Association of bacteriorhodopsin with lipid-impregnated filters. Evidence for fusion of bacteriorhodopsin-containing vesicles with the lipid phase of the filter

Bacteriorhodopsin vesicles were associated with cellulose-nitrate filters impregnated with a solution of phospholipids in hexadecane. The generation of (photo)potentials upon illumination of the filter was studied in the absence and presence of ionophores, phospholipase A₂, EDTA or polyene antibiotics.From these experiments the following conclusions are drawn.

1. 1. Upon illumination of the filter, bacteriorhodopsin pumps protons into aqueous compartments located in the filter.

2. 2. These aqueous compartments possibly do not originate from the compartments enclosed by the bacteriorhodopsin vesicles. Evidence is obtained that aqueous compartments are present in the surface layers of the lipid-impregnated filters.

3. 3. The results are explained most easily by a mechanism, whereby fusion occurs between the vesicles and the lipids of the filter.

Purple membrane vesicles: morphology and proton translocation.

Purple membrane vesicles prepared by different techniques differ widely in their morphology and ability to establish a proton gradient in the light. The procedures used to prepare active vesicles do not completely dissociate the purple membrane and thus preserve a preferential orientation of the protein, while most of the lipid is exchanged for added lipid. Responses to illumination are largely determined by the size of the vesicles and the degree to which bacteriorhodopsin is preferentially oriented. Any attempt to compare the interaction of different lipids with bacteriorhodopsin by measuring the pH response must take these factors into account. With an improved technique we have obtained vesicles of rather uniform size and bacteriorhodopsin orientation, which accumulate protons with an initial rate of 160 ng H+ sec-1 mg-1 protein at light intensities of 10(6) erg cm-2 sec-1. The kinetics of the process are complex and at present insufficiently understood.     

Lipid-impregnated filters as a tool for studying the electric current-generating proteins.

Porous filters and collodion film impregnated with decane solution of phospholipids, were used for measurements of electric potential differences generated by bacteriorhodopsin, chromatophore redox chain, H⁺-ATPase, pyrophosphatase, and mitochondrial respiratory chain. It was shown that reconstituted proteoliposomes, containing e.g., bacteriorhodopsin or natural coupling membrane vesicles, such as Rhodospirillum rubrum chromatophores, can be attached to a filter surface by means of Ca²⁺ or Mg²⁺ ions. Addition of the respective energy source was found to result in electric potential difference being generated across the filter. This effect was measured directly by $\text{Ag}\text{AgCl}$ electrodes immersed into electrolyte solutions on both sides of the filter. Using a phospholipid-impregnated collodion film one can measure electric responses as fast as 300 nsec. The phospholipid-impregnated filters turned out to be sensitive and reliable electrodes for measuring the concentration of synthetic penetrating ions, such as phenyldicarbaundecaborane, tetraphenylborate, tetrapentylammonium, and tetraphenylphosphonium. By measuring changes in the concentration of these ions in the suspension of proteoliposomes, chromatophores, mitochondria, or bacterial cells, one can follow the formation and dissipation of transmembrane potential differences in these systems. It is shown that the phospholipid-impregnated filters are much more reliable and handy than planar phospholipid membranes previously used for studying electrogenic activity of electric current-producing membrane proteins.     

Structure-function studies on bacteriorhodopsin. IV. Purification and renaturation of bacterio-opsin polypeptide expressed in Escherichia coli

Expression of the bacterio-opsin gene in Escherichia coli has been described in the accompanying papers. We now describe rapid and efficient methods for the purification of the E. coli-expressed bacterio-opsin. Bacterio-opsin can be extracted from E. coli membranes in a denatured form by using an organic solvent containing chloroform, methanol, water, and triethylamine. The bacterio-opsin, enriched to 30-50% in the extract, can be further purified to 90% by ion-exchange chromatography on DEAE-Trisacryl or hydroxylapatite chromatography in organic solvents or by preparative sodium dodecyl sulfate gel electrophoresis. In appropriate aqueous phospholipid/detergent mixtures, up to 80% of purified protein refolds and binds retinal covalently to regenerate the bacteriorhodopsin chromophore. When reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles, bacteriorhodopsin from E. coli shows the expected proton pumping activity in response to illumination.     

