Various Levels of Cross-Resistance to Bacillus sphaericus Strains in Culex pipiens (Diptera: Culicidae) Colonies Resistant to B. sphaericus Strain 2362

We studied the cross-resistance to three highly toxic Bacillus sphaericus strains, IAB-59 (serotype H6), IAB-881 (serotype H3), and IAB-872 (serotype H48), of four colonies of the Culex pipiens complex resistant to B. sphaericus 2362 and 1593, both of which are serotype H5a5b strains. Two field-selected highly resistant colonies originating from India (KOCHI, 17,000-fold resistance) and France (SPHAE, 23,000-fold resistance) and a highly resistant laboratory-selected colony from California (GeoR, 36,000-fold resistance) showed strong cross-resistance to strains IAB-881 and IAB-872 but significantly weaker cross-resistance to IAB-59 (3- to 43-fold resistance). In contrast, a laboratory-selected California colony with low-level resistance (JRMM-R, 5-fold resistance) displayed similar levels of resistance (5- to 10-fold) to all of the B. sphaericus strains tested. Thus, among the mosquitocidal strains of B. sphaericus we identified a strain, IAB-59, which was toxic to several Culex colonies that were highly resistant to commercial strains 2362 and 1593. Our analysis also indicated that strain IAB-59 may possess other larvicidal factors. These results could have important implications for the development of resistance management strategies for area-wide mosquito control programs based on the use of B. sphaericus preparations.     

Various levels of cross-resistance to Bacillus sphaericus strains in Culex pipiens (Diptera: Culicidae) colonies resistant to B. sphaericus strain 2362.

We studied the cross-resistance to three highly toxic Bacillus sphaericus strains, IAB-59 (serotype H6), IAB-881 (serotype H3), and IAB-872 (serotype H48), of four colonies of the Culex pipiens complex resistant to B. sphaericus 2362 and 1593, both of which are serotype H5a5b strains. Two field-selected highly resistant colonies originating from India (KOCHI, 17,000-fold resistance) and France (SPHAE, 23,000-fold resistance) and a highly resistant laboratory-selected colony from California (GeoR, 36,000-fold resistance) showed strong cross-resistance to strains IAB-881 and IAB-872 but significantly weaker cross-resistance to IAB-59 (3- to 43-fold resistance). In contrast, a laboratory-selected California colony with low-level resistance (JRMM-R, 5-fold resistance) displayed similar levels of resistance (5- to 10-fold) to all of the B. sphaericus strains tested. Thus, among the mosquitocidal strains of B. sphaericus we identified a strain, IAB-59, which was toxic to several Culex colonies that were highly resistant to commercial strains 2362 and 1593. Our analysis also indicated that strain IAB-59 may possess other larvicidal factors. These results could have important implications for the development of resistance management strategies for area-wide mosquito control programs based on the use of B. sphaericus preparations.     

几株球形芽孢杆菌二元毒素基因的检测及对敏感和抗性尖音库蚊的毒性

根据Bacillus sphaericus 2362二元毒素基因核苷酸序列合成的一组寡聚核苷酸为引物,通过PCR扩增出1.1 kb的DNA片段作探针检测了C₃-41、IAB881、IAB872、BS-197和lPl-G菌株中二元毒素基因。Southern杂交表明C₃-41、IAB881、IAB872和BS-197菌株中3.5kb Hind III及LPl-G中4.7kb Hind III的酶切片段分别带有与探针有高度同源性的二元毒素基因。SDS-PAGE和Western印迹杂交表明所有菌株都能产生41.9kD和51.4kD的毒素蛋白。C₃.41、IAB881、BS.197和2362的全发酵液和碱抽提液对敏感尖音库蚊Culex pipienssubsp.Pipiens幼虫毒性高,但对抗性幼虫几乎无毒,LPl-G对敏感和抗性蚊幼虫具有相同的中度毒杀作用;IAB872对敏感幼虫毒性高,对抗性幼虫的毒力同LPl-G相似。这两株菌对抗性蚊幼虫的毒性可能是由Mtx毒素蛋白所导致的。     

