Coarse-grained dynamics of the receiver domain of NtrC: fluctuations, correlations and implications for allosteric cooperativity

Receiver domains are key molecular switches in bacterial signaling. Structural studies have shown that the receiver domain of the nitrogen regulatory protein C (NtrC) exists in a conformational equilibrium encompassing both inactive and active states, with phosphorylation of Asp54 allosterically shifting the equilibrium towards the active state. To analyze dynamical fluctuations and correlations in NtrC as it undergoes activation, we have applied a coarse-grained dynamics algorithm using elastic network models. Normal mode analysis reveals possible dynamical pathways for the transition of NtrC from the inactive state to the active state. The diagonalized correlation between the inactive and the active (phosphorylated) state shows that most correlated motions occur around the active site of Asp54 and in the region Thr82 to Tyr101. This indicates a coupled correlation of dynamics in the "Thr82-Tyr101" motion. With phosphorylation inducing significant flexibility changes around the active site and alpha3 and alpha4 helices, we find that this activation makes the active-site region and the loops of alpha3/beta4 and alpha4/beta5 more stable. This means that phosphorylation entropically favors the receiver domain in its active state, and the induced conformational changes occur in an allosteric manner. Analyses of the local flexibility and long-range correlated motion also suggest a dynamics criterion for determining the allosteric cooperativity of NtrC, and may be applicable to other proteins.     

The Residue Threonine 82 of DevR (DosR) Is Essential for DevR Activation and Function in Mycobacterium tuberculosis Despite Its Atypical Location

The DevR (DosR) response regulator initiates the bacterial adaptive response to a variety of signals, including hypoxia in in vitro models of dormancy. Its receiver domain works as a phosphorylation-mediated switch to activate the DNA binding property of its output domain. Receiver domains are characterized by the presence of several highly conserved residues, and these sequence features correlate with structure and hence function. In response regulators, interaction of phosphorylated aspartic acid at the active site with the conserved threonine is believed to be crucial for phosphorylation-mediated conformational change. DevR contains all the conserved residues, but the structure of its receiver domain in the unphosphorylated protein is strikingly different, and key threonine (T82), tyrosine (Y101), and lysine (K104) residues are placed uncharacteristically far from the D54 phosphorylation site. In view of the atypical location of T82 in DevR, the present study aimed to examine the importance of this residue in the activation mechanism. Mycobacterium tuberculosis expressing a DevR T82A mutant protein is defective in autoregulation and supports hypoxic induction of the DevR regulon only very weakly. These defects are ascribed to slow and partial phosphorylation and the failure of T82A mutant protein to bind cooperatively with DNA. Our results indicate that the T82 residue is crucial in implementing conformational changes in DevR that are essential for cooperative binding and for subsequent gene activation. We propose that the function of the T82 residue in the activation mechanism of DevR is conserved in spite of the unusual architecture of its receiver domain.     

Molecular dynamic simulations of the N-terminal receiver domain of NtrC reveal intrinsic conformational flexibility in the inactive state

The N-terminal receiver domain of NtrC is the molecular switch in the two-component signal transduction. It is the first protein where structures of both the active (phosphyroylated) and inactive (unphosphyroylated) states are determined experimentally. Phosphorylation of the NtrC at the active site induces large structural change. NMR experiments suggested that the wild type unphosphorylated NtrC adopts both the active and the inactive conformations and the phosphorylation stabilizes the active conformations. We applied free (unconstrained) molecular dynamic (MD) simulation to examine the intrinsic flexibilities and stabilities of the NtrC receiver domain in both the active and inactive conformations. Molecular dynamic simulations showed that the inactive state of NtrC receiver domain is more flexible than the active state. There were large movements in helix 4 and loop beta3-alpha3 which coincide with major structural differences between the inactive and active states. We observed large root-mean-square deviations from the initial starting structure and the large root-mean-square fluctuations during MD simulation for the inactive state. We then investigated the activation pathway with Targeted MD simulation. We show that the intrinsic flexibility in the loop beta3-alpha3 plays an important role in triggering the conformational change. Phosphorylation at the active site may serve to stabilize the conformational change. These results together suggest that the unphosphorylated NtrC receiver domain could be involved in a conformational equilibrium between two different states.     

