pp60v-src transformation of rat cells but not chicken cells strongly correlates with low-affinity phosphopeptide binding by the SH2 domain.

Substrates critical for transformation by pp60v-src remain unknown, as does the precise role of the src homology 2 (SH2) domain in this process. To continue exploring the role of the SH2 domain in pp60v-src-mediated transformation, site-directed mutagenesis was used to create mutant v-src alleles predicted to encode proteins with overall structural integrity intact but with reduced ability to bind phosphotyrosine-containing peptides. Arginine-175, which makes critical contacts in the phosphotyrosine-binding pocket, was mutated to lysine or alanine. Unexpectedly, both mutations created v-src alleles that transform chicken cells with wild-type (wt) efficiency and are reduced for transformation of rat cells; these alleles are host dependent for transformation. Additionally, these alleles resulted in a round morphological transformation of chicken cells, unlike 12 of the 13 known host-dependent src SH2 mutations that result in a fusiform morphology. Analysis of phosphopeptide binding by the mutant SH2 domains reveal that the in vitro ability to bind phosphopeptides known to have a high affinity for wt src SH2 correlates with wt (round) morphological transformation in chicken cells and in vitro ability to bind phosphopeptides known to have a low affinity for wt src SH2 correlates with rat cell transformation. These results suggest that the search for critical substrates in rat cells should be among proteins that interact with pp60v-src with low affinity.     

Autophosphorylation is required for high kinase activity and efficient transformation ability of proteins encoded by host range alleles of v-src.

pp60v-src is a nonreceptor protein tyrosine kinase that can transform both chicken and rodent fibroblasts. The src homology 2 (SH2) domain of this protein serves a critical role in the regulation of protein tyrosine kinase activity. The host range proteins pp60v-src-L, which contains a deletion of a highly conserved residue (Phe-172) in the SH2 domain, and pp60v-src-PPP, which contains a change from a Leu to a Phe at amino acid 186 in the SH2 domain, transform chicken but not rat cells and have slightly reduced kinase activity measured in vitro. The data presented here show that these altered proteins require autophosphorylation on Tyr-416 for high kinase activity and transforming ability. In the absence of autophosphorylation, there is a further decrease of at least threefold in in vitro kinase activity relative to the phosphorylated host range parental protein, no morphological transformation, a reduction in anchorage independent growth, and no disruption of the actin cytoskeleton. In addition, these SH2 mutations abolish the ability of the SH2 domain to bind a phosphorylated peptide that corresponds to the autophosphorylation site of pp60src. Thus, like mutant alleles of c-src encoding transformation competent proteins, and unlike v-src, transformation by pp60v-src-F172 delta and pp60v-src-L186F is dependent on phosphorylation of Y-416 for high kinase activity and transformation ability. The dependence of transformation on phosphotyrosine is not a reflection of an intramolecular interaction between the autophosphorylation site and the SH2 domains since purified SH2 domains are incapable of binding phosphorylated autophosphorylation site peptides in vitro.     

Transformation and pp60v-src autophosphorylation correlate with SHC-GRB2 complex formation in rat and chicken cells expressing host-range and kinase-active, transformation-defective alleles of v-src.

The biochemical properties of several pp60v-src substrates believed to participate in src-mediated transformation were examined in cells expressing a kinase-active, transformation-defective v-src allele (v-src-F172 delta/Y416F) and its parental allele, v-src-F172 delta, a host-range--dependent allele that transforms chicken cells to a fusiform morphology, but does not transform rat cells. Because pp60v-src-F172 delta is dependent on autophosphorylation for transforming ability, these alleles provide a unique opportunity to examine the role of pp60v-src autophosphorylation in regulating substrate interactions. Increased pp125FAK tyrosine phosphorylation and high levels of pp60v-src-associated phosphotidylinositol-3' kinase activity were detected specifically in chicken cells exhibiting round, refractile transformation but not in cells transformed to a fusiform morphology. Increased pp125FAK kinase activity, but not increased pp125FAK tyrosine-phosphorylation correlated with pp60v-src autophosphorylation and increased anchorage-independent growth. Thus, pp125FAK and PI3'K may participate in morphological transformation by v-src. Furthermore, association of phosphorylated SHC with the adapter GRB2 correlated with increased anchorage-independent growth (and autophosphorylation) in both rat and chicken cells independent of the morphological phenotype induced. Therefore, host-range dependence for transformation may be regulated through association of SHC with GRB2, thus implicating SHC as a crucial substrate for src-dependent transformation.     

