Alanine radicals,part 3: properties of the components contributing to the EPR spectrum of X-irradiated alanine dosimeters

The amino acid l-alpha-alanine has attracted considerable interest for use in radiation dosimetry and has been formally accepted as a secondary standard for high-dose and transfer dosimetry. Recent results have shown that the alanine EPR spectrum consists of contributions from three different radicals. A set of benchmark spectra describing the essential spectral features of these three radical components was used for reconstructions of the experimental spectra. In the present work, these basis spectra have been used to investigate the differential effects of variations in radiation doses and microwave power, as well as the dependence upon temperature annealing and UV illumination. The results presented here, based solely on relatively low-energy (60-80 keV) X rays, indicate that the three components behave very similarly with respect to radiation dose at room temperature. However, with respect to the thermal annealing/fading behavior and microwave power saturation properties, the three species behave significantly differently. It is concluded that even if it is now realized that three different radicals contribute to the composite EPR alanine spectrum, this has a minor impact on the established protocols for present-day applications (high-dose) of EPR/alanine dosimetry. However, some care should be exercised when e.g. constructing calibration curves, since fading and power saturation behavior may vary over the dose range in question. New results from UV-illumination experiments suggest a possible procedure for experimental spectral separation of the EPR signals due to the three radicals.     

Effect of temperature on the electron paramagnetic resonance spectrum of irradiated alanine.

Polycrystalline samples of the amino acid L-alpha-alanine have been irradiated with X rays at both room temperature and higher temperatures. The electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra of alanine powder irradiated at room temperature are dominated by the well-known room-temperature-stable alanine radical CH3C*HCOOH. Upon heating of room-temperature-irradiated alanine powder, a strong decay of the signal was observed, and the features of the spectrum recently ascribed to a second stable radical in alanine irradiated at room temperature become more pronounced, providing an experimental isolation of this second alanine radical. In combination with the high-temperature experiments, a multivariate statistical decomposition method, maximum likelihood common factor analysis, was used to determine the number of components in irradiated alanine powder which behave differently as a function of temperature. The EPR components found in the present study are compared with simulations using earlier EPR and ENDOR single-crystal data.     

High-field/ high-frequency EPR study on stable free radicals formed in sucrose by gamma-irradiation

The EPR spectrum of sucrose irradiated by high-energy radiation is complex due to the presence of more than one radical species. In order to decompose the spectrum and elucidate the radical magnetic parameters a high-field (HF(-)EPR) study on stable free radicals in gamma-irradiated polycrystalline sucrose (table sugar) was performed at three different high frequencies--94, 190 and 285 GHz as well as at the conventional X-band. We suggest a presence of three stable radicals R1, R2 and R3 as the main radical species. Due to the increase of g-factor resolution at high fields the g-tensors of these radicals could be extracted by accurate simulations. The moderate g-anisotropy suggests that all three radicals are carbon-centred. Results from an earlier ENDOR study on X-irradiated sucrose single crystals (Vanhaelewyn et al., Appl Radiat Isot, 52, 1221 (2000)) were used for analyzing of the spectra in more details. It was confirmed that the strongest hyperfine interaction has a relatively small anisotropy, which indicates either the absence of alpha-protons or a strongly distorted geometry of the radicals.     

EPR dosimetric properties of 2-methylalanine: EPR, ENDOR and FT-EPR investigations

To find an EPR dosimeter material that is sensitive enough for clinical use, the substance 2-methylalanine (2MA) with the chemical structure (CH(3))(2)C(NH(3)(+))COO(-) was tested for its sensitivity to ionizing radiation, dose response, and radical stability over time. At equal and moderate settings of microwave power and modulation amplitude, 2MA was found to be 70% more sensitive than L-alpha-alanine, which is the most common EPR dosimeter material today. The dose response is linear, at least in the dose range of interest (0.5-00 Gy), and the time-dependent variations in signal intensity are very small and may be corrected for easily. The energy dependence of the stopping power and energy absorption was calculated and was found to be similar to that of alanine. The dependence of the signal intensity on microwave power and modulation amplitude was investigated, and the optimal settings were found to be 25 mW (Bruker ER 4102ST) and 12 gauss, respectively. Single crystals of 2MA were analyzed using ENDOR and ENDOR-induced EPR to identify the radiation-induced radicals that formed. Only one radical, in which the amino group is detached from the original molecule, was identified. This radical is obviously dominating and is apparently the only one relevant for dosimetry purposes. The complete set of coupling parameters for three hyperfine couplings is reported. The power saturation properties and spectral line width are ruled by the relaxation times T(1) and T(2). To determine the relaxation times of 2MA, pulsed EPR experiments were performed on single crystals. Two different values of T(1) were obtained, one in the range 1-3 micros, shown to be of importance for the dosimetry properties, and another that is strongly anisotropic with a value between 10 and 35 micros that does not seem to affect the saturation behavior. T(2) was estimated to be of the order of 200-300 ns.     

