Programmed cell death in bacteria: translational repression by mRNA end-pairing

The hok / sok and pnd systems of plasmids R1 and R483 mediate plasmid maintenance by killing plasmid-free cells. Translation of the exceptionally stable hok and pnd mRNAs is repressed by unstable antisense RNAs. The different stabilities of the killer mRNAs and their cognate repressors explain the onset of translation in plasmid-free cells. The full-length hok and pnd mRNAs are inert with respect to translation and antisense RNA binding. We have previously shown that the mRNAs contain two negative translational control elements. Thus, the mRNAs contain upstream anti-Shine–Dalgarno elements that repress translation by shielding the Shine–Dalgarno ele-ments. The mRNAs also contain fold-back-inhibition elements ( fbi  ) at their 3' ends that are required to maintain the inert mRNA configuration. Using genetic complementation, we show that the 3' fbi elements pair with the very 5' ends of the mRNAs. This pairing sets the low rate of 3' exonucleolytical processing, which is required for the accumulation of an activatable pool of mRNA. Unexpectedly, the hok and pnd mRNAs were found to contain translational activators at their 5' ends (termed tac  ). Thus, the fbi elements inhibit translation of the full-length mRNAs by sequestration of the tac elements. The fbi elements are removed by 3' exonucleolytical processing. Mutational ana-lyses indicate that the 3' processing triggers refolding of the mRNA 5' ends into translatable configurations in which the 5' tac elements base pair with the anti-Shine–Dalgarno sequences.     

The rifampicin-inducible genes srn6 from F and pnd from R483 are regulated by antisense RNAs and mediate plasmid maintenance by kiiling of plasmid-free segregants

The gene systems srnB of plasmid F and pnd of plasmid R483 were discovered because of their induction by rifampicin. Induction caused membrane damage, RNase I influx, degradation of stable RNA and, consequently, cell killing. We show here that the srnB and pnd systems mediate efficient stabilization of a mini-R1 test-plasmid. We also show that the killer genes srnB' and pndA are regulated by antisense RNAs, and that the srnC- and pndB-encoded antisense RNAs, denoted SrnC- and PndB-RNAs, are unstable molecules of approximately 60 nucleotides. The srnB and pndA mRNAs were found to be very stable. The differential decay rates of the inhibitory antisense RNAs and the killer-gene-encoding mRNAs explain the induction of these gene systems by rifampicin. Furthermore, the observed plasmid-stabilization phenotype associated with the srnB and pnd systems is a consequence of this differential RNA decay: the newborn plasmid-free cells inherit the stable mRNAs, which, after decay of the unstable antisense RNAs, are translated into killer proteins, thus leading to selective killing of the plasmid-free segregants. Thus our observations lead us to conclude that the F srnB and R483 pnd systems are phenotypically indistinguishable from the R1 hok/sok system, despite a 50% dissimilarity at the level of DNA sequence.     

Mechanism of post-segregational killing: translation of Hok, SrnB and Pnd mRNAs of plasmids R1, F and R483 is activated by 3''-end processing.

The gene systems hok/sok of R1, srnB of F and pnd of R483 mediate plasmid maintenance by killing of plasmid-free segregants. Translation of the very stable mRNAs encoding the killer proteins is regulated by small unstable antisense RNAs. The differential decay rates of the inhibitory antisense RNAs and the mRNAs encoding the killer proteins is the basis for the onset of killer mRNA translation in newborn plasmid-free segregants and the killing of these cells. We have suggested previously that this requires that the killer mRNAs occur in two forms. A translationally inactive form was proposed to be converted into a 3'-truncated, translationally active mRNA. In the presence of the antisense RNA, translation from this killer mRNA should be inhibited. In this communication we present in vivo and in vitro evidence that support this model. The requirement for 3'-processing for killer gene expression is demonstrated. By using in vitro techniques it is shown that full-length Hok mRNA is translationally inactive, whereas a 3'-end truncated version of the Hok mRNA is translationally active. In vitro secondary structure probing suggests that the 3'-end of the full-length Hok mRNA folds back onto the translational initiation region of the mok gene and thereby inhibits translation of the mRNA. By inference we conclude that the Pnd and SrnB mRNAs are regulated by a similar mechanism.     

