Probing stability and dynamics of proteins by protease digestion. I: Comparison of protease susceptibility and thermal stability of cytochromes c

Protease susceptibility of homologous proteins in their native conformations was studied. This work aims to establish a broad and quantitative basis for the utilization of protease digestion to analyze the local stability of native proteins. Using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) the time course of the proteolytic degradation of intact proteins was quantitatively traced. Rapid separation of peptide fragments with HPLC made possible the elucidation of sequential digestion originating from the cleavage at a very few sites which are locally unstable in the protein structure. Using four serine proteases, chymotrypsin, trypsin, elastase and subtilisin BPN', we found some common trends in proteolysis for a group of proteins of the cytochrome c family. By comparing of the proteolysis and thermal denaturation with ten homologous cytochromes c extracted from horse, beef, Candida krusei, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, chicken, tuna, pigeon, rabbit, dog and rat, protease susceptibility was related to locally unfolding states intrinsic to the native conformation.     

Effects of Size of Carbohydrate Chain on Protease Digestion of Aspergillus niger Endo-β-1,4-glucanase

Three different carbohydrate-depleted enzymes were prepared from an endo-β-l,4-glucanase of Aspergillus niger IF031125 by treatment with endo-β-N-acetylglucosaminidase or α-mannosidase. They were purified by Concanavalin A-Sepharose affinity and DEAE ion-exchange column chromatographies. The molecular sizes of these enzymes had been decreased from 40 kDa containing 9.0% carbohydrate to 39, 38, and 37kDa with carbohydrate at 4.5, 1.3, and 0.8% (wt/wt), respectively. The native and these carbohydrate-depleted enzymes were compared in their enzymatic properties, and it was found that they were identical in their catalytic activities and both thermal and pH stabilities. However, the 37-kDa enzyme was more susceptible to proteolysis by Savinase, proteinase K, and Pronase E. On the other hand, the specific protease trypsin showed no such effect on activity of all enzymes. These results suggested that the core structure of the asparagine-linked sugar chain, which consisted of three monosaccharide residues, contributed to the high stability of the endo-β-l,4-glucanase against protease digestion.     

The HtrA Protease from Streptococcus pneumoniae Digests Both Denatured Proteins and the Competence-stimulating Peptide

The HtrA protease of Streptococcus pneumoniae functions both in a general stress response role and as an error sensor that specifically represses genetic competence when the overall level of biosynthetic errors in cellular proteins is low. However, the mechanism through which HtrA inhibits development of competence has been unknown. We found that HtrA digested the pneumococcal competence-stimulating peptide (CSP) and constituted the primary extracytoplasmic CSP-degrading activity in cultures of S. pneumoniae. Mass spectrometry demonstrated that cleavage predominantly followed residue Phe-8 of the CSP-1 isoform of the peptide within its central hydrophobic patch, and in competition assays, both CSP-1 and CSP-2 interacted with HtrA with similar efficiencies. More generally, analysis of β-casein digestion and of digestion within HtrA itself revealed a preference for substrates with non-polar residues at the P1 site. Consistent with a specificity for exposed hydrophobic residues, competition from native BSA only weakly inhibited digestion of CSP, but denaturation converted BSA into a strong competitive inhibitor of such proteolysis. Together these findings support a model in which digestion of CSP by HtrA is reduced in the presence of other unfolded proteins that serve as alternative targets for degradation. Such competition may provide a mechanism by which HtrA functions in a quality control capacity to monitor the frequency of biosynthetic errors that result in protein misfolding.     

Isolation and Characterization of Fragments of the ATP-Dependent Protease Lon from Escherichia coli Obtained by Limited Proteolysis

Conditions of limited proteolysis of the protease Lon from Escherichia coli that provided the formation of fragments approximately corresponding to the enzyme domains were found for studying the domain functioning. A method of isolation of the domains was developed, and their functional characteristics were compared. The isolated proteolytic domain (LonP fragment) of the enzyme was shown to exhibit both peptidase and proteolytic activities; however, it cleaved large protein substrates at a significantly lower rate than the full-size protease Lon. On the other hand, the LonAP fragment, containing both the ATPase and the proteolytic domains, retained almost all of the enzymatic properties of the full-size protein. Both LonP and LonAP predominantly form dimers unlike the native protease Lon functioning as a tetramer. These results suggest that the N-terminal domain of protease Lon may play a considerable role in the process of the enzyme oligomerization.     