Coupling between the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle and the protonmotive force in Halobacterium halobium cell envelope vesicles. II. Quantitation and preliminary modeling of the M----bR reactions

The cell membrane of Halobacterium halobium (H. halobium) contains the proton-pump bacteriorhodopsin, which generates a light-driven transmembrane protonmotive force. The interaction of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle with the electric potential component of the protonmotive force has been investigated. H. halobium cell envelope vesicles have been prepared by sonication and further purified by ultracentrifugation on Ficoll/NaCl/CsCl density gradients. Under continuous illumination (550 +/- 50 nm) varied from 0 to 40 mW cm-2, the vesicles maintain a membrane potential of 0 to -100 mV. The membrane potential was measured by flow dialysis of 3H-TPMP+ uptake and could be abolished by the uncoupler carbonylcyanide-m-chlorophenylhydrazone. Time-resolved absorption spectroscopy was used to measure the decay kinetics of the M photocycle intermediate, which was initiated by a weak laser flash (588 nm), while the vesicles were continuously illuminated as above. The M decay kinetics were fitted with two exponential decays by a computer deconvolution program. The faster decaying form decreases in amplitude (70 to 10% of the total) and the slower decaying form increases in amplitude and lifetime (23 to 42 ms) as the background light intensity increases. Although any correlation between the membrane potential and the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle M-forms is complex, the present data will allow specific tests of the physical mechanism for this interaction to be designed and conducted.     

Light-driven primary sodium ion transport in halobacterium halobium membranes

Light-induced sodium extrusion from H halobium cell envelope vesicles proceeds largely through an uncoupler-sensitive pathway involving bacteriorhodopsin and a proton/sodium antiporter. Vesicles from bacteriorhodopsin-negative strains also extrude sodium ions during illumination, but this transport is not sensitive to uncouplers and has been proposed to involve a light-energized primary sodium pump. Proton uptake in such vesicles is passive, and under steady-state illumination the large electrical potential (negative inside) is just balanced by a pH difference (acid inside), so that the protonmotive force is near zero. Action spectra indicated that this effect of illumination is attributable to a pigment absorbing near 585 nm (of 568 for bacteriorhodopsin). Bleaching of the vesicles by prolonged illumination with hydroxylamine results in inactivation of the transport; retinal addition causes partial return of the activity. Retinal addition also causes the appearance of an absorption peak at 588 nm, while the absorption of free retinal decreases. The 588 nm pigment is present in very small quantities (0.13 nmole/mg protein), and behaves differently from bacteriorhodopsin in a number of respects. Vesicles can be prepared from bacteriorhodopsin-containing H halobium strains in which primary transport for both protons and sodium can be observed. Both pumps appear to cause the outward transport of the cations. The observations indicate the existence of a second retinal protein, in addition to bacteriorhodopsin, in H halobium, which is associated with primary sodium translocation. The initial proton uptake normally observed during illumination of whole H halobium cells may therefore be a passive flux in response to the primary sodium extrusion.     

Incorporation of bacteriorhodopsin into large unilamellar liposomes by reverse phase evaporation

The reverse phase evaporation procedure was used to prepare large unilamellar liposomes containing bacteriorhodopsin. Electron microscopy showed that proteoliposomes were unilamellar and fairly uniform in size provided the preparation was extruded through calibrated nucleopore membranes : the vesicles have diameters around 200 nm. The spectral properties of the bacteriorhodopsin in the large liposomes resembled those of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane. Furthermore, the chromoprotein in the reconstituted vesicles had an inside-out orientation and on illumination, translocated protons efficiently from the external medium into the vesicles in the presence of the ionophore valinomycin. In the absence of the latter, a light-independent transmembrane potential of about 60 mV was measured from thiocyanate distribution. In the presence of valinomycin, this transmembrane electrical potential was abolished and then a light-dependent transmembrane pH gradient of about 2 pH units could be generated.     

