Recognition of tRNAs by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases: Escherichia coli tRNAMet and E. coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase

In previous work we identified several specific sites in Escherichia coli tRNAfMet that are essential for recognition of this tRNA by E. coli methionyl-tRNA synthetase (MetRS) (EC 6.1.1.10). Particularly strong evidence indicated a role for the nucleotide base at the wobble position of the anticodon in the discrimination process. We have now investigated the aminoacylation activity of a series of tRNAfMet derivatives containing single base changes in each position of the anticodon. In addition, derivatives containing permuted sequences and larger and smaller anticodon loops have been prepared. The variant tRNAs have been enzymatically synthesized in vitro by using T4 RNA ligase (EC 6.5.1.3). Base substitutions in the wobble position have been found to reduce aminoacylation rates by at least five orders of magnitude. Derivatives having base substitutions in the other two positions of the anticodon are aminoacylated 55-18,500 times slower than normal. Nucleotides that have specific functional groups in common with the normal anticodon bases are better tolerated at each of these positions than those that do not. A tRNAfMet variant having a six-membered loop containing only the CA sequence of the anticodon is aminoacylated still more slowly, and a derivative containing a five-membered loop is not measurably active. The normal loop size can be increased by one nucleotide with a relatively small effect on the rate of aminoacylation, which indicates that the spatial arrangement of the nucleotides is less critical than their chemical nature. We conclude from these data that recognition of tRNAfMet requires highly specific interactions of MetRS with functional groups on the nucleotide bases of the anticodon sequence. Several other aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are known to require one or more anticodon bases for efficient aminoacylation of their tRNA substrates, and data from other laboratories suggest that anticodon sequences may be important for accurate discrimination between cognate and noncoagnate tRNAs by these enzymes.     

The translational efficiency of tRNA is a property of the anticodon arm

We have reciprocally transplanted the anticodon arm sequences of a set of amber suppressor tRNA genes, using recombinant DNA techniques. By this means, a very efficient suppressor may be converted to a poor one, and the poorest tRNA to the efficiency of the best one. In tRNA molecules of normal 2 degrees and 3 degrees structure, the suppressor efficiencies of different composite tRNAs having the same anticodon arm sequence are approximately the same. Large numbers of simultaneous changes throughout the rest of the molecule do not affect the efficiency. Selective nucleotide modification as a result of varied anticodon arm sequences cannot explain these efficiencies. Efficiencies are also unlikely to differ because of selective aminoacylation. Measurement of in vivo tRNA shows, however, that tRNA levels do vary if the anticodon arm sequence is changed. If tRNA levels are normalized, the anticodon arm effect on the translational efficiency remains. Therefore, different anticodon arms, all of normal secondary structure, are not equivalent in translation. The most efficient sequences in this series resemble those found in natural tRNAs associated with similar anticodons, as is proposed in the extended anticodon theory (Yarus, M. (1982) Science 218, 646-652). These molecules also provide some information on the specificity of nucleotide modification enzymes and on determinants of the steady-state tRNA level.     

Direct analysis of aminoacylation levels of tRNAs in vivo. Application to studying recognition of Escherichia coli initiator tRNA mutants by glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase.

We describe the use of a gel electrophoretic method for measuring the levels of aminoacylation in vivo of mutant Escherichia coli initiator tRNAs, which are substrates for E. coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS) due to an anticodon sequence change. Using this method, we have compared the effects of introducing further mutations in the acceptor stem, at base pairs 1:72, 2:71, and 3:70 and discriminator base 73, on the recognition of these tRNAs by E. coli GlnRS in vitro and in vivo. The effects of the acceptor stem mutations on the kinetic parameters for aminoacylation of the mutant tRNAs in vitro are consistent with interactions seen between this region of tRNA and GlnRS in the crystal structure of tRNA(Gln). GlnRS complex. Except for one mutant, the observed levels of aminoacylation of the mutant tRNAs in vivo agree with those expected on the basis of the kinetic parameters obtained in vitro. We have also measured the relative amounts of aminoacyl-tRNAs for the various mutants and their activities in suppression of an amber codon in vivo. We find that there is, in general, a good correlation between the relative amounts of aminoacyl-tRNAs and their activities in suppression.     