Studies on Bacterial Protease

The neutral protease of Bacillus amylosacchariticus was inactivated by low concentrations of several metal-chelating agents and the inactivated enzyme with EDTA restored its activity almost completely by the addition of Zn⁺⁺ or Co⁺⁺ and partially by Fe⁺⁺ or Mn⁺⁺, if these metal ions were added shortly after the EDTA-treatment. The native enzyme was found to contain 0.19% of zinc together with a significant amount of calcium. Parallel increase in specific activity and zinc content of enzyme preparation was observed throughout the purification procedure. The elution pattern of enzyme activity on a CM-cellulose column chromatography also completely coincided with that of protein-bound zinc. A zinc-free inactive enzyme was also reactivated by the addition of zinc or cobalt ions, clearly showing that the neutral protease of B. amylosacchariticus is a zinc mctalloenzyme.     

Degradation by proteases Lon, Clp and HtrA, of Escherichia coli proteins aggregated in vivo by heat shock; HtrA protease action in vivo and in vitro

Thermally aggregated, endogenous proteins of Escheri-chia coli form a distinct fraction, denoted S, which is separable by sucrose-density-gradient centrifugation. It was shown earlier that DnaK, DnaJ, IbpA and IbpB heat-shock proteins are associated with the S fraction. Comparison of the rise and decay of the S fraction in mutants defective for heat-shock proteases Lon (La), Clp, HtrA (DegP, Do) and in wild-type strains made studies of proteolysis and the function of the heat-shock response possible in vivo. Different timing and the extent of action of particular proteases was revealed by the initial size and decay kinetics of the S fraction. The proteases Lon, Clp, and HtrA all participated in removal of the aggregated proteins. Mutation in the gene encoding ClpB caused the most prominent effect (47% stabilization of the S fraction). The correlation between the disappearance of the S fraction and proteolytic activity was supported by the result of the in vitro reaction. Approximately one third of the isolated S fraction was converted to trichloroacetic acid-soluble products by the purified HtrA protease. Mg²⁺ ions stimulated the reaction, in contrast to the reaction of the HtrA protease with casein. The digestion of the aggregated proteins, unlike the digestion of casein, by HtrA protease in vitro was inhibited by added DnaJ, which might reflect protection of the aggregated proteins in vivo by DnaJ from excessive degradation. One might expect that such an activity of DnaJ would promote denatured protein renaturation versus proteolysis. Moreover, among the aggregated proteins that are discernible by electrophoresis, none could be identified as being more susceptible than any other to HtrA degradation. The separation pattern of these proteins before and after the in vitro digestion did not show a difference corresponding to the loss of about 30% of constituting proteins. This was interpreted as recognition by the HtrA protease of a state of protein denaturation rather than specific amino acid sequences in particular proteins. We conclude that the fraction consisting of proteins heat- aggregated in vivo (i.e. the S fraction) contains endogenous substrates for the heat-shock proteases tested. Their use for in vitro reaction reveals information that is in some respects different from that obtained with exogenous substrates such as casein.     