Use of alanine-silicone pellets for electron paramagnetic resonance gamma dosimetry.

Silicone is proposed as an alternative binding substance in the production of D-L alanine pellets used in electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) dosimetry of gamma rays. The dosimeters are manufactured at room temperature, making the production simple. Examination by EPR silicone-alanine pellets irradiated with 60Co gamma rays in the dose range 10 to 10(6) Gy shows that the proposed silicone binder does not affect typical alanine dose-response curves. Thermal stability of the pellets below 40 degrees C is good, but their pre-dose EPR signal amplitude is slightly higher than for nonirradiated alanine.     

Ascorbic acid radicals induced by the action of radiation in tissues from rat organs frozen at 77 K

Subsequent annealing technique and computer assistant analysis of EPR spectra were used to isolate an asymmetric EPR signal Rs(g = 2,0051; delta H = 0.8 mT) from the EPR spectrum of rat spleen gamma-irradiated at 77 K. Radicals with the same EPR spectrum were registered in: 1) water solution of ascorbic acid (2.10(-2) M, pH 3.4) frozen and irradiated at 77 K and 2) water-glycerol solution of ascorbic acid (10(-2) M, pH 10.3) frozen rapidly at the moment of intensive autooxidation. These model experiments allow to conclude that Rs signal is caused by the radicals of semidehydroascorbic acid. Radiochemical yield of these radicals as well as of all the radicals induced by gamma radiation in the whole rat tissues were measured. The EPR signal (Rs) is equivalent to the well known "artifact" signal of lyophilized tissues. The explanation of the mechanism of the radicals formation taking place under annealing of the frozen and irradiated tissues was suggested.     

EPR evidence of two structurally different diferric sites in Mycobacterium tuberculosis R2-2 ribonucleotide reductase protein

Mixed-valent species were generated in the diiron site of active (with tyrosyl free radical) and met (without radical) forms of protein R2-2 in a class Ib ribonucleotide reductase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis by low temperature reduction (γ-irradiation) at 77 K. The primary mixed-valent EPR signal is a mixture of two components with axial symmetry and g_av<2.0, observable at temperatures up to 77 K, and assigned to antiferromagnetically coupled high spin ferric/ferrous sites. The two components in the primary EPR signal can be explained by the existence of two structurally distinct μ-oxo-bridged diferric centers, possibly related to structural heterogeneity around the iron site, and/or different properties of the two polypeptide chains in the homodimeric protein after the radical reconstitution reaction. Annealing of the irradiated R2-2 samples to 143 K transforms the primary EPR signal into a rhombic spectrum characterized by g_av<1.8 and observable only below 25 K. This spectrum is assigned to a partially relaxed form with a μ-hydroxo-bridge. Further annealing at 228 K produces a new complex rhombic EPR spectrum composed of at least two components. An identical EPR spectrum was observed and found to be stable upon chemical reduction of Mycobacterium tuberculosis RNR R2-2 at 293 K by dithionite.     

Tryptophan or tyrosine? On the nature of the amino acid radical formed following hydrogen peroxide treatment of cytochrome c oxidase

