Improving our science: the evolution of butterfly sampling and surveying methods over time

Butterflies are consistently the focus of conservation research because they contribute to ecosystem services, act as biological indicators, and are in decline worldwide. Land managers and researchers use many methods to measure butterfly populations, but this creates issues for standardization and production of comparative, rigorous data. To promote methods more appropriate for research-based conservation, we conducted a literature review focusing on the implementation and advancement of butterfly monitoring methods over time. We identified four main methods that are most frequently used in butterfly research and monitoring: (1) trapping and netting, (2) mark-recapture, (3) transects (Pollard walks), and (4) distance sampling. Although a progression of method development has occurred over time, all methods are still currently used in butterfly research, with trapping, netting, and mark-recapture used in 85% of studies. Over the last century, the amount of butterfly research has steadily increased, so it is vital to select methods that produce accurate, and comparable data. However, we found that method selection was not solely based on the type of data needed for accurate interpretation and extrapolation of results. Instead, land context, species abundance, and historically-used methods are driving method selection. As butterflies remain a high conservation priority, researchers must provide rigorous data that are necessary for creating effective conservation plans and policies by using a framework for method selection.     

White butterfly (

Once widespread, Cook?s scurvy grass (or nau, Lepidium oleraceum) is now confined to a few offshore populations. Classed as nationally endangered by the New?Zealand Department of Conservation, populations of Cook?s scurvy grass are threatened by a number of factors, including introduced herbivorous insect species such as the white butterfly (Pieris rapae) and white rust infection caused by the oomycete Albugo candida. In this paper, we investigate the occurrence of white butterfly on Cook?s scurvy grass and possible interactions with the white rust infection on the northernmost of the Matariki Islands in the Firth of Thames, New?Zealand. We found that larger host plants were more likely to be infested with white butterfly. The occurrence of white butterfly eggs and larvae also decreased as levels of white rust increased. Twenty-eight percent of the white butterfly larvae collected and reared in the laboratory were parasitised by the braconid wasp species Cotesia rubecula. We also reared a hyperparasitoid belonging to the super-family Chalcidoidea from one of the parasitoid cocoons. Further studies on the trophic interactions between Cook?s scurvy grass, Albugo?candida and white butterfly and its parasitoids could improve the understanding of the threats posed by plant pathogens and insect herbivores to populations of Cook?s scurvy grass, which in turn may lead to new management strategies for conservation.     

Dispersal in the Glanville fritillary butterfly in fragmented versus continuous landscapes: comparison between three methods

1. Habitat fragmentation may lead to natural selection on dispersal rate and other life‐history traits. Both theoretical analyses and empirical studies suggest that habitat fragmentation may select either for increased or decreased dispersal depending on the traits of the species and the characteristics of the landscape. 2. Dispersal and movement rates in Glanville fritillary butterflies (Melitaea cinxia) originating from a continuous landscape in China and from a highly fragmented landscape in Finland were compared using three different methods. 3. The methods included replicated mark‐release‐recapture (MRR) experiments conducted in the natural environments in China and Finland, tracking with harmonic radar of captive‐reared but free‐flying butterflies in a common environment in the field, and replicated common garden experiments in a large outdoor population cage. 4. The results were largely consistent, showing that butterflies from the more continuous landscape in China had a lower movement rate than butterflies originating from the fragmented landscape in Finland. Butterflies originating from newly‐established populations in Finland moved significantly longer distances than butterflies originating from old populations in Finland or from China, demonstrating significant intra‐specific variation in dispersal rate in Finland. These results are consistent with model predictions for the Glanville fritillary. 5. The tracking experiment revealed a result that would have been impossible to obtain with MRR experiments: movement rate was influenced by a significant interaction between population origin (China vs. Finland) and ambient air temperature.     

Andorran butterfly monitoring scheme

In 2004 Andorra started its own Butterfly Monitoring Scheme, BMSAnd. At present, the network is made up of 6 sites distributed across the country which are widely representative of the habitats present in Andorra. Up until 2009, 129 species had been recorded on the transect routes, which represent 83% of the 156 species identified in Andorra. Of these, 39 are listed as Species of European Conservation Concern (SPEC) in the Red Data Book of European Butterflies, 5 of which are in the SPEC1-3 category and the other 34 are in the SPEC4a and 4b categories.     

蝴蝶文化趣谈

文章综述蝴蝶的名称、蝴蝶与诗词、故事、服饰、邮票、绘画、工艺品、婚配、音乐和节日10个文化领域有关的内容,揭示蝴蝶对人类文化生活的重要影响,以期使人们更好的理解保护蝴蝶多样性的重要性。     

Coastal heathland succession influences butterfly community composition and threatens endangered butterfly species

Succession has a strong influence on species diversity and composition of semi-natural open terrestrial ecosystems. While several studies examined the effects of succession on butterflies in grassland and forest ecosystems, the response of heathland butterflies to succession had not been investigated so far. To address this issue we sampled butterfly abundance and environmental parameters on the Baltic island of Hiddensee (NE Germany) along a gradient of coastal heathland succession from grey dunes to birch forest. Our results provide evidence that succession of coastal heathland has a strong influence on butterfly diversity, abundance, and species composition. Thereby grass and tree encroachment present the main threats for heathland butterflies. Diversity and abundance of butterflies were highest in shrub-encroached heath directly followed by early stages of coastal heathland succession (dwarf-shrub heath, grey dune). Both observed threatened species (Hipparchia semele, Plebeius argus) were negatively affected by succession: abundance decreased with increasing vegetation density (both species) and grass cover (P. argus); consequently, the two later successional stages (shrub, birch forest) were not occupied. Our findings highlight the importance of the preservation of early stages of coastal heathland succession for endangered butterfly species. For coastal heathland management we therefore suggest to maintain early successional stages by sheep grazing, mowing or, in case of high nutrient contents, intensive techniques such as sod-cutting or choppering. To a lower extend shrub-encroached sites should also be present, which might be beneficial for overall species richness.     