A Strain of Bacillus sphaericus Causes Slower Development of Resistance in Culex quinquefasciatus

Two field-collected Culex quinquefasciatus colonies were subjected to selection pressure by three strains of Bacillus sphaericus, C3-41, 2362, and IAB59, under laboratory conditions. After 13 and 18 generations of exposure to high concentrations of C3-41 and IAB59, a field-collected low-level-resistant colony developed >144,000- and 46.3-fold resistance to strains C3-41 and IAB59, respectively. A field-collected susceptible colony was selected with 2362 and IAB59 for 46 and 12 generations and attained >162,000- and 5.7-fold resistance to the two agents, respectively. The pattern of resistance evolution in mosquitoes depended on continuous selection pressure, and the stronger the selection pressure, the more quickly resistance developed. The resistant colonies obtained after selection with B. sphaericus C3-41 and 2362 showed very high levels of cross-resistance to B. sphaericus 2362 and C3-41, respectively, but they displayed only low-level cross-resistance to IAB59. On the other hand, the IAB59-selected colonies had high cross-resistance to both strains C3-41 and 2362. Additionally, the slower evolution of resistance against strain IAB59 may be explained by the presence of another larvicidal factor. This is in agreement with the nontoxicity of the cloned and purified binary toxin (Bin1) of IAB59 for 2362-resistant larvae. We also verified that all the B. sphaericus-selected colonies showed no cross-resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis, suggesting that it would be a promising alternative in managing resistance to B. sphaericus in C. quinquefasciatus larvae.     

Selection of the most potent Bacillus sphaericus strains based on activity ratios determined on three mosquito species

Summary The larvicidal power of more than 180 Bacillus sphaericus strains belonging to six H serotypes has been assayed on Culex pipiens, Anopheles stephensi and Aedes aegypti under standardized conditions. The most potent strains are distributed into serotype H5a5b, generally toxic to the three mosquito species, and serotypes H6 and H25, toxic to C. pipiens and A. stephensi. Strains of serotypes 26a26b and H2a2b are much less toxic and most often only on C. pipiens. The relative potency of each strain can be expressed by specific titres on the different mosquito species and by activity ratios derived from such titres.     

Two Bacillus sphaericus binary toxins share the midgut receptor binding site: implications for resistance of Culex pipiens complex (Diptera: Culicidae) larvae

This work demonstrates that Bin1 and Bin2 toxins, produced by Bacillus sphaericus strains IAB59 and 2362, respectively, share a binding site in midgut brush border membranes (BBMF) from Culex pipiens complex larvae. However, a colony selected with strain IAB59, displaying a resistance ratio of only 42-fold to IAB59, but a 162,000-fold resistance to strain 2362, was found to miss receptors for Bin2 in the BBMF. This correlates with results showing that Bin1, produced in strain IAB59, failed to bind specifically to BBMF from other colony highly resistant to strain 2362. Data indicate the loss of the BBMF bound receptor as a general mechanism of resistance to binary toxins in mosquito.     

