A widely applicable, high-throughput TR-FRET assay for the measurement of kinase autophosphorylation: VEGFR-2 as a prototype

Homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) assays represent a highly sensitive and robust high-throughput screening (HTS) method for the quantification of kinase activity. Traditional TR-FRET kinase assays detect the phosphorylation of an exogenous substrate. The authors describe the development and optimization of a TR-FRET technique that measures the autophosphorylation of vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 2 (VEGFR-2) kinase and extend its applicability to a variety of other kinases. The VEGFR-2 assay demonstrated dose-dependent inhibition by compounds known to modulate the catalytic activity of this receptor. In addition, kinetic analysis of a previously characterized VEGFR-2 inhibitor was performed using the method, and results were consistent with those obtained using a different assay format. Because of the known involvement of VEGFR-2 in angiogenesis, this assay should facilitate HTS for antiangiogenic agents. In addition, this general technique should have utility for the screening for inhibitors of kinases as potential therapeutic agents for many other disease indications.     

Development, validation and implementation of immobilized metal affinity for phosphochemicals (IMAP)-based high-throughput screening assays for low-molecular-weight compound libraries

This protocol describes assay development, validation and implementation of automated immobilized metal affinity for phosphochemicals (IMAP)-based fluorescence polarization (FP) and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) high-throughput screening (HTS) assays for identification of low-molecular-weight kinase inhibitors. Both procedures are performed in miniaturized kinase reaction volumes and involve the stepwise addition of test or control compounds, enzyme and substrate/ATP. Kinase reactions are stopped by subsequent addition of IMAP-binding buffer. Assay attributes of the IMAP FP and TR-FRET methodologies are described. HTS assays developed using these procedures should result in Z-factors and low assay variability necessary for robust HTS assays. Providing that the required reagents and equipment are available, one scientist should be able to develop a 384-well, miniaturized HTS assay in approximately 6-8 weeks. Specific automated HTS assay conditions will determine the number of assay plates processed in a screening session, but two scientists should expect to process between 100 and 150 assay plates in one 8-h screening day.     

Comparison of miniaturized time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer and enzyme-coupled luciferase high-throughput screening assays to discover inhibitors of Rho-kinase II (ROCK-II)

Kinases are important drug discovery targets for a wide variety of therapeutic indications; consequently, the measurement of kinase activity remains a common high-throughput screening (HTS) application. Recently, enzyme-coupled luciferase-kinase (LK) format assays have been introduced. This format measures luminescence resulting from metabolism of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) via a luciferin/luciferase-coupled reaction. In the research presented here, 1536-well format time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) and LK assays were created to identify novel Rho-associated kinase II (ROCK-II) inhibitors. HTS campaigns for both assays were conducted in this miniaturized format. It was found that both assays were able to consistently reproduce the expected pharmacology of inhibitors known to be specific to ROCK-II (fasudil IC50: 283 +/- 27 nM and 336 +/- 54 nM for TR-FRET and LK assays, respectively; Y-27632 IC50: 133 +/- 7.8 nM and 150 +/- 22 nM for TR-FRET and LK assays, respectively). In addition, both assays proved robust for HTS efforts, demonstrating excellent plate Z' values during the HTS campaign (0.84 +/- 0.03; 0.72 +/- 0.05 for LK and TR-FRET campaigns, respectively). Both formats identified scaffolds of known and novel ROCK-II inhibitors with similar sensitivity. A comparison of the performance of these 2 assay formats in an HTS campaign was enabled by the existence of a subset of 25,000 compounds found in both our institutional and the Molecular Library Screening Center Network screening files. Analysis of the HTS campaign results based on this subset of common compounds showed that both formats had comparable total hit rates, hit distributions, amount of hit clusters, and format-specific artifact. It can be concluded that both assay formats are suitable for the discovery of ROCK-II inhibitors, and the choice of assay format depends on reagents and/or screening technology available.     