Purple membrane vesicles: Morphology and proton translocation

Summary Purple membrane vesicles prepared by different techniques differ widely in their morphology and ability to establish a proton gradient in the light. The procedures used to prepare active vesicles do not completely dissociate the purple membrane and thus preserve a preferential orientation of the protein, while most of the lipid is exchanged for added lipid. Responses to illumination are largely determined by the size of the vesicles and the degree to which bacteriorhodopsin is preferentially oriented. Any attempt to compare the interaction of different lipids with bacteriorhodopsin by measuring the pH response must take these factors into account.With an improved technique we have obtained vesicles of rather uniform size and bacteriorhodopsin orientation, which accumulate protons with an initial rate of 160 ng H⁺ sec^–1 mg^–1 protein at light intensities of 10⁶ erg cm^–2 sec^–1. The kinetics of the process are complex and at present insufficiently understood.     

Formations of electrochemical proton gradient and adenosine triphosphate in proteoliposomes containing purified adenosine triphosphatase and bacteriorhodopsin.

Proteoliposome vesicles containing both bacteriorhodopsin of Halobacterium halobium and H+-translocating ATPase [EC 3.6,1.3] of a thermophilic bacterium, PS3, (TF0-F1) were reconstituted by either the dialysis method or the sonication method. Generation of the electrochemical proton gradient (deltamuH+) in these vesicles was measured using 9-aminoacridine for estimation of the chemical (deltapH) component and 8-anilinonaphthalene sulfonate for the electrical (deltaphi) component). In illuminated bacteriorhodopsin-vesicles the deltamuH+ reached 180-190 mV when reconstituted by the dialysis method and 210-220 mV when reconstituted by the sonication method. Vesicles reconstituted from both TF0-F1 and bacteriorhodopsin by the dialysis method generated a deltapH+ of about 200 mV on addition of ATP, while vesicles prepared by the sonication method generated very little deltamuH+, if any. These vesicles generated similar deltamuH+ on illumination to that found in bacteriorhodopsin-vesicles. Using vesicles reconstituted from both TF0-F1 and bacteriorhodopsin by the dialysis method, light dependent ATP synthesis was measured in relation to deltamuH+ formation. It was necessary to generate a deltamuH+ of above 170 mV for demonstration of appreciable formation of ATP and the greater the deltamuH+, the faster the rate of ATP synthesis.     

A mechanism of respiratory control: studies with proteoliposomes containing cytochrome oxidase and bacteriorhodopsin

Both beef heart cytochrome oxidase and bacteriorhodopsin of Halobacterium halobium were reconstituted into liposomes by the sonication-cholate dialysis method. The proteoliposomes showed the respiratory control ratio of 4.2, and steady-state illumination of the vesicles lead to the 2.7-fold stimulation of the oxidase activity in the absence of uncouplers. The light-stimulated state 4 respiration increased with light intensity, but light had no effect on the oxidase activity that had been relieved by addition of uncouplers. Proteoliposomes with the photosensitive oxidase activity were also obtained when cytochrome oxidase vesicles were fused with bacteriorhodopsin vesicles in the presence of calcium chloride, and the extent of photoactivation was maximally 1.4-fold. The light-induced respiratory release was observed even in the presence of valinomycin or nigericin, indicating that the oxidase activity was sensitive to both the membrane potential and the pH gradient. We propose as a mechanism of the respiratory control that the process of proton transport to the reaction center for water formation is the rate limiting step for the cytochrome oxidase activity.     

Kinetics and stoichiometry of light-induced proton release and uptake from purple membrane fragments, Halobacterium halobium cell envelopes, and phospholipid vesicles containing oriented purple membrane

We have used flash spectroscopy and pH indicator dyes to measure the kinetics and stoichiometry of light-induced proton release and uptake by purple membrane in aqueous suspension, in cell envelope vesicles and in lipid vesicles. The preferential orientation of bacteriorhodopsin in opposite directions in the envelope and lipid vesicles allows us to show that uptake of protons occurs on the cytoplasmic side of the purple membrane and release on the exterior side.

In suspensions of isolated purple membrane, approximately one proton per cycling bacteriorhodopsin molecule appears transiently in the aqueous phase with a half-rise time of 0.8 ms and a half-decay time of 5.4 ms at 21 °C.

In cell envelope preparations which consist of vesicles with a preferential orientation of purple membrane, as in whole cells, and which pump protons out, the acidification of the medium has a half-rise time of less than 1.0 ms, which partially relaxes in approx. 10 ms and fully relaxes after many seconds.

