Comparison of zebrafish (Danio rerio) and fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) as test species in the Fish Sexual Development Test (FSDT)

Results are presented from a validation (with 5 laboratories) of the Fish Sexual Development Test (FSDT) developed to detect endocrine disrupters (EDs) and included in the OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) working program. The aromatase-inhibiting fungicide prochloraz was tested in zebrafish (Danio rerio) and fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas). The fish were exposed during sexual differentiation and development from 0 to 60 days post hatch (dph). After exposure, the vitellogenin (VTG) concentrations were quantified in head/tail homogenate and the sex ratio was determined (defined as female, male, intersex or undifferentiated). NOEC/LOEC and EC(x) designs were compared to optimize the test approach. Results show that both species are highly sensitive to prochloraz during sexual development. They respond by skewing of the sex ratio towards male phenotype and by a VTG decline in females. The NOEC/LOEC approach is preferred because sex ratio is difficult to analyze with a regression model. The mean NOEC/LOEC for prochloraz on the sex ratio was 43.3/134 μg/L and 101/293 μg/L for zebrafish and fathead minnow, respectively. The mean NOEC/LOEC on the decline in female VTG concentration was 65/110 μg/L and ~30/68 μg/L respectively. In conclusion, zebrafish and fathead minnow are suitable species in the FSDT and their sexual differentiation is equally labile to EDs.     

Small fish models for identifying and assessing the effects of endocrine-disrupting chemicals

Endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs), particularly those that affect the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal (HPG) axis of vertebrates, have become a focus of regulatory screening and testing throughout the world. Small fish species, principally the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas), Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes), and zebrafish (Danio rerio), are used as model organisms for several of these testing programs. Fish are appropriate models for testing EDCs, not only from the perspective of existing ecological impacts, but also in terms of species extrapolation. Specifically, there is a significant degree of conservation of basic aspects of the HPG axis across vertebrates, which provides a technically robust basis for using results from fish tests to predict likely modes/mechanisms of action of potential EDCs in other vertebrates. Different experimental designs/endpoints for partial- and full-life cycle tests with fish that enable a consideration of a broad range of EDCs are described. Examples of results with specific chemicals in tests with the fathead minnow, medaka, and zebrafish are presented and discussed in terms of sensitivity and specificity for different classes of EDCs.     

Comparison of ELISAs for detecting vitellogenin in the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas)

Measurement of vitellogenin (VTG) concentrations in the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) is currently being considered and evaluated for screening of endocrine active substances. One of the proposed methods, an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) based on VTG from carp (Cyprinus carpio), was recently evaluated in an inter-laboratory ring test using whole body homogenates from juvenile fathead minnows. The objective of the current study was to compare the performance of three different ELISAs for measuring fathead minnow VTG: (1) a heterologous carp VTG (cVTG) ELISA used in the ring test, (2) a homologous fathead minnow VTG (fVTG) ELISA, and (3) a hybrid ELISA with the antibody developed for cVTG, but using fVTG for coating the plates and preparing standard curves. VTG was measured in whole body homogenates from juvenile fathead minnows exposed to 17alpha-ethynylestradiol (EE(2); 10 ng/l) and whole body homogenates and plasma from adult fathead minnows exposed to 17beta-estradiol (E(2); 5 mg/kg; i.p.). The cVTG assay showed lower specificity for fathead minnow VTG in whole body homogenates and plasma from treated fish, compared to the fVTG assay. VTG concentrations in juvenile fathead minnow homogenates from the EE(2)-exposed group were approximately 50-fold higher when measured using the fVTG method compared to the cVTG method. Use of the homologous fVTG in the hybrid cVTG assay yielded VTG concentrations in the range of the fVTG assay but the low specificity persisted. The homologous fVTG assay is recommended to achieve accurate quantification of VTG levels in fathead minnows.     

