Quantitative footprinting analysis of the netropsin-DNA interaction

The results of a series of quantitative footprinting experiments of the netropsin-DNA interaction as studied using two different DNA cleaving probes, the enzyme DNase I and a cationic manganese porphyrin complex, are described. Plots of the relative change in oligonucleotide concentration as a function of drug concentration, covering approximately 110 base pairs of a DNA restriction fragment, revealed netropsin induced changes in the cleavage rates of both probes. These appeared as inhibitions for the binding sites, enhancements where no binding took place, and enhancement/inhibitions for the weak binding sites. Determination of the concentration of drug necessary to reduce the amount of a particular oligomer to half of its initial value allowed a ranking of the affinities of the various binding sites on the fragment. In addition to uncovering the location of a number of overlapping netropsin binding sites, the data allowed additional insight on the manner in which both probes alter their DNA cleavage rates in the drug-footprinting experiment.     

Rate enhancements in the DNase I footprinting experiment.

Footprinting experiments for DNase I digests of a 139-base-pair segment of pBR-322 DNA in the presence of either netropsin or actinomycin D were carried out. Plots of oligonucleotide concentration as a function of drug concentration were analyzed to study the enhancement in cleavage rates at approximately 30 sites, accompanying drug binding at other sites. The pattern of enhancements is not consistent with drug-induced DNA structural changes, but agrees with a redistribution mechanism involving DNase I. Since the total number of enzyme molecules per fragment remains unchanged, drug binding at some sites increases the enzyme concentration at other sites, giving rise to increased cleavage. The consequences of the redistribution mechanism for analysis of footprinting experiments are indicated.     

Quantitative footprinting analysis using a DNA-cleaving metalloporphyrin complex

The results of quantitative footprinting studies involving the antiviral agent netropsin and a DNA-cleaving cationic metalloporphyrin complex are presented. An analysis of the footprinting autoradiographic spot intensities using a model previously applied to footprinting studies involving the enzyme DNase I [Ward, B., Rehfuss, R., Goodisman, J., & Dabrowiak, J. C. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 1198-1205] led to very low values for netropsin binding constants on a restriction fragment from pBR-322 DNA. In this work, we show that, because the porphyrin binds with high specificity to DNA, it does not report site loading information in the same manner as does DNase I. We elucidate a model involving binding equilibria for individual sites and include competitive binding of drug and porphyrin for the same site. The free porphyrin and free drug concentrations are determined by binding equilibria with the carrier (calf thymus DNA) which is present in excess and acts as a buffer for both. Given free porphyrin and free netropsin concentrations for each total drug concentration in a series of footprinting experiments, one can calculate autoradiographic spot intensities in terms of the binding constants of netropsin to the various sites on the 139 base pair restriction fragment. The best values of these binding constants are determined by minimizing the sum of the squared differences between calculated and experimental footprinting autoradiographic spot intensities. Although the determined netropsin binding constants are insensitive to the value assumed for the porphyrin binding constant toward its highest affinity sites, the best mean-square deviation between observed and calculated values, D, depends on the choice of (average) drug binding constant to carrier DNA, Kd.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Determination of netropsin-DNA binding constants from footprinting data

A theory for deriving drug-DNA site binding constants from footprinting data is presented. Plots of oligonucleotide concentration, as a function of drug concentration, for various cutting positions on DNA are required. It is assumed that the rate of cleavage at each nucleotide position is proportional to the concentration of enzyme at that nucleotide and to the probability that the nucleotide is not blocked by drug. The probability of a nucleotide position not being blocked is calculated by assuming a conventional binding equilibrium for each binding site with exclusions for overlapping sites. The theory has been used to evaluate individual site binding constants for the antiviral agent netropsin toward a 139 base pair restriction fragment of pBR-322 DNA. Drug binding constants, evaluated from footprinting data in the presence of calf thymus DNA and poly(dGdC) as carrier and in the absence of carrier DNA, were determined by obtaining the best fit between calculated and experimental footprinting data. Although the strong sites on the fragment were all of the type (T.A)4, the value of the binding constant was strongly sequence dependent. Sites containing the dinucleotide sequence 5'-TA-3' were found to have significantly lower binding constants than those without this sequence, suggesting that an adenine-adenine clash produces a DNA structural alteration in the minor groove which discourages netropsin binding to DNA. The errors, scope, and limitations associated with the method are presented and discussed.     

