Morphological Characterization of a Low‐Bandgap Crystalline Polymer:PCBM Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

Understanding the morphology of polymer‐based bulk heterojunction (BHJ) solar cells is necessary to improve device efficiencies. Blends of a low‐bandgap silole‐containing conjugated polymer, poly[(4,4′‐bis(2‐ethylhexyl)dithieno[3,2‐b;2′,3′‐d]silole)‐2,6‐diyl‐alt‐(4,7‐bis(2‐thienyl)‐2,1,3‐benzothiadiazole)‐5,5′‐diyl] (PSBTBT) with [6,6]phenyl‐C61‐butyric acid methyl ester (PCBM) were investigated under different processing conditions. The surface morphologies and vertical segregation of the “As‐Spun”, “Pre‐Annealed”, and “Post‐Annealed” films were studied by scanning force microscopy, contact angle measurements, X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy, near‐edge X‐ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy, dynamic secondary ion mass spectrometry, and neutron reflectivity. The results showed that PSBTBT was enriched at the cathode interface in the “As‐Spun” films and thermal annealing increased the segregation of PSBTBT to the free surface, while thermal annealing after deposition of the cathode increased the PCBM concentration at the cathode interface. Grazing‐incidence X‐ray diffraction and small‐angle neutron scattering showed that the crystallization of PSBTBT and segregation of PCBM occurred during spin coating, and thermal annealing increased the ordering of PSBTBT and enhanced the segregation of the PCBM, forming domains ～10 nm in size, leading to an improvement in photovoltaic performance.     

The Influence of MoOx Anode Stoicheometry on the Performance of Bulk Heterojunction Polymer Solar Cells

Bulk heterojunction solar cells containing molybdenum oxide hole extracting anode contacts have been fabricated with varying stoicheometry using radio frequency reactive sputtering from a Molybdenum metal target. A blend of the newly synthesised conjugated polymer poly[9‐(heptadecan‐9‐yl)‐9H‐carbazole‐2,7‐diyl‐alt‐(5,6‐bis(octyloxy)‐4,7‐di(thiophen‐2‐yl)benzo[c][1,2,5]thiadiazole)‐5,5‐diyl] (PCDTBT‐8) and fullerene [6,6]‐Phenyl‐C71‐butyric acid methyl ester (PC70BM) was used as the photoactive layer and device results show that anodes with greater than 98% Molybdenum (VI) oxide result in peak power conversion efficiencies of 3.7%.The presence of up to 28% of Mo (V) results in no significant reduction in efficiency, however the presence of metallic Mo (IV) and lower oxidation states lead to severe reductions in device performance due to a combination of a large hole extraction energy barrier of approximately 0.9eV and reduced device stability.     

The Physics of Small Molecule Acceptors for Efficient and Stable Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

Organic bulk heterojunction solar cells based on small molecule acceptors have recently seen a rapid rise in the power conversion efficiency with values exceeding 13%. This impressive achievement has been obtained by simultaneous reduction of voltage and charge recombination losses within this class of materials as compared to fullerene‐based solar cells. In this contribution, the authors review the current understanding of the relevant photophysical processes in highly efficient nonfullerene acceptor (NFA) small molecules. Charge generation, recombination, and charge transport is discussed in comparison to fullerene‐based composites. Finally, the authors review the superior light and thermal stability of nonfullerene small molecule acceptor based solar cells, and highlight the importance of NFA‐based composites that enable devices without early performance loss, thus resembling so‐called burn‐in free devices.     