Evidence for Reduced Drug Susceptibility without Emergence of Major Protease Mutations following Protease Inhibitor Monotherapy Failure in the SARA Trial

BackgroundMajor protease mutations are rarely observed following failure with protease inhibitors (PI), and other viral determinants of failure to PI are poorly understood. We therefore characterized Gag-Protease phenotypic susceptibility in subtype A and D viruses circulating in East Africa following viral rebound on PIs.MethodsSamples from baseline and treatment failure in patients enrolled in the second line LPV/r trial SARA underwent phenotypic susceptibility testing. Data were expressed as fold-change in susceptibility relative to a LPV-susceptible reference strain.ResultsWe cloned 48 Gag-Protease containing sequences from seven individuals and performed drug resistance phenotyping from pre-PI and treatment failure timepoints in seven patients. For the six patients where major protease inhibitor resistance mutations did not emerge, mean fold-change EC₅₀ to LPV was 4.07 fold (95% CI, 2.08–6.07) at the pre-PI timepoint. Following viral failure the mean fold-change in EC₅₀ to LPV was 4.25 fold (95% CI, 1.39–7.11, p = 0.91). All viruses remained susceptible to DRV. In our assay system, the major PI resistance mutation I84V, which emerged in one individual, conferred a 10.5-fold reduction in LPV susceptibility. One of the six patients exhibited a significant reduction in susceptibility between pre-PI and failure timepoints (from 4.7 fold to 9.6 fold) in the absence of known major mutations in protease, but associated with changes in Gag: V7I, G49D, R69Q, A120D, Q127K, N375S and I462S. Phylogenetic analysis provided evidence of the emergence of genetically distinct viruses at the time of treatment failure, indicating ongoing viral evolution in Gag-protease under PI pressure.ConclusionsHere we observe in one patient the development of significantly reduced susceptibility conferred by changes in Gag which may have contributed to treatment failure on a protease inhibitor containing regimen. Further phenotype-genotype studies are required to elucidate genetic determinants of protease inhibitor failure in those who fail without traditional resistance mutations whilst PI use is being scaled up globally.     

Reverse Zymography Alone does not Confirm Presence of a Protease Inhibitor

Reverse zymography is applied for identification and semi-quantification of protease inhibitors that are of protein in nature. However, a protein that shows band in reverse zymography against a protease used for digestion of the gel need not be an inhibitor; it might be resistant to degradation by the protease. We demonstrate that in reverse zymography, avidin, streptavidin and the leaf extract of Catharanthus roseus behave like inhibitors of proteases like papain, ficin, bromelain extracts from pineapple leaf, stem and fruit and trypsin. Still, they do not act as inhibitors of those proteases when enzyme assays were done in solution. In reverse zymography, the extract of pineapple crown leaf shows two major inhibitor bands against its own proteases. Identification of these proteins from sequences derived from MALDI TOF MS analysis indicated that they are fruit and stem bromelains. Avidin, streptavidin and bromelains are ‘kinetically stable proteins’ that are usually resistant to proteolysis. Thus, it is recommended that identification of an inhibitor of a protease by reverse zymography should be supported by independent assay methods for confirmation.     

Proteolytic and partial sequencing studies of the bifunctional dihydrofolate reductase-thymidylate synthase from Daucus carota

The bifunctional dihydrofolate reductase-thymidylate synthase (DHFR-TS) of Daucus carota has been further characterized as regards molecular weight, amino acid composition, protease digestion and microsequencing of proteolytic peptides. Data reported in this paper demonstrate that the carrot protein has a calculated M _r of 124000 thus indicating that, contrarily to what has previously been suggested, it occurs as a dimer of identical subunits. Results of partial amino acid microsequencing show the presence of sequences highly homologous with those of the active sites of both DHFR and TS from other organisms confirming, at the structural level, the bifunctional nature of the carrot protein. As in the case of Leishmania tropica DHFR-TS, incubation of the carrot protein with V8 protease led to a rapid loss of TS activity while retaining that of DHFR. However the pattern of proteolysis did not allow to establish whether the sequence of domains is DHFR-TS as in Leishmania, or vice versa. Low homology of other amino acid sequences, as judged by computer analysis, and absence of common epitopes indicate an apparent divergence between carrot and leishmanian proteins.     

