Internal eliminated sequences interrupting the Oxytricha 81 locus: allelic divergence, conservation, conversions, and possible transposon origins

Internal eliminated sequences (IESs) often interrupt ciliate genes in the silent germline nucleus but are exactly excised and eliminated from the developing somatic nucleus from which genes are then expressed. Some long IESs are transposons, supporting the hypothesis that short IESs are ancient transposon relics. In light of that hypothesis and to explore the evolutionary history of a collection of IESs, we have compared various alleles of a particular locus (the 81 locus) of the ciliated protozoa Oxytricha trifallax and O. fallax. Three short IESs that interrupt two genes of the locus are found in alleles from both species, and thus must be relatively ancient, consistent with the hypothesis that short IESs are transposon relics. In contrast, TBE1 transposon interruptions of the locus are allele-specific and probably the results of recent transpositions. These IESs (and the TBE1s) are precisely excised from the DNA of the developing somatic macronucleus. Each IES interrupts a highly conserved sequence. A few nucleotides at the ends of each IES are also conserved, suggesting that they interact critically with IES excision machinery. However, most IES nucleotide positions have evolved at high rates, showing little or no selective constraint for function. Nonetheless, the length of each IES has been maintained (+/- 3 bp). While one IES is approximately 33 bp long, three other IESs have very similar sizes, approximately 70 bp long. Two IESs are surrounded by direct repeats of the sequence TTCTT. No other sequence similarities were found between any of the four IESs. However, the ends of one IES do match the inverted terminal repeat consensus sequence of the "TA" IESs of Paramecium. Three O. trifallax alleles appear to have been recipients in recent conversion events that could have been provoked by double-strand breaks associated with IES ends subsequent to IES transposition. Our findings support the hypothesis that short IESs evolved from ancient transposons that have lost most of their sequences, except those necessary for precise excision during macronuclear development.      

Evolution of internal eliminated segments and scrambling in the micronuclear gene encoding DNA polymerase alpha in two Oxytricha species.

To learn about the evolution of internal eliminated segments (IESs) and gene scrambling in hypotrichous ciliates we determined the structure of the micronuclear (germline) gene encoding DNA polymerasealpha(DNA polalpha) in Oxytricha trifallax and compared it to the previously published structure of the germline DNA polalphagene in Oxytricha nova . The DNA polalphagene of O.trifallax contains 51 macronuclear-destined segments (MDSs) separated by 50 IESs, compared to 45 MDSs and 44 IESs in the O.nova gene. This means that IESs and MDSs have been gained and/or lost during evolutionary divergence of the two species. Most of the MDSs are highly scrambled in a similar non-random pattern in the two species. We present a model to explain how IESs, non-scrambled MDSs and scrambled MDSs may be added and/or eliminated during evolution. Corresponding IESs in the two species differ totally in sequence, and junctions between MDSs and IESs are shifted by 1-18 bp in O.trifallax compared to the O.nova gene. In both species a short region of the gene is distantly separated from the main part of the gene. Comparison of the gene in the two species shows that IESs and scrambling are highly malleable over evolutionary time.     

A mutation in Paramecium tetraurelia reveals functional and structural features of developmentally excised DNA elements.

The excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs) from the germline micronuclear DNA occurs during the differentiation of a new macronuclear genome in ciliated protozoa. In Paramecium, IESs are generally short (28-882 bp), AT rich DNA elements that show few conserved sequence features with the exception of an inverted-terminal-repeat consensus sequence that has similarity to the ends of mariner/Tcl transposons (KLOBUTCHER and HERRICK 1995). We have isolated and analyzed a mutant cell line that cannot excise a 370-bp IESs (IES2591) from the coding region of the 51A variable surface protein gene. A single micronuclear C to T transition within the consensus sequence prevents excision. The inability to excise IES259 I has revealed a 28-bp IES inside the larger IES, suggesting that reiterative integration of these elements can occur. Together, the consensus sequence mutation and the evidence for reiterative integration support the theory that Paramecium IESs evolved from transposable elements. Unlike a previously studied Paramecium IES, the presence of this IES in the macronucleus does not completely inhibit excision of its Mild-type micronuclear copy through multiple sexual generations.     

The germline gene encoding DNA polymerase alpha in the hypotrichous ciliate Oxytricha nova is extremely scrambled.