Utilization of fluorescence polarization and time resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer assay formats for SAR studies: Src kinase as a model system

High-throughput screening (HTS), a major component of lead identification, often utilizes fluorescence-based assay technologies. For example, HTS kinase assays are formatted using a variety of fluorescence-based assay technologies including, but not limited to, dissociation enhanced lanthanide fluoroimmunoassay (DELFIA), time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET), and fluorescence polarization (FP). These assays offer tremendous advantages such as a nonradioactive format, ease of automation, and excellent reproducibility. Fluorescence-based assays frequently used for lead identification can also be useful for structure activity relationship (SAR) studies during lead optimization. An important issue when assessing an assay to be used for SAR is the ability of the assay to discriminate high-affinity small molecule inhibitors (pM-nM) from low-affinity inhibitors (microM-mM). The purpose of this study was to utilize HTS-friendly assay formats for SAR by developing TR-FRET, FP, and DELFIAassays measuring Src kinase activity and to define the theoretical lower limit of small molecule inhibitor detection achievable with these assay formats. The authors show that 2 homogeneous assay formats, TR-FRET and FP, allowed for the development of Src kinase assays with a lower limit of detection of K(i) = 0.01 nM. This study indicates that assay technologies typically used for HTS can be used during lead optimization by providing quantitative measurements of compound activity critical to driving SAR studies.     

Assay concordance between SPA and TR-FRET in high-throughput screening

High-throughput screening (HTS) of large chemical libraries has become the main source of new lead compounds for drug development. Several specialized detection technologies have been developed to facilitate the cost- and time-efficient screening of millions of compounds. However, concerns have been raised, claiming that different HTS technologies may produce different hits, thus limiting trust in the reliability of HTS data. This study was aimed to investigate the reliability of the authors most frequently used assay techniques: scintillation proximity assay (SPA) and homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). To investigate the data concordance between these 2 detection technologies, the authors screened a large subset of the Schering compound library consisting of 300,000 compounds for inhibitors of a nonreceptor tyrosine kinase. They chose to set up this study in realistic HTS scale to ensure statistical significance of the results. The findings clearly demonstrate that the choice of detection technology has no significant impact on hit finding, provided that assays are biochemically equivalent. Data concordance is up to 90%. The little differences in hit findings are caused by threshold setting but not by systematic differences between the technologies. The most significant difference between the compared techniques is that in the SPA format, more false-positive primary hits were obtained.     

A homogeneous single-label time-resolved fluorescence cAMP assay

G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are an important class of pharmaceutical drug targets. Functional high-throughput GPCR assays are needed to test an increasing number of synthesized novel drug compounds and their function in signal transduction processes. Measurement of changes in the cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) concentration is a widely used method to verify GPCR activation in the adenylyl cyclase pathway. Here, a single-label time-resolved fluorescence and high-throughput screening (HTS)-feasible method was developed to measure changes in cAMP levels in HEK293(i) cells overexpressing either β(2)-adrenergic or δ-opioid receptors. In the quenching resonance energy transfer (QRET) technique, soluble quenchers reduce the signal of unbound europium(III)-labeled cAMP in solution, whereas the antibody-bound fraction is fluorescent. The feasibility of this homogeneous competitive assay was proven by agonist-mediated stimulation of receptors coupled to either the stimulatory G(s) or inhibitory G(i) proteins. The reproducibility of the assays was excellent, and Z' values exceeded 0.7. The dynamic range, signal-to-background ratio, and detection limit were compared with a commercial time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) assay. In both homogeneous assays, similar assay parameters were obtained when adenylyl cyclase was stimulated directly by forskolin or via agonist-mediated activation of the G(s)-coupled β(2)AR. The advantage of using the single-label approach relates to the cost-effectiveness of the QRET system compared with the two-label TR-FRET assay as there is no need for labeling of two binding partners leading to reduced requirements for assay optimization.     

High-throughput fluorescence polarization assay for chemical library screening against anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 family member Bfl-1

Overexpression of the anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 family proteins occurs commonly in human cancers. Bfl-1 is highly expressed in some types of malignant cells, contributing significantly to tumor cell survival and chemoresistance. Therefore, it would be desirable to have chemical antagonists of Bfl-1. To this end, we devised a fluorescence polarization assay (FPA) using Bfl-1 protein and fluorescein-conjugated Bid BH3 peptide, which was employed for high-throughput screening of chemical libraries. Approximately 66 000 compounds were screened for the ability to inhibit BH3 peptide binding to Bfl-1, yielding 14 reproducible hits with ≥50% displacement. After dose-response analysis and confirmation using a secondary assay based on time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET), two groups of Bfl-1-specific inhibitors were identified, including chloromaleimide and sulfonylpyrimidine series compounds. FPAs generated for each of the six anti-apoptotic Bcl-2 proteins demonstrated selective binding of both classes of compounds to Bfl-1. Analogs of the sulfonylpyrimidine series were synthesized and compared with the original hit for Bfl-1 binding by both FPAs and TR-FRET assays. The resulting structure-activity relation analysis led to the chemical probe compound CID-2980973 (ML042). Collectively, these findings demonstrate the feasibility of using the HTS assay for discovery of selective chemical inhibitors of Bfl-1.     

