Expression screening of membrane proteins with cell-free protein synthesis

Detailed biophysical studies of integral membrane proteins are often hampered by sample preparation difficulties. Membrane proteins are typically difficult to express in sufficient amounts to enable the use of demanding techniques such as nuclear magnetic resonance and X-ray crystallography for structural biology. Here, we show that an inexpensive batch-based cell-free expression system can be a viable alternative for production of a wide range of different membrane proteins, both of prokaryotic and eukaryotic origin. Out of 38 tested protein constructs, 37 express at levels suitable for structural biology, i.e. enough to produce several milligrams of protein routinely and without excessive costs. This success rate was not anticipated and is even more impressive considering that more than half of the expressed proteins where of mammalian origin. A detergent screen identified Brij-58 as the, in general, most successful choice for co-translational solubilization of the expressed proteins.     

New limits of sensitivity of site-directed spin labeling electron paramagnetic resonance for membrane proteins

Site-directed spin labeling electron paramagnetic resonance is a biophysical technique based on the specific introduction of spin labels to one or more sites in diamagnetic proteins, which allows monitoring dynamics and water accessibility of the spin-labeled side chains, as well as nanometer distances between two (or more) labels. Key advantages of this technique to study membrane proteins are addressed, with focus on the recent developments which will expand the range of applicability. Comparison with other biophysical methods is provided to highlight the strength of EPR as complementary tool for structural biology. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Beyond the Structure-Function Horizon of Membrane Proteins edited by Ute Hellmich, Rupak Doshi and Benjamin McIlwain.     

Toward the fourth dimension of membrane protein structure: insight into dynamics from spin-labeling EPR spectroscopy

Trapping membrane proteins in the confines of a crystal lattice obscures dynamic modes essential for interconversion between multiple conformations in the functional cycle. Moreover, lattice forces could conspire with detergent solubilization to stabilize a minor conformer in an ensemble thus confounding mechanistic interpretation. Spin labeling in conjunction with electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy offers an exquisite window into membrane protein dynamics in the native-like environment of a lipid bilayer. Systematic application of spin labeling and EPR identifies sequence-specific secondary structures, defines their topology and their packing in the tertiary fold. Long range distance measurements (60 ?-80 ?) between pairs of spin labels enable quantitative analysis of equilibrium dynamics and triggered conformational changes. This review highlights the contribution of spin labeling to bridging structure and mechanism. Efforts to develop methods for determining structures from EPR restraints and to increase sensitivity and throughput promise to expand spin labeling applications in membrane protein structural biology.     

Genome-wide structural analysis reveals novel membrane binding properties of AP180 N-terminal homology (ANTH) domains

An increasing number of cytosolic proteins are shown to interact with membrane lipids during diverse cellular processes, but computational prediction of these proteins and their membrane binding behaviors remains challenging. Here, we introduce a new combinatorial computation protocol for systematic and robust functional prediction of membrane-binding proteins through high throughput homology modeling and in-depth calculation of biophysical properties. The approach was applied to the genomic scale identification of the AP180 N-terminal homology (ANTH) domain, one of the modular lipid binding domains, and prediction of their membrane binding properties. Our analysis yielded comprehensive coverage of the ANTH domain family and allowed classification and functional annotation of proteins based on the differences in local structural and biophysical features. Our analysis also identified a group of plant ANTH domains with unique structural features that may confer novel functionalities. Experimental characterization of a representative member of this subfamily confirmed its unique membrane binding mechanism and unprecedented membrane deforming activity. Collectively, these studies suggest that our new computational approach can be applied to genome-wide functional prediction of other lipid binding domains.     

