The chick's marginal zone and primitive streak formation. II. Quantification of the marginal zone's potencies--temporal and spatial aspects

When a posterior fragment of the chick's marginal zone (PM) was exchanged with equal sized lateral marginal zone fragment (LM), of the same blastoderm, its capacity to initiate an ectopic primitive streak (PS) was found to be both size and stage dependent. Good correlation was demonstrated between the areas of PM fragments and the number of cells they contained. In stage X blastoderms, PM fragments containing less than 1200 cells were incapable of initiating an ectopic PS. Transplanted PMs containing between 1200 and 1500 cells initiated a lateral ectopic PS in 50% of the cases, while in the other 50% a posterior PS developed from the original posterior side. PMs containing 1500 cells or more in all cases initiating an ectopic PS and inhibited the formation of a posterior PS. At stage XI, laterally transplanted PMs containing less than 1800 cells were not effective. Stage XI PMs containing 1800-2300 cells in some cases succeeded in initiating a lateral ectopic PS, in addition to the posterior one. Stage XI PMs containing 2300 cells or more invariably promoted the development of an ectopic PS, but were unable to suppress the formation of a posterior PS, so that two PSs developed in the same blastoderm, one posterior and one ectopic. When a stage XI PM fragment was laterally transplanted into a younger, stage X blastoderm, the minimal effective cell number needed to initiate an ectopic PS increased to at least 3000 cells, again without inhibiting the formation of a posterior PS. The inductive potential of a stage X PM is therefore at least twice that of a stage XI PM. The marginal zone belt of stage X blastoderms was checked for the decrease in its developmental potential from the posterior to the lateral side by evaluating its effect on the developmental expression of two competing stage X PMs, one located posteriorly and the other inserted laterally. The developmental expression of the laterally inserted PM was consistently inferior to that of the posterior PM. The developmental expression of each PM was not related to absolute size, but depended on the size ratio of lateral PM/posterior PM. When the ratio was 1.2 or less, only posterior PSs developed. When the ratio was 1.3-1.4, three different results were encountered: (1) only a posterior PS, (2) posterior plus lateral, and (3) only lateral PS. When the ratio was 1.5 or more, only a lateral PS developed, which suppressed the posterior PS.     

The marginal zone and its contribution to the hypoblast and primitive streak of the chick embryo

The marginal zone of the chick embryo has been shown to play an important role in the formation of the hypoblast and of the primitive streak. In this study, time-lapse filming, fate mapping, ablation and transplantation experiments were combined to study its contribution to these structures. It was found that the deep (endodermal) portion of the posterior marginal zone contributes to the hypoblast and to the junctional endoblast, while the epiblast portion of the same region contributes to the epiblast of the primitive streak and to the definitive (gut) endoderm derived from it. Within the deep part of the posterior marginal zone, a subpopulation of HNK-1-positive cells contributes to the hypoblast. Removal of the deep part of the marginal zone prevents regeneration of the hypoblast but not the formation of a primitive streak. Removal of both layers of the marginal zone leads to a primitive streak of abnormal morphology but mesendodermal cells nevertheless differentiate. These results show that the two main properties of the posterior marginal zone (contributing to the hypoblast and controlling the site of primitive streak formation) are separable, and reside in different germ layers. This conclusion does not support the idea that the influence of the posterior marginal zone on the development of axial structures is due to it being the source of secondary hypoblast cells.     

Rauber's sickle and not the caudal marginal zone induces a primitive streak, blood vessels, blood cell formation and coelomic vesicles in avian blastoderms

By using the quail-chicken chimera technique, we studied the reactivity and the eventual developmental or inducing capacities of the avian caudal marginal zone (in comparison with Rauber's sickle), when associated in vitro with different avian blastoderm components. If a fragment of quail sickle endoblast is placed on the caudal marginal zone of a whole unincubated chicken blastoderm, then a secondary miniature embryo will develop in this caudal marginal zone. The primitive streak and accompanying neural plate of the secondary embryo are directed peripherally into the caudal germ wall, away from Rauber's sickle. Thus, the 'mirror image development' indicates that the upper layer of the caudal marginal zone can react in the same way as the upper layer of the area centralis, because of the presence of sickle endoblast. A quail Rauber's sickle fragment placed on an isolated anti-sickle region always induces a primitive streak directed centrally. After prolonged culture, blood vessels and associated coelomic vesicles are formed. By contrast if a quail caudal marginal zone is placed on an isolated chicken anti-sickle region, the primitive streak, blood vessels and coelomic vesicles do not form. Thus, in contrast to the inducing effect of Rauber's sickle, the caudal marginal zone has no inducing effect by itself, even in the absence of the dominating effect of Rauber's sickle.     