Cloning,Expression, Purification,and Characterization of Biologically Active Recombinant Hemagglutinin-33, Type A Botulinum Neurotoxin Associated Protein

Botulinum neurotoxin type A, the most toxic substance known to mankind, is produced by Clostridium botulinum type A as a complex with a group of neurotoxin-associated proteins (NAPs) through polycistronic expression of a clustered group of genes. Hemagglutinin-33 (Hn-33) is a 33 kDa subcomponent of NAPs, which is resistant to protease digestion, a feature likely to be involved in the protection of the botulinum neurotoxin from proteolysis. In order to fully understand the function of Hn-33, large amounts of Hn-33 will be needed without dealing with biosafety risks to grow large cultures of C. botulinum. There are difficulties to clone the genes with the high A + T contents produced by C. botulinum. We report here for the first time using the Gateway technology to clone functional Hn-33 that has been expressed in E. coli. The yield of the recombinant Hn-33 was about 12 mg per liter of E. coli culture. The recombinant Hn-33 folds well in aqueous solution as shown with circular dichroism spectra, resists temperature-denaturation, is totally resistant to trypsin proteolysis despite the presence of cleavage sites on the molecular surface, and maintains its biological activities comparable to the native Hn-33 hemagglutination.     

Studies on Bacterial Protease

Substrate specificity of the crystalline neutral protease of B. amylosacchariticus was investigated using the B-chain of oxidized beef insulin as the substrate, and the results were compared with those of proteases obtained from other strains of Bacillus subtilis. The neutral protease split the B-chain at eleven sites of the peptide linkages, indicating the narrow specificity as compared with subtilopeptidase A, The results also indicated that the peptide bonds susceptible to the action of the neutral protease were mainly those involving amino group of hydrophobic amino acids and tyrosine, with a few exception. The enzyme showed potent activities in casein digestion at near neutrality and in milk clotting at pH 5.6, whereas it was completely inert on esters and keratin, and only slightly active toward elastin.     

Purification of Recombinant HIV-1 Protease

Abstract

A method is described to purify recombinant HIV-1 protease from soluble extracts of Escherichia coli. The isolation involves QAE-Sepharose anion exchange chromatography, hexyl agarose hydrophobic interaction chromatography, MonoS cation exchange chromatography, and Superose 6 size exclusion chromatography. Approximately 100 μg of protease was obtained from 18 g E. coli paste. The protein was judged to be homogeneous due to the presence of a single band on a silver-stained SDS polyacrylamide gel.     

The Extent of Protease Resistance of Misfolded Prion Protein Is Highly Dependent on the Salt Concentration

Transmissible spongiform encephalopathies are neurodegenerative diseases caused by prions in mammals. An aberrantly folded protein (PrP^Sc) is the main component of these proteinaceous infectious particles. Prions exhibit strong resistance to protease digestion, which is typically exploited for biochemical discrimination from its native cellular form (PrP^C). This classical feature has been partially challenged by the isolation of sizeable amounts of protease-sensitive PrP^Sc isoforms that self-propagate in vivo. Here, we report that the degree of PrP^Sc protease resistance is highly dependent on the concentration of salt in the solution. Similar changes were observed in PrP^Sc obtained from different strains and species. Strikingly, the effect of salt is reversible and is associated with changes on the size of PrP^Sc particles, but surprisingly, the more protease-sensitive species consists of a larger size. These findings shed light on the mechanistic aspects of prion proteolysis and should be considered when assessing samples of biomedical relevance.     

Tobacco Etch Virus Protease: Crystal Structure of the Active Enzyme and Its Inactive Mutant

Tobacco Etch Virus Protease (TEV protease) is widely used as a tool for separation of recombinant target proteins from their fusion partners. The crystal structures of two mutants of TEV protease, the active autolysis-resistant mutant TEV-S219D in complex with the proteolysis product, and the inactive mutant TEV-C151A in complex with a substrate, have been determined at 1.8 and 2.2 Å resolution, respectively. The active sites of both mutants, including their oxyanion holes, have identical structures. The C-terminal residues 217–221 of the enzyme are involved in formation of the binding pockets S ₃–S ₆. This indicates that the autolysis of the peptide bond Met218–Ser219 exerts a strong effect on the fine-tuning of the substrate in the enzyme active site, which results in a considerable decrease in the enzymatic activity.     

