Yeast centromere DNA is in a unique and highly ordered structure in chromosomes and small circular minichromosomes

We have examined the chromatin structure of the centromere regions of chromosomes III and XI in yeast by using cloned functional centromere DNAs (CEN3 and CEN11) as labeled probes. When chromatin from isolated nuclei is digested with micrococcal nuclease and the resulting DNA fragments separated electrophoretically and blotted to nitrocellulose filters, the centromeric nucleosomal sub-units are resolved into significantly more distinct ladders than are those from the bulk of the chromatin. A discrete protected region of 220–250 bp of CEN sequence flanked by highly nuclease-sensitive sites was revealed by mapping the exact nuclease cleavage sites within the centromeric chromatin. On both sides of this protected region, highly phased and specific nuclease cutting sites exist at nucleosomal intervals (160 bp) for a total length of 12–15 nucleosomal subunits. The central protected region in the chromatin of both centromeres spans the 130 bp segment that exhibits the highest degree of sequence homology (71%) between functional CEN3 and CEN11 DNAs. This unique chromatin structure is maintained on CEN sequences introduced into yeast on autonomously replicating plasmids, but is not propagated through foreign DNA sequences flanking the inserted yeast DNA.     

Chromatin structures of Kluyveromyces lactis centromeres in K. lactis and Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We have investigated the chromatin structure of Kluyveromyces lactis centromeres in isolated nuclei of K. lactis and Saccharomyces cerevisiae by using micrococcal nuclease and DNAse I digestion. The protected region found in K. lactis is approximately 270 bp long and encompasses the centromeric DNA elements, KlCDEI, KlCDEII, and KlCDEIII, but not KlCDE0. Halving KlCDEII to 82 bp impaired centromere function and led to a smaller protected structure (210 bp). Likewise, deletion of 5 bp from KlCDEI plus adjacent flanking sequences resulted in a smaller protected region and a decrease in centromere function. The chromatin structures of KlCEN2 and KlCEN4 present on plasmids were found to be similar to the structures of the corresponding centromeres in their chromosomal context. A different protection pattern of KlCEN2 was detected in S. cerevisiae, suggesting that KlCEN2 is not properly recognized by at least one of the centromere binding proteins of S. cerevisiae. The difference is mainly found at the KlCDEIII side of the structure. This suggests that one of the components of the ScCBF3-complex is not able to bind to KlCDEIII, which could explain the species specificity of K. lactis and S. cerevisiae centromeres.     

Identification and characterization of the centromere from chromosome XIV in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

A functional centromere located on a small DNA restriction fragment from Saccharomyces cerevisiae was identified as CEN14 by integrating centromere-adjacent DNA plus the URA3 gene by homologous recombination into the yeast genome and then by localizing the URA3 gene to chromosome XIV by standard tetrad analysis. DNA sequence analysis revealed that CEN14 possesses sequences (elements I, II, and III) that are characteristic of other yeast centromeres. Mitotic and meiotic analyses indicated that the CEN14 function resides on a 259-base-pair (bp) RsaI-EcoRV restriction fragment, containing sequences that extend only 27 bp to the right of the element I to III region. In conjunction with previous findings on CEN3 and CEN11, these results indicate that the specific DNA sequences required in cis for yeast centromere function are contained within a region about 150 bp in length.     

Restriction endonuclease cleavage of satellite DNA in intact bovine nuclei

We have analyzed the efficiency with which specific nucleotide sequences within nucleosomes are recognized and cleaved by DNA restriction endonucleases. A system amenable to this sort of analysis is the cleavage of the bovine genome with the restriction endonuclease EcoRI. Bovine satellite I comprises 7% of the genome and is tandemly repetitious with an EcoRI site at 1400 base pair (bp) intervals within this sequence. The ease with which this restriction fragment can be measured permits an analysis of the accessibility of this sequence when organized in a nucleosomal array.Initial studies indicated that satellite I sequences are organized in a nucleosomal structure in a manner analogous to that observed for total genomic DNA. We then examined the accessibility of the EcoRI cleavage sites in satellite to endonucleolytic cleavage in intact nuclei. We find that whereas virtually all the satellite I sequences from naked DNA are cleaved into discrete 1400 bp fragments, only 33% of the satellite I DNA is liberated as this fragment from intact nuclei. These data indicate that 57% of the EcoRI sites in nuclei are accessible to cleavage and that cleavage can occur within the core of at least half the nucleosomal subunits. Analysis of the products of digestion suggests a random distribution of nucleosomes about the EcoRI sites of satellite I DNA.Finally, the observation that satellite sequences can be cleaved from nuclei to 1400 bp length fragments with their associated proteins provides a method for the isolation of specific sequences as chromatin. Using sucrose gradient velocity centrifugation, we have isolated a 70% pure fraction of satellite I chromatin. Nuclease digestion of this chromatin fraction reveals the presence of nucleosomal subunits and indicates that specific sequences can be isolated in this manner without gross disorganization of their subunit structure.     