Properties and applied use of the mosquitocidal bacterium,Bacillus sphaericus

Strains of Bacillus sphaericus exhibit varying levels of virulence against mosquito larvae. The most potent strain, B. sphaericus 2362, which is the active ingredient in the commercial product VectoLex^®, together with another well-known larvicide Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis, is used to control vector and nuisance mosquito larvae in many regions of the world. Although not all strains of B. sphaericus are mosquitocidal, lethal strains produce one or two combinations of three different types of toxins. These are (1) the binary toxin (Bin) composed of two proteins of 42 kDa (BinA) and 51 kDa (BinB), which are synthesized during sporulation and co-crystallize, (2) the soluble mosquitocidal toxins (Mtx1, Mtx2 and Mtx3) produced during vegetative growth, and (3) the two-component crystal toxin (Cry48Aa1/Cry49Aa1). Non-mosquitocidal toxins are also produced by certain strains of B. sphaericus, for example sphaericolysin, a novel insecticidal protein toxic to cockroaches. Larvicides based on B. sphaericus-based have the advantage of longer persistence in treated habitats compared to B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis. However, resistance is a much greater threat, and has already emerged at significant levels in field populations in China and Thailand treated with B. sphaericus. This likely occurred because toxicity depends principally on Bin rather than various combinations of crystal (Cry) and cytolytic (Cyt) toxins present in B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis. Here we review both the general characteristics of B. sphaericus, particularly as they relate to larvicidal isolates, and strategies or considerations for engineering more potent strains of this bacterium that contain built-in mechanisms that delay or overcome resistance to Bin in natural mosquito populations.     

Contribution of S-Layer Proteins to the Mosquitocidal Activity of Lysinibacillus sphaericus

Lysinibacillus sphaericus strains belonging the antigenic group H5a5b produce spores with larvicidal activity against larvae of Culex mosquitoes. C7, a new isolated strain, which presents similar biochemical characteristics and Bin toxins in their spores as the reference strain 2362, was, however, more active against larvae of Culex mosquitoes. The contribution of the surface layer protein (S-layer) to this behaviour was envisaged since this envelope protein has been implicated in the pathogenicity of several bacilli, and we had previously reported its association to spores. Microscopic observation by immunofluorescence detection with anti S-layer antibody in the spores confirms their attachment. S-layers and BinA and BinB toxins formed high molecular weight multimers in spores as shown by SDS-PAGE and western blot detection. Purified S-layer from both L. sphaericus C7 and 2362 strain cultures was by itself toxic against Culex sp larvae, however, that from C7 strain was also toxic against Aedes aegypti. Synergistic effect between purified S-layer and spore-crystal preparations was observed against Culex sp. and Aedes aegypti larvae. This effect was more evident with the C7 strain. In silico analyses of the S-layer sequence suggest the presence of chitin-binding and hemolytic domains. Both biochemical characteristics were detected for both S-layers strains that must justify their contribution to pathogenicity.     

Effects of Bacillus sphaericus 1593 and 2362 spore/crystal toxin on cultured mosquito cells

An in vitro assay system for the toxin of Bacillus sphaericus strains 1593 and 2362 has been developed utilizing cultured Culex quinquefasciatus cells. The cytotoxic activity of extracts of B. sphaericus strain 1593 did not necessarily correlate with insecticidal activity. Cytotoxicity and larvicidal activity were neutralized by immune rabbit serum prepared against crude toxin extracts as well as by serum prepared against purified toxin from strain 2362. This purified toxin was also found to be cytotoxic. Activation with mosquito larval gut homogenates enhanced cytotoxicity of both 1593 extracts and purified toxin from 2362. The activity of cytotoxic preparations against three mosquito cell lines paralleled the activity of B. sphaericus spores against larvae of these mosquito species. The results suggest the presence of a protoxin and one or more cytotoxic proteins derived from it.     

Serological classification of Bacillus sphaericus strains on the basis of toxicity to mosquito larvae

Summary A toxicity study of 54 Bacillus sphaericus strains isolated from vectors or breeding sites has led to a relatively homogeneous grouping of mosquito pathogenic strains into five H-serotypes among the nine serotypes determined. Each serotype seems to be characterized by a different level of toxicity and a classification of these five serotypes can be made on the basis of this toxicity. Within these serotypes, a scale of toxicity has been tentatively fixed and an arbitrary limit of toxicity suggested.     

