Techniques for studying protein heterogeneity and post-translational modifications

Proteins often undergo several post-translational modification steps in parallel to protein folding. These modifications can be transient or of a more permanent nature. Most modifications are, however, susceptible to alteration during the lifespan of proteins. Post-translational modifications thus generate variability in proteins that are far beyond that provided by the genetic code. Co- and post-translational modifications can convert the 20 specific codon-encoded amino acids into more than 100 variant amino acids with new properties. These, and a number of other modifications, can considerably increase the information content and functional repertoire of proteins, thus making their analysis of paramount importance for diagnostic and basic research purposes. Various methods used in proteomics, such as 2D gel electrophoresis, 2D liquid chromatography, mass spectrometry, affinity-based analytical methods, interaction analyses, ligand blotting techniques, protein crystallography and structure–function predictions, are all applicable for the analysis of these numerous secondary modifications. In this review, examples of some of these techniques in studying the heterogeneity of proteins are highlighted. In the future, these methods will become increasingly useful in biomarker searches and in clinical diagnostics.     

Rapid identification of proteins by peptide-mass fingerprinting

BACKGROUND: Developments in 'soft' ionisation techniques have revolutionized mass-spectro-metric approaches for the analysis of protein structure. For more than a decade, such techniques have been used, in conjuction with digestion b specific proteases, to produce accurate peptide molecular weight 'fingerprints' of proteins. These fingerprints have commonly been used to screen known proteins, in order to detect errors of translation, to characterize post-translational modifications and to assign diulphide bonds. However, the extent to which peptide-mass information can be used alone to identify unknown sample proteins, independent of other analytical methods such as protein sequence analysis, has remained largely unexplored. RESULTS: We report here on the development of the molecular weight search (MOWSE) peptide-mass database at the SERC Daresbury Laboratory. Practical experience has shown that sample proteins can be uniquely identified from a few as three or four experimentally determined peptide masses when these are screened against a fragment database that is derived from over 50 000 proteins. Experimental errors of a few Daltons are tolerated by the scoring algorithms, thus permitting the use of inexpensive time-of-flight mass spectrometers. As with other types of physical data, such as amino-acid composition or linear sequence, peptide masses provide a set of determinants that are sufficiently discriminating to identify or match unknown sample proteins. CONCLUSION: Peptide-mass fingerprints can prove as discriminating as linear peptide sequences, but can be obtained in a fraction of the time using less protein. In many cases, this allows for a rapid identification of a sample protein before committing it to protein sequence analysis. Fragment masses also provide information, at the protein level, that is complementary to the information provided by large-scale DNA sequencing or mapping projects.     

Proteomics studies of post-translational modifications in plants

Post-translational modifications of proteins greatly increase protein complexity and dynamics, co-ordinating the intricate regulation of biological events. The global identification of post-translational modifications is a difficult task that is currently accelerated by advances in proteomics techniques. There has been significant development in sample preparation methods and mass spectrometry instrumentation. To reduce the complexity and to increase the amount of modified proteins available for analysis, proteins are usually subjected to prefractionation such as chromatographic purification and affinity enrichment. In this review, the post-translational modification studies in plants are summarized. The sample preparation strategies applied to each study are also described. These include affinity-based enrichment methods, immobilized metal affinity chromatography and immunoprecipitation used for phosphorylation and ubiquitination studies, respectively, and the phase partitioning approach for glycosylphosphatidylinositol modification studies.     

Analysis of recombinat glycoproteins by mass spectrometry

The advent of new technologies for analysis of biopolymers by mass spectrometry has revolutionised strategies for recombinant protein characterization. The principal recent developments have been matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Using these tools, accurate molecular mass determinations can now be obtained routinely-often using minute (picomole-femtomole) quantities of protein or protein fragments. These techniques have proved indispensible for detailed characterization of the post-translational modifications of recombinant proteins produced by eukaryotic systems. Glycosylation is arguably the most important and complex of these modifications and has prompted widespread use of these new techniques. In this mini-review article I describe recent advances in the use of mass spectrometry for analysis of recombinant glycoproteins.     