Kinetic discrimination of tRNA identity by the conserved motif 2 loop of a class II aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase

The selection of tRNAs by their cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases is critical for ensuring the fidelity of protein synthesis. While nucleotides that comprise tRNA identity sets have been readily identified, their specific role in the elementary steps of aminoacylation is poorly understood. By use of a rapid kinetics analysis employing mutants in tRNA(His) and its cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase, the role of tRNA identity in aminoacylation was investigated. While mutations in the tRNA anticodon preferentially affected the thermodynamics of initial complex formation, mutations in the acceptor stem or the conserved motif 2 loop of the tRNA synthetase imposed a specific kinetic block on aminoacyl transfer and decreased tRNA-mediated kinetic control of amino acid activation. The mechanistic basis of tRNA identity is analogous to fidelity control by DNA polymerases and the ribosome, whose reactions also demand high accuracy.     

Importance of the anticodon sequence in the aminoacylation of tRNAs by methionyl-tRNA synthetase and by valyl-tRNA synthetase in an Archaebacterium

The mode of recognition of tRNAs by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases and translation factors is largely unknown in archaebacteria. To study this process, we have cloned the wild type initiator tRNA gene from the moderate halophilic archaebacterium Haloferax volcanii and mutants derived from it into a plasmid capable of expressing the tRNA in these cells. Analysis of tRNAs in vivo show that the initiator tRNA is aminoacylated but is not formylated in H. volcanii. This result provides direct support for the notion that protein synthesis in archaebacteria is initiated with methionine and not with formylmethionine. We have analyzed the effect of two different mutations (CAU-->CUA and CAU-->GAC) in the anticodon sequence of the initiator tRNA on its recognition by the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases in vivo. The CAU-->CUA mutant was not aminoacylated to any significant extent in vivo, suggesting the importance of the anticodon in aminoacylation of tRNA by methionyl-tRNA synthetase. This mutant initiator tRNA can, however, be aminoacylated in vitro by the Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase, suggesting that the lack of aminoacylation is due to the absence in H. volcanii of a synthetase, which recognizes the mutant tRNA. Archaebacteria lack glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase and utilize a two-step pathway involving glutamyl-tRNA synthetase and glutamine amidotransferase to generate glutaminyl-tRNA. The lack of aminoacylation of the mutant tRNA indicates that this mutant tRNA is not a substrate for the H. volcanii glutamyl-tRNA synthetase. The CAU-->GAC anticodon mutant is most likely aminoacylated with valine in vivo. Thus, the anticodon plays an important role in the recognition of tRNA by at least two of the halobacterial aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases.     

Fluorine-19 nuclear magnetic resonance as a probe of the solution structure of mutants of 5-fluorouracil-substituted Escherichia coli valine tRNA.