It has been reported that different amino acid radicals are formed following the addition of hydrogen peroxide to cytochrome c oxidase (CcO) from bovine heart or from Paracoccus denitrificans. A broad unresolved signal in the electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectra of bovine CcO has been assigned to a tryptophan radical, probably Trp126 [Rigby et al. Biochemistry 2000, 39, 5921-5928]. In the P. denitrificans enzyme, a similarly broad signal but with a well-resolved hyperfine structure was shown to originate from a tyrosyl radical and was tentatively assigned to the active site Tyr280 [MacMillan et al. Biochemistry 1999, 38, 9179-9184]. We confirm that the EPR signal from P. denitrificans CcO can be simulated using spectral parameters typical for known Tyr radicals in other systems. However, the rotational conformation of the phenolic ring of Tyr280 is inconsistent with our simulation. Instead, the simulation parameters we used correspond to the rotational conformation of ring that matches very accurately the conformation found in Tyr167, a residue that is close enough ( approximately 10 A) to the binuclear centre to readily donate an electron. The broad unresolved EPR signal in the bovine oxidase has been thought previously to be inconsistent with a tyrosyl radical. However, we have simulated a hypothetical EPR spectrum arising from a Tyr129 radical (the equivalent of Tyr167 in P. denitrificans CcO) and showed that it is similar to the observed broad signal. The possibility exists, therefore, that the homological tyrosine amino acid (Tyr167/Tyr129) is responsible for the EPR spectrum in both the Paraccoccus and the bovine enzyme. This correspondence between the two enzymes at least allows the possibility that this radical may have functional importance.     

Taurine for EPR dosimetry

EPR dosimetry is characterized by its non-destructive read-out and the possibility of dose archival. Here, taurine is proposed as a radiation dosimeter using EPR spectroscopy. The EPR spectrum of taurine was studied and assigned, and changes in the taurine EPR spectrum as a result of the change in both modulation amplitude and microwave power were quantified. For gamma radiation, the energy absorption coefficient and the collision mass stopping power of taurine were compared to the corresponding values of soft tissue and alanine, in addition to calculation of effective atomic numbers. The response of taurine to gamma radiation doses in the range from 0.1 to 50 kGy was investigated, as well as that in the range from 1.0 to 20.0 Gy using numerically enhanced EPR taurine spectra. Both response curves showed a linear behavior. In addition, the time dependence of radiation-induced radicals was studied for short (during the first 6 h after irradiation) and long (during about 3 months after irradiation) time periods, and a reasonable degree of stability of the taurine radicals was observed. It is concluded that taurine is a promising dosimeter, which is characterized by its simple spectrum, radical stability, and wide range of linear response to gamma radiation.     

The decomposition of the EPR spectra of multicomponent systems irradiated at 77 K into paramagnetic center signals of different natures]

Main principles of the way to decompose an EPR spectrum of a multicomponent system, irradiated at 77 K, into separate radiation-induced paramagnetic centre signals are given. The decomposition is possible due to the computer assistant spectra processing, and is based on different properties of different paramagnetic centres, namely, on different thermostability of the centres, on different rate of relaxation, and on different photosensitivity. Concrete examples of the EPR spectrum decomposition into different free radical signals are given for cases of murine liver and spleen irradiated at 77 K. Radiochemical yields of different free radicals, induced by gamma radiation at 77 K in whole biological tissues, were defined. The data on nature and properties of the paramagnetic centres induced by radiation in biological tissues are shortly reviewed.     

In vivo monitoring of hydroxyl radical generation caused by x-ray irradiation of rats using the spin trapping/EPR technique

Measurement of hydroxyl radical (*OH) in living animals irradiated with ionizing radiation should be required to clarify the mechanisms of radiation injury and the in vivo assessment of radiation protectors, because generation of *OH is believed to be one of the major triggers of radiation injury. In this study, *OH generation was monitored by spin trapping the secondary methyl radical formed by the reaction of *OH with dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Rats were injected intraperitoneally with a DMSO solution of alpha-phenyl-N-tert-butylnitrone (PBN). X-irradiation of the rats remarkedly increased the six-line EPR signal in the bile. The strengthened signal was detectable above 40 Gy. Use of 13C-substituted DMSO revealed that the signal included the methyl radical adduct of PBN as a major component. The EPR signal of the PBN-methyl radical adduct was completely suppressed by preadministration of methyl gallate, a scavenger of *OH but not of methyl radical. Methyl gallate did not reduce the spin adducts to EPR-silent forms. These observations indicate that what we were measuring was *OH generated in vivo by x-irradiation. This is the first report of the in vivo monitoring of *OH generation at a radiation dose close to what people might receive in the case of radiological accident or radiation therapy.     

