Constitutive versus regulated SNARE assembly: a structural basis

SNARE complex formation is essential for intracellular membrane fusion. Vesicle-associated (v-) SNARE intertwines with target membrane (t-) SNARE to form a coiled coil that bridges two membranes and facilitates fusion. For the SNARE family involved in neuronal communications, complex formation is tightly regulated by the v-SNARE-membrane interactions. However, it was found using EPR that complex formation is spontaneous for a different SNARE family that is involved in protein trafficking in yeast. Further, reconstituted yeast SNAREs promoted membrane fusion, different from the inhibited fusion for reconstituted neuronal SNAREs. The EPR structural analysis showed that none of the coiled-coil residues of yeast v-SNARE is buried in the hydrophobic layer of the membrane, making the entire coiled-coil motif accessible, again different from the deep insertion of the membrane-proximal region of neuronal v-SNARE into the bilayer. Importantly, yeast membrane fusion is constitutively active, while synaptic membrane fusion is regulated, consistent with the present results for two SNARE families. Thus, the v-SNARE-membrane interaction may be a major molecular determinant for regulated versus constitutive membrane fusion in cells.     

Regulation of neuronal SNARE assembly by the membrane

In the neuron, SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptors) assembly acts centrally in driving membrane fusion, a required process for neurotransmitter release. In the cytoplasm, vesicular SNARE VAMP-2 (vesicle-associated membrane protein-2) engages with two plasma membrane SNAREs, syntaxin 1A and SNAP-25 (synaptosome-associated protein of 25 kDa), to form the core complex that bridges two membranes. Although various factors regulate SNARE assembly, the membrane also aids in regulation by trapping VAMP-2 in the membrane. Fluorescence and EPR analyses revealed that the insertion of seven C-terminal core-forming residues into the membrane controls complex formation of the entire core region, even though the preceding 54 core-forming residues are fully exposed and freely moving. When two interfacial tryptophan residues in this region were replaced with hydrophilic serine residues, the mutation supported rapid complex formation. The results suggest that the membrane-proximal region of VAMP-2 is a regulatory module for SNARE assembly, providing new insights into calcium-triggered membrane fusion.     

The membrane-dipped neuronal SNARE complex: a site-directed spin labeling electron paramagnetic resonance study

The formation of the soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) complex is an essential process for membrane fusion and the neurotransmitter release in neurons. As an initial step toward the determination of the membrane topology of the SNARE complex, residues at the membrane-water interface were investigated with site-specific spin labeling electron paramagnetic resonance. EPR analysis revealed that the basic amino acid-rich interfacial region, which is universal for all transmembrane SNARE proteins, inserts into the membrane, eliminating the gap between the core complex and the membrane. The result raises the possibility that core complex formation directly leads to the apposition of two membranes, which could facilitate membrane fusion.     

A partially zipped SNARE complex stabilized by the membrane

The SNARE complex acts centrally for intracellular membrane fusion, an essential process for vesicular transport in cells. Association between vesicle-associated (v-) SNARE and target membrane (t-) SNARE results in the coiled coil core that bridges two membranes. Here, the structure of the SNARE complex assembled by recombinant t-SNARE Sso1p/Sec9 and v-SNARE Snc2p, which are involved in post-Golgi trafficking in yeast, was investigated using EPR. In detergent solutions, SNAREs formed a fully assembled core. However, when t-SNAREs were reconstituted into the proteoliposome and mixed with the soluble SNARE motif of Snc2p, a partially zipped core in which the N-terminal region is structured, whereas the C-terminal region is frayed, was detected. The partially zipped and fully assembled complexes coexisted with little free energy difference between them. Thus, the core complex formation of yeast SNAREs might not serve as the energy source for the fusion, which is different from what has been known for neuronal SNAREs. On the other hand, the results from the proteoliposome fusion assay, employing cysteine- and nitroxide-scanning mutants of Sso1p, suggested that the formation of the complete core is required for membrane fusion. This implies that core SNARE assembly plays an essential role in setting up the proper geometry of the lipid-protein complex for the successful fusion.     