Development of a High-Throughput Fluorescence Polarization Assay to Identify Novel Ligands of Glutamate Carboxypeptidase II

Glutamate carboxypeptidase II (GCPII) is an important target for therapeutic and diagnostic interventions aimed at prostate cancer and neurologic disorders. Here we describe the development and optimization of a high-throughput screening (HTS) assay based on fluorescence polarization (FP) that facilitates the identification of novel scaffolds inhibiting GCPII. First, we designed and synthesized a fluorescence probe based on a urea-based inhibitory scaffold covalently linked to a Bodipy TMR fluorophore (TMRGlu). Next, we established and optimized conditions suitable for HTS and evaluated the assay robustness by testing the influence of a variety of physicochemical parameters (e.g., pH, temperature, time) and additives. Using known GCPII inhibitors, the FP assay was shown to be comparable to benchmark assays established in the field. Finally, we evaluated the FP assay by HTS of a 20 000-compound library. The novel assay presented here is robust, highly reproducible (Z' = 0.82), inexpensive, and suitable for automation, thus providing an excellent platform for HTS of small-molecule libraries targeting GCPII.     

High-throughput identification of inhibitors of human mitochondrial peptide deformylase

The human mitochondrial peptide deformylase (HsPDF) provides a potential new target for broadly acting antiproliferative agents. To identify novel nonpeptidomimetic and nonhydroxamic acid-based inhibitors of HsPDF, the authors have developed a high-throughput screening (HTS) strategy using a fluorescence polarization (FP)-based binding assay as the primary assay for screening chemical libraries, followed by an enzymatic-based assay to confirm hits, prior to characterization of their antiproliferative activity against established tumor cell lines. The authors present the results and performance of the established strategy tested in a pilot screen of 2880 compounds and the identification of the 1st inhibitors. Two common scaffolds were identified within the hits. Furthermore, cytotoxicity studies revealed that most of the confirmed hits have antiproliferative activity. These findings demonstrate that the designed strategy can identify novel functional inhibitors and provide a powerful alternative to the use of functional assays in HTS and support the hypothesis that HsPDF inhibitors may constitute a new class of antiproliferative agent.     

Comparison of assay technologies for a nuclear receptor assay screen reveals differences in the sets of identified functional antagonists

Many assay technologies currently exist to develop high-throughput screening assays, and the number of choices continues to increase. Results from a previous study comparing assay technologies in our laboratory do not support the common assumption that the same hits would be found regardless of which assay technology is used. To extend this investigation, a nuclear receptor antagonist assay was developed using 3 assay formats: AlphaScreen, time-resolved fluorescence (TRF), and time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET). Compounds ( approximately 42000) from the Novartis library were evaluated in all 3 assay formats. A total of 128 compounds were evaluated in dose-response experiments, and 109 compounds were confirmed active from all 3 formats. The AlphaScreen, TRF, and TR-FRET assay technologies identified 104, 23, and 57 active compounds, respectively, with only 18 compounds active in all 3 assay formats. A total of 128 compounds were evaluated in a cell-based functional assay, and 35 compounds demonstrated activity in this cellular assay. Furthermore, 34, 11, and 16 hits that were originally identified in the dose-response experiment by AlphaScreen, TRF, and TR-FRET assay technologies, respectively, were functionally active. The results of the study indicated that AlphaScreen identified the greatest number of functional antagonists.     

A simple, no-wash cell adhesion-based high-throughput assay for the discovery of small-molecule regulators of the integrin CD11b/CD18

The leukocyte-specific integrin CD11b/CD18 plays a key role in the biological function of these cells and represents a validated therapeutic target for inflammatory diseases. Currently, the low affinity interaction between CD11b/CD18 integrin and its respective ligand poses a challenge in the development of cell-based adhesion assays for the high-throughput screening (HTS) environment. Here the authors describe a simple cell-based adhesion assay that can be readily used for HTS for the discovery of functional regulators of CD11b/CD18. The assay consistently produces acceptable Z' values (> 0.5) for HTS. After testing the assay using 2 established blocking antibodies as reference biologicals, the authors performed a proof-of-concept primary screen using a library of 6612 compounds and identified both agonist and antagonist hits.     

