Mammalian sex chromosomes: design or accident?

Mammalian sex chromosomes evolved (and are still evolving) from a homomorphic pair by the progressive loss of active genes from the Y chromosome. Among the changes that have accompanied this differentiation, it is difficult to determine causes, effects and correlates. Comparative studies suggest that the choice of a gene, and thus a chromosome pair, to control the sex-determining pathway may be quite arbitrary, and that sex chromosomes and sex-determining genes are more likely to be the products of random changes than the products of selection for function.     

Apoptosis: suicide, execution or murder?

Apoptosis, a controlled form of cell death, appears to be regulated in several ways. Early studies indicated that de novo protein synthesis was required for apoptosis of thymocytes, but more recent studies have found that other cells can undergo apoptosis when protein synthesis is blocked or that inhibition of protein or RNA synthesis can induce apoptosis. Whether these findings reflect distinct forms of apoptosis or variations on a single pathway is not yet known. In this article the case for a single pathway to apoptosis, accessible at multiple points, is discussed.     

Phagocyte-derived reactive species: salvation or suicide?

Activated phagocytes produce "reactive oxygen, halogen and nitrogen species" that help to kill some types of microorganism. How these species destroy microorganisms remains, however, an enigma: both direct oxidative damage and indirect damage (whereby reactive species promote the actions of other antibacterial agents) are involved, and no single mechanism is likely to account for the killing of all microorganisms. Phagocyte-derived reactive species are known to injure human tissues and to contribute to inflammation. Recently, however, we have learned that they can also be anti-inflammatory by modulating the immune response. These data have implications for the proposed use of antioxidants to treat inflammation.     

Methylglyoxal production in bacteria: suicide or survival?

Methylglyoxal is a toxic electrophile. In Escherichia coli cells, the principal route of methylglyoxal production is from dihydroxyacetone phosphate by the action of methylglyoxal synthase. The toxicity of methylglyoxal is believed to be due to its ability to interact with the nucleophilic centres of macromolecules such as DNA. Bacteria possess an array of detoxification pathways for methylglyoxal. In E. coli, glutathione-based detoxification is central to survival of exposure to methylglyoxal. The glutathione-dependent glyoxalase I-II pathway is the primary route of methylglyoxal detoxification, and the glutathione conjugates formed can activate the KefB and KefC potassium channels. The activation of these channels leads to a lowering of the intracellular pH of the bacterial cell, which protects against the toxic effects of electrophiles. In addition to the KefB and KefC systems, E. coli cells are equipped with a number of independent protective mechanisms whose purpose appears to be directed at ensuring the integrity of the DNA. A model of how these protective mechanisms function will be presented. The production of methylglyoxal by cells is a paradox that can be resolved by assigning an important role in adaptation to conditions of nutrient imbalance. Analysis of a methylglyoxal synthase-deficient mutant provides evidence that methylglyoxal production is required to allow growth under certain environmental conditions. The production of methylglyoxal may represent a high-risk strategy that facilitates adaptation, but which on failure leads to cell death. New strategies for antibacterial therapy may be based on undermining the detoxification and defence mechanisms coupled with deregulation of methylglyoxal synthesis. Received: 30 March 1998 / Accepted: 22 June 1998     

Neurons bearing presenilins: weapons for defense or suicide?

Apoptotic machinery designed for cell's organized self-destruction involve different systems of proteases which cleave vital proteins and disassemble nuclear and cytoplasmic structures, committing the cell to death. The most studied apoptotic proteolytic system is the caspase family, but calpains and the proteasome could play important roles as well. Alzheimer's disease associated presenilins showed to be a substrate for such proteolytic systems, being processed early in several apoptotic models, and recent data suggest that alternative presenilin fragments could regulate cell survival. Mutations in genes encoding presenilins proved to sensitize neurons to apoptosis by different mechanisms e.g. increased caspase-3 activation, oxyradicals production and calcium signaling dysregulation. Here we review the data involving presenilins in apoptosis and discuss a possible role of presenilins in the regulation of apoptotic biochemical machinery.     

Functional diversity of motoneuron dendrites: by accident or design?