Stimulation of homologous recombination through targeted cleavage by chimeric nucleases

Chimeric nucleases that are hybrids between a nonspecific DNA cleavage domain and a zinc finger DNA recognition domain were tested for their ability to find and cleave their target sites in living cells. Both engineered DNA substrates and the nucleases were injected into Xenopus laevis oocyte nuclei, in which DNA cleavage and subsequent homologous recombination were observed. Specific cleavage required two inverted copies of the zinc finger recognition site in close proximity, reflecting the need for dimerization of the cleavage domain. Cleaved DNA molecules were activated for homologous recombination; in optimum conditions, essentially 100% of the substrate recombined, even though the DNA was assembled into chromatin. The original nuclease has an 18-amino-acid linker between the zinc finger and cleavage domains, and this enzyme cleaved in oocytes at paired sites separated by spacers in the range of 6 to 18 bp, with a rather sharp optimum at 8 bp. By shortening the linker, we found that the range of effective site separations could be narrowed significantly. With no intentional linker between the binding and cleavage domains, only binding sites exactly 6 bp apart supported efficient cleavage in oocytes. We also showed that two chimeric enzymes with different binding specificities could collaborate to stimulate recombination when their individual sites were appropriately placed. Because the recognition specificity of zinc fingers can be altered experimentally, this approach holds great promise for inducing targeted recombination in a variety of organisms.     

A nuclear protein that binds preferentially to methylated DNA in vitro may play a role in the inaccessibility of methylated CpGs in mammalian nuclei

The effects of DNA methylation on gene expression and chromatin structure suggest the existence of a mechanism in the nucleus capable of distinguishing methylated and non-methylated sequences. We report the finding of a nuclear protein in several vertebrate tissues and cell lines that binds preferentially to methylated DNA in vitro. Its lack of sequence-specific requirements makes it potentially capable of binding to any methylated sequence in mammalian nuclei. An in vivo counterpart of these results is that methylated CpGs are inaccessible to nucleases within nuclei. In contrast, non-methylated CpG sites, located mainly at CpG islands, and restriction sites not containing this dinucleotide, are relatively accessible. The possibility that DNA methylation acts through binding to specific proteins that could alter chromatin structure is discussed.     

Selective excision of the centromere chromatin complex from Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We have taken advantage of the known structural parameters associated with centromere DNA in vivo to construct a CEN fragment that can be selectively excised from the chromatin DNA with restriction endonucleases. CEN3 DNA is organized in chromatin such that a 220-250-bp region encompassing the elements of centromere homology is resistant to nuclease digestion. Restriction enzyme linkers encoding the Bam HI-recognition site were ligated to a 289 base pair DNA segment that spans the 220-250-bp protected core (Bloom et al., 1984). Replacement of this CEN3-Bam HI linker cassette into a chromosome or plasmid results in formation of a complete structural and functional centromeric unit. A centromere core complex that retains its protected chromatin conformation can be selectively excised from intact nuclei by restriction with the enzyme Bam HI. The centromeric protein-DNA complex is therefore not dependent upon the intact torsional constrains on linear chromosomes for its structural integrity. Isolation of this complex provides a novel approach to characterizing authentic centromeric proteins bound to DNA in their native state.     