Swimming performance and energy homeostasis in juvenile laboratory raised fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) exposed to uranium mill effluent

Research at the Key Lake uranium mill (Saskatchewan, Canada) suggests effluent discharged from the mill affects energy stores of resident fish, but the mechanisms by which energy homeostasis is affected and the subsequent effects on swimming performance are unknown. In the present study larvae were collected from laboratory raised adult fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) exposed to 5% diluted uranium mill effluent or control (dechlorinated municipal) water, and reared in the same treatments to 60 days post hatch (dph). Critical swimming speed (U_crit) was significantly lower in effluent exposed 60 dph fish compared to control fish. Fish used in tests were considered fatigued and compared to fish without swim testing (non-fatigued). There were no differences in whole body glycogen or triglyceride concentrations between effluent exposed versus control fish. However, fatigued fish from both treatments had significantly lower triglycerides, but not glycogen, compared to non-fatigued fish from the same treatment. Whole body β–hydroxyacyl coenzymeA dehydrogenase activity was similar in fish from both treatments, but citrate synthase activity was significantly lower in effluent exposed fish. Our results suggest uranium mill effluent exposure in the laboratory affects aerobic energy metabolism and swimming performance in juvenile fathead minnow, which could affect wild fish survivability.     

A rapid, direct assay to measure degranulation of primary granules in neutrophils from kidney of fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas Rafinesque, 1820)

A direct, rapid, quantitative colorimetric assay to determine neutrophil primary granule degranulation was adapted for use with fathead minnow kidney neutrophils. The assay measures the exocytosis of myeloperoxidase (MPO) using 3,3',5,5'-tetramethylbenzidine as a substrate. The assay was validated by comparing the total myeloperoxidase content of neutrophil populations obtained from adult cattle, as a known positive, and fish; evaluating the effects of calcium ionophore (CaI), phorbol myristate acetate (PMA), aqueous solution of beta-glucan (MGAQ) and zymosan (Z) with and without cytochalasin B (cyto B) as stimulants of degranulation; determining the kinetics of primary granule exocytosis and detecting changes in degranulation when fish were exposed to stress and anaesthesia with MS-222. The MPO assay detected MPO activity in fathead minnow neutrophils that correlated to neutrophil numbers, confirmed that degranulation was increased when CaI was used compared to other stimulants, determined degranulation peak at 60 min and confirmed decreased degranulation after exposure to handling and crowding stress, with and without MS-222. Therefore, the MPO assay is capable of detecting important differences that may occur in degranulation of fathead minnow kidney neutrophil primary granules and in total neutrophil myeloperoxidase content.     

Acquired Recognition of Chemical Stimuli from Pike,Esox lucius,by Brook Sticklebacks,Culaea inconstans (Osteichthyes,Gasterosteidae)

In this study we test whether brook sticklebacks (Culaea inconstans) can acquire predator recognition through releaser-induced recognition learning, i.e. simultaneous exposure to aversive ('releasing') stimuli and neutral stimuli causing learned aversion to the neutral stimuli. We exposed wild-caught pike-naive brook sticklebacks (collected from a creek containing fathead minnows, Pimephales promelas, but not pike, Esox lucius) to chemical stimuli from pike that were mixed with brook stickleback skin extract, fathead minnow skin extract, or a control of distilled water. In subsequent tests 2 d later, when only pike stimuli were presented, sticklebacks conditioned with stickleback skin extract and fathead minnow skin extract exhibited antipredator behaviour (i.e. increased schooling and movement toward the substrate), while those conditioned with distilled water did not. Sticklebacks conditioned with stickleback skin extract responded to pike with a more intense response, in terms of movement toward the substrate, than those conditioned with fathead minnow skin extract, suggesting that conspecific skin extract may be a stronger stimulus than heterospecific skin extract for learning recognition of predators. To our knowledge this is the first study to demonstrate that an acanthopterygian fish can acquire predator recognition through the pairing of conspecific alarm pheromone with the cue of a predator. Furthermore, our results are the first to demonstrate that fish can acquire predator recognition through the pairing of a heterospecific alarm pheromone with the cue of a predator. These results suggest that brook sticklebacks will benefit by being in close proximity to fathead minnows. Acquired predator recognition has long-term consequences in mediating predator-prey interactions.     