Phospholipid vesicles, which contain bacteriorhodopsin preferentially oriented in the opposite direction and pump protons in, show an alkalinization of the medium with a time constant of approximately 10 ms, preceded by a much smaller and faster acidification. The alkalinization relaxes over many seconds.

The initial fast acidification in the lipid vesicles and the fast relaxation in the envelope vesicles are accounted for by the misoriented fractions of bacteriorhodopsin. The time constants of the main effects, acidification in the envelopes and alkalinization in the lipid vesicles correlate with the time constants for the release and uptake of protons in the isolated purple membrane, and therefore show that these must occur on the outer and inner surface respectively. The slow relaxation processes in the time range of several seconds must be attributed to the passive back diffusion of protons through the vesicle membrane.     

Structure and energy-linked activities in reconstituted bacteriorhodopsin--yeast ATPase proteoliposomes.

Bacteriorhodopsin-F₁·F₀ (mitochondrial oligomycin-sensitive ATPase complex) proteoliposomes have poor proton pumping and photophosphorylation activities when reconstituted by cholate dialysis. A considerable proportion of the bacteriorhodopsin is not incorporated by cholate dialysis, the particles being too large to be combined into liposomes. Much better reconstitution is achieved where the purple membranes are first fragmented by sonication. Optimal incorporation occurs where bacteriorhodopsin and the phospholipids are sonicated together, suggesting that some perturbation of the liposomes is necessary for successful integration. Since F₁·F₀ is denatured by sonication a two-step reconstitution procedure has been developed wherein bacteriorhodopsin is first incorporated by sonication, then F₁·F₀ by cholate dialysis. The vesicles have high phosphorylation rates and also catalyze postillumination [³²P]ATP formation where pyridine is present during first stage illumination.F₁·F₀ can also be incorporated into sonicated bacteriorhodopsin vesicles by “direct incorporation.” This depends on the presence of negatively charged amphiphiles such as cholate or phosphatidylserine in the membranes, and is stimulated by divalent metal cations. Optimum conditions for the various reconstitution procedures are described.     

On the glutamate transport through cell envelope vesicles of Halobacterium halobium

Glutamate uptake by envelope vesicles of Halobacterium halobium was measured. Previous authors showed that the glutamate uptake needs the illumination as well as Na+ gradient across the membrane. The latter is considered to be the driving force for the uptake. No satisfactory explanation for the necessity of the illumination has not been given. We found that in the absence of Cl- in the medium, only Na+ gradient was enough to induce the glutamate uptake, i.e. no illumination was needed. Glutamate uptake was measured with various strains of H. halobium. We found that the envelope vesicles prepared from strains containing no bacteriorhodopsin showed the glutamate uptake in the dark and in the presence of Cl- in the medium provided only that Na+ gradient is imposed.     

Refolding of bacteriorhodopsin in lipid bilayers. A thermodynamically controlled two-stage process

Possible steps in the folding of bacteriorhodopsin are revealed by studying the refolding and interaction of two fragments of the molecule reconstituted in lipid vesicles. (1) Two denatured bacteriorhodopsin fragments have been purified starting from chymotryptically cleaved bacteriorhodopsin. Cleaved bacteriorhodopsin has been renatured from a mixture of the fragments in Halobacterium lipids/retinal/dodecyl sulfate solution following removal of dodecyl sulfate by precipitation with potassium. The renatured molecules have the same absorption spectrum and extinction coefficient as native cleaved bacteriorhodopsin. They are integrated into small lipid vesicles as a mixture of monomers and aggregates. Extended lattices form during the partial dehydration process used to orient samples for X-ray and neutron crystallography. (2) Correct refolding of cleaved bacterioopsin occurs upon renaturation in the absence of retinal. Regeneration of the chromophore and reformation of the purple membrane lattice are observed following subsequent addition of all-trans retinal. (3) The two chymotryptic fragments have been reinserted separately into lipid vesicles and refolded in the absence of retinal. Circular dichroism spectra of the polypeptide backbone transitions indicate that they have regained a highly alpha-helical structure. The kinetics of chromophore regeneration following reassociation have been studied by absorption spectroscopy. Upon vesicle fusion, the refolded fragments first reassociate, then bind retinal and finally regenerate cleaved bacteriorhodopsin. The complex formed in the absence of retinal is kinetically indistinguishable from cleaved bacterioopsin. The refolded fragments in lipid vesicles are stable for months, both as separate entities and after reassociation. These observations provide further evidence that the native folded structure of bacteriorhodopsin lies at a free energy minimum. They are interpreted in terms of a two-stage folding mechanism for membrane proteins in which stable transmembrane helices are first formed. They subsequently pack without major rearrangement to produce the tertiary structure.     

