Doubled haploid versus S1 family recurrent selection for testcross performance in a maize population

Theoretically, in a recurrent selection program, the use of doubled haploids (DH) can increase genetic advance per unit of time. To evaluate the efficiency expected from the use of DH for the improvement of grain yield in a maize (Zea mays L.) population, two recurrent selection programs for testcross performance were initiated using testcross progenies from DH lines and S₁ families. In 4 years one selection cycle using DH and two selection cycles using S₁ families were carried out with the same selection intensity for both methods. As expected, testcross genetic variance was twice as high among DH lines as among S₁ families. The predicted genetic gain was 8.2% for the DH selection cycle, and 10.6% for the two S₁ selection cycles, giving a per year advantage of 29% for the S₁ family method over the DH method with a cycle of 4 years. With a 3-year cycle for the DH method, both methods were expected to be equivalent. Using a tester related to the one used for selection, the genetic gains obtained were equivalent for both methods: 6.6% for the DH cycle and 7.0% for the two S₁ cycles. With a 3-year cycle for the DH method, the advantage would have been in favor of DH method. Furthermore, the DH method has the advantage of simultaneously producing lines that are directly usable as parents of a hybrid. Thus, if the genetic advance per unit of time is evaluated at the level of developed varieties even with the same or with a lower genetic advance in population improvement, the DH method appears to be the most efficient.     

Quantitative Genetics of Doubled Haploid Populations and Application to the Theory of Line Development

The line value of a genotype is defined as the expected value of all lines that can be derived from this genotype. Specific genetic effects are defined for this value: only additive and additive by additive epistatic effects are necessary. There is no dominance effect for such a value. A general expression for the covariances between related lines is given. From a design with several lines per haplodiploidized plant taken at random from a population it is possible to estimate the additive variance for line value and the variance of additive by additive epistasis for line value. Variances of higher order epistasis can be estimated with a two-factor mating design in which a cross is replaced by the population of lines that can be derived from it. With a diallel or a factorial design a direct test for the presence of homozygous by homozygous epistasis is possible. The application of the concept of line value to the theory of line development leads to simple expressions of genetic advance in one cycle of recurrent selection according to the testing system. A brief consideration of these expressions leads to the conclusion that single doubled haploid descent recurrent selection will be one of the most efficient methods for low heritabilities and with a rapid development of doubled haploid lines.     

Estimation of genetic variability and heritability for biofuel feedstock yield in several populations of switchgrass

Information on heritability and predicted gains from selection for increased biomass yield for ethanol production in switchgrass is limited and may vary among breeding populations. The purpose of this study was to estimate heritability and predicted gains from selection for higher biomass yield within a lowland ecotype switchgrass population, Southern Lowland 93 (SL‐93), and two upland ecotype switchgrass populations, Southern Upland Northern Upland Early Maturing (SNU‐EM) and Southern Upland Northern Upland Late Maturing (SNU‐LM). Narrow‐sense heritabilities (h_n²) for biomass yield in each of the three populations were estimated via progeny–parent regression analysis. Half‐sib (HS) progeny families from 130 randomly selected plants from the SL‐93 population were evaluated for biomass yield in replicated trials in 2002 and 2003. Clonal parent plants were evaluated for biomass yield in separate environments to provide unbiased h_n² estimates from progeny–parent regression. Yield differences were highly significant among SL‐93 HS progenies within and over years. For the SL‐93 population, h_n² estimates were 0.13 and 0.12 based on individual plant and phenotypic family mean (PFM) selection, respectively. Predicted genetic gains (ΔG) per selection cycle were 0.15 kg dry matter (dm) plant^?1 and 0.10 kg dm plant^?1 for PFM and individual plant selection methods, respectively. For the SNU‐EM and SNU‐LM populations, year and year × HS family effects were highly significant (P < 0.01) and the HS family effect over years was nonsignificant (P < 0.05). However, HS family effects were highly significant within respective years (P < 0.01). Estimates of h_n² for the SNU‐EM and SNU‐LM populations based on PFM and individual plant selection were similar, ranging from 0.44 to 0.47; ΔG per selection cycle ranged from 0.22 to 0.33 kg dm plant^?1. The magnitudes of the estimates of additive genetic variation suggest that selection for higher biomass yield should be possible. The substantial effect of environment on biomass yields in the upland populations and the failure of families to respond similarly over years stress the importance of adequately testing biomass yield over years to assess yield.     