The four-helix bundle of the neuronal target membrane SNARE complex is neither disordered in the middle nor uncoiled at the C-terminal region

Assembly of the SNARE complex is an essential step for membrane fusion and neurotransmitter release in neurons. The plasma membrane SNAREs syntaxin 1A and SNAP-25 (t-SNAREs) and the delivery-vesicle SNARE VAMP2 (or v-SNARE) contain the "SNARE regions" that essentially mediate SNARE pairing. Using site-directed spin labeling and EPR distance measurement we show that two identical copies of the SNARE region from syntaxin 1A intertwine as a coiled coil near the "ionic layer" region. The structure of the t-SNARE complex appears to be virtually identical to that of the ternary SNARE complex, except that VAMP2 is substituted to the second copy of syntaxin 1A. Furthermore, it appears that the coiled coil structure is maintained up to residue 259 of syntaxin 1A, identical to that of the ternary complex. These results are somewhat contradictory to the previous reports, suggesting that the t-SNARE complex has the disordered midsection (Xiao, W. Z., Poirier, M. A., Bennett, M. K., and Shin, Y. K. (2001) Nat. Struc. Biol. 8, 308-311) and the uncoiled C-terminal region (Margittai, M., Fasshauer, D., Pabst, S., Jahn, R., and Langen, R. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 13169-13177). The newly refined structure of the t-SNARE complex provides a basis for the better understanding of the SNARE assembly process. It also provides possible structural-functional clues to the membrane fusion in the v-SNARE deleted fusion models.     

Probing domain swapping for the neuronal SNARE complex with electron paramagnetic resonance

Highly conserved soluble N-ethylmaleimide sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) proteins control membrane fusion at synapses. The target plasma membrane-associated SNARE proteins and the vesicle-associated SNARE protein assemble into a parallel four-helix bundle. Using a novel EPR approach, it is found that the SNARE four-helix bundles are interconnected via domain swapping that is achieved by substituting one of the two SNAP-25 helices with the identical helix from the second four-helical bundle. Domain swapping is likely to play a role in the multimerization of the SNARE complex that is required for successful membrane fusion. The new EPR application employed here should be useful to study other polymerizing proteins.     

Membrane topologies of neuronal SNARE folding intermediates

Assembly of the SNARE complex is essential for neurotransmitter release at synapses. Target plasma membrane SNAREs (t-SNAREs) syntaxin 1A and SNAP-25 form the t-SNARE complex that serves as an intermediate toward final SNARE assembly with vesicle-associated SNARE (v-SNARE). Membrane topologies of syntaxin 1A and the t-SNARE complex were investigated using site-directed spin labeling EPR. EPR analysis revealed that the basic region at the membrane-water interface is unstructured but inserted into the membrane. Such membrane insertion leaves no gap between the t-SNARE core and the membrane. Yet the lack of structure could provide the flexibility necessary for the t-SNARE core. Further, the insertion of the basic interfacial region into the membrane may have profound implications for the mechanism of SNARE-induced membrane fusion.     

SNARE assembly and membrane fusion, a kinetic analysis

SNARE (soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor) assembly may promote intracellular membrane fusion, an essential process for vesicular transport in cells. Core complex formation between vesicle-associated SNARE and target membrane SNARE perhaps drives the merging of two membranes into a single bilayer. Using spin-labeling EPR, trans-SNARE complex formation was monitored "locally" at four different core locations of recombinant yeast SNAREs, which are individually reconstituted into phospholipid vesicles. The results indicate that the time scales of core formation are virtually the same at all four locations throughout the core region, indicating the possibility of a single step core assembly, which appears to be somewhat different from what has been postulated by the "zipper" model. The EPR data were then compared with the kinetics of the lipid mixing measured with the fluorescence assay. The analysis suggests that SNARE core assembly occurs on a much faster time scale than the lipid mixing, providing a new insight into the timing of individual events in SNARE-induced membrane fusion.     

