Hydrogenases of phototrophic microorganisms

This review surveys recent work done in the laboratory of the author and related laboratories on the properties and possible practical applications of hydrogenases of phototrophic microorganisms. Homogeneous hydrogenase preparations were obtained from purple non-sulfur (Rhodospirillum rubrum S1, Rhodobacter capsulatus B10) and purple sulfur (Chromatium vinosum D, Thiocapsa roseopersicina BBS) bacteria, and from the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium limicola forma thiosulfatophilum L; highly purified hydrogenase samples were prepared from the cyanobacterium Anabaena cylindrica and from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardii. It was shown that hydrogenases of R. capsulatus and T. roseopersicina contain Ni and Fe-S cluster. The cytochromes of the c or b type serve as native electron acceptors for the hydrogenases of the purple bacteria and cyanobacteria; rubredoxin or cytochrome c for the hydrogenase of the green sulfur bacterium; and ferredoxin for Ch. reinhardii hydrogenase. The hydrogenase of T. roseopersicina BBS reversibly activates H2 at Eh less than -290 mV (pH 7), whereas those from R. capsulatus and from C. limicola f. thiosulfatophilum exhibit their maximum activity at Eh greater than -300 mV and are thus favourable only for the H2 uptake. Hydrogenase synthesis in different phototrophs depends on pO2, H2 concentrations and organic substrates. Organic compounds, which serve as electron donors and carbon sources, repress hydrogenase synthesis in R. rubrum, R. capsulatus and in Ectothiorhodospira shaposhnikovii when present at high concentrations. The synthesis of T. roseopersicina hydrogenase is constitutive. H2 notably stimulates hydrogenase activity in R. capsulatus. The synthesis of hydrogenase in R. sphaeroides 2R occurs only in the presence of H2 and does not depend on the presence of organic compounds in the medium.     

The role of Hox hydrogenase in the H2 metabolism of Thiocapsa roseopersicina

The purple sulfur phototrophic bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina BBS synthesizes at least three NiFe hydrogenases (Hox, Hup, Hyn). We characterized the physiological H(2) consumption/evolution reactions in mutants having deletions of the structural genes of two hydrogenases in various combinations. This made possible the separation of the functionally distinct roles of the three hydrogenases. Data showed that Hox hydrogenase (unlike the Hup and Hyn hydrogenases) catalyzed the dark fermentative H(2) evolution and the light-dependent H(2) production in the presence of thiosulfate. Both Hox(+) and Hup(+) mutants demonstrated light-dependent H(2) uptake stimulated by CO(2) but only the Hup(+) mutant was able to mediate O(2)-dependent H(2) consumption in the dark. The ability of the Hox(+) mutant to evolve or consume hydrogen was found to depend on a number of interplaying factors including both growth and reaction conditions (availability of glucose, sulfur compounds, CO(2), H(2), light). The study of the redox properties of Hox hydrogenase supported the reversibility of its action. Based on the results a scheme is suggested to describe the role of Hox hydrogenase in light-dependent and dark hydrogen metabolism in T. roseopersicina BBS.     

Accessory proteins functioning selectively and pleiotropically in the biosynthesis of [NiFe] hydrogenases in Thiocapsa roseopersicina.

There are at least two membrane-bound (HynSL and HupSL) and one soluble (HoxEFUYH) [NiFe] hydrogenases in Thiocapsa roseopersicina BBS, a purple sulfur photosynthetic bacterium. Genes coding for accessory proteins that participate in the biosynthesis and maturation of hydrogenases seem to be scattered along the chromosome. Transposon-based mutagenesis was used to locate the hydrogenase accessory genes. Molecular analysis of strains showing mutant phenotypes led to the identification of hupK (hoxV ), hypC1, hypC2, hypD, hypE, and hynD genes. The roles of hynD, hupK and the two hypC genes were investigated in detail. The putative HynD was found to be a hydrogenase-specific endoprotease type protein, participating in the maturation of the HynSL enzyme. HupK plays an important role in the formation of the functionally active membrane-bound [NiFe] hydrogenases, but not in the biosynthesis of the soluble enzyme. In-frame deletion mutagenesis showed that HypC proteins were not specific for the maturation of either hydrogenase enzyme. The lack of either HypC protein drastically reduced the activity of every hydrogenase. Hence both HypCs might participate in the maturation of [NiFe] hydrogenases. Homologous complementation with the appropriate genes substantiated the physiological roles of the corresponding gene products in the H2 metabolism of T. roseopersicina.     