Exceptional overproduction of a functional human membrane protein

Eukaryotic--especially human--membrane protein overproduction remains a major challenge in biochemistry. Heterologously overproduced and purified proteins provide a starting point for further biochemical, biophysical and structural studies, and the lack of sufficient quantities of functional membrane proteins is frequently a bottleneck hindering this. Here, we report exceptionally high production levels of a correctly folded and crystallisable recombinant human integral membrane protein in its active form; human aquaporin 1 (hAQP1) has been heterologously produced in the membranes of the methylotrophic yeast Pichia pastoris. After solubilisation and a two step purification procedure, at least 90 mg hAQP1 per liter of culture is obtained. Water channel activity of this purified hAQP1 was verified by reconstitution into proteoliposomes and performing stopped-flow vesicle shrinkage measurements. Mass spectrometry confirmed the identity of hAQP1 in crude membrane preparations, and also from purified protein reconstituted into proteoliposomes. Furthermore, crystallisation screens yielded diffraction quality crystals of untagged recombinant hAQP1. This study illustrates the power of the yeast P. pastoris as a host to produce exceptionally high yields of a functionally active, human integral membrane protein for subsequent functional and structural characterization.     

Minimal nanodisc without exogenous lipids for stabilizing membrane proteins in detergent-free buffer

Membrane protein stabilization after detergent solubilization presents drawbacks for structural and biophysical studies, in particular that of a reduced stability in detergent micelles. Therefore, alternative methods are required for efficient stabilization. Lipid nanodisc made with the membrane scaffold protein MSP is a valuable system but requires a fine optimization of the lipid to protein ratio. We present here the use of the scaffold protein MSP without added lipids as a minimal system to stabilize membrane proteins. We show that this method is applicable to α-helical and β-strands transmembrane proteins. This method allowed cryo-electron microscopy structural study of the bacterial transporter MexB. A protein quantification indicates that MexB is stabilized by two MSP proteins. This simplified and efficient method proposes a new advance in harnessing the MSP potential to stabilize membrane proteins.     

Cell-free expression as an emerging technique for the large scale production of integral membrane protein

Membrane proteins are highly underrepresented in structural data banks due to tremendous difficulties that occur upon approaching their structural analysis. Inefficient sample preparation from conventional cellular expression systems is in many cases the first major bottleneck. Preparative scale cell-free expression has now become an emerging alternative tool for the high level production of integral membrane proteins. Many toxic effects attributed to the overproduction of recombinant proteins are eliminated by cell-free expression as viable host cells are no longer required. A unique characteristic is the open nature of cell-free systems that offers a variety of options to manipulate the reaction conditions in order to protect or to stabilize the synthesized recombinant proteins. Detergents or lipids can easily be supplemented and membrane proteins can therefore be synthesized directly into a defined hydrophobic environment of choice that permits solubility and allows the functional folding of the proteins. Alternatively, cell-free produced precipitates of membrane proteins can efficiently be solubilized in mild detergents after expression. Highly valuable for structural approaches is the fast and efficient cell-free production of uniformly or specifically labeled proteins. A considerable number of membrane proteins from diverse families like prokaryotic small multidrug transporters or eukaryotic G-protein coupled receptors have been produced in cell-free systems in high amounts and in functionally active forms. We will give an overview about the current state of the art of this new approach with special emphasis on technical aspects as well as on the functional and structural characterization of cell-free produced membrane proteins.     

Saturation transfer EPR studies of membrane alteration in hereditary spherocytosis

Our earlier spin label electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) studies of hereditary spherocytosis (HS) erythrocyte revealed the existence of structural alteration(s) when the membrane is subjected to heat stress. We have now used saturation transfer EPR to show restricted motion in membrane proteins even without subjecting membrane to stress. The abnormal motional behavior is amplified when membranes are incubated at 47 degrees C and is readily detectable by conventional EPR. Gel electrophoresis and lipid assays show that proteins but not lipids are released upon heating. Thus, the more restricted motions in HS membranes may be due to a different membrane protein organization, ultimately resulting in the abnormal morphology of HS cells.     

Structure determination of membrane proteins in five easy pieces

Rotational Alignment (RA) solid-state NMR provides the basis for a general method for determining the structures of membrane proteins in phospholipid bilayers under physiological conditions. Membrane proteins are high priority targets for structure determination, and are challenging for existing experimental methods. Because membrane proteins reside in liquid crystalline phospholipid bilayer membranes it is important to study them in this type of environment. The RA solid-state NMR approach we have developed can be summarized in five steps, and incorporates methods of molecular biology, biochemistry, sample preparation, the implementation of NMR experiments, and structure calculations. It relies on solid-state NMR spectroscopy to obtain high-resolution spectra and residue-specific structural restraints for membrane proteins that undergo rotational diffusion around the membrane normal, but whose mobility is otherwise restricted by interactions with the membrane phospholipids. High resolution spectra of membrane proteins alone and in complex with other proteins and ligands set the stage for structure determination and functional studies of these proteins in their native, functional environment.     