A general approach for the study of a population of testcross progenies and consequences for recurrent selection

Summary A model to study genetic effects at the level of a population of testcross progenies is presented. As there is no dominance for the testcross value, with the restriction of epistasis to pairs of loci, only additive x additive epistasis can contribute to the variance among progenies. To estimate the variance among progenies due to epistasis, it is necessary to have the population structured in families of full sibs, half sibs or S₁, with only a few plants per family tested in combination with the tester. Using a two-way mating design to produce the families, it is possible to estimate the variance due to additive x additive epistasis. The consequence of the presence of epistasis is studied at the level of recurrent selection for combining ability with the tester. It seems that epistasis itself does not change the efficiency of the breeding methods considered. However, when the population from intercrossing is structured in families, it could be efficient to use a combined selection when the heritability is very low. In this case it would be efficient to produce full-sib families (by single-pair matings) at the level of intercrossing. The best procedure is to produce such families at the same time as crossing with the tester. In comparison to the classical scheme of selection for combining ability with a tester, such a modification increases the efficiency of selection 41.1% if an off-season generation can be used.     

Genotypic and environmental variation in some colour characteristics of carrots

Five colour characteristics were studied in seventeen carrot trials in which four varieties of the Chantenay type and four of the Autumn King type were grown at two densities at several sites for 3 yr. The Chantenay type had lower percentages of green-topped and green-cored roots and a higher score for internal colour; the Autumn King type had a lower percentage of purple-topped roots. Differences between varieties within types were also detected. Large environmental effects mainly resulted from differences between individual trials. Percentages of discoloured roots were higher at the low density. Genotype × environment (GE) interactions of practical importance were detected for all characters except internal colour. Some of these interactions were adequately described in terms of different linear regression coefficients for the genotypes, when genotypic values were regressed on environmental means. The results indicate that a low density should be chosen when selecting for reduced discolorations. Broad-sense heritabilities, estimated from variance components for the genotypic, environmental and GE effects, show that the most efficient selection for a colour character, in one season and with four test plots per family, would be achieved when such plots were grown at four separate sites.     

A method of line development using doubled haploids: the single doubled haploid descent recurrent selection

Summary Different methods of line development using doubled haploids in recurrent selection are presented. They are divided into two types: recurrent selection with progeny testing and recurrent selection on the phenotype of lines. It is shown that one of the best methods of line development is based on single doubled haploid descent recurrent selection. Only one line is studied per plant of the population, and the best lines are intercrossed. Using this method it is very easy to extract lines for variety development.     

Genetic analysis of indicators of cholesterol synthesis and absorption: lathosterol and phytosterols in Dutch twins and their parents.

Significant familial aggregation was observed for plasma levels of lathosterol (an indicator of whole-body cholesterol synthesis) and plant sterols campesterol and beta-sitosterol (indicators of cholesterol absorption) in 160 Dutch families consisting of adolescent mono- and dizygotic twin pairs and their parents. For lathosterol a moderate genetic heritability in parents and offspring (29%) was found. In addition, shared environment also contributed significantly (37%) to variation in plasma lathosterol concentrations in twin siblings. However, a model with different genetic heritabilities in the two generations (10% in parents and 68% in offspring) fitted the data almost as well. For plasma plant sterol concentrations high heritabilities were found. For campesterol heritability was 80% and for beta-sitosterol it was 73%, without evidence for differences in heritability between sexes or generations. No influence of common environmental influences shared by family members was seen for either campesterol or beta-sitosterol. Taken together, these results confirm and expand the hypothesis that individual differences in plasma levels of noncholesterol sterols are moderately (lathosterol) to highly (plant sterols) heritable.     