Formation of micronuclei in erythrocytes of the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) after acute treatment with mitomycin C or cyclophosphamide

Despite the widespread use of the fathead minnow in ecotoxicology, there have been relatively few studies on genotoxicity biomarkers in this small, warm-water fish species. Consequently, we investigated the effect of two known genotoxins, mitomycin C and cyclophosphamide, on micronucleus induction in spleen and peripheral blood erythrocytes of this species. Initially, 96-h experiments after intra-peritoneal (i.p.) injections of mitomycin C and cyclophosphamide were undertaken to determine the maximum tolerated dose (MTD). From these studies, MTDs of 10 and 400 mg/kg, respectively, were obtained: doses that were higher than those reported for other fish species. Next, an assessment of micronucleus induction at 1, 2, 4, 8 and 14 days after injection was undertaken for each compound at the MTD. Mitomycin C at 10 mg/kg significantly induced micronuclei in erythrocytes from the spleen, but not from the peripheral blood, at 8 and 14 days. In addition, the overall levels of micronuclei observed were lower than most previously published data from other fish species. In contrast to mitomycin C, treatment with 400 mg/kg cyclophosphamide failed to significantly induce micronuclei in erythrocytes from any of the tissues employed, in contrast to previous reports of significant induction in other species. The reasons for the apparent relative insensitivity of the fathead minnow to these clastogens, with respect to both MTDs and micronucleus induction, are not clear. The fathead minnow, however, has previously been described as relatively insensitive compared to other fish species with respect to selected carcinogens and cytochrome P450 inducers; the latter suggesting that the lack of a significant induction following cyclophosphamide exposure may be due to low metabolic activation in vivo. Consequently, further clarifying work is required to delineate the response shown, considering the extensive use of this species in ecotoxicology research and regulatory testing.     

Microsatellite loci for fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas)

We describe the cloning and characterization of seven microsatellite loci (six dinucleotide and one tetranucleotide) from fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas). In a sample of 48 fish from a captive population, polymorphism at these loci ranged from 4 to 11 alleles with expected heterozygosities ranging from 0.59 to 0.82. These loci will be extremely useful to researchers currently studying the ecotoxicology, behaviour and population genetics of this species.     

Natural disturbance and life history: consequences of winterkill on fathead minnow in boreal lakes

Age, growth and reproductive characteristics of fathead minnow Pimephales promelas populations inhabiting four lakes that varied in the extent and frequency of winterkill were studied in the boreal region of western Canada. The lifespan of fathead minnows inhabiting lakes prone to winterkill was 1–2 years shorter than those in less disturbed lakes. In populations prone to winterkill, fish displayed faster growth rates and grew to a larger size‐at‐age, particularly during the first year of life. Although lower population densities in winterkill lakes probably contributed to this increased growth, adults in these populations tended to spawn earlier in the season than the smaller adults in more stable populations. Fathead minnows in lakes prone to winterkill also matured at an earlier age and allocated a greater proportion of their body mass to gonads than conspecifics in the more benign, stable lakes. These trends are consistent with predictions for organisms in variable, unpredictable environments and, because fathead minnows are tolerant to a wide range of environmental conditions, suggest that variation in life‐history traits among populations is probably a product of both selection and phenotypic plasticity.     

Assessing variation in the potential susceptibility of fish to pharmaceuticals,considering evolutionary differences in their physiology and ecology

Fish represent the planet''s most diverse group of vertebrates and they can be exposed to a wide range of pharmaceuticals. For practical reasons, extrapolation of pharmaceutical effects from ‘model’ species to other fish species is adopted in risk assessment. Here, we critically assess this approach. First, we show that between 65% and 86% of human drug targets are evolutionarily conserved in 12 diverse fish species. Focusing on nuclear steroid hormone receptors, we further show that the sequence of the ligand binding domain that plays a key role in drug potency is highly conserved, but there is variation between species. This variation for the oestrogen receptor, however, does not obviously account for observed differences in receptor activation. Taking the synthetic oestrogen ethinyloestradiol as a test case, and using life-table-response experiments, we demonstrate significant reductions in population growth in fathead minnow and medaka, but not zebrafish, for environmentally relevant exposures. This finding contrasts with zebrafish being ranked as more ecologically susceptible, according to two independent life-history analyses. We conclude that while most drug targets are conserved in fish, evolutionary divergence in drug-target activation, physiology, behaviour and ecological life history make it difficult to predict population-level effects. This justifies the conventional use of at least a 10× assessment factor in pharmaceutical risk assessment, to account for differences in species susceptibility.     

