Determinants of cation transport selectivity: Equilibrium binding and transport kinetics

ConclusionThe equilibrium ion-binding properties of ion channels and transporters can be difficult to discern from crystal structures alone, as proteins often adopt different lowest energy states depending on the ions bound. In cases where transport is slow, their inherent ion-binding preferences can be used to infer their transport preferences. However, in cases where transport is fast, the transport selectivity can hide their equilibrium preferences by accentuating the kinetics of ions hopping through a channel over its inherent ion-binding preferences. Thus, depending on the arrangement of ion-binding sites in a channel’s selectivity filter, one can achieve either selective or nonselective ion transport.The equilibrium K⁺ selectivity of some nonselective channels suggests a potential mechanism whereby they could evolve into a fast K⁺-selective channel. K⁺ channels and nonselective channels like CNG and HCN are related to one another in both sequence and structure, suggesting an evolutionary link between them. Swap experiments show that only a few mutations separate a nonselective channel from a K⁺-selective channel. One might imagine an evolutionary path between these channels in which the equilibrium preference for a K⁺ ion in a nonselective channel evolves into a K⁺-selective channel through these few mutations to create the selective ion queue. Alternatively, a slow single-ion channel with an equilibrium and transport preference for K⁺ ions could be transformed into a fast multi-ion channel through mutations that create a queue of K⁺-selective ion-binding sites, as is seen in most K⁺ channels studied to date.In the case of multi-ion selectivity filters, such as those found in K⁺ channels, the selectivity filter can be viewed as the active site that interacts with different queues of ions and water molecules. At least three properties emerge from multi-ion queues: (1) high conductance by reducing the affinity of multiple bound ions versus single ions; (2) high selectivity by allowing disfavored ions time to dissociate back into solution; and, consequently, (3) robust selectivity in an environment where ion concentrations can change. For transporters and carriers, the equilibrium preference and slow transport naturally create robust selectivity. In all these cases, equilibrium-based ion selectivity is achieved by slowing transport enough so that the disfavored ion is able to dissociate back into solution before transport takes place.     

Microscopic model for selective permeation in ion channels.

Ionic permeation in the selectivity filter of ion channels is analyzed by a microscopic model based on molecular kinetic theory. The energy and flux equations are derived by assuming that: (a) the selectivity filter is formed by a symmetrical array of carbonyl groups; (b) ion movement is near the axis of the channel; (c) a fraction of water molecules is separated from the ion while it moves across the selectivity filter; (d) the applied voltage drops linearly across the selectivity filter; (e) ions move independently. Energy profiles, single channel conductances, and the degree of hydration of K+ in a hypothetical K+ channel are examined by varying the following microscopic parameters: ion radius and mass, channel radius, number of effective water dipoles, and number of carbonyl groups. The i-V curve is linear up to +/- 170 mV. If the positions of energy maxima and minima are fixed, this linear range is reduced to +/- 50 mV. Channel radius and ion-water interactions are found to be two major channel structural determinants for selectivity sequences. Both radius and mass of an ion are important in selectivity mediated by these interactions. The theory predicts a total of 15 possible kinetic selectivity sequences for alkali cations in ion channels with a single selectivity filter.     

Characterization of a large conductance non-selective anion channel in B lymphocytes

Studies on ion channel currents in freshly isolated murine B lymphocytes with the patch clamp technique revealed the presence of a non-selective anion channel of large conductance in inside-out (i/o) patches. This channel is characterized here according to its unitary conductance, ion selectivity, regulatory factors, distribution and kinetic behaviour. With a unitary conductance of 348 +/- 4.4 pS in a normal physiological ion gradient, it exhibited an indiscriminate selectivity to cations (Na+ and K+). Selectivity to chloride over sodium was established by substitution of high concentrations of NaCl (450 mM) in the bath (i/o patches), resulting in a selectivity ratio (PCl/PNa) of 33. Selectivity to chloride over potassium was confirmed in a similar manner by substitution of TEA-Cl for KCl, yielding a selectivity ratio (PCl/Pk) greater than 80. Conductance of aspartate through the channel demonstrated the non-selective nature of this anion channel. Voltage proved to be a regulatory factor but other influences on channel activity were also present, including the configuration of the patch (channel is inactive in cell attached patches), and the enhancement of activity at negative membrane voltages by previous pulsing. Intracellular levels of calcium (i/o patches) did not appear to control channel conductances or regulate kinetic activity. Kinetic behaviour of this channel was complex, with periods of bursting and flickering activity interspersed with prolonged closed/open intervals. Multiple subconductance states were also present. The complex properties and behaviour of this channel suggest a possible role in signal transduction in B cell activation.     

