Singlet oxygen production in photosynthesis

A photosynthetic organism is subjected to photo-oxidative stress when more light energy is absorbed than is used in photosynthesis. In the light, highly reactive singlet oxygen can be produced via triplet chlorophyll formation in the reaction centre of photosystem II and in the antenna system. In the antenna, triplet chlorophyll is produced directly by excited singlet chlorophyll, while in the reaction centre it is formed via charge recombination of the light-induced charge pair. Changes of the mid-point potential of the primary quinone acceptor in photosystem II modulate the pathway of charge recombination in photosystem II and influence the yield of singlet oxygen production. Singlet oxygen can be quenched by beta-carotene, alpha-tocopherol or can react with the D1 protein of photosystem II as target. If not completely quenched, it can specifically trigger the up-regulation of the expression of genes which are involved in the molecular defence response of plants against photo-oxidative stress.     

Structural and functional dynamics of plant photosystem II

Given the unique problem of the extremely high potential of the oxidant P(+)(680) that is required to oxidize water to oxygen, the photoinactivation of photosystem II in vivo is inevitable, despite many photoprotective strategies. There is, however, a robustness of photosystem II, which depends partly on the highly dynamic compositional and structural heterogeneity of the cycle between functional and non-functional photosystem II complexes in response to light level. This coordinated regulation involves photon usage (energy utilization in photochemistry) and excess energy dissipation as heat, photoprotection by many molecular strategies, photoinactivation followed by photon damage and ultimately the D1 protein dynamics involved in the photosystem II repair cycle. Compelling, though indirect evidence suggests that the radical pair P(+)(680)Pheo(-) in functional PSII should be protected from oxygen. By analogy to the tentative oxygen channel of cytochrome c oxidase, oxygen may be liberated from the two water molecules bound to the catalytic site of the Mn cluster, via a specific pathway to the membrane surface. The function of the proposed oxygen pathway is to prevent O(2) from having direct access to P(+)(680)Pheo(-) and prevent the generation of singlet oxygen via the triplet-P(680) state in functional photosytem IIs. Only when the, as yet unidentified, potential trigger with a fateful first oxidative step destroys oxygen evolution, will the ensuing cascade of structural perturbations of photosystem II destroy the proposed oxygen, water and proton pathways. Then oxygen has direct access to P(+)(680)Pheo(-), singlet oxygen will be produced and may successively oxidize specific amino acids of the phosphorylated D1 protein of photosystem II dimers that are confined to appressed granal domains, thereby targeting D1 protein for eventual degradation and replacement in non-appressed thylakoid domains.     

Role of singlet oxygen in chloroplast to nucleus retrograde signaling in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

High light illumination of photosynthetic organisms stimulates the production of singlet oxygen by photosystem II and causes photooxidative stress. In Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, singlet oxygen also induces the expression of the nuclear-encoded glutathione peroxidase homologous gene GPXH. We provide evidence that singlet oxygen stimulates GPXH expression by activating a signaling mechanism outside the thylakoid membrane. Singlet oxygen from photosystem II could be detected with specific probes in the aqueous phase of isolated thylakoid suspensions and the cytoplasm of high light stressed cells. This indicates that singlet oxygen can stimulate a response farther from its production site than generally believed.     

Acclimation of photosynthesis to nitrogen deficiency in Phaseolus vulgaris

Nitrogen deficiency diminishes consumption of photosynthates in anabolic metabolism. We studied adjustments of the photosynthetic machinery in nitrogen-deficient bean plants and found four phenomena. First, the number of chloroplasts per cell decreased. Chloroplasts of nitrogen starved leaves contained less pigments than those of control leaves, but the in vitro activities of light reactions did not change when measured on chlorophyll basis. Second, nitrogen deficiency induced cyclic electron transfer. The amounts of Rubisco and ferredoxin-NADP⁺ reductase decreased in nitrogen starved plants. Low activities of these enzymes are expected to lead to increase in reduction of oxygen by photosystem I. However, diaminobenzidine staining did not reveal hydrogen peroxide production in nitrogen starved plants. Measurements of far-red-light-induced redox changes of the primary donor of photosystem I suggested that instead of producing oxygen radicals, nitrogen starved plants develop a high activity of cyclic electron transport that competes with oxygen for electrons. Nitrogen starvation led to decrease in photochemical quenching and increase in non-photochemical quenching, indicating that cyclic electron transport reduces the plastoquinone pool and acidifies the lumen. A third effect is redistribution of excitation energy between the photosystems in favor of photosystem I. Thus, thylakoids of nitrogen starved plants appeared to be locked in state 2, which further protects photosystem II by decreasing its absorption cross-section. As a fourth response, the proportion of non-Q_B-reducing photosystem II reaction centers increased and the redox potential of the Q_B/Q_B⁻ pair decreased by 25 mV in a fraction of photosystem II centers of nitrogen starved plants.     

