Evidence that stationary-phase hypermutation in the Escherichia coli chromosome is promoted by recombination

Adaptive (or stationary-phase) mutation is a group of phenomena in which mutations appear to occur more often when selected than when not. They may represent cellular responses to the environment in which the genome is altered to allow survival. The best-characterized assay system and mechanism is reversion of a lac allele on an F' sex plasmid in Escherichia coli, in which the stationary-phase mutability requires homologous recombination functions. A key issue has concerned whether the recombination-dependent mutation mechanism is F' specific or is general. Hypermutation of chromosomal genes occurs in association with adaptive Lac(+) mutation. Here we present evidence that the chromosomal hypermutation is promoted by recombination. Hyperrecombinagenic recD cells show elevated chromosomal hypermutation. Further, recG mutation, which promotes accumulation of recombination intermediates proposed to prime replication and mutation, also stimulates chromosomal hypermutation. The coincident mutations at lac (on the F') and chromosomal genes behave as independent events, whereas coincident mutations at lac and other F-linked sites do not. This implies that transient covalent linkage of F' and chromosomal DNA (Hfr formation) does not underlie chromosomal mutation. The data suggest that recombinational stationary-phase mutation occurs in the bacterial chromosome and thus can be a general strategy for programmed genetic change.     

Opposing Roles of the Holliday Junction Processing Systems of Escherichia Coli in Recombination-Dependent Adaptive Mutation

Aspects of the molecular mechanism of ``adaptive' mutation are emerging from one experimental system: reversion of an Escherichia coli lac frameshift mutation carried on a conjugative plasmid. Homologous recombination is required and the mutations resemble polymerase errors. Reports implicating a role for conjugal transfer proteins suggested that the mutation mechanism is ordinary replication error occurring during transfer synthesis, followed by conjugation-like recombination, to capture the replicated fragment into an intact replicon. Whereas conjugational recombination uses either of two systems of Holliday junction resolution, we find that the adaptive lac reversions are inhibited by one resolution system and promoted by the other. Moreover, temporary absence of both resolution systems promotes mutation. These results imply that recombination intermediates themselves promote the mutations.     

Stationary-state mutagenesis inEscherichia coli: A model

Stationary-phase mutagenesis in nondividingE. coli cells exposed to a nonlethal stress was, a few years ago, claimed to be a likely case of a Lamarckian mechanism capable of producing exclusively useful mutations in a directed manner. After a heated debate over the last decade it now appears to involve a Darwinian mechanism that generates a transient state of hypermutagenesis, operating on a large number of sites spread over the entire genome, at least in a proportion of the resting cells. Most of the studies that clarified this position were on the reversion of a frameshift mutation present in alacI-lacZ fusion inE. coli strain FC40. Several groups have extensively examined both the sequence changes associated with these reversions and the underlying genetic requirements. On the basis of our studies on the genomic sequence analysis, we recently proposed a model to explain the specific changes associated with the reversion hotspots. Here we propose a more detailed version of this model that also takes into account the observed genetic requirements of stationary-state mutagenesis. Briefly, G:T/U mismatches produced at methylatable cytosines are preferentially repaired in nondividing cells by the very short patch mismatch repair (VSPMR) mechanism which is itself mutagenic and can produce mutations in very short stretches located in the immediate vicinity of these cytosine methylation sites. This mechanism requires a homologous or homeologous strand invasion step and an error-prone DNA synthesis step and is dependent on RecA, RecBCD and a DNA polymerase. The process is initiated near sequences recognized by Dcm and Vsr enzymes and further stimulated if these sequences are a part of CHI or CHI-like sequences, but a double-strand-break-dependent recombination mediated by the RecBCD pathways proposed by others seems to be nonessential. The strand transfer step is proposed to depend on RecA, RuvA, RuvB and RuvC and is opposed by RecG and MutS. The model also gives interesting insights into the evolution of theE. coli genome.     

Enhanced Evolvability in Immunoglobulin V Genes Under Somatic Hypermutation

Darwinian theory requires that mutations be produced in a nonanticipatory manner; it is nonetheless consistent to suggest that mutations that have repeatedly led to nonviable phenotypes would be introduced less frequently than others—if under appropriate genetic control. Immunoglobulins produced during infection acquire point mutations that are subsequently selected for improved binding to the eliciting antigen. We and others have speculated that an enhancement of mutability in the complementarity-determining regions (CDR; where mutations have a greater chance of being advantageous) and/or decrement of mutability in the framework regions (FR; where mutations are more likely to be lethal) may be accomplished by differential codon usage in concert with the known sequence specificity of the hypermutation mechanism. We have examined 115 nonproductively rearranged human Ig sequences. The mutation patterns in these unexpressed genes are unselected and therefore directly reflect inherent mutation biases. Using a χ² test, we have shown that the number of mutations in the CDRs is significantly higher than the number of mutations found in the FRs, providing direct evidence for the hypothesis that mutations are preferentially targeted into the CDRs.     