5-Bromodeoxyuridine inhibition of the epiblast competence for primitive streak formation in the young chick blastoderm

The competence of stage XIII chick epiblast which under the influence of an inductive hypoblast is directed to form a normal primitive streak, is affected by 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR). The BUdR-treated epiblast forms an atypical primitive streak and no axial mesoderm. However, a nonorganized mesenchymal layer is formed between the epiblast and the hypoblast, and atypical neural tissue in the epiblast. BUdR interferes neither with hypoblast formation nor with its inductivity even when blastoderms are treated with BUdR as early as uterine stage VIII and later.     

Analysis of tissue flow patterns during primitive streak formation in the chick embryo

We have investigated the patterns of tissue flow underlying the formation of the primitive streak in the chick embryo. Analysis of time-lapse sequences of brightfield images to extract the tissue velocity field and of fluorescence images of small groups of DiI-labelled cells have shown that epiblast cells move in two large-scale counter-rotating streams, which merge at the site of streak formation. Despite the large-scale tissue flows, individual cells appear to move little relative to their neighbours. As the streak forms, it elongates in both the anterior and posterior directions. Inhibition of actin polymerisation via local application of the inhibitor latrunculin A immediately terminates anterior extension of the streak tip, but does not prevent posterior elongation. Inhibition of actin polymerisation at the base of the streak completely inhibits streak formation, implying that continuous movement of cells into the base of the forming streak is crucial for extension. Analysis of cycling cells in the early embryo shows that cell-cycle progression in the epiblast is quite uniform before the primitive streak forms then decreases in the central epiblast and incipient streak and increases at the boundary between the area pellucida and area opaca during elongation. The cell-cycle inhibitor aphidicolin, at concentrations that completely block cell-cycle progression, permits initial streak formation but arrests development during extension. Our analysis suggests that cell division maintains the cell-flow pattern that supplies the streak with cells from the lateral epiblast, which is critical for epiblast expansion in peripheral areas, but that division does not drive streak formation or the observed tissue flow.     

Interactions between Wnt and Vg1 signalling pathways initiate primitive streak formation in the chick embryo

The posterior marginal zone (PMZ) of the chick embryo has Nieuwkoop centre-like properties: when transplanted to another part of the marginal zone, it induces a complete embryonic axis, without making a cellular contribution to the induced structures. However, when the PMZ is removed, the embryo can initiate axis formation from another part of the remaining marginal zone. Chick Vg1 can mimic the axis-inducing ability of the PMZ, but only when misexpressed somewhere within the marginal zone. We have investigated the properties that define the marginal zone as a distinct region. We show that the competence of the marginal zone to initiate ectopic primitive streak formation in response to cVg1 is dependent on Wnt activity. First, within the Wnt family, only Wnt8C is expressed in the marginal zone, in a gradient decreasing from posterior to anterior. Second, misexpression of Wnt1 in the area pellucida enables this region to form a primitive streak in response to cVg1. Third, the Wnt antagonists Crescent and Dkk-1 block the primitive streak-inducing ability of cVg1 in the marginal zone. These findings suggest that Wnt activity defines the marginal zone and allows cVg1 to induce an axis. We also present data suggesting some additional complexity: first, the Vg1 and Wnt pathways appear to regulate the expression of downstream components of each other's pathway; and second, misexpression of different Wnt antagonists suggests that different classes of Wnts may cooperate with each other to regulate axis formation in the normal embryo.     

C-Reactive protein (CRP)-mediated inhibition of the induction of in vitro antibody formation. I. T-cell dependence of the inhibition.