A common switch in activation of the response regulators NtrC and PhoB: phosphorylation induces dimerization of the receiver modules.

During signal transduction, response regulators of two-component systems are phosphorylated in a conserved receiver module. Phosphorylation induces activation of the non-conserved output domain. We fused various domains of the response regulators NtrC, PhoB or CheB to the DNA binding domain of lambda repressor. Analysis of these hybrid proteins shows that the receiver modules of NtrC and PhoB are potential dimerization domains. In the unphosphorylated proteins, the ability of the receiver modules to dimerize is masked due to inhibition by their output domains. Inhibition can be relieved in two ways: phosphorylation of the receiver module or deletion of the output domain. In contrast, the receiver module of CheB lacks this ability for dimerization. We propose a model which groups response regulators into two classes. Common to both classes is the interaction between receiver and output domain in the unphosphorylated protein. In class I (e.g. NtrC and PhoB), this interaction leads to the inhibition of the receiver module. Phosphorylation relieves inhibition, thereby inducing activation via dimerization of the receiver modules. In class II (e.g. CheB), the interaction between receiver and output domain results in inhibition of the output domain. Phosphorylation relieves inhibition, thereby activating the output domain.     

Molecular Dynamic Simulations of the N-Terminal Receiver Domain of NtrC Reveal Intrinsic Conformational Flexibility in the Inactive State

Abstract

The N-terminal receiver domain of NtrC is the molecular switch in the two-component signal transduction. It is the first protein where structures of both the active (phosphyroylated) and inactive (unphosphyroylated) states are determined experimentally. Phosphorylation of the NtrC at the active site induces large structural change. NMR experiments suggested that the wild type unphosphorylated NtrC adopts both the active and the inactive conformations and the phosphorylation stabilizes the active conformations. We applied free (unconstrained) molecular dynamic (MD) simulation to examine the intrinsic flexibilities and stabilities of the NtrC receiver domain in both the active and inactive conformations. Molecular dynamic simulations showed that the inactive state of NtrC receiver domain is more flexible than the active state. There were large movements in helix 4 and loop β3-α3 which coincide with major structural differences between the inactive and active states. We observed large root-mean-square deviations from the initial starting structure and the large root-mean-square fluctuations during MD simulation for the inactive state. We then investigated the activation pathway with Targeted MD simulation. We show that the intrinsic flexibility in the loop β3-α3 plays an important role in triggering the conformational change. Phosphorylation at the active site may serve to stabilize the conformational change. These results together suggest that the unphosphorylated NtrC receiver domain could be involved in a conformational equilibrium between two different states.     

An electrostatic network and long-range regulation of Src kinases

The regulatory mechanism of Src tyrosine kinases includes conformational activation by a change in the catalytic domain tertiary structure and in domain-domain contacts between the catalytic domain and the SH2/SH3 regulatory domains. The kinase is activated when tyrosine phosphorylation occurs on the activation loop, but without phosphorylation of the C-terminal tail. Activation also occurs by allostery when contacts between the catalytic domain (CD) and the regulatory SH3 and SH2 domains are released as a result of exogenous protein binding. The aim of this work is to examine the proposed role of an electrostatic network in the conformational transition and to elucidate the molecular mechanism for long-range, allosteric conformational activation by using a combination of experimental enzyme kinetics and nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. Salt dependence of the induction phase is observed in kinetic assays and supports the role of an electrostatic network in the transition. In addition, simulations provide evidence that allosteric activation involves a concerted motion coupling highly conserved residues, and spanning several nanometers from the catalytic site to the regulatory domain interface to communicate between the CD and the regulatory domains.     

Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Structure and Dynamics of the Response Regulator Sma0114 from Sinorhizobium meliloti

Receiver domains control intracellular responses triggered by signal transduction in bacterial two-component systems. Here, we report the solution nuclear magnetic resonance structure and dynamics of Sma0114 from the bacterium Sinorhizobium meliloti, the first such characterization of a receiver domain from the HWE-kinase family of two-component systems. The structure of Sma0114 adopts a prototypical α(5)/β(5) Rossman fold but has features that set it apart from other receiver domains. The fourth β-strand of Sma0114 houses a PFxFATGY sequence motif, common to many HWE-kinase-associated receiver domains. This sequence motif in Sma0114 may substitute for the conserved Y-T coupling mechanism, which propagates conformational transitions in the 455 (α4-β5-α5) faces of receiver domains, to prime them for binding downstream effectors once they become activated by phosphorylation. In addition, the fourth α-helix of the consensus 455 face in Sma0114 is replaced with a segment that shows high flexibility on the pico- to nanosecond time scale by (15)N relaxation data. Secondary structure prediction analysis suggests that the absence of helix α4 may be a conserved property of the HWE-kinase-associated family of receiver domains to which Sma0114 belongs. In spite of these differences, Sma0114 has a conserved active site, binds divalent metal ions such as Mg(2+) and Ca(2+) that are required for phosphorylation, and exhibits micro- to millisecond active-site dynamics similar to those of other receiver domains. Taken together, our results suggest that Sma0114 has a conserved active site but differs from typical receiver domains in the structure of the 455 face that is used to effect signal transduction following activation.     

Crystal structure of a cyanobacterial phytochrome response regulator

The two-component signal transduction pathway widespread in prokaryotes, fungi, molds, and some plants involves an elaborate phosphorelay cascade. Rcp1 is the phosphate receiver module in a two-component system controlling the light response of cyanobacteria Synechocystis sp. via cyanobacterial phytochrome Cph1, which recognizes Rcp1 and transfers its phosphoryl group to an aspartate residue in response to light. Here we describe the crystal structure of Rcp1 refined to a crystallographic R-factor of 18.8% at a resolution of 1.9 A. The structure reveals a tightly associated homodimer with monomers comprised of doubly wound five-stranded parallel beta-sheets forming a single-domain protein homologous with the N-terminal activator domain of other response regulators (e.g., chemotaxis protein CheY). The three-dimensional structure of Rcp1 appears consistent with the conserved activation mechanism of phosphate receiver proteins, although in this case, the C-terminal half of its regulatory domain, which undergoes structural changes upon phosphorylation, contributes to the dimerization interface. The involvement of the residues undergoing phosphorylation-induced conformational changes at the dimeric interface suggests that dimerization of Rcp1 may be regulated by phosphorylation, which could affect the interaction of Rcp1 with downstream target molecules.     

Structure and regulatory mechanism of Aquifex aeolicus NtrC4: variability and evolution in bacterial transcriptional regulation

Genetic changes lead gradually to altered protein function, making deduction of the molecular basis for activity from a sequence difficult. Comparative studies provide insights into the functional consequences of specific changes. Here we present structural and biochemical studies of NtrC4, a sigma-54 activator from Aquifex aeolicus, and compare it with NtrC1 (a paralog) and NtrC (a homolog from Salmonella enterica) to provide insight into how a substantial change in regulatory mechanism may have occurred. Activity assays show that assembly of NtrC4's active oligomer is repressed by the N-terminal receiver domain, and that BeF₃ ⁻ addition (mimicking phosphorylation) removes this repression. Observation of assembly without activation for NtrC4 indicates that it is much less strongly repressed than NtrC1. The crystal structure of the unactivated receiver-ATPase domain combination shows a partially disrupted interface. NMR structures of the regulatory domain show that its activation mechanism is very similar to that of NtrC1. The crystal structure of the NtrC4 DNA-binding domain shows that it is dimeric and more similar in structure to NtrC than NtrC1. Electron microscope images of the ATPase-DNA-binding domain combination show formation of oligomeric rings. Sequence alignments provide insights into the distribution of activation mechanisms in this family of proteins.     