Retrospective dosimetry after criticality accidents using low-frequency EPR: a study of whole human teeth irradiated in a mixed neutron and gamma-radiation field

In the context of accidental or intentional radiation exposures (nuclear terrorism), it is essential to separate rapidly those individuals with substantial exposures from those with exposures that do not constitute an immediate threat to health. Low-frequency electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy provides the potential advantage of making accurate and sensitive measurements of absorbed radiation dose in teeth without removing the teeth from the potential victims. Up to now, most studies focused on the dose-response curves obtained for gamma radiation. In radiation accidents, however, the contribution of neutrons to the total radiation dose should not be neglected. To determine how neutrons contribute to the apparent dose estimated by EPR dosimetry, extracted whole human teeth were irradiated at the SILENE reactor in a mixed neutron and gamma-radiation field simulating criticality accidents. The teeth were irradiated in free air as well as in a paraffin head phantom. Lead screens were also used to eliminate to a large extent the contribution of the gamma radiation to the dose received by the teeth. The EPR signals, obtained with a low-frequency (1.2 GHz) spectrometer, were compared to dosimetry measurements at the same location. The contribution of neutrons to the EPR dosimetric signal was negligible in the range of 0 to 10 Gy and was rather small (neutron/gamma-ray sensitivity in the range 0-0.2) at higher doses. This indicates that the method essentially provides information on the dose received from the gamma-ray component of the radiation.     

EPR evidence of two structurally different diferric sites in Mycobacterium tuberculosis R2-2 ribonucleotide reductase protein

Mixed-valent species were generated in the diiron site of active (with tyrosyl free radical) and met (without radical) forms of protein R2-2 in a class Ib ribonucleotide reductase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis by low temperature reduction (γ-irradiation) at 77 K. The primary mixed-valent EPR signal is a mixture of two components with axial symmetry and g_av<2.0, observable at temperatures up to 77 K, and assigned to antiferromagnetically coupled high spin ferric/ferrous sites. The two components in the primary EPR signal can be explained by the existence of two structurally distinct μ-oxo-bridged diferric centers, possibly related to structural heterogeneity around the iron site, and/or different properties of the two polypeptide chains in the homodimeric protein after the radical reconstitution reaction. Annealing of the irradiated R2-2 samples to 143 K transforms the primary EPR signal into a rhombic spectrum characterized by g_av<1.8 and observable only below 25 K. This spectrum is assigned to a partially relaxed form with a μ-hydroxo-bridge. Further annealing at 228 K produces a new complex rhombic EPR spectrum composed of at least two components. An identical EPR spectrum was observed and found to be stable upon chemical reduction of Mycobacterium tuberculosis RNR R2-2 at 293 K by dithionite.     

EPR studies of 5-bromouracil crystal after irradiation with X rays in the bromine K-edge region

Radicals induced in a single crystal of 5-bromouracil (BrUra) by synchrotron soft X rays in the bromine K-edge region (13.461-13.482 keV) were investigated using the X-band EPR method. The crystal was irradiated at three peak energies of the absorption spectrum at room temperature or at 80 K. A hydrogen abstraction radical derived from N1 of the pyrimidine ring was commonly observed for all of the energies used, though with some variation in quantity. Similar characteristics were also observed in the EPR signal for the off-K-edge low-energy (13.42 keV) and (60)Co gamma rays used for comparison. When irradiated at 80 K, a much larger exposure (roughly 10 times) of soft X rays was needed to obtain the same signal intensity as that observed at room temperature. EPR signals were not detectable with gamma irradiation at liquid nitrogen temperature.     

Reaction of bovine cytochrome c oxidase with hydrogen peroxide produces a tryptophan cation radical and a porphyrin cation radical

Oxidized bovine cytochrome c oxidase reacts with hydrogen peroxide to generate two electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) free radical signals (Fabian, M., and Palmer, G. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 13802-13810). These radicals are associated with the binuclear center and give rise to two overlapped EPR signals, one signal being narrower in line width (DeltaHptp = 12 G) than the other (DeltaHptp = 45 G). We have used electron nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) spectrometry to identify the two different chemical species giving rise to these two EPR signals. Comparison of the ENDOR spectrum associated with the narrow signal with that of compound I of horseradish peroxidase (formed by reaction of that enzyme with hydrogen peroxide) demonstrates that the two species are virtually identical. The chemical species giving rise to the narrow signal is therefore identified as an exchange-coupled porphyrin cation radical similar to that formed in horseradish peroxidase compound I. Comparison of the ENDOR spectrum of compound ES (formed by the reaction of hydrogen peroxide with cytochrome c peroxidase) with that of the broad signal indicates that the chemical species giving rise to the broad EPR signal in cytochrome c oxidase is probably an exchange coupled tryptophan cation radical. This is substantiated using H(2)O/D(2)O solvent exchange experiments where the ENDOR difference spectrum of the broad EPR signal of cytochrome c oxidase shows a feature consistent with hyperfine coupling to the exchangeable N(1) proton of a tryptophan cation radical.     