Interdomain Contacts and the Stability of Serralysin Protease from Serratia marcescens

The serralysin family of bacterial metalloproteases is associated with virulence in multiple modes of infection. These extracellular proteases are members of the Repeats-in-ToXin (RTX) family of toxins and virulence factors, which mediated virulence in E. coli, B. pertussis, and P. aeruginosa, as well as other animal and plant pathogens. The serralysin proteases are structurally dynamic and their folding is regulated by calcium binding to a C-terminal domain that defines the RTX family of proteins. Previous studies have suggested that interactions between N-terminal sequences and this C-terminal domain are important for the high thermal and chemical stabilities of the RTX proteases. Extending from this, stabilization of these interactions in the native structure may lead to hyperstabilization of the folded protein. To test this hypothesis, cysteine pairs were introduced into the N-terminal helix and the RTX domain and protease folding and activity were assessed. Under stringent pH and temperature conditions, the disulfide-bonded mutant showed increased protease activity and stability. This activity was dependent on the redox environment of the refolding reaction and could be blocked by selective modification of the cysteine residues before protease refolding. These data demonstrate that the thermal and chemical stability of these proteases is, in part, mediated by binding between the RTX domain and the N-terminal helix and demonstrate that stabilization of this interaction can further stabilize the active protease, leading to additional pH and thermal tolerance.     

Molecular Phylogenetic Characterization of Streptomyces Protease Inhibitor Family

We previously found that proteinaceous protease inhibitors homologous to Streptomyces subtilisin inhibitor (SSI) are widely produced by various Streptomyces species, and we designated them ``SSI-like proteins' (Taguchi S, Kikuchi H, Suzuki M, Kojima S, Terabe M, Miura K, Nakase T, Momose H [1993] Appl Environ Microbiol 59:4338–4341). In this study, SSI-like proteins from five strains of the genus Streptoverticillium were purified and sequenced, and molecular phylogenetic trees were constructed on the basis of the determined amino acid sequences together with those determined previously for Streptomyces species. The phylogenetic trees showed that SSI-like proteins from Streptoverticillium species are phylogenetically included in Streptomyces SSI-like proteins but form a monophyletic group as a distinct lineage within the Streptomyces proteins. This provides an alternative phylogenetic framework to the previous one based on partial small ribosomal RNA sequences, and it may indicate that the phylogenetic affiliation of the genus Streptoverticillium should be revised. The phylogenetic trees also suggested that SSI-like proteins possessing arginine or methionine at the P1 site, the major reactive center site toward target proteases, arose multiple times on independent lineages from ancestral proteins possessing lysine at the P1 site. Most of the codon changes at the P1 site inferred to have occurred during the evolution of SSI-like proteins are consistent with those inferred from the extremely high G + C content of Streptomyces genomes. The inferred minimum number of amino acid replacements at the P1 site was nearly equal to the average number for all the variable sites. It thus appears that positive Darwinian selection, which has been postulated to account for accelerated rates of amino acid replacement at the major reaction center site of mammalian protease inhibitors, may not have dictated the evolution of the bacterial SSI-like proteins. Received: 23 August 1996 / Accepted: 20 November 1996     

CODAS Syndrome Is Associated with Mutations of LONP1, Encoding Mitochondrial AAA+ Lon Protease