Ion selectivity of the apical membrane Na channel in the toad urinary bladder

The ion selectivity of the apical membrane Na channel in the toad urinary bladder was investigated. The electrical potential difference and resistance across the basal-lateral membrane were reduced using high concentrations of KCl in the serosal bathing medium, and gradients for various ions were imposed across the apical membrane by altering the composition of the mucosal bathing medium. Ion fluxes through the channel were measured as the transepithelial current inhibited by amiloride, a specific blocker of the channel's Na conductance. The selectivity sequence for alkali metal cations was H greater than Li greater than Na much greater than K. K permeability was barely detectable; the selectivity for Na over K was about 1000:1. Ammonium, hydroxyl ammonium and hydrazinium ions were, like K, virtually impermeant. The results suggest that the size of the unhydrated ion is an important factor in determining permeability in this channel.     

In channelrhodopsin-2 Glu-90 is crucial for ion selectivity and is deprotonated during the photocycle

The light-activated microbial ion channel channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) is a powerful tool to study cellular processes with high spatiotemporal resolution in the emerging field of optogenetics. To customize the channel properties for optogenetic experiments, a detailed understanding of its molecular reaction mechanism is essential. Here, Glu-90, a key residue involved in the gating and selectivity mechanism of the ion channel is characterized in detail. The deprotonation of Glu-90 during the photocycle is elucidated by time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy, which seems to be part of the opening mechanism of the conductive pore. Furthermore, Glu-90 is crucial to ion selectivity as also revealed by mutation of this residue combined with voltage clamp experiments. By dynamic homology modeling, we further hypothesized that the conductive pore is flanked by Glu-90 and located between helices A, B, C, and G.     

Different roles for aspartates and glutamates for cation permeation in bacterial sodium channels

A key driving force for ion channel selectivity is represented by the negative charge of the Selectivity Filter carried by aspartate (D) and glutamate (E) residues. However, the structural effects and specific properties of D and E residues have not been extensively studied. In order to investigate this issue we studied the mutants of NaChBac channel with all possible combinations of D and E in the charged rings in position 191 and 192. Electrophysiological measurements showed significant Ca²⁺ currents only when position 191 was occupied by E. Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics simulations revealed the existence of two binding sites, corresponding to the charged rings and another one, more internal, at the level of L190. The simulations showed that the ion in the innermost site can interact with the residue in position 191 only when this is glutamate. Based on the MD simulations, we suggest that a D in position 191 leads to a high affinity Ca²⁺ block site resulting from a significant drop in the free energy of binding for an ion moving between the binding sites; in contrast, the free energy change is more gradual when an E residue occupies position 191, resulting in Ca²⁺ permeability. This scenario is consistent with the model of ion channel selectivity through stepwise changes in binding affinity proposed by Dang and McCleskey. Our study also highlights the importance of the structure of the selectivity filter which should contribute to the development of more detailed physical models for ion channel selectivity.     

Molecular properties of Oep21, an ATP-regulated anion-selective solute channel from the outer chloroplast membrane

The flux of phosphorylated carbohydrates, the major export products of chloroplasts, is regulated at the level of the inner and presumably also at the level of the outer membrane. This is achieved through modulation of the outer membrane Oep21 channel currents and tuning of its ion selectivity. Refined analysis of the Oep21 channel properties by biochemical and electrophysiological methods revealed a channel formed by eight beta-strands with a wider pore vestibule of dvest approximately 2.4 nm at the intermembrane site and a narrower filter pore of drestr approximately 1 nm. The Oep21 pore contains two high affinity sites for ATP, one located at a relative transmembrane electrical distance delta = 0.56 and the second close to the vestibule at the intermembrane site. The ATP-dependent current block and reduction in anion selectivity of the Oep21 channel is relieved by the competitive binding of phosphorylated metabolic intermediates like 3-phosphoglycerate and glycerinaldehyde 3-phosphate. Deletion of a C-terminal putative FX4K binding motif in Oep21 decreased the capability of the channel to tune its ion selectivity by about 50%, whereas current block remained unchanged.     