In order to utilize 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to probe the solution structure of Escherichia coli tRNAVal labeled by incorporation of 5-fluorouracil, we have assigned its 19F spectrum. We describe here assignments made by examining the spectra of a series of tRNAVal mutants with nucleotide substitutions for individual 5-fluorouracil residues. The result of base replacements on the structure and function of the tRNA are also characterized. Mutants were prepared by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis of a cloned tRNAVal gene, and the tRNAs transcribed in vitro by bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. By identifying the missing peak in the 19F NMR spectrum of each tRNA variant we were able to assign resonances from fluorouracil residues in loop and stem regions of the tRNA. As a result of the assignment of FU33, FU34 and FU29, temperature-dependent spectral shifts could be attributed to changes in anticodon loop and stem conformation. Observation of a magnesium ion-dependent splitting of the resonance assigned to FU64 suggested that the T-arm of tRNAVal can exist in two conformations in slow exchange on the NMR time scale. Replacement of most 5-fluorouracil residues in loops and stems had little effect on the structure of tRNAVal; few shifts in the 19F NMR spectrum of the mutant tRNAs were noted. However, replacing the FU29.A41 base-pair in the anticodon stem with C29.G41 induced conformational changes in the anticodon loop as well as in the P-10 loop. Effects of nucleotide substitution on aminoacylation were determined by comparing the Vmax and Km values of tRNAVal mutants with those of the wild-type tRNA. Nucleotide substitution at the 3' end of the anticodon (position 36) reduced the aminoacylation efficiency (Vmax/Km) of tRNAVal by three orders of magnitude. Base replacement at the 5' end of the anticodon (position 34) had only a small negative effect on the aminoacylation efficiency. Substitution of the FU29.A41 base-pair increased the Km value 20-fold, while Vmax remained almost unchanged. The FU4.A69 base-pair in the acceptor stem, could readily be replaced with little effect on the aminoacylation efficiency of E. coli tRNAVal, indicating that this base-pair is not an identity element of the tRNA, as suggested by others.     

Recognition of tRNA backbone for aminoacylation with cysteine: evolution from Escherichia coli to human

The underlying basis of the genetic code is specific aminoacylation of tRNAs by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. Although the code is conserved, bases in tRNA that establish aminoacylation are not necessarily conserved. Even when the bases are conserved, positions of backbone groups that contribute to aminoacylation may vary. We show here that, although the Escherichia coli and human cysteinyl-tRNA synthetases both recognize the same bases (U73 and the GCA anticodon) of tRNA for aminoacylation, they have different emphasis on the tRNA backbone. The E. coli enzyme recognizes two clusters of phosphate groups. One is at A36 in the anticodon and the other is in the core of the tRNA structure and includes phosphate groups at positions 9, 12, 14, and 60. Metal-ion rescue experiments show that those at positions 9, 12, and 60 are involved with binding divalent metal ions that are important for aminoacylation. The E. coli enzyme also recognizes 2'-hydroxyl groups within the same two clusters: at positions 33, 35, and 36 in the anticodon loop, and at positions 49, 55, and 61 in the core. The human enzyme, by contrast, recognizes few phosphate or 2'-hydroxy groups for aminoacylation. The evolution from the backbone-dependent recognition by the E. coli enzyme to the backbone-independent recognition by the human enzyme demonstrates a previously unrecognized shift that nonetheless has preserved the specificity for aminoacylation with cysteine.     

Starvation-induced cleavage of the tRNA anticodon loop in Tetrahymena thermophila

Amino acid deprivation triggers dramatic physiological responses in all organisms, altering both the synthesis and destruction of RNA and protein. Here we describe, using the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila, a previously unidentified response to amino acid deprivation in which mature transfer RNA (tRNA) is cleaved in the anticodon loop. We observed that anticodon loop cleavage affects a small fraction of most or all tRNA sequences. Accumulation of cleaved tRNA is temporally coordinated with the morphological and metabolic changes of adaptation to starvation. The starvation-induced endonucleolytic cleavage activity targets tRNAs that have undergone maturation by 5' and 3' end processing and base modification. Curiously, the majority of cleaved tRNAs lack the 3' terminal CCA nucleotides required for aminoacylation. Starvation-induced tRNA cleavage is inhibited in the presence of essential amino acids, independent of the persistence of other starvation-induced responses. Our findings suggest that anticodon loop cleavage may reduce the accumulation of uncharged tRNAs as part of a specific response induced by amino acid starvation.     

Conversion of a methionine initiator tRNA into a tryptophan-inserting elongator tRNA in vivo.