Annexin B12 is a sensor of membrane curvature and undergoes major curvature-dependent structural changes

The regulation of membrane curvature plays an important role in many membrane trafficking and fusion events. Recent studies have begun to identify some of the proteins involved in controlling and sensing the curvature of cellular membranes. A mechanistic understanding of these processes is limited, however, as structural information for the membrane-bound forms of these proteins is scarce. Here, we employed a combination of biochemical and biophysical approaches to study the interaction of annexin B12 with membranes of different curvatures. We observed selective and Ca(2+)-independent binding of annexin B12 to negatively charged vesicles that were either highly curved or that contained lipids with negative intrinsic curvature. This novel curvature-dependent membrane interaction induced major structural rearrangements in the protein and resulted in a backbone fold that was different from that of the well characterized Ca(2+)-dependent membrane-bound form of annexin B12. Following curvature-dependent membrane interaction, the protein retained a predominantly alpha-helical structure but EPR spectroscopy studies of nitroxide side chains placed at selected sites on annexin B12 showed that the protein underwent inside-out refolding that brought previously buried hydrophobic residues into contact with the membrane. These structural changes were reminiscent of those previously observed following Ca(2+)-independent interaction of annexins with membranes at mildly acidic pH, yet they occurred at neutral pH in the presence of curved membranes. The present data demonstrate that annexin B12 is a sensor of membrane curvature and that membrane curvature can trigger large scale conformational changes. We speculate that membrane curvature could be a physiological signal that induces the previously reported Ca(2+)-independent membrane interaction of annexins in vivo.     

Quantitative imaging of membrane lipid order in cells and organisms

It is now recognized that lipids and proteins in cellular membranes are not homogenously distributed. A high degree of membrane order is the biophysical hallmark of cholesterol-enriched lipid rafts, which may induce the lateral sorting of proteins within the membrane. Here we describe a quantitative fluorescence microscopy technique for imaging localized lipid environments and measuring membrane lipid order in live and fixed cells, as well as in intact tissues. The method is based on the spectral ratiometric imaging of the polarity-sensitive membrane dyes Laurdan and di-4-ANEPPDHQ. Laurdan typically requires multiphoton excitation, making it suitable for the imaging of tissues such as whole, living zebrafish embryos, whereas di-4-ANEPPDHQ imaging can be achieved with standard confocal microscopes. This approach, which takes around 4 h, directly examines the organization of cellular membranes and is distinct from alternative approaches that infer membrane order by measuring probe partitioning or dynamics.     

Recent contributions from solid-state NMR to the understanding of membrane protein structure and function

The plasma membrane functions as a semi-permeable barrier, defining the interior (or cytoplasm) of an individual cell. This highly dynamic and complex macromolecular assembly comprises predominantly lipids and proteins held together by entropic forces and provide the interface through which a cell interacts with its immediate environment. The extended sheet-like bilayer structure formed by the phospholipids is a highly adaptable platform whose structure and composition may be tuned to provide specialised functionality. Although a number of biophysical techniques including X-ray crystallography have been used to determine membrane protein structures, these methods are unable to replicate and accommodate the complexity and diversity of natural membranes. Solid state NMR (ssNMR) is a versatile method for structural biology and can be used to provide new insights into the structures of membrane components and their mutual interactions. The extensive variety of sample forms amenable for study by ssNMR, allows data to be collected from proteins in conditions that more faithfully resemble those of native environment, and therefore is much closer to a functional state.     

