Modulation of oxygen affinity in hemoglobin by solvent components. Interaction of bovine hemoglobin with 2,3-diphosphoglycerate and monatomic anions

In the absence of Cl- in Hepes buffer at pH 7.4, the oxygen affinity of bovine and human hemoglobin is equally sensitive to 2,3-diphosphoglyceric acid. The low oxygen affinity measured for bovine hemoglobin at physiological salt concentration can be explained by the high affinity of Cl- anions for oxygen-linked sites that are absent in human hemoglobin. Bovine hemoglobin can discriminate between the different halogens in the sense that different halide concentrations are necessary to produce the same P50. Competition experiments indicate that the halogens interact with the same oxygen-linked sites. In agreement with the different affinities for halides, the Bohr effect of bovine hemoglobin is larger in the presence of Cl- than in that of Br- and there is good agreement between the number of protons and anions exchanged with the solvent upon oxygenation of bovine hemoglobin.     

Solvent regulation of oxygen affinity in hemoglobin. Sensitivity of bovine hemoglobin to chloride ions

Under physiological conditions of pH (7.4) and chloride concentration (0.15 M), the oxygen affinity of bovine hemoglobin is substantially lower than that of human hemoglobin. Also, the Bohr effect is much more pronounced in bovine hemoglobin. Numerical simulations indicate that both phenomena can be explained by a larger preferential binding of chloride ions to deoxyhemoglobin in the bovine system. Also, they show that the larger preferential binding may be produced by a decreased affinity of the anions for oxyhemoglobin, thereby stressing the potential relevance of the oxy conformation in regulating the functional properties of the protein. The conformation of the amino-terminal end of the beta subunits appears to regulate the interaction of hemoglobin with solvent components. The pronounced sensitivity of the oxygen affinity of bovine hemoglobin to chloride concentration and to pH suggests that in bovine species these are the modulators of oxygen transport in vivo.     

Hemoglobins of the tadpole of the bullfrog, Rana catesbeiana. Temperature dependence of oxygen binding and pH dependence of subunit dissociation.

The temperature dependence of the oxygen equilibrium of tadpole hemoglobin has been determined between 0 degrees and 32 degrees for the unfractionated but phosphate-free lysate and between 12 degrees and 32 degrees for each of the four isolated components between pH 6 and 10 in 0.05 M cacodylate, Tris, or glycine buffers containing 0.1 M NaCl and 1 mM EDTA. Under these conditions the Bohr effect (defined as deltalog p50/deltapH) of the unfractionated lysate is positive at low temperatures between pH 6 and 8.5 and is negative above pH 8.5 to 8.8 at any temperature. As the temperature rises the Bohr effect below pH 8.5 changes greatly. In the interval pH 7.0 to 7.5, the magnitude of the Bohr effect decreases from + 0.28 at 0 degrees to zero at about 24 degrees and becomes negative, as in mammalian hemoglobins, above this temperature. Measurements with the isolated components show that the temperature dependence of oxygen binding for Components I and II and for Components III and IV is very similar. For both sets of components the apparent overall enthalpy of oxygenation at pH 7.5 is about -16.4 kcal/mol and -12.6 kcal/mol at pH 9.5. The measured enthalpies include contributions from the active Bohr groups, the buffer ions themselves, the hemoglobin groups contributing buffering, and any pH-dependent, oxygenation-dependent binding of ions such as chloride by the hemoglobin. The apportioning of the total enthalpy among these various processes remains to be determined. Between pH 8 and 10.5 tadpole oxyhemoglobin undergoes a pH-dependent dissociation from tetramer to dimer. The pH dependence of the apparent tetramer-dimer dissociation constant indicates that at pH 9.5 the dissociation of each tetramer is accompanied by the release of approximately 2 protons. In this pH range the oxygen equilibrium measurements indicate that about 0.5 proton is released for each oxygen molecule bound. The results are consistent with the conclusion that one acid group per alphabeta dimer changes its pK from about 10 to 8 or below upon dissociation of the tetramer.     