Modelling butterfly wing eyespot patterns

Eyespots are concentric motifs with contrasting colours on butterfly wings. Eyespots have intra- and interspecific visual signalling functions with adaptive and selective roles. We propose a reaction-diffusion model that accounts for eyespot development. The model considers two diffusive morphogens and three non-diffusive pigment precursors. The first morphogen is produced in the focus and determines the differentiation of the first eyespot ring. A second morphogen is then produced, modifying the chromatic properties of the wing background pigment precursor, inducing the differentiation of a second ring. The model simulates the general structural organization of eyespots, their phenotypic plasticity and seasonal variability, and predicts effects from microsurgical manipulations on pupal wings as reported in the literature.     

Eco-evo-devo advances with butterfly eyespots

1. Download : Download high-res image (186KB)
2. Download : Download full-size image

     

Elements of butterfly wing patterns

The color patterns on the wings of butterflies are unique among animal color patterns in that the elements that make up the overall pattern are individuated. Unlike the spots and stripes of vertebrate color patterns, the elements of butterfly wing patterns have identities that can be traced from species to species, and typically across genera and families. Because of this identity it is possible to recognize homologies among pattern elements and to study their evolution and diversification. Individuated pattern elements evolved from non-individuated precursors by compartmentalization of the wing into areas that became developmentally autonomous with respect to color pattern formation. Developmental compartmentalization led to the evolution of serially repeated elements and the emergence of serial homology. In these compartments, serial homologues were able to acquire site-specific developmental regulation and this, in turn, allowed them to diverge morphologically. Compartmentalization of the wing also reduced the developmental correlation among pattern elements. The release from this developmental constraint, we believe, enabled the great evolutionary radiation of butterfly wing patterns. During pattern evolution, the same set of individual pattern elements is arranged in novel ways to produce species-specific patterns, including such adaptations as mimicry and camouflage.     

Optics of the butterfly eye

The afocal apposition optics of butterfly eyes was examined from both a geometrical optics and a wave optics point of view. We used several different species of butterfly but put special emphasis on a common Australian nymphalid,Heteronympha merope. From the anatomy of the retina, the optics of isolated components of the eye and the ophthalmoscopy of the intact living eye we derived the following.

Visual fields of butterfly interneurons

A relatively novel and precise technique was employed for the detailed plotting of the extent and nature of the fields of fibres in the visual pathway of 11 species of butterflies. For these experiments, a moving, flashing spot of light on the face of an oscilloscope was used as a photostimulator. Some 160 fibres were analysed by this technique. In many cases, the response to light adaptation was observed. Unlike many previous reports, units were found to have exceedingly complex fields, not easily described.Two major categories of optic lobe units were detected. These included: (1) fibres with large diffuse fields with many ‘holes’ and channels within their substance, which were markedly altered by light adaptation, and (2) relatively uncommon, smaller visual fields, which were somewhat more uniform in responsiveness.Four categories of visual fields were recorded in the protocerebrum. These included: (1) units with a large, diffuse field with a sharp boundary corresponding to the horizon, (2) binocular fields with much, little, or no overlap, (3) large diffuse fields, not unlike those discovered in the optic lobe, and (4) fibres demonstrating an inhibitory influence and resulting decrease in the size of the visual field as a result of contralateral stimulation.     

Acceptance angles of butterfly ommatidia

The ommatidial acceptance angle (angular sensitivity) of seven species of butterflies was determined by a novel technique. Measurements were based upon the fact that light adaptation produces a graded contraction of specific retinula cells with a concomitant reduction in the brillance of the observed reflection (glow). Measurements were, therefore, based upon the changes in the intensity of the reflections as an adapting light was moved to various spatial positions. Measurements were also made on the angle of illumination that would produce reflections, as well as the angle through which reflections could be observed. Average angles so determined were: half-linear sensitivity, 1°16′; reflection (acceptance), 2°47′; reflection (viewing), 9–10°; inter-ommatidial, 1°47′. These results suggest that the butterfly eye may have greater acuity than those of previously studied insects.     

Discerning the dietary habits of the smooth butterfly ray Gymnura lessae using two distinct methods,otolith identification and metagenetics

Two different methods, metagenetics and free-otolith identification, were used to identify prey in the stomach contents of 531 Gymnura lessae captured by trawling in Mobile Bay, Alabama 2016–2018. Both methods were found to produce analogous results and were therefore combined into a single complete dataset. All prey were teleosts; the families Sciaenidae and Engraulidae were the most important prey (prey specie index of relative importance 89.3% I_PSRI). Multivariate analyses indicated that the diet of G. lessae varied with sex and seasonality. Specifically, variability was probably due to morphologically larger females consuming larger teleost prey species compared with males, whereas seasonal variability was probably due to changes in the available prey community composition. The findings indicate that both metagenetics and free otolith identification, used independently or complementarily, offer robust means of characterising dietary habits for teleost-specialised species such as G. lessae, which may play an important role in the structure and maintenance of coastal food webs such as those in Mobile Bay.     

厦门市森林蝴蝶种类

在厦门市森林昆虫调查基础上,1998-2004年对厦门市森林蝴蝶进行种类调查,鉴定厦门市森林蝴蝶7科39种,并编制分种检索表.