Balance of power: a view of the mechanism of photosynthetic state transitions.

Photosynthesis in plants involves photosystem I and photosystem II, both of which use light energy to drive redox processes. Plants can balance the distribution of absorbed light energy between the two photosystems. When photosystem II is favoured, a mobile pool of light harvesting complex II moves from photosystem II to photosystem I. This short-term and reversible redistribution is known as a state transition. It is associated with changes in the phosphorylation of light harvesting complex II but the regulation is complex. Redistribution of energy during state transitions depends on an altered binding equilibrium between the light harvesting complex II-photosystem II and light harvesting complex II-photosystem I complexes.     

Plastoquinol is more active than α-tocopherol in singlet oxygen scavenging during high light stress of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

In the present study, we have performed comparative analysis of different prenyllipids in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii cultures during high light stress under variety of conditions (presence of inhibitors, an uncoupler, heavy water). The obtained results indicate that plastoquinol is more active than α-tocopherol in scavenging of singlet oxygen generated in photosystem II. Besides plastoquinol, also its oxidized form, plastoquinone shows antioxidant action during the stress conditions, resulting in formation of plastoquinone-C, whose level can be regarded as an indicator of singlet oxygen oxidative stress in vivo. The pronounced stimulation of α-tocopherol consumption and α-tocopherolquinone formation by an uncoupler, FCCP, together with the results of additional model system studies, led to the suggestion that α-tocopherol can be recycled in thylakoid membranes under high light conditions from 8a-hydroperoxy-α-tocopherone, the primary oxidation product of α-tocopherol by singlet oxygen.     

Coregulation of light-harvesting complex II phosphorylation and lhcb mRNA accumulation in winter rye

Winter rye plants grown under contrasting environmental conditions or just transiently shifted to varying light and temperature conditions, were studied to elucidate the chloroplast signal involved in regulation of photosynthesis genes in the nucleus. Photosystem II excitation pressure, reflecting the plastoquinone redox state, and the phosphorylation level of thylakoid light-harvesting proteins (LHCII and CP29) were monitored together with changes occurring in the accumulation of lhcb, rbcS and psbA mRNAs. Short-term shifts of plants to changed conditions, from 1 h to 2 d, were postulated to reveal signals crucial for the initiation of the acclimation process. Comparison of these results with those obtained from plants acclimated during several weeks' growth at contrasting temperature and in different light regimes, allow us to make the following conclusions: (1) LHCII protein phosphoylation is a sensitive tool to monitor redox changes in chloroplasts; (2) LHCII protein phosphorylation and lhcb mRNA accumulation occur under similar conditions and are possibly coregulated via an activation state of the same kinase (the LHCII kinase); (3) Maximal accumulation of lhcb mRNA during the diurnal light phase seems to require an active LHCII kinase whereas inactivation of the kinase is accompanied by dampening of the circadian oscillation in the amount of lhcb mRNA; (4) Excitation pressure of photosystem II (reduction state of the plastoquinone pool) is not directly involved in the regulation of lhcb mRNA accumulation. Instead (5) the redox status of the electron acceptors of photosystem I in the stromal compartment seems to be highly regulated and crucial for the regulation of lhcb gene expression in the nucleus.     