Analysis of sporamin forms expressed in different subcellular compartments of transgenic tobacco plants by IMAC and ESI-MS

Various forms of sporamin (spo, Δpro, ΔproHDEL and spoHDEL) corresponding to different targetings within the plant cell, respectively, to the vacuole, the extracellular compartment and the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) for the last two were used as model proteins to study further structural modifications. These proteins were expressed in tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum L. cv. PB D6), purified by immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography (IMAC) and then analyzed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Conformational and post-translational modifications were observed between these different forms of sporamin, extracted from leaves. By the combination of these two techniques, detection of discrete intermediate species was achieved. Three distinct entities were detected for the vacuolar form of sporamin (spo) indicating a two-step processing of the protein, while only one entity, shorter by two amino-acids at its N-terminus, was detected for the extracellular form of sporamin (Δpro). The analysis of sporamin forms with an HDEL amino-acid extension can not be deduced easily from MS data and may reflect post-translational modifications distinct from proteolytic processing. Thus post-translational modifications appear to be closely related to targeting within the plant cell.     

Construction and application of a yeast surface-displayed human cDNA library to identify post-translational modification-dependent protein-protein interactions

Although post-translational modifications such as phosphorylation mediate fundamental biological processes within the cell, relatively few methods exist that allow proteome-wide identification of proteins that interact with these modifications. We constructed a yeast surface-displayed human cDNA library and utilized it to identify protein fragments with affinity for phosphorylated peptides derived from the major tyrosine autophosphorylation sites of the epidermal growth factor receptor or focal adhesion kinase. We identified cDNAs encoding the Src homology 2 domains from adapter protein APS, phosphoinositide 3-kinase regulatory subunit 3, SH2B, and tensin, demonstrating the effectiveness of this approach. Our results suggest that large libraries of functional human protein fragments can be efficiently displayed on the yeast surface. In addition to the analysis of post-translational modifications, yeast surface-displayed human cDNA libraries have many potential applications, including identifying targets and defining potential cross-reactive proteins for small molecules or drugs.     

Combined 2D electrophoretic approaches for the study of white lupin mature seed storage proteome

Seed proteome analysis by 2D IEF/SDS-PAGE techniques is challenging for the intrinsic difficulties related to quantitative disparity of the seed proteins, i.e. storage and non-storage proteins, their polymorphic nature, the extensive post-translational modifications and the paucity of deposited primary structures available. Conversely, 2D maps of seed proteomes can be extremely useful for a number of fundamental and applied investigations. In this work, we have used a combination of two experimental approaches to identify the main protein components of an emerging protein-rich legume seed, that is white lupin seed (Lupinus albus, L.). One is the canonical proteomic approach including 2D electrophoretic separation and mass spectrometry of selected trypsin-digested polypeptides; the other approach is a group comparative 2D electrophoretic analysis of cotyledonary protein families. To this second purpose, the three main families of lupin seed proteins, namely alpha-conglutins, the 11S globulin fraction, beta-conglutins, the 7S globulin fraction, and gamma-conglutin, a basic 7S protein, were isolated by conventional biochemical techniques and their 2D reference maps were compared with the total protein map. With the first approach 37 out of 40 spots, making up about 35% of total spot volumes in the 2D map, were found to belong to the main seed protein families. Thanks to cDNA-deduced lupin storage protein sequences, determined on purpose and deposited, most of the identification statistical parameters were very good. Moreover, it was possible to identify several endogenously proteolysed subunits in the map. The second comparative approach, beside confirming these attributions, allowed to allocate 124 polypeptides within the three main lupin protein families. These two approaches proved to be mutually validating and their combined use was effective for the establishment of a seed proteome map even in the case of sequence and protein post-translational processing lack of information. The results obtained also extend our knowledge of the seed storage protein polymorphism of white lupin.     