In pursuit of a molecular mechanism for adaptive gene amplification

"Adaptive" or "stationary-phase" mutation is a collection of apparent stress responses in which cells exposed to a growth-limiting environment generate genetic changes, some of which can allow resumption of rapid growth. In the well-characterized Lac system of Escherichia coli, reversions of a lac frameshift allele give rise to adaptive point mutations. Also in this system, adaptive gene amplification has been documented as a separate and parallel response that allows growth on lactose medium without acquisition of a compensatory frameshift mutation. In amplification, the DNA region containing the weakly functional lac allele becomes amplified to multiple copies, which produce sufficient enzyme activity to allow growth on the otherwise growth-limiting lactose medium. The amplifications are "adaptive" in that they occur after cells encounter the growth-limiting environment. Adaptive amplification is a reversible genetic change that allows adaptation and growth. It may be similar to chromosomal instability observed in the origins and progression of many cancers. We explore possible molecular mechanisms of adaptive amplification in the bacterial system and note parallels to chromosomal instability in other systems.     

Spontaneous Point Mutations That Occur More Often When Advantageous than When Neutral

Recent reports have called into question the widespread belief "that mutations arise continuously and without any consideration for their utility" (in the words of J. Cairns) and have suggested that some mutations (which Cairns called "directed" mutations) may occur as specific responses to environmental challenges, i.e., they may occur more often when advantageous than when neutral. In this paper it is shown that point mutations in the trp operon reverted to trp+ more frequently under conditions of prolonged tryptophan deprivation when the reversions were advantageous, than in the presence of tryptophan when the reversions were neutral. The overall mutation rate, as determined from the rates of mutation to valine resistance and to constitutive expression of the lac operon, did not increase during tryptophan starvation. The trp reversion rate did not increase when the cells were starved for cysteine for a similar period, indicating that the increased reversion rate was specific to conditions where the reversions were advantageous. Two artifactual explanations for the observations, delayed growth of some preexisting revertants and cryptic growth by some cells at the expense of dying cells within aged colonies, were tested and rejected as unlikely. The trp+ reversions that occurred while trp- colonies aged in the absence of tryptophan were shown to be time-dependent rather than replication-dependent, and it is suggested that they occur by mechanisms different from those that have been studied in growing cells. A heuristic model for the molecular basis of such mutations is proposed and evidence consistent with that model is discussed. It is suggested that the results in this and previous studies can be explained on the basis of underlying random mechanisms that act during prolonged periods of physiological stress, and that "directed" mutations are not necessarily the basis of those observations.     

Mutagenesis on cloned yeast genes. The mutation of the yeast gene comprising the plasmid and chromosome

The cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae were transformed by plasmid pYG-007 treated in vitro with o-methylhydroxylamine. The plasmid consists of a portion of the bacterial plasmid with genes of resistance to ampicillin, chloramphenicol and tetracycline, 2 mkm yeast DNA and yeast genes ADE2 and LEU2. The collection of mutants containing a mutant allele of ADE2 gene within the plasmid was obtained. Interallelic complementation and that induced by suppression were studied in these ade 2 mutants. It was shown that all these induced ade 2 mutations were base-pair substitutions. Using the mechanism of conversion we managed to transfer the plasmid ade 2 mutations into the chromosome. Three pairs of strains carrying similar mutation in plasmid and chromosome were created. Analysis of frequency of reversions induced by UV-light and hydroxylaminopurine in the mutant ade2 locus comprised in the plasmid and chromosome showed that the former induced reversions in plasmid alleles less effectively than the latter.     

Adaptive mutation inEscherichia coli strain FC40

Mutations can arise in static populations of cells that are subjected to nonlethal selective pressure, a phenomenon that has been called ‘adaptive mutation’. This phenomenon has been extensively studied in FC40, a strain ofEscherichia coli that cannot metabolize lactose (Lac⁻) but that reverts to lactose utilization (Lac⁺) when lactose is its sole energy and carbon source. The adaptive Lac⁺ mutations arise by two mutational processes: a recombination-dependent process that is highly active on the episome carrying the Lac⁻ allele, and an unknown process that affects the whole genome. Most of the Lac⁺ mutations are due to the first process, which also produces nonselected mutations on the F′ episome. However, about 10% of the Lac⁺ mutations arise in a subpopulation of cells that experience a period of transient hypermutation. Although minor contributors to any one type of mutation, the hypermutators account for nearly all cases of multiple mutations. The evolutionary implications of these results are: (i) DNA synthesis associated with recombination may be an important source of spontaneous mutation, particularly in cells that are not actively growing; (ii) the efficient mutational mechanism that occurs on the episome could result in the horizontal transfer of new alleles among species that carry and exchange conjugal plasmids; and (iii) a subpopulation of transient hypermutators could be a source of multiple mutations that would allow for rapid adaptive evolution under adverse conditions.     