A mutation at the ATP-binding site of pp60v-src abolishes kinase activity, transformation, and tumorigenicity.

We constructed a mutant, called RSV-SF2, at the ATP-binding site of pp60v-src. In this mutant, lysine-295 is replaced with methionine. SF2 pp60v-src was found to have a half-life similar to that of wild-type pp60v-src and was localized in the membranous fraction of the cell. Rat cells expressing SF2 pp60v-src were morphologically untransformed and do not form tumors. The SF2 pp60v-src isolated from these cells lacked kinase activity with either specific immunoglobulin or other substrates, and expression of SF2 pp60v-src failed to cause an increase of total phosphotyrosine in the proteins of infected cells. Wild-type pp60v-src was phosphorylated on serine and tyrosine in infected cells, and the analogous phosphorylations could also be carried out in vitro. Phosphorylation of serine was catalyzed by a cyclic AMP-dependent protein kinase, and phosphorylation of tyrosine was perhaps catalyzed by pp60v-src itself. By contrast, SF2 pp60v-src could not be phosphorylated on serine or tyrosine either in infected cells or in vitro. These findings strengthen the belief that the phosphotransferase activity of pp60v-src is required for neoplastic transformation by the protein and suggest that the binding of ATP to pp60v-src elicits an allosteric change required for phosphorylation of serine in the protein.     

Aberrant protein phosphorylation at tyrosine is responsible for the growth-inhibitory action of pp60v-src expressed in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Expression of pp60v-src, the transforming protein of Rous sarcoma virus, arrests the growth of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. To determine the basis of this growth arrest, yeast strains were constructed that expressed either wild-type v-src or various mutant v-src genes under the control of the galactose-inducible, glucose repressible GAL1 promoter. When shifted to galactose medium, cells expressing wild-type v-src ceased growth immediately and lost viability, whereas cells expressing a catalytically inactive mutant (K295M) continued to grow normally, indicating that the kinase activity of pp60v-src is required for its growth inhibitory effect. Mutants of v-src altered in the SH2/SH3 domain (XD4, XD6, SPX1, and SHX13) and a mutant lacking a functional N-terminal myristoylation signal (MM4) caused only a partial inhibition of growth, indicating that complete growth inhibition requires either targeting of the active kinase or binding of the kinase to phosphorylated substrates, or both. Cells arrested by v-src expression displayed aberrant microtubule structures, alterations in DNA content and elevated p34CDC28 kinase activity. Immunoblotting with antiphosphotyrosine antibody showed that many yeast proteins, including the p34CDC28 kinase, became phosphorylated at tyrosine in cells expressing v-src. Both the growth inhibition and the tyrosine-specific protein phosphorylation observed following v-src expression were reversed by co-expression of a mammalian phosphotyrosine-specific phosphoprotein phosphatase (PTP1B). However a v-src mutant with a small insertion in the catalytic domain (SRX5) had the same lethal effect as wild-type v-src, yet induced only very low levels of protein-tyrosine phosphorylation. These results indicate that inappropriate phosphorylation at tyrosine is the primary cause of the lethal effect of pp60v-src expression but suggest that only a limited subset of the phosphorylated proteins are involved in this effect.     

Elevated phosphatidylinositol kinase activity in Rous sarcoma virus-transformed cells. Lack of evidence for enzyme translocation

Phosphatidylinositol kinase (E.C. 2.7.1.67) activity of rat fibroblasts transformed by Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) was measured and compared with immunoprecipitated protein tyrosine kinase activity associated with pp60v-src. Both enzyme activities were elevated in the particulate fractions from wild-type RSV-transformed cells and cells transformed by a temperature-sensitive mutant of RSV when grown at the permissive temperature. The presence of the non-ionic detergent Nonidet P-40 in the phosphatidylinositol kinase assays stimulated the soluble and particulate forms of the enzyme to different degrees but did not affect the relative differences between transformed and untransformed cells. Our results indicate that phosphatidylinositol kinase activity is a good correlate of RSV transformation and suggest a functional relationship between pp60v-src and phosphatidylinositol kinase.     