Towards the analysis of protein species: an overview about strategies and methods

The deciphering of the relationship between function and exact chemical composition of a defined protein species in the context of the proteome is one of the major challenges in proteomics and molecular cell physiology. In the Special Issue of Amino Acids about the analysis of protein species current approaches are reviewed and new methods described focusing on the investigation of protein species. On the basis of the articles in this Special Issue it can be summarized that first important and promising steps towards the comprehensive analysis of protein species have been done. It is already possible to obtain full (100%) sequence coverage of proteins by mass spectrometry, if the amount of proteins available for their analysis allows their proteolytic degradation by more than one protease and the subsequent mass spectrometric analysis of the resulting peptides. Employing affinity chromatography helps to analyse proteins with defined post-translational modifications thus opening a targeted view on e.g. the phosphoproteome. In the future the aim to identify the exact chemical composition including not one but every posttranslational modification and complete sequence coverage on the protein species level should be achievable with further progress in sample preparation techniques, especially concerning separation techniques on the protein level, mass spectrometry and algorithms for mass spectrometric data processing. For determining the function of defined protein species a closer cooperation between cell biologists and proteomics experts is desirable.     

Consequences of post-translational modifications on amyloid proteins as revealed by protein semisynthesis

Alterations to the global levels of certain types of post-translational modifications (PTMs) are commonly observed in neurodegenerative diseases. The net influence of these PTM changes to the progression of these diseases can be deduced from cellular and animal studies. However, at the molecular level, how one PTM influences a given protein is not uniform and cannot be easily generalized from systemic observations, thus requiring protein-specific interrogations. Given that protein aggregation is a shared pathological hallmark in neurodegeneration, it is important to understand how these PTMs affect the behavior of amyloid-forming proteins. For this purpose, protein semisynthesis techniques, largely via native chemical and expressed protein ligation, have been widely used. These approaches have thus far led to our increased understanding of the site-specific consequences of certain PTMs to amyloidogenic proteins’ endogenous function, their propensity for aggregation, and the structural variations these PTMs induce toward the aggregates formed.     

High-throughput mass spectrometric discovery of protein post-translational modifications.

The availability of genome sequences, affordable mass spectrometers and high-resolution two-dimensional gels has made possible the identification of hundreds of proteins from many organisms by peptide mass fingerprinting. However, little attention has been paid to how information generated by these means can be utilised for detailed protein characterisation. Here we present an approach for the systematic characterisation of proteins using mass spectrometry and a software tool FindMod. This tool, available on the internet at http://www.expasy.ch/sprot/findmod.html , examines peptide mass fingerprinting data for mass differences between empirical and theoretical peptides. Where mass differences correspond to a post-translational modification, intelligent rules are applied to predict the amino acids in the peptide, if any, that might carry the modification. FindMod rules were constructed by examining 5153 incidences of post-translational modifications documented in the SWISS-PROT database, and for the 22 post-translational modifications currently considered (acetylation, amidation, biotinylation, C-mannosylation, deamidation, flavinylation, farnesylation, formylation, geranyl-geranylation, gamma-carboxyglutamic acids, hydroxylation, lipoylation, methylation, myristoylation, N -acyl diglyceride (tripalmitate), O-GlcNAc, palmitoylation, phosphorylation, pyridoxal phosphate, phospho-pantetheine, pyrrolidone carboxylic acid, sulphation) a total of 29 different rules were made. These consider which amino acids can carry a modification, whether the modification occurs on N-terminal, C-terminal or internal amino acids, and the type of organisms on which the modification can be found. We illustrate the utility of the approach with proteins from 2-D gels of Escherichia coli and sheep wool, where post-translational modifications predicted by FindMod were confirmed by MALDI post-source decay peptide fragmentation. As the approach is amenable to automation, it presents a potentially large-scale means of protein characterisation in proteome projects.     