Photosynthetic acclimation to light gradients in plant stands comes out of shade

Dense plant populations or canopies exhibit a strong enrichment in far-red wavelengths which leads to unequal excitation of the two photosystems. In the long-term plants acclimate to changes in light quality by adjusting photosystem stoichiometry and antenna structure, a mechanism called here long-term response (LTR). Using an artificial light system it is possible to mimic such naturally occurring gradients in light quality under controlled laboratory conditions. By this means we recently demonstrated that the LTR is crucial for plant fitness and survival of Arabidopsis. We could also demonstrate that the chlorophyll fluorescence parameter Fs/Fm is a genuine non-invasive functional indicator for acclimatory changes during the LTR. Here we give supportive data that the Fs/Fm can be also used to monitor the LTR in field experiments in which Arabidopsis plants were grown either under canopies or wavelength-neutral shade. Furthermore our data support the notion that acclimation responses to light quality and light quantity are separate mechanisms. Thus, the long-term response to light quality represents an important and distinct acclimation strategy for improving plant survival under changing light quality conditions.Key words: photosynthetic acclimation, redox control, long-term responses, light quality, Arabidopsis, plant fitness     

The role of the PsbS protein in the protection of photosystems I and II against high light in Arabidopsis thaliana

The PsbS protein is recognised in higher plants as an important component in dissipating excess light energy via its regulation of non-photochemical quenching. We investigated photosynthetic responses in the arabidopsis npq4 mutant, which lacks PsbS, and in a mutant over-expressing PsbS (oePsbS). Growth under low light led to npq4 and wild-type plants being visibly indistinguishable, but induced a phenotype in oePsbS plants, which were smaller and had shorter flowering spikes. Here we report that chloroplasts from npq4 generated more singlet oxygen (¹O₂) than those from oePsbS. This accompanied a higher extent of photosystem II photoinhibition of leaves from npq4 plants. In contrast, oePsbS was more damaged by high light than npq4 and the wild-type at the level of photosystem I. The plastoquinone pool, as measured by thermoluminescence, was more oxidised in the oePsbS than in npq4, whilst the amount of photo-oxidisable P₇₀₀, as probed with actinic light or saturating flashes, was higher in oePsbS compared to wild-type and npq4. Taken together, this indicates that the level of PsbS has a regulatory role in cyclic electron flow. Overall, we show that under high light oePsbS plants were more protected from ¹O₂ at the level of photosystem II, whereas lack of cyclic electron flow rendered them susceptible to damage at photosystem I. Cyclic electron flow is concluded to be essential for protecting photosystem I from high light stress.     

Sensing environmental temperature change through imbalances between energy supply and energy consumption: Redox state of photosystem II

A basic requirement of all photosynthetic organisms is a balance between overall energy supply through temperature-independent photochemical reactions and energy consumption through the temperature-dependent biochemical reactions of photosynthetic electron transport and contiguous metabolic pathways. Since the turnover of photosystem II (PSII) reaction centers is a limiting step in the conversion of light energy into ATP and NADPH, any energy imbalance may be sensed through modulation of the redox state of PSII. This can be estimated in vivo by chlorophyll a fluorescence as changes in the redox state of PSII, or photosystem II excitation pressure, which reflects changes in the redox poise of intersystem electron transport carriers. Through comparisons of photosynthetic adjustment, we show that growth at low temperature mimics growth at high light. We conclude that terrestrial plants, green algae and cyanobacteria do not respond to changes in growth temperature or growth irradiance per se, but rather, respond to changes in the redox state of intersystem electron transport as reflected by changes in PSII excitation pressure, We suggest that this chloroplastic redox sensing mechanism may be an important component for sensing abiotic stresses in general. Thus, in addition to its role in energy transduction, the chloroplast may also be considered a primary sensor of environmental change through a redox sensing/signalling mechanism that acts synergistically with other signal transduction pathways to elicit the appropriate molecular and physiological responses.     

Plasticity in the composition of the light harvesting antenna of higher plants preserves structural integrity and biological function

Arabidopsis plants in which the major trimeric light harvesting complex (LHCIIb) is eliminated by antisense expression still exhibit the typical macrostructure of photosystem II in the granal membranes. Here the detailed analysis of the composition and the functional state of the light harvesting antennae of both photosystem I and II of these plants is presented. Two new populations of trimers were found, both functional in energy transfer to the PSII reaction center, a homotrimer of CP26 and a heterotrimer of CP26 and Lhcb3. These trimers possess characteristic features thought to be specific for the native LHCIIb trimers they are replacing: the long wavelength form of lutein and at least one extra chlorophyll b, but they were less stable. A new population of loosely bound LHCI was also found, contributing to an increased antenna size for photosystem I, which may in part compensate for the loss of the phosphorylated LHCIIb that can associate with this photosystem. Thus, the loss of LHCIIb has triggered concerted compensatory responses in the composition of antennae of both photosystems. These responses clearly show the importance of LHCIIb in the structure and assembly of the photosynthetic membrane and illustrate the extreme plasticity at the level of the composition of the light harvesting system.     