Polyamines are essential for cell transformation by pp60v-src: delineation of molecular events relevant for the transformed phenotype

Ornithine decarboxylase (ODC), the key enzyme of polyamine biosynthesis, becomes upregulated during cell proliferation and transformation. Here we show that intact ODC activity is needed for the acquisition of a transformed phenotype in rat 2R cells infected with a temperature-sensitive mutant of Rous sarcoma virus. Addition of the ODC inhibitor alpha-difluoromethyl ornithine (DFMO) to the cells (in polyamine-free medium) before shift to permissive temperature prevented the depolymerization of filamentous actin and morphological transformation. Polyamine supplementation restored the transforming potential of pp60v-src. DFMO did not interfere with the expression of pp60v-src or its in vitro tyrosine kinase activity. The tyrosine phosphorylation of most cellular proteins, including ras GAP, did not either display clear temperature- or DFMO-sensitive changes. A marked increase was, however, observed in the tyrosine phosphorylation of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase and proteins of 33 and 36 kD upon the temperature shift, and these hyperphosphorylations were partially inhibited by DFMO. A DFMO-sensitive increase was also found in the total phosphorylation of calpactins I and II. The well-documented association of GAP with the phosphotyrosine-containing proteins p190 and p62 did not correlate with transformation, but a novel 42-kD tyrosine phosphorylated protein was complexed with GAP in a polyamine- and transformation-dependent manner. Further, tyrosine phosphorylated proteins of 130, 80/85, and 36 kD were found to coimmunoprecipitate with pp60v-src in a transformation-related manner. Altogether, this model offers a tool for sorting out the protein phosphorylations and associations critical for the transformed phenotype triggered by pp60v- src, and implicates a pivotal role for polyamines in cell transformation.     

The use of Rous sarcoma virus transformation mutants with differing tyrosine kinase activities to study the relationships between vinculin phosphorylation, pp60v-src location and adhesion plaque integrity

Tyrosine-specific phosphorylation of cellular proteins has been implicated in the neoplastic transformation of cells by Rous sarcoma virus (RSV). One of the putative substrates for the src gene product (pp60v-src) of RSV is the cytoskeletal protein vinculin, giving rise to the hypothesis that tyrosine-specific phosphorylation of vinculin disrupts adhesion plaque integrity, leading to the characteristic rounded morphology of RSV-transformed cells. We have investigated this hypothesis by analysing the properties of fibroblasts transformed by conditional and non-conditional mutants of RSV which confer different morphologies on infected cells, with respect to formation of microfilament bundles, formation of vinculin-containing adhesion plaques, the deposition of a fibronectin-containing extracellular matrix, the localization of pp60v-src and the tyrosine-specific phosphorylation of vinculin. Cells transformed by the temperature-sensitive (ts) RSV mutant LA32 cultured at 41 degrees C were morphologically normal, and contained prominent microfilament bundles and well-developed adhesion plaques. However, these cells had a fully active pp60v-src kinase, had pp60v-src concentrated in their adhesion plaques and contained vinculin which was heavily phosphorylated on tyrosine residues. Cells transformed by a recovered avian sarcoma virus, rASV 2234.3 exhibited a markedly fusiform morphology with pp60v-src concentrated in well-developed adhesion plaques and an elevation of the phosphotyrosine content of vinculin. Cells transformed by LA32 at restrictive temperature comprise morphologically normal cells, indistinguishable from untransformed CEF, yet which contain tyrosine-phosphorylated vinculin and suggest that neither tyrosine-specific phosphorylation of vinculin nor pp60v-src concentration in adhesion plaques is sufficient for the rounded morphology of RSV-transformed cells.     

Glutamic acid decarboxylase activity is stimulated in quail retina neuronal cells transformed by Rous sarcoma virus and is regulated by pp60v-src.

Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) stimulates in quail embryo neuro-retina (NR) cultures the specific activity of glutamic acid decarboxylase (GAD), the enzyme responsible for the synthesis of gamma-aminobutyric acid, a major inhibitory neurotransmitter in NR and in central nervous system. In quail embryo NR cultures transformed by ts NY-68, a thermodependent transformation-defective mutant of RSV, stimulation of GAD activity is regulated by pp60v-src, the product of the src gene of RSV. Fibroblasts and myoblasts have a very low GAD activity that is not stimulated after transformation by RSV. Neuronal clones, previously derived from ts NY-68-transformed established NR cell lines, have a high GAD activity which is regulated by pp60v-src, while other clones have a low GAD activity apparently not regulated by pp60v-src. These data indicate that pp60v-src selectively activates the expression of GAD in distinct neuronal cells of quail embryo NR cultures transformed by RSV. GAD activity is also stimulated in NR cells infected with viruses containing v-mil.     

Specific desensitization of the epidermal growth factor receptor by pp60v-src

BALB/c 3T3 cells infected with a temperature-sensitive mutant (LA90) of RSV have been used to investigate possible heterologous interactions between the pp60v-src tyrosyl kinase and the epidermal growth factor (EGF) and bradykinin receptors. The LA90 pp60v-src exhibits a very rapid activation t1/2 (less than 5 min) of protein kinase activity on decreasing the temperature from 40 degrees C to 35 degrees C. This change in temperature was also found to induce a very rapid decrease in the affinity for 125I-EGF of receptors on the RSV-LA90-infected cells but not of those on control parental cells. However, no significant changes were detected in the binding of 3H-bradykinin to either cell line. Two separable processes control the desensitization of the EGF receptor by pp60v-src, both of which are independent of protein kinase C. The first is rapid and transient, while the second is sensitive to cycloheximide and persists long after inactivation of pp60v-src.     

Detection of phosphotyrosine-containing proteins in polyomavirus middle tumor antigen-transformed cells after treatment with a phosphotyrosine phosphatase inhibitor.

Cells transformed with the middle tumor antigen (mT) of polyomavirus were treated with sodium orthovanadate (Na3VO4), an inhibitor of phosphotyrosine phosphatases, to enhance for the detection of cellular proteins which are phosphorylated on tyrosine. Na3VO4 treatment of mT-transformed rat F1-11 cells resulted in a 16-fold elevation in the level of phosphotyrosine associated with total cellular proteins. Parental F1-11 cells displayed only a twofold increase in phosphotyrosine following Na3VO4 treatment. The abundance of phosphotyrosine in Na3VO4-treated mT-transformed F1-11 cells was twofold higher than in untreated Rous sarcoma virus (RSV)-transformed F1-11 cells and 3.5-fold lower than in Na3VO4-treated RSV-transformed F1-11 cells. Tyrosine phosphorylation of many cellular proteins, including p36, the major substrate of the RSV pp60v-src protein, was detected in Na3VO4-treated mT-transformed F1-11 cells at levels comparable to those observed in RSV-transformed cells. Some of the major protein species recognized by antiphosphotyrosine antibodies in Na3VO4-treated mT-transformed cells displayed electrophoretic mobilities similar to those detected in RSV-transformed F1-11 cells. Tyrosine phosphorylation of p36 was also detected in fibroblasts infected with polyomavirus. There was no detectable difference in the kinase activity of pp60c-src:mT extracted from untreated and Na3VO4-treated mT-transformed cells; however, Na3VO4 treatment of F1-11 and mT-transformed F1-11 cells was shown to inhibit the activity of phosphotyrosine phosphatases in a crude assay of total cellular activity with pp60v-src as the substrate. Thus, Na3VO4 treatment may allow the detection of phosphotyrosine-containing proteins in mT-transformed cells by preventing the turnover of phosphate on substrates phosphorylated by activated cellular protein-tyrosine kinases associated with mT. These results suggest that tyrosine phosphorylation of cellular proteins may be involved in the events that are responsible for mT-induced cellular transformation.     

The mitogenic activity of pp60v-src, the oncogenic protein product of the src gene of avian sarcoma virus, is independent of external serum growth factors

The oncogenic pp60v-src product of ASV (avian sarcoma virus) is shown to be a potent endogenous mitogen, which, unlike mitogens such as PDGF (platelet derived growth factor), is able to stimulate host cell proliferation without the help of other growth factors. Thus, NRK rat cells, infected with a temperature-sensitive ASV mutant which produces an abnormally thermolabile pp60v-src, became proliferatively quiescent at a pp60v-src-inactivating 40 degrees C in medium containing either 0.2% calf serum or no serum at all. Adding PDGF stimulated the quiescent tsASV-NRK cells at 40 degrees C to initiate DNA replication in medium containing 0.2% serum, but not in serum-free medium. By contrast, activating internal pp60v-src by dropping the temperature to a permissive 36 degrees C stimulated these quiescent cells to transit G1, initiate DNA replication and to enter mitosis even in serum-free medium. Thus, relative to PDGF, endogenous pp60v-src behaves as a complete mitogen.     

