Metal-ion catalyzed polymerization in the eutectic phase in water-ice: a possible approach to template-directed RNA polymerization

The emergence of an RNA world requires among other processes the non-enzymatic, template-directed replication of genetic polymers such as RNA or related nucleic acids, possibly catalyzed by metal-ions. The absence of uridilate derivative polymerization on adenine containing templates has been the main issue preventing an efficient template-directed RNA polymerization. We report here the investigation of template-directed RNA polymerization in the eutectic phase in water–ice. In particular, it was found that activated uridilate monomers in the presence of metal-ion catalysts could efficiently elongate RNA hairpins whose 5′-overhangs served as the templating sequence. The same applies for every other pyrimidine and purine nucleobase. Moreover, the initial elongation rates were always higher in the presence of a template complementary to the nucleotide than in systems without proper base-pairing opportunities. These results suggest that a template-directed RNA polymerization catalyzed by metal-ions could be carried out under eutectic phase in water–ice conditions.     

The Origins of the RNA World

The general notion of an “RNA World” is that, in the early development of life on the Earth, genetic continuity was assured by the replication of RNA and genetically encoded proteins were not involved as catalysts. There is now strong evidence indicating that an RNA World did indeed exist before DNA- and protein-based life. However, arguments regarding whether life on Earth began with RNA are more tenuous. It might be imagined that all of the components of RNA were available in some prebiotic pool, and that these components assembled into replicating, evolving polynucleotides without the prior existence of any evolved macromolecules. A thorough consideration of this “RNA-first” view of the origin of life must reconcile concerns regarding the intractable mixtures that are obtained in experiments designed to simulate the chemistry of the primitive Earth. Perhaps these concerns will eventually be resolved, and recent experimental findings provide some reason for optimism. However, the problem of the origin of the RNA World is far from being solved, and it is fruitful to consider the alternative possibility that RNA was preceded by some other replicating, evolving molecule, just as DNA and proteins were preceded by RNA.     

Constructing an RNA world

A popular theory of life’s origins states that the first biocatalysts were not made of protein but were made of RNA or a very similar polymer. Experiments are beginning to confirm that the catalytic abilities of RNA are compatible with this ‘RNA world’ hypothesis. For example, RNA can synthesize short fragments of RNA in a template-directed fashion and promote formation of peptide, ester and glycosidic linkages. However, no known activity fully represents one presumed by the ‘RNA world’ theory, and reactions such as oxidation and reduction have yet to be demonstrated. Filling these gaps would place the hypothesis on much firmer ground and provide components for building minimal forms of RNA-based cellular life.     

Constructing an RNA world

A popular theory of life’s origins states that the first biocatalysts were not made of protein but were made of RNA or a very similar polymer. Experiments are beginning to confirm that the catalytic abilities of RNA are compatible with this ‘RNA world’ hypothesis. For example, RNA can synthesize short fragments of RNA in a template-directed fashion and promote formation of peptide, ester and glycosidic linkages. However, no known activity fully represents one presumed by the ‘RNA world’ theory, and reactions such as oxidation and reduction have yet to be demonstrated. Filling these gaps would place the hypothesis on much firmer ground and provide components for building minimal forms of RNA-based cellular life.     

Constructing an RNA world

A popular theory of life’s origins states that the first biocatalysts were not made of protein but were made of RNA or a very similar polymer. Experiments are beginning to confirm that the catalytic abilities of RNA are compatible with this ‘RNA world’ hypothesis. For example, RNA can synthesize short fragments of RNA in a template-directed fashion and promote formation of peptide, ester and glycosidic linkages. However, no known activity fully represents one presumed by the ‘RNA world’ theory, and reactions such as oxidation and reduction have yet to be demonstrated. Filling these gaps would place the hypothesis on much firmer ground and provide components for building minimal forms of RNA-based cellular life.     

Intramolecular RNA replicase: Possibly the first self-replicating molecule in the RNA world

Although there is more and more evidence suggested the existence of an RNA World during the origin of life, the scenario concerning the origin of the RNA World remains blurry. Usually it is speculated that it originated from a prebiotic nucleotide pool, during which a self-replicating RNA synthesis ribozyme may have emerged as the first ribozyme – the RNA replicase. However, there is yet no ersuasive supposition for the mechanism for the self-favouring feature of the replicase, thus the speculation remains unconvincing. Here we suggest that intramolecular catalysis is a possible solution. Two RNA synthesis ribozymes may be integrated into one RNA molecule, as two functional domains which could catalyze the copy of each other. Thus the RNA molecule could self-replicate and be referred to as “intramolecular replicase“ here. Computational simulation to get insight into the dynamic mechanism of emergence of the intramolecular replicase from a nucleotide pool is valuable and would be included in a following work of our group.     