The Introduction into Bacillus sphaericus of the Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. medellin cyt1Ab1 Gene Results in Higher Susceptibility of Resistant Mosquito Larva Populations to B. sphaericus

The fragment containing the gene encoding the cytolytic Cyt1Ab1 protein from Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. medellin and its flanking sequences (I. Thiery, A. Delécluse, M. C. Tamayo, and S. Orduz, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 63:468–473, 1997) was introduced into Bacillus sphaericus toxic strains 2362, 2297, and Iab872 by electroporation with the shuttle vector pMK3. Only small amounts of the protein were produced in recombinant strains 2362 and Iab872. The protein was detected in these strains only by Western blotting and immunodetection with antibody raised against Cyt1Ab1 protein. Large amounts of Cyt1Ab1 protein were produced in B. sphaericus recombinant strain 2297, and there was an additional crystal, other than that of the binary toxin, within the exosporium. The production of the Cyt1Ab1 protein in addition to the binary toxin did not increase the larvicidal activity of the B. sphaericus recombinant strain against susceptible mosquito populations of Culex pipiens or Aedes aegypti. However, it partially restored (10 to 20 times) susceptibility of the resistant mosquito populations of C. pipiens (SPHAE) and Culex quinquefasciatus (GeoR) to the binary toxin. The Cyt1Ab1 protein produced in recombinant B. thuringiensis SPL407(pcyt1Ab1) was synthesized in two types of crystal—one round and with various dense areas, surrounded by an envelope, and the other a regular cuboid crystal, very similar to that found in the B. sphaericus recombinant strain.     

A strain of Bacillus sphaericus causes slower development of resistance in Culex quinquefasciatus

Two field-collected Culex quinquefasciatus colonies were subjected to selection pressure by three strains of Bacillus sphaericus, C3-41, 2362, and IAB59, under laboratory conditions. After 13 and 18 generations of exposure to high concentrations of C3-41 and IAB59, a field-collected low-level-resistant colony developed >144,000- and 46.3-fold resistance to strains C3-41 and IAB59, respectively. A field-collected susceptible colony was selected with 2362 and IAB59 for 46 and 12 generations and attained >162,000- and 5.7-fold resistance to the two agents, respectively. The pattern of resistance evolution in mosquitoes depended on continuous selection pressure, and the stronger the selection pressure, the more quickly resistance developed. The resistant colonies obtained after selection with B. sphaericus C3-41 and 2362 showed very high levels of cross-resistance to B. sphaericus 2362 and C3-41, respectively, but they displayed only low-level cross-resistance to IAB59. On the other hand, the IAB59-selected colonies had high cross-resistance to both strains C3-41 and 2362. Additionally, the slower evolution of resistance against strain IAB59 may be explained by the presence of another larvicidal factor. This is in agreement with the nontoxicity of the cloned and purified binary toxin (Bin1) of IAB59 for 2362-resistant larvae. We also verified that all the B. sphaericus-selected colonies showed no cross-resistance to Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis, suggesting that it would be a promising alternative in managing resistance to B. sphaericus in C. quinquefasciatus larvae.     

Expression of Binary Toxin Genes in the Mosquito-Colonizable Bacteria, <Emphasis Type="Italic">Bacillus cereus</Emphasis>, Leads to High Toxicity Against <Emphasis Type="Italic">Culex quinquefasciatus</Emphasis> Larvae

Two B. cereus strains, Ae10 and Cx5, isolated from mosquito larval guts, were transformed with a recombinant plasmid, pBS373, harboring binary toxin genes from Bacillus sphaericus 2297. Immunoblotting analysis clearly revealed the production and presence of the 51-kDa toxin protein in both strains. Two recombinant B. cereus strains Ae10 and Cx5 showed very high toxicity against C. quinquefasciatus larvae. Since both strains have a close relationship with the mosquito larvae in the native environment and are capable of recolonizing in the guts of mosquito larvae, these strains can be considered promising new hosts for an effective delivery of mosquito-larvicidal toxins.     

