chromatography mass spectrometry data. The sequence-specific peptide selection not only reduces the complexity of digest mixtures, but also provides additional information for peptide identification. The targeted peptides are those that have either serine or threonine adjacent to a protease cleavage site. The sequence information should greatly aid in both database matching for protein identification and for de novo sequence determination.     

Multiple excitatory receptor types on individual olfactory neurons: implications for coding of mixtures in the spiny lobster

The aim of our paper was to investigate whether single olfactory receptor neurons (ORNs) of the spiny lobster Panulirus argus functionally express more than one type of receptor, examine the consequences of this on coding of mixtures, and compare principles of odorant mixture coding by spiny lobsters with that by the channel catfish, which has been studied extensively using the same experimental and analytical procedures (Caprio et al. 1989; Kang and Caprio 1991). We examined responses of individual taurine-sensitive ORNs to binary mixtures of excitatory compounds, either competitive agonists (taurine, β-alanine, hypotaurine) or non-competitive agonists (taurine, l-glutamate, ammonium chloride, adenosine-5′-monophosphate). Responses to mixtures were compared to two indices: mixture discrimination index (MDI) and independent component index (ICI). Binary mixtures of competitive agonists had MDI values close to 1.0, as expected for competitors. Mixtures of non-competitive agonists had ICI values averaging 0.83, indicating the effects of the components are not independent. We conclude that individual olfactory cells of spiny lobsters can express more than one type of receptor mediating excitation, one of which typically has a much higher density or affinity, and that spiny lobster and catfish olfactory cells encode mixtures of two excitatory agonists using similar rules. Accepted: 20 December 1996     

Combining protein-based IMAC, peptide-based IMAC, and MudPIT for efficient phosphoproteomic analysis

Immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) is a common strategy used for the enrichment of phosphopeptides from digested protein mixtures. However, this strategy by itself is inefficient when analyzing complex protein mixtures. Here, we assess the effectiveness of using protein-based IMAC as a pre-enrichment step prior to peptide-based IMAC. Ultimately, we couple the two IMAC-based enrichments and MudPIT in a quantitative phosphoproteomic analysis of the epidermal growth factor pathway in mammalian cells identifying 4470 unique phosphopeptides containing 4729 phosphorylation sites.     

Calculating affinity constants of substrate mixtures in a chemostat

An “oversimplified” method for calculating affinity constants in substrate mixtures is evaluated concerning its validity. It is shown that the real affinity to the mixture as determined by using the correct method is always higher, i.e., leads to a lower affinity constant, as compared to the wrong method frequently used.     

Interactions of concanavalin A with asparagine-linked glycopeptides: formation of homogeneous cross-linked lattices in mixed precipitation systems

We have previously shown that certain oligomannose and bisected hybrid type glycopeptides are bivalent for binding to concanavalin A (Con A) [Bhattacharyya, L., Ceccarini, C., Lorenzoni, P., & Brewer, C. F. (1987) J. Biol. Chem. 262, 1288-1293]. Each glycopeptide gives a quantitative precipitation profile with the protein which consists of a single peak that corresponds to the binding stoichiometry of glycopeptide to protein monomer (1:2). We have shown that the affinities of the primary and secondary sites of the glycopeptides influence their extent of precipitation with the lectin [Bhattacharyya, L., & Brewer, C. F. (1988) Eur. J. Biochem. (in press)]. In the present study, we demonstrate that equimolar mixtures of any two of the glycopeptides result in a quantitative precipitation profile which shows two protein peaks. Using radiolabeled glycopeptides, the precipitation profiles of the individual glycopeptides were determined. The results show that each glycopeptide forms its own precipitation profile with the protein which is independent of the profile of the other glycopeptide. For mixtures containing an equimolar ratio of two glycopeptides, the glycopeptide with lower affinity shows a precipitation maximum at a lower concentration than the one with higher affinity. However, this can be reversed by increasing the ratio of the lower affinity glycopeptide in the mixture. Thus, the relative precipitation maxima of the glycopeptides are determined by mass-action equilibria involving competitive binding of the two carbohydrates to the protein. These equilibria, in turn, are sensitive to the relative amounts and affinities of the carbohydrates at both their primary and secondary sites.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Control of fibroblast growth factor (FGF) 7- and FGF1-induced mitogenesis and downstream signaling by distinct heparin octasaccharide motifs

Variation in length, disaccharide composition, and sulfation of heparan sulfate (HS) affects fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signaling. However, it is unclear whether the specific distribution of groups within oligosaccharides or random variations in charge density underlies the effects. Recently we showed that a mixture of undersulfated octasaccharides exhibiting 7 and 8 sulfates (7,8-S-OctaF7) generated from heparin had the highest affinity for FGF7 monitored by salt resistance (>0.60 M salt) of octasaccharide-FGF7 complexes. 7,8-S-OctaF7 also had the highest specific activity for formation of a complex with dimeric FGFR2IIIb competent to bind FGF7. Here we show that when endogenous HS was inhibited by chlorate treatment, 7,8-S-OctaF7 specifically supported FGF7-stimulated DNA synthesis and downstream signaling in FGFR2IIIb-expressing mouse keratinocytes. It failed to support FGF1 signaling in both HS-deficient mouse keratinocytes and 3T3 fibroblasts. In contrast, abundant, more highly sulfated and heterogenous mixtures of octasaccharides with lower affinity (0.30-0.60 M salt) for FGF7 supported FGF1-induced signaling in both cell types. In contrast to the two-component 7,8-S-OctaF7 mixture from FGF7, the high affinity octasaccharide fraction from FGF1 was a heterogeneous mixture with components ranging from 8 to 12 sulfates with 11-S-octasaccharides the most abundant. The high affinity fraction exhibited similar properties to the lower affinity fractions from both FGF1 and FGF7. Octasaccharide mixtures eluting from FGF1 between 0.30 and 0.60 M and above 0.60 M salt were nearly equal in support of FGF1 signaling in fibroblasts and keratinocytes. Both were deficient in support of FGF7-induced signaling in keratinocytes. The results show that both variations in overall charge density and specific distribution of charged groups within HS motifs exhibit FGF-specific control over formation of FGF-HS-FGFR complexes and downstream signaling.