Translational control and differential RNA decay are key elements regulating postsegregational expression of the killer protein encoded by the parB locus of plasmid R1

The parB locus of plasmid R1, which mediates plasmid stability via postsegregational killing of plasmid-free cells, encodes two genes, hok and sok. The hok gene product is a potent cell-killing protein. The hok gene is regulated at the translational level by the sok gene-encoded repressor, a small anti-sense RNA complementary to the hok mRNA. The hok mRNA is extraordinarily stable, while the sok RNA decays rapidly. The mechanism of postsegregational killing is explained by the following model; the sok RNA molecule rapidly disappears in cells that have lost a parB-carrying plasmid, leading to translation of the stable hok mRNA. Consequently, the Hok protein is synthesized and killing of the plasmid-free cell follows.     

Sok antisense RNA from plasmid R1 is functionally inactivated by RNase E and polyadenylated by poly(A) polymerase I

The hok/sok system of plasmid R1, which mediates plasmid stabilization by the killing of plasmid-free cells, codes for two RNA species, Sok antisense RNA and hok mRNA. Sok RNA, which is unstable, inhibits translation of the stable hok mRNA. The 64 nt Sok RNA folds into a single stem-loop domain with an 11 nt unstructured 5' domain. The initial recognition reaction between Sok RNA and hok mRNA takes place between the 5' domain and the complementary region in hok mRNA. In this communication we examine the metabolism of Sok antisense RNA. We find that RNase E cleaves the RNA 6 nt from its 5' end and that this cleavage initiates Sok RNA decay. The RNase E cleavage occurs in the part of Sok RNA that is responsible for the initial recognition of the target loop in hok mRNA and thus leads to functional inactivation of the antisense. The major RNase E cleavage product (denoted pSok_-6) is rapidly degraded by polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNPase). Thus, the RNase E cleavage tags pSok₋₆ for further rapid degradation by PNPase from its 3' end. We also show that Sok RNA is polyadenylated by poly(A) polymerase I (PAP I), and that the poly(A)-tailing is prerequisite for the rapid 3'-exonucleolytic degradation by PNPase.     

Comparison of ccd of F, parDE of RP4, and parD of R1 using a novel conditional replication control system of plasmid R1

A number of plasmid-encoded gene systems are thought to stabilize plasmids by killing plasmid-free cells (also termed post-segregational killing or plasmid addiction). Here we analyse the mechanisms of plasmid stabilization by ccd of F, parDE of RP4 and parD of R1, and compare them to hok/sok of R1. To induce synchronous plasmid loss we constructed a novel plasmid replication-arrest system, which possesses the advantage that plasmid replication can be completely arrested by the addition of IPTG, a non-metabolizable inducer. Using isogenic plasmid constructions we have found, for the first time, consistent correlation between the effect on steady-state loss rates and the effect on cell proliferation in the plasmid replication-arrest assay for all three systems. The parDE system had the most pronounced effect both on plasmid stabilization and on plasmid retention after replication arrest. In contrast, ccd and parD both exhibited weaker effects than anticipated from previously published results. Thus, our results indicate that the function and efficiencies of some of the systems should be reconsidered. Our results are consistent with the previously postulated hypothesis that ccd and parDE act by killing plasmid-free segregants, whereas parD seems to act by inhibiting cell division of plasmid-free segregants.     

Combining the hok/sok, parDE, and pnd postsegregational killer loci to enhance plasmid stability.

To enhance plasmid segregational stability in bacterial cells, two pairs of independent postsegregational killing loci (genes which induce host killing upon plasmid loss) isolated from plasmids R1, R483, or RP4 (hok+/sok+ pnd+ or hok+/sok+ parDE+) were cloned into a common site of the beta-galactosidase expression vector pMJR1750 (ptac::lacZ+) to form a series of plasmids in which the effect of one or two stability loci on segregational plasmid stability could be discerned. Adding two antisense killer loci (hok+/sok+ pnd+) decreased the specific growth rate by 50% though they were more effective at reducing segregational instability than hok+/sok+ alone. With the ptac promoter induced fully (2.0 mM isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside) and no antibiotic selection pressure, the combination of a proteic killer locus (parDE+) with antisense killer loci (hok+/sok+) had a negligible impact on specific growth rate, maintained high beta-galactosidase expression, and led to a 30 and 190% increase in segregational stability (based on stable generations) as compared to plasmids containing either hok+/sok+ or parDE+ alone, respectively. Use of hok+/sok+ or parDE+ alone with high cloned-gene expression led to ninefold and fourfold increases in the number of stable generations, respectively. Two convenient cloning cassettes have been constructed to facilitate cloning the dual hok+/sok+ parDE+ and hok+/sok+ pnd+ killer systems.     