We report the structure of the micronuclear (germline) gene encoding the large catalytic subunit of DNA polymerase alpha (DNA pol alpha) in the ciliate Oxytricha nova. It contains 44 internal eliminated segments (IESs) that divide the gene into 45 macronuclear-destined segments (MDSs) that are in a non-randomly scrambled order with an inversion near the gene center. Odd numbered MDSs 29-43, containing 230 bp out of a total of 4938 bp of macronuclear sequence, are missing from the 14 kb cloned gene. The missing MDSs have not been located but are at least several kilobases from the main body of the gene. The remarkably scrambled DNA pol alpha gene must be extensively cut, re-ordered and spliced and an inversion must occur to produce an unscrambled, functional version of the gene during development of a new macronucleus. Unscrambling is hypothesized to occur by a homologous recombination mechanism guided by repeat sequences at MDS ends.     

Evolution of the scrambled germline gene encoding α-telomere binding protein in three hypotrichous ciliates

The micronuclear genes encoding α-telomere-binding protein (αTP) in Oxytricha trifallax and Stylonychia mytilus contain multiple internal eliminated segments, or IESs, that divide the gene into multiple parts called macronuclear destined segments, or MDSs. The MDSs have become disordered, or scrambled, during evolution. The scrambled structures of the αTP genes in Oxytricha trifallax and S. mytilus have been compared with the previously published scrambled structure of the αTP gene in O. nova. The scrambled patterns of the αTP gene in the three species are similar but show significant differences. The micronuclear genes in O. nova and S. mytilus consist of 13 IESs and 14 MDSs, but the gene in O. trifallax is divided into three additional MDSs by the presence of three additional IESs, believed to have been inserted into the O. trifallaxαTP gene after divergence of O. trifallax from the other two species. Corresponding IESs among the three species have shifted along the DNA during evolution, presumably by a mutational mechanism that changes the short repeat sequences that flank IESs. The IESs also have changed markedly in length by insertion and/or deletion of nucleotides. Comparison of the putative αTP amino acid sequences in the three species reveals three conserved and three nonconserved domains. The 5′ nontranslated regions of the gene-sized molecules encoding αTP contain several conserved segments, and the 3′ nontranscribed trailer contains one conserved segment. Received: 29 May 1998; in revised form: 3 August 1998 / Accepted: 18 August 1998     

The evolutionary scrambling and developmental unscrambling of germline genes in hypotrichous ciliates.

Genes in the germline (micronuclear) genome of hypotrichous ciliates are interrupted by multiple, short, non-coding, AT-rich sequences called internal eliminated segments, or IESs. During conversion of a micronucleus to a somatic nucleus (macronucleus) after cell mating, all IESs are excised from the germline genes and the gene segments, called macronuclear-destined segments, or MDSs, are spliced. Excision of the approximately 150 000 IESs from a haploid germline genome in Oxytricha nova requires approximately 150 000 recombinant events. In three of 10 genes the MDSs are scrambled. During macronuclear development the MDSs are unscrambled, possibly by folding of the DNA to allow MDSs to ligate in the correct order. The nine MDSs in the actin I gene of O.nova are scrambled in the random order, 3-4-6-5-7-9-2-1-8, and MDS 2 is inverted. The 14 MDSs in the alphaTP gene of O.nova and Stylonychia mytilus are scrambled in the non-random order, 1-3-5-7-9-11-2-4-6-8-10-12-13-14. The 45 MDSs in the DNA pol alpha gene are non-randomly scrambled into an odd/even series, with an inversion of one-third of the gene. Additional IESs have been inserted into these three genes during evolution of Oxytricha trifallax, slightly modifying scrambling patterns. The non-random scrambled patterns in the alphaTP and DNA pol alpha genes are explained by multiple, simultaneous IES insertions. The randomly scrambled pattern in the actin I gene may arise from an initially non-randomly scrambled pattern by recombination among multiple IESs. Alternatively, IESs inserted sporadically (individually) in a non-scrambled configuration might subsequently recombine, converting a non-scrambled gene into a randomly scrambled one. IESs shift along a DNA molecule, most likely as a result of mutations at MDS/IES junctions. Shifting of IESs has the effect of 'transferring' nucleotides from one MDS to another, but does not change the overall sequence of nucleotides in the combined MDSs. In addition to shifting in position, IESs accumulate mutations at a high rate and increase and decrease in length within a species and during speciation. The phenomena of IESs and of MDS scrambling represent remarkable flexibility of the hypotrich genome, possibly reflecting a process of MDS shuffling that facilitates the evolution of genes.     