Effect of Cl- and H+ on the oxygen binding properties of glutaraldehyde-polymerized bovine hemoglobin-based blood substitutes

Bovine hemoglobin was cross-linked with glutaraldehyde, resulting in high oxygen affinity polymeric hemoglobin dispersions of varying molecular weight distributions. High oxygen affinity acellular oxygen carriers were designed in order to exhibit oxygen release profiles closer to that of human red blood cells (RBCs), without exhibiting the inherent increased vasoactivity that occurs with low oxygen affinity acellular oxygen carriers (1, 2). Oxygen dissociation curves were measured for polymerized hemoglobin dispersions at various pH values (7.0, 7.4, and 8.0) and chloride ion concentrations. Unmodified hemoglobin showed an increase in oxygen affinity with increased chloride ion concentration and a decrease in oxygen affinity with increased pH, as was previously demonstrated in the literature (3). For glutaraldehyde-polymerized hemoglobin dispersions, the ability of the oxygen affinity to respond to changes in Bohr H+ and Cl- concentration was weakened. However, at acidic physiological pH (pH = 7), the Bohr effect was still present at high Cl- concentrations. Thus, the Bohr effect maintained some dependency on the Cl- concentration.     

Functional characterization of the single hemoglobin of the migratory bird Ciconia ciconia

Hemolysate from white stork displayed a single hemoglobin component, thus resulting into two bands and two globin peaks in dissociating PAGE and reversed phase-HPLC, respectively. Stripped hemoglobin showed an oxygen affinity higher than that of human HbA, a small Bohr effect, and a cooperative oxygen binding. A small decrease of oxygen affinity, of the same extent in all the pH range examined, was observed by addition of chloride, thus indicating an unusual chloride-independent Bohr effect (DeltalogP50/Deltalog pH=-0.24). Saturating amounts of inositol hexakisphosphate, largely decreased hemoglobin-oxygen affinity (DeltalogP(50)=1.17 at pH 7.0), and increased the extent of its Bohr effect (DeltalogP50/DeltalogpH=-0.45). The phosphate binding curve allowed to measure a very high overall binding constant (K=1.18 x 10(5) M(-1)). The effect of temperature on the oxygen affinity was measured, and the enthalpy change of oxygenation resulted almost independent on pH. Structural-functional relationships are discussed by considering some amino acid residues situated at alpha1/beta1 and alpha1/beta2 interfaces, such as alpha38 and alpha89 positions. The presence of only one hemoglobin component, a rare event among birds, and its functional properties have been related to the physiological oxygen requirements of this soaring migrant bird and to its technique of flight during migration.     

Hemoglobin Abruzzo (beta143 (H21) His replaced by Arg). Consequences of altering the 2,3-diphosphoglycerate binding site.

Hemoglobin Abruzzo is an abnormal human hemoglobin with a substitution at a residue known to be involved in the binding of 2,3-diphosphoglyceric acid. It has increased oxygen affinity and reduced heme-heme interaction in the absence of organic or inorganic phosphate cofactors. In inorganic phosphate buffers the Bohr effect and heme-heme interaction are normal, but the oxygen affinity remains higher than that of hemoglobin A. CO combination in inorganic phosphate is more strongly autocatalytic than in normal hemoglobin and a slower rate of oxygen dissociation is observed. Although many of the functional differences of this variant may be attributed to the high oxygen affinity of the mutant beta chains, the interactions between subunits are also affected by the histidine to arginine substitution at beta143. Stripped hemoglobin Abruzzo appears to be significantly more dissociated than hemoglobin A. Kinetic studies indicate that interaction with organic or inorganic phosphates decreases its subunit dissociation. In all of the functional properties examined, hemoglobin Abruzzo is more sensitive to the allosteric influence of organic and inorganic anions than is hemoglobin A.     

The hemoglobin system of the brown moray Gymnothorax unicolor: structure/function relationships.

The Gymnothorax unicolor hemoglobin system is characterized by two components, called cathodic and anodic on the basis of their isoelectric point, which were separated by ion-exchange chromatography. The oxygen-binding properties of the purified components were studied in the absence and presence of chloride and/or GTP or ATP in the pH range 6.5-8.0. Stripped cathodic hemoglobin showed a small reverse Bohr effect, high oxygen affinity, and low co-operativity; the addition of chloride only caused a small decrease in oxygen affinity. In the presence of GTP or ATP, the oxygen affinity was dramatically reduced, the co-operativity increased, and the reverse Bohr effect abolished. Stripped anodic hemoglobin is characterized by both low oxygen affinity and co-operativity, and displayed a normal Bohr effect; the addition of chloride increased co-operativity, whereas ATP and GTP significantly modulated oxygen affinity at acidic pH values, enhancing the Bohr effect and giving rise to the Root effect. The complete amino-acid sequences of the alpha and beta chains of both hemoglobins were established; the molecular basis of the functional properties of the hemoglobins is discussed in the light of the primary structure and compared with those of other fish hemoglobins.     

