Greedily building protein networks with confidence

MOTIVATION: With genome sequences complete for human and model organisms, it is essential to understand how individual genes and proteins are organized into biological networks. Much of the organization is revealed by proteomics experiments that now generate torrents of data. Extracting relevant complexes and pathways from high-throughput proteomics data sets has posed a challenge, however, and new methods to identify and extract networks are essential. We focus on the problem of building pathways starting from known proteins of interest. RESULTS: We have developed an efficient, greedy algorithm, SEEDY, that extracts biologically relevant biological networks from protein-protein interaction data, building out from selected seed proteins. The algorithm relies on our previous study establishing statistical confidence levels for interactions generated by two-hybrid screens and inferred from mass spectrometric identification of protein complexes. We demonstrate the ability to extract known yeast complexes from high-throughput protein interaction data with a tunable parameter that governs the trade-off between sensitivity and selectivity. DNA damage repair pathways are presented as a detailed example. We highlight the ability to join heterogeneous data sets, in this case protein-protein interactions and genetic interactions, and the appearance of cross-talk between pathways caused by re-use of shared components. SIGNIFICANCE AND COMPARISON: The significance of the SEEDY algorithm is that it is fast, running time O[(E + V) log V] for V proteins and E interactions, a single adjustable parameter controls the size of the pathways that are generated, and an associated P-value indicates the statistical confidence that the pathways are enriched for proteins with a coherent function. Previous approaches have focused on extracting sub-networks by identifying motifs enriched in known biological networks. SEEDY provides the complementary ability to perform a directed search based on proteins of interest. AVAILABILITY: SEEDY software (Perl source), data tables and confidence score models (R source) are freely available from the author.     

Computational Prediction of Protein–Protein Interactions

Recently a number of computational approaches have been developed for the prediction of protein–protein interactions. Complete genome sequencing projects have provided the vast amount of information needed for these analyses. These methods utilize the structural, genomic, and biological context of proteins and genes in complete genomes to predict protein interaction networks and functional linkages between proteins. Given that experimental techniques remain expensive, time-consuming, and labor-intensive, these methods represent an important advance in proteomics. Some of these approaches utilize sequence data alone to predict interactions, while others combine multiple computational and experimental datasets to accurately build protein interaction maps for complete genomes. These methods represent a complementary approach to current high-throughput projects whose aim is to delineate protein interaction maps in complete genomes. We will describe a number of computational protocols for protein interaction prediction based on the structural, genomic, and biological context of proteins in complete genomes, and detail methods for protein interaction network visualization and analysis.     

Building protein-protein interaction networks with proteomics and informatics tools

The systematic characterization of the whole interactomes of different model organisms has revealed that the eukaryotic proteome is highly interconnected. Therefore, biological research is progressively shifting away from classical approaches that focus only on a few proteins toward whole protein interaction networks to describe the relationship of proteins in biological processes. In this minireview, we survey the most common methods for the systematic identification of protein interactions and exemplify different strategies for the generation of protein interaction networks. In particular, we will focus on the recent development of protein interaction networks derived from quantitative proteomics data sets.     

Global protein function prediction from protein-protein interaction networks

Determining protein function is one of the most challenging problems of the post-genomic era. The availability of entire genome sequences and of high-throughput capabilities to determine gene coexpression patterns has shifted the research focus from the study of single proteins or small complexes to that of the entire proteome. In this context, the search for reliable methods for assigning protein function is of primary importance. There are various approaches available for deducing the function of proteins of unknown function using information derived from sequence similarity or clustering patterns of co-regulated genes, phylogenetic profiles, protein-protein interactions (refs. 5-8 and Samanta, M.P. and Liang, S., unpublished data), and protein complexes. Here we propose the assignment of proteins to functional classes on the basis of their network of physical interactions as determined by minimizing the number of protein interactions among different functional categories. Function assignment is proteome-wide and is determined by the global connectivity pattern of the protein network. The approach results in multiple functional assignments, a consequence of the existence of multiple equivalent solutions. We apply the method to analyze the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae protein-protein interaction network. The robustness of the approach is tested in a system containing a high percentage of unclassified proteins and also in cases of deletion and insertion of specific protein interactions.     

Roles for the two-hybrid system in exploration of the yeast protein interactome

Comprehensive analysis of protein-protein interactions is a challenging endeavor of functional proteomics and has been best explored in the budding yeast. The yeast protein interactome analysis was achieved first by using the yeast two-hybrid system in a proteome-wide scale and next by large-scale mass spectrometric analysis of affinity-purified protein complexes. While these interaction data have led to a number of novel findings and the emergence of a single huge network containing thousands of proteins, they suffer many false signals and fall short of grasping the entire interactome. Thus, continuous efforts are necessary in both bioinformatics and experimentation to fully exploit these data and to proceed another step forward to the goal. Computational tools to integrate existing biological knowledge buried in literature and various functional genomic data with the interactome data are required for biological interpretation of the huge protein interaction network. Novel experimental methods have to be developed to detect weak, transient interactions involving low abundance proteins as well as to obtain clues to the biological role for each interaction. Since the yeast two-hybrid system can be used for the mapping of the interaction domains and the isolation of interaction-defective mutants, it would serve as a technical basis for the latter purpose, thereby playing another important role in the next phase of protein interactome research.     