6 Crystal structure studies of RNA molecules containing 2′–5′-linkages

RNA can play dual roles as a carrier of genetic information and as a catalyst of specific reactions, and it may have been the first biopolymer to have emerged on the early earth. The non-enzymatic replication of RNA was likely a key step in the evolution of simple cellular life from prebiotic chemistry. In the current model of template-directed polymerization of activated monomers, the chemical copying of RNA always generates a mixture of 3′–5′ and 2′–5′ backbone linkages due to the similar nucleophilicity and orientation of the 2′ and 3′ hydroxyl groups on the ribose. This lack of regiospecificity has been regarded as a central problem for the evolution of functional RNAs, since the resulting backbone heterogeneity was expected to disrupt their folding, molecular recognition and catalytic properties of functional RNAs such as ribozymes. However, a recent study from our lab has demonstrated that RNAs with a certain percentage of 2′–5′ linkages can still retain RNA functions, for example, in a FMN-binding aptamer and a hammerhead ribozyme system. More interestingly, it has been known for a long time that 2′–5′ linkages can reduce the melting temperature of RNA duplexes, making it easier to separate the strands. Although the detailed mechanism is still not clear, considering that strand separation is another unsolved big problem for non-enzymatic RNA replication, this feature may actually afford a selective advantage to duplexes exhibiting backbone heterogeneity. In addition, previous studies have revealed that 2′–5′ linkages in a RNA duplex are more easily hydrolyzed compared to normal 3′–5′ linkages. Thus, there is a selective advantage for the evolution of homogeneous RNA systems with more accurate replication. Altogether, the coexistence of 2′–5′ and 3′–5′ linkages may be a central feature that allowed RNA to play a central role in the original stage of life. In this work, we will present several X-ray crystal structures of RNA duplexes and an aptamer that contain 2′–5′ linkages. These structures help us to understand how RNA can adjust its structure to accommodate the backbone heterogeneity.     

Peptide nucleic acids and the origin of life

The possibilities of pseudo-peptide-DNA mimics like PNA (peptide nucleic acid) having a role for the prebiotic origin of life prior to an RNA world is discussed on the basis of literature data showing that this type of molecules might have formed on the primitive earth (or other places in the universe), as well as data indicating the possibilities of template-directed PNA chemical replication and ligation. In particular, the merits of an achiral prebiotic genetic material is discussed.     

Nucleotide synthetase ribozymes may have emerged first in the RNA world

Though the "RNA world" hypothesis has gained a central role in ideas concerning the origin of life, the scenario concerning its emergence remains uncertain. It has been speculated that the first scene may have been the emergence of a template-dependent RNA synthetase ribozyme, which catalyzed its own replication: thus, "RNA replicase." However, the speculation remains uncertain, primarily because of the large sequence length requirement of such a replicase and the lack of a convincing mechanism to ensure its self-favoring features. Instead, we propose a nucleotide synthetase ribozyme as an alternative candidate, especially considering recent experimental evidence suggesting the possibility of effective nonenzymatic template-directed synthesis of RNA. A computer simulation was conducted to support our proposal. The conditions for the emergence of the nucleotide synthetase ribozyme are discussed, based on dynamic analysis on a computer. We suggest the template-dependent RNA synthetase ribozyme emerged later, perhaps after the emergence of protocells.     

Non-enzymatic, template-directed ligation of 2'-5' oligoribonucleotides. Joining of a template and a ligator strand.