Nongeminate Recombination in Planar and Bulk Heterojunction Organic Solar Cells

Nongeminate recombination in organic solar cells based on copper phthalocyanine (CuPc) and C₆₀ is investigated. Two device architectures, the planar heterojunction (PHJ) and the bulk heterojunction (BHJ), are directly compared in view of differences in charge carrier decay dynamics. A combination of transient photovoltage (TPV) experiments, yielding the small perturbation charge carrier lifetime, and charge extraction measurements, providing the charge carrier density is applied. In organic solar cells, charge photogeneration and recombination primarily occur at the donor–acceptor heterointerface. Whereas the BHJ can often be approximated by an effective medium due to rather small scale phase separation, the PHJ has a well defined two‐dimensional heterointerface. In order to study nongeminate recombination dynamics in PHJ devices the charge accumulation at this interface is most relavent. As only the spatially averaged carrier concentration can be determined from extraction techniques, the charge carrier density at the interface n_int is derived from the open circuit voltage. Comparing the experimental results with macroscopic device simulation, the differences of recombination and charge carrier densities in CuPc:C₆₀ PHJ and BHJ devices are discussed with respect to the device performance. The open circuit voltage of BHJ is larger than for PHJ at low light intensities, but at 0.3 sun the situation is reversed: here, the PHJ can finally take advantage of its generally longer charge carrier lifetimes, as the active recombination region is smaller.     

Shelf Life Degradation of Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells: Intrinsic Evolution of Charge Transfer Complex

Achievement of long‐term stability of organic photovoltaics is currently one of the major topics for this technology to reach maturity. Most of the techniques used to reveal degradation pathways are destructive and/or do not allow for real‐time measurements in operating devices. Here, three different, nondestructive techniques able to provide real‐time information, namely, film absorbance, capacitance–voltage (C–V), and impedance spectroscopy (IS), are combined over a period of 1 year using non‐accelerated intrinsic degradation conditions. It is discerned between chemical modifications in the active layer, physical processes taking place in the bulk of the blend from those at the active layer/contact interfaces. In particular, it is observed that during the ageing experiment, the main source for device performance degradation is the formation of donor–acceptor charge‐transfer complex (–) that acts as an exciton quencher. Generation of these radical species diminishes photocurrent and reduces open‐circuit voltage by the creation of electronic defect states. Conclusions extracted from absorption, C–V, and IS measurements will be further supported by a range of other techniques such as atomic force microscopy, X‐ray diffraction, and dark‐field imaging of scanning transmission electron microscopy on ultrathin cross‐sections.     

Trade‐Off between Trap Filling,Trap Creation,and Charge Recombination Results in Performance Increase at Ultralow Doping Levels in Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

Doping of organic bulk heterojunction solar cells has the potential to improve their power conversion efficiency (PCE). Deconvoluting the effect of doping on charge transport, recombination, and energetic disorder remains challenging. It is demonstrated that molecular doping has two competing effects: on one hand, dopant ions create additional traps while on the other hand free dopant‐induced charges fill deep states possibly leading to V _OC and mobility increases. It is shown that molar dopant concentrations as low as a few parts per million can improve the PCE of organic bulk heterojunctions. Higher concentrations degrade the performance of the cells. In doped cells where PCE is observed to increase, such improvement cannot be attributed to better charge transport. Instead, the V _OC increase in unannealed P3HT:PCBM cells upon doping is indeed due to trap filling, while for annealed P3HT:PCBM cells the change in V _OC is related to morphology changes and dopant segregation. In PCDTBT:PC70BM cells, the enhanced PCE upon doping is explained by changes in the thickness of the active layer. This study highlights the complexity of bulk doping in organic solar cells due to the generally low doping efficiency and the constraint on doping concentrations to avoid carrier recombination and adverse morphology changes.     

Morphology‐Dependent Trap Formation in High Performance Polymer Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

Bulk heterojunction solar cells (BHJs) based on poly[N‐9″‐hepta‐decanyl‐2,7‐carbazole‐alt‐5,5‐(4′,7′‐di‐2‐thienyl‐2′,1′,3′‐benzothiadiazole)] (PCDTBT) can have internal quantum efficiencies approaching 100% but require active layers that are too thin to absorb more than ～70% of the above band gap light. When the active layer thickness is increased so that the cell absorbs more light, the fill factor and open circuit voltage decrease rapidly, so that the overall power conversion efficiency decreases. We find that hole‐traps in the polymer, which we characterize using space‐charge limited current measurements, play an important role in the performance of PCDTBT‐based BHJs and may limit the active layer thickness. Recombination due to carrier trapping is not often considered in BHJs because it is not believed to be a dominant loss mechanism in the “fruit‐fly” P3HT system. Furthermore, we show that in contrast to P3HT, PCDTBT has only weak short‐range molecular order, and that annealing at temperatures above the glass transition decreases the order in the π–π stacking. The decrease in structural order is matched by the movement of hole‐traps deeper into the band gap, so that thermal annealing worsens hole transport in the polymer and reduces the efficiency of PCDTBT‐based BHJs. These findings suggest that P3HT is not prototypical of the new class of high efficiency polymers, and that further improvement of BHJ efficiencies will necessitate the study of high efficiency polymers with low structural order.     