Ion binding to KcsA: implications in ion selectivity and channel gating

Binding of K+ and Na+ to the potassium channel KcsA has been characterized from the stabilization observed in the heat-induced denaturation of the protein as the ion concentration is increased. KcsA thermal denaturation is known to include (i) dissociation of the homotetrameric channel into its constituent subunits and (ii) protein unfolding. The ion concentration-dependent changes in the thermal stability of the protein, evaluated as the Tm value for thermal-induced denaturation of the protein, may suggest the existence of both high- and low-affinity K+ binding sites of KcsA, which lend support to the tenet that channel gating may be governed by K+ concentration-dependent transitions between different affinity states of the channel selectivity filter. We also found that Na+ binds to KcsA with a KD similar to that estimated electrophysiologically from channel blockade. Therefore, our findings on ion binding to KcsA partly account for K+ over Na+ selectivity and Na+ blockade and argue against the strict “snug fit” hypothesis used initially to explain ion selectivity from the X-ray channel structure. Furthermore, the remarkable effects of increasing the ion concentration, K+ in particular, on the Tm of the denaturation process evidence that synergistic effects of the metal-mediated intersubunit interactions at the channel selectivity filter are a major contributor to the stability of the tetrameric protein. This observation substantiates the notion of a role for ions as structural “effectors” of ion channels.     

Modeling of ion permeation in calcium and sodium channel selectivity filters

Structure-function studies have shown that it is possible to convert a sodium channel to a calcium-selective channel by a single amino acid substitution in the selectivity filter locus. Ion permeation through the "model selectivity filter" was modeled with a reduced set of functional groups representative of the constituent amino acid side chains. Force-field minimizations were conducted to obtain the energy profile of the cations as they get desolvated and bind to the "model selectivity filter." The calculations suggest that the ion selectivity in the calcium channel is due to preferential binding, whereas in the sodium channel it is due to exclusion. Energetics of displacement of a bound cation from the calcium "model selectivity filter" by another cation suggest that "multi-ion mechanism" reduces the activation barrier for ion permeation. Thus, the simple model captures qualitatively most of the conduction characteristics of sodium and calcium channels. However, the computed barriers for permeation are fairly large, suggesting that ion interaction with additional residues along the transport path may be essential to effect desolvation.     

Non-Equilibrium Dynamics Contribute to Ion Selectivity in the KcsA Channel

The ability of biological ion channels to conduct selected ions across cell membranes is critical for the survival of both animal and bacterial cells. Numerous investigations of ion selectivity have been conducted over more than 50 years, yet the mechanisms whereby the channels select certain ions and reject others are not well understood. Here we report a new application of Jarzynski’s Equality to investigate the mechanism of ion selectivity using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics simulations of Na⁺ and K⁺ ions moving through the KcsA channel. The simulations show that the selectivity filter of KcsA adapts and responds to the presence of the ions with structural rearrangements that are different for Na⁺ and K⁺. These structural rearrangements facilitate entry of K⁺ ions into the selectivity filter and permeation through the channel, and rejection of Na⁺ ions. A mechanistic model of ion selectivity by this channel based on the results of the simulations relates the structural rearrangement of the selectivity filter to the differential dehydration of ions and multiple-ion occupancy and describes a mechanism to efficiently select and conduct K⁺. Estimates of the K⁺/Na⁺ selectivity ratio and steady state ion conductance for KcsA from the simulations are in good quantitative agreement with experimental measurements. This model also accurately describes experimental observations of channel block by cytoplasmic Na⁺ ions, the “punch through” relief of channel block by cytoplasmic positive voltages, and is consistent with the knock-on mechanism of ion permeation.     