Reverse mosaicism in Fanconi anemia: natural gene therapy via molecular self-correction

Fanconi anemia (FA) is a genetically and phenotypically heterogenous autosomal recessive disease associated with chromosomal instability and hypersensitivity to DNA crosslinkers. Prognosis is poor due to progressive bone marrow failure and increased risk of neoplasia, but revertant mosaicism may improve survival. Mechanisms of reversion include back mutation, intragenic crossover, gene conversion and compensating deletions/insertions. We describe the types of reversions found in five mosaic FA patients who are compound heterozygotes for single base mutations in FANCA or FANCC. Intragenic crossover could be shown as the mechanism of self-correction in the FANCC patient. Restoration to wildtype via back mutation or gene conversion of either the paternal or maternal allele was observed in the FANCA patients. The sequence environments of these mutations/reversions were indicative of high mutability, and selective advantage of bone marrow precursor cells carrying a completely restored FANCA allele might explain the surprisingly uniform pattern of these reversions. We also describe a first example of in vitro phenotypic reversion via the emergence of a compensating missense mutation 15 amino acids downstream of the constitutional mutation, which explains the reversion to MMC resistance of the respective lymphoblastoid cell line. With one exception, our mosaic patients showed improvement of their hematological status during a three- to six-year observation period, indicating a proliferative advantage of the reverted cell lineages. In patients with Fanconi anemia, genetic instability due to defective caretaker genes sharply increases the risk of neoplasia, but at the same time increases the chance for revertant mosaicism leading to improved bone marrow function.     

SOS mutator DNA polymerase IV functions in adaptive mutation and not adaptive amplification.

Adaptive point mutation and amplification are induced responses to environmental stress, promoting genetic changes that can enhance survival. A specialized adaptive mutation mechanism has been documented in one Escherichia coli assay, but its enzymatic basis remained unclear. We report that the SOS-inducible, error-prone DNA polymerase (pol) IV, encoded by dinB, is required for adaptive point mutation in the E. coli lac operon. A nonpolar dinB mutation reduces adaptive mutation frequencies by 85% but does not affect adaptive amplification, growth-dependent mutation, or survival after oxidative or UV damage. We show that pol IV, together with the major replicase, pol III, can account for all adaptive point mutations at lac. The results identify a role for pol IV in inducible genetic change.     

Protein evolution by hypermutation and selection in the B cell line DT40

Genome-wide mutations and selection within a population are the basis of natural evolution. A similar process occurs during antibody affinity maturation when immunoglobulin genes are hypermutated and only those B cells which express antibodies of improved antigen-binding specificity are expanded. Protein evolution might be simulated in cell culture, if transgene-specific hypermutation can be combined with the selection of cells carrying beneficial mutations. Here, we describe the optimization of a GFP transgene in the B cell line DT40 by hypermutation and iterative fluorescence activated cell sorting. Artificial evolution in DT40 offers unique advantages and may be easily adapted to other transgenes, if the selection for desirable mutations is feasible.     

Amplification of lac cannot account for adaptive mutation to Lac+ in Escherichia coli

When the Lac- strain of Escherichia coli, FC40, is incubated with lactose as its sole carbon and energy source, Lac+ revertants arise at a constant rate, a phenomenon known as adaptive mutation. Two alternative models for adaptive mutation have been proposed: (i) recombination-dependent mutation, which specifies that recombination occurring in nongrowing cells stimulates error-prone DNA synthesis, and (ii) amplification-dependent mutation, which specifies that amplification of the lac region and growth of the amplifying cells creates enough DNA replication to produce mutations at the normal rate. Here, we examined several of the predictions of the amplification-dependent mutation model and found that they are not fulfilled. First, inhibition of adaptive mutation by a gene that is toxic when overexpressed does not depend on the proximity of the gene to lac. Second, mutation at a second locus during selection for Lac+ revertants is also independent of the proximity of the locus to lac. Third, mutation at a second locus on the episome occurs even when the lac allele under selection is on the chromosome. Our results support the hypothesis that most Lac+ mutants that appear during lactose selection are true revertants that arise in a single step from Lac- cells, not from a population of growing or amplifying precursor cells.