Intracellular localization and processing of pp60v-src proteins expressed by two distinct temperature-sensitive mutants of Rous sarcoma virus.

The transforming protein of Rous sarcoma virus, pp60v-src, is known to be a tyrosine protein kinase, but the mechanism of cell transformation remains unclear. In further investigating pp60v-src structure and function, we have analyzed two temperature-sensitive (ts) Rous sarcoma virus src gene mutants, tsLA29 and tsLA32. The mutations in tsLA29 and tsLA32 map in the carboxy-terminal region and the amino-terminal half of pp60v-src, respectively, and encode mutant proteins with either temperature-labile (tsLA29) or -stable (tsLA32) kinase activities. Here we examined the intracellular processing and localization of these pp60v-src mutants and extended our characterization of transformation parameters expressed by cells infected by the Rous sarcoma virus variants. No obvious defects in functional integrity of the tsLA32 pp60v-src could yet be demonstrated, whereas the tsLA29 pp60v-src was perturbed not only in kinase activity, but also in aspects of protein processing and localization. Analysis of transformation parameters expressed by infected cells demonstrated the complete temperature lability of both mutants.     

Restriction of the in vitro and in vivo tyrosine protein kinase activities of pp60c-src relative to pp60v-src.

The tyrosine protein kinase activities of pp60c-src and pp60v-src were compared. The activities were qualitatively similar in vitro when the src proteins were bound in an immune complex with monoclonal antibody; both proteins utilized either ATP or GTP as phosphate donors, preferred Mn2+ to Mg2+, and had similar exogenous substrate specificities. The specific activity of pp60c-src was about 10-fold lower than that of pp60v-src for exogenous substrate phosphorylation but was only 1.1- to 2-fold lower than that of pp60v-src for autophosphorylation. Six glycolytic enzymes, including three not previously identified as substrates for pp60src phosphorylation, were phosphorylated by both pp60c-src and pp60v-src. Levels of pp60c-src fourfold higher than the amount of pp60v-src in src-plasmid-transformed cells did not detectably alter the level of phosphotyrosine in cellular proteins, but increasing the expression of pp60c-src another twofold (which induces cells to form foci in monolayer culture (P.J. Johnson, P.M. Coussens, A.V. Danko, and D. Shalloway, Mol. Cell. Biol. 5:1073-1083, 1985) resulted in a threefold increase in the level of cellular protein phosphotyrosine. Immunoprecipitation and analysis of the alkali-stable phosphoproteins by two-dimensional electrophoresis showed that, in contrast to pp60v-src-transformed cells, pp36 and enolase are only weakly phosphorylated in these high-level pp60c-src overexpresser cells. Even allowing for the in vitro differences in specific activities of phosphorylation, these results suggest that the pp60c-src tyrosine protein phosphorylating activity may be restricted relative to that of pp60v-src by additional in vivo mechanisms.     

Expression of pp60v-src alters the ionic permeability of the plasma membrane in rat cells

The transmembrane potential of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV)-infected Rat-1 cells, expressing the pp60v-src protein kinase, is markedly less negative (by approximately 30 mV) than that of their normal counterparts. By contrast, the membrane potential of Rat-1 cells infected with Kirsten sarcoma virus is virtually unaltered. The RSV-induced membrane depolarization is shown to be due to a severalfold increase in the cation permeability ratio (PNa/PK) of the plasma membrane. When cells infected with a temperature-sensitive mutant of RSV (ts LA29), encoding a src protein with heat-labile kinase activity, are shifted from the nonpermissive to the permissive temperature, a rapid and sustained membrane depolarization is observed. Conversely, thermal inactivation of the ts LA29 pp60v-src kinase activity rapidly restores the membrane potential to near normal levels. Addition of epidermal growth factor, platelet-derived growth factor, or insulin to uninfected cells fails to cause a detectable change in membrane potential. We conclude that, unlike growth factor receptor tyrosine kinases, pp60v-src can induce, either directly or indirectly, a major change in the membrane permeability to monovalent cations.     