Purified human C-reactive protein (CRP) inhibited the in vitro anti-hapten antibody plaque-forming cells (PFC) response of both carrier keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH)-primed and unimmunized Balb/c spleen cells to TNP-KLH. The inhibitory effect was neutralized by the CRP-substrate, C-polysaccharide. The response to the T-independent antigens, TNP-T4 and DNP-lys-Ficoll, was not inhibited by CRP. A cell population that was suppressive for the in vitro PFC response was generated by incubating normal spleen cells with CRP. These cells suppressed the PFC response of syngeneic KLH-primed cells to TNP-KLH in proportion to the number of added lymphoid cells with bound CRP. Selective depletion of B cells, T cells or macrophages before incubation with CRP revealed that T cells were required for the induction of suppressive cells. Treatment of spleen cells after incubation with CRP, with T cell-specific antisera and C abolished suppressor-cell activity. Mitomycin-C treatment of the CRP-binding cells did not alter their suppressive activity. These results indicated that CRP mediates suppression of antibody induction to T-dependent antigens by interacting with T cells and generating a suppressive T-cell population.     

Tsukushi cooperates with VG1 to induce primitive streak and Hensen's node formation in the chick embryo

Three classes of signaling molecule, VG1, WNT and BMP, play crucial roles in axis formation in the chick embryo. Although VG1 and WNT signals have a pivotal function in inducing the primitive streak and Hensen's node in the embryo midline, their action is complemented by that of BMP antagonists that protect the prospective axial tissue from the inhibitory influence of BMPs secreted from the periphery. We have previously reported that a secreted factor, chick Tsukushi (TSK), is expressed in the primitive streak and Hensen's node, where it works as a BMP antagonist. Here, we describe a new crucial function for TSK in promoting formation of the primitive streak and Hensen's node by positively regulating VG1 activity. We provide evidence that TSK directly binds VG1 in vitro, and that TSK and VG1 functionally interact in axis formation, as shown by biological assays performed in chick and Xenopus embryos. Furthermore, we show that alternative splicing of TSK RNA leads to the formation of two isoforms (TSKA, originally designated as TSK, and TSKB) that differ in their C-terminal region. Biochemical and biological assays indicate that TSKB is a much weaker BMP antagonist than TSKA, although both isoforms efficiently interact with VG1. Remarkably, although both TSKA and TSKB are expressed throughout the early extending primitive streak, their expression patterns diverge during gastrulation. TSKA expression concentrates in Hensen's node, a well-known source of anti-BMP signals, whereas TSKB accumulates in the middle primitive streak (MPS), a region known to work as a node-inducing center where VG1 expression is also specifically localized. Loss-of-function experiments demonstrate that TSKB, but not TSKA, function is required in the MPS for induction of Hensen's node. Taken together, these results indicate that TSK isoforms play a crucial role in chick axis formation by locally modulating VG1 and BMP activities during gastrulation.     

The ECM moves during primitive streak formation--computation of ECM versus cellular motion

Galileo described the concept of motion relativity--motion with respect to a reference frame--in 1632. He noted that a person below deck would be unable to discern whether the boat was moving. Embryologists, while recognizing that embryonic tissues undergo large-scale deformations, have failed to account for relative motion when analyzing cell motility data. A century of scientific articles has advanced the concept that embryonic cells move ("migrate") in an autonomous fashion such that, as time progresses, the cells and their progeny assemble an embryo. In sharp contrast, the motion of the surrounding extracellular matrix scaffold has been largely ignored/overlooked. We developed computational/optical methods that measure the extent embryonic cells move relative to the extracellular matrix. Our time-lapse data show that epiblastic cells largely move in concert with a sub-epiblastic extracellular matrix during stages 2 and 3 in primitive streak quail embryos. In other words, there is little cellular motion relative to the extracellular matrix scaffold--both components move together as a tissue. The extracellular matrix displacements exhibit bilateral vortical motion, convergence to the midline, and extension along the presumptive vertebral axis--all patterns previously attributed solely to cellular "migration." Our time-resolved data pose new challenges for understanding how extracellular chemical (morphogen) gradients, widely hypothesized to guide cellular trajectories at early gastrulation stages, are maintained in this dynamic extracellular environment. We conclude that models describing primitive streak cellular guidance mechanisms must be able to account for sub-epiblastic extracellular matrix displacements.     