The role of the anticodon and discriminator base in aminoacylation of tRNAs with tryptophan has been explored using a recently developed in vivo assay based on initiation of protein synthesis by mischarged mutants of the Escherichia coli initiator tRNA. Substitution of the methionine anticodon CAU with the tryptophan anticodon CCA caused tRNA(fMet) to be aminoacylated with both methionine and tryptophan in vivo, as determined by analysis of the amino acids inserted by the mutant tRNA at the translational start site of a reporter protein containing a tryptophan initiation codon. Conversion of the discriminator base of tRNA(CCA)fMet from A73 to G73, the base present in tRNA(Trp), eliminated the in vivo methionine acceptor activity of the tRNA and resulted in complete charging with tryptophan. Single base changes in the anticodon of tRNA(CCA)fMet containing G73 from CCA to UCA, GCA, CAA, and CCG (changes underlined) essentially abolished tryptophan insertion, showing that all three anticodon bases specify the tryptophan identity of the tRNA. The important role of G73 in tryptophan identity was confirmed using mutants of an opal suppressor derivative of tRNA(Trp). Substitution of G73 with A73, C73, or U73 resulted in a large loss of the ability of the tRNA to suppress an opal stop codon in a reporter protein. Base pair substitutions at the first three positions of the acceptor stem of the suppressor tRNA caused 2-12-fold reductions in the efficiency of suppression without loss of specificity for aminoacylation of the tRNA with tryptophan.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Systematic alterations in the anticodon arm make tRNA(Glu)-Suoc a more efficient suppressor.

Using site-specific mutagenesis, we constructed five more efficient variants of tRNA(Glu)-Suoc, an extremely inefficient ochre suppressor. Each variant has an extended anticodon, or region of the anticodon arm, which is more similar to that found in normal tRNAs which translate codons Uxx. Suppressor efficiency invariably increases with similarity of the extended anticodon to that of a normal Uxx-translating tRNA. Altered nucleotides in both helix and loop strongly affect efficiency, with no position dependence and no significant interaction between substitutions. The variant with all substitutions is 230-fold more efficient (in one context) than the parental tRNA(Glu)-Suoc. Two other unexpected variants seem to be 'context mutants', having altered response to message context.     

The in vivo stability, maturation and aminoacylation of anticodon-substituted Escherichia coli initiator methionine tRNAs

We have constructed eight anticodon-modified Escherichia coli initiator methionine (fMet) tRNAs by insertion of synthetic ribotrinucleotides between two fragments ('half molecules') derived from the initiator tRNA. The trinucleotides, namely CAU (the normal anticodon), CAA, CAC, CAG, GAA, GAC, GAG and GAU, were joined to the 5' and 3' tRNA fragments with T4 RNA ligase. The strategy of reconstruction permitted the insertion of radioactive 32P label between nucleotides 36 and 37. tRNAs were microinjected into the cytoplasm of Xenopus laevis oocytes, and the following properties were evaluated: the stability of these eubacterial tRNA variants in the eukaryotic oocytes; the enzymatic modification of the adenosine at position 37 (3' adjacent to the anticodon) and aminoacylation of the chimeric tRNAs by endogenous oocyte aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. In contrast to other variants, the two RNAs having CAU and GAU anticodons were stable and underwent quantitative modification at A-37. These results show that the enzyme responsible for the modification of A-37 to N-[N-(9-beta-D-ribofuranosylpurine-6-yl)carbamoyl]threonine (t6A) is present in the cytoplasm of oocytes and is very sensitive to the anticodon environment of the tRNA. Also, these same GAU and CAU anticodon-containing tRNAs are fully aminoacylated with the heterologous oocyte aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases in vivo. During the course of this work we developed a generally applicable assay for the aminoacylation of femtomole amounts of labelled tRNAs.     

The specificity of aminoacylation: a tRNA-tRNA interaction model.

Most of the isoacceptor species for a particular tRNA can be classified according to the middle base in the anticodon together with the fourth base in the amino acid stem. These specifying nucleotides would operate if a tRNA-tRNA interaction occurs on the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase so that the anticodon of one tRNA molecule faces the fourth base of the other tRNA molecule. This model explains most of the misacylation reactions or changes in aminoacylation after mutation or chemical modifications of tRNAs. It also provides an explanation for biochemical properties of the aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases such as the presence of two active sites, and for the high fidelity of the aminoacylation. It may give insight into the origin and stability of the genetic code.     