Baselines for Lifetime of Organic Solar Cells

The process of accurately gauging lifetime improvements in organic photovoltaics (OPVs) or other similar emerging technologies, such as perovskites solar cells is still a major challenge. The presented work is part of a larger effort of developing a worldwide database of lifetimes that can help establishing reference baselines of stability performance for OPVs and other emerging PV technologies, which can then be utilized for pass‐fail testing standards and predicting tools. The study constitutes scanning of literature articles related to stability data of OPVs, reported until mid‐2015 and collecting the reported data into a database. A generic lifetime marker is utilized for rating the stability of various reported devices. The collected data is combined with an earlier developed and reported database, which was based on articles reported until mid‐2013. The extended database is utilized for establishing the baselines of lifetime for OPVs tested under different conditions. The work also provides the recent progress in stability of unencapsulated OPVs with different architectures, as well as presents the updated diagram of the reported record lifetimes of OPVs. The presented work is another step forward towards the development of pass‐fail testing standards and lifetime prediction tools for emerging PV technologies.     

The Crucial Influence of Fullerene Phases on Photogeneration in Organic Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

The conjugated polymer, poly(2,5‐bis(3‐hexadecylthiophen‐2‐yl)thieno[3,2‐b]thiophene) (pBTTT‐C₁₆), allows a systematic tuning of the blend morphology by varying the acceptor type and fraction, making it a well‐suited structural model for studying the fundamental processes in organic bulk heterojunction solar cells. To analyze the role of intercalated and pure fullerene domains on charge carrier photogeneration, time delayed collection field (TDCF) measurements and Fourier‐transform photocurrent spectroscopy (FTPS) are performed on pBTTT‐C₁₆:[6,6]‐phenyl‐C₆₁‐butyric acid methyl ester (PC₆₁BM) solar cells with various stoichiometries. A weak influence of excess photon energy on photogeneration along with a photogeneration having a weaker field dependence at increasing fullerene loading is found. The findings are assigned to a dissociation via thermalized charge transfer (CT) states supported by an enhanced electron delocalization along spatially extended PC₆₁BM nanophases that form in addition to a bimolecular crystal (BMC) for PC₆₁BM rich blends. The highly efficient transfer of charge carriers from the BMC into the pure domains are studied further by TDCF measurements performed on non‐intercalated pBTTT‐C₁₆:bisPC₆₁BM blends. They reveal a field dependent charge generation similar to the 1:4 PC₆₁BM blend, demonstrating that the presence of pure acceptor phases is the major driving force for an efficient, field independent CT dissociation.     

The Effect of Fluorination in Manipulating the Nanomorphology in PTB7:PC71BM Bulk Heterojunction Systems

The best performing low bandgap copolymers PTB series to date which is based on thieno[3,4‐b]thiophene‐alt‐benzodithiophene units blended with [6,6]‐phenyl‐C71‐butyric acid methyl ester (PC₇₁BM), have been the focus of polymer‐based solar cells. Here, novel fluorinated polymers PTB7‐Fx (fluorine units coupled with submonomer thieno[3,4‐b]thiophene) with varied degree of fluorination are used as electron donor materials. The PTB7‐Fx:PC₇₁BM bulk heterojunction (BHJ) films spin‐coated from the host solvent chlorobenzene without and with solvent additive 1,8‐diiodooctane (DIO) and the corresponding solar cell devices are systematically investigated to address the morphology‐efficiency relationship. Self‐assembled BHJ morphology is already observed for as‐spun blend films. After adding the solvent additive DIO, the pronounced ordered structures are suppressed and better intermixed films with much smaller domain sizes result. Full fluorination of the third C‐atom of thienothiophene gives rise to the highest power conversion efficiency. As the absorption properties, film morphology and crystallinity remain similar for different degrees of fluorination, the main influence of the photovoltaic performance is ascribed to the different lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of each polymer instead of the film morphology. Thus the device performance can be efficiently improved by tuning the energy level of the polymer without necessarily changing either the film nanomorphology or crystallinity dramatically.     