Chromatin structure at the replication origins and transcription-initiation regions of the ribosomal RNA genes of Tetrahymena

The chromatin structure of regulatory regions of the extrachromosomal rRNA genes of Tetrahymena thermophila was probed by nuclease treatment of isolated nuclei. The chromatin near the origins of replication contains hypersensitive sites for micrococcal nuclease, DNAase I, and DNAase II. These sites persist in starved cells, consistent with the origins' being maintained in an altered chromatin structure independent of DNA replication. The region between the two origins of replication is organized into a phased array of seven nucleosomes, the fourth of which is centered at the axis of symmetry of the palindromic rDNA. The entire transcribed region and 150 bp upstream from the initiation site are generally accessible to nucleases; any histone proteins associated with these regions are clearly not in a highly organized nucleosomal array as seen in the central region. Comparison of the chromatin structures of the central spacer of T. thermophila and T. pyriformis rDNA reveals that deletion or insertion of DNA has occurred in increments of 200 bp. This is taken to imply that there are constraints on the evolution of spacer DNA sequences at the level of the nucleosome.     

Subunit structure of chromatin and the organization of eukaryotic highly repetitive DNA: indications of a phase relation between restriction sites and chromatin subunits in African green monkey and calf nuclei.

The periodicities of the restriction enzyme cleavage sites in highly repetitive DNAs of six mammalian species (monkey, mouse, sheep, human, calf and rat) appear related to the length of DNA contained in the nucleosome subunit of chromatin. We suggest that the nucleosome structure is an essential element in the generation and evolution of repeated DNA sequences in mammals (Brown et al., 1978; Maio et al., 1977). The possibility of a phase relation between DNA repeat sequences and associated nucleosome proteins is consistent with this hypothesis and has been tested by restriction enzyme and micrococcal nuclease digestions of repetitive DNA sequences in isolated, intact nuclei.Sites for four different restriction enzyme activities, EcoRI, EcoRI¹, HindIII and HaeIII have been mapped within the repeat unit of component α DNA, a highly repetitive DNA fraction of the African green monkey. The periodicity of cleavage sites for each of the enzymes (176 ± 4 nucleotide base-pairs) corresponds closely to the periodicity (about 185 nucleotide base-pairs) of the sites attacked in the initial stages of micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclear chromatin. In intact monkey nuclei, EcoRI-RI¹ sites are accessible to restriction enzyme cleavage; the HindIII and HaeIII sites are not. The results suggest (1) that, in component α chromatin, the EcoRI-RI¹ sites are found at the interstices of adjacent nucleosomes and (2) the HindIII and HaeIII sites are protected from cleavage by their location on the protein core of the nucleosome. This interpretation was confirmed by experiments in which DNA segments of mononucleosomes and nucleosome cores released from CV-1 nuclei by micrococcal nuclease were subsequently treated with EcoRI, EcoRI¹ and HindIII. A major secondary segment of component α, about 140 nucleotide base-pairs in length, was released only by treatment with HindIII, in keeping with the location of the HindIII sites in the restriction map and their resistance to cleavage in intact nuclei.EcoRI reduces calf satellite I DNA to a segment of about 1408 nucleotide basepairs. In contrast, restriction of calf satellite I DNA with EcoRI¹ produces six prominent segments ranging in size from 176 to 1408 nucleotide base-pairs. Treatment of isolated calf nuclei with either EcoRI or EcoRI¹ did not produce segments shorter than 1408 base-pairs, indicating that while canonical EcoRI sites are accessible to attack, the irregularly spaced EcoRI¹ sites are specifically blocked. The results are consistent with a phase relation between the repeat sequence of calf satellite I DNA and an octameric array of nucleosomes.     

Epigenetic modification of centromeric chromatin: hypomethylation of DNA sequences in the CENH3-associated chromatin in Arabidopsis thaliana and maize

The centromere in eukaryotes is defined by the presence of a special histone H3 variant, CENH3. Centromeric chromatin consists of blocks of CENH3-containing nucleosomes interspersed with blocks of canonical H3-containing nucleosomes. However, it is not known how CENH3 is precisely deposited in the centromeres. It has been suggested that epigenetic modifications of the centromeric chromatin may play a role in centromere identity. The centromeres of Arabidopsis thaliana are composed of megabase-sized arrays of a 178-bp satellite repeat. Here, we report that the 178-bp repeats associated with the CENH3-containing chromatin (CEN chromatin) are hypomethylated compared with the same repeats located in the flanking pericentromeric regions. A similar hypomethylation of DNA in CEN chromatin was also revealed in maize (Zea mays). Hypomethylation of the DNA in CEN chromatin is correlated with a significantly reduced level of H3K9me2 in Arabidopsis. We demonstrate that the 178-bp repeats from CEN chromatin display a distinct distribution pattern of the CG and CNG sites, which may provide a foundation for the differential methylation of these repeats. Our results suggest that DNA methylation plays an important role in epigenetic demarcation of the CEN chromatin.     