Developmentally programmed DNA splicing in Paramecium reveals short-distance crosstalk between DNA cleavage sites

Somatic genome assembly in the ciliate Paramecium involves the precise excision of thousands of short internal eliminated sequences (IESs) that are scattered throughout the germline genome and often interrupt open reading frames. Excision is initiated by double-strand breaks centered on the TA dinucleotides that are conserved at each IES boundary, but the factors that drive cleavage site recognition remain unknown. A degenerate consensus was identified previously at IES ends and genetic analyses confirmed the participation of their nucleotide sequence in efficient excision. Even for wild-type IESs, however, variant excision patterns (excised or nonexcised) may be inherited maternally through sexual events, in a homology-dependent manner. We show here that this maternal epigenetic control interferes with the targeting of DNA breaks at IES ends. Furthermore, we demonstrate that a mutation in the TA at one end of an IES impairs DNA cleavage not only at the mutant end but also at the wild-type end. We conclude that crosstalk between both ends takes place prior to their cleavage and propose that the ability of an IES to adopt an excision-prone conformation depends on the combination of its nucleotide sequence and of additional determinants.     

尖毛虫属Actin Ⅰ、α-TBP和DNA pol α乱序基因的模式研究

研究旨在对尖毛虫属内现有物种的3种乱序小核基因结构进行比较,探讨其乱序模式。于湛江湖光红树林水域中采集到一个尖毛虫属物种Oxytricha sp.（ZJ）,成功扩增了其肌动蛋白Ⅰ（ActinⅠ）、端粒结合蛋白（α-TBP）、DNA聚合酶α（DNA pol α）3个乱序基因的完整大核基因序列和完整/部分小核基因序列,并结合已有资料对比研究了尖毛虫属这3个乱序基因的进化。结果表明:（1）Oxytricha sp.（ZJ）与O.nova的小核Actin Ⅰ基因具有相同的乱序模式,区别于其余的尖毛虫属物种;在增加尖毛虫属物种的基础上,对前人推测提出了质疑,我们认为MDS-IES接合处移动现象在乱序MDSs之间并非比非乱序MDSs之间更保守。（2）Oxytricha sp.（ZJ）与O.nova的小核α-TBP基因具有相同乱序模式和相似长度的IESs。（3）Oxytricha sp.（ZJ）的小核DNA pol α基因乱序模式,区别于任一已报道物种,与属内O. trifallax最为相近。基于序列分析,在DNA pol α基因中发现了一例IES转换为MDS的痕迹,以及由此导致原先MDS的丢失。研究发现在编码区内IES向MDS的转变,使得本应删除的序列成为基因组永久保留的一部分。     

Identification of single nucleotide mutations that prevent developmentally programmed DNA elimination in Paramecium tetraurelia

The excision of internal eliminated sequences (IESs) occurs during the differentiation of a new somatic macronuclear genome in ciliated protozoa. In Paramecium tetraurelia, IESs show few conserved features with the exception of an invariant 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide that is part of an 8-bp inverted terminal repeat consensus sequence with similarity to the ends of mariner/Tc1 transposons. We have isolated and analyzed two mutant cell lines that are defective in excision of individual IESs in the A-51 surface antigen gene. Each cell line contains a mutation in the flanking 5'-TA-3' dinucleotide of IES6435 and IES1835 creating a 5'-CA-3' flanking sequence that prevents excision. The results demonstrate that the first position of the 5'-TA-3' is required IES excision just as previous mutants have shown that the second position (the A residue) is required. Combining these results with other Paramecium IES mutants suggests that there are few positions essential for IES excision in Paramecium. Analysis of many IESs reveals that there is a strong bias against particular nucleotides at some positions near the IES termini. Some of these strongly biased positions correspond to known IES mutations, others correlate with unusual features of excision.     