Quantifying the Nongeminate Recombination Dynamics in Nonfullerene Bulk Heterojunction Organic Solar Cells

In this study, a comprehensive analytical model to quantify the total nongeminate recombination losses, originating from bimolecular as well as bulk and surface trap‐assisted recombination mechanisms in nonfullerene‐based bulk heterojunction organic solar cells is developed. This proposed model is successfully employed to obtain the different contributions to the recombination current of the investigated solar cells under different illumination intensities. Additionally, the model quantitatively describes the experimentally measured open‐circuit voltage versus light intensity dependence. Most importantly, it is possible to calculate the experimental results with the same fitting parameter values from the presented model. The validity of this model is also proven by a combination of other independent, steady‐state, and transient experimental techniques. This new powerful analytical tool will enable researchers in the photovoltaic community to take into account the synergetic contribution from all relevant types of nongeminate recombination losses in different optoelectronic systems and target their analysis of recombination dynamics at any operating voltage.     

Understanding the Role of Thermal Processing in High Performance Solution Processed Small Molecule Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

Two similar structural versions of a molecular donor, in which two terminal hexyl‐substituted bithiophene units are connected to a central dithienosilole (DTS) through electron deficient thiadiazolopyridine (PT) units, and which differ only in the position of pyridyl N‐atoms, were explored to study the interplay of crystallization and vertical phase segregation as a result of annealing. The donor materials exhibit greatly contrasting photovoltaic performance despite similarity in molecule structure. The difference in position of the pyridal N‐atom which points away (distal configuration; compound 1) or towards (proximal configuration; compound 2) from the DTS core, modifies the aggregation/molecular packing in the solid state, resulting in differences in the phase segregation and formation of crystalline domains. A systematic study of the temperature dependence of photovoltaic performance reveals a parameter trade‐off: as annealing temperature increases, higher donor crystallinity and ordering results, but increased donor segregation near the surface or decrease in electrode selectivity also occurs, resulting in increased interfacial recombination and hence reduction in open‐circuit voltage (V_oc). The higher crystalline nature of 2 is found to have a higher impact on cell performance despite a competing undesired effect at the donor/aluminum cathode interface, contributing to its superior performance to 1 when blended with [6,6]phenyl‐C₆₁‐butyric acid methyl ester (PC₆₁BM). Molecule 2 exhibits a performance increase of a factor of two after thermal annealing at 100 °C, achieving a power conversion efficiency of 5.7%.     

Charge‐Carrier Mobility Requirements for Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells with High Fill Factor and External Quantum Efficiency >90%

To increase the efficiency of bulk heterojunction (BHJ) solar cells beyond 15%, 300 nm thick devices with 0.8 fill factor (FF) and external quantum efficiency (EQE) >90% are likely needed. This work demonstrates that numerical device simulators are a powerful tool for investigating charge‐carrier transport in BHJ devices and are useful for rapidly determining what semiconductor pro­perties are needed to reach these performance milestones. The electron and hole mobility in a BHJ must be ≈10^?2 cm² V^?1 s^?1 in order to attain a 0.8 FF in a 300 nm thick device with the recombination rate constant of poly(3‐hexyl­thiophene):[6,6]‐phenyl‐C61‐butyric acid methyl ester (P3HT:PCBM). Thus, the hole mobility of donor polymers needs to increase from ≈10^?4 to ≈10^?2 cm² V^?1 s^?1 in order to significantly improve device performance. Furthermore, the charge‐carrier mobility required for high FF is directly proportional to the BHJ recombination rate constant, which demonstrates that decreasing the recombination rate constant could dramatically improve the efficiency of optically thick devices. These findings suggest that researchers should prioritize improving charge‐carrier mobility when synthesizing new materials for BHJ solar cells and highlight that they should aim to understand what factors affect the recombination rate constant in these devices.     