Combined S2 and crossbred family selection in full-sib reciprocal recurrent selection

Summary A method (CRRS) that combines S₂ and crossbred family selection in full-sib reciprocal recurrent selection (FSRRS) is proposed. The method requires four generations per cycle in single-eared maize populations. Selection is based on performance of S₂ and full-sib families by applying selection index theory. Equations to estimate the coefficients included in the index are given. These estimates are functions of the genetic and phenotypic variances and covariances among and between the two kinds of families. Comparisons of FSRRS and CRRS under equivalent amount of effort show that CRRS has some advantage over FSRRS for low heritability of the trait being selected (e.g., maize yield) and when only one or two locations with two replications are involved in the selection experiment.Joint contribution: Institute Nacional de Investigaciones Agrarias, La Coruna, Spain; and Agricultural Research, Science and Education Administration, U.S. Department of Agriculture, and Journal Paper No. J-10118 of the Iowa Agriculture and Home Economics Experiment Station, Ames, IA 50011. Project 2194     

Potential for selection on plants for water-use efficiency as estimated by carbon isotope discrimination

Water-use efficiency is thought to be related to plant performance and natural selection for plants in arid habitats, based on a general expectation that increased water-use efficiency is associated with decreased carbon gain and biomass accumulation. Using leaf carbon isotope discrimination Δ to determine integrated water-use efficiency, we estimated genetic variance for, and examined the relationships among Δ, biomass, and gas exchange characters for full-sibling families of the woody shrub, Chrysothamnus nauseosus, grown from seed collected at Tintic, Utah. In both well-watered greenhouse and common garden experiments, and water-limited common garden experiments, there were significant family differences for Δ, biomass, and morphological characters, indicating a potential for genetic change in response to selection. However, estimates of broad-sense heritabilities for Δ were low, indicating that the rate of change in response to selection would be relatively slow. This was consistent with the large amount of phenotypic plasticity observed for Δ as it differed with water treatment and year in the garden experiment. Phenotypically, aboveground biomass and Δ were negatively correlated within the well-watered treatments (i.e., more water-use efficient plants were larger), not correlated within the water-limited treatment, and positively correlated for combined well-watered and water-limited garden treatments, suggesting that variation in both photosynthetic capacity and stomatal limitation contribute to the variation in Δ. In contrast to the phenotypic correlations, genetic correlations for biomass and Δ were consistently negative within each treatment, and selection for higher water-use efficiency through low Δ for C. nauseosus plants in this population would tend to shift populations toward larger plants. For C. nauseosus, increased water-use efficiency is not necessarily associated with decreased carbon gain.     

The origin and evolution of geminivirus-related DNA sequences in Nicotiana

A horizontal transmission of a geminiviral DNA sequence, into the germ line of an ancestral Nicotiana, gave rise to multiple repeats of geminivirus-related DNA, GRD, in the genome. We follow GRD evolution in Nicotiana tabacum (tobacco), an allotetraploid, and its diploid relatives, and show GRDs are derived from begomoviruses. GRDs occur in two families: the GRD5 family's ancestor integrated into the common ancestor of three diploid species, Nicotiana kawakamii, Nicotiana tomentosa and Nicotiana tomentosiformis, on homeologous group 4 chromosomes. The GRD3 family was acquired more recently on chromosome 2 in a lineage of N. tomentosiformis, the paternal ancestor of tobacco. Both GRD families include individual members that are methylated and diverged. Using relative rates of synonymous and nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions, we tested for evidence of selection on GRD units and found none within the GRD3 and GRD5 families. However, the substitutions between GRD3 and GRD5 do show a significant excess of synonymous changes, suggesting purifying selection and hence a period of autonomous evolution between GRD3 and GRD5 integration. We observe in the GRD3 family, features of Helitrons, a major new class of putative rolling-circle replicating eukaryotic transposon, not found in the GRD5 family or geminiviruses. We speculate that the second integration event, resulting in the GRD3 family, involved a free-living geminivirus, a Helitron and perhaps also GRD5. Thus our data point towards recurrent dynamic interplay between geminivirus and plant DNA in evolution.     