Effects of components of theBacillus sphaericus toxin on mosquito larvae and mosquito-derived tissue culture-grown cells

Bacillus sphaericus 2362 produces a parasporal crystal containing 42 and 51 kilodalton (kDa) proteins. Both of these proteins are required for toxicity to mosquito larvae; neither is toxic alone. When overexpressed inB. subtilis, these two proteins accumulate as amorphous inclusions (AIs). Bioassays involving larvae ofCulex pipiens and different ratios of these AIs indicated that maximal toxicity was observed at a ratio of approximately one 42-kDa protein to one 51-kDa protein. Purified preparations of these proteins, as well as derivatives similar to those which accumulate in the gut of mosquito larvae, were also toxic when combined, but not toxic singly. Different results were obtained when the toxicity of these preparations was tested for tissue culture-grown cells ofC. quinquefasciatus. Under these conditions, the 39-kDa derivative of the 42-kDa protein was alone sufficient for toxicity, which was not increased by the addition of the 51-kDa protein or its derivatives. These results indicate that theB. sphaericus larvicide acts as a binary toxin in mosquitos, whereas only the 39-kDa protein is required for full toxicity to tissue culture-grown cells.     

Bacillus sphaericus Mtx1 and Mtx2 toxins co-expressed in Escherichia coli are synergistic against Aedes aegypti larvae

Mtx1 and Mtx2 are mosquitocidal toxins produced by some strains of Bacillus sphaericus during vegetative phase of growth. Mtx1 from B. sphaericus 2297 shows higher toxicity against Culex quinquefasciatus larvae than to Aedes aegypti larvae whereas Mtx2 from B. sphaericus 2297 shows lower toxicity against C. quinquefasciatus than to A. aegypti larvae. To test synergism of these toxins against A. aegypti larvae, mtx1 and mtx2 genes were cloned into a single plasmid and expressed in Escherichia coli. Cells producing both Mtx1 and Mtx2 toxins exhibited high synergistic activity against A. aegypti larvae approximately 10 times compared to cells expressing only a single toxin. Co-expression of both toxins offers an alternative to improve efficacy of recombinant bacterial insecticides. There is a high possibility to develop these toxins to be used as an environmentally friendly mosquito control agent.     

Interpreting the SDS-PAGE protein patterns with self-organizing maps: application for the characterization of mosquito-pathogenic Bacillus strains

Aims: To present the pairwise comparison of potential mosquito‐pathogenic Bacillus strains based on their SDS‐PAGE protein patterns and to evaluate their characteristic toxicity patterns. Methods and Results: In this work, 20 Bacillus strains were subjected to qualitative toxicity tests against Aedes aegypti and Culex quinquefasciatus larvae. The selected strains were then characterized by SDS‐PAGE protein profiles. The highly heterogeneous multiple protein components of protein patterns were analysed using self‐organizing map (SOM), a ‘visualization and clustering’ tool. Members of mosquitocidal Bacillus species were classified in four distinct clusters, and then toxicity patterns were examined. Cluster (1, 1) comprised of three highly toxic strains of Bacillus sphaericus: SPH88, 1593 and KSD‐4; cluster (1, 2) consisted of two B. sphaericus strains: SSII‐1 and Bsp‐R that showed weak larvicidal activity; cluster (2, 1) constituted two B. sphaericus strains: WHO2297 and ISPC‐5 that possessed moderate toxicity; and cluster (2, 2) contained four B. thuringiensis ssp. israelensis strains: ONR‐60A, HD500, IPS70 and IPS82 belonging to serotype H14 but exhibited moderate to high mosquito larvicidal toxicity. Conclusions: SOM served as a colour‐coded alternate for easy visualization of similarities or dissimilarities between the strains even at the infra subspecies level. Furthermore, characteristic toxicity patterns of Bacillus strains of different clusters were determined. Significance and Impact of the Study: Analysis of electrophoretic protein patterns using SOM provides a better insight into the inter‐relationships of bacterial strains through similarity‐based clustering and pairwise comparison of two strains.     