Highly specific antibody to Rous sarcoma virus src gene product recognizes a novel population of pp60v-src and pp60c-src molecules

Antiserum to the Rous sarcoma virus (RSV)-transforming protein, pp60v-src, was produced in rabbits immunized with p60 expressed in Escherichia coli. alpha p60 serum immunoprecipitated quantitatively more pp60v-src than did tumor-bearing rabbit (TBR) sera. When RSV-transformed cell lysates were preadsorbed with TBR serum, the remaining lysate contained additional pp60v-src, which was recognized only by reimmunoprecipitation with alpha p60 serum and not by TBR serum. In subcellular fractions of RSV-infected chicken embryo fibroblasts (RSV-CEFs) and field vole cells probed with TBR serum, the majority of the pp60v-src was associated with the plasma membrane-enriched P100 fraction. However, alpha p60 serum revealed equal distribution of pp60v-src and its kinase activity between the P1 (nuclear) and P100 fractions. The same results were obtained for pp60c-src in uninfected CEFs. On discontinuous sucrose gradients nearly 50% of the P1-pp60v-src sedimented with nuclei, in fractions where no plasma membrane was detected. Indirect immunofluorescence microscopy of RSV-CEFs with alpha p60 serum revealed a distinct pattern of perinuclear fluorescence, in addition to staining at the cell periphery. Thus the use of a highly specific antibody reveals that enzymatically active pp60v-src and pp60c-src molecules are present in other intracellular structures, probably juxtareticular nuclear membranes, in addition to the plasma membrane in normal, uninfected, and wild-type RSV-infected cells.     

Visualization of phosphotyrosine containing molecules within the detergent insoluble cell matrix of v-src transformed fibroblasts

The RSV oncogene v-src is known to transform host cells through the action of a single gene protein product (pp60src) endowed with tyrosine specific kinase activity. The nature and cellular localization of substrates of pp60src kinase are largely unknown. Detergent insoluble cell matrix was prepared by treating RSV-transformed mouse fibroblasts with the non-ionic detergent NP-40. These preparations, highly enriched in cytoskeletal proteins, when observed in the E M consisted mainly of a meshwork of filaments; fragments of plasma membrane and nuclear “ghosts” were also present. Antibodies against phosphotyrosine -previously shown to be reactive with protein phosphorylated at tyrosine residues- were prepared and affinity purified using a synthetic hapten (azobenzyl phosphonic acid, ABP). By means of the immunogold techniques applied to electron microscopy, phosphotyrosine containing molecules were found to be present in RSV transformed, but not in control fibroblasts. Gold particles were mostly bound to electron dense granular material associated with the filaments. These results are consistent with the idea that pp60src itself and some tyrosine phosphorylated proteins may be found among detergent-insoluble cell structures.     

pp60v-src association with the cytoskeleton induces actin reorganization without affecting polymerization status

The mechanism by which Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) induces a reorganization of actin and its associated proteins and a reduction in microfilament bundles is at present poorly understood. To examine the relationship between the organization of the microfilament system and the polymerization state of actin after transformation, we have investigated these changes in a Rat-1 cell line transformed by LA29, a temperature-sensitive (ts) mutant of RSV. Parallel immunofluorescence and biochemical analysis demonstrated that LA29 pp60v-src was ts for tyrosine kinase activity and cytoskeletal association. Changes in the distribution and organization of actin, alpha-actinin and vinculin were dependent on the association of a kinase-active pp60v-src molecule with the detergent-insoluble cytoskeleton. Whilst there was a transformation-dependent loss of microfilament bundles, biochemical quantitation demonstrated that the polymerization state of the actin in both detergent-soluble and insoluble fractions of these cells grown at temperatures either permissive or restrictive for transformation was quantitatively unchanged. These results indicate that the loss of microfilament bundles after transformation is not due to a net depolymerization of filamentous actin but rather to a reorganization of polymeric actin from microfilament bundles and stress fibers to other polymeric forms within the cell. The polymeric nature of the actin in these cells was confirmed by electron microscopy of cytoskeletons and substrate-adherent membranes.