Controlling Solution‐Phase Polymer Aggregation with Molecular Weight and Solvent Additives to Optimize Polymer‐Fullerene Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

The bulk heterojunction (BHJ) solar cell performance of many polymers depends on the polymer molecular weight (M _n) and the solvent additive(s) used for solution processing. However, the mechanism that causes these dependencies is not well understood. This work determines how M _n and solvent additives affect the performance of BHJ solar cells made with the polymer poly(di(2‐ethylhexyloxy)benzo[1,2‐b:4,5‐b′]dithiophene‐co‐octylthieno[3,4‐c]pyrrole‐4,6‐dione) (PBDTTPD). Low M _n PBDTTPD devices have exceedingly large fullerene‐rich domains, which cause extensive charge‐carrier recombination. Increasing the M _n of PBDTTPD decreases the size of these domains and significantly improves device performance. PBDTTPD aggregation in solution affects the size of the fullerene‐rich domains and this effect is linked to the dependency of PBDTTPD solubility on M _n. Due to its poor solubility high M _n PBDTTPD quickly forms a fibrillar polymer network during spin‐casting and this network acts as a template that prevents large‐scale phase separation. Furthermore, processing low M _n PBDTTPD devices with a solvent additive improves device performance by inducing polymer aggregation in solution and preventing large fullerene‐rich domains from forming. These findings highlight that polymer aggregation in solution plays a significant role in determining the morphology and performance of BHJ solar cells.     

Quantifying and Understanding Voltage Losses Due to Nonradiative Recombination in Bulk Heterojunction Organic Solar Cells with Low Energetic Offsets

Open‐circuit voltage (V_OC) losses in organic photovoltaics (OPVs) inhibit devices from reaching V_OC values comparable to the bandgap of the donor–acceptor blend. Specifically, nonradiative recombination losses (?V_nr) are much greater in OPVs than in silicon or perovskite solar cells, yet the origins of this are not fully understood. To understand what makes a system have high or low loss, an investigation of the nonradiative recombination losses in a total of nine blend systems is carried out. An apparent relationship is observed between the relative domain purity of six blends and the degree of nonradiative recombination loss, where films exhibiting relatively less pure domains show lower ?V_nr than films with higher domain purity. Additionally, it is shown that when paired with a fullerene acceptor, polymer donors which have bulky backbone units to inhibit close π–π stacking exhibit lower nonradiative recombination losses than in blends where the polymer can pack more closely. This work reports a strategy that ensures ?V_nr can be measured accurately and reports key observations on the relationship between ?V_nr and properties of the donor/acceptor interface.     

The Role of Photon Energy in Free Charge Generation in Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

To determine the role of photon energy on charge generation in bulk heterojunction solar cells, the bias voltage dependence of photocurrent for excitation with photon energies below and above the optical band gap is investigated in two structurally related polymer solar cells. Charges generated in (poly[2,6‐(4,4‐bis(2‐ethylhexyl)‐4H‐cyclopenta[2,1‐b;3,4‐b′′]dithiophene)‐alt‐4,7‐(2,1,3‐benzothia­diazole)] (C‐PCPDTBT):[6,6]‐phenyl‐C61‐butyric acid methyl ester (PCBM) solar cells via excitation of the low‐energy charge transfer (CT) state, situated below the optical band gap, need more voltage to be extracted than charges generated with excitation above the optical band gap. This indicates a lower effective binding energy of the photogenerated electrons and holes when the excitation is above the optical band gap than when excitation is to the bottom of the CT state. In blends of PCBM with the silicon‐analogue, poly[(4,4‐bis(2‐ethylhexyl)dithieno[3,2‐b:2′,3′‐d]silole)‐2,6‐diyl‐alt‐(2,1,3‐benzothiadiazole)‐4,7‐diyl] (Si‐PCPDTBT), there is no effect of the photon energy on the electric field dependence of the dissociation efficiency of the CT state. C‐PCPDTBT and Si‐PCPDTBT have very similar electronic properties, but their blends with PCBM differ in the nanoscale phase separation. The morphology is coarser and more crystalline in Si‐PCPDTBT:PCBM blends. The results demonstrate that the nanomorphological properties of the bulk heterojunction are important for determining the effective binding energy in the generation of free charges at the heterojunction.