On the novel H2-activating iron-sulfur center of the "Fe-only" hydrogenases

The two hydrogenases (I and II) of the anaerobic N2-fixing bacterium Clostridium pasteurianum (Cp) and the hydrogenases of the anaerobes Megasphaera elsdenii (Me) and Desulfovibrio vulgaris (strain Hildenborough, Dv), contain iron-sulfur clusters but not nickel. They are the most active hydrogenases known. All four enzymes in their reduced states give rise to EPR signals typical of [4Fe-4S]1+ clusters but exhibit novel EPR signals in their oxidized states. For example, Cp hydrogenase I exhibits a sharp rhombic EPR signal when oxidized under mild conditions but the enzyme is inactivated by over-oxidation and then exhibits an axial EPR signal. A similar axial signal is observed from mildly oxidized hydrogenase I after treatment with CO. EPR, M?ssbauer and ENDOR spectroscopy indicate that the EPR signals from the oxidized enzyme and its CO derivative arise from a novel spin-coupled Fe center. Low temperature magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) studies reveal that an EPR-silent Fe-S cluster with S greater than 1/2 is also present in oxidized hydrogenase I. From a study of all spectroscopic properties of Cp, Dv, and Me hydrogenases, it is concluded that the H2-activating site of all four is a novel Fe-S cluster with S greater than 0 and integer, which in the oxidized state is exchange-coupled to a S = 1/2 species. The data are most consistent with the S = 1/2 species being a low spin Fe(III) center. The H2-activating site is susceptible to oxidative rearrangements to yield both active and inactive states of the enzyme. We discuss the possible implications of these finding to methods of enzyme oxidation and purification procedures currently used for hydrogenases.     

Relationships in hydrogen metabolism between hydrogenase and nitrogenase in phototrophic bacteria.

Purple bacteria Rhodospirillum rubrum and Thiocapsa roseopersicina form two enzymes, hydrogenase and nitrogenase, which participate in hydrogen metabolism. H2 photoproduction in these bacteria is associated mainly or completely with the action of nitrogenase. The soluble and membrane-bound hydrogenases of T. roseopersicina have similar physicochemical properties (mol. weight, subunit composition, N-terminal amino acids, Fe2+ and S2- content, pl. Eo'). In comparison with other hydrogenases the enzyme from R. rubrum and T. roseopersicina evolve H2 with high rate from reduced cytochrome c3, but not from ferredoxins. H2 production and N2 fixation take place in the presence of NAD(P)H. NADP-reductase, ferredoxin and cytochrome c3 participate in this reaction. Possible relationships between hydrogenase-nitrogenase in the metabolism of molecular hydrogen are discussed.     

Measuring the pH dependence of hydrogenase activities

The pH dependences of activities of homogenous hydrogenases of Thiocapsa roseopersicina and Desulfomicrobium baculatum in the reaction of hydrogen uptake in solution in the presence of benzyl viologen and the pH dependences of catalytic currents of hydrogen oxidation by electrodes on which these hydrogenases were immobilized were compared. Maximal activities of the hydrogenases from T. roseopersicina and D. baculatum in the reaction hydrogen uptake in solution were observed at pH 9.5 and 8.5, respectively. However, the steady-state current caused by catalytic uptake of hydrogen was maximal for the T. roseopersicina hydrogenase-containing electrode at pH 5.5-6.5 under overvoltage of 30-60 mV, whereas for electrodes with D. baculatum hydrogenase it was maximal at pH 6.0-6.5. Analysis of these data suggests that pH-dependent changes in the hydrogenase activities in solution during hydrogen uptake are due not only to the effect of proton concentration on the enzyme conformation or protonation of certain groups of the enzyme active center, but they are rather indicative of changes in free energy of the reaction accompanying changes in pH.     