Nonhelical leash and alpha-helical structures determine the potency of a peptide antagonist of human T-cell leukemia virus entry

Viral fusion proteins mediate the entry of enveloped viral particles into cells by inducing fusion of the viral and target cell membranes. Activated fusion proteins undergo a cascade of conformational transitions and ultimately resolve into a compact trimer of hairpins or six-helix bundle structure, which pulls the interacting membranes together to promote lipid mixing. Significantly, synthetic peptides based on a C-terminal region of the trimer of hairpins are potent inhibitors of membrane fusion and viral entry, and such peptides are typically extensively alpha-helical. In contrast, an atypical peptide inhibitor of human T-cell leukemia virus (HTLV) includes alpha-helical and nonhelical leash segments. We demonstrate that both the C helix and C-terminal leash are critical to the inhibitory activities of these peptides. Amino acid side chains in the leash and C helix extend into deep hydrophobic pockets at the membrane-proximal end of the HTLV type 1 (HTLV-1) coiled coil, and these contacts are necessary for potent antagonism of membrane fusion. In addition, a single amino acid substitution within the inhibitory peptide improves peptide interaction with the core coiled coil and yields a peptide with enhanced potency. We suggest that the deep pockets on the coiled coil are ideal targets for small-molecule inhibitors of HTLV-1 entry into cells. Moreover, the extended nature of the HTLV-1-inhibitory peptide suggests that such peptides may be intrinsically amenable to modifications designed to improve inhibitory activity. Finally, we propose that leash-like mimetic peptides may be of value as entry inhibitors for other clinically important viral infections.     

The Habc domain and the SNARE core complex are connected by a highly flexible linker

Syntaxin 1a is a member of the SNARE superfamily of small, mostly membrane-bound proteins that mediate membrane fusion in all eukaryotic cells. Upon membrane fusion, syntaxin 1 forms a stable complex with its partner SNAREs. Syntaxin contains a C-terminal transmembrane domain, an adjacent SNARE motif that interacts with its partner SNAREs, and an N-terminal Habc domain. The Habc domain reversibly folds back upon the SNARE motif, resulting in a "closed" conformation that is stabilized by binding to the protein munc18. The SNARE motif and the Habc domain are separated by a linker region of about 40 amino acids. When syntaxin is complexed with munc18, the linker is structured and consists of a mix of turns and small alpha-helices. When syntaxin is complexed with its partner SNAREs, the Habc domain is dissociated, but the structure of the linker region is not known. Here we used site-directed spin labeling and EPR spectroscopy to determine the structure of the linker region of syntaxin in the SNARE complex. We found that the entire linker region of syntaxin is unstructured except for three residues at the N-terminal and six residues at the C-terminal boundary whereas the structures of the flanking regions in the Habc domain and the SNARE motif correspond to the high-resolution structures of the isolated fragments. We conclude that the linker region exhibits a high degree of conformational flexibility.     

Hrs regulates early endosome fusion by inhibiting formation of an endosomal SNARE complex

Movement through the endocytic pathway occurs principally via a series of membrane fusion and fission reactions that allow sorting of molecules to be recycled from those to be degraded. Endosome fusion is dependent on SNARE proteins, although the nature of the proteins involved and their regulation has not been fully elucidated. We found that the endosome-associated hepatocyte responsive serum phosphoprotein (Hrs) inhibited the homotypic fusion of early endosomes. A region of Hrs predicted to form a coiled coil required for binding the Q-SNARE, SNAP-25, mimicked the inhibition of endosome fusion produced by full-length Hrs, and was sufficient for endosome binding. SNAP-25, syntaxin 13, and VAMP2 were bound from rat brain membranes to the Hrs coiled-coil domain. Syntaxin 13 inhibited early endosomal fusion and botulinum toxin/E inhibition of early endosomal fusion was reversed by addition of SNAP-25(150-206), confirming a role for syntaxin 13, and establishing a role for SNAP-25 in endosomal fusion. Hrs inhibited formation of the syntaxin 13-SNAP-25-VAMP2 complex by displacing VAMP2 from the complex. These data suggest that SNAP-25 is a receptor for Hrs on early endosomal membranes and that the binding of Hrs to SNAP-25 on endosomal membranes inhibits formation of a SNARE complex required for homotypic endosome fusion.     