Antisense RNA regulation in prokaryotes: rapid RNA/RNA interaction facilitated by a general U-turn loop structure

Efficient gene control by antisense RNA requires rapid bi-molecular interaction with a cognate target RNA. A comparative analysis revealed that a YUNR motif (Y=pyrimidine, R=purine) is ubiquitous in RNA recognition loops in antisense RNA-regulated gene systems. The (Y)UNR sequence motif specifies two intraloop hydrogen bonds forming U-turn structures in many anticodon-loops and all T-loops of tRNAs, the hammerhead ribozyme and in other conserved RNA loops. This structure creates a sharp bend in the RNA phosphate-backbone and presents the following three to four bases in a solvent-exposed, stacked configuration providing a scaffold for rapid interaction with complementary RNA. Sok antisense RNA from plasmid R1 inhibits translation of the hok mRNA by preventing ribosome entry at the mok Shine & Dalgarno element. The 5' single-stranded region of Sok-RNA recognizes a loop in the hok mRNA. We show here, that the initial pairing between Sok antisense RNA and its target in hok mRNA occurs with an observed second-order rate-constant of 2 x 10(6) M(-1) s(-1). Mutations that eliminate the YUNR motif in the target loop of hok mRNA resulted in reduced antisense RNA pairing kinetics, whereas mutations maintaining the YUNR motif were silent. In addition, RNA phosphate-backbone accessibility probing by ethylnitrosourea was consistent with a U-turn structure formation promoted by the YUNR motif. Since the YUNR U-turn motif is present in the recognition units of many antisense/target pairs, the motif is likely to be a generally employed enhancer of RNA pairing rates. This suggestion is consistent with the re-interpretation of the mutational analyses of several antisense control systems including RNAI/RNAII of ColE1, CopA/CopT of R1 and RNA-IN/RNA-OUT of IS10.     

The istA gene of insertion sequence IS21 is essential for cleavage at the inner 3'' ends of tandemly repeated IS21 elements in vitro.

The bacterial 2.1 kb insertion sequence IS21 occurs as a tandem repeat [=(IS21)2] on the broad host range plasmid R68.45. In (IS21)2, the two IS21 elements are separated by 3 bp termed junction sequence. Plasmids carrying (IS21)2 form cointegrates with other replicons at high frequencies. The two IS21 genes, istA and istB, were found to be necessary for cointegrate formation in vivo. Since the outer ends of (IS21)2 are dispensable for cointegrate formation, we favor a transposition model according to which a plasmid carrying (IS21)2 is cleaved at the junction sequence; the opened plasmid is then inserted into a target replicon. Here we show that Escherichia coli cell extracts, which contained over-produced IstA protein, nicked a supercoiled (IS21)2 plasmid precisely at the inner 3' termini of IS21; the resulting staggered cut generated 5' protrusions. The istA gene, but not the istB gene, was required for in vitro cleavage of an IS21-IS21 junction. Because of this cleavage and our previous findings (generation of 4 bp target duplications and loss of the junction sequence after cointegrate formation in vivo) we propose that plasmids with (IS21)2 produce cointegrates by a mechanism which involves joining of the inner 3' ends of IS21 to the 5' ends of the target.     

Exclusion of T4 phage by the hok/sok killer locus from plasmid R1.

The hok (host killing) and sok (suppressor of killing) genes (hok/sok) efficiently maintain the low-copy-number plasmid R1. To investigate whether the hok/sok locus evolved as a phage-exclusion mechanism, Escherichia coli cells that contain hok/sok on a pBR322-based plasmid were challenged with T1, T4, T5, T7, and lambda phage. Upon infection with T4, the optical density of cells containing hok/sok on a high-copy-number plasmid continued to increase whereas the optical density for those lacking hok/sok rapidly declined. The presence of hok/sok reduced the efficiency of plating of T4 by 42% and decreased the plaque size by approximately 85%. Single-step growth experiments demonstrated that hok/sok decreased the T4 burst size by 40%, increased the time to form mature phage (eclipse time) from 22 to 30 min, and increased the time to cell lysis (latent period) from 30 to 60 min. These results further suggest that single cells exhibit altruistic behavior.