Characterization of the CO-induced, CO-tolerant hydrogenase from Rhodospirillum rubrum and the gene encoding the large subunit of the enzyme.

In the presence of carbon monoxide, the photosynthetic bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum induces expression of proteins which allow the organism to metabolize carbon monoxide in the net reaction CO + H2O --> CO2 + H2. These proteins include the enzymes carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH) and a CO-tolerant hydrogenase. In this paper, we present the complete amino acid sequence for the large subunit of this hydrogenase and describe the properties of the crude enzyme in relation to other known hydrogenases. The amino acid sequence deduced from the CO-induced hydrogenase large-subunit gene (cooH) shows significant similarity to large subunits of other Ni-Fe hydrogenases. The closest similarity is with HycE (58% similarity and 37% identity) from Escherichia coli, which is the large subunit of an Ni-Fe hydrogenase (isoenzyme 3). The properties of the CO-induced hydrogenase are unique. It is exceptionally resistant to inhibition by carbon monoxide. It also exhibits a very high ratio of H2 evolution to H2 uptake activity compared with other known hydrogenases. The CO-induced hydrogenase is tightly membrane bound, and its inhibition by nonionic detergents is described. Finally, the presence of nickel in the hydrogenase is addressed. Analysis of wild-type R. rubrum grown on nickel-depleted medium indicates a requirement for nickel for hydrogenase activity. However, analysis of strain UR294 (cooC insertion mutant defective in nickel insertion into CODH) shows that independent nickel insertion mechanisms are utilized by hydrogenase and CODH. CooH lacks the C-terminal peptide that is found in other Ni-Fe hydrogenases; in other systems, this peptide is cleaved during Ni processing.     

Regulation of two nickel-requiring (inducible and constitutive) hydrogenases and their coupling to nitrogenase in Methylosinus trichosporium OB3b.

Two uptake hydrogenases were found in the obligate methanotroph Methylosinus trichosporium OB3b; one was constitutive, and a second was induced by H2. Both hydrogenases could be assayed by measuring methylene blue reduction anaerobically or by coupling their activity to nitrogenase acetylene reduction activity in vivo in an O2-dependent reaction. The H2 concentration for half-maximal activity of the inducible and constitutive hydrogenases in both assays was 0.01 and 0.5 bar (1 and 50 kPa), respectively, making it easy to distinguish these enzymes from one another both in vivo and in vitro. Hydrogen uptake was shown to be coupled to ATP synthesis in methane-starved cells. Methane, methanol, formate, succinate, and glucose all repressed the H2-mediated synthesis of the inducible hydrogenase. Furthermore, this enzyme was only expressed in N-starved cultures and was repressed by NH4+ and NO3-; synthesis of the constitutive hydrogenase was not affected by excess N in the growth medium. In nickel-free, EDTA-containing medium, the activities of these two enzymes were negligible; however, both enzyme activities appeared rapidly following the addition of nickel to the culture. Chloramphenicol, when added along with nickel, had no effect on the rapid appearance of either the constitutive or inducible activity, indicating that nickel is not required for synthesis of the hydrogenase apoproteins. These observations all suggest that these hydrogenases are nickel-containing enzymes. Finally, both hydrogenases were soluble and could be fractionated by 20% ammonium sulfate; the constitutive enzyme remained in the supernatant solution, while the inducible enzyme was precipitated under these conditions.     

The mechanisms of H2 activation and CO binding by hydrogenase I and hydrogenase II of Clostridium pasteurianum