CODAS syndrome is a multi-system developmental disorder characterized by cerebral, ocular, dental, auricular, and skeletal anomalies. Using whole-exome and Sanger sequencing, we identified four LONP1 mutations inherited as homozygous or compound-heterozygous combinations among ten individuals with CODAS syndrome. The individuals come from three different ancestral backgrounds (Amish-Swiss from United States, n = 8; Mennonite-German from Canada, n = 1; mixed European from Canada, n = 1). LONP1 encodes Lon protease, a homohexameric enzyme that mediates protein quality control, respiratory-complex assembly, gene expression, and stress responses in mitochondria. All four pathogenic amino acid substitutions cluster within the AAA⁺ domain at residues near the ATP-binding pocket. In biochemical assays, pathogenic Lon proteins show substrate-specific defects in ATP-dependent proteolysis. When expressed recombinantly in cells, all altered Lon proteins localize to mitochondria. The Old Order Amish Lon variant (LONP1 c.2161C>G[p.Arg721Gly]) homo-oligomerizes poorly in vitro. Lymphoblastoid cell lines generated from affected children have (1) swollen mitochondria with electron-dense inclusions and abnormal inner-membrane morphology; (2) aggregated MT-CO2, the mtDNA-encoded subunit II of cytochrome c oxidase; and (3) reduced spare respiratory capacity, leading to impaired mitochondrial proteostasis and function. CODAS syndrome is a distinct, autosomal-recessive, developmental disorder associated with dysfunction of the mitochondrial Lon protease.     

A Computational Module Assembled from Different Protease Family Motifs Identifies PI PLC from Bacillus cereus as a Putative Prolyl Peptidase with a Serine Protease Scaffold

Proteolytic enzymes have evolved several mechanisms to cleave peptide bonds. These distinct types have been systematically categorized in the MEROPS database. While a BLAST search on these proteases identifies homologous proteins, sequence alignment methods often fail to identify relationships arising from convergent evolution, exon shuffling, and modular reuse of catalytic units. We have previously established a computational method to detect functions in proteins based on the spatial and electrostatic properties of the catalytic residues (CLASP). CLASP identified a promiscuous serine protease scaffold in alkaline phosphatases (AP) and a scaffold recognizing a β-lactam (imipenem) in a cold-active Vibrio AP. Subsequently, we defined a methodology to quantify promiscuous activities in a wide range of proteins. Here, we assemble a module which encapsulates the multifarious motifs used by protease families listed in the MEROPS database. Since APs and proteases are an integral component of outer membrane vesicles (OMV), we sought to query other OMV proteins, like phospholipase C (PLC), using this search module. Our analysis indicated that phosphoinositide-specific PLC from Bacillus cereus is a serine protease. This was validated by protease assays, mass spectrometry and by inhibition of the native phospholipase activity of PI-PLC by the well-known serine protease inhibitor AEBSF (IC50 = 0.018 mM). Edman degradation analysis linked the specificity of the protease activity to a proline in the amino terminal, suggesting that the PI-PLC is a prolyl peptidase. Thus, we propose a computational method of extending protein families based on the spatial and electrostatic congruence of active site residues.     

Probing stability and dynamics of proteins by protease digestion. II: Identification of the initial chymotryptic cleavage sites of homologous cytochromes c

Three homologous cytochromes c from horse, rabbit and tuna were subjected to chymotryptic digestion and their initial cleavage sites were identified. The sites in oxidized cytochromes c are the COOH-terminal sides of Tyr-48, Phe-46 and Tyr-46 for horse, rabbit and tuna cytochromes c, respectively. The results show that the chymotrypsin attacks a single site in each protein; the sites are located at the almost identical position on the polypeptide chain. Through the time-course studies of digestion, it was found that the three cytochromes c have different chymotrypsin-susceptibility at the initial cleavage site in the order of horse less than rabbit less than tuna. Studies on chymotryptic digestion of tuna cytochrome c in the reduced form revealed that the haem-reduction does not alter the initial cleavage site but increases the resistance to the proteolysis at the site. The uniqueness of the initial cleavage site in each cytochrome c species suggests that the protease susceptibility reflects some overall properties of the protein. At the same time, it was clarified that the initial cleavage site is also affected by a neighboring region by the fact that another potential cleavage site is located near the site in question. In order to elucidate the initial cleavage site, several physical properties of tuna cytochrome c molecule deduced from the X-ray 3D structure, accessible surface area, temperature factor, effective hydrophobicity and electrostatic potential, were compared with the experimental results and it was concluded that these properties given by a residue have no direct relationship with the chymotrypsin susceptibility.