Self-association of the H3 region of syntaxin 1A. Implications for intermediates in SNARE complex assembly

Intracellular membrane fusion requires SNARE proteins found on the vesicle and target membranes. SNAREs associate by formation of a parallel four-helix bundle, and it has been suggested that formation of this complex promotes membrane fusion. The membrane proximal region of the cytoplasmic domain of the SNARE syntaxin 1A, designated H3, contributes one of the four helices to the SNARE complex. In the crystal structure of syntaxin 1A H3, four molecules associate as a homotetramer composed of two pairs of parallel helices that are anti-parallel to each other. The H3 oligomer observed in the crystals is also found in solution, as assessed by gel filtration and chemical cross-linking studies. The crystal structure reveals that the highly conserved Phe-216 packs against conserved Gln-226 residues present on the anti-parallel pair of helices. Modeling indicates that Phe-216 prevents parallel tetramer formation. Mutation of Phe-216 to Leu appears to allow formation of parallel tetramers, whereas mutation to Ala destabilizes the protein. These results indicate that Phe-216 has a role in preventing formation of stable parallel helical bundles, thus favoring the interaction of the H3 region of syntaxin 1a with other proteins involved in membrane fusion.     

Activity determinants and functional specialization of Arabidopsis PEN1 syntaxin in innate immunity

In eukaryotes, proteins of the soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) family are believed to have a general role for the fusion of intracellular transport vesicles with acceptor membranes. Arabidopsis thaliana PEN1 syntaxin resides in the plasma membrane and was previously shown to act together with its partner SNAREs, the adaptor protein SNAP33, and endomembrane-anchored VAMP721/722 in the execution of secretory immune responses against powdery mildew fungi. We conducted a structure-function analysis of PEN1 and show that N-terminal phospho-mimicking and non-phosphorylatable variants neither affected binary nor ternary SNARE complex formation with cognate partners in vitro. However, expression of these syntaxin variants at native protein levels in a pen1 mutant background suggests that phosphorylation is required for full resistance activity in planta. All tested site-directed substitutions of SNARE domain or "linker region" residues reduced PEN1 defense activity. Two of the variants failed to form ternary complexes with the partner SNAREs in vitro, possibly explaining their diminished in planta activity. However, impaired pathogen defense in plants expressing a linker region variant is likely because of PEN1 destabilization. Although Arabidopsis PEN1 and SYP122 syntaxins share overlapping functions in plant growth and development, PEN1 activity in disease resistance is apparently the result of a complete functional specialization. Our findings are consistent with the hypothesis that PEN1 acts in plant defense through the formation of ternary SNARE complexes and point to the existence of unknown regulatory factors. Our data indirectly support structural inferences that the four-helical coiled coil bundle in ternary SNARE complexes is formed in a sequential order from the N- to C-terminal direction.     

Association of a novel PDZ domain-containing peripheral Golgi protein with the Q-SNARE (Q-soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive fusion protein (NSF) attachment protein receptor) protein syntaxin 6