Effect of phosphorylation on the interdomain interaction of the response regulator,NarL

DNA binding by the effector domain (NarLC) of the response regulator, NarL, is modulated by the phosphorylation state of the receiver domain (NarLN). The receiver domain appears to block the site of DNA binding in the nonphosphorylated state. Phosphorylation is proposed to disrupt this interaction, causing the effector domain to be released and free to bind DNA (Baikalov, I., Schroder, I., Kaczor-Grzeskowiak, M., Grzeskowiak, K., Gunsalus, R. P., and Dickerson, R. E. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 11053-61). To better understand this modulation, we analyzed the interaction between the two domains in the absence of a polypeptide linkage. Using multidimensional NMR, we mapped chemical shift changes that occurred during a titration between the two isolated domains. Specific residues in NarLC exhibit large chemical shift changes upon the addition of NarLN. These residues are primarily at the interface between the two domains as seen in the crystal structure. Using the residues with the largest chemical shift changes, we observed a dissociation constant of 88 +/- 7 microM. In the presence of 10 mM MgCl(2), the affinity is reduced 4-fold to about 350 microM. This work shows that the domains interact in trans and that this interaction, while fairly weak, provides a way to monitor the energetics of domain-domain interaction in this system. Phosphorylation of NarLN by a small-molecule phosphate donor, phosphoramidate, decreases this interaction about 25-fold from the nonphosphorylated sample. The results support the model that the mechanism of activation of NarL involves a disruption of the interdomain interface and suggests that the linker is not necessary for the transmission of signal across the domain interface. The linker does play a role in increasing the local concentration of the domains and therefore increasing the amount of closed conformation with respect to the open conformation. We estimate the levels of open conformation to be low (about 1%) in the nonphosphorylated state in the absence of magnesium ion and much higher in the phospho state (near 50%). This modulation of the open or active state via the interaction at the interface may also be applicable to other multidomain response regulator proteins.     

Evidence for phosphorylation-dependent conformational changes in methylesterase CheB

Enhancement of methylesterase activity of the response regulator CheB is dependent upon phosphorylation of the N-terminal regulatory domain of the enzyme. This domain plays a dual role in the regulation of methylesterase activity with an inhibitory effect in the unphosphorylated state and a stimulatory effect in the phosphorylated state. Structural studies of the unphosphorylated state have indicated that the basis for the regulatory domain's inhibitory effect is partial blockage of access of substrate to the active site suggesting that the activation upon phosphorylation involves a repositioning of the two domains with respect to each other. We report in this study evidence for phosphorylation-dependent conformational changes in CheB. Differences in rates of proteolytic cleavage by trypsin between the phosphorylated and unphosphorylated states have been observed at three sites in the protein with one site, 113, within the regulatory domain and two sites, 134 and 148, lying within the interdomain linker. These results support the hypothesis for the mechanism for the activation of CheB wherein phosphorylation of a specific aspartate residue within the N-terminal domain results in a propagated conformational change within the regulatory domain leading to a repositioning of its two domains. Presumably, structural changes in the regulatory domain of CheB facilitate a repositioning of the N- and C-terminal domains, leading to stimulation of methylesterase activity.     

A structural model of anti‐anti‐σ inhibition by a two‐component receiver domain: the PhyR stress response regulator

PhyR is a hybrid stress regulator conserved in α‐proteobacteria that contains an N‐terminal σ‐like (SL) domain and a C‐terminal receiver domain. Phosphorylation of the receiver domain is known to promote binding of the SL domain to an anti‐σ factor. PhyR thus functions as an anti‐anti‐σ factor in its phosphorylated state. We present genetic evidence that Caulobacter crescentus PhyR is a phosphorylation‐dependent stress regulator that functions in the same pathway as σ^T and its anti‐σ factor, NepR. Additionally, we report the X‐ray crystal structure of PhyR at 1.25 Å resolution, which provides insight into the mechanism of anti‐anti‐σ regulation. Direct intramolecular contact between the PhyR receiver and SL domains spans regions σ₂ and σ₄, likely serving to stabilize the SL domain in a closed conformation. The molecular surface of the receiver domain contacting the SL domain is the structural equivalent of α4‐β5‐α5, which is known to undergo dynamic conformational change upon phosphorylation in a diverse range of receiver proteins. We propose a structural model of PhyR regulation in which receiver phosphorylation destabilizes the intramolecular interaction between SL and receiver domains, thereby permitting regions σ₂ and σ₄ in the SL domain to open about a flexible connector loop and bind anti‐σ factor.