Dynamic proteomics in modeling of the living cell. Protein-protein interactions

This review is devoted to describing, summarizing, and analyzing of dynamic proteomics data obtained over the last few years and concerning the role of protein-protein interactions in modeling of the living cell. Principles of modern high-throughput experimental methods for investigation of protein-protein interactions are described. Systems biology approaches based on integrative view on cellular processes are used to analyze organization of protein interaction networks. It is proposed that finding of some proteins in different protein complexes can be explained by their multi-modular and polyfunctional properties; the different protein modules can be located in the nodes of protein interaction networks. Mathematical and computational approaches to modeling of the living cell with emphasis on molecular dynamics simulation are provided. The role of the network analysis in fundamental medicine is also briefly reviewed.     

Glycosaminoglycan interaction networks and databases

Glycosaminoglycans are complex polysaccharides exhibiting a large structural and conformational diversity. These key biological players organize the extracellular matrix, contribute to cell–matrix interactions, and regulate cell signaling. Natural and synthetic libraries of glycosaminoglycans have been spotted on microarrays to find glycosaminoglycan partners and determine the size and the chemical groups promoting protein binding. Advances in glycosaminoglycan sequencing allow the characterization of glycosaminoglycan sequences interacting with proteins, and glycosaminoglycan-mediated pull-down proteomics can identify glycosaminoglycan-binding proteins at a proteome scale in various biological samples. The analysis of the glycosaminoglycan interaction networks generated using these data gives insights into the molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying glycosaminoglycan functions. These interactomes can also be used to design inhibitors targeting specific GAG interactions for therapeutic purpose.     

Semantically assessing the reliability of protein interactions

Protein–protein interactions (PPIs) play very important roles in many cellular processes, and provide rich information for discovering biological facts and knowledge. Although various experimental approaches have been developed to generate large amounts of PPI data for different organisms, high-throughput experimental data usually suffers from high error rates, and as a consequence, the biological knowledge discovered from this data is distorted or incorrect. Therefore, it is vital to assess the quality of protein interaction data and extract reliable protein interactions from the high-throughput experimental data. In this paper, we propose a new Semantic Reliability (SR) method to assess the reliability of each protein interaction and identify potential false-positive protein interactions in a dataset. For each pair of target interacting proteins, the SR method takes into account the semantic influence between proteins that interact with the target proteins, and the semantic influence between the target proteins themselves when assessing the interaction reliability. Evaluations on real protein interaction datasets demonstrated that our method outperformed other existing methods in terms of extracting more reliable interactions from original protein interaction datasets.     

Proteomics in the post-genome age.

The genome sequencing effort has helped spawn the burgeoning field of proteomics. This review article examines state-of-the-art proteomics methods that are helping change the discovery paradigm in a variety of biological disciplines and, in particular, protein biochemistry. The review discusses both classical and novel methods to perform high-throughput qualitative and quantitative "global" as well as targeted proteome analysis of complex biological systems. From a drug discovery standpoint, the synergy between genomics and proteomics will help elucidate disease mechanisms, identify novel drug targets, and identify surrogate biomarkers that could be used to conduct clinical trials.     

Predicting interactions in protein networks by completing defective cliques

Datasets obtained by large-scale, high-throughput methods for detecting protein-protein interactions typically suffer from a relatively high level of noise. We describe a novel method for improving the quality of these datasets by predicting missed protein-protein interactions, using only the topology of the protein interaction network observed by the large-scale experiment. The central idea of the method is to search the protein interaction network for defective cliques (nearly complete complexes of pairwise interacting proteins), and predict the interactions that complete them. We formulate an algorithm for applying this method to large-scale networks, and show that in practice it is efficient and has good predictive performance. More information can be found on our website http://topnet.gersteinlab.org/clique/ CONTACT: Mark.Gerstein@yale.edu SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Supplementary Materials are available at Bioinformatics online.     

Integrating a functional proteomic approach into the target discovery process

Functional proteomics is a promising technique for the rational identification of novel therapeutic targets by elucidation of the function of newly identified proteins in disease-relevant cellular pathways. Of the recently described high-throughput approaches for analyzing protein-protein interactions, the yeast two-hybrid (Y2H) system has turned out to be one of the most suitable for genome-wide analysis. However, this system presents a challenging technical problem: the high prevalence of false positives and false negatives in datasets due to intrinsic limitations of the technology and the use of a high-throughput, genetic assay. We discuss here the different experimental strategies applied to Y2H assays, their general limitations and advantages. We also address the issue of the contribution of protein interaction mapping to functional biology, especially when combined with complementary genomic and proteomic analyses. Finally, we illustrate how the combination of protein interaction maps with relevant functional assays can provide biological support to large-scale protein interaction datasets and contribute to the identification and validation of potential therapeutic targets.     

