Post-transcriptional control of bacteriophage T4 gene 25 expression: mRNA secondary structure that enhances translational initiation.

Secondary structure of the mRNA in the translational initiation region is an important determinant of translation efficiency. However, the secondary structures that enhance or facilitate translation initiation are rare. We have previously proposed that such structure may exist in the case of bacteriophage T4 gene 25 translational initiation region, which contains three potential Shine-Dalgarno sequences (SD1, SD2, and SD3) with a spacing of 8, 17, and 27 nucleotides from the initiation codon of this gene, respectively. We now present results that clearly demonstrate the existence of a hairpin structure that includes SD1 and SD2 sequences and brings the SD3, the most typical of these Shine-Dalgarno sequences, to a favourable spacing with the initiation codon of gene 25.Using a phage T7 expression system, we show that mutations that prevent the formation of hairpin structure or eliminate the SD3 sequence result in a decreased level of gp25 synthesis. Double mutation in base-pair V restores the level of gene 25 expression that was decreased by either of the two mutations (C-to-G and G-to-C) alone, as predicted by an effect attributable to mRNA secondary structure. We introduced the mutations into the bacteriophage T4 by plasmid-phage recombination. Changes in the plaque and burst sizes of T4 mutants, carrying single and double mutations in the translational initiation region of gene 25, strongly suggest that the predicted mRNA secondary structure controls (enhances) the level of gene 25 expression in vivo. Hybridization of total cellular RNA with a gene 25 specific probe indicated that secondary structure or mutations in the translational initiation region do not notably affect the 25 mRNA stability. Immunoblot analysis of gp25 in Escherichia coli cells infected by T4 mutants showed that mRNA secondary structure increases the level of gp25 synthesis by three- to fourfold. Since the secondary structure increases the level of gp25 synthesis and does not affect mRNA stability, we conclude that this structure enhances translation initiation. We discuss some features of two secondary structures in the translational initiation regions of T4 genes 25 and 38.     

A systematic analysis of the beta hairpin motif in the Protein Data Bank

The beta hairpin motif is a ubiquitous protein structural motif that can be found in molecules across the tree of life. This motif, which is also popular in synthetically designed proteins and peptides, is known for its stability and adaptability to broad functions. Here, we systematically probe all 49,000 unique beta hairpin substructures contained within the Protein Data Bank (PDB) to uncover key characteristics correlated with stable beta hairpin structure, including amino acid biases and enriched interstrand contacts. We find that position specific amino acid preferences, while seen throughout the beta hairpin structure, are most evident within the turn region, where they depend on subtle turn dynamics associated with turn length and secondary structure. We also establish a set of broad design principles, such as the inclusion of aspartic acid residues at a specific position and the careful consideration of desired secondary structure when selecting residues for the turn region, that can be applied to the generation of libraries encoding proteins or peptides containing beta hairpin structures.     

The 5'-proximal hairpin of turnip yellow mosaic virus RNA: its role in translation and encapsidation

The RNA genome of turnip yellow mosaic virus (TYMV) consists of more than 6,000 nucleotides. During a study of the roles of the two hairpins located in its 90-nucleotide 5' untranslated region, it was observed that stabilization of the 5'-proximal hairpin leads to a delay in the development of symptoms on plants. This delay in symptom development for both locally and systemically infected leaves was found to be dependent on a change in the free energy of the hairpin caused by introduced mutations. A protoplast transfection assay revealed that the accumulation of plus-strand full-length RNA and subgenomic RNA, as well as protein expression levels, was affected by hairpin stability. Stabilization of this hairpin inhibited translation. A model is proposed in which a destabilized 5'-proximal hairpin allows maximal translation of the viral proteins. It is suggested that this hairpin may exist in close proximity to the 5' cap as long as its stability is low enough to enable translation. However, at an acidic pH, the hairpin structure becomes more stable and is functionally transformed into the initiation signal for viral packaging. Slightly acidic conditions can be found in chloroplasts, where TYMV assembly is driven by a low pH generated by active photosynthesis.     