Role of the three consecutive G:C base pairs conserved in the anticodon stem of initiator tRNAs in initiation of protein synthesis in Escherichia coli.

The three consecutive G:C base pairs, G29:C41, G30:C40, and G31:C39, are conserved in the anticodon stem of virtually all initiator tRNAs from eubacteria, eukaryotes, and archaebacteria. We show that these G:C base pairs are important for function of the tRNA in initiation of protein synthesis in vivo. We changed these base pairs individually and in combinations and analyzed the activities of the mutant Escherichia coli initiator tRNAs in initiation in vivo. For assessment of activity of the mutant tRNAs in vivo, mutations in the G:C base pairs were coupled to mutation in the anticodon sequence from CAU to CUA. Mutations in each of the G:C base pairs reduced activity of the mutant tRNA in initiation, with mutation in the second G:C base pair having the most severe effect. The greatly reduced activity of this C30:G40 mutant tRNA is not due to defects in aminoacylation or formulation of the tRNA or defects in base modification of the A37, next to the anticodon, which we had previously shown to be important for activity of the mutant tRNAs in initiation. The anticodon stem mutants are most likely affected specifically at the step of binding to the ribosomal P site. The pattern of cleavages in the anticodon loop of mutant tRNAs by S1 nuclease indicate that the G:C base pairs may be involved directly in interactions of the tRNA with components of the P site on the ribosome rather than indirectly by inducing a particular conformation of the anticodon loop critical for function of the tRNA in initiation.     

Distinctive acceptor-end structure and other determinants of Escherichia coli tRNAPro identity.

The previously uncharacterized determinants of the specificity of tRNAPro for aminoacylation (tRNAPro identity) were defined by a computer comparison of all Escherichia coli tRNA sequences and tested by a functional analysis of amber suppressor tRNAs in vivo. We determined the amino acid specificity of tRNA by sequencing a suppressed protein and the aminoacylation efficiency of tRNA by examining the steady-state level of aminoacyl-tRNA. On substituting nucleotides derived from the acceptor end and variable pocket of tRNAPro for the corresponding nucleotides in a tRNAPhe gene, the identity of the resulting tRNA changed substantially but incompletely to that of tRNAPro. The redesigned tRNAPhe was weakly active and aminoacyl-tRNA was not detected. Ethyl methanesulfonate mutagenesis of the redesigned tRNAPhe gene produced a mutant with a wobble pair in place of a base pair in the end of the acceptor-stem helix of the transcribed tRNA. This mutant exhibited both a tRNAPro identity and substantial aminoacyl-tRNA. The results speak for the importance of a distinctive conformation in the acceptor-stem helix of tRNAPro for aminoacylation by the prolyl-tRNA synthetase. The anticodon also contributes to tRNAPro identity but is not necessary in vivo.     

Mutant enzymes and tRNAs as probes of the glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase: tRNA(Gln) interaction.

This paper focuses on several aspects of the specificity of mutants of Escherichia coli glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase (GlnRS) and tRNA(Gln). Temperature-sensitive mutants located in glnS, the gene for GlnRS, have been described previously. The mutations responsible for the temperature-sensitive phenotype were analyzed, and pseudorevertants of these mutants isolated and characterized. The nature of these mutations is discussed in terms of their location in the three-dimensional structure of the tRNA(Gln).GlnRS complex. In order to characterize the specificity of the aminoacylation reaction, mutant tRNA(Gln) species were synthesized with either a 2'-deoxy AMP or 3'-deoxy AMP as their 3'-terminal nucleotide. Subsequent assays for aminoacylation and ATP/PPi exchange activity established the esterification of glutamine to the 2'-hydroxyl of the terminal adenosine; there is no glutaminylation of the 3'-OH group. This correlates with the classification of GlnRS as a class I aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. Mutations in tRNA(Gln) are discussed which affect the recognition of GlnRS and the current concept of glutamine identity in E coli is reviewed.