Homology-Dependent Maternal Inhibition of Developmental Excision of Internal Eliminated Sequences in Paramecium tetraurelia

Thousands of single-copy internal eliminated sequences (IESs) are excised from the germ line genome of ciliates during development of the polygenomic somatic macronucleus, following sexual events. Paramecium IESs are short, noncoding elements that frequently interrupt coding sequences. No absolutely conserved sequence element, other than flanking 5′-TA-3′ direct repeats, has been identified among sequenced IESs; the mechanisms of their specific recognition and precise elimination are unknown. Previous work has revealed the existence of an epigenetic control of excision. It was shown that the presence of one IES in the vegetative macronucleus results in a specific inhibition of the excision of the same element during the development of a new macronucleus, in the following sexual generation. We have assessed the generality and sequence specificity of this transnuclear maternal control by studying the effects of macronuclear transformation with 13 different IESs. We show that at least five of them can be maintained in the new macronuclear genome; sequence specificity is complete both between genes and between different IESs in the same gene. In all cases, the degree of excision inhibition correlates with the copy number of the maternal IES, but each IES shows a characteristic inhibition efficiency. Short internal IES-like segments were found to be excised from two of the IESs when excision between normal boundaries was inhibited. Available data suggest that the sequence specificity of these maternal effects is mediated by pairing interactions between homologous nucleic acids.     

Internal Eliminated Segments (IESs) of Oxytrichidae1

ABSTRACT Internal eliminated segments (IESs) are sequences that interrupt coding and noncoding regions of germline (micronuclear) genes of ciliated protozoa. IESs are flanked by short, unique repeat sequences, which are presumably required for precise IES excision during macronuclear development. Coding and noncoding segments of genes separated by IESs are called macronuclear-destined segments, or MDSs. We have compiled the characteristics of 89 individual IESs in 12 micronuclear genes in the Oxytricha and Stylonychia genera to define the IES phenomenon precisely, a first step in determining the origin, function and significance of IESs. Although all 89 IESs among the 12 different genes are AT-rich, they show no other similarity in sequence, length, position or number. Two main types of IESs are present. IESs that separate scrambled MDSs are significantly shorter and more frequent and have longer flanking repeat sequences than IESs that intervene between nonscrambled MDSs. A comparison of the nonscrambled gene encoding β-telomere binding protein in three species of hypotrichs shows that even in the same gene IESs are not conserved in sequence, length, position, or number from species to species. A comparison of IESs in the scrambled gene encoding actin I in the three species shows that the evolutionary behavior of IESs in a scrambled gene may be more constrained. However, IESs in the scrambled actin I gene have shifted along the DNA molecule during evolution. In total, the various studies show that IESs are hypermutable in sequence and length. They insert, excise, and shift along DNA molecules more or less randomly during evolution, with no discernible function or consequences.     

Volatility of internal eliminated segments in germ line genes of hypotrichous ciliates.

Germ line micronuclear genes in ciliated protozoa contain two types of interrupting sequences. Some genes contain introns, but internal eliminated segments (IESs) are much more prevalent. IESs are AT-rich DNA segments that separate macronucleus-destined segments (MDSs) in micronuclear genes. All IESs are excised and destroyed when a micronucleus develops into a macronucleus after each cell mating. IESs have no discernible function. Therefore, an investigation of the behavior of IESs in evolution has been undertaken to assess their possible significance. The IESs in the micronuclear gene encoding the beta-subunit of the telomere-binding protein (beta-TP) are not conserved in number, position, sequence, or length during the evolution of four oxytrichid ciliates. In contrast, the scrambled pattern of MDSs and IESs of the micronuclear actin I gene has been conserved during evolution; however, the precise positions, sequences, and lengths of the IESs differ among species, and in some organisms the actin I gene contains an additional IES and MDS. Corresponding IESs in the actin I genes among the different organisms have shifted positions by 1 to 14 bp, presumably by a mutation-shifting mechanism, creating differences in the repeat sequences flanking IESs. Thus, conservation of a particular repeat sequence among species is not required for IES excision. The changes in IES number and position in the beta-TP genes among ciliates are in sharp contrast to the stability of the intron position. Therefore, IESs are volatile, hypermutable elements that are inserted, removed, shifted, and modified continuously in the germ line through evolutionary time.     