Simple protein complex purification and identification method for high-throughput mapping of protein interaction networks

Most current methods for purification and identification of protein complexes use endogenous expression of affinity-tagged bait, tandem affinity tag purification of protein complexes followed by specific elution of complexes from beads, and gel separation and in-gel digestion prior to mass spectrometric analysis of protein interactors. We propose a single affinity tag in vitro pull-down assay with denaturing elution, trypsin digestion in organic solvent, and LC-ESI MS/MS protein identification using SEQUEST analysis. Our method is simple and easy to scale-up and automate, making it suitable for high-throughput mapping of protein interaction networks and functional proteomics.     

Protein interaction networks

The study of protein interactions is playing an ever increasing role in our attempts to understand cells and diseases on a system-wide level. This article reviews several experimental approaches that are currently being used to measure protein-protein, protein-DNA and gene-gene interactions. These techniques have now been scaled up to produce extensive genome-wide data sets that are providing us with a first glimpse of global interaction networks. Complementing these experimental approaches, several computational methodologies to predict protein interactions are also reviewed. Existing databases that serve as repositories for protein interaction information and how such databases are used to analyze high-throughput data from a pathway perspective is also addressed. Finally, current efforts to combine multiple data types to obtain more accurate and comprehensive models of protein interactions are discussed. It is clear that the evolution of these experimental and computational approaches is rapidly changing our view of biology, and promises to provide us with an unprecedented ability to model cells and organisms at a system-wide level.     

Functional evaluation of domain-domain interactions and human protein interaction networks

MOTIVATION: Large amounts of protein and domain interaction data are being produced by experimental high-throughput techniques and computational approaches. To gain insight into the value of the provided data, we used our new similarity measure based on the Gene Ontology (GO) to evaluate the molecular functions and biological processes of interacting proteins or domains. The applied measure particularly addresses the frequent annotation of proteins or domains with multiple GO terms. RESULTS: Using our similarity measure, we compare predicted domain-domain and human protein-protein interactions with experimentally derived interactions. The results show that our similarity measure is of significant benefit in quality assessment and confidence ranking of domain and protein networks. We also derive useful confidence score thresholds for dividing domain interaction predictions into subsets of low and high confidence. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.     

Current trends in computational inference from mass spectrometry-based proteomics

Mass spectrometry offers a high-throughput approach to quantifying the proteome associated with a biological sample and hence has become the primary approach of proteomic analyses. Computation is tightly coupled to this advanced technological platform as a required component of not only peptide and protein identification, but quantification and functional inference, such as protein modifications and interactions. Proteomics faces several key computational challenges such as identification of proteins and peptides from tandem mass spectra as well as their quantitation. In addition, the application of proteomics to systems biology requires understanding the functional proteome, including how the dynamics of the cell change in response to protein modifications and complex interactions between biomolecules. This review presents an overview of recently developed methods and their impact on these core computational challenges currently facing proteomics.     

Estimating gene regulatory networks and protein-protein interactions of Saccharomyces cerevisiae from multiple genome-wide data

MOTIVATION: Biological processes in cells are properly performed by gene regulations, signal transductions and interactions between proteins. To understand such molecular networks, we propose a statistical method to estimate gene regulatory networks and protein-protein interaction networks simultaneously from DNA microarray data, protein-protein interaction data and other genome-wide data. RESULTS: We unify Bayesian networks and Markov networks for estimating gene regulatory networks and protein-protein interaction networks according to the reliability of each biological information source. Through the simultaneous construction of gene regulatory networks and protein-protein interaction networks of Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell cycle, we predict the role of several genes whose functions are currently unknown. By using our probabilistic model, we can detect false positives of high-throughput data, such as yeast two-hybrid data. In a genome-wide experiment, we find possible gene regulatory relationships and protein-protein interactions between large protein complexes that underlie complex regulatory mechanisms of biological processes.     

Discovery of regulatory molecular events and biomarkers using 2D capillary chromatography and mass spectrometry

An important component of proteomic research is the high-throughput discovery of novel proteins and protein–protein interactions that control molecular events that contribute to critical cellular functions and human disease. The interactions of proteins are essential for cellular functions. Identifying perturbation of normal cellular protein interactions is vital for understanding the disease process and intervening to control the disease. A second area of proteomics research is the discovery of proteins that will serve as biomarkers for the early detection, diagnosis and drug treatment response for specific diseases. These studies have been referred to as clinical proteomics. To discover biomarkers, proteomics research employs the quantitative comparison of peptide and protein expression in body fluids and tissues from diseased individuals (case) versus normal individuals (control). Methods that couple 2D capillary liquid chromatography (LC) and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) analysis have greatly facilitated this discovery science. Coupling 2D-LC/MS/MS analysis with automated genome-assisted spectra interpretation allows a direct, high-throughput and high-sensitivity identification of thousands of individual proteins from complex biological samples. The systematic comparison of experimental conditions and controls allows protein function or disease states to be modeled. This review discusses the different purification and quantification strategies that have been developed and used in combination with 2D-LC/MS/MS and computational analysis to examine regulatory protein networks and clinical samples.