组蛋白翻译后修饰技术研究进展

翻译后修饰调控着真核生物大部分蛋白质的活性,这些修饰的解读对研究生物功能是必不可少的。组蛋白翻译后修饰是蛋白质翻译后修饰中研究的较好一类小分子碱性蛋白,易被各种生物大分子修饰,尤其易发生在N-末端的尾部。不同组合式修饰构成了"组蛋白密码",在细胞的发育、生长、分化和动态平衡中,组蛋白密码影响着染色体的结构状态,进而调控基因的表达状态。组蛋白翻译后修饰的研究可作为一种模式来解析蛋白质复杂的修饰状态及研究其分子功能。翻译后修饰分析技术的发展对组蛋白密码的解析是至关重要的。重点讨论组蛋白修饰分析技术的发展和应用。     

Surface accessibility of protein post-translational modifications

Protein post-translational modifications are crucial to the function of many proteins. In this study, we have investigated the structural environment of 8378 incidences of 44 types of post-translational modifications with 19 different approaches. We show that modified amino acids likely to be involved in protein-protein interactions, such as ester-linked phosphorylation, methylarginine, acetyllysine, sulfotyrosine, hydroxyproline, and hydroxylysine, are clearly surface associated. Other modifications, including O-GlcNAc, phosphohistidine, 4-aspartylphosphate, methyllysine, and ADP-ribosylarginine, are either not surface associated or are in a protein's core. Artifactual modifications were found to be randomly distributed throughout the protein. We discuss how the surface accessibility of post-translational modifications can be important for protein-protein interactivity.     

Electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry of intact intrinsic membrane proteins.

Membrane proteins drive and mediate many essential cellular processes making them a vital section of the proteome. However, the amphipathic nature of these molecules ensures their detailed structural analysis remains challenging. A versatile procedure for effective electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) of intact intrinsic membrane proteins purified using reverse-phase chromatography in aqueous formic acid/isopropanol is presented. The spectra of four examples, bacteriorhodopsin and its apoprotein from Halobacterium and the D1 and D2 reaction-center subunits from spinach thylakoids, achieve mass measurements that are within 0.01% of calculated theoretical values. All of the spectra reveal lesser quantities of other molecular species that can usually be equated with covalently modified subpopulations of these proteins. Our analysis of bovine rhodopsin, the first ESI-MS study of a G-protein coupled receptor, yielded a complex spectrum indicative of extensive molecular heterogeneity. The range of masses measured for the native molecule agrees well with the range calculated based upon variable glycosylation and reveals further heterogeneity arising from other covalent modifications. The technique described represents the most precise way to catalogue membrane proteins and their post-translational modifications. Resolution of the components of protein complexes provides insights into native protein/protein interactions. The apparent retention of structure by bacteriorhodopsin during the analysis raises the potential of obtaining tertiary structure information using more developed ESI-MS experiments.     

Site-selective glycosylation of proteins: creating synthetic glycoproteins

In higher organisms, the functions of many proteins are modulated by post-translational modifications (PTMs). Glycosylation is by far the most diverse of the PTM processes. Natural protein production methods typically produce PTM or glycoform mixtures within which function is difficult to dissect or control. Chemical tagging methods allow the precise attachment of multiple glycosylation modifications to bacterially expressed (bare) protein scaffolds, allowing reconstitution of functionally effective mimics of glycoproteins in higher organisms. In this way combining chemical control of PTM with readily available protein scaffolds provides a systematic platform for creating probes of protein-PTM interactions. This protocol describes the modification of Cys residues in proteins using glycomethanethiosulfonates and glycoselenenylsulfides and the modification of azidohomoalanine residues, introduced by Met replacement using auxotrophic Met(-) Escherichia coli strains, with glycoalkynes and the combination of these techniques for the creation of dual-tagged proteins. Each glycosylation procedure outlined in this protocol can be achieved in half a day.     