PDZ domains are involved in the scaffolding and assembly of multi-protein complexes at various subcellular sites. We describe here the isolation and characterization of a novel PDZ domain-containing protein that localizes to the Golgi apparatus. Using an in silico cloning approach, we have identified and isolated a cDNA encoding a ubiquitously expressed 59-kDa protein that we call FIG. It is composed of two coiled coil regions, a leucine zipper, and a single PDZ domain. Cytological studies using indirect immunofluorescence microscopy revealed that FIG is a peripheral protein that uses one of its coiled coil domains to localize to the Golgi apparatus. To ascertain the modalities of this Golgi localization, the same coiled coil region was tested for its ability to interact with a panel of coiled coil domain-containing integral membrane Golgi proteins. Using a series of GST fusion protein binding assays, co-immunofluorescence and co-immunoprecipitation experiments, we show that FIG specifically binds to the coiled coil domain-containing Q-SNARE (Q-soluble NSF attachment protein receptor) protein syntaxin 6 both in vitro and in vivo. The structural features of FIG and its interaction with a SNARE protein suggest that FIG may play a role in membrane vesicle trafficking. This is the first example of a PDZ domain-containing peripheral protein that localizes to the Golgi through a coiled coil-mediated interaction with a resident membrane protein. Our results broaden the scope of PDZ domain-mediated functions.     

Membrane fusion mediated by coiled coils: a hypothesis

A molecular model of the low-pH-induced membrane fusion by influenza hemagglutinin (HA) is proposed based upon the hypothesis that the conformational change to the extended coiled coil creates a high-energy hydrophobic membrane defect in the viral envelope or HA expressing cell. It is known that 1) an aggregate of at least eight HAs is required at the fusion site, yet only two or three of these HAs need to undergo the "essential" conformational change for the first fusion pore to form (Bentz, J. 2000. Biophys. J. 78:000-000); 2) the formation of the first fusion pore signifies a stage of restricted lipid flow into the nascent fusion site; and 3) some HAs can partially insert their fusion peptides into their own viral envelopes at low pH. This suggests that the committed step for HA-mediated fusion begins with a tightly packed aggregate of HAs whose fusion peptides are inserted into their own viral envelope, which causes restricted lateral lipid flow within the HA aggregate. The transition of two or three HAs in the center of the aggregate to the extended coiled coil extracts the fusion peptide and creates a hydrophobic defect in the outer monolayer of the virion, which is stabilized by the closely packed HAs. These HAs are inhibited from diffusing away from the site to admit lateral lipid flow, in part because that would initially increase the surface area of hydrophobic exposure. The other obvious pathway to heal this hydrophobic defect, or some descendent, is recruitment of lipids from the outer monolayer of the apposed target membrane, i.e., fusion. Other viral fusion proteins and the SNARE fusion protein complex appear to fit within this hypothesis.     

Phage T5 straight tail fiber is a multifunctional protein acting as a tape measure and carrying fusogenic and muralytic activities

We report a bioinformatic and functional characterization of Pb2, a 121-kDa multimeric protein that forms phage T5 straight fiber and is implicated in DNA transfer into the host. Pb2 was predicted to consist of three domains. Region I (residues 1-1030) was mainly organized in coiled coil and shared features of tape measure proteins. Region II (residues 1030-1076) contained two alpha-helical transmembrane segments. Region III (residues 1135-1148) included a metallopeptidase motif. A truncated version of Pb2 (Pb2-Cterm, residues 964-1148) was expressed and purified. Pb2-Cterm shared common features with fusogenic membrane polypeptides. It formed oligomeric structures and inserted into liposomes triggering their fusion. Pb2-Cterm caused beta-galactosidase release from Escherichia coli cells and in vitro peptidoglycan hydrolysis. Based on these multifunctional properties, we propose that binding of phage T5 to its receptor triggers large conformational changes in Pb2. The coiled coil region would serve as a sensor for triggering the opening of the head-tail connector. The C-terminal region would gain access to the host envelope, permitting the local degradation of the peptidoglycan and the formation of the DNA pore by fusion of the two membranes.     