Genetic similarity and relationships of DNA fingerprints with performance and with heterosis in Japanese quail lines from two origins and under reciprocal recurrent or within-line selection for early egg production

DNA fingerprints of Japanese quail male and female pure line breeders were obtained with probes 33.6, 33.15, and R18.1 and they yielded a total of 59 scoreable bands. Bandsharing (0 < BS < 1) was calculated within and between six quail lines of two origins, and under reciprocal recurrent (AA and BB), within-line (DD and EE) or no (PP and FF) selection. Twenty one pair types were compared. BS was 0.30 higher within line than between lines. BS with the control line was smaller for reciprocal recurrent selection lines than for lines under individual selection. Bandsharing between the two reciprocal recurrent selection lines was 0.19 lower than between lines under individual selection. These results indicate that the two selection methods had different effects on the genetic constitution of the lines, in agreement with previous observations made from the analysis of biochemical polymorphisms with the same set of birds. Egg production and weight traits of pure and crossbred progeny from fingerprinted quail were obtained and compared, and a linear relationship with the measure of bandsharing was estimated. No significant regression coefficient of performance on BS was found over all progeny genetic types. Heterosis from individual matings could also be estimated under the two selection methods since the same birds were parents of both pure and crossbred performance-tested quail. The association of heterosis with the difference between BS of parents of the purebreds and BS of parents of their half-sib crossbreds was favourable and significant for early production traits in lines DD and EE, but no relationship was found in lines AA and BB. These results indicate that the high level of heterosis obtained through reciprocal recurrent selection, and the heterosis observed under within-line selection may have, partly at least, a different genetic determinism. Therefore, the relationship of heterosis with BS may also depend on the past history of selection in the lines.     

RESPONSES OF FLORAL TRAITS TO SELECTION ON PRIMARY SEXUAL INVESTMENT IN SPERGULARIA MARINA: THE BATTLE BETWEEN THE SEXES

Two widespread assumptions underlie theoretical models of the evolution of sex allocation in hermaphroditic species: (1) resource allocations to male and female function are heritable; and (2) there is an intrinsic, genetically based negative correlation between male and female reproductive function. These assumptions have not been adequately tested in wild species, although a few studies have detected either genetic variation in pollen and ovule production per flower or evidence of trade-offs between male and female investment at the whole plant level. It may also be argued, however, that in highly autogamous, perfect-flowered plant taxa that exhibit genetic variation in gamete production, strong stabilizing selection for an efficient pollen:ovule ratio should result in a positive correlation among genotypes with respect to mean ovule and mean pollen production per flower. Here we report the results of a three-generation artificial selection experiment conducted on a greenhouse population of the autogamous annual plant Spergularia marina. Starting with a base population of 1200 individuals, we conducted intense mass selection for two generations, creating four selected lines (high and low ovule production per flower; high and low anther production per flower) and a control line. By examining the direct and correlated responses of several floral traits to selection on gamete production per flower, we evaluated the expectations that primary sexual investment would exhibit heritable variation and that resource-sharing, variation in resource-garnering ability, or developmental constraints mold the genetic correlations expressed among floral organs. The observed direct and correlated responses to selection on male and female gamete production revealed significant heritabilities of both ovule and anther production per flower and a significant negative genetic correlation between them. When plants were selected for increased ovules per flower over two generations, ovule production increased and anther production declined relative to the control line. Among plants selected for decreased anthers per flower, we observed a decline in anther production and an increase in ovule production relative to the control line. In contrast, the lines selected for low ovules per flower and for high anthers per flower exhibited no evidence for significant genetic correlations between male and female primary investment. Correlated responses to selection also indicate a genetically based negative correlation between the production of normal versus developmentally abnormal anthers (staminoid organs); a positive correlation between the production of ovules versus staminoid organs; and a positive correlation between the production of anthers and petals. The negative relationship between male versus female primary investment supports classical sex allocation theory, although the asymmetrical correlated responses to selection indicate that this relationship is not always expressed.     

Hybrid maize breeding with doubled haploids: V. Selection strategies for testcross performance with variable sizes of crosses and S1 families