Mechanistic study on the reaction of a radical SAM dehydrogenase BtrN by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy

BtrN is a radical SAM ( S-adenosyl- l-methionine) enzyme that catalyzes the oxidation of 2-deoxy- scyllo-inosamine (DOIA) into 3-amino-2,3-dideoxy- scyllo-inosose (amino-DOI) during the biosynthesis of 2-deoxystreptamine (DOS) in the butirosin producer Bacillus circulans. Recently, we have shown that BtrN catalyzes the transfer of a hydrogen atom at C-3 of DOIA to 5'-deoxyadenosine, and thus, the reaction was proposed to proceed through the hydrogen atom abstraction by the 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical. In this work, the BtrN reaction was analyzed by EPR spectroscopy. A sharp double triplet EPR signal was observed when the EPR spectrum of the enzyme reaction mixture was recorded at 50 K. The spin coupling with protons partially disappeared by reaction with [2,2- (2)H 2]DOIA, which unambiguously proved the observed signal to be a radical on C-3 of DOIA. On the other hand, the EPR spectrum of the [4Fe-4S] cluster of BtrN during the reaction showed a complex signal due to the presence of several species. Comparison of signals derived from a [4Fe-4S] center of BtrN incubated with various combinations of products (5'-deoxyadenosine, l-methionine, and amino-DOI) and substrates (SAM and DOIA) indicated that the EPR signals observed during the reaction were derived from free BtrN, a BtrN-SAM complex, and a BtrN-SAM-DOIA complex. Significant changes in the EPR signals upon binding of SAM and DOIA suggest the close interaction of both substrates with the [4Fe-4S] cluster.     

Ammonium formate, a compound for sensitive EPR dosimetry

Alanine EPR dosimetry has been applied successfully when measuring intermediate and high radiation doses. Although the performance of alanine dosimetry is being improved, the sensitivity of the material is too low for a fast and simple low- dose determination. Here we present the results using ammonium formate as an EPR dosimeter material. Ammonium formate is seven times more sensitive than alanine, using spectrometer settings optimized for the latter. Deuterated ammonium formate is found to be more than eight times more sensitive than alanine. Analysis of signal stability with time shows that the ammonium formate signal is stable by 5 min after irradiation and that no change in signal intensity is found during 8 days. The atomic composition of ammonium formate is closer to that of tissue than alanine, and thus the energy dependence is smaller than that of alanine at photon energies below 200 keV. Power saturation studies indicate that the energy transfer between the spins and the lattice is fast in ammonium formate, which gives the possibility of using high microwave power without saturation to further increase the sensitivity. These results suggest that ammonium formate has some important properties required of an EPR dosimeter for applications in dosimetry in the dose range typical for radiation therapy.     

A comparative dosimetry study of an alanine dosimeter with a PTW PinPoint chamber at ultra-high dose rates of synchrotron radiation

The use of synchrotron X-ray sources provides innovative approaches in radiation therapy. The unique possibility to generate quasi-parallel beams promoted the development of microbeam radiation therapy (MRT), an innovative approach able to reduce damages to normal tissues while delivering considerable doses in the lesion. Accurate dosimetry in broad-beam configuration (prior to the spatial fractionation of the incident X-ray fan) is very challenging at ultra-high dose rate synchrotron sources.The available reference dosimetry protocol based on the use of a PTW PinPoint ionization chamber was compared with alanine dosimetry at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF) ID17 Biomedical beamline, an orthovoltage X-ray source with an average dose rate of 11.6 kGy/s. Reference dose measurements of the alanine pellets were performed at the National Centre for Radiation Research and Technology (NCRRT) ⁶⁰Co facility in Egypt. All alanine dosimeters were analysed by an electron paramagnetic resonance spectrometer.We determined a relative response r_ESRF = 0.932 ± 0.027 (1σ) of the alanine pellets irradiated at the ESRF compared to the ⁶⁰Co facility. Considering the appropriate corrections for the ESRF polychromatic spectrum and the different field size used, our result is in agreement with the previous work of Waldeland et al. for which the utilised alanine contained the same amount of binder, and it is consistent with the works of Anton et al. and Butler et al. for which the utilised alanine contained a higher amount of binder.We confirm that alanine is an appropriate dosimeter for ultra-high dose rate calibration of orthovoltage X-ray sources.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance in irradiated fingernails: variability of dose dependence and possibilities of initial dose assessment