Dependence on pH of formation and oxygen affinity of hemoglobin S fibers in the presence and absence of phosphates and polyphosphates

This paper presents data on the effect of phosphates and polyphosphates on the formation of hemoglobin S fiber, and on the Bohr effect of hemoglobin S samples whose concentration was high enough (near 5 mM) in order to form fibers upon deoxygenation. The experiments were performed in 0.2 M Bistris or Tris buffers at 30 degrees C in the presence and absence of inositol hexakisphosphate and of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate. Alternatively, 0.2 M phosphate buffers were used without addition of effectors. Under these conditions, few fibers were formed in Tris or Bistris buffers, while extensive fiber formation occurred in the presence of phosphates and polyphosphates. In all cases, increasing pH strongly inhibited fiber formation. At pH 7.5 and above, fibers were not formed in our samples. In the presence of phosphates and polyphosphates fiber formation reduced the oxygen affinity of hemoglobin S with respect to either hemoglobin A or soluble hemoglobin S under similar experimental conditions. The fiber-polyphosphate complexes showed a larger Bohr effect than that in hemoglobin A. In the presence of inositol hexakisphosphate fiber-forming solutions of hemoglobin S liberated as much as six protons per tetramer upon oxygen binding. The increased liberation of protons was probably due to a higher affinity of the effectors for the fibers of hemoglobin S. Very likely the higher affinity was supported by a conformational change of hemoglobin S specific for the fibers.     

Ligand binding properties of hemoglobin 3 of the trout, Salmo gairdneri. The occurrence of an acid Bohr effect in the absence of heme-heme interaction.

The four components of hemoglobin from the rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri) have been isolated. The oxygen affinities of the first two components eluted from the DEAE-cellulose column have much smaller pH dependencies than the last two components. These components have very low O2 affinities at low pH. The effect of pH on the equilibrium and kinetics of ligand binding to the third fraction, the pH-dependent component present in greatest amounts, has been studied. Measurements of ligand binding equilibria demonstrate the presence of both an alkaline and an acid Bohr effect. In the region of the alkaline Bohr effect the value of n in the Hill equation is a function of ligand affinity. For CO binding n decreases as the pH is decreased until at pH 6, the minimum ligand affinity is reached. At this pH there is also a complete loss of cooperative ligand binding. Decreasing the pH further results in an increase of ligand affinity, but this acid Bohr effect is not associated with a reappearance of cooperativity. This suggests that Fraction 3 of S. gairdneri is frozen in the low affinity, deoxygenated conformation at low pH and that the quaternary structure does not change even when fully liganded. However, the properties of the low affinity conformation of this hemoglobin are pH-dependent.     

Hemoglobin Richmond. Subunit dissociation and oxygen equilibrium properties.

In hemoglobin Richmond (beta102 leads to Lys), amino acid substitution has occurred at the same site as the mutation in hemoglobin Kansas (beta102 Asn leads to Thr), a variant with very low oxygen affinity. Although hemoglobin Richmond has been shown to have increased tetramer-dimer dissociation, its oxygen affinity has been inferred to be normal from studies on hemolysates of carriers. We have isolated hemoglobin Richmond and have further studied its properties. We confirm that the oxygen affinity of pure hemoglobin Richmond under conditions similar to those found in vivo is normal. However, the Bohr effect of the variant hemoglobin is markedly abnormal. Its oxygen affinity is low at high pH and high at low pH, relative to hemoglobin A. The tetramer-dimer equilibrium displays a strong pH dependence such that protons promote dissociation. A model is presented in which the structural change in hemoglobin Richmond results in low oxygen affinity, like hemoglobin Kansas. However, the close linkage between tetramer-dimer dissociation and proton concentration seen with hemoglobin Richmond results in normal oxygen affinity at intracellular pH and hemoglobin concentration, and carriers display no hematological abnormalities.     

Cobalt hemoglobin: pH dependence of Adair constants and the Bohr effects.