The anomalous mole fraction effect in calcium channels: a measure of preferential selectivity

The cause of the anomalous mole fraction effect (AMFE) in calcium-selective ion channels is studied. An AMFE occurs when the conductance through a channel is lower in a mixture of salts than in the pure salts at the same concentration. The textbook interpretation of the AMFE is that multiple ions move through the pore in coordinated, single-file motion. Instead of this, we find that at its most basic level an AMFE reflects a channel's preferential binding selectivity for one ion species over another. The AMFE is explained by considering the charged and uncharged regions of the pore as electrical resistors in series: the AMFE is produced by these regions of high and low ion concentration changing differently with mole fraction due to the preferential ion selectivity. This is demonstrated with simulations of a model L-type calcium channel and a mathematical analysis of a simplistic point-charge model. The particle simulations reproduce the experimental data of two L-type channel AMFEs. Conditions under which an AMFE may be found experimentally are discussed. The resistors-in-series model provides a fundamentally different explanation of the AMFE than the traditional theory and does not require single filing, multiple occupancy, or momentum-correlated ion motion.     

Contribution of ion binding affinity to ion selectivity and permeation in KcsA, a model potassium channel

Ion permeation and selectivity, key features in ion channel function, are believed to arise from a complex ensemble of energetic and kinetic variables. Here we evaluate the contribution of pore cation binding to ion permeation and selectivity features of KcsA, a model potassium channel. For this, we used E71A and M96V KcsA mutants in which the equilibrium between conductive and nonconductive conformations of the channel is differently shifted. E71A KcsA is a noninactivating channel mutant. Binding of K(+) to this mutant reveals a single set of low-affinity K(+) binding sites, similar to that seen in the binding of K(+) to wild-type KcsA that produces a conductive, low-affinity complex. This seems consistent with the observed K(+) permeation in E71A. Nonetheless, the E71A mutant retains K(+) selectivity, which cannot be explained on the basis of just its low affinity for this ion. At variance, M96V KcsA is a rapidly inactivating mutant that has lost selectivity for K(+) and also conducts Na(+). Here, low-affinity binding and high-affinity binding of both cations are detected, seemingly in agreement with both being permeating species in this mutant channel. In conclusion, binding of the ion to the channel protein seemingly explains certain gating, ion selectivity, and permeation properties. Ion binding stabilizes greatly the channel and, depending upon ion type and concentration, leads to different conformations and ion binding affinities. High-affinity states guarantee binding of specific ions and mediate ion selectivity but are nonconductive. Conversely, low-affinity states would not discriminate well among different ions but allow permeation to occur.     

Ion selectivity of the apical membrane Na channel in the toad urinary bladder

Summary The ion selectivity of the apical membrane Na channel in the toad urinary bladder was investigated. The electrical potential difference and resistance across the basal-lateral membrane were reduced using high concentrations of KCl in the serosal bathing medium, and gradients for various ions were imposed across the apical membrane by altering the composition of the mucosal bathing medium. Ion fluxes through the channel were measured as the transepithelial current inhibited by amiloride, a specific blocker of the channel's Na conductance. The selectivity sequence for alkali metal cations was H>Li>NaK. K, permeability was barely detectable; the selectivity for Na over K was about 1000:1. Ammonium, hydroxyl ammonium and hydrazinium ions were, like K, virtually impermeant. The results suggest that the size of the unhydrated ion is an important factor in determining permeability in this channel.     