Hydrogenase I (bidirectional) and hydrogenase II (uptake) of Clostridium pasteurianum have been investigated by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, in the presence and absence of the inhibitor, CO. These hydrogenases contain both a novel type of iron-sulfur cluster (H), which is the proposed site of H2 catalysis, and ferredoxin-type [4Fe-4S] clusters (F). The results show that the H clusters of these two hydrogenases have very different properties. The H cluster of oxidized hydrogenase II (Hox-II) exhibits three distinct EPR signals, two of which are pH-dependent. Hox-II binds CO reversibly to give a single, pH-independent species with a novel, rhombic EPR spectrum. The H cluster of reduced hydrogenase II (Hred-II) does not react with CO. In contrast, the EPR spectrum of Hox-I appears homogeneous and independent of pH. Hox-I has a much lower affinity for CO than Hox-II, and binds CO irreversibly to give an axial EPR signal. Hred-I also binds CO irreversibly. The EPR spectra of Fred-I and Fred-II show little or no change after CO treatment. Prior exposure to CO does not affect the catalytic activity of the reduced or oxidized hydrogenases when assayed in the absence of CO, but both enzymes are irreversibly inactivated if CO is present during catalysis. Mechanisms for H2 activation by hydrogenase I and hydrogenase II are proposed from the determined midpoint potentials (Em, pH 8.0) of H-I and H-II (Em approximately -400 mV, -CO; approximately -360 mV, +CO), F-I (Em = -420 mV, +/- CO), and F-II (Em = -180 mV, +/- CO). These allow one to rationalize the different modes of CO binding to the two hydrogenases and suggest why hydrogenase II preferentially catalyzes H2 oxidation. The results are discussed in light of recent spectroscopic data on the structures of the two H clusters.     

Spectroscopic characterization of the nickel and iron-sulphur clusters of hydrogenase from the purple photosynthetic bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina. 1. Electron spin resonance spectroscopy

The thermostable hydrogenase from Thiocapsa roseopersicina was examined by low-temperature ESR spectroscopy. Two types of signals were detected, from an oxidized iron-sulphur cluster and a nickel centre (Ni-A). In the oxidized protein additional signals were observed due to spin-spin interaction between the two paramagnetic centres. This interaction could be reversibly abolished by reduction to a redox potential below 105 mV. This implies that an additional redox centre is involved in the interaction, for which an Fe3+ ion is suggested. Reduction with hydrogen induced a second type of nickel ESR signal (Ni-C), corresponding to an intermediate redox state seen in other nickel hydrogenases. The Ni-C species was light-sensitive at cryogenic temperatures. At temperatures near to 4.2 K the Ni-C signal showed evidence of interaction with another paramagnetic centre, presumably a second iron-sulphur cluster. On reoxidation a signal due to a third Ni(III) species, Ni-B, increased in amplitude. These results establish that metal centres in the hydrogenase from T. roseopersicina are closely similar to those of the well-studied hydrogenase from Chromatium vinosum.     

Delivery of iron-sulfur clusters to the hydrogen-oxidizing [NiFe]-hydrogenases in Escherichia coli requires the A-type carrier proteins ErpA and IscA

During anaerobic growth Escherichia coli synthesizes two membrane-associated hydrogen-oxidizing [NiFe]-hydrogenases, termed hydrogenase 1 and hydrogenase 2. Each enzyme comprises a catalytic subunit containing the [NiFe] cofactor, an electron-transferring small subunit with a particular complement of [Fe-S] (iron-sulfur) clusters and a membrane-anchor subunit. How the [Fe-S] clusters are delivered to the small subunit of these enzymes is unclear. A-type carrier (ATC) proteins of the Isc (iron-sulfur-cluster) and Suf (sulfur mobilization) [Fe-S] cluster biogenesis pathways are proposed to traffic pre-formed [Fe-S] clusters to apoprotein targets. Mutants that could not synthesize SufA had active hydrogenase 1 and hydrogenase 2 enzymes, thus demonstrating that the Suf machinery is not required for hydrogenase maturation. In contrast, mutants devoid of the IscA, ErpA or IscU proteins of the Isc machinery had no detectable hydrogenase 1 or 2 activities. Lack of activity of both enzymes correlated with the absence of the respective [Fe-S]-cluster-containing small subunit, which was apparently rapidly degraded. During biosynthesis the hydrogenase large subunits receive their [NiFe] cofactor from the Hyp maturation machinery. Subsequent to cofactor insertion a specific C-terminal processing step occurs before association of the large subunit with the small subunit. This processing step is independent of small subunit maturation. Using western blotting experiments it could be shown that although the amount of each hydrogenase large subunit was strongly reduced in the iscA and erpA mutants, some maturation of the large subunit still occurred. Moreover, in contrast to the situation in Isc-proficient strains, these processed large subunits were not membrane-associated. Taken together, our findings demonstrate that both IscA and ErpA are required for [Fe-S] cluster delivery to the small subunits of the hydrogen-oxidizing hydrogenases; however, delivery of the Fe atom to the active site might have different requirements.     