The ErbB4 extracellular region retains a tethered-like conformation in the absence of the tether

The epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and its homologs ErbB3 and ErbB4 adopt a tethered conformation in the absence of ligand in which an extended hairpin loop from domain II contacts the juxtamembrane region of domain IV and tethers the domain I/II pair to the domain III/IV pair. By burying the hairpin loop, which is required for formation of active receptor dimers, the tether contact was thought to prevent constitutive activation of EGFR and its homologs. Amino‐acid substitutions at key sites within the tether contact region fail to result in constitutively active receptors however. We report here the 2.5 Å crystal structure of the N‐terminal three extracellular domains of ErbB4, which bind ligand but lack domain IV and thus the tether contact. This ErbB4 fragment nonetheless adopts a domain arrangement very similar to the arrangement adopted in the presence of the tether suggesting that regions in addition to the tether contribute to maintaining this conformation and inactivity in the absence of the tether contact. We suggest that the tether conformation may have evolved to prevent crosstalk between different EGFR homologs and thus allow diversification of EGFR and its homologs.     

Translational control by delayed RNA folding: identification of the kinetic trap

The maturation or A-protein gene of single-stranded RNA phage MS2 is preceded by a 130-nt long untranslated leader. When MS2 RNA folding is at equilibrium, the gene is untranslatable because the leader adopts a well-defined cloverleaf structure in which the Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence of the maturation gene is taken up in long-distance base pairing with an upstream complementary sequence (UCS). Synthesis of the A-protein takes place transiently while the RNA is synthesized from the minus strand. This requires that formation of the inhibitory cloverleaf is slow. In vitro, the folding delay was on the order of minutes. Here, we present evidence that this postponed folding is caused by the formation of a metastable intermediate. This intermediate is a small local hairpin that contains the UCS in its loop, thereby preventing or slowing down its pairing with the SD sequence. Mutants in which the small hairpin could not be formed made no detectable amounts of A-protein and were barely viable. Apparently, here the cloverleaf formed quicker than ribosomes could bind. On the other hand, mutants in which the small intermediary hairpin was stabilized produced more A-protein than wild type and were viable. One hardly growing mutant that could not form the metastable hairpin and did not make detectable amounts of A-protein was evolved. The emerging pseudo-revertant had selected two second site repressor mutations that allowed reconstruction of a variant of the metastable intermediate. The pseudo-revertant had also regained the capacity to produce the A-protein.     

Leeway and constraints in the forced evolution of a regulatory RNA helix.

The start of the coat protein gene of RNA phage MS2 adopts a well-defined hairpin structure of 12 bp (including one mismatch) in which the start codon occupies the loop position. An earlier expression study using partial MS2 cDNA clones had indicated that the stability of this hairpin is important for gene expression. For every -1.4 kcal/mol increase in stability a 10-fold reduction in coat protein was obtained. Destabilizations beyond the wild-type value did not affect expression. These results suggested that the hairpin was tuned in the sense that it has the highest stability still compatible with maximal ribosome loading. Employing an infectious MS2 cDNA clone, we have now tested the prediction that the delta G 0 of the coat protein initiator helix is set at a precise value. We have introduced stabilizing and destabilizing mutations into this hairpin in the intact phage and monitored their evolution to viable species. By compensatory mutations, both types of mutants quickly revert along various pathways to wild-type stability, but not to wild-type sequence. As a rule the second-site mutations do not change the encoded amino acids or the Shine-Dalgarno sequence. The return of too strong hairpins to wild-type stability can be understood from the need to produce adequate supplies of coat protein. The return of unstable hairpins to wild-type stability is not self-evident and is presently not understood. The revertants provide an evolutionary landscape of slightly suboptimal phages, that were stable at least for the duration of the experiment (approximately 20 infection cycles).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The Presence in tRNA Molecule Sequences of the Double Hairpin,an Evolutionary Stage Through Which the Origin of this Molecule is Thought to have Passed