Peptide toxins that selectively target insect Na(V) and Ca(V) channels

Numerous metazoans express venoms for the purpose of defense, competitor deterrence or prey capture. Peptide neurotoxins are particularly well represented in the venoms of arachnids, cnidarians and mollusks and these toxins often possess high affinity and specificity for particular classes of ion channels. Some of these toxins have become the defining pharmacology for certain vertebrate ion channel subtypes. Unfortunately, due to differences in the structure, pharmacology and ion selectivity of insect voltage-gated sodium (Na(V)) and calcium (Ca(V)) channels compared with their vertebrate counterparts, these peptide toxins have proven less useful for the characterization of insect ion channels. Despite these disparities in channel structure and function, the armament of peptide toxins that specifically modulate the activity of insect ion channels is slowly expanding. This review focuses on insect-selective peptide toxins and their utility for the study of insect Na(V) and Ca(V) channels. The high affinity and selectivity of some of these neurotoxins means that they have the potential to become the defining pharmacology for specific subtypes of insect ion channels. In addition, it might be possible to exploit the phyletic specificity of these toxins as the basis for rational development of novel classes of ion channel insecticides.     

Molecular dynamics study of the KcsA potassium channel

The structural, dynamical, and thermodynamic properties of a model potassium channel are studied using molecular dynamics simulations. We use the recently unveiled protein structure for the KcsA potassium channel from Streptomyces lividans. Total and free energy profiles of potassium and sodium ions reveal a considerable preference for the larger potassium ions. The selectivity of the channel arises from its ability to completely solvate the potassium ions, but not the smaller sodium ions. Self-diffusion of water within the narrow selectivity filter is found to be reduced by an order of magnitude from bulk levels, whereas the wider hydrophobic section of the pore maintains near-bulk self-diffusion. Simulations examining multiple ion configurations suggest a two-ion channel. Ion diffusion is found to be reduced to approximately (1)/(3) of bulk diffusion within the selectivity filter. The reduced ion mobility does not hinder the passage of ions, as permeation appears to be driven by Coulomb repulsion within this multiple ion channel.     

Ligand-gated ion channels: mechanisms underlying ion selectivity

Anion/cation selectivity is a critical property of ion channels and underpins their physiological function. Recently, there have been numerous mutagenesis studies, which have mapped sites within the ion channel-forming segments of ligand-gated ion channels that are determinants of the ion selectivity. Site-directed mutations to specific amino acids within or flanking the M2 transmembrane segments of the anion-selective glycine, GABA(A) and GABA(C) receptors and the cation-selective nicotinic acetylcholine and serotonin (type 3) receptors have revealed discrete, equivalent regions within the ion channel that form the principal selectivity filter, leading to plausible molecular mechanisms and mathematical models to describe how ions preferentially permeate these channels. In particular, the dominant factor determining anion/cation selectivity seems to be the sign and exposure of charged amino acids lining the selectivity filter region of the open channel. In addition, the minimum pore diameter, which can be influenced by the presence of a local proline residue, also makes a contribution to such ion selectivity in LGICs with smaller diameters increasing anion/cation selectivity and larger ones decreasing it.     

Ion solvation and structural stability in a sodium channel investigated by molecular dynamics calculations

The stability and ion binding properties of the homo-tetrameric pore domain of a prokaryotic, voltage-gated sodium channel are studied by extensive all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, with the channel protein being embedded in a fully hydrated lipid bilayer. It is found that Na(+) ion presents in a mostly hydrated state inside the wide pore of the selectivity filter of the sodium channel, in sharp contrast to the nearly fully dehydrated state for K(+) ions in potassium channels. Our results also indicate that Na(+) ions make contact with only one or two out of the four polypeptide chains forming the selectivity filter, and surprisingly, the selectivity filter exhibits robust stability for various initial ion configurations even in the absence of ions. These findings are quite different from those in potassium channels. Furthermore, an electric field above 0.5V/nm is suggested to be able to induce Na(+) permeation through the selectivity filter.     