Purification and properties of hydrogenase from phototrophic bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina]

The isolation method and some peoperties of purple sulphur bacteria (Thiocapsa roseopersicina strain BBS) hydrogenase are described Hydrogenase molecular weight is found to be 66000; it contains 3.7 moles of S2- and 3.9 moles of Fe2+ per one mole of the enzyme;pI=4.2. The enzyme absorption spectrum has the maximum at 400-412 nm which is characteristic of proteins containing non-haem iron. Hydrogenase is suggested to consist pf 4 subunits of two types: with molar weight 27000 and 6000. Unlike other hydrogenases, this enzyme is rather resistant to O2 and is more thermostable: the inactivation of the enzyme was observed at the temperature above 80 degrees C; Hydrogenase preparation catalyses D2-H2O exchange reaction, H2 evolution from the reduced methyl viologene (MV) and H2 absorption in the presense of MV or benzylviologene but not in the presense of NAD(P), FAD, FMN, azocarmine, methylene blue and ferricyanide.     

Dual organism design cycle reveals small subunit substitutions that improve [NiFe] hydrogenase hydrogen evolution

Background

Photosynthetic microorganisms that directly channel solar energy to the production of molecular hydrogen are a potential future biofuel system. Building such a system requires installation of a hydrogenase in the photosynthetic organism that is both tolerant to oxygen and capable of hydrogen production. Toward this end, we have identified the [NiFe] hydrogenase from the marine bacterium Alteromonas macleodii “Deep ecotype” that is able to be heterologously expressed in cyanobacteria and has tolerance to partial oxygen. The A. macleodii enzyme shares sequence similarity with the uptake hydrogenases that favor hydrogen uptake activity over hydrogen evolution. To improve hydrogen evolution from the A. macleodii hydrogenase, we examined the three Fe-S clusters found in the small subunit of many [NiFe] uptake hydrogenases that presumably act as a molecular wire to guide electrons to or from the active site of the enzyme. Studies by others altering the medial cluster of a Desulfovibrio fructosovorans hydrogenase from 3Fe-4S to 4Fe-4S resulted in two-fold improved hydrogen evolution activity.

Results

We adopted a strategy of screening for improved hydrogenase constructs using an Escherichia coli expression system before testing in slower growing cyanobacteria. From the A. macleodii enzyme, we created a mutation in the gene encoding the hydrogenase small subunit that in other systems is known to convert the 3Fe-4S medial cluster to 4Fe-4S. The medial cluster substitution did not improve the hydrogen evolution activity of our hydrogenase. However, modifying both the medial cluster and the ligation of the distal Fe-S cluster improved in vitro hydrogen evolution activity relative to the wild type hydrogenase by three- to four-fold. Other properties of the enzyme including thermostability and tolerance to partial oxygen did not appear to be affected by the substitutions.

Conclusions

Our results show that substitution of amino acids altering the ligation of Fe-S clusters in the A. macleodii [NiFe] uptake hydrogenase resulted in increased hydrogen evolution activity. This activity can be recapitulated in multiple host systems and with purified protein. These results validate the approach of using an E. coli-cyanobacteria shuttle system for enzyme expression and improvement.

     