Influence of the lipid membrane environment on structure and activity of the outer membrane protein Ail from Yersinia pestis

The surrounding environment has significant consequences for the structural and functional properties of membrane proteins. While native structure and function can be reconstituted in lipid bilayer membranes, the detergents used for protein solubilization are not always compatible with biological activity and, hence, not always appropriate for direct detection of ligand binding by NMR spectroscopy. Here we describe how the sample environment affects the activity of the outer membrane protein Ail (attachment invasion locus) from Yersinia pestis. Although Ail adopts the correct β-barrel fold in micelles, the high detergent concentrations required for NMR structural studies are not compatible with the ligand binding functionality of the protein. We also describe preparations of Ail embedded in phospholipid bilayer nanodiscs, optimized for NMR studies and ligand binding activity assays. Ail in nanodiscs is capable of binding its human ligand fibronectin and also yields high quality NMR spectra that reflect the proper fold. Binding activity assays, developed to be performed directly with the NMR samples, show that ligand binding involves the extracellular loops of Ail. The data show that even when detergent micelles support the protein fold, detergents can interfere with activity in subtle ways.     

The synthesis and high-level expression of a beta2-adrenergic receptor gene in a tetracycline-inducible stable mammalian cell line

High-level expression of G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) in functional form is required for structure-function studies. The main goal of the present work was to improve expression levels of beta2-adrenergic receptor (beta2-AR) so that biophysical studies involving EPR, NMR, and crystallography can be pursued. Toward this objective, the total synthesis of a codon-optimized hamster beta2-AR gene suitable for high-level expression in mammalian systems has been accomplished. Transient expression of the gene in COS-1 cells resulted in 18 +/- 3 pmol beta2-AR/mg of membrane protein, as measured by saturation binding assay using the beta2-AR antagonist [3H] dihydroalprenolol. Previously, we reported the development of an HEK293S tetracycline-inducible system for high-level expression of rhodopsin. Here, we describe construction of beta2-AR stable cell lines using the HEK293S-TetR-inducible system, which, after induction, express wild-type beta2-AR at levels of 220 +/- 40 pmol/mg of membrane protein corresponding to 50 +/- 8 microg/15-cm plate. This level of expression is the highest reported so far for any wild-type GPCR, other than rhodopsin. The yield of functional receptor using the single-step affinity purification is 12 +/- 3 microg/15-cm plate. This level of expression now makes it feasible to pursue structure-function studies using EPR. Furthermore, scale-up of beta2-AR expression using suspension cultures in a bioreactor should now allow production of enough beta2-AR for the application of biophysical techniques such as NMR spectroscopy and crystallography.     

Reconstitution of integral membrane proteins into isotropic bicelles with improved sample stability and expanded lipid composition profile

Reconstitution of integral membrane proteins into membrane mimetic environments suitable for biophysical and structural studies has long been a challenge. Isotropic bicelles promise the best of both worlds-keeping a membrane protein surrounded by a small patch of bilayer-forming lipids while remaining small enough to tumble isotropically and yield good solution NMR spectra. However, traditional methods for the reconstitution of membrane proteins into isotropic bicelles expose the proteins to potentially destabilizing environments. Reconstituting the protein into liposomes and then adding short-chain lipid to this mixture produces bicelle samples while minimizing protein exposure to unfavorable environments. The result is higher yield of protein reconstituted into bicelles and improved long-term stability, homogeneity, and sample-to-sample reproducibility. This suggests better preservation of protein structure during the reconstitution procedure and leads to decreased cost per sample, production of fewer samples, and reduction of the NMR time needed to collect a high quality spectrum. Furthermore, this approach enabled reconstitution of protein into isotropic bicelles with a wider range of lipid compositions. These results are demonstrated with the small multidrug resistance transporter EmrE, a protein known to be highly sensitive to its environment.     