Photosynthetic acclimation: state transitions and adjustment of photosystem stoichiometry--functional relationships between short-term and long-term light quality acclimation in plants

In dense plant populations, individuals shade each other resulting in a low-light habitat that is enriched in far-red light. This light quality gradient decreases the efficiency of the photosynthetic light reaction as a result of imbalanced excitation of the two photosystems. Plants counteract such conditions by performing acclimation reactions. Two major mechanisms are known to assure efficient photosynthesis: state transitions, which act on a short-term timescale; and a long-term response, which enables the plant to re-adjust photosystem stoichiometry in favour of the rate-limiting photosystem. Both processes start with the perception of the imbalanced photosystem excitation via reduction/oxidation (redox) signals from the photosynthetic electron transport chain. Recent data in Arabidopsis indicate that initialization of the molecular processes in both cases involve the activity of the thylakoid membrane-associated kinase, STN7. Thus, redox-controlled phosphorylation events may not only adjust photosystem antenna structure but may also affect plastid, as well as nuclear, gene expression. Both state transitions and the long-term response have been described mainly in molecular terms, while the physiological relevance concerning plant survival and reproduction has been poorly investigated. Recent studies have shed more light on this topic. Here, we give an overview on the long-term response, its physiological effects, possible mechanisms and its relationship to state transitions as well as to nonphotochemical quenching, another important short-term mechanism that mediates high-light acclimation. Special emphasis is given to the functional roles and potential interactions between the different light acclimation strategies. A working model displays the various responses as an integrated molecular system that helps plants to acclimate to the changing light environment.     

Photorespiration is More Effective than the Mehler Reaction in Protecting the Photosynthetic Apparatus against Photoinhibition

I. Isolated intact chloroplasts: Photosystem II, but not photosystem I, of the electron transport chain is rapidly photoinactivated even by very low intensities of red light when no large proton gradient can be formed and the electron transport chain becomes over-reduced in the absence of oxygen and other reducable substrates. Electron acceptors including oxygen provide protection against photoinactivation. Nevertheless, photosystem II is rapidly, and photosystem I more slowly, photoinactivated by high intensities of red light when oxygen is the only electron acceptor available. Increased damage is observed at increased oxygen concentrations although catalase is added to destroy H₂O₂ formed during oxygen reduction in the Mehler reaction. Photoinactivation can be decreased, but not prevented by ascorbate which reduces hydrogen peroxide inside the chloroplasts and increases coupled electron flow. II. Leaves: Simple measurements of chlorophyll fluorescence permit assessment of damage to photosystem II after exposure of leaves to high intensity illumination. In contrast to isolated chloroplasts, chloroplasts suffer more damage in situ at reduced than at elevated oxygen concentrations. The difference in the responses is due to photorespiration which is active in leaves, but not in isolated chloroplasts. After photosynthesis and photorespiration are inhibited by feeding glyceraldehyde to leaves, photoinactivation is markedly increased, although oxygen reduction in the Mehler reaction is not affected by glyceraldehyde. In the presence of reduced CO₂ levels, photorespiratory reactions, but not the Mehler reaction, can prevent the overreduction of the electron transport chain. Over-reduction indicates ineffective control of photosystem II activity. Effective control is needed for protection of the electron transport chain against photoinactivation. It is suggested to be made possible by coupled cyclic electron flow around photosystem I which is facilitated by the redox poising resulting from the interplay between photorespiratory carbohydrate oxidation and the refixation of evolved CO₂.     

Too much light? How beta-carotene protects the photosystem II reaction centre.