Template-guided recombination for IES elimination and unscrambling of genes in stichotrichous ciliates

The micronuclear versions of genes in stichotrichous ciliates are interrupted by multiple, short, non-coding DNA segments called internal eliminated segments, or IESs. IESs divide a gene into macronuclear destined segments, or MDSs. In some micronuclear genes MDSs are in a scrambled disorder. During development of a micronucleus into a macronucleus after cell mating the IESs are excised from micronuclear genes and the MDSs are spliced in the sequentially correct order. Pairs of short repeat sequences in the ends of MDSs undergo homologous recombination to excise IESs and splice MDSs. However, the repeat sequences are too short to guide unambiguously their own alignment in preparation for recombination. Based on experiments by others on the distantly related ciliate, Paramecium, we propose a molecular model of template-guided recombination to explain the excision of the 100,000-150,000 IESs and splicing of MDSs, including unscrambling, in the genome of stichotrichous ciliates. The model solves the problem of correct pairing of pointers, precisely identifies MDS-IES junctions, and provides for irreversible recombination.     

Cis-acting requirements in flanking DNA for the programmed elimination of mse2.9: a common mechanism for deletion of internal eliminated sequences from the developing macronucleus of Tetrahymena thermophila

During macronuclear development in the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila, extensive DNA deletions occur, eliminating thousands of internal eliminated sequences (IESs). Using an rDNA-based transformation assay we have analyzed the role during DNA deletion of DNA flanking mse2.9, an IES within the second intron of a gene encoding an as yet incompletely characterized protein. We establish that a cis-acting sequence for mse2.9 deletion acts at a distance to specify deletion boundaries. A complex sequence element necessary for efficient and accurate mse2.9 deletion is located in the region 47–81 bp from the right side of mse2.9. The ability of a variety of IES flanking sequences to rescue a processing deficient mse2.9 construct indicates that some cis-acting signal is shared among different IESs. In addition, the short intronic sequence that flanks mse2.9 is able to direct efficient and accurate processing. Despite no obvious sequence similarity between mse2.9 and other IESs, we suggest that a common mechanism is used to delete different families of IESs in Tetrahymena.     

A Comparison of Internal Eliminated Sequences in the Genes that Encode Two K+-Channel Isoforms in Paramecium tetraurelia

We examined both the somatic (macro-) and the germinal (micronuclear) DNAs that encode two K⁺-channel isoforms. PAK1 and PAK11 , in Paramecium tetraurelia. The coding regions of these two isoforms are 88% identical in nucleotides and 95% identical in amino acids. Their introns are also highly conserved. Even some of the internal eliminated sequences in PAK1 and PAK11 are clearly related. PAK1 has five IESs; PAK11 has four. The first (5'-most) IESs of the two genes are located at the same site in the coding sequence but differ in size. The 2nd IES in PAK1 (206-bp), the largest among the nine IESs, has no PAK11 counterpart. The 3rd, 4th and 5th IESs in PAK1 have a counterpart in PAK11 that is similar in size and in sequence, and identical in its position in the coding sequence. In addition, the first IES of PAK11 bears some resemblance to the 4th one of PAK1. The similarities and differences between the two sets of IESs are discussed with respect to the origin and divergence of the two K⁺-channel isoforms.     

Massive colonization of protein-coding exons by selfish genetic elements in Paramecium germline genomes

Ciliates are unicellular eukaryotes with both a germline genome and a somatic genome in the same cytoplasm. The somatic macronucleus (MAC), responsible for gene expression, is not sexually transmitted but develops from a copy of the germline micronucleus (MIC) at each sexual generation. In the MIC genome of Paramecium tetraurelia, genes are interrupted by tens of thousands of unique intervening sequences called internal eliminated sequences (IESs), which have to be precisely excised during the development of the new MAC to restore functional genes. To understand the evolutionary origin of this peculiar genomic architecture, we sequenced the MIC genomes of 9 Paramecium species (from approximately 100 Mb in Paramecium aurelia species to >1.5 Gb in Paramecium caudatum). We detected several waves of IES gains, both in ancestral and in more recent lineages. While the vast majority of IESs are single copy in present-day genomes, we identified several families of mobile IESs, including nonautonomous elements acquired via horizontal transfer, which generated tens to thousands of new copies. These observations provide the first direct evidence that transposable elements can account for the massive proliferation of IESs in Paramecium. The comparison of IESs of different evolutionary ages indicates that, over time, IESs shorten and diverge rapidly in sequence while they acquire features that allow them to be more efficiently excised. We nevertheless identified rare cases of IESs that are under strong purifying selection across the aurelia clade. The cases examined contain or overlap cellular genes that are inactivated by excision during development, suggesting conserved regulatory mechanisms. Similar to the evolution of introns in eukaryotes, the evolution of Paramecium IESs highlights the major role played by selfish genetic elements in shaping the complexity of genome architecture and gene expression.