HTS promiscuity analyses for accelerating decision making

Frequent hitters are compounds that are detected as a "hit" in multiple high-throughput screening (HTS) assays. Such behavior is specific (e.g., target family related) or unspecific (e.g., reactive compounds) or can result from a combination of such behaviors. Detecting such hits while predicting the underlying reason behind their promiscuous behavior is desirable because it provides valuable information not only about the compounds themselves but also about the assay methodology and target classes at hand. This information can also greatly reduce cost and time during HTS hit profiling. The present study exemplifies how to mine large HTS data repositories, such as the one at Boehringer Ingelheim, to identify frequent hitters, gain further insights into the causes of promiscuous behavior, and generate models for predicting promiscuous compounds. Applications of this approach are demonstrated using two recent large-scale HTS assays. The authors believe this analysis and its concrete applications are valuable tools for streamlining and accelerating decision-making processes during the course of hit discovery.     

Label Free Fragment Screening Using Surface Plasmon Resonance as a Tool for Fragment Finding – Analyzing Parkin,a Difficult CNS Target

Surface Plasmon Resonance (SPR) is rarely used as a primary High-throughput Screening (HTS) tool in fragment-based approaches. With SPR instruments becoming increasingly high-throughput it is now possible to use SPR as a primary tool for fragment finding. SPR becomes, therefore, a valuable tool in the screening of difficult targets such as the ubiquitin E3 ligase Parkin. As a prerequisite for the screen, a large number of SPR tests were performed to characterize and validate the active form of Parkin. A set of compounds was designed and used to define optimal SPR assay conditions for this fragment screen. Using these conditions, more than 5000 pre-selected fragments from our in-house library were screened for binding to Parkin. Additionally, all fragments were simultaneously screened for binding to two off target proteins to exclude promiscuous binding compounds. A low hit rate was observed that is in line with hit rates usually obtained by other HTS screening assays. All hits were further tested in dose responses on the target protein by SPR for confirmation before channeling the hits into Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) and other hit-confirmation assays.     

Pharmacological characterization of a fluorescent uptake assay for the noradrenaline transporter

The noradrenaline transporter (NET) is a Na(+)/Cl(-) dependent monoamine transporter that mediates rapid clearance of noradrenaline from the synaptic cleft, thereby terminating neuronal signaling. NET is an important target for drug development and is known to be modulated by many psychoactive compounds, including psychostimulants and antidepressants. Here, the authors describe the development and pharmacological characterization of a nonhomogeneous fluorescent NET uptake assay using the compound 4-(4-dimethylaminostyryl)-N-methylpyridinium (ASP(+)). Data presented show that the pharmacology of both the classic radiolabeled (3)H-noradrenaline- and ASP(+)-based uptake assays are comparable, with an excellent correlation between potency obtained for known modulators of NET (r = 0.95, p < 0.0001). Furthermore, the fluorescent uptake assay is highly reproducible and has sufficiently large Z' values to be amenable for high-throughput screening (HTS). The advantage of this assay is compatibility with both 96- and 384-well formats and lack of radioactivity usage. Thus, the authors conclude that the assay is an inexpensive, viable approach for the identification and pharmacological profiling of small-molecule modulators of the monoamine transporter NET and may be amenable for HTS.     

Comparison of assay technologies for a tyrosine kinase assay generates different results in high throughput screening

In today's high-throughput screening (HTS) environment, an increasing number of assay detection technologies are routinely utilized in lead finding programs. Because of the relatively broad applicability of several of these technologies, one is often faced with a choice of which technology to utilize for a specific assay. The aim of this study was to address the question of whether the same compounds would be identified from screening a set of samples in three different versions of an HTS assay. Here, three different versions of a tyrosine kinase assay were established using scintillation proximity assay (SPA), homogeneous time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (HTR-FRET), and fluorescence polarization (FP) technologies. In this study, 30,000 compounds were evaluated in each version of the kinase assay in primary screening, deconvolution, and dose-response experiments. From this effort, there was only a small degree of overlap of active compounds identified subsequent to the deconvolution experiment. When all active compounds were then profiled in all three assays, 100 and 101 active compounds were identified in the HTR-FRET and FP assays, respectively. In contrast, 40 compounds were identified in the SPA version of the kinase assay, whereas all of these compounds were detected in the HTR-FRET assay only 35 were active in the FP assay. Although there was good correlation between the IC(50) values obtained in the HTR-FRET and FP assays, poor correlations were obtained with the IC(50) values obtained in the SPA assay. These findings suggest that significant differences can be observed from HTS depending on the assay technology that is utilized, particularly in assays with high hit rates.     