A hierarchy of gene expression accompanying induction of the primitive streak by Vg1 in the chick embryo

In the chick embryo, two secreted factors have recently be shown to cooperate in inducing the first axial structure, the primitive streak: cWnt8C (normally expressed around the circumference of the embryo, in the marginal zone) and the TGF beta superfamily member cVg1 (expressed in the posterior part of the marginal zone) (Development 128 (2001) 2915). Misexpression of Vg1 in the anterior marginal zone induces an ectopic primitive streak and recapitulates the morphological changes associated with normal primitive streak formation. Here, we analyse the time-course of appearance and disappearance of expression of 12 genes (cVg1, Lef1, Nodal, FGF8, cWnt8C, cBra, cNot1, goosecoid, HNF3 beta, Chordin, Otx2 and Sox3, whose normal expression is also polarized at early stages of development) in response to cVg1 misexpression in the anterior marginal zone. We show that a hierarchy of gene expression accompanies induction of the ectopic axis, reminiscent of the order in which the same genes begin to be expressed in the normal embryo.     

Protein synthesis in epiblast versus hypoblast during the critical stages of induction and growth of the primitive streak in the chick embryo.

In the chick the inducing power of the hypoblast for primitive streak was assumed to reach its maximum at the beginning of the primitive streak stage and to last until its completion. It was therefore of interest to trace the protein synthetic activity of the epiblast and hypoblast during five successive developmental stages and to correlate them with the known morphogenetic events.The investigation was done along two lines: 1) A quantitative survey was made of the uptake of tritiated phenylalanine into epiblasts versus hypoblasts and their incorporation into trichloroacetic acid-precipitable protein. 2) Incorporation of label into protein was followed by a comparative investigation of the electropherograms of epiblast versus hypoblast at the different stages.The quantitative survey has shown an almost uniform and rather low incorporation of label into protein in the hypoblast layer with a very short period of doubled activity between full hypoblast and initial primitive streak (p.s.). During this period the inductive capacity of the hypoblast for primitive streak was supposed to reach its maximal value.The qualitative survey indicated different patterns of incorporation in the two layers studied. Of special interest are two peaks (III and IV) which appear in the hypoblast previous to p.s. formation at the time of its augmented synthetic activity which also coincides with the onset of its inductive capacity. At later stages two similar peaks appear in the epiblast. It is suggested that a protein included in the above peaks might represent the inductor of the primitive streak.     

Mitotic cells and their microappendages in the primitive streak of the chick embryo.

Fresh pullet eggs (White Leghorn Strain) were incubated to the primitive streak stage of development. Blastoderms were fixed in situ with isotonic aldehyde fixatives and prepared for scanning electron miscropy by means of post-osmication, critical point drying and gold-palladium coating. Cells judged to be in various stages of mitosis by their surface contours were numerous on the ventral surface of the chick blastoderm. Cells which were in the late preparatory stages for mitosis had rounded up from their surroundings. Microvilli dominated the surface. The degree of separation and number of microvilli increased until late metaphase or anaphase. Mitotic cells did not completely separate themselves from adjacent cells. Ruffles and blebs were not prominent during mitotis and long filopodia were absent. A definite localization of microappendages (microvilli, blebs, ruffles) to the area of cytokinesis was evident in early telophase and persisted through daughter cell formation.     

The marginal zone and marginal sinus in the spleen of the gerbil. A light and electron microscopy study

The spleen of the adult gerbil (M. unguiculatus) is characterized by the absence of venous sinuses and ellipsoid sheaths. The follicle (white pulp) is separated from the surrounding red pulp by a distinct marginal zone. The cell types in the marginal zone are common to both the follicle and red pulp. Separating the marginal zone from the follicle is a vascular channel of capillary dimension, the marginal sinus. A number of terminal segments of the arterial vessels within the follicle were observed to form a direct connection with the marginal sinus. Ultrastructurally, discontinuities were evident within the walls of the marginal sinus that would permit passage of both cellular and plasma components from the marginal sinus to either marginal zone or the follicle.     