Isolation of novel Bacillus species showing high mosquitocidal activity against several mosquito species

Two novel mosquitocidal bacteria, VB17 and VB24, identified as new Bacillus species were isolated from dead mosquito larvae obtained in Florida aquatic habitats. Gas chromatographic analysis of fatty acid methyl esters (GC-FAME) and 16S rRNA sequencing indicated that VB24 is closely related to Bacillus sphaericus whereas VB17 does not have a close relationship with either Bacillus thuringiensis or B. sphaericus. Both isolates were significantly more active than B. sphaericus 2362 against Aedes taeniorhynchus, Anopheles quadrimaculatus, Culex quinquefasciatus larvae, and as active as B. sphaericus 2362 against Anopheles gambiae. Interestingly, however, both were not active against Aedes aegypti larvae, indicating some level of insecticidal specificity.     

Characterization and toxicity to mosquito larvae of four Bacillus sphaericus strains isolated from Brazilian soils.

Four Bacillus sphaericus strains, S1, S2, S5, and L2, isolated from Brazilian soils, were found to be toxic to larvae of the mosquitoes Culex pipiens and Anopheles stephensi at a level similar to that of strain 2362 which is now used operationally. Like strain 2362, the four strains belonged to the serotype H5 and produced major proteins of apparent molecular weights of 125, 110, 56, and 43 kDa. These latter two proteins were immunologically related to toxins of the same molecular weight as B. sphaericus 2362. Although the four Brazilian strains were very similar to strain 2362, gas chromatography analysis of the fatty acids revealed that these strains were different from strain 2362 and from each other, except for a possible similarity between strains S1 and S5.     

A 1.1-Kilobase Region Downstream of the bin Operon in Bacillus sphaericus Strain 2362 Decreases Bin Yield and Crystal Size in Strain 2297

The 2297 strain of Bacillus sphaericus produces a crystal of the Bin (binary) toxin that is approximately fourfold larger than that of strain 2362, the strain currently used in VectoLex, a commercial mosquito larvicide. Comparison of the regions downstream from the bin operon in these two strains showed that strain 2362 contained a 1.6-kb region with four orf genes not found in strain 2297. Insertion of a 1.1-kb portion of this region from strain 2362 by homologous recombination downstream from the bin operon in strain 2297 reduced Bin toxin production by 50 to 70% and toxicity to fourth-instar larvae of Culex quinquefasciatus by 68%. These results suggest that the 1.6-kb region downstream from the bin operon in B. sphaericus 2362 is responsible for the lower Bin yield and smaller crystal size characteristic of this strain.     

Efficient expression of mosquito-larvicidal proteins in a gram-negative bacterium capable of recolonization in the guts of Anopheles dirus larva

The gram-negative bacterium, An11/2 G1, isolated from the guts of Anopheles dirus mosquito larvae, was identified as Enterobacter amnigenus. The E. amnigenus was able to recolonize in the gut of An. dirus larva but not in those of Aedes aegypti and Culex quinquefasciatus larvae. It was able to float in water for a longer period than Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. israelensis and Bacillus sphaericus. These are desirable characteristics for a delivery vehicle of mosquito-larvicidal toxins for the control of mosquito larvae, and E. amnigenus was therefore used as a host to express the cryIVB gene of B. thuringiensis subsp. israelensis and the binary toxin genes of B. sphaericus. The recombinant E. amnigenus produced a high level of CryIVB protein, which was toxic to larvae of Ae. aegypti and An. dirus. Another E. amnigenus producing the 51-kDa protein of B. sphaericus was toxic to larvae of An. dirus and Cx. quinquefasciatus. The recombinant plasmids were stable in E. amnigenus without the presence of selective pressure for at least 23 generations. The recombinant E. amnigenus should represent a desirable biological agent for controlling mosquito larvae. Received: 20 February 1998 / Received last revision: 5 October 1998 / Accepted: 11 October 1998