The distribution and geometry of the dendritic trees of spinal motoneurons obey several well-established rules. Some of these rules are based on systematic relationships between quantitative geometrical features (e.g. total dendritic length) and the three-dimensional trajectory followed by dendrites from their origin to their termination. Since dendritic geometry partially determines the transmission of current and voltage signals generated by synapses on the dendritic tree, our goal was to compare the efficacy of signal transmission by dendritic trajectories that followed different directions. To achieve this goal, we constructed detailed compartmental models of the dendritic trees of intracellularly stained neck motoneurons and calculated the electrotonic properties of each soma-to-terminal trajectory. These properties displayed a high degree of variability. To determine if this variability was due, in part, to the orientation (e.g. rostral, rostral-dorsal-lateral) of the trajectory, each trajectory was classified according to its orientation. The attenuation of current and voltage signals en route to the soma were strongly related to trajectory orientation. Trajectories with similar attenuation factors formed functional subunits that were arranged in distinct domains within the ventral horn. The difference in the efficacy of signal transmission between subunits was increased by activation of neighbouring synapses due to trajectory-related differences in non-linear summation. These results indicate that the input-output properties of motoneurons depend on the direction of the path taken by dendrites from their origin at the cell body to their terminals.     

Failures of reproductive suppression in dwarf mongooses (Helogale parvula): accident or adaptation?

In many communally breeding species, only the dominant femalenormally breeds, while subordinates tolerate reproductive suppression(these are "despotic" species, in the terminology of Brown,1987; Macdonald and Moehlman, 1983; Vehrencamp, 1983). Yet inmany species for which reproductive suppression is the norm(across a wide variety of taxa), subordinates do occasionallybreed. Because reproduction by subordinates is atypical forthese species, it is often regarded as simple failure of thenormal mechanisms of suppression. An alternate hypothesis isthat subordinate pregnancies represent an evolutionary compromisebetween dominant and subordinate, in which dominants concedetheir monopoly on reproduction in order to retain helpers. Weuse data from a long-term study of dwarf mongooses (Helogaleparvula) in Serengeti National Park, Tanzania, to test thishypothesis, using an inclusive fitness model adapted from oneby Vehrencamp (1983). We find that the incidence of subordinatepregnancy closely matches that predicted by the model, suggestingthat the mechanisms that underlie reproductive suppression indwarf mongooses are finely adjusted to the social and demographicenvironment. [Behav Ecol 1991; 2: 7–15]     

Pollinators entering female dioecious figs: why commit suicide?

In the dioecious fig/pollinator mutualism, the female wasps that pollinate figs on female trees die without reproducing, whereas wasps that pollinate figs on male trees produce offspring. Selection should strongly favour wasps that avoid female figs and enter only male figs. Consequently, fig trees would not be pollinated and fig seed production would ultimately cease, leading to extinction of both wasp and fig. We experimentally presented pollinators in the wild (southern India) with a choice between male and female figs of a dioecious fig species, Ficus hispida L. Our results show that wasps do not systematically discriminate between sexes of F. hispida. We propose four hypotheses to explain why wasp choice has not evolved, and how a mutualism is thus maintained in which all wasps that pollinate female figs have zero fitness.     

Significant increase in trisomy 21 in Berlin nine months after the Chernobyl reactor accident: temporal correlation or causal relation?

OBJECTIVE--To assess whether the increased prevalence of trisomy 21 in West Berlin in January 1987 might have been causally related to exposure to ionising radiation as a result of the Chernobyl reactor accident or was merely a chance event. DESIGN--Analysis of monthly prevalence of trisomy 21 in West Berlin from January 1980 to December 1989. SETTING--Confines of West Berlin. RESULTS--Owing to the former "island" situation of West Berlin and its well organised health services, ascertainment of trisomy 21 was thought to be almost complete. A cluster of 12 cases occurred in January 1987 as compared with two or three expected. After exclusion of factors that might have explained the increase, including maternal age distribution, only exposure to radiation as a result of the Chernobyl reactor accident remained. In six of seven cases that could be studied cytogenetically the extra chromosome was of maternal origin, confirming that nondisjunction had occurred at about the time of conception. CONCLUSION--On the basis of two assumptions--(a) that maternal meiosis is an error prone process susceptible to exogenous factors at the time of conception; (b) that owing to the high prevalence of iodine deficiency in Berlin a large amount of iodine-131 would have been accumulated over a short period--it is concluded that the increased prevalence of trisomy 21 in West Berlin in January 1987 was causally related to a short period of exposure to ionising radiation as a result of the Chernobyl reactor accident.     

Adaptationism: Hypothesis or Heuristic?

Elliott Sober (1987, 1993) and Orzack and Sober (forthcoming) argue that adaptationism is a very general hypothesis that can be tested by testing various particular hypotheses that invoke natural selection to explain the presence of traits in populations of organisms. In this paper, I challenge Sobers claim that adaptationism is an hypothesis and I argue that it is best viewed as a heuristic (or research strategy). Biologists would still have good reasons for employing this research strategy even if it turns out that natural selection is not the most important cause of evolution.