In hybrid maize (Zea mays L.) breeding, doubled haploids (DH) are increasingly replacing inbreds developed by recurrent selfing. Doubled haploids may be developed directly from S₀ plants in the parental cross or via S₁ families. In both these breeding schemes, we examined 2 two-stage selecting strategies, i.e., considering or ignoring cross and family structure while selection among and within parental crosses and S₁ families. We examined the optimum allocation of resources to maximize the selection gain ΔG and the probability P(q) of identifying the q% best genotypes. Our specific objectives were to (1) determine the optimum number and size of crosses and S₁ families, as well as the optimum number of test environments and (2) identify the superior selection strategy. Selection was based on the evaluation of testcross progenies of (1) DH lines in both stages (DHTC) and (2) S₁ families in the first stage and of DH lines within S₁ families in the second stage (S₁TC-DHTC) with uniform and variable sizes of crosses and S₁ families. We developed and employed simulation programs for selection with variable sizes of crosses and S₁ families within crosses. The breeding schemes and selection strategies showed similar relative efficiency for both optimization criteria ΔG and P (0.1%). As compared with DHTC, S₁TC-DHTC had larger ΔG and P (0.1%), but a higher standard deviation of ΔG. The superiority of S₁TC-DHTC was increased when the selection was done among all DH lines ignoring their cross and family structure and using variable sizes of crosses and S₁ families. In DHTC, the best selection strategy was to ignore cross structures and use uniform size of crosses.     

Variation and inheritance of sodium transport in rice

Sodium transport in rice is characterised by large variability between individual plants, and large environmental interaction. As a result of these two factors, plant sodium content is a continuous variable which is not distributed normally. This applies both to the quantity of sodium in the plant and to the concentration of sodium on a unit fresh or dry weight basis. This variability is in part because the transpirational by-pass flow, dependent upon root anatomy and development, contributes to sodium uptake. Variability in sodium content within designated cultivars is heritable and line selections diverge during recurrent selection, suggesting that selection is working on residual heterozygosity rather than on a family of homozygous lines. Varieties differ in average sodium uptake into the plant but the direct correlation of this with survival is weak. This is because other independent characters are important (and these have not been combined by natural selection nor by chance) and because overall performance is confounded by the spurious advantage of the tall (non-dwarf) plant type. This advantage is spurious because much of it is due to plant size rather than to any genetic information for salt tolerance. The benefit deriving from plant size will not be heritable in crosses with genotypes of the improved (dwarf), high-yielding plant type because the dwarfing genes are dominant. Sodium transport is heritable in crosses, and the results presented show that both low sodium transport and low sodium to potassium ratio can be selected independently of plant type. This allows the selection of dwarf plants (which are agronomically desirable) with low sodium transport (which will improve salt tolerance).     

Genomic Predictability of Interconnected Biparental Maize Populations

Intense structuring of plant breeding populations challenges the design of the training set (TS) in genomic selection (GS). An important open question is how the TS should be constructed from multiple related or unrelated small biparental families to predict progeny from individual crosses. Here, we used a set of five interconnected maize (Zea mays L.) populations of doubled-haploid (DH) lines derived from four parents to systematically investigate how the composition of the TS affects the prediction accuracy for lines from individual crosses. A total of 635 DH lines genotyped with 16,741 polymorphic SNPs were evaluated for five traits including Gibberella ear rot severity and three kernel yield component traits. The populations showed a genomic similarity pattern, which reflects the crossing scheme with a clear separation of full sibs, half sibs, and unrelated groups. Prediction accuracies within full-sib families of DH lines followed closely theoretical expectations, accounting for the influence of sample size and heritability of the trait. Prediction accuracies declined by 42% if full-sib DH lines were replaced by half-sib DH lines, but statistically significantly better results could be achieved if half-sib DH lines were available from both instead of only one parent of the validation population. Once both parents of the validation population were represented in the TS, including more crosses with a constant TS size did not increase accuracies. Unrelated crosses showing opposite linkage phases with the validation population resulted in negative or reduced prediction accuracies, if used alone or in combination with related families, respectively. We suggest identifying and excluding such crosses from the TS. Moreover, the observed variability among populations and traits suggests that these uncertainties must be taken into account in models optimizing the allocation of resources in GS.     

Computer simulation of within family selection in finite populations

Summary The relative efficiency, in terms of selection limits, between mass selection and within family selection was compared by computer simulation methods. A 20-locus additive model was used to simulate a quantitative trait under selection. It was assumed that 50–75 percent of the genetic variance in the base population was controlled by four major genes initially at low frequencies.In populations of size N=100 no loss of major genes was found when either method of selection was used. When N=50 within family selection was generally superior to mass selection but when N=10 the situation was reversed. For N=30 within family selection was more efficient only under high selection intensity or high heritability situations.     