Colloidal aggregate detection by rapid fluorescence measurement of liquid surface curvature changes in multiwell plates

A simple fluorescence method is reported for the detection of colloidal aggregate formation in solution, with specific applications to determine the critical micelle concentration (CMC) of surfactants and detect small-molecule promiscuous inhibitors. The method exploits the meniscus curvature changes in high-density multiwell plates associated with colloidal changes in solution. The shape of the meniscus has a significant effect on fluorescence intensity when detected using a top-read fluorescence plate reader because of the effect of total internal reflection on fluorescence emission through a curved liquid surface. A dynamic range of 60% is calculated and observed and is measured with a relative sensitivity of 2%. Facile determination of the CMC of a variety of surfactants is demonstrated, as well as a screening assay for aggregate forming properties of small drug-like compounds, a common cause of promiscuous inhibition in high-throughput screening (HTS) enzyme inhibitor assays. Our preliminary results show a potential HTS assay with Z' factor of 0.76, with good separation between aggregating and nonaggregating small molecules. The method combines the high sensitivity and universality of classic surface tension methods with simplicity and high-throughput determination, enabling facile detection of molecular interactions involving a change in liquid or solid surface character.     

The RING finger protein RNF8 recruits UBC13 for lysine 63-based self polyubiquitylation

The heterodimeric ubiquitin conjugating enzyme (E2) UBC13-UEV mediates polyubiquitylation through lysine 63 of ubiquitin (K63), rather than lysine 48 (K48). This modification does not target proteins for proteasome-dependent degradation. Searching for potential regulators of this variant polyubiquitylation we have identified four proteins, namely RNF8, KIA00675, KF1, and ZNRF2, that interact with UBC13 through their RING finger domains. These domains can recruit, in addition to UBC13, other E2s that mediate canonical (K48) polyubiquitylation. None of these RING finger proteins were known previously to recruit UBC13. For one of these proteins, RNF8, we show its activity as a ubiquitin ligase that elongates chains through either K48 or K63 of ubiquitin, and its nuclear co-localization with UBC13. Thus, our screening reveals new potential regulators of non-canonical polyubiquitylation.     

A comparison of ALPHAScreen, TR-FRET, and TRF as assay methods for FXR nuclear receptors

New developments in detection technologies are providing a variety of biomolecular screening strategies from which to choose. Consequently, we performed a detailed analysis of both separation-based and non-separation-based formats for screening nuclear receptor ligands. In this study, time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET), ALPHAScreen, and time-resolved fluorescence (TRF) assays were optimized and compared with respect to sensitivity, reproducibility, and miniaturization capability. The results showed that the ALPHAScreen system had the best sensitivity and dynamic range. The TRF assay was more time consuming because of the number of wash steps necessary. The TR-FRET assay had less interwell variation, most likely because of ratiometric measurement. Both the ALPHAScreen and the TR-FRET assays were miniaturized to 8-microl volumes. Of the photomultiplier tube-based readers, the ALPHAScreen reader (ALPHAQuest) presented the advantage of faster reading times through simultaneous reading with four photomultiplier tubes.     

Homogeneous TR-FRET high-throughput screening assay for calcium-dependent multimerization of sorcin

A homogeneous high-throughput screening method based on time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (TR-FRET) for the measurement of calcium-dependent multimerization of an EF-hand protein, sorcin, is described. The assay is based on a specific sorcin binding peptide conjugated either with an intrinsically highly fluorescent europium chelate (donor) or an Alexa Fluor 700 fluorophore (acceptor). Addition of calcium results in multimerization of sorcin, allowing several peptides to bind simultaneously to the epitopes of the multimeric protein complex, and the proximity of peptides labeled either with donor or acceptor label results in fluorescence resonance energy transfer between the 2 labels. When no calcium is present, the protein remains in a monomer form, and thus no FRET can take place. In the optimized assay construct, the assay was performed in 45 min, and a more than 20-fold signal-to-background ratio was achieved. The reversibility of sorcin multimerization was shown by chelating free calcium with ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid (EDTA). The developed homogeneous assay can be used in screening molecules that either inhibit or enhance multimerization of sorcin, and the assay format is applicable to various noncompetitive high-throughput screening assays detecting protein multimerization reactions.