Precise oxygen equilibrium curves have been obtained for cobalt hemoglobin at pH values from 5.5 to 8.2. The Hill plots are symmetric having asymptotes with slopes of unity. At pH 7.0, cobalt hemoglobin has p0.5 = 116 toor (15.45 kPa), pm = 117 torr (15.58 kPa) and a Hill coefficient of n = 1.72. The values of n decrease slightly with either decrease or increase of pH; the protein is almost non-cooperative at pH greater than 8.2. The Adair constants have been calculated with a non-linear least-squares program. From deltalnpm/deltapH a maximum of 2.5 Bohr protons was calculated at physiological pH values. The majority of alkaline Bohr protons are released after binding of the first and the third oxygen with maxima at pH 7.6 and 7.3, respectively. The acid Bohr effect was also observed with the majority of the protons taken up following the first and third oxygen bound. Smaller alkaline Bohr effects were obtained by differential titration and at higher pH than that calculated from oxygen equilibria. The discrepancy can be largely attributed to the binding of salt components to cobalt hemoglobin.     

Characterization of the hemoglobins of the Australian lungfish Neoceratodus forsteri (Krefft)

We examined for the first time the hemoglobin components of the blood of the Australian lungfish, Neoceratodus forsteri and their functional responses to pH and the allosteric modulators adenosine triphosphate (ATP), guanosine triphosphate (GTP), 2,3-bisphosphoglyceric acid (BPG) and inositol hexaphosphate (IHP) at 25 degrees C. Lysates prepared from stripped, unfractionated hemolysate produced sigmoidal oxygen equilibrium curves with high oxygen affinity (oxygen partial pressure required for 50% hemoglobin saturation, p(50)=5.3 mmHg) and a Hill coefficient of 1.9 at pH 7.5. p(50) was 8.3 and 4.5 mmHg at pH 6 and 8, respectively, which corresponded to a modest Bohr coefficient (Delta log p(50)/Delta pH) of -0.13. GTP increased the pH sensitivity of oxygen binding more than ATP, such that the Bohr coefficient was -0.77 in the presence of 2 mmol L(-1) GTP. GTP was the most potent regulator of hemoglobin affinity, with concentrations of 5 mmol L(-1) causing an increase in p(50) from 5 to 19 mm Hg at pH 7.5, while the order of potency of the other phosphates was IHP>ATP>BPG. Three hemoglobin isoforms were present and each contained both alpha and beta chains with distinct molecular weights. Oxygen affinity and pH-dependence of isoforms I and II were essentially identical, while isoform III had a lower affinity and increased pH-dependence. The functional properties of the hemoglobin system of Neoceratodus appeared consistent with an active aquatic breather adapted for periodic hypoxic episodes.     

Influence of carbon monoxide on hemoglobin-oxygen binding.

The oxygen dissociation curve and Bohr effect were measured in normal whole blood as a function of carboxyhemoglobin concentration [HbCO]. pH was changed by varying CO2 concentration (CO2 Bohr effect) or by addition of isotonic NaOH or HCl at constant PCO2 (fixed acid Bohr effect). As [HbCO] varied through the range of 2, 25, 50, and 75%, P50 was 26.3, 18.0, 11.6, and 6.5 mmHg, respectively. CO2 Bohr effect was highest at low oxygen saturations. This effect did not change as [HbCO] was increased. However, as [HbCO] was increased from 2 to 75%, the fixed acid Bohr factor increased in magnitude from -0.20 to -0.80 at very low oxygen saturations. The effect of molecular CO2 binding (carbamino) on oxygen affinity was eliminated at high [HbCO]. These results are consistent with the initial binding of O2 or CO to the alpha-chain of hemoglobin. The results also suggest that heme-heme interaction is different for oxygen than for carbon monoxide.     

Saturation dependency of the Bohr effect: interactions among H-+, CO2, and DPG.