Decauridylate containing exclusively a 2'-5' phospho-diester bond ([2'-5']U10) served as a template for the synthesis of oligoadenylates [oligo(A)s] from the 5'-phosphorimidazolide of 2'-5' diadenylate (ImpA-2'p5'A). Joining of [2'-5']U10and ImpA2'p5'A also took place in substantial amounts to yield long-chain oligoribonucleotides in the template-directed reaction. An unusual CD spectrum ascribed to helix formation between [2'-5']U10and [2'-5'](pA)2was observed under the same conditions as that of the template-directed reaction. The 3'-5' linked decauridylate ([3'-5']U10) also promoted the template-directed synthesis of oligo(A)s from ImpA2'p5'A, but more slowly compared with [2'-5']U10. The results indicate that short-chain RNA oligomers with a 2'-5' phosphodiester bond could lead to longer oligoribonucleotides by template-directed chain elongation.     

Template-directed chemistry and the origins of the RNA world

Prompted by the growing number of reports about reactions catalyzed by ribozymes, this paper summarizes mechanistic and kinetic aspects of template-directed (TD) chemistry important for the synthesis of a diverse population of polynucleotides and analogues possibly up to 100 units long. Assuming that this chemistry takes place in a microenvironment conducive to life under the constant influx of mM concentrations of activated monomeric building blocks, the proposed scenario represents a working hypothesis for the prebiotic synthesis of the RNA world.

     

Template-directed primer extension catalyzed by the Tetrahymena ribozyme.

The Tetrahymena ribozyme has been shown to catalyze an RNA polymerase-like reaction in which an RNA primer is extended by the sequential addition of pN nucleotides derived from GpN dinucleotides, where N = A, C, or U. Here, we show that this reaction is influenced by the presence of a template; bases that can form Watson-Crick base pairs with a template add as much as 25-fold more efficiently than mismatched bases. A mutant enzyme with an altered guanosine binding site can catalyze template-directed primer extension with all four bases when supplied with dinucleotides of the form 2-aminopurine-pN.     

The Fidelity of Template-Directed Oligonucleotide Ligation and the Inevitability of Polymerase Function

The first living systems may have employed template-directed oligonucleotide ligation for replication. The utility of oligonucleotide ligation as a mechanism for the origin and evolution of life is in part dependent on its fidelity. We have devised a method for evaluating ligation fidelity in which ligation substrates are selected from random sequence libraries. The fidelities of chemical and enzymatic ligation are compared under a variety of conditions. While reaction conditions can be found that promote high fidelity copying, departure from these conditions leads to error-prone copying. In particular, ligation reactions with shorter oligonucleotide substrates are less efficient but more faithful. These results support a model for origins in which there was selective pressure for template-directed oligonucleotide ligation to be gradually supplanted by mononucleotide polymerization.     

The Importance of Stochastic Transitions for the Origin of Life

We discuss the origin of life in terms of an RNA World scenario in which the creation of autocatalytic sequences is the key step. Our computational models illustrate that life arises by a rare stochastic event that occurs due to spatially localized concentration fluctuations. This allows the chemical system to jump from a non-living state with very low ribozyme concentration to a living state that is controlled by ribozymes. Once the living state is established locally, it can spread deterministically through the rest of the system. These are generic features also possessed by more complex models with a greater degree of chemical realism.     

Template-directed photoligation of oligodeoxyribonucleotides via 4-thiothymidine.

Non-enzymatic, template-directed ligation of oligonucleotides in aqueous solution has been of great interest because of its potential synthetic and biomedical utility and implications for the origin of life. Though there are many methods for template-directed chemical ligation of oligonucleotides, there are only three reported photochemical methods. In the first report, template-directed photoligation was effected by cyclobutane dimer formation between the 5'- and 3'-terminal thymidines of two oligonucleotides with >290 nm light, which also damages DNA itself. To make the photochemistry of native DNA more selective, we have replaced the thymidine at the 5'-end of one oligonucleotide with 4-thiothymidine (s4T) and show that it photoreacts at 366 nm with a T at the 3'-endof another oligonucleotide in the presence of a complementary template. When a single mismatch is introduced opposite either the s4T or its adjoining T, the ligation efficiency drops by a factor of five or more. We also show that by linking the two ends of the oligonucleotides together, photoligation can be used to form circular DNA molecules and to 'photopadlock' circular DNA templates. Thus, s4T-mediated photo-ligation may have applications to phototriggered antisense-based or antigene-based genetic tools, diagnostic agents and drugs, especially for those situations in which chemical or enzyme-mediated ligation isundesirable or impossible, for example inside a cell.     