Comparison of binding sites in DNA for berenil, netropsin and distamycin. A footprinting study

Techniques of DNase I and micrococcal nuclease footprinting have been used to compare the binding sites for berenil, netropsin and distamycin on two different DNA fragments. Each ligand binds to the A + T-rich zones which contain clusters of at least four A.T base pairs. Neither guanosine nor cytidine nucleotides appear to be allowed within the A + T-rich runs which constitute the preferred binding sites, although they are sometimes protected from DNase I cleavage in neighbouring regions. Berenil and netropsin share with distamycin the property of causing enhanced rates of cleavage at certain sequences flanking their binding sites. There are significant differences in the concentrations of each ligand required to produce defined patterns of protection, seemingly dependent upon the nature (and possibly the gross base composition) of the piece of DNA being used in the experiment.     

Structural changes and enhancements in DNase I footprinting experiments.

In footprinting experiments, an increase in DNA cleavage with addition of ligand to a system may be due to a ligand-induced structural change. Ligand binding also enhances cleavage by displacing the cleavage agent from ligand-binding sites, thus increasing its concentration elsewhere. The theory and characteristics of this mass-action enhancement are given, and it is shown how it may be recognized. Results of DNase I footprinting of small oligomers, with actinomycin D as ligand, are analyzed to reveal which enhancements are due to mass action, and which can reasonably be ascribed to structural changes. Patterns in the footprinting plots from our experiments on actinomycin D binding to a 139-base-pair DNA fragment (with DNase I as a probe) are studied in the same way. The likely origins of these patterns are discussed, as are enhancements occurring with other probes commonly used in footprinting experiments.     

Specific protection of DNA by distamycin A, netropsin and bis-netropsins against the action of DNAse I

Interaction of netropsin, distamycin A and a number of bis-netropsins with DNA fragments of definite nucleotide sequence was studied by footprinting technique. The nuclease protection experiments were made at fixed DNA concentration and varying ligand concentrations. The affinity of ligand for a DNA site was estimated from measurements of ligand concentration that causes 50% protection of the DNA site. Distribution pattern of the protected and unprotected regions along the DNA fragment was compared with the theoretically expected arrangement of the ligand along the same DNA. The comparison led us to the following conclusions: 1. Footprinting experiments show that at high levels of binding the arrangement of netropsin molecules along the DNA corresponds closely to the distribution pattern expected from theoretical calculations based on the known geometry of netropsin--DNA complex. However, the observed differences in the affinity of netropsin for various DNA sequences is markedly greater than that expected from theoretical calculations. 2. Netropsin exhibits a greater selectivity of binding than that expected for a ligand with three specific reaction centers associated with the antibiotic amide groups. It binds preferentially to DNA regions containing four or more successive AT pairs. Among 13 putative binding sites for netropsin with four or more successive AT pairs there are 11 strong binding sites and two weaker sites which are occupied at 2 D/P less than or equal to 1/9 and 2 D/P = 1/4, respectively. 3. The extent of specificity manifested by distamycin A is comparable to that shown by netropsin although the molecule of distamycin A contains four rather than three amide groups. At high levels of binding distamycin A occupies the same binding sites on DNA as netropsin does. 4. The binding specificity of bis-netropsins is greater than that of netropsin. Bis-netropsins can bind to DNA in such a way that the two netropsin-like fragments are implicated in specific interaction with DNA base pairs. However, the apparent affinity of bis-netropsins estimated from footprinting experiments is comparable with that of netropsin for the same DNA region. 5. At high levels of binding bis-netropsins and distamycin A (but not netropsin) can occupy any potential site on DNA irrespectively of the DNA sequence. 6. Complex formation with netropsin increases sensitivity to DNase I at certain DNA sites along with the protection effect observed at neighboring sites.     