Applications of Genetic Code Expansion in Studying Protein Post-translational Modification

Various post-translational modifications can naturally occur on proteins, regulating the activity, subcellular localization, interaction, or stability of the proteins. However, it can be challenging to decipher the biological implication or physiological roles of site-specific modifications due to their dynamic and sub-stoichiometric nature. Genetic code expansion method, relying on an orthogonal aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase/tRNA pair, enables site-specific incorporation of non-canonical amino acids. Here we focus on the application of genetic code expansion to study site-specific protein post-translational modification in vitro and in vivo. After a brief introduction, we discuss possibilities of incorporating non-canonical amino acids containing post-translational modifications or their mimics into target proteins. This approach is applicable for Ser/Thr/Tyr phosphorylation, Tyr sulfation/nitration/hydroxylation, Lys acetylation/acylation, Lys/His mono-methylation, as well as Arg citrullination. The next section describes the use of a precursor non-canonical amino acid followed by chemical and/or enzymatic reactions to afford the desired modification, such as Cys/Lys acylation, ubiquitin and ubiquitin-like modifications, as well as Lys/Gln methylation. We also discuss means for functional regulation of enzymes involving in post-translational modifications through genetically incorporated non-canonical amino acids. Lastly, the limitations and perspectives of genetic code expansion in studying protein post-translational modification are described.     

Comparative profiling of the mammalian mitochondrial proteome: multiple aconitase-2 isoforms including N-formylkynurenine modifications as part of a protein biomarker signature for reactive oxidative species

The activity of mitochondria induces, as a byproduct, a variety of post-translational modifications in associated proteins, which have functional downstream consequences for processes such as apoptosis, autophagy, and plasticity; e.g., reactive oxygen species (ROS), which induce N-formyl-kynurenine from oxidized tryptophans in certain mitochondrial proteins which are localized in close spatial proximity to their source. This type of fast molecular changes has profound influence on cell death and survival with implications in a number of pathologies. The quantitative and differential analysis of bovine heart mitochondria by four 2D-PAGE methods, including 2D-PAGE with high-resolution IEF as first dimension, revealed that due to limited resolution, those methods employing blue native-, tricine-urea-, and 16-BAC-PAGE as the first dimension are less applicable for the differential quantitative analysis of redundant protein spots which might give insight into post-translational modifications that are relevant in age- and stress-related changes. Moreover, 2D-PAGE with high resolution IEF was able to resolve a surprisingly large number of membrane proteins from mitochondrial preparations. For aconitase-2, an enzyme playing an important role in mitochondrial aging, a more thorough molecular analysis of all separable isoforms was performed, leading to the identification of two particular N-formylkynurenine modifications. Next to protein redundancy, native protein-protein interactions, with the potential of relating certain post-translational modification patterns to distinct oligomeric states, e.g., oxidative phosphorylation super complexes, might provide novel and (patho-) physiologically relevant information. Among proteins identified, 14 new proteins (GenBank entries), previously not associated with mitochondria, were found.     

Two-dimensional reference map of Agrobacterium tumefaciens proteins

Proteomics based on two-dimensional (2-D) gel electrophoresis of proteins followed by spot identification with mass spectrometry is a commonly used method for physiological studies. Physiological proteomics requires 2-D reference maps, on which most of the main proteins are identified. We present a reference map for the bacterial plant pathogen Agrobacterium tumefaciens proteins, which contains more than 300 entries with an isoelectric point (pI) between 4 and 7. The quantitative study of the proteins in the analytical window of the master gel demonstrated unique features, in comparison with other bacteria. In addition, a theoretical analysis of several protein parameters was performed and compared with the experimental results. A comparison of the theoretical molecular weight (MW) of the proteins and their theoretical pI with their vertical and horizontal migration distances, respectively, pointed out the existence of several proteins that strongly diverted from the graph trend-line. These proteins were clearly subjected to post-translational modifications, which changed their pI and/or MW. Additional support for post-translational modifications comes from the identification of multiple spots of the same gene products. Post-translational modifications appear to be more common than expected, at least for soluble proteins, as more than 10% of the proteins were associated with multiple spots.