Photophosphorylation in cell envelope vesicles from Halobacteriumhalobium

We have prepared vesicles from cell envelope membranes of $\text{Halobacterium}\text{halobium}$ strains R₁ and ET-15 which are able to synthesize ATP in response to illumination. This photophosphorylation is inhibited by dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) and by phloretin. ATP synthesis in L vesicles from the R₁ strain (which contain bacteriorhodopsin) is inhibited by the protonophore 1799 but not by valinomycin. In M vesicles from the R₁ strain and in ET-15 vesicles (both contain halorhodopsin) photophosphorylation is inhibited by both 1799 and valinomycin. These data are consistent with the idea that light-driven ATP synthesis can be coupled to the electrochemical H⁺ gradient generated by bacteriorhodopsin or by halorhodopsin through the membrane potential component of protonmotive force.     

Proton transport by bacteriorhodopsin through an interface film

Summary Interface films of purple membrane and lipid containing spectroscopically intact and oriented bacteriorhodopsin have been used as a model system to study the function of this protein. Small positive charges in surface potential (<1 mV) are detected upon illumination of these films at the air-water interface. These photopotentials, are not affected by overlaying the interface film with a thin layer (0.3 mm) of decane. However, they are dramatically increased when lipid soluble proton carriers FCCP or DNP are added to the decane. The polarity of the photopotential indicates that, in the light, positive charges are transported through the interface from the aqueous to the organic phase. The action spectrum of the photopotential is identical to the absorption spectrum of bacteriorhodopsin. Since bacteriorhodopsin molecules are oriented with their intracellular surface towards the aqueous subphase, the characteristics of the photopotential indicate that in the light bacteriorhodopsin translocates protons from its intracellular to its extracellular surface. The kinetics of the photopotential reveal that the rate and extent of proton transport are proportional both to the fraction of bacteriorhodopsin molecules excited and to the concentration of proton acceptor. The photopotentials result from changes in the ionic distribution across the decane-water interface and can be cancelled by lipid soluble anions.     

Coupling between the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle and the protonmotive force in Halobacterium halobium cell envelope vesicles. III. Time-resolved increase in the transmembrane electric potential and modeling of the associated ion fluxes.

Bacteriorhodopsin functions as an electrogenic, light-driven proton pump in Halobacterium halobium. In cell envelope vesicles, its photocycle kinetics can be correlated with membrane potential. The initial decay rate of the M photocycle intermediate(s) decreases with increasing membrane potential, allowing the construction of a calibration curve. The laser (592.5 nm) was flashed at various time delays following the start of background illumination (592 +/- 25 nm) and transient absorbance changes at 418 nm monitored in cell envelope vesicles. The vesicles were loaded with and suspended in either 3 M NaCl or 3 M KCl buffered with 50 mM HEPES at pH 7.5 and the membrane permeability to protons modified by pretreatment with N,N'-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide. In each case the membrane potential rose with a halftime of approximately 75 ms. The steady-state potential achieved depends on the cation present and the proton permeability of the membrane, i.e., higher potentials are developed in dicyclohexylcarbodiimide treated vesicles or in NaCl media as compared with KCl media. The results are modeled using an irreversible thermodynamics formulation, which assumes a constant driving reaction affinity (Ach) and a variable reaction rate (Jr) for the proton-pumping cycle of bacteriorhodopsin. Additionally, the model includes a voltage-gated, electrogenic Na+/H+ antiporter that is active when vesicles are suspended in NaCl. Estimates for the linear phenomenological coefficients describing the overall proton-pumping cycle (Lr = 3.5 X 10(-11)/mol2/J X g X s), passive cation permeabilities (LHu = 2 X 10(-10), LKu = 2.2 X 10(-10), LNau = 1 X 10(-11)), and the Na+/H+ exchange via the antiporter (Lex = 5 X 10(-11)) have been obtained.     