Theoretical Analysis of the Footprinting Experiment

Abstract

In the footprinting experiment, an end-radiolabeled DNA restriction fragment is subjected to digest by an endonuclease in the presence and absence of a ligand which alters the endonuclease cleavage rate at sites of ligand-DNA contact. The location of these sites, and the strength of the ligand binding, are then deduced from the measured concentrations of the different oligonucleotides produced by the digest. We analyze the experiment in terms of coupled kinetic equations which take into account the cutting rates of endonuclease for sites with ligand present and absent, and the rates of binding and dissociation of the ligand to a site. As long as the ligand concentration remains essentially constant (which occurs, for example, if digest is terminated early enough to assure that all fragments result from single cuts by the endonuclease), the oligonucleotide concentrations reflect only the ligand binding equilibrium constant (ratio of rate constants) and the cutting rates in the presence and absence of ligand. We also show how the measured oligonucleotide concentrations (from, e.g. an autoradiogram) can be used to deduce the ligand equilibrium binding constants for the various sites on the polymer.     

Determination of equilibrium binding affinity of distamycin and netropsin to the synthetic deoxyoligonucleotide sequence d(GGTATACC)2 by quantitative DNase I footprinting

A new method for determining the equilibrium binding constant of antitumor drugs to specific DNA sequences by quantitative DNase I footprinting is presented. The use of a short synthetic DNA oligomer to define a homogeneous population of DNA binding sites enables the calculation of the free drug concentration and the fraction of DNA sites complexed with drug in solution and is described for the first time. Since a 1:1 stoichiometry is observed for each drug-oligomer DNA complex, it becomes possible to calculate equilibrium binding constants in solution. By use of this technique, the binding affinities of the nonintercalating drugs netropsin and distamycin to the synthetic oligonucleotide d(GGTATACC)2 are determined to be Ka (25 degrees C) = 1.0 X 10(5) and 2.0 X 10(5) M-1, respectively. Quantitation of the temperature dependence associated with complex formation results in a determination of standard enthalpies of -3.75 and -8.48 kcal mol-1 for the binding of netropsin and distamycin, respectively. Calculation of other thermodynamic parameters are found to be in agreement with previous studies and indicate that the DNA binding process for these compounds is predominantly enthalpy driven. This method of quantitative DNase I footprinting is demonstrated to be a useful technique for the measurement of drug affinities to specific binding sites on DNA oligomers which are designed and synthesized expressly for this purpose. Applications of the technique to the determination of drug binding affinities at specific sites within native DNA sequences are discussed.     

Site-specific binding constants for actinomycin D on DNA determined from footprinting studies.

We report site-specific binding constants for the intercalating anticancer drug actinomycin D (Act-D), binding to a 139-base-pair restriction fragment from pBR 322 DNA. The binding constants are derived from analysis of footprinting experiments, in which the radiolabeled 139-mer is cleaved using DNase I, the cleavage products undergo gel electrophoresis, and, from the gel autoradiogram, spot intensities, proportional to amounts of cleaved fragments, are measured. A bound drug prevents DNase I from cleaving at approximately 7 bonds, leading to decreased amounts of corresponding fragments. With the radiolabel on the 3' end of the noncoding strand (A-label), we measured relative amounts of 54 cleavage products at 25 Act-D concentrations. For cleavage of the 139-mer with the label on the 3' end of the coding strand (G-label), relative amounts of 43 cleavage products at 11 Act-D concentrations were measured. These measurements give information about approximately 120 base pairs of the restriction fragment (approximately 12 turns of the DNA helix); in this region, 14 strong and weak Act-D binding sites were identified. The model used to interpret the footprinting plots is derived in detail. Binding constants for 14 sites on the fragment are obtained simultaneously. It is important to take into account the effect of drug binding at its various sites on the local concentration of probe elsewhere. It is also necessary to include in the model weak as well as strong Act-D sites on the carrier DNA which is present, since the carrier DNA controls the free-drug concentration. As expected, the strongest sites are those with the sequence (all sequences are 5'----3') GC, with TGCT having the highest binding constant, 6.4 x 10(6) M-1. Sites having the sequence GC preceded by G are weak binding sites, having binding constants approximately 1 order of magnitude lower than those of the strong sites. Also, the non-GC-containing sequences CCG and CCC bind Act-D with a binding constant comparable to those of the weak GGC sites. The analysis may reveal drug-induced structural changes on the DNA, which are discussed in terms of the mechanism of Act-D binding.     