LCP-Tm: An Assay to Measure and Understand Stability of Membrane Proteins in a Membrane Environment

Structural and functional studies of membrane proteins are limited by their poor stability outside the native membrane environment. The development of novel methods to efficiently stabilize membrane proteins immediately after purification is important for biophysical studies, and is likely to be critical for studying the more challenging human targets. Lipidic cubic phase (LCP) provides a suitable stabilizing matrix for studying membrane proteins by spectroscopic and other biophysical techniques, including obtaining highly ordered membrane protein crystals for structural studies. We have developed a robust and accurate assay, LCP-T_m, for measuring the thermal stability of membrane proteins embedded in an LCP matrix. In its two implementations, protein denaturation is followed either by a change in the intrinsic protein fluorescence on ligand release, or by an increase in the fluorescence of a thiol-binding reporter dye that measures exposure of cysteines buried in the native structure. Application of the LCP-T_m assay to an engineered human β₂-adrenergic receptor and bacteriorhodopsin revealed a number of factors that increased protein stability in LCP. This assay has the potential to guide protein engineering efforts and identify stabilizing conditions that may improve the chances of obtaining high-resolution structures of intrinsically unstable membrane proteins.     

Structural studies on membrane proteins using non-linear spin label EPR spectroscopy

Non-linear electron spin resonance (EPR) techniques suitable for measuring proximity relationships in membranes are reviewed. These were developed during the past decade in order to measure changes sensitively in the spin-lattice relaxation time (T1) of nitroxyl spin labels covalently attached to membrane lipids or proteins. In combination with paramagnetic quenching agents and double spin-labelling, the methods were further developed for distance measurements. Selected examples are given to illustrate different methods, and types of data obtained for both integral and peripheral membrane proteins.     

Styrene-maleic acid copolymer effects on the function of the GPCR rhodopsin in lipid nanoparticles

Styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers solubilize biological membranes to form lipid nanoparticles (SMALPs) that contain membrane proteins surrounded by native lipids, thus enabling the use of a variety of biophysical techniques for structural and functional studies. The question of whether SMALPs provide a truly natural environment or SMA solubilization affects the functional properties of membrane proteins, however, remains open. We address this question by comparing the photoactivation kinetics of rhodopsin, a G-protein-coupled receptor in the disk membranes of rod cells, in native membrane and SMALPs prepared at different molar ratios between SMA(3:1) and rhodopsin. Time-resolved absorption spectroscopy combined with complex kinetic analysis reveals kinetic and mechanistic differences between the native membrane and SMA-stabilized environment. The results suggest a range of molar ratios for nanoparticles suitable for kinetic studies.     

A functional NMR for membrane proteins: dynamics,ligand binding,and allosteric modulation

By nature of conducting ions, transporting substrates and transducing signals, membrane channels, transporters and receptors are expected to exhibit intrinsic conformational dynamics. It is therefore of great interest and importance to understand the various properties of conformational dynamics acquired by these proteins, for example, the relative population of states, exchange rate, conformations of multiple states, and how small molecule ligands modulate the conformational exchange. Because small molecule binding to membrane proteins can be weak and/or dynamic, structural characterization of these effects is very challenging. This review describes several NMR studies of membrane protein dynamics, ligand‐induced conformational rearrangements, and the effect of ligand binding on the equilibrium of conformational exchange. The functional significance of the observed phenomena is discussed.     

Comprehensive evaluation of solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy sample preparation for helical integral membrane proteins

The preparation of high quality samples is a critical challenge for the structural characterization of helical integral membrane proteins. Solving the structures of this diverse class of proteins by solution nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR) requires that well-resolved 2D ¹H/¹⁵N chemical shift correlation spectra be obtained. Acquiring these spectra demands the production of samples with high levels of purity and excellent homogeneity throughout the sample. In addition, high yields of isotopically enriched protein and efficient purification protocols are required. We describe two robust sample preparation methods for preparing high quality, homogeneous samples of helical integral membrane proteins. These sample preparation protocols have been combined with screens for detergents and sample conditions leading to the efficient production of samples suitable for solution NMR spectroscopy. We have examined 18 helical integral membrane proteins, ranging in size from approximately 9 kDa to 29 kDa with 1–4 transmembrane helices, originating from a number of bacterial and viral genomes. 2D ¹H/¹⁵N chemical shift correlation spectra acquired for each protein demonstrate well-resolved resonances, and >90% detection of the predicted resonances. These results indicate that with proper sample preparation, high quality solution NMR spectra of helical integral membrane proteins can be obtained greatly enhancing the probability for structural characterization of these important proteins.