We analyse 6,810 tRNAs, calculating the free energy of the corresponding double hairpin and ‘cigar’ secondary structures, for which we find a high thermodynamic and statistical significance. We also analyse these tRNAs for similarity and complementarity of their 5′ and 3′ halves or segments of them in intra-and inter-molecular comparisons. We find very clear signs that the two halves of tRNAs had an evident evolutionary relationship, although it is not totally clear whether this was a relationship of homology or complementarity between the 5′ and 3′ halves of tRNAs, even if there is strong evidence in favour of the homology hypothesis. Overall, these data favour models for the origin of the tRNA molecule postulating that a duplication event involving a hairpin structure as a precursor was involved in the origin of this molecule. Moreover, we interpret these results and favour the hypothesis that sees the assembly of two hairpin structures sharing a homology relationship as the intermediate evolutionary stage preceding the appearance of the cloverleaf structure of tRNA.     

Viral escape from antisense RNA

RNA coliphage SP was propagated for several generations on a host expressing an inhibitory antisense RNA complementary to bases 31–270 of the positive-stranded genome. Phages evolved that escaped inhibition. Typically, these escape mutants contained 3–4 base substitutions, but different sequences were observed among different isolates. The mutations were located within three different types of structural features within the predicted secondary structure of SP genomic RNA: (i) hairpin loops; (ii) hairpin stems; and (iii) the 5' region of the phage genome complementary to the antisense molecule. Computer modelling of the mutant genomic RNAs showed that all of the substitutions within hairpin stems improved the Watson–Crick pairing of the stem. No major structural rearrangements were predicted for any of the mutant genomes, and most substitutions in coding regions did not alter the amino acid sequence. Although the evolved phage populations were polymorphic for substitutions, many substitutions appeared independently in two selected lines. The creation of a new, perfect, antisense RNA against an escape mutant resulted in the inhibition of that mutant but not of other escape mutants nor of the ancestral, unevolved phage. Thus, at least in this system, a population of viruses that evolved to escape from a single antisense RNA would require a cocktail of several antisense RNAs for inhibition.     

Structural Constraints and Mutational Bias in the Evolutionary Restoration of a Severe Deletion in RNA Phage MS2

A 4-nucleotide (nt) deletion was made in the 36-nt-long intercistronic region separating the coat and replicase genes of the single-stranded RNA phage MS2. This region is the focus of several RNA structures conferring high fitness. One such element is the operator hairpin, which, in the course of infection, will bind a coat-protein dimer, thereby precluding further replicase synthesis and initiating encapsidation. Another structure is a long-distance base pairing (MJ) controlling replicase expression. The 4-nt deletion does not directly affect the operator hairpin but it disrupts the MJ pairing. Its main effect, however, is a frame shift in the overlapping lysis gene. This gene starts in the upstream coat gene, runs through the 36-nt-long intercistronic region, and ends in the downstream replicase cistron. Here we report and interpret the spectrum of solutions that emerges when the crippled phage is evolved. Four different solutions were obtained by sequencing 40 plaques. Three had cured the frame shift in the lysis gene by inserting one nt in the loop of the operator hairpin causing its inactivation. Yet these low-fitness revertants could further improve themselves when evolved. The inactivated operator was replaced by a substitute and thereafter these revertants found several ways to restore control over the replicase gene. To allow for the evolutionary enrichment of low-probability but high-fitness revertants, we passaged lysate samples before plating. Revertants obtained in this way also restored the frame shift, but not at the expense of the operator. By taking larger and larger lysates samples for such bulk evolution, ever higher-fitness and lower-frequency revertants surfaced. Only one made it back to wild type. As a rule, however, revertants moved further and further away from the wild-type sequence because restorative mutations are, in the majority of cases, selected for their capacity to improve the phenotype by optimizing one of several potential alternative RNA foldings that emerge as a result of the initial deletion. This illustrates the role of structural constraints which limit the path of subsequent restorative mutations. [Reviewing Editor: Dr. John Hulsenbeck]     