The photosystem II reaction centre of all oxygenic organisms is subject to photodamage by high light i.e. photoinhibition. In this review I discuss the reasons for the inevitable and unpreventable oxidative damage that occurs in photosystem II and the way in which beta-carotene bound to the reaction centre significantly mitigates this damage. Recent X-ray structures of the photosystem II core complex (reaction centre plus the inner antenna complexes) have revealed the binding sites of some of the carotenoids known to be bound to the complex. In the light of these X-ray structures and their known biophysical properties it is thus possible to identify the two beta-carotenes present in the photosystem II reaction centre. The two carotenes are both bound to the D2 protein and this positioning is discussed in relation to their ability to act as quenchers of singlet oxygen, generated via the triplet state of the primary electron donor. It is proposed that their location on the D2 polypeptide means there is more oxidative damage to the D1 protein and that this underlies the fact that this latter protein is continuously re-synthesised, at a far greater rate than any other protein involved in photosynthesis. The relevance of a cycle of electrons around photosystem II, via cytochrome b(559), in order to re-reduce the beta-carotenes when they are oxidised and hence restore their ability to quench singlet oxygen, is also discussed.     

PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION5 Is Essential for Proper Acclimation of Arabidopsis Photosystem I to Naturally and Artificially Fluctuating Light Conditions

In nature, plants are challenged by constantly changing light conditions. To reveal the molecular mechanisms behind acclimation to sometimes drastic and frequent changes in light intensity, we grew Arabidopsis thaliana under fluctuating light conditions, in which the low light periods were repeatedly interrupted with high light peaks. Such conditions had only marginal effect on photosystem II but induced damage to photosystem I (PSI), the damage being most severe during the early developmental stages. We showed that PROTON GRADIENT REGULATION5 (PGR5)-dependent regulation of electron transfer and proton motive force is crucial for protection of PSI against photodamage, which occurred particularly during the high light phases of fluctuating light cycles. Contrary to PGR5, the NAD(P)H dehydrogenase complex, which mediates cyclic electron flow around PSI, did not contribute to acclimation of the photosynthetic apparatus, particularly PSI, to rapidly changing light intensities. Likewise, the Arabidopsis pgr5 mutant exhibited a significantly higher mortality rate compared with the wild type under outdoor field conditions. This shows not only that regulation of PSI under natural growth conditions is crucial but also the importance of PGR5 in PSI protection.     

Redox functions of carotenoids in photosynthesis

Carotenoids are well-known as light-harvesting pigments. They also play important roles in protecting the photosynthetic apparatus from damaging reactions of chlorophyll triplet states and singlet oxygen in both plant and bacterial photosynthesis. Recently, it has been found that beta-carotene functions as a redox intermediate in the secondary pathways of electron transfer within photosystem II and that carotenoid cation radicals are transiently formed after photoexcitation of bacterial light-harvesting complexes. The redox role of beta-carotene in photosystem II is unique among photosynthetic reaction centers and stems from the very strongly oxidizing intermediates that form in the process of water oxidation. Because of the extended pi-electron-conjugated system of carotenoid molecules, the cation radical is delocalized. This enables beta-carotene to function as a "molecular wire", whereby the centrally located oxidizing species is shuttled to peripheral redox centers of photosystem II where it can be dissipated without damaging the system. The physiological significance of carotenoid cation radical formation in bacterial light-harvesting complexes is not yet clear, but may provide a novel mechanism for excitation energy dissipation as a means of photoprotection. In this paper, the redox reactions of carotenoids in photosystem II and bacterial light-harvesting complexes are presented and the possible roles of carotenoid cation radicals in photoprotection are discussed.     

A mechanism for regulation of chloroplast LHC II kinase by plastoquinol and thioredoxin

State transitions are acclimatory responses to changes in light quality in photosynthesis. They involve the redistribution of absorbed excitation energy between photosystems I and II. In plants and green algae, this redistribution is produced by reversible phosphorylation of the chloroplast light harvesting complex II (LHC II). The LHC II kinase is activated by reduced plastoquinone (PQ) in photosystem II-specific low light. In high light, when PQ is also reduced, LHC II kinase becomes inactivated by thioredoxin. Based on newly identified amino acid sequence features of LHC II kinase and other considerations, a mechanism is suggested for its redox regulation.