Nucleosome depletion alters the chromatin structure of Saccharomyces cerevisiae centromeres.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae centromeric DNA is packaged into a highly nuclease-resistant chromatin core of approximately 200 base pairs of DNA. The structure of the centromere in chromosome III is somewhat larger than a 160-base-pair nucleosomal core and encompasses the conserved centromere DNA elements (CDE I, II, and III). Extensive mutational analysis has revealed the sequence requirements for centromere function. Mutations affecting the segregation properties of centromeres also exhibit altered chromatin structures in vivo. Thus the structure, as delineated by nuclease digestion, correlated with functional centromeres. We have determined the contribution of histone proteins to this unique structural organization. Nucleosome depletion by repression of either histone H2B or H4 rendered the cell incapable of chromosome segregation. Histone repression resulted in increased nuclease sensitivity of centromere DNA, with up to 40% of CEN3 DNA molecules becoming accessible to nucleolytic attack. Nucleosome depletion also resulted in an alteration in the distribution of nuclease cutting sites in the DNA surrounding CEN3. These data provide the first indication that authentic nucleosomal subunits flank the centromere and suggest that nucleosomes may be the central core of the centromere itself.     

Variation in Chromatin Structure of the rDNA Transcribed Region in Human Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes

The rDNA transcribed region (TR) was tested for its accessibility for RsaI recognizing 15 TR sites, DNase I, and photoinducible arylazide (N-(4-azido-2-hydroxybenzoyl)-N,N"-diaminoheptane acetate) in isolated nuclei, and for the arylazide in intact cells. Arylazide readily entered the cells and did not appreciably affect the chromatin structure. Its photolysis products efficiently modified DNA in accessible sites. Single-strand breaks made by DNase I were not transformed into two-strand ones in rDNA TR, suggesting the necessity of denaturing electrophoresis for such an analysis. About 70% of all rDNA copies proved poorly accessible for endonucleases and arylazide, the accessibility being higher in their 18S and 5.8S rRNA gene regions than in the regions of the external transcribed spacers (ETSs) and the 28S rRNA gene. Proteinase K disrupted this structure, and the corresponding copies were extracted from nuclei. This explained whyin situ hybridization occasionally fails to reveal rDNA in the nucleolar fibrillar center (FC) on electron microscopic preparations. In other rDNA copies, TR (excluding 5"-ETS) was accessible for nucleases and arylazide. These copies were not extracted from nuclei treated with proteinase K. Some of their RsaI sites were protected by tightly bound proteins. Seven such regions were identified in TR. Possible association of the molecular structure, nucleolar location, and functional state of rDNA is discussed.     

Organization of 5S genes in chromatin of Xenopus laevis.

The chromatin organization of the genes coding for 5S RNA in Xenopus laevis has been investigated with restriction endonucleases and micrococcal nuclease. Digestion of nuclei from liver, kidney, blood and kidney cells maintained in culture with micrococcal nuclease reveals that these Xenopus cells and tissues have shorter nucleosome repeat lengths than the corresponding cells and tissues from other higher organisms. 5S genes are organized in nucleosomes with repeat lengths similar to those of the bulk chromatin in liver (178 bp) and cultured cells (165 bp); however, 5S gene chromatin in blood cells has a shorter nucleosome repeat (176 bp) than the bulk of the genome in these cells (184 bp). From an analysis of the 5S DNA fragments produced by extensive restriction endonuclease cleavage of chromatin in situ, no special arrangement of the nucleosomes with respect to the sequence of 5S DNA can be detected. The relative abundance of 5S gene multimers follows a Kuhn distribution, with about 57% of all HindIII sites cleaved. This suggests that HindIII sites can be cleaved both in the nucleosome core and linker regions.     