Distinctive structures between chimpanzee and human in a brain noncoding RNA

Human accelerated region 1 (HAR1) is a short DNA region identified recently to have evolved the most rapidly among highly constrained regions since the divergence from our common ancestor with chimpanzee. It is transcribed as part of a noncoding RNA specifically expressed in the developing human neocortex. Employing a panoply of enzymatic and chemical probes, our analysis of HAR1 RNA proposed a secondary structure model differing from that published. Most surprisingly, we discovered that the substitutions between the chimpanzee and human sequences led the human HAR1 RNA to adopt a cloverleaf-like structure instead of an extended and unstable hairpin in the chimpanzee sequence. Thus, the rapid evolutionary changes resulted in a profound rearrangement of HAR1 RNA structure. Altogether, our results provide a structural context for elucidating HAR1 RNA function.     

Mutational analysis of the bacteriophage alpha 3 origin of complementary DNA synthesis: in vivo properties of mutants

Bacteriophage alpha 3 origin of complementary strand DNA synthesis contains two potential secondary loop structures, I and II, which have been implicated in direct recognition sites for host Escherichia coli dnaG protein. To elucidate the function of the hairpin loops, we have introduced point mutations within the stem of the hairpin II so as to disturb its base-pairings. A mutant, oriAA, which had two point mutations in the region, formed minute plaques on E. coli host cells and its mean burst size at 37 degrees C was about 50, whereas that of wild-type was 250. In addition, the growth of oriAA at 42 degrees C was thermosensitive and the burst size was reduced to 5. From the oriAA, a revertant-like phage oriGA occurred spontaneously with a high-frequency of about 2.10(-2). It retained one point mutation and the plaque size and phage yield were nearly same as those of wild-type. These results are discussed with respect to the role of secondary structure as well as specific nucleotide sequence in the recognition site for the dnaG protein.     

Transient tertiary structures in tau,an intrinsically disordered protein

An intrinsically disordered protein (IDP) does not have a definite 3D structure, and because of its highly flexible nature it evolves dynamically in very large and diverse regions of the phase space. A standard molecular dynamics run can sample only a limited region of the latter; even though this kind of simulation may be effective in sampling local temporary secondary structures, it is not sufficient to highlight properties that require a larger sampling of the phase space to be detected, like transient tertiary structures. But if the structure of an IDP is dynamically evolved using metadynamics (an algorithm that keeps track of the regions of the phase space already sampled), the system can be forced to wander in a much larger region of the phase space. We have applied this procedure to the simulation of tau, one of the largest totally disordered proteins. Combining the results of the simulation with small-angle X-ray scattering yields a significant improvement in the sampling of the phase space in comparison with standard molecular dynamics, and provides evidence of extended hairpin- and paperclip-like transient tertiary structures of the molecule. The more persistent tertiary pattern is a hairpin folding encompassing part of the N-terminal, the proline-rich domain, the former repeat and a functionally relevant part of the second repeat.     

The HIV-1 leader RNA conformational switch regulates RNA dimerization but does not regulate mRNA translation

The untranslated leader RNA is the most conserved part of the human immunodeficiency virus type I (HIV-1) genome. It contains many regulatory motifs that mediate a variety of steps in the viral life cycle. Previous work showed that the full-length leader RNA can adopt two alternative structures: a long distance interaction (LDI) and a branched multiple-hairpin (BMH) structure. The BMH structure exposes the dimer initiation site (DIS) hairpin, whereas this motif is occluded in the LDI structure. Consequently, these structures differ in their capacity to form RNA dimers in vitro. The BMH structure is dimerization-competent, due to DIS hairpin formation, but also presents the splice donor (SD) and RNA packaging (Psi) hairpins. In the LDI structure, an extended RNA packaging (Psi(E)) hairpin is folded, which includes the splice donor site and gag coding sequences. The gag initiation codon is engaged in a long distance base pairing interaction with sequences in the upstream U5 region in the BMH structure, thus forming the evolutionarily conserved U5-AUG duplex. Therefore, the LDI-BMH equilibrium may affect not only the process of RNA dimer formation but also translation initiation. In this study, we designed mutations in the 3'-terminal region of the leader RNA that alter the equilibrium of the LDI-BMH structures. The mutant leader RNAs are affected in RNA dimer formation, but not in their translation efficiency. These results indicate that the LDI-BMH status does not regulate HIV-1 RNA translation, despite the differential presentation of the gag initiation codon in both leader RNA structures.     