Hydrogenase of purple bacteria: properties and regulation of synthesis

Physico-chemical properties of homogeneous preparations of soluble and membrane-bound hydrogenases from the purple sulfur bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina BBS and membrane-bound hydrogenase of Rhodopseudomonas capsulata, strain B10 have been studied. Compared to the enzymes from other sources, the hydrogenase of Thiocapsa roseopersicina is more stable to O₂ and products of its reduction (O ₂ ^- , H₂O₂), temperature and a number of other factors of the medium. A natural electron donor for T. roseopersicina hydrogenase is a low-potential cytochrome C₃, while the natural electron acceptors for hydrogenases of R. capsulata, T. roseopersicina, Ectothiorhodospira shaposhnikovii and Anabaena cylindrica are cytochromes of groups c and b.In different phototrophs, synthesis of hydrogenase can be inhibited by the presence of high concentrations of O₂. In some microorganisms (e.g. Rhodopseudomonas capsulata, strain B10) the repressing effect on hydrogenase formation is also exhibited by organic compounds. H₂ may not necessarily be present for hydrogenase synthesis by purple bacteria, but its presence may considerable increase the level of the enzyme.Abbreviations SDS sodium dodecylsulfate - Hipip high-potential iron — sulfur protein - R Rhodopseudomonas - T Thiocapsa - Rh Rhodospirillum - C Chromatium This paper is dedicated to Professor Dr. H.G. Schlegel in honour of his sixtieth birthday and in recognition of his great contribution in the field of physiology and biochemistry of microorganisms capable of using H₂. Professor H.G. Schlegel had a profound and most fuitful influence on the progress in the research of the laboratory headed by the author     

Purification and properties of cytochrome c552 from purple sulfur bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina

The method of purification up to electrophoretical homogeneity of cytochrome c552 from the phototrophic bacterium Thiocapsa roseopersicina, strain BBS is described. For the cytochrome absorption spectrum the maxima at 417, 523 and 552 nm are characteristic for the reduced state and at 409 nm--for the oxidized state. The molecular weight is equal to 62000. The cytochrome contains two hemes per molecule and consists of two subunits. pI is 4.1; E0' is about 10 mV. Cytochrome c552 is a flavoprotein according to its fluorescence spectrum and subunit structure. T. roseopersicina cytochrome c552 is able to be reduced with sulphide, cysteine and ascorbate as well as with H2 in the presence of hydrogenase from the same bacterium. These data suggest that cytochrome c552 from T. roseopersicina functions in vivo at the initial stage of electron transport from hydrogen and sulphide.     

Effect of redox potential on activity of hydrogenase 1 and hydrogenase 2 in Escherichia coli

This report elucidates the distinctions of redox properties between two uptake hydrogenases in Escherichia coli. Hydrogen uptake in the presence of mediators with different redox potential was studied in cell-free extracts of E. coli mutants HDK103 and HDK203 synthesizing hydrogenase 2 or hydrogenase 1, respectively. Both hydrogenases mediated H(2) uptake in the presence of high-potential acceptors (ferricyanide and phenazine methosulfate). H(2) uptake in the presence of low-potential acceptors (methyl and benzyl viologen) was mediated mainly by hydrogenase 2. To explore the dependence of hydrogen consumption on redox potential of media in cell-free extracts, a chamber with hydrogen and redox ( E(h)) electrodes was used. The mutants HDK103 and HDK203 exhibited significant distinctions in their redox behavior. During the redox titration, maximal hydrogenase 2 activity was observed at the E(h) below -80 mV. Hydrogenase 1 had maximum activity in the E(h) range from +30 mV to +110 mV. Unlike hydrogenase 2, the activated hydrogenase 1 retained activity after a fast shift of redox potential up to +500 mV by ferricyanide titration and was more tolerant to O(2). Thus, two hydrogenases in E. coli are complementary in their redox properties, hydrogenase 1 functioning at higher redox potentials and/or at higher O(2) concentrations than hydrogenase 2.     

A cytoplasmic nickel-iron hydrogenase with high specific activity from Desulfovibrio multispirans sp. N., a new species of sulfate reducing bacterium

A hydrogenase from a new species of sulfate reducing bacterium has been isolated and characterized. In contrast to other hydrogenases isolated from Desulfovibrio, this enzyme is found in the cytoplasmic fraction rather than in the periplasm. The specific activity of the enzyme, as measured in the hydrogen evolution assay, is twice as high as the specific activity of the hydrogenase from D. gigas. It also differentiates itself from the periplasmic Desulfovibrio hydrogenases by being more active in the hydrogen evolution rather than in the hydrogen uptake assay. The enzyme was shown to contain 0.9 atoms of nickel, 11 atoms of iron and 10 atoms of labile sulfide per mole of enzyme. It exhibits an unusually low intensity of the g = 2.31 nickel EPR signal in the isolated enzyme but shows a normal intensity for the g = 2.19 nickel EPR signal when reduced under hydrogen.