Molecular characterization of estrogen receptors 1, 2a, and 2b and their tissue and ontogenic expression profiles in fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas)

There are two estrogen receptor (ER) subtypes in fish, Esr1 and Esr2 (formerly ERalpha and ERbeta), and in some species the Esr2 subtype has two forms, Esr2b (formerly ERbeta1) and Esr2a (formerly ERbeta2 or ERgamma). There is little information, however, on the different characteristics and functional significance of the two receptor subtypes in fish, and this is especially relevant for understanding the disruption of ER signaling by chemicals with estrogenic activity. In this study, the full-length cDNAs for esr1 (3167 base pairs [bp]) and esr2b (2318 bp), and a partial-length (267 bp) cDNA for esr2a, were cloned and characterized in fathead minnow (fhm; Pimephales promelas), and their patterns of expression established during development and in adults. Real-time polymerase chain reaction revealed some clear distinctions in the ontogenic and tissue expression of fhm esr1, esr2b, and esr2a, suggesting different functions for each ER subtype. Fhm ERs were expressed in brain, pituitary, liver, gonad, intestine, and gill of male and female fish, esr2b and esr2a were also expressed in muscle. Fhm esr1 and esr2b were expressed predominantly in the liver, whereas fhm esr2a was expressed predominantly in intestine and was lowest expressed in liver. Responses of the different hepatic ERs in male fathead minnow exposed to 100 ng estradiol/L differed, with a significant induction (5-fold) of fhm esr1 but no effect on esr2b or esr2a expression, suggesting different mechanisms of regulation for the different ERs. The detailed characterization of ERs in fathead minnow provides the foundation for understanding the molecular basis of estrogenic disruption in fish.     

Temporal characterization of growth of fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) larvae during sublethal hydrogen cyanide exposure

Growth of fathead minnow yolk sac larvae was characterized from changes in dry weight and total content and concentrations of RNA, DNA and protein in fish exposed to a sublethal level of HCN (58 micrograms/l) and in age matched controls. Cyanide toxicosis occurred within 24 hr of exposure as evidenced by significant reductions in protein and RNA content and RNA/DNA ratio of larvae. After 96 hr exposure to HCN, larvae exhibited the same growth rate and protein synthetic rate (RNA/DNA) as control fish. HCN toxicosis and recovery is rapid and at least partial tolerance to HCN develops within 96 hr of exposure in larval fathead minnows.     

Effects of Fathead Minnow Colonization and Removal on a Prairie Wetland Ecosystem

Fish communities in prairie wetlands are extremely dynamic. Due to complete winterkills and periodic colonization, individual basins alternate between supporting a fish population and being fishless. Here we assess the ecological consequences of colonization and subsequent extinction of a fathead minnow population in a prairie wetland. We used a BACI-type approach (before-after control impact) in which data from the colonized wetland were paired with data from a similar fishless site first when both wetlands were fishless (1996), then when the minnow population reached moderate densities in the colonized site (1998), and then again when the colonized site became fishless after treatment with rotenone (1999). Fish colonization resulted in significant increases in turbidity, total phosphorus, and chlorophyll a in the water column; it also caused significant decreases in the abundance of aquatic insects and large cladocerans. Elimination of the minnow population largely reversed the effects of minnow colonization. Our results indicate that characteristics of prairie wetlands can vary as they alternate between supporting fathead minnow populations and being fishless and that ecological characteristics may change rapidly in response to minnow colonization or elimination. Received 18 July 2000; Accepted 17 January 2001.     