A comparative genomics study of nine Paramecium species reveals successful invasion of genes by transposable elements in their germline genomes, showing that the internal eliminated sequences (IESs) followed an evolutionary trajectory remarkably similar to that of spliceosomal introns.     

Tec3, a new developmentally eliminated DNA element in Euplotes crassus

More than 100,000 interstitial segments of DNA (internal eliminated sequences [IESs]) are excised from the genome during the formation of a new macronucleus in Euplotes crassus. IESs include unique sequence DNA as well as two related families of transposable elements, Tec1 and Tec2. Here we describe a new class of E. crassus transposons, Tec3, which is present in 20 to 30 copies in the micronuclear genome. Tec3 elements have long inverted terminal repeats and contain a degenerate open reading frame encoding a tyrosine-type recombinase. One characterized copy of Tec3 (Tec3-1) is 4.48 kbp long, has 1.23-kbp inverted terminal repeats, and resides within the micronuclear copy of the ribosomal protein L29 gene (RPL29). The 23 bp at the extreme ends of this element are very similar to those in other E. crassus IESs and, like these other IESs, Tec3-1 is excised during the polytene chromosome stage of macronuclear development to generate a free circular form with an unusual junction structure. In contrast, a second cloned element, Tec3-2, is quite similar to Tec3-1 but lacks the terminal 258 bp of the inverted repeats, so that its ends do not resemble the other E. crassus IES termini. The Tec3-2 element appears to reside in a large segment of the micronuclear genome that is subject to developmental elimination. Models for the origins of these two types of Tec3 elements are presented, along with a discussion of how some members of this new transposon family may have come to be excised by the same machinery that removes other E. crassus IESs.     

A novel chromodomain protein, pdd3p, associates with internal eliminated sequences during macronuclear development in Tetrahymena thermophila

Conversion of the germ line micronuclear genome into the genome of a somatic macronucleus in Tetrahymena thermophila requires several DNA rearrangement processes. These include (i) excision and subsequent elimination of several thousand internal eliminated sequences (IESs) scattered throughout the micronuclear genome and (ii) breakage of the micronuclear chromosomes into hundreds of DNA fragments, followed by de novo telomere addition to their ends. Chromosome breakage sequences (Cbs) that determine the sites of breakage and short regions of DNA adjacent to them are also eliminated. Both processes occur concomitantly in the developing macronucleus. Two stage-specific protein factors involved in germ line DNA elimination have been described previously. Pdd1p and Pdd2p (for programmed DNA degradation) physically associate with internal eliminated sequences in transient electron-dense structures in the developing macronucleus. Here, we report the purification, sequence analysis, and characterization of Pdd3p, a novel developmentally regulated, chromodomain-containing polypeptide. Pdd3p colocalizes with Pdd1p in the peripheral regions of DNA elimination structures, but is also found more internally. DNA cross-linked and immunoprecipitated with Pdd1p- or Pdd3p-specific antibodies is enriched in IESs, but not Cbs, suggesting that different protein factors are involved in elimination of these two groups of sequences.     

Micronuclear and macronuclear forms of beta-tubulin genes in the ciliate Chilodonella uncinata reveal insights into genome processing and protein evolution

Chilodonella uncinata, like all ciliates, contains two distinct nuclei in every cell: a germline micronucleus and a somatic macronucleus. During development of the macronucleus from a zygotic nucleus, the genome is processed in several ways, including elimination of internal sequences. In this study, we analyze micronuclear and macronuclear copies of beta-tubulin in C. uncinata and find at least four divergent paralogs of beta-tubulin in the macronucleus. We characterize the micronuclear version of one paralog and compare its internally eliminated sequences (IESs) with previously described IESs in this species. These comparisons reveal the presence of a conserved sequence motif within IESs. In addition, we compare the sequences of beta-tubulin from C. uncinata with other ciliates and to other alveolates in order to test the hypothesis that the mode of molecular evolution in ciliates obscures phylogenetic signal in protein-coding genes. We find that heterogeneous rates of substitution in beta-tubulin across ciliates result in unstable genealogies that are inconsistent with phylogenies based on small subunit rDNA genes and on ultrastructure. We discuss the implications of our findings for genome processing and protein evolution in ciliates.