Small ligands that neither bind to nor alter the structure of d(GA·TC)n sequences in DNA

Three minor-groove binding ligands have been used to study the characteristics of two d(GA·CT)_n DNAs embedded in longer DNA fragments. The binding of mithramycin, netropsin or Thia-Net to these sequences has been studied using DNAse I footprinting. None of these ligands appeared to bind to d(GA·CT)₅ nor to d(GA·CT)₂₂ extensively, although with mithramycin some protected bonds were detected at the very edge of these sequences. In general, these small ligands did not enhance the DNAse I cleavage patterns at the alternating d(GA·CT)_n flanking sequences located near DNA regions where the drug was bound. The d(GA·CT)_n sequences could act as a rigid block in which it is not easy to propagate structural changes, whereas other sequences flanking the binding sites showed cleavage enhancements.     

Molecular recognition between oligopeptides and nucleic acids. DNA sequence specificity and binding properties of an acridine-linked netropsin hybrid ligand

The binding to DNA of a mixed function ligand (NETGA) is described, in which a potential intercalating group, an acridine moiety, is incorporated at the carboxyl terminus of the minor groove binding oligopeptide netropsin skeleton. Scatchard analysis of absorption data provided evidence of two modes of binding to DNA with K1 = 9.1 x 10(5) M-1 at low r values (0.003-0.1), and a binding site size n = 10, indicative of binding of both moeities. At high binding ratios (greater than 0.1), K2 = 0.9 x 10(5) M-1 and n = 5 corresponding to external binding. Complementary strand MPE footprinting on a pBR322 restriction fragment showed NETGA binds to 5'-AAAT like netropsin. It causes enhanced cleavage by MPE, particularly at G-C rich sequences and remote from the preferred binding sites. Viscometry measurements provided evidence for biphasic modes of the two binding portions of NETGA. Fluorescence polarization and linear dichroism measurements were in accord with distinct modes of interaction of the acridine (intercalation) and oligopeptide (minor groove binding) portions of NETGA. LD measurements on NETGA indicate that the oligopeptide moiety (netropsin-like) has an orientation typical of minor groove binders, whereas the degree of intercalation of the acridine group is decreased by association of the oligopeptide moiety.     

Sequence-specific cleavage of double-stranded DNA caused by X-ray ionization of the platinum atom in the Pt-bis-netropsin--DNA complex.

An analog of the antibiotic netropsin containing two netropsin-like fragments linked covalently via a platinum atom has been synthesized. DNase I and hydroxyl radical footprinting studies have shown that this compound binds at selective sites on a DNA restriction fragment with a known nucleotide sequence. After X-ray irradiation of Pt-bis-netropsin--DNA complexes a platinum-mediated cleavage of DNA is observed at specific DNA sites. This enables one to determine the location of the synthetic ligand on the DNA with a precision of about one nucleotide. The cleavage activity seems to be related to the emission of Auger electrons from the platinum atom that cause rupture of the deoxyribose residues on the two DNA strands near the position of the platinum atom in the complex.     