Light-induced leucine transport in Halobacterium halobium envelope vesicles: a chemiosmotic system.

Halabacterium halobium cell envelope vesicles accumulate L-[14-C]leucine during illumination, against a large concentration gradient. Leucine uptake requires Na-+ and is optimal in KCl-loaded vesicles resuspended in KCl-NaCl solution (1.5 M:1.5 M). Half-maximal transport is seen at 1 X 10-minus 6 M leucine. In the dark the accumulated leucine is rapidly and exponentially lost from the vesicles. The action spectrum and the light-intensity dependence indicate that the transport is related to the extrusion of protons, mediated by bacteriorhodopsin. Since light gives rise to both a pH gradient and an opposing transmembrane potential (interior negative), it wass responsible for providing the energy for leucine transport. The following results were obtained under illumination: (1) membrane-permeant cations and valinomycin or gramicidin greatly inhibited leucine transport without altering the pH gradient; (2) buffering both inside and outside the vesicles eliminated the pH gradient while enhancing leucine transport; (3) dicyclohexylcarbodiimide increased the pH gradient without affecting leucine transport; (4) arsenate did not inhibit leucine uptake. A diffusion potential, established by adding valinomycin to KCl-loaded vesicles, caused leucine influx in the dark. These results suggest that the leucine transport system is not coupled to ATP hydrolysis, and responds to the membrane potential rather than to the pH gradient. The Na-+ dependence of the transport and the observation that a small NaCl pulse causes transient leucine influx in the dark in KCl-loaded vesicles, resuspended in KCl, even in the presence of p-trifluoromethoxycarbonylcyanide phenylhydrazone or with buffering, suggest that the translocation of leucine is facilitated by symport with Na-+.     

Light-induced glutamate transport in Halobacterium halobium envelope vesicles. I. Kinetics of the light-dependent and the sodium-gradient-dependent uptake.

During illumination Halobacterium halobium cell envelope vesicles accumulate [3H]glutamate by an apparently unidirectional transport system. The driving force for the active transport originates from the light-dependent translocation of protons by bacteriorhodopsin and is due to a transmembrane electrical potential rather than a pH difference. Transport of glutamate against high concentration gradients is also achieved in the dark, with high outside/inside Na+ gradients. Transport in both cases proceeds with similar kinetics and shows a requirement for Na+ on the outside and for K+ on the inside of the vesicles. The unidirectional nature of glutamate transport seems to be due to the low permeability of the membranes to the anionic glutamate, and to the differential cation requirement of the carrier on the two sides of the membrane for substrate translocation. Thus, glutamate gradients can be collapsed in the dark either by lowering the intravesicle pH (with nigericin, or carbonyl cyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone plus valinomycin), or by reversing the cation balance across the membranes, i.e., providing NaCl on the inside and KCl on the outside of the vesicles. In contrast to the case of light-dependent glutamate transport, the initial rates of Na+-gradient-dependent transport are not depressed when an opposing diffusion potential is introduced by adding the membrane-permeant cation, triphenylmethylphosphonium bromide. Therefore, it appears that, although the electrical potential must be the primary source of energy for the light-dependent transport, the translocation step itself is electrically neutral.     

Light-dependent cation gradients and electrical potential in Halobacterium halobium cell envelope vesicles.

Vesicles can be prepared from Halobacterium halobium cell envelopes, which contain properly oriented bacteriorhodopsin and which extrude H+ during illumination. The pH difference that is generated across the membranes is accompanied by an electrical potential of 90-100 mV (interior negative) and the movements of other cations. Among these is the efflux of Na+, which proceeds against its electrochemical potential. The relationship between the size and direction of the light-induced pH gradient and the rate of depletion of Na+ from the vesicles, as well as other evidence, suggest that the active Na+-extrusion is facilitated by a membrane component that exchanges H+ for Na+ with a stoichiometry greater than 1. The gradients of H+ and Na+ are thus coupled to one another. The Na+-gradient (Na+out greater than Na+in), which arises during illumination, plays a major role in energizing the active transport of amino acids.