Location of the primary sites of micrococcal nuclease cleavage on the nucleosome core

The positions and relative frequencies of the primary cleavages made by micrococcal nuclease on the DNA of nucleosome core particles have been found by fractionating the double-stranded products of digestion and examining their single-stranded compositions. This approach overcomes the problems caused by secondary events such as the exonucleolytic and pseudo-double-stranded actions of the nuclease and, combined with the use of high resolution gel electrophoresis, enables the cutting site positions to be determined with a higher precision than has been achieved hitherto. The micrococcal nuclease primary cleavage sites lie close (on average, within 0.5 nucleotide) to those previously determined by Lutter (1981) for the nucleases DNase I and DNase II. These similarities show that the accessible regions are the same for all three nucleases, the cleavage sites being dictated by the structure of the nucleosome core. The differences in the final products of the digestion are explained in terms of secondary cleavage events of micrococcal nuclease. While the strongly protected regions of the nucleosome core DNA are common to all three nucleases, there are differences in the relative degrees of cutting at the more exposed sites characteristic of the particular enzyme. In particular, micrococcal nuclease shows a marked polarity in the 3'-5' direction in the cutting rates as plotted along a single strand of the nucleosomal DNA. This is explained in terms of the three-dimensional structure of the nucleosome where, in any accessible region of the double helix, the innermost strand is shielded by the outermost strand on the one side and the histone core on the other. The final part of the paper is concerned with the preference of micrococcal nuclease to cleave at (A,T) sequences in chromatin.     

Requirements for double-strand cleavage by chimeric restriction enzymes with zinc finger DNA-recognition domains

This study concerns chimeric restriction enzymes that are hybrids between a zinc finger DNA-binding domain and the non-specific DNA-cleavage domain from the natural restriction enzyme FokI. Because of the flexibility of DNA recognition by zinc fingers, these enzymes are potential tools for cleaving DNA at arbitrarily selected sequences. Efficient double-strand cleavage by the chimeric nucleases requires two binding sites in close proximity. When cuts were mapped on the DNA strands, it was found that they occur in pairs separated by ~4 bp with a 5′ overhang, as for native FokI. Furthermore, amino acid changes in the dimer interface of the cleavage domain abolished activity. These results reflect a requirement for dimerization of the cleavage domain. The dependence of cleavage efficiency on the distance between two inverted binding sites was determined and both upper and lower limits were defined. Two different zinc finger combinations binding to non-identical sites also supported specific cleavage. Molecular modeling was employed to gain insight into the precise location of the cut sites. These results define requirements for effective targets of chimeric nucleases and will guide the design of novel specificities for directed DNA cleavage in vitro and in vivo.     

Specific cleavage of chromatin by restriction nucleases.

Digestion of mouse and rat liver nuclei with a restriction nuclease from Bacillus subtilis (Bsu) is examined in continuation of previous work from this laboratory (Pfeiffer et al., 1975, Nature 258, 450). The finding of more than 95% C in the 5'-termini of the DNA fragments generated during digestion with Bsu shows that the participation of endogenous nucleases in Bsu digestion is extremely small. The restriction nuclease Hae III, an isoschizomer of Bsu, yields identical degradation patterns. The patterns conform to what one expects from statistical calculations based on a nucleosome structure of chromatin with a region preferentially accessible to the nuclease of 40-50 nucleotide pairs per nucleosome. Integrity of the histones is maintained during digestion with restriction nucleases. Digestion of mouse liver nuclei with EcoRII shows that most if not all of the satellite DNA is organized in a nucleosome structure. Also in rat liver, much of the repetitive DNA appears to be present in nucleosomes.     

Prepartation of soluble chromatin and specific chromatin fractions with restriction nucleases.

By digestion of rat liver nuclei with EndoR HaeIII, EndoR EcoRI, and EndoR Bam and subsequent lysis of the nuclei approx. 90%, 40%, and 45%, respectively, of the chromatin were solubilized. The plateau values of solubilization are in agreement with a model in which the chromatin strands are crosslinked and/or attached to a supporting structure. The distribution of DNA lengths in the soluble and insoluble chromatin fractions were determined. According to digestion experiments with restriction nucleases rat liver DNA contains highly repetitive sequences, some of which are arranged in tandem repeats of 95 and 380 nucleotide pairs, respectively. With EndoR EcoRI chromatin containing the repetitive RNA was preferentially solubilized and, by subsequent sucrose gradient centrifugation, purified to about 90%. The useful properties of chromatin prepared by the specific action of restriction nucleases are discussed.