The results of electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) measurements in irradiated fingernails are presented. In total, 83 samples of different fingernails were studied. Five different groups of samples were selected based on the collection time of fingernail samples, their level of mechanical stress, and the number and size of clippings: (1) recently (<24 h) cut, irradiated and measured with EPR without any treatment of samples, and with rigorous control of size and number of clippings (stressed–fresh, controlled); (2) recently (<24 h) cut, irradiated and measured with EPR after application of a special treatment (10 min of water soaking, 5 min of drying time) to reduce the mechanical stress caused by cutting the samples, and with rigorous control of size and number of clippings (unstressed–fresh, controlled); (3) previously (>24 h) cut, stored at room temperature, additionally cut into small pieces immediately prior to study, irradiated and measured with EPR without any treatment of samples, and with rigorous control of size and number of clippings (stressed–old, controlled); (4) previously (>24 h) cut, stored at room temperature, additionally cut into small pieces immediately prior to the study, irradiated and measured with EPR after application of a special treatment to reduce mechanical stress caused by cut, and with rigorous control of size and number of clippings (unstressed–old, controlled); and (5) recently (<24 h) cut, irradiated and measured with EPR after application of a special treatment to reduce the mechanical stress caused by cut, and without rigorous control of size and number of clippings (unstressed–fresh, uncontrolled). Except for the fifth selected group, variability of the dose dependence inside all groups was found to be not statistically significant, although the variability among the different groups was significant. Comparison of the mean dose dependences obtained for each group allowed selection of key factors responsible for radiation sensitivity (dose response per unit of mass and dose) and the shape of dose dependence in fingernails. The major factor responsible for radiation sensitivity of fingernails was identified as their water content, which can affect radiation sensitivity up to 35%. The major factor responsible for the shape of the radiation sensitivity was identified as the mechanical stress. At a significant level of mechanical stress, the shape of the dose dependence is linear in the studied dose range (<20 Gy), and in lesser-stressed samples it is of an exponential growth including saturation, which depends on the degree of mechanical stress. In view of the findings, recommendations are discussed and presented for the appropriate protocol for EPR dose measurements in fingernails.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance radiation dose assessment in fingernails of the victim exposed to high dose as result of an accident

In this paper, we report results of radiation dose measurements in fingernails of a worker who sustained a radiation injury to his right thumb while using 130 kVp X-ray for nondestructive testing. Clinically estimated absorbed dose was about 20–25 Gy. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) dose assessment was independently carried out by two laboratories, the Naval Dosimetry Center (NDC) and French Institut de Radioprotection et de Sûreté Nucléaire (IRSN). The laboratories used different equipments and protocols to estimate doses in the same fingernail samples. NDC used an X-band transportable EPR spectrometer, e-scan produced by Bruker BioSpin, and a universal dose calibration curve. In contrast, IRSN used a more sensitive Q-band stationary spectrometer (EMXplus) with a new approach for the dose assessment (dose saturation method), derived by additional dose irradiation to known doses. The protocol used by NDC is significantly faster than that used by IRSN, nondestructive, and could be done in field conditions, but it is probably less accurate and requires more sample for the measurements. The IRSN protocol, on the other hand, potentially is more accurate and requires very small amount of sample but requires more time and labor. In both EPR laboratories, the intense radiation-induced signal was measured in the accidentally irradiated fingernails and the resulting dose assessments were different. The dose on the fingernails from the right thumb was estimated as 14 ± 3 Gy at NDC and as 19 ± 6 Gy at IRSN. Both EPR dose assessments are given in terms of tissue kerma. This paper discusses the experience gained by using EPR for dose assessment in fingernails with a stationary spectrometer versus a portable one, the reasons for the observed discrepancies in dose, and potential advantages and disadvantages of each approach for EPR measurements in fingernails.