Cation-selective mutations in the M2 domain of the inhibitory glycine receptor channel reveal determinants of ion-charge selectivity

Ligand-gated ion channel receptors mediate neuronal inhibition or excitation depending on their ion charge selectivity. An investigation into the determinants of ion charge selectivity of the anion-selective alpha1 homomeric glycine receptor (alpha1 glycine receptor [GlyR]) was undertaken using point mutations to residues lining the extra- and intracellular ends of the ion channel. Five mutant GlyRs were studied. A single substitution at the intracellular mouth of the channel (A-1'E GlyR) was sufficient to convert the channels to select cations over anions with P(Cl)/P(Na) = 0.34. This result delimits the selectivity filter and provides evidence that electrostatic interactions between permeating ions and pore residues are a critical factor in ion charge selectivity. The P-2'Delta mutant GlyR retained its anion selectivity (P(Cl)/P(Na) = 3.81), but it was much reduced compared with the wild-type (WT) GlyR (P(Cl)/P(Na) = 27.9). When the A-1'E and the P-2'Delta mutations were combined (selectivity double mutant [SDM] GlyR), the relative cation permeability was enhanced (P(Cl)/P(Na) = 0.13). The SDM GlyR was also Ca(2+) permeable (P(Ca)/P(Na) = 0.29). Neutralizing the extracellular mouth of the SDM GlyR ion channel (SDM+R19'A GlyR) produced a more Ca(2+)-permeable channel (P(Ca)/P(Na) = 0.73), without drastically altering monovalent charge selectivity (P(Cl)/P(Na) = 0.23). The SDM+R19'E GlyR, which introduces a negatively charged ring at the extracellular mouth of the channel, further enhanced Ca(2+) permeability (P(Ca)/P(Na) = 0.92), with little effect on monovalent selectivity (P(Cl)/P(Na) = 0.19). Estimates of the minimum pore diameter of the A-1'E, SDM, SDM+R19'A, and SDM+R19'E GlyRs revealed that these pores are larger than the alpha1 GlyR, with the SDM-based GlyRs being comparable in diameter to the cation-selective nicotinic acetylcholine receptors. This result provides evidence that the diameter of the ion channel is also an important factor in ion charge selectivity.     

Peptide toxins that selectively target insect NaV and CaV channels

Numerous metazoans express venoms for the purpose of defense, competitor deterrence, or prey capture. Peptide neurotoxins are particularly well represented in the venoms of arachnids, cnidarians and mollusks and these toxins often possess high affinity and specificity for particular classes of ion channels. Some of these toxins have become the defining pharmacology for certain vertebrate ion channel subtypes. Unfortunately, due to differences in the structure, pharmacology, and ion selectivity of insect voltage-gated sodium (Na_V) and calcium (Ca_V) channels compared with their vertebrate counterparts, these peptide toxins have proven less useful for the characterization of insect ion channels. Despite these disparities in channel structure and function, the armament of peptide toxins that specifically modulate the activity of insect ion channels is slowly expanding. This review focuses on insect-selective peptide toxins and their utility for the study of insect Na_V and Ca_V channels. The high affinity and selectivity of some of these neurotoxins means that they have the potential to become the defining pharmacology for specific subtypes of insect ion channels. In addition, it might be possible to exploit the phyletic specificity of these toxins as the basis for rational development of novel classes of ion channel insecticides.     

Ion selectivity of epithelial Na channels

Epithelial Na channels are apparently pore-forming membrane proteins which conduct Na much better than any other biologically abundant ion. The conductance to Na can be 100 to 1000 times higher than that to K. The only other ions that can readily get through this channel are protons and Li. Small organic cations cannot pass through the channel, and water may also be impermeant. The selectivity properties of epithelial Na channels appear to be determined by at least three factors: A high field-strength anionic site, most likely a carboxyl residue of glutamic or aspartic acid residues on the channel protein, probably accounts for the high conductance through these channels of Na and Li and to the low conductance of K, Rb and Cs. A restriction in the size of the pore at its narrowest point probably accounts for the low conductance of organic cations as well as the possible exclusion of water molecules. The outer mouth of the channel appears to be negatively charged and may control access to the region of highest selectivity and may serve as a preliminary selectivity filter, attracting cations over anions. These conclusions are illustrated by the cartoon of the channel in Fig. 3. This picture is obviously both fanciful and simplified, but its general points will hopefully be testable. It leaves open a number of important questions, including: does amiloride block the channel by binding within the outer mouth? what does the inner mouth of the channel look like, and does this part of the channel contribute to selectivity? and what, if any, are the interactions between the features of the channel that impart selectivity and those that control the regulation of the channel by hormonal and other factors?