A conserved membrane-spanning amino acid motif drives homomeric and supports heteromeric assembly of presynaptic SNARE proteins

Assembly of the SNARE proteins synaptobrevin/VAMP, syntaxin, and SNAP-25 to binary and ternary complexes is important for docking and/or fusion of presynaptic vesicles to the neuronal plasma membrane prior to regulated neurotransmitter release. Despite the well characterized structure of their cytoplasmic assembly domains, little is known about the role of the transmembrane segments in SNARE protein assembly and function. Here, we identified conserved amino acid motifs within the transmembrane segments that are required for homodimerization of synaptobrevin II and syntaxin 1A. Minimal motifs of 6-8 residues grafted onto an otherwise monomeric oligoalanine host sequence were sufficient for self-interaction of both transmembrane segments in detergent solution or membranes. These motifs constitute contiguous areas of interfacial residues assuming alpha-helical secondary structures. Since the motifs are conserved, they also contributed to heterodimerization of synaptobrevin II and syntaxin 1A and therefore appear to constitute interaction domains independent of the cytoplasmic coiled coil regions. Interactions between the transmembrane segments may stabilize the SNARE complex, cause its multimerization to previously observed multimeric superstructures, and/or be required for the fusogenic activity of SNARE proteins.     

Sequential N- to C-terminal SNARE complex assembly drives priming and fusion of secretory vesicles

During exocytosis a four-helical coiled coil is formed between the three SNARE proteins syntaxin, synaptobrevin and SNAP-25, bridging vesicle and plasma membrane. We have investigated the assembly pathway of this complex by interfering with the stability of the hydrophobic interaction layers holding the complex together. Mutations in the C-terminal end affected fusion triggering in vivo and led to two-step unfolding of the SNARE complex in vitro, indicating that the C-terminal end can assemble/disassemble independently. Free energy perturbation calculations showed that assembly of the C-terminal end could liberate substantial amounts of energy that may drive fusion. In contrast, similar N-terminal mutations were without effects on exocytosis, and mutations in the middle of the complex selectively interfered with upstream maturation steps (vesicle priming), but not with fusion triggering. We conclude that the SNARE complex forms in the N- to C-terminal direction, and that a partly assembled intermediate corresponds to the primed vesicle state.     

Interhelical interactions in the gp41 core: implications for activation of HIV-1 membrane fusion

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein complex (gp120-gp41) promotes viral entry by mediating the fusion of viral and cellular membranes. Formation of a stable trimer-of-hairpins structure in the gp41 ectodomain brings the two membranes into proximity, leading to membrane fusion. The core of this hairpin structure is a six-helix bundle in which three carboxyl-terminal outer helices pack against an inner trimeric coiled coil. Here we investigate the role of these conserved interhelical interactions on the structure and function of both the envelope glycoprotein and the gp41 core. We have replaced each of the eight amino acids at the buried face of the carboxyl-terminal helix with a representative amino acid, alanine. Structural and physicochemical characterization of the alanine mutants shows that hydrophobic interactions are a dominant factor in the stabilization of the six-helix bundle. Alanine substitutions at the Trp628, Trp631, Ile635, and Ile642 residues also affected envelope processing and/or gp120-gp41 association and abrogated the ability of the envelope glycoprotein to mediate cell-cell fusion. These results suggest that the amino-terminal region of the gp41 outer-layer alpha-helix plays a key role in the sequence of events associated with HIV-1 entry and have implications for the development of antibodies and small-molecule inhibitors of this conserved element.     

The length of the flexible SNAREpin juxtamembrane region is a critical determinant of SNARE-dependent fusion.

The topology of a SNARE complex bridging two docked vesicles could act as a mechanical couple to do work on the lipid bilayer resulting in fusion. To test this, we prepared a series of modified SNARE proteins and determined their effects on SNARE-dependent membrane fusion. When two helix-breaking proline residues are introduced into the juxtamembrane region of VAMP, there is little or no effect on fusion, and the same change in syntaxin 1A only reduced the extent and rate of fusion by half. The insertion of a flexible linker between the transmembrane domain and the conserved coiled-coil domain only moderately affected fusion; however, fusion efficiency systematically decreased with increasing length of the linker. Together, these results rule out a requirement for helical continuity and suggest that distance is a critical factor for membrane fusion.