Detection of VHSV IVb within the gonads of Great Lakes fish using in situ hybridization

Viral haemorrhagic septicaemia virus (VHSV) genotype IVb was recently detected as the cause of numerous mortality events in Great Lakes fish. In situ hybridization was used to examine the gonads from 13 fish, including freshwater drum Aplodinotus grunniens and muskellunge Esox masquinongy that were infected naturally, as well as rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss and fathead minnows Pimphales promelas, which were experimentally infected. Although the ovaries and testes of fish infected by VHSV IVb had few lesions, viral RNA was present in the ovaries of the rainbow trout and fathead minnow and was abundant in the gonads of muskellunge and in the ovaries of freshwater drum. Viral RNA was present mainly surrounding yolk vacuoles/granules or adjacent to the germinal vesicle, with lesser amounts found within the germinal vesicle, in the mesovarium and/or tunica albuginea and blood vessels of the ovary. Viral RNA was also found in and surrounding primary and secondary spermatocytes of the muskellunge.     

Measurement of vitellogenin,a biomarker for exposure to oestrogenic chemicals,in a wide variety of cyprinid fish

There is increasing concern about man-made chemicals in the aquatic environment that mimic oestrogens because they may disrupt reproductive function. Vitellogenin, a precursor of egg-yolk in fish and other oviparous animals, may be used as a biomarker for “oestrogen” exposure. This study investigated the use of a radioimmunoassay developed to carp (Cyprinus carpio) vitellogenin to measure vitellogenin in other species of fish, especially cyprinids that would be of value for field and laboratory studies on oestrogenic xenobiotics. Of the nine families of fish studied, only vitellogenin from cyprinids (to which the carp belongs) showed good cross-reactivity in the carp vitellogenin radioimmunoassay. Vitellogenin from cyprinids native to Europe that cross reacted in the carp vitellogenin radioimmunoassay included: bream (Abramis brama), roach (Rutilus rutilus), rudd (Scardinius erythropthalmus), gudgeon (Gobio gobio) and minnow (Phoxinus phoxinus). Vitellogenin from cyprinids used widely in ecotoxicology that cross reacted in the carp vitellogenin radioimmunoassay included: fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas), zebrafish (Brachydanio rerio) and goldfish (Carassius auratus). In the cyprinids studies, the concentrations of vitellogenin in mature females were between a few hundred and a thousand microgram per millilitre. Concentrations of plasma vitellogenin in immature females were always greater than 200 ng·m^-1, whereas in males (with the exception of the fathead minnow) plasma vitellogenin concentrations were less than 20 ng·ml^-1 (and generally, much lower). The results suggest that the structure of vitellogenin is highly conserved within the cyprinid family and that the carp vitellogenin radioimmunoassay may be used to measure the concentrations of vitellogenin in plasma from a wide variety of cyprinids.     

Vitellogenin induction by 17beta-estradiol and 17alpha-ethinylestradiol in male zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Adult male zebrafish (Danio rerio) were exposed to 17beta-estradiol (E2) or 17alpha-ethinylestradiol (EE2) in flow-through systems for 8 days. This was done to compare the sensitivity of the estrogen inducible vitellogenin (Vtg) biomarker system of this proposed OECD test guideline species to other relevant test species. Vtg was quantified in whole body homogenate by a species-specific ELISA. Actual water concentrations of E2 and EE2 were quantified by LC-MS, with detection limits of 1.0 and 0.6 ng/l, respectively. Vtg induction (LOEC) occurred in whole body homogenate at actual water concentrations of 21 ng E2/l and 3.0 ng EE2/l, respectively. As an alternative to the ANOVA approach, the relationship between the percentage of responding fish (Vtg) and the external E2 or EE2 concentration was determined by logistic regression analysis. Based on the regression analysis, EC-values could be determined: EC10, EC50 and EC90 were 15.4, 41.2 and 67.1 ng E2/l, respectively and 0.92, 2.51 and 4.09 ng EE2/l, respectively. Comparisons of these response limits to corresponding values for rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss), fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) and Japanese medaka (Oryzias latipes) revealed the zebrafish as a sensitive test species.