Assignment of DNA binding sites for 4',6-diamidine-2-phenylindole and bisbenzimide (Hoechst 33258). A comparative footprinting study

DNA binding sites for the minor groove-binding ligands DAPI (4',6-diamidine-2-phenylindole) and Hoechst 33258 (bisbenzimide) have been analysed using DNAase I and micrococcal nuclease footprinting techniques. Both drugs appear to bind to AT-rich regions containing at least four such basepairs. Hoechst 33258 seems to bind relatively poorly to nucleotide sequences containing the alternating step TpA. However, in contrast to DAPI, it can more readily accommodate the presence of guanosine residues at the end of the binding site. We compare the DNA binding sites for DAPI and Hoechst 33258 with those determined for the related minor groove-binding ligands, berenil, netropsin and distamycin A, under comparable conditions, and discuss the importance of using different footprinting probes when analysing drug-DNA interactions.     

Quantitative footprinting analysis

This review outlines the steps for obtaining relative constants for drugs from footprinting data. After correcting the autoradiographic spot intensities for differing amounts of radioactive DNA loaded into the lanes of a sequencing gel, footprinting plots, showing individual spot intensities as a function of drug concentration, are constructed. The initial relative slopes of footprinting plots are proportional to the binding constant of the drug for its DNA sites. Slopes of plots outside the drug binding sites can be used to identify locations of altered DNA structure. It illustrates the power of quantitative footprinting analysis by analyzing the binding of the antiviral agent netrospin to a 139-base pair restriction fragment in the presence of the antitumor agent actinomycin D. While two netrospin binding regions are unaffected by actinomycin D a third region experiences enhanced binding in the presence of the antitumor agent.     

Sequence-recognition and cleavage of DNA by a netropsin-phenazine-di-N-oxide conjugate

We report the synthesis, DNA-binding and cleaving properties, and cytotoxic activities of R-128, a hybrid molecule in which a bis-pyrrolecarboxamide-amidine element related to the antibiotic netropsin is covalently tethered to a phenazine-di-N-oxide chromophore. The affinity and mode of interaction of the conjugate with DNA were investigated by a combination of absorption spectroscopy, circular dichroism, and electric linear dichroism. This hybrid molecule binds to AT-rich sequences of DNA via a bimodal process involving minor groove binding of the netropsin moiety and intercalation of the phenazine moiety. The bidentate mode of binding was evidenced by linear dichroism using calf thymus DNA and poly(dA-dT).(dA-dT). In contrast, the drug fails to bind to poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC), because of the obstructive effect of the guanine 2-amino group exposed in the minor groove of this polynucleotide. DNase I footprinting studies indicated that the conjugate interacts preferentially with AT-rich sequences, but the cleavage of DNA in the presence of a reducing agent can occur at different sequences not restricted to the AT sites. The main cleavage sites were detected with a periodicity of about 10 base pairs corresponding to approximately one turn of the double helix. This suggests that the cleavage may be dictated by the structure of the double helix rather than the primary nucleotide sequence. The conjugate which is moderately toxic to cancer cells complements the tool box of reagents which can be utilized to produce DNA strand scission. The DNA cleaving properties of R-128 entreat further exploration into the use of phenazine-di-N-oxides as tools for investigating DNA structure.     

Specific DNA cleavage by an analog of netropsin containing a copper(II) chelating peptide Gly-Gly-His]