Monte Carlo simulation of early molecular evolution in the RNA World

The origin of life remains a highly speculative field, mainly due to the shortage of our knowledge on prebiotic chemistry and basic understanding on the essence of life. In this context, computer simulation is expected to play an important role. For instance, the scenario concerning the genesis of the widely accepted RNA World remains blurry, though we have gathered some circumstantial evidence and fragmented knowledge on several supposed stages, including formation of polynucleotides from a prebiotic nucleotide pool, emergence of RNA replicases (RNA molecules catalyzing their own replication), and evolution of RNA replicases. It is highly valuable to simulate the stages as a continuous process to evaluate the plausibility of the supposition and study the rules involved. Here we construct a computer simulation on the process using Monte Carlo method. It demonstrates that primordial RNA replicases may appear and spread in a nucleotide pool provided they could recognize their own sequence and their complements as catalytic targets, and then may evolve to more efficient RNA replicases. Apart from its indication on the genesis of the RNA World, the vivid simulation of emergence of the “first replicative molecules” and their subsequent evolution is impressive and may help to get insight into “how could self-replication and Darwinian evolution, two key features of life, emerge in a non-life background?” thus improve our understanding of “what is life” when studying origins of life.     

Synthesis of pyrophosphates for in vitro selection of catalytic RNA molecules

Reported here are synthetic routes to pyrophosphates linking riboflavin with various nucleosides. The focus is on a flavin-uracil dinucleotide having a biotin tag on the uracil, a molecule that has potential value in the selection of RNA enzymes that catalyze the template-directed polymerization of RNA in the 3'-to-5' direction, which is the direction opposite that catalyzed by standard protein polymerases. Two detailed procedures are presented to prepare this new compound, as well as one procedure to prepare the new flavin-2,6-diaminopurine dinucleotide.     

On the origin of DNA genomes: evolution of the division of labor between template and catalyst in model replicator systems

The division of labor between template and catalyst is a fundamental property of all living systems: DNA stores genetic information whereas proteins function as catalysts. The RNA world hypothesis, however, posits that, at the earlier stages of evolution, RNA acted as both template and catalyst. Why would such division of labor evolve in the RNA world? We investigated the evolution of DNA-like molecules, i.e. molecules that can function only as template, in minimal computational models of RNA replicator systems. In the models, RNA can function as both template-directed polymerase and template, whereas DNA can function only as template. Two classes of models were explored. In the surface models, replicators are attached to surfaces with finite diffusion. In the compartment models, replicators are compartmentalized by vesicle-like boundaries. Both models displayed the evolution of DNA and the ensuing division of labor between templates and catalysts. In the surface model, DNA provides the advantage of greater resistance against parasitic templates. However, this advantage is at least partially offset by the disadvantage of slower multiplication due to the increased complexity of the replication cycle. In the compartment model, DNA can significantly delay the intra-compartment evolution of RNA towards catalytic deterioration. These results are explained in terms of the trade-off between template and catalyst that is inherent in RNA-only replication cycles: DNA releases RNA from this trade-off by making it unnecessary for RNA to serve as template and so rendering the system more resistant against evolving parasitism. Our analysis of these simple models suggests that the lack of catalytic activity in DNA by itself can generate a sufficient selective advantage for RNA replicator systems to produce DNA. Given the widespread notion that DNA evolved owing to its superior chemical properties as a template, this study offers a novel insight into the evolutionary origin of DNA.     

How the discovery of ribozymes cast RNA in the roles of both chicken and egg in origin-of-life theories

Scientific theories about the origin-of-life theories have historically been characterized by the chicken-and-egg problem of which essential aspect of life was the first to appear, replication or self-sustenance. By the 1950s the question was cast in molecular terms and DNA and proteins had come to represent the carriers of the two functions. Meanwhile, RNA, the other nucleic acid, had played a capricious role in origin theories. Because it contained building blocks very similar to DNA, biologists recognized early that RNA could store information in its linear sequences. With the discovery in the 1980s that RNA molecules were capable of biological catalysis, a function hitherto ascribed to proteins alone, RNA took on the role of the single entity that could act as both chicken and egg. Within a few years of the discovery of these catalytic RNAs (ribozymes) scientists had formulated an RNA World hypothesis that posited an early phase in the evolution of life where all key functions were performed by RNA molecules. This paper traces the history the role of RNA in origin-of-life theories with a focus on how the discovery of ribozymes influenced the discourse.