Antagonism of Nodal signaling by BMP/Smad5 prevents ectopic primitive streak formation in the mouse amnion

The strength and spatiotemporal activity of Nodal signaling is tightly controlled in early implantation mouse embryos, including by autoregulation and feedback loops, and involves secreted and intracellular antagonists. These control mechanisms, which are established at the extra-embryonic/embryonic interfaces, are essential for anterior-posterior patterning of the epiblast and correct positioning of the primitive streak. Formation of an ectopic primitive streak, or streak expansion, has previously been reported in mutants lacking antagonists that target Nodal signaling. Here, we demonstrate that loss-of-function of a major bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) effector, Smad5, results in formation of an ectopic primitive streak-like structure in mutant amnion accompanied by ectopic Nodal expression. This suggests that BMP/Smad5 signaling contributes to negative regulation of Nodal. In cultured cells, we find that BMP-activated Smad5 antagonizes Nodal signaling by interfering with the Nodal-Smad2/4-Foxh1 autoregulatory pathway through the formation of an unusual BMP4-induced Smad complex containing Smad2 and Smad5. Quantitative expression analysis supports that ectopic Nodal expression in the Smad5 mutant amnion is induced by the Nodal autoregulatory loop and a slow positive-feedback loop. The latter involves BMP4 signaling and also induction of ectopic Wnt3. Ectopic activation of these Nodal feedback loops in the Smad5 mutant amnion results in the eventual formation of an ectopic primitive streak-like structure. We conclude that antagonism of Nodal signaling by BMP/Smad5 signaling prevents primitive streak formation in the amnion of normal mouse embryos.     

Hepten inhibitors of the endogenous galactose binding lectins and anti-lectin antibodies inhibit primitive streak formation in the early chick embryo

The early chick blastoderm expresses two endogenous galactose-bindinglectins of 14 kDa and 16 kDa. We have studied the effect thelectin hapten inhibitors thiodigalactoside and the syntheticneoglycoprotein lactosyl-bovine serum albumin as well as polyclonalanti-lectin antibodies on the development of early chick embryoscultured in a defined medium. Controls consisted of maltose,maltosyl bovine serum albumin and rabbit IgG. Embryos treatedat the onset of cell migration during early gastrulation underwentblastoderm retraction with decrease in surface area. In addition,they exhibited a lack of demarcation between the presumptiveembryonic area (area pellucida) and the presumptive extraembryonicarea (area opaca). These blastoderms also lacked a primitivestreak, that is, the structure that forms in the area pellucidaduring gastrulation as cell migrate to form the endodermal andmesodermal layers of the embryo. Embryos treated at later stagesof gastrulation showed development similar to that of controlsin that they were able to undergo early organogenesis. The resultssuggest that lectin mediated mechanisms are essential for themigratory movements of early gastrulation and that, at lategastrulation, other mechanisms exist in the embryo to compensatefor lectin function. blastoderm chick embryo galectin     

FGF signaling regulates mesoderm cell fate specification and morphogenetic movement at the primitive streak.

Although FGF signaling plays an integral role in the migration and patterning of mesoderm at gastrulation, the mechanism and downstream targets of FGF activity have remained elusive. Here, we demonstrate that FGFR1 orchestrates the epithelial to mesenchymal transition and morphogenesis of mesoderm at the primitive streak by controlling Snail and E-cadherin expression. Furthermore, we show that FGFR1 functions in mesoderm cell fate specification by positively regulating Brachyury and Tbx6 expression. Finally, we provide evidence that the attenuation of Wnt3a signaling observed in Fgfr1 -/- embryos can be rescued by lowering E-cadherin levels. We propose that modulation of cytoplasmic beta-catenin levels, associated with FGF-induced downregulation of E-cadherin, provides a molecular link between FGF and Wnt signaling pathways at the streak.     

The hypoblast of the chick embryo positions the primitive streak by antagonizing nodal signaling

The hypoblast (equivalent to the mouse anterior visceral endoderm) of the chick embryo plays a role in regulating embryonic polarity. Surprisingly, hypoblast removal causes multiple embryonic axes to form, suggesting that it emits an inhibitor of axis formation. We show that Cerberus (a multifunctional antagonist of Nodal, Wnt, and BMP signaling) is produced by the hypoblast and inhibits primitive streak formation. This activity is mimicked by Cerberus-Short (CerS), which only inhibits Nodal. Nodal misexpression can initiate an ectopic primitive streak, but only when the hypoblast is removed. We propose that, during normal development, the primitive streak forms only when the hypoblast is displaced away from the posterior margin by the endoblast, which lacks Cerberus.