Experimental data are reported on DNA-cleaving activity of the synthetic netropsin analogs consisting of the two N-propylpyrrole carboxamide units linked covalently through two or three glycine residues to a copper-chelating tripeptide glycyl-glycyl-L-histidine. Incubation of DNA restriction fragment and netropsin analog in the presence of ascorbate, hydrogen peroxide and Cu2+ ions resulted in selective cleavage of the DNA at or near the preferred sites for binding of netropsin analog. A similar cleavage pattern is observed after X-ray irradiation of DNA complexes with netropsin analogs tethered with Cu2+ ions. The cleavage patterns are found to be dependent on the length of the connecting chain between the histidine-containing tripeptide and netropsin analog. The netropsin analog containing three glycine residues in the connecting chain, but not the analog with a shorter linker chain, can generate an intense cleavage of one of the two polynucleotide chains at a position corresponding to the presumed binding site for the dimeric ligand species. More than 50% of the total DNA can be cleaved at this position after X-ray irradiation. From analysis of the nucleotide sequences surrounding the preferred cleavage site on several DNA fragments we found that the consensus is 5'-TTTTNCA*AAA-3', where N is an arbitrary nucleotide. The Cu(2+)-mediated cleavage of DNA occurs at the second adenine (indicated by an asterisk) from the 5'-end of the sequence. The greatest cleavage activity is observed when the molar ratio of Cu2+ to the netropsin analog is equal to 0.5. Evidently, the Cu(2+)-ligated and unligated oligopeptide species interacts with each other to form a heterodimer bound to DNA at the cleavage site. To test the validity of this model we have studied the binding of unligated netropsin analog and netropsin analog complexed with Cu2+ ion to a self-complementary oligonucleotide 5'-GCGTTTTGCAAAACGC-3'. It is found that binding of Cu(2+)-ligated netropsin analog to the DNA oligomer preincubated with unligated form of the oligopeptide is a cooperative process for which interactions between the two bound ligands are responsible. The cooperativity parameter is estimated to be on the order of factor 6. Finally, a model is proposed in which a heterodimer stabilized by interligand beta-sheet binds in the minor DNA groove.     

Footprinting reveals that nogalamycin and actinomycin shuffle between DNA binding sites.

The hypothesis that sequence-selective DNA-binding antibiotics locate their preferred binding sites by a process involving migration from nonspecific sites has been tested by footprinting with DNAase I. Footprinting patterns on the tyrT DNA fragment produced by nogalamycin and actinomycin change with time after mixing the antibiotic with the DNA. Sites of protection as well as enhanced cleavage are seen to develop in a fashion which is both temperature and concentration-dependent. At certain sites cutting is transiently enhanced, then blocked. Limited evidence for slow reaction with echinomycin and mithramycin is presented, but the kinetics of footprinting with daunomycin and distamycin appear instantaneous. The feasibility of adducing direct evidence for shuffling by footprinting seems to be governed by slow dissociation of the antibiotic-DNA complex. It may also be dependent upon the mode of binding, be it intercalative or non-intercalative in character.     

Netropsin, distamycin A, bis-netropsins as selective inhibitors of restrictases and DNAse I

The simultaneous analysis of DNAase I "footprinting" data and restriction endonucleases inhibition data was performed on the same DNA end-labelled fragment. The inhibition induced by netropsin, a number of bis-netropsins and distamycin A was investigated. These experiments led us to the following conclusions. The restriction endonucleases inhibition by the ligands is caused by the ligand molecules binding in the close vicinity to the restriction endonuclease recognition sequence. The zone of +/- 4 bp from the center of the restriction endonuclease recognition sequence can be defined as the zone of the influence of the bounded ligand on the restriction endonuclease. But in this case the intersection of recognition sequence and the binding site occupied by a single ligand molecule is not sufficient for the inhibition to occur. Restriction endonuclease cutting sites protected by netropsin can be predicted basing upon known nucleotide sequence specificity of netropsin. Netropsin and bis-netropsins show different nucleotide sequence specificity. This fact can be used for selective inhibition of restriction endonucleases.     

Sequence selective binding of ditrisarubicin B to DNA: comparison with daunomycin

DNase I footprinting has been used to examine the sequence selective binding of ditrisarubicin B, novel anthracycline antibiotic, to DNA. At 37°C no footprinting pattern is observed, the drug protects all sites from enzymic cleavage with equal efficiency. At 4°C a footprinting pattern is induced with low drug concentrations which is different from that produced by daunomycin. The best binding sites contain the dinucleotide step GpT (ApC) and are located in regions of alternating purines and pyrimidines.