The Bohr effect was measured in normal whole blood and in blood with low DPG concentration as a function of oxygen saturation. pH was changed by varying CO2 concentration (CO2 Bohr effect) or by addition of isotonic NaOH or HC1 at constant PCO2 (fixed acid Bohr effect). At nornal DPG concentration CO2 Bohr effect was -0.52 at 50% blood oxygen saturation, increasing in magnitude at lower saturation and decreasing in magnitude at higher saturation. In DPG depleted blood with base excess (BE) similar to 0 meq/1, there was similar dependence of CO2 Bohr effect on oxygen saturation. At BE similar to -10 meq/1, influence of saturation was comparable, but the magnitude of the Bohr effect was markedly increased at all saturations. Fixed acid Bohr effect at normal DPG concentration was -0.45 at saturations of 50-90% but decreased at lower saturations. In DPG-depleted blood fixed acid Bohr effect averaged about -0.33 with minimal variation with saturation. Influence of DPG on oxygen affinity was greater at intermediate saturations and less at saturations below 20% and above 80%. Effect of CO2, independent of pH, was many fold greater at lower oxygen saturations than at higher saturations. These results support the suggestion that the alpha chain of hemoglobin is the site of the initial oxygenation reaction. Physiologically they indicate that the relative contribution of CO2 and fixed acid, as well as the level of oxygen saturation and DPG concentration, may be important in determining PO2 of capillary blood and resulting oxygen delivery.     

The reversible binding of oxygen to sulfhemoglobin.

The O2 binding properties of sulfhemoglobin were studied. The oxygen tension required for half-saturation of sulfhemoglobin is more than 2 orders of magnitude higher than that for hemoglobin A. The binding of O2 exhibits an alkaline Bohr effect larger than that observed for hemoglobin, yet the Hill number is unity. From the Bohr titration curve, 0.68 proton is released during O2 binding at 0 degrees C. Sulfhemoglobin prepared from carboxypeptidase A-treated hemoglobin has an affinity for O2 which is about the same as that of sulfhemoglobin at the theoretical limit of the Bohr titration curve. Like its carboxypeptidase A-treated hemoglobin precursor, this sulfhemoglobin does not bind O2 cooperatively. Thus, sulfhemoglobin appears to be in a high affinity form at alkaline pH and a low affinity form at acid pH, similar to hemoglobin A. These results demonstrate that the magnitude of the Hill number is not always an indicator of the interaction between oxygen binding and other functions in a hemoglobin.     

The effect of 4-isothiocyanatobenzene sulfonic acid on the oxygen affinity of human hemoglobin

Human hemoglobin reacts with 4-Isothiocyanatobenzene sulfonic acid at the four amino groups of the N-terminal valines. The modified protein shows a decreased oxygen affinity over a wide pH range, a reduced alkaline Bohr effect, decreased co-operativity, and a reduced effect of inositol hexasulfate on the oxygen affinity.     

Hemoglobin Deer Lodge (beta 2 His replaced by Arg). Consequences of altering the 2,3-diphosphoglycerate binding site.

Hemoglobin Deer Lodge is an abnormal human hemoglobin with arginine substituted for histidine at the beta 2 position. X-ray crystallography of normal human hemoglobin has shown that the beta 2 residue is normally part of the binding site for 2,3-diphosphoglycerate. The substitution of arginine for histidine at beta 2 affects both the kinetics and equilibria of ligand binding. When stripped of anions, Hb Deer Lodge has an increased oxygen affinity and a decreased degree of cooperativity relative to Hb A. The alkaline Bohr effect is slightly increased and there are marked increases in oxygen affinity below pH 6 and above pH 8. In the presence of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate the cooperativity in increases to nromal and the pH dependence of oxygen binding is reduced. This contrasts with the enhanced Bohr effect seen for Hb A in the presence of organic phosphates. Due to enhanced anion binding at high pH, Hb Deer Lodge has a slightly lower oxygen affinity than Hb A at pH 9 in the presence of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate or inositol hexaphosphate. Kinetic studies at neutral pH in the absence of organic phosphates revealed biphasicity in the rate of oxygen dissociation from Hb Deer Lodge, while approximately linear time courses were observed for Hb A. The fast phase of the oxygen dissociation kinetics shows great pH sensitivity, and organic phosphates increase the rate and percentage of the fast phase without greatly affecting the slow phase. The two phases are not resolvable at high pH. CO combination kinetics are much like those of Hb A except that "fast" and "slow" phases were apparent at wavelengths near the deoxy-CO isobestic point. We suggest that functional differences between the alpha and beta chains are enhanced in Hb Deer Lodge. After flash photolysis of the CO derivative, the percentage of quickly reacting material was slightly greater for Hb Deer Lodge than for Hb A. This may imply a somewhat greater tendency to dissociate into high affinity subunits. The substitution of arginine for histidine at beta 2 thus results in a macromolecule whose ligand-binding properties are significantly altered, the primary differences being expressed at high pH where Hb Deer Lodge binds anions more strongly than Hb A. The properties of Hb Deer Lodge are compared to those of other hemoglobin variants with substitutions at residues involved in binding of 2,3-diphosphoglycerate.     