Genetic variation in variability: Phenotypic variability of fledging weight and its evolution in a songbird population

Variation in traits is essential for natural selection to operate and genetic and environmental effects can contribute to this phenotypic variation. From domesticated populations, we know that families can differ in their level of within‐family variance, which leads to the intriguing situation that within‐family variance can be heritable. For offspring traits, such as birth weight, this implies that within‐family variance in traits can vary among families and can thus be shaped by natural selection. Empirical evidence for this in wild populations is however lacking. We investigated whether within‐family variance in fledging weight is heritable in a wild great tit (Parus major) population and whether these differences are associated with fitness. We found significant evidence for genetic variance in within‐family variance. The genetic coefficient of variation (GCV) was 0.18 and 0.25, when considering fledging weight a parental or offspring trait, respectively. We found a significant quadratic relationship between within‐family variance and fitness: families with low or high within‐family variance had lower fitness than families with intermediate within‐family variance. Our results show that within‐family variance can respond to selection and provides evidence for stabilizing selection on within‐family variance.     

The effect of gametic-phase disequilibrium on the prediction of response to recurrent selection in plants

Selection reduces additive genetic variation by generating gametic-phase disequilibrium, a phenomenon largely ignored when predicting response in plant breeding programs. The development of gametic-phase disequilibrium is here taken into account when predicting the response to selection for various schemes of recurrent selection applicable to plant populations. A general program permits prediction of response to selection from schemes of recurrent selection in which two or more rounds of selection occur in each cycle. An example from Sugar Beet, with alternate rounds of half-sib and S1 family selection, is illustrated. It is shown that failure to take into account the effects of gametic-phase disequilibrium can result in substantial overestimation of the response to selection as well as to changes in rank of the merits of alternative breeding schemes. For a given scheme, ignoring gametic-phase disequilibrium has only small effects on defining the optimum allocation of plots and the numbers of families tested.     

Estimating heritability using family-pooled phenotypic and genotypic data: a simulation study applied to aquaculture

Estimating heritability based on individual phenotypic and genotypic measurements can be expensive and labour-intensive in commercial aquaculture breeding. Here, the feasibility of estimating heritability using within-family means of phenotypes and allelic frequencies was investigated. Different numbers of full-sib families and family sizes across ten generations with phenotypic and genotypic information on 10 K SNPs were analysed in ten replicates. Three scenarios, representing differing numbers of pools per family (one, two and five) were considered. The results showed that using one pool per family did not reliably estimate the heritability of family means. Using simulation parameters appropriate for aquaculture, at least 200 families of 60 progeny per family divided equally in two pools per family was required to estimate the heritability of family means effectively. Although application of five pools generated more within- and between- family relationships, it reduced the number of individuals per pool and increased within-family residual variation, hence, decreased the heritability of family means. Moreover, increasing the size of pools resulted in increasing the heritability of family means towards one. In addition, heritability of family mean estimates were higher than family heritabilities obtained from Falconer’s formula due to lower intraclass correlation estimate compared to the coefficient of relationship.Subject terms: Genome evolution     

Association between line per se and testcross performance for eight agronomic and quality traits in winter rye

Key message

We investigated associations between line per se and testcross performance in rye and suggested that selection for per se performance is valuable for several traits in multi-stage selection programs.

Abstract

Genotypic correlation between line per se and testcross performance is an important quantitative-genetic parameter for optimizing hybrid breeding programs. The main goal of this survey was to study the association of line per se and testcross performance at the phenotypic level. We used experimental data from the line per se and testcross performance of two segregating winter rye populations (A, B) with each of 220 progenies tested in six environments for eight agronomic and quality traits. Genotypic variances were considerably larger for per se than for testcross performance of all investigated traits resulting in higher heritabilities of the former in most instances. Genotypic correlations (r _g) between testcross and line per se performance decreased with increasing complexity of the trait as shown by the respective heritabilities. They were highest (r _g ≥ 0.7) for plant height and test weight in population B, and thousand-kernel weight, falling number and starch content in both populations. A selection of these traits for line per se performance in early generations will save field plots in further testing testcross performance and increase efficiency of hybrid breeding.