Diversity of DIS, SD and psi hairpins in HIV-1 isolates of group M: in silico study

The primary sequence and secondary structure of the region encompassing DIS, SD and psi hairpins in HIV-1 genomic RNAs have been analyzed for 731 group M isolates from NCBI database. The secondary structures have been predicted by the m fold program (M. Zuker). Though the primary sequence of the region studied was found to be highly heterogeneous, this region is folded into DIS, SD and psi hairpins (DIS-, SD- and psi-like hairpins) in 96% of the isolates studied. The phylogenetic analysis showed that the most frequent variants of DIS hairpin (DIS(Lai), DIS(Mal) and DIS(C)) tolerate certain base changes. Particularly, base changes at stem position 23 occur 5 and 33 times more frequently in DIS(Lai) than in DIS(Mal) and DIS(C), respectively, while A insertion at the 5'end of apical loop is tolerated in DIS(Mal) and DIS(C) but not in DIS(Lai). We have revealed that the bottom base pair substitution G-C --> A-U in SD hairpin is highly specific for subtype D isolates. All variants of DIS, SD and psi hairpins found in our database are discussed, systematized and presented in schemes of hypothetical transitions between variants via a single base change. Most variants of DIS and psi hairpins were found to adopt several conformations.     

A local, interactive network of 3' RNA elements supports translation and replication of Turnip crinkle virus

The majority of the 3' untranslated region (UTR) of Turnip crinkle virus (TCV) was previously identified as forming a highly interactive structure with a ribosome-binding tRNA-shaped structure (TSS) acting as a scaffold and undergoing a widespread conformational shift upon binding to RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). Tertiary interactions in the region were explored by identifying two highly detrimental mutations within and adjacent to a hairpin H4 upstream of the TSS that reduce translation in vivo and cause identical structural changes in the loop of the 3' terminal hairpin Pr. Second-site changes that compensate for defects in translation/accumulation and reverse the structural differences in the Pr loop were found in the Pr stem, as well as in a specific stem within the TSS and within the capsid protein (CP) coding region, suggesting that the second-site changes were correcting a conformational defect and not restoring specific base pairing. The RdRp-mediated conformational shift extended upstream through this CP open reading frame (ORF) region after bypassing much of an intervening, largely unstructured region, supporting a connection between 3' elements and coding region elements. These data suggest that the Pr loop, TSS, and H4 are central elements in the regulation of translation and replication in TCV and allow for development of an RNA interactome that maps the higher-order structure of a postulated RNA domain within the 3' region of a plus-strand RNA virus.     

A comparison of the binding to polynucleotides of complementary and noncomplementary oligonucleotides.

The binding of oligonucleotides to synthetic polynucleotides has been studied as a control for investigations of the binding of oligonucleotides to natural RNA molecules. Only combinations that involved A-U, G-C, and G-G pairs were found to be significantly stable under the experimental conditions used here. The stability of the oligomerpolymer pairing increased with the length of the region paired and with its G + C content. Further, some different sequence isomers of the same G + C content exhibited quite different binding constants. This variability is consistent with certain sequence differences in the double-strand stacking interactions stabilizing the oligomer-polymer association. Oligomer binding was also shown to depend upon the identity of the polymer residues neighboring the binding site, indicating the effect upon oligomer binding of small changes in the single-strand conformation of the binding site. These observations validate the criteria that allow one to decide if an observed association constant of an oligomer to an RNA molecule reflects a complete complementarity between the two or not. This improves the basis for using oligonucleotide binding constants to RNA of known sequences to map secondary structure.