Role of Bohr group salt bridges in cooperativity in hemoglobin.

Possible problems in measuring the first Adair constant, K1, from accurate oxygen equilibrium curves have been investigated. Of these only the presence of small amounts of CO-hemoglobin or hemoglobin dimers had a significant effect. The former can be eliminated by treatment with oxygen, the latter by measuring the concentration-dependence of K1 or working at high protein concentrations. K1 values have been measured for normal hemoglobin at pH 7 and 9, hemoglobin specifically reacted with cyanate at Val 1alpha (alphac2beta2) and des(His 146beta) hemoglobin at pH 7. K1 is equal to KT, the oxygen affinity of the T state of hemoglobin, for all these hemoglobins and was increased in all of them when compared to normal hemoglobin at pH 7. This shows that the breakage of the Bohr group salt bridges by increasing pH or specific modification changes KT. Hence the Bohr group salt bridges break on ligation of the T state and are partially responsible for the free energy of cooperativity.     

Interaction of hemoglobin with salts: Effects on the functional properties of human hemoglobin

Oxygen isotherms of human hemoglobin measured in distilled water and in solutions of different inorganic salts in the concentration range from below 10^?3 m to above 1·5 m at neutral pH indicate that the oxygen affinity decreases with increasing salt concentration in the lower range of ionic strength; above the physiological range, there is in most cases a further decrease in oxygen affinity, but this varies with the nature of the salt and, in some instances, the affinity goes through a maximum.The effect of cations, which is opposite to that of anions, operates primarily in the higher concentration range; i.e. above 0·1 m. This effect is especially large for Li⁺, Ca²⁺ and Mg²⁺.The alkaline Bohr effect depends strongly on anion concentration, being displaced towards higher pH values and being reduced in magnitude as chloride concentration is increased. On the other hand, the acid Bohr effect, observed below pH 6, appears to be independent of chloride concentration from 6 × 10^?2 m to 2 m.The overall heat of oxygenation has been determined for the isoionic protein as well as at different concentrations of chloride and phosphate. The average intrinsic heat of reaction of hemoglobin with oxygen in solution is found to be ?14·6 kcal/mol of O₂.     

High and low oxygen affinity conformations of T state hemoglobin

To understand the interplay between tertiary and quaternary transitions associated with hemoglobin function and regulation, oxygen binding curves were obtained for hemoglobin A fixed in the T quaternary state by encapsulation in wet porous silica gels. At pH 7.0 and 15 degrees C, the oxygen pressure at half saturation (p50) was measured to be 12.4 +/- 0.2 and 139 +/- 4 torr for hemoglobin gels prepared in the absence and presence of the strong allosteric effectors inositol hexaphosphate and bezafibrate, respectively. Both values are in excellent agreement with those found for the binding of the first oxygen to hemoglobin in solution under similar experimental conditions. The corresponding Hill coefficients of hemoglobin gels were 0.94 +/- 0.02 and 0.93 +/- 0.03, indicating, in the frame of the Monod, Wyman, and Changeux model, that high and low oxygen-affinity tertiary T-state conformations have been isolated in a pure form. The values, slightly lower than unity, reflect the different oxygen affinity of alpha- and beta-hemes. Significantly, hemoglobin encapsulated in the presence of the weak effector phosphate led to gels that show intermediate oxygen affinity and Hill coefficients of 0.7 to 0.8. The heterogeneous oxygen binding results from the presence of a mixture of the high and low oxygen-affinity T states. The Bohr effect was measured for hemoglobin gels containing the pure conformations and found to be more pronounced for the high-affinity T state and almost absent for the low-affinity T state. These findings indicate that the functional properties of the T quaternary state result from the contribution of two distinct, interconverting conformations, characterized by a 10-fold difference in oxygen affinity and a different extent of tertiary Bohr effect. The very small degree of T-state cooperativity observed in solution and in the crystalline state might arise from a ligand